Nancey Murphy - What Gives Us Personal Identity?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 дек 2024

Комментарии • 52

  • @chyfields
    @chyfields 11 дней назад +1

    As with genes, there is an unbroken female line all the way back to Source; the Mother who had a mother, who had a mother, who had a mother and so on. Each mother carries the essence of Source, down through the generations; the ancestral soul, I think.

  • @offtheradarsomewhere.
    @offtheradarsomewhere. 11 дней назад +2

    Interpretation of experiences, creates our uniqueness 💫💙🙏

  • @pandoraeeris7860
    @pandoraeeris7860 11 дней назад +2

    Without my Driver's License, I wouldn't have ID.

  • @Hugoknots
    @Hugoknots 11 дней назад +6

    So many assertions, very little elaboration.

  • @joelharris4399
    @joelharris4399 11 дней назад +4

    One of the profoundest truths you'll ever learn in this lifetime without having to resort to the arcane arts: know thyself

  • @S3RAVA3LM
    @S3RAVA3LM 11 дней назад +1

    Personal identity(person):
    1. Birthed, therefore somebody's baby(child). Born in a country, therefore insert national identity. Skin color, therefore insert color identity. Sex, therefore, insert either male or female. Personality, therefore, another conditioned identity. Has preferences, therefore insert such condition as identity, i.e. christian, muslim, liberal, conservative, etc. Has to do with the corporeal organism, aka the body.
    Hu-man(soul) - what it means to be man:
    1. To become Self realized. Self inquire. Know thyself. Long towards the stars, yearn for higher knowledge and wisdom. Be kind to all life, mutual with thy person and all nature. Tend nature, care for her, and she will care for you. Acknowledge natural order and abide by such divine law. Seek the Divine - recognize Truth, Justice, The Good, Beauty, Wisdom. Appreciate also creativity, emotion, imagination, and not only logical and rational thinking. Be disciplined and true to heart. Recollect and become divinized.

  • @XcRainbowBrighT
    @XcRainbowBrighT 11 дней назад +5

    so do not think critically is what she said. 1:19

    • @devos3212
      @devos3212 6 дней назад

      Ya thats pretty much what I took away from this interview. Ridiculous.

  • @dongshengdi773
    @dongshengdi773 11 дней назад

    Science says we shouldn't be existing.
    The Anthropic Principle:
    This concept suggests that we observe the universe as we do because if it were significantly different, we wouldn't be here to observe it, potentially explaining the seemingly fine-tuned conditions for life.
    The Problem of the "Fine-Tuning":
    Scientists point to the seemingly improbable values of fundamental physical constants that appear necessary for life to exist, raising questions about why these values are as they are.

  • @ptgannon1
    @ptgannon1 9 дней назад +1

    She is using the word, "know" when she should be using the word "believe." She certainly doesn't know. She has faith, which means she pretends to know things she does not know. Robert asked the key question: What is the mechanism by which this happens, and she has no answer.
    QFT or quantum field theory explains the mechanism. Who we are is the culmination of all the thoughts, education, memories, experiences, emotions, etc. we have over the course of a lifetime. Every one of those were created by neurons firing. No neurons firing = no thoughts. QFT tells us that we and our natural world are comprised of (mostly) quarks and electrons) and it tells us EVERYTHING that interacts with that stuff. Neurons, like the rest of our world are made of quarks and electrons. All the "information" that comes from neurons firing is found within those quarks and electrons, and when we die, they dissipate back into the cosmos through decomposition or cremation. QFT confirms beyond reasonable doubt that there are no god, devil, soul, ghost or spirit forces, fields or particles (vibrating fields) interacting with the quarks and electrons, we and our natural world are made of, and that renders gods, devils and whatnot moot. There is no mechanism by which "who we are" continues beyond death. Robert asked the right question, and he got no answer. She provided no good reason to share her infantile belief.

  • @907-q7u
    @907-q7u 10 дней назад

    An inner-monologue for starters.

