katrina-range ng voice nya nakakabilib,at runs riff,to empress sarah- diction,tone ng voice, emotion, clarity,ramdam na ramdam mo ang ibig sbhin ng kanta na anak
I guess, both of them, are giving justice to this song "Anak" with their powerful voices and wonderful versions. That's what we are being Filipinos, created by our Almighty God with every unique talent. Please let's stop comparing them because it couldn't help them as our fellow Filipino Citizens.❤❤❤❤❤ #SpreadTheLoveNotHate❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
No comparison. Both are great sa sari-sariling boses at version. Louie Ocampo yan guys. Para kumanta si Sarah at Katrina sa concert, it means, theyre both great! 🫰
mas mganda kc ang version ni KATRINA VELARDE buhay ang dugo mo pag c KATRINA VELARDE ang umatake kkaiba out of this world ang boses ni KATRINA VELARDE pang world class ang performance ni KATRINA VELARDE yun lang period no.
Katrina focus sa Vocals, Vs Sarah mas nag Focus sa Vocals at Portraying ng character and giving the real message ng kanta, at Hindi lahat kayang Gawin Yan except Kay Ms Lea Salonga, kaya nga sabi nga ni Ms Reg dati sa interview nya ni required sa kanya kumuha ng acting course para , mag karoong sya ng emotion sa pag kanta, at ung tamang delivery, phrases ng song ,
Sarah was superb. Katrina was supreme. The fact that the arrangement was really intended for Sarah, na naitawid at naihain pa ni Katrina, walang comparison dapat. Ibig sabihin ganun kahirap ang keys ng areglo n yan. Bravo to both great artists.
This is the only comment n ngustuhan ko . Some people can't really appreciate Katrina's work . I love both of them . They're both great singers and unique in their own way. 🙏🏻❤
mga content creator lng nman tlaga ang may pa comparison nkakabwisit... kaya kahit deserve ni mamshie Kat na makilala at marinig ang kanyang musika kahit man lang sa RUclips, hnde, kasi dahil sa Vs Vs na yan, dahil jan hndi nagiging interesado ang iba na pansinin ang musika ni Kat kasi naunahan na ng katoxican ng ibang fan ng singers... I'm not a "popster" but my Tita is... as in yung popster na present sa shows like sa ASAP, yung sumisigaw ng "we love you Sarah"... but I love SarahG pero hndi diehard... those were the popsters I knew from mid 2000-2010, with personalities like SarahG, pero ngayon mygosh mema nlang tlaga ang mga 'fans kuno' mga genZ fans na kasabayan ng pag usbong ng social media.. mga toxic grabe
Sarah G the Best sya ang nanalo sa classick rock awards sa japan mga international singer ang mga kalaban nya..yan ang version nya..kailangan ba yan tinatanong.
Parehong magaling. Hindi dapat ikinukumpara dahil meron clang kanya kanyang boses na napakaganda. Magkaiba cla ng atake pero I must say outstanding tlga pareho. Walang itulak kabigin!!!
@@ligaya8341 Huwag ka ngang ano jan...kaya nagkakagulo mga fans ng dalawa paaway ka rin ehh noh. Di matanggap...di matanggap! Hiwag nga kayong nangdadoqn ng mga tao.
Dun plang sa ung part na "at ang Tanong anak, bakit ka nag kaganyan?" malalaman muna kung ganu ka galing na singer si sarah, ung pain, anger , pagiging aggressive sa pag kanta, ung lungkot ,wow talaga, sa buong performance nya nagawa nyang ipag combined Ang acting skills at singing, at napaka rare ng mga ganyang bagay sa pinas ngaun, malalaman mo nlang ung ibig sabihin ko kung pano bigkasin ni Katrina ung part na un vs ung Kay Sarah, alam na kung sino panalo delivery palang, giving the meaning of the song, Period Sarah is Really a Great Artist, kaya nga nanalo sya as Best Asian Performer dahil sa Kantang Yan sa Classic Rock Awards na ginanap sa Japan, Kasama nya mga ibang International Rock artist , sa buong Mundo, iba talaga nagagawa ng magaling ka na ngang Singer , magaling ka pang Actress,
Mas ramdam ko talaga yung kanta sa version ni Sarah. Well, ginawa ang arrangement na yan for Sarah G. Sobrang satisfying kung paano niya nilaro yung kanta. Still the unbeatable version.
Dun ako sa na feel ku yung kanta at talagang ramdam mo Ang massage ng song kahit dalhin nyopo ito sa contest aminin natin o Hindi si Sarah Ang winner dyan sa mga judge hehe
Di naman need tanungin yan i love both but Sarah g no one can defeat her bawat kinakanta nya talagang ina-act nya ng may angas take note with with D6 Note po ang anak version nya
Parehas magaling po , pero iba talaga Kay queen sgg , madadala ka , ramdam n ramdam ang meaning ng kanta , grabeee lng talaga ung emosyon plus angas 👏👏🙌
Wag nating pagkumparahin. Pareho silang talentado. Parehong Viva Artists. Iniidolo rin ni Katrina si Sarah. Nag host si Sarah ng Little Big Star kung saan contender si Katrina with Charice and Sam Concepcion.
The best parin c Sarah kumanta.kc with feelings talaga.hindi basta lang birit..tsaka tapos na cia sa ganra ng pueot birit binago na nia ang janra nia.ung janra na naaayon sa titulo nia as Popstar Royalty..
Ang lyrics ng Anak parang script lang Yan sa pelikula, dapat alam mo I deliver , at I portray ng Tama, kaya nga madalas sabihin ng mga vocal coach" singer is like an actor" pero sa nakikita ko Ang daming faney d2 Di alam kung anng Tama at Mali, how many times Nakita nating ganyan style ni kat sa pag kanta, iisa lang ung way ni kat sa pag portray pag deliver ng kanta, ung pag bigkas plang nya sa, at Ang Tanong anak, bakit ka nag ka ganyan, Wala na eh, semplang na sya Doon, kung typical na singing, oo magaling tlga sya, as a singer/biretera lang, pero as an Artist, Hindi tlaga , ung part nga lang sa dulo monotone na, binigkas nya lang ung line, tapos, literal na effortless, Kinanta nya lang pero , delivery, ung tamang phrases, un Ang sablay sa kanya, kung sa bagay, trademark na Yan ng mga lyric soprano, ganyang style, kaya nga Kilala sila sa buong Mundo most common type of voice, Kahit sa classical music napaka kunti lang nakukuha nilang rule dahil sa tone ng voice at way nila ng pag dedeliver ng song , pero sa TaaS ng boses no question Doon, bentang benta d2 sa pinas ,
Kahit sino magcover nito walang makakapantay sa version ni Sarah kung pataasan ng boses walang duda na mas magaling si Kat..hndi man kasing taas ang boses ni Sarah gaya ng mga biritira..pero grabe ang astig ng performance..yung growl at headbang pa lang rockstar na rockstar ang dating..lahat talaga ng genre kayang-kaya nyang kantahin .kudos din kay Ms.Kat sobrang taas ng version nya.
Realtalk magkaiba sila yung kay kat tugtug lang ang rock birit version padin kay katrina,, at rock yung kay sarah tugtug pati voice at atake kasama n character ni sarah rock n rock. Wag na ipilit pareho magaling sa totoo lang.
D nman maipgkakaila magaling c Katrina pero ng pakinggan ko Po ito n different time alam muh ung napapapaangat aq with SG every moves Kasama p Ang facial expressions samantalang Kay miss vilarde kalma lng hahahaha
Omg kinikilabutan ako sa kanta ni satah g. Subrang linis ay napaka power ng voice mag sama samang head tone growl. Omg I'll go for sarah g. Also aye kat is soo good suoer sustained ang high notes and linis din pero ung emotionns ng sarag g gigil nakaka panindig balahibo 😇♥️ both are so doing well 😇
it's right!that it's not really about raising the voice, but about how to make the song a story..besides, they both have high notes, maybe we can hear that SG still has a semi-whistle.pero ang masasabi ko lang pareho silang magaling that's it! Period ☺️
Sarah is more of like - story telling, na malumanay at first, then maangas ang mga bigkas ng salita sa dulo na parang kasama ako sa kwento. Katrina is gearing towards power vocals! Forte nya is belting. Naaral nya agad ang kanta that was intended for Sarah. Both were supreme!! Mahuhusay and magagaling.
I u guys doesn't listen it right, Katrina Velarde is one of kind .from lower notes to highest pitch w/o any cracking her voice, with sustain long one pitch . Loewe Ocampo never regret or appreciate what Katrina did her song ANAK. HE WAS VERY HAPPY how she sang it .Awesome Katrina velarde your one the kind singer. God bless always.
Hard Rock vs Power Ballad? I'll go for the Rock version. It's very rare for Filipino singers to pull off this kind of vocal skill but power ballad is so common. Just my thought.
Walang bago kay katrina.. alam mong ibibirit nia ng todo at ginawa nga nia.. panget yung puro birit.. sarah naman rock version at akma ang quality ng voice sa kanta. Explosive kay sarah.. kay katrina sa dami ng birit nakakasawa pakinggan.
Walang bago kay SG. Alam na natin na i-hehead bang nya lng yung kanta kase di na mataas boses nya. Nakakasawa na yung puro tula at head bang lng. Naisip mo ba to. Edi same lng. Hahahahaha!
So heto nanaman po tau, nagkokompara nanaman kay SG 🙄🙄 sa video na to nakailang kanta na si SG that time? Si KV yan lang ung kinanta sa buong concert ni Sir Louie.
bakit ito yung piniling video kay sarah? marami pa si sarah na version na mas buo boses niya at mas rock ang atake nya. bakit ito yung nilagay? hayy mga ibang pinoy talaga. rock ang arrangement ng kanta pero ginagawang birit ang basehan tapos binabash si sarah dahil kinanta nya ng rock. nanalo si sarah ng international classic rock awards sa version nya no. mahiya nga kayo bago kayo mangbash.