  • @someonesomeone25
    @someonesomeone25 9 дней назад

    The self is largely a narrative and language illusion, there is no permanent self. We do change.

  • @hisham_m-f5m
    @hisham_m-f5m 11 дней назад +1

    For me, I see "Social Construct" including us as a part of such construct is the only valid answer to this profound question.

  • @rahullahiri4668
    @rahullahiri4668 11 дней назад +2

    The short answer : social security number

  • @gettaasteroid4650
    @gettaasteroid4650 11 дней назад +1

    the details are always important, you can't strain the whole thing off just to remove a philosopher only to turn around and swallow the whole camel

  • @jackwt7340
    @jackwt7340 10 дней назад +1

    How did the universe evolve the sense of fear? 😱

  • @williamburts3114
    @williamburts3114 11 дней назад +1

    To be aware is to be self-aware. And that is a truth that is ever-constant and not transitory.

    • @williamburts3114
      @williamburts3114 5 дней назад

      @SillyHumons True, but knowing that you "be" or "am" underlies all of that.

    • @williamburts3114
      @williamburts3114 5 дней назад

      @SillyHumons to me, knowing that " you be" or " am" is what constitutes "self" since to be aware is to be self-aware.

    • @williamburts3114
      @williamburts3114 4 дня назад

      @SillyHumonsYou asked? "Is there anything more to it"? Not that I am conscious of. Consciousness just could be an existence that is the basis of its own support.

  • @User-kjxklyntrw
    @User-kjxklyntrw 10 дней назад

    If material world made of collapsing vibrational energy, how we able to thinking, how mind be exist

  • @iamZubairShaikh
    @iamZubairShaikh 11 дней назад +2

    It's our souls all the way.

    • @LuuLuong-bn8iy
      @LuuLuong-bn8iy 11 дней назад

      sold souls so..... 😅😂😂😂😂

    • @iamZubairShaikh
      @iamZubairShaikh 11 дней назад

      @LuuLuong-bn8iy you can't sell your soul... what people do so to say in certain circumstances is they compromise their INTEGRITY and subdue their CONSCIOUS.

  • @Maxwell-mv9rx
    @Maxwell-mv9rx 11 дней назад +2

    Lack experiement and details . She doesnt explains what is soul or self. Consequencies About It she keep out serious philosophy. Wortheless rethoric. Conseuscionss figure out self It is brain activities is nil evidence. She shows senseless rethoric.

  • @Jinxed007
    @Jinxed007 11 дней назад

    So the things you "do know" hinge 100% on the things you "can't know"?

  • @cstbb568
    @cstbb568 11 дней назад +6

    Well I suppose you can believe whatever makes you feel good, it doesn't mean it is scientific.

    • @edgarrenenartatez1932
      @edgarrenenartatez1932 9 дней назад

      And they didn't claim their discussion was a scientific one. Their discussion was interdisciplinary- crisscrossing philosophy, science, and theology.

    • @cstbb568
      @cstbb568 9 дней назад

      @@edgarrenenartatez1932 Agree, but what I meant is that if you are proposing some explanation in that area, I understand it should be verifiable scientifically.

    • @zgobermn6895
      @zgobermn6895 8 дней назад

      @@cstbb568 The scientist, the philosopher, the theologian, even simply a thinking person can look at the data (observed phenomenon) and propose hypothesis that attempt to explain the data. Even in the field of science scientists often make inferences (as do the other disciplines) that go beyond mere descriptions of data and into the field of logic (which is not science though science utilizes logic to be credible). Theories are then constructed that not only purport to explain the data but are also used to predict further inquiries. Now theories can be 'purely' scientific or philosophical (that has implications for metaphysics e.g., theological) or both (there are always unknowns especially when dealing with 'unobservables').

    • @cstbb568
      @cstbb568 8 дней назад

      @@zgobermn6895 True, anyone can propose whatever hypothesis he wants, but as long as you can't mesure or explain it with science it stays at that, an opinion, a belief if you want, You can't postulate it as a fact.