My 1st Love Sarah G. 2nd is Katrina V. Both of them are Filipinos Pride. Amazing Artist and different in many ways...Sarah G. Is up there, while Katrina V. Is getting there...they both shining, 🇵🇭♥️
I love Katrina and I know when its Kat, it's always going to be out of this world especially her riffs and runs. But I have to go with Sarah's performance here. The vocal shifting, the tone, her phrasing and how she plays around with the character of her voice really gave the song with lots of colors and dimensions. Though knowing that this was not arranged for Kat and still gave justice to the song, really worth a recognition. Both of them are amazing in their own way!
Katrina is awesome, the best singer ever. She can prolong from lowerst notes to the highest longest w/o breaking voice w vibrado of course w/o breathing in one note till the end . That's Katrina best singer in the Philippines and the world. She sings with meaning to it .
Kat better superior breath control, note extension. Just technically better and only 24 hours to prepare. Give it up for the girl, Sarah, she bailed your ___ out.
@@sersoisoimedia8494people seems to forget that singing is an art and most of the time one artist speaks to you more than the other because just like any form of art, some likes modern and some likes classical just as how some likes ballad and some likes rnb. So yeah my point is its a matter of preference. Both did very well, no one surpasses the other because art does not work that way. But my preference here, the artist that spoke to me is Sarah. But still kudos to Kat because she is still amazing.
Sorry to say pro di naman pataasan ang labanan sa pagkanta. Sa pagdeliver yan ng message. Sarah G deliver the message very well. Kahit rock version sya ng Anak andun yung mensahe about sa Anak. Only people who appreciates music understand that. Quality pa lng ng boses ni Sarah sa first line malakas na ang impact.
@@Phil-xx6fu alin ang mag belt ng highnotes?😂madami ng biritira dito sa Pinas dear,hndi na bago sa pandinig ng mga tao.hndi man kasing taas ang boses ni Sarah gaya ng mga biritira pero kaya nya din..pero ang mga kayang gawin ni Sarah hndi nya kayang gawin..lahat ng genre kayang kantahin ni Sarah..ang pagsayaw habang kumanta pa lang hndi na nila kaya.
@@Phil-xx6fu eh bakit never ko pa narinig si katrina magboses rakista o mag growl man lang na tunog natural? sabi mo kaya gawin lahat ng kaya ni sarah diba? mataas boses niya oo. pero marami pa rin ako di naririnig na genre at timbre sa boses niya na nagagawa ni sarah.
Isang patunay na mahirap ang mga ginagawa ni sarahg ang daming technique ni sarahg jusko halimaw kung halimaw mapapanganga ka talaga c kath nmn ok din kaso pansin kulang si kath nakafucos lang sa mataas na tono di katulad ni sarahg jusko nakakagulat ka sarahg napapabilib mo ako
First of all can we appreciate both? u can't just throw fake and bias statements against these two artists just bc you hate one of them. no matter what you say about katrina, she's still vocally impressive, the woman can sing with great agility, on the other hand, Sarah G. which is emotions and swag on performing the song. both are incredible singer. y'all stop pitting these women against each other. both great, both have job, both can sing, both can deliver a song, both have talent than all the haters out there. opx!
@@joeteeignacio9230 magaling lang sya sa highnotes...pero mas unbeatable ang rock ni Sarah.w/ headbang pa yan ha..while Kat nakafocus sya sa highnotes.
@@Arahmie2396 I disagree. Mas magaling din sa low notes si Kat over Sarah so let's not go there. Sarah is great being a complete package, but singing wise - I'd go for Kat any day.
There is no point comparing! They are both great in their own craft. They have individuality. Yan naman tayo sa kumpara2x. Away lang patutunguhan nyan. Why not appreciate their rendition? Pasalamat nlng tayo may tumanggap sa awitin na yan. Sa kahirap2x nmn ng song na yan at galing pa ni Sarah magperform ng song, appreciate nlng natin na binigyan justice and respect ang song at ang arrangement. Maging kontento at masaya nlng tayo. I think proud naman si Sarah sa performance ni Kat. Kahit di same sa performance eh naitaguyod din naman po. Peace yo'all!
Madalas tong sabihin ng mga vocal coach ung line na to - "Singer are like an Actor" si Sarah mas nag focus sa pag kwento ng meaning ng kanta, si Katrina focus sa pag sustain ng note un Ang pinag kaiba, Sarah can sustain long note ,pero pinili nyang i interpret ng maganda ung song, kaysa mag focus sa vocals lang, lahat ng mga vocal coach sinasabi itong line na to Singer are like actors, at ung kanta na anak ung lyrics nun un Ang script mo , depende sa singer kung mag fofocus sya sa technical, or sa Meaning ng song, sa case ni Sarah nag focus sya sa dalawa ,iba Ang atake ni Sarah sa song , combination ng acting, delivery at great phrases plus vocals, Vs Katrina Vocals lang , Ang ginagawa ni Sarah na parang kinakapos ng hininga is artistic choice, special mabigat ung meaning Nung song, ma drama, kaya ganun Ang tunog Kay Sarah, crying, kinakapos , breathy , anger, pag susumamo, at ung Ang kulang Kay Katrina, pero maiintindihan nman un Kasi Di nman sya actress. Like Sarah, Tandaan mo sabi nga ni Regine, kaya nga pina kuha sya ng acting course dahil Wala syang ka emo emotion kumanta ng baguhan pa sya, same Kay Katrina ngaun, technically, no questions, pero delivery, pare parehas lang tunog ng mga biriterang singer ngaun, puro ingay lang maririnig mo, parang latang walang laman. Kaya dun palang malalaman mo, na mas magaling at mas matalino si Sarah Kay Katrina , when it comes to singing and portraying the character,. And giving true message ng kanta.
@@meganzaldariagga7396 at ung mga sinabi ko un Ang Wala sya, technically no question, magaling tlaga sya as a typical singer sa pinas / biritera, pero as an Artist, Hindi, kung totoong magaling syang artist, why Wala sya super Hit, song, madaming nag sasabing magaling sya but , walang bumibili sa quality ng voice nya may may original song sya pero walang puso pag kumakanta, dun palang patunay na impressed nya lang mga ibang tao sa TaaS ng boses nya, pero Hindi Ang mga puso nila, phrases plang obvious na, dun plang sa part Ang at Ang tanng Anak, bakit ka nag ka ganyan, semplang na sya delivery plang, may ganun bang magaling na artist, o singer, , tinalo pa sya nila kz, yeng , Juris at Moira,
hindi raw kaya ni sarah ang mataas but sarah hit D6 note (headtone) in this video. saka nilagyan lang ng runs at may sustained notes mas magaling na agad? lol no hate kay kat she was also amazing here but the audacity ng sa comsec to compare her to THEE sarah geronimo??? saka ibabash niyo pa??? u better stop. sarah aint won best asian performer at the classic rock awards in japan for this version for nothing.
Alam mo kung gano kababaw ung ibang supporter d2, Reaction nila, - gabeh ung Long Notes, Lung Power, Birit, Ang TaaS ng boses😂😂😂 Huh talaga ba, Yan Ang basehan nyo pagiging magaling, Di nga alam pano ibigay ung message ng kanta, to think na Ang bigat Nung kanta, bawat lines, kahit anng birit Gawin nya, pag nawala ung kahulugan nung kanta , mawawal din pati galing mo sa pag kanta, kaya nga Di sya sumisikat ng husto, mas sikat pa si Moira, Kz, Juris , mas maraming nabentang album, at kanta, - Tama nga ung line , na aanhin mo Ang dilata kung Wala nman laman, ganyan mga singer ngaun na biritera, parang lata Ang iingay, . Kasi nga walang laman pag Kumanta.
As far as I know, yong number ni Katrina intended talaga kay Sarah. Siguro may emergency and need ng replacement para sa prod na to and lucky si Katrina napili, which is grabe naman talaga vocal range ni girl. Ayon nabasa ko lang sa isang post ni Katrina. Pero ANGAS talaga ng kay SG. Bute nga bumalik na sa ASAP at may sarili siyang prod. Miss it so much, SARAH GERONIMO forever 😍😍😍😍
I was Very Entaintained, Sarah is great for story telling of that's song.. and sinabayan pa ng mga high notes ni Kat . wla naku hahanapin pa.. nasa kanilang dalawa na Ang hanap ko.. I'm so proud to be Filipino...
Dito mo talaga makikita ang character ng boses ni Sarah. It may not as high as Kat's rendition pero 'yong storytelling and emotion ay talagang top-notch para kay Sarah G. Siya iyong klase ng performer na may wow factor talaga.
katrina's take was great but no one beats the original (sarah g) sarah even won best asian performer at the classic rock awards in japan because of her performance of this song anak.
Tigilan nyo nga ako sa ganyang paniniwala na NO ONE BEATS THE ORIGINAL. hahaha. Ang tanging lamang lng ng original ay dahil sya ang naunang kumanta ng song na yun but that doesn't mean na yun na ang best rendition. Ampaka tanga naman kung ganyan magisip. Hahahahaa. Isip isip naman pag may time. Hehehehe. 🤗🤗🤗❤❤❤👍👍👍😍😛😛
Mas maganda parin ang version ni Sarah..kumbaga yung message talaga ng song para sa anak mararamdaman mo.mas mataas lang ang version ni Kat.tapos mas madaming birit kay Kat ..kay Sarah kasi pure rock..hndi nman kasi rock version kay Kat.yung growl pa lang ni Sarah rockstar na rockstar ang dating...tsaka FYI yan ang nagpanalo sa Japan classic Rock award na kasabayan nya magperform Aerosmith,Johny Deep.and many more na Rockstar sa international.
Sarah g Ang may highest version kung high notes lang basehan nyo haha mga di marunong makinig naka-hit sya ng D6 Notes with angas story basta walang makakapantay kahit sino pa itapat nyo mga hunghang🤣
Wow.napaka galing.gandang sapat naman talaga.super cute 😘 ng nag iisang super mega 🌈 diamond 💎 for all season 💞 concert 🎶 dancing queen 👑 Asian pop Royalty 🙌 super star ⭐✨ pretty pantastic idol.9,999stars yan.🤩👋💯👏🌌🌟🌠💫👍✨⭐🙌👑🎶💞💎🌈😘
1. Galing kumanta. Taas ng boses. Pangmalakasan. Nakakamangha. 😮 2. Kinausap at pinagalitan ako. Pinamukha sa akin kung gaano ako kasira ulo. Pinamukha sa akin kung gaano kahalaga yung mga magulang ko. Sa isang kanta, rock pa. Nakakaiyak. 😢
Strength talaga ni Sarah G Ang head voice.. they are both great.. magaling din si kat pero iba Kay Sarah G may angas.. pagbumibirit talaga sya may pagka Celine Dion talaga Ang tone nya..Basta I can't explain.. Pareho Silang magaling walang tapon..
katrina-range ng voice nya nakakabilib,at runs riff,to empress
sarah- diction,tone ng voice, emotion, clarity,ramdam na ramdam mo ang ibig sbhin ng kanta na anak
On point ♥️
I guess, both of them, are giving justice to this song "Anak" with their powerful voices and wonderful versions. That's what we are being Filipinos, created by our Almighty God with every unique talent. Please let's stop comparing them because it couldn't help them as our fellow Filipino Citizens.❤❤❤❤❤
#SpreadTheLoveNotHate❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Pareho lang na magaling.
Let's just appreciate them both please. 💙❤️💚
No comparison. Both are great sa sari-sariling boses at version. Louie Ocampo yan guys. Para kumanta si Sarah at Katrina sa concert, it means, theyre both great! 🫰
Parehong Magaling Pero Mas na feel ko ang version ni Sarah 👏👏👏
🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Si Sarah pa din.Kahit anong SABIHIN ng madami😊
Sgg kami e bakit ba? ✌️
mas mganda kc ang version ni KATRINA VELARDE buhay ang dugo mo pag c KATRINA VELARDE ang umatake kkaiba out of this world ang boses ni KATRINA VELARDE pang world class ang performance ni KATRINA VELARDE yun lang period no.
How supeb you are Sarah my idol so spectacular when you performed and always so gorgeous and the way you dressed up simply stunning ❤️
grabe Yung range Ng voice ni Katrina, talagang ma papawow ka. Pero Kay Sarah andon kasi Yung angas,emotion at the same time.
Katrina focus sa Vocals, Vs Sarah mas nag Focus sa Vocals at Portraying ng character and giving the real message ng kanta, at Hindi lahat kayang Gawin Yan except Kay Ms Lea Salonga, kaya nga sabi nga ni Ms Reg dati sa interview nya ni required sa kanya kumuha ng acting course para , mag karoong sya ng emotion sa pag kanta, at ung tamang delivery, phrases ng song ,
Sarah was superb. Katrina was supreme. The fact that the arrangement was really intended for Sarah, na naitawid at naihain pa ni Katrina, walang comparison dapat. Ibig sabihin ganun kahirap ang keys ng areglo n yan. Bravo to both great artists.
This is the only comment n ngustuhan ko . Some people can't really appreciate Katrina's work . I love both of them . They're both great singers and unique in their own way. 🙏🏻❤
❤
Grabe k sa galing feel n feel ko Ang pgkanta mo sarah
mga content creator lng nman tlaga ang may pa comparison nkakabwisit... kaya kahit deserve ni mamshie Kat na makilala at marinig ang kanyang musika kahit man lang sa RUclips, hnde, kasi dahil sa Vs Vs na yan, dahil jan hndi nagiging interesado ang iba na pansinin ang musika ni Kat kasi naunahan na ng katoxican ng ibang fan ng singers... I'm not a "popster" but my Tita is... as in yung popster na present sa shows like sa ASAP, yung sumisigaw ng "we love you Sarah"... but I love SarahG pero hndi diehard... those were the popsters I knew from mid 2000-2010, with personalities like SarahG, pero ngayon mygosh mema nlang tlaga ang mga 'fans kuno' mga genZ fans na kasabayan ng pag usbong ng social media.. mga toxic grabe
Sa mag collab sila or mag kasama sa concert
Sarah G the Best sya ang nanalo sa classick rock awards sa japan mga international singer ang mga kalaban nya..yan ang version nya..kailangan ba yan tinatanong.
Kat - Sustain and Range
Sara - emotion and story telling
Sarah can also belt.. pero this song is for Sarah may halong rock and powerful tlaga boses nya..maangas di lang boses pati galaw
Parehong magaling. Hindi dapat ikinukumpara dahil meron clang kanya kanyang boses na napakaganda. Magkaiba cla ng atake pero I must say outstanding tlga pareho. Walang itulak kabigin!!!
Oo nga wag kumpara ksi pareho kababayan natin yan ih maging masaya tau sa mga talento ng kababayan natin🇯🇵🇵🇭
Mas magang Ang Sarah ko pang international
@@ligaya8341 Huwag ka ngang ano jan...kaya nagkakagulo mga fans ng dalawa paaway ka rin ehh noh. Di matanggap...di matanggap! Hiwag nga kayong nangdadoqn ng mga tao.
@@ligaya8341 9
Dun plang sa ung part na "at ang Tanong anak, bakit ka nag kaganyan?" malalaman muna kung ganu ka galing na singer si sarah, ung pain, anger , pagiging aggressive sa pag kanta, ung lungkot ,wow talaga, sa buong performance nya nagawa nyang ipag combined Ang acting skills at singing, at napaka rare ng mga ganyang bagay sa pinas ngaun, malalaman mo nlang ung ibig sabihin ko kung pano bigkasin ni Katrina ung part na un vs ung Kay Sarah, alam na kung sino panalo delivery palang, giving the meaning of the song, Period Sarah is Really a Great Artist, kaya nga nanalo sya as Best Asian Performer dahil sa Kantang Yan sa Classic Rock Awards na ginanap sa Japan, Kasama nya mga ibang International Rock artist , sa buong Mundo, iba talaga nagagawa ng magaling ka na ngang Singer , magaling ka pang Actress,
tlga lang h mema klang teh
Sarah parin mas astig .magkaiba sila ng version..Rock version kay Sarah kay Kat naman more on birit.
Mas ramdam ko talaga yung kanta sa version ni Sarah. Well, ginawa ang arrangement na yan for Sarah G. Sobrang satisfying kung paano niya nilaro yung kanta. Still the unbeatable version.
Tama..magaling naman c Katrina pero mas ramdam ko yong version ni Sarah
@@ellacrillon3972 Technicality wise, Sarah served! 💥
Still Sarah Geronimo...the best❤❤❤
For me Forever SarahG♥️♥️♥️
Dun ako sa na feel ku yung kanta at talagang ramdam mo Ang massage ng song kahit dalhin nyopo ito sa contest aminin natin o Hindi si Sarah Ang winner dyan sa mga judge hehe
Tama ,Ms.Lea nga sinasabi na hndi sa taas ng boses masasabi na magaling kang singer.
Patawa ka grabe
Di naman need tanungin yan i love both but Sarah g no one can defeat her bawat kinakanta nya talagang ina-act nya ng may angas take note with with D6 Note po ang anak version nya
Parehas magaling po , pero iba talaga Kay queen sgg , madadala ka , ramdam n ramdam ang meaning ng kanta , grabeee lng talaga ung emosyon plus angas 👏👏🙌
JUST A FACT: Sarah G's version gave the Philippines its first trophy from Classic Rock Awards (the biggest award giving body for Rock genre)
That Classic Rock Award is the counterpart of Grammy's. 😊
Sarah G. Lang Sakalam.. iba kasi yung Ramdam at nafefeel mo yung kanta. Sa Humahanga at Nawiwindang ka sa highNotes.
Katrina is a singer here, and sarah is an artist, she sings with art.
No one can beat iba talaga may pitik e thats my sarah g
Wag nating pagkumparahin. Pareho silang talentado. Parehong Viva Artists. Iniidolo rin ni Katrina si Sarah. Nag host si Sarah ng Little Big Star kung saan contender si Katrina with Charice and Sam Concepcion.
Tama kac mag kaiba sila ng flavour at wag naman gawing sabungan ang momshieKAT ko at sarahGko
The best parin c Sarah kumanta.kc with feelings talaga.hindi basta lang birit..tsaka tapos na cia sa ganra ng pueot birit binago na nia ang janra nia.ung janra na naaayon sa titulo nia as Popstar Royalty..
go for sarah....🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Lahat may knya kanyang galing pero ang narating ni sarah d kayang abutin ng khit sino.✌️✌️
Ang lyrics ng Anak parang script lang Yan sa pelikula, dapat alam mo I deliver , at I portray ng Tama, kaya nga madalas sabihin ng mga vocal coach" singer is like an actor" pero sa nakikita ko Ang daming faney d2 Di alam kung anng Tama at Mali, how many times Nakita nating ganyan style ni kat sa pag kanta, iisa lang ung way ni kat sa pag portray pag deliver ng kanta, ung pag bigkas plang nya sa, at Ang Tanong anak, bakit ka nag ka ganyan, Wala na eh, semplang na sya Doon, kung typical na singing, oo magaling tlga sya, as a singer/biretera lang, pero as an Artist, Hindi tlaga , ung part nga lang sa dulo monotone na, binigkas nya lang ung line, tapos, literal na effortless, Kinanta nya lang pero , delivery, ung tamang phrases, un Ang sablay sa kanya, kung sa bagay, trademark na Yan ng mga lyric soprano, ganyang style, kaya nga Kilala sila sa buong Mundo most common type of voice, Kahit sa classical music napaka kunti lang nakukuha nilang rule dahil sa tone ng voice at way nila ng pag dedeliver ng song , pero sa TaaS ng boses no question Doon, bentang benta d2 sa pinas ,
Wow galing ng idol ko sarah g
Kahit sino magcover nito walang makakapantay sa version ni Sarah kung pataasan ng boses walang duda na mas magaling si Kat..hndi man kasing taas ang boses ni Sarah gaya ng mga biritira..pero grabe ang astig ng performance..yung growl at headbang pa lang rockstar na rockstar ang dating..lahat talaga ng genre kayang-kaya nyang kantahin .kudos din kay Ms.Kat sobrang taas ng version nya.
Realtalk magkaiba sila yung kay kat tugtug lang ang rock birit version padin kay katrina,, at rock yung kay sarah tugtug pati voice at atake kasama n character ni sarah rock n rock. Wag na ipilit pareho magaling sa totoo lang.
Dami niyo hanash
yung version na yan original kay Sarah.
Parehas naman silang magaling bakit need pa ikumpara ..
D nman maipgkakaila magaling c Katrina pero ng pakinggan ko Po ito n different time alam muh ung napapapaangat aq with SG every moves Kasama p Ang facial expressions samantalang Kay miss vilarde kalma lng hahahaha
Queen SG syempre
They have different versions so pareho silang magaling. Just support OPM. Bravo!👏👏👏
Yes po pero version ni SGG po Ginamit ni kath medyo inaba lang kaunti
@@jhezsandres2393 😭🙏
Omg kinikilabutan ako sa kanta ni satah g. Subrang linis ay napaka power ng voice mag sama samang head tone growl. Omg I'll go for sarah g. Also aye kat is soo good suoer sustained ang high notes and linis din pero ung emotionns ng sarag g gigil nakaka panindig balahibo 😇♥️ both are so doing well 😇
it's right!that it's not really about raising the voice, but about how to make the song a story..besides, they both have high notes, maybe we can hear that SG still has a semi-whistle.pero ang masasabi ko lang pareho silang magaling that's it! Period ☺️
Magalig pareho sila....the most important thing be proud everybody...dahil my pareho silang aking galing...
Sarah is more of like - story telling, na malumanay at first, then maangas ang mga bigkas ng salita sa dulo na parang kasama ako sa kwento.
Katrina is gearing towards power vocals! Forte nya is belting. Naaral nya agad ang kanta that was intended for Sarah.
Both were supreme!! Mahuhusay and magagaling.
I u guys doesn't listen it right, Katrina Velarde is one of kind .from lower notes to highest pitch w/o any cracking her voice, with sustain long one pitch . Loewe Ocampo never regret or appreciate what Katrina did her song ANAK. HE WAS VERY HAPPY how she sang it .Awesome Katrina velarde your one the kind singer. God bless always.
Agree ,katrina voice is one of à kind, Sarah is good too. But singing wise Katrina is super good. This is our opinion love from California.
Sarah ♥️
Angas at gigil ikaw na talaga Sarah. Salute!
Hard Rock vs Power Ballad? I'll go for the Rock version. It's very rare for Filipino singers to pull off this kind of vocal skill but power ballad is so common. Just my thought.
Sarah G ❤❤❤
Dun ako sa umaawit na nagkukwento. Yung ramdam ko ang mensahe ng kanta. Superb as always - Sarah!
Sarah padin malinaw yong bosis malamig tagos sa puso
Walang bago kay katrina.. alam mong ibibirit nia ng todo at ginawa nga nia.. panget yung puro birit.. sarah naman rock version at akma ang quality ng voice sa kanta. Explosive kay sarah.. kay katrina sa dami ng birit nakakasawa pakinggan.
Walang bago kay SG. Alam na natin na i-hehead bang nya lng yung kanta kase di na mataas boses nya. Nakakasawa na yung puro tula at head bang lng. Naisip mo ba to. Edi same lng. Hahahahaha!
Sarah, xempre feelings wow😢😢😢
So heto nanaman po tau, nagkokompara nanaman kay SG 🙄🙄 sa video na to nakailang kanta na si SG that time? Si KV yan lang ung kinanta sa buong concert ni Sir Louie.
bakit ito yung piniling video kay sarah? marami pa si sarah na version na mas buo boses niya at mas rock ang atake nya. bakit ito yung nilagay?
hayy mga ibang pinoy talaga. rock ang arrangement ng kanta pero ginagawang birit ang basehan tapos binabash si sarah dahil kinanta nya ng rock. nanalo si sarah ng international classic rock awards sa version nya no. mahiya nga kayo bago kayo mangbash.
My 1st Love Sarah G.
2nd is Katrina V.
Both of them are Filipinos Pride.
Amazing Artist and different in many ways...Sarah G. Is up there, while Katrina V. Is getting there...they both shining, 🇵🇭♥️
Syempre una kong naging idol si SG 2nd si KV❤
No need to compare the two artist. They are both amazing. They have different versions. And they did so well
I love Katrina and I know when its Kat, it's always going to be out of this world especially her riffs and runs. But I have to go with Sarah's performance here. The vocal shifting, the tone, her phrasing and how she plays around with the character of her voice really gave the song with lots of colors and dimensions. Though knowing that this was not arranged for Kat and still gave justice to the song, really worth a recognition. Both of them are amazing in their own way!
To each his own, I prefer Kat's, too powerful to be ignored.
Katrina is awesome, the best singer ever. She can prolong from lowerst notes to the highest longest w/o breaking voice w vibrado of course w/o breathing in one note till the end . That's Katrina best singer in the Philippines and the world. She sings with meaning to it .
Kat better superior breath control, note extension. Just technically better and only 24 hours to prepare. Give it up for the girl, Sarah, she bailed your ___ out.
People who appreciate true music does not compare two great and amazing artist with different versions
@@sersoisoimedia8494people seems to forget that singing is an art and most of the time one artist speaks to you more than the other because just like any form of art, some likes modern and some likes classical just as how some likes ballad and some likes rnb. So yeah my point is its a matter of preference. Both did very well, no one surpasses the other because art does not work that way. But my preference here, the artist that spoke to me is Sarah. But still kudos to Kat because she is still amazing.
Sorry to say pro di naman pataasan ang labanan sa pagkanta. Sa pagdeliver yan ng message. Sarah G deliver the message very well. Kahit rock version sya ng Anak andun yung mensahe about sa Anak. Only people who appreciates music understand that. Quality pa lng ng boses ni Sarah sa first line malakas na ang impact.
Tama .mas gusto ko version ni Sarah ..iba ang atake eh, rock version pero sobrang tagos 🥰😍❤️
I thought only people who appreciates understand. You should also appreciate Katrina. Both them did so well
Sarah is more soulful while katrina shows her vocal range ..
Kat can do both of those.
@@Phil-xx6fu Walang soul ang Kat mo
@@Taurean511 Yung magagawa ni SG kayang kaya ni Kat pero yung kayang gawin ni Kat....🙂
@@Phil-xx6fu alin ang mag belt ng highnotes?😂madami ng biritira dito sa Pinas dear,hndi na bago sa pandinig ng mga tao.hndi man kasing taas ang boses ni Sarah gaya ng mga biritira pero kaya nya din..pero ang mga kayang gawin ni Sarah hndi nya kayang gawin..lahat ng genre kayang kantahin ni Sarah..ang pagsayaw habang kumanta pa lang hndi na nila kaya.
@@Phil-xx6fu eh bakit never ko pa narinig si katrina magboses rakista o mag growl man lang na tunog natural? sabi mo kaya gawin lahat ng kaya ni sarah diba? mataas boses niya oo. pero marami pa rin ako di naririnig na genre at timbre sa boses niya na nagagawa ni sarah.
sarah g. still.
sg. dama mo yung galit, inis at gigil sa anak habang awa sa magulang sa boses, buo pa. yun lang po. hahahahaha.
Sara G still gives the best.. Although Katrina made it too but Sara G emotionally give it all..
Isang patunay na mahirap ang mga ginagawa ni sarahg ang daming technique ni sarahg jusko halimaw kung halimaw mapapanganga ka talaga c kath nmn ok din kaso pansin kulang si kath nakafucos lang sa mataas na tono di katulad ni sarahg jusko nakakagulat ka sarahg napapabilib mo ako
Sarah mas makahulugan at may emosyon. Only Sarah can give justice to this song.
the asia's Queen of pop. Sarah g. parteda concerts pa nyan..pero control at puso sa pag kanta... sarah g. parin tlga.
Magaling si SG sobra
Si katrina naman super powerful!
sarah g story telling tagos sa puso bawat letrang binibigkas
First of all can we appreciate both? u can't just throw fake and bias statements against these two artists just bc you hate one of them. no matter what you say about katrina, she's still vocally impressive, the woman can sing with great agility, on the other hand, Sarah G. which is emotions and swag on performing the song. both are incredible singer. y'all stop pitting these women against each other. both great, both have job, both can sing, both can deliver a song, both have talent than all the haters out there. opx!
I go for Sarah. She is indeed a total performer. Not only she can sing she can also make you feel the song. She can dance and make the stage alive.
i guest you only listen But doesnt know how to sing
Both are Viva's pride. Katrina is great, but Sarah's rendition is unbeatable.
Both artists are awesome.
Nah, Katrina's was so much better by a mile. Sarah did well though.
@@joeteeignacio9230 magaling lang sya sa highnotes...pero mas unbeatable ang rock ni Sarah.w/ headbang pa yan ha..while Kat nakafocus sya sa highnotes.
@@Arahmie2396 I disagree. Mas magaling din sa low notes si Kat over Sarah so let's not go there. Sarah is great being a complete package, but singing wise - I'd go for Kat any day.
@@joeteeignacio9230 okay magkakaiba tayo ng gusto..basta for me mas astig ang perfomance ni Sarah.
@@Arahmie2396 Yes, magkaiba talaga tayo. To each his own. Kaya wag natin i shove sa iba ang gusto natin dahil magkaiba talaga ang gusto ng bawat tao.
Kinililabutan ako kay Sarah! The best 👏👏👏
Kapag Power belter kasi Katrina kasi kaya nya abutin mga high notes. sa low voice nman c Sarah
Kay Sarah parin ako..
Ang angas mo Sars!
Hindi masakit sa tenga. 👏👏👏
Bitr
Katsina is great
Stll Sarah clear ang meaning sa kanta
There is no point comparing! They are both great in their own craft. They have individuality. Yan naman tayo sa kumpara2x. Away lang patutunguhan nyan. Why not appreciate their rendition? Pasalamat nlng tayo may tumanggap sa awitin na yan. Sa kahirap2x nmn ng song na yan at galing pa ni Sarah magperform ng song, appreciate nlng natin na binigyan justice and respect ang song at ang arrangement. Maging