  • @ansleyrubarb8672
    @ansleyrubarb8672 11 дней назад +1

    ...Please, we are wonderfully formed in the womb. We each have different fingerprints, gifts,& talents. Not only this, suppose after we pass, what we have learned, in our lives, our next life is in the Quantum state. Where we learn to exist with in new parameters more GOD like by choice. Simply love GOD & our neighbors as requested by GOD. A 2nd Heaven operating within GOD'S Love, Peace, & Joy, respectfully, ordinarychuck hotmail... captivus brevis... you tube... Blessings...

  • @LuuLuong-bn8iy
    @LuuLuong-bn8iy 11 дней назад +1

    souls sold so.... 😅😂😂😂😂

    • @evaadam3635
      @evaadam3635 11 дней назад

      ...paid with cash or hell ?😢

    • @christianrelloso2649
      @christianrelloso2649 10 дней назад

      There are horror story that his soul sold to the devil in exchange for wealth and pleasure, but his life made it weak and miserable.

  • @jamesruscheinski8602
    @jamesruscheinski8602 10 дней назад

    brain recoheres into quantum time - space?

  • @sujok-acupuncture9246
    @sujok-acupuncture9246 11 дней назад +4

    She is under hallucinations...

  • @aothman55
    @aothman55 11 дней назад

    She is having an allusion that she or we are going to have next world. The question is what are you going to do over there.

  • @jamesruscheinski8602
    @jamesruscheinski8602 10 дней назад

    brain causation?

  • @mikemattingly9181
    @mikemattingly9181 9 дней назад

    au-GUS-tin

  • @ingenuity296
    @ingenuity296 10 дней назад +1

    Do cells have souls? Are they reincarnated?

  • @SandipChitale
    @SandipChitale 10 дней назад

    Every time she is on CTT she loses more credibility. "Secular Philosophers do not have any answers either!" she goes ....really? May be she should listen to "Max More - What Does It Mean to Be a Person?" video on CTT.

  • @ThomasChalloner
    @ThomasChalloner 10 дней назад

    Cheese wine processed foods

  • @stevewest7851
    @stevewest7851 10 дней назад

    Interview an astrologer next

  • @MarkVincent-v4i
    @MarkVincent-v4i 11 дней назад

    No. We are souls and uniquely made in God's image.
    Yes, I agree resurrection of the body.
    Yes and No. Moral character of Jesus is now and not yet. Perfect love is actualized because of Christ and realized in the Holy Spirit.

    • @alirezam7247
      @alirezam7247 11 дней назад

      I think we can agree that aside from our identities, our personality changes with age.
      If resurrection is true, which persona among the continuum of the ones we evolved will be resurrected?
      Note that you cant necessarily pick the moment before death because otherwise how would you deal with someone who has lost their mind due to Alzheimer or some other disease or accident?

  • @jhunt5578
    @jhunt5578 11 дней назад

    Gobbledygook

  • @evaadam3635
    @evaadam3635 11 дней назад +1

    "What Give Us Personal Identity?"
    It is not your physical human body, enslaved or driven by natural laws, that defines your true personal identity..
    It is your Freedom to BELIEVE anything for good or bad reason that exposes the fact that your WILL is NOT NATURAL...
    ..this truth about your "Freedom to Choose What to BELIEVE", which can not be a property of physical matter, defines your true personal identity as SUPERNATURAL which I believe is your free aware immortal soul who is a free split of the Holy Spirit...
    ... without the existence of your free immortal soul, you are no different than a mere animal driven by natural instincts, no free choice and, so, can not be held accountable..
    ..the existence of our supernatural immortal souls with Free Will to CHOOSE is the reason why we are accountable for the consequences of the free choices we make...
    ..it is also the reason why the only rational choice of belief to explain our origin is the belief in the existence of a Supernatural SOURCE or GOD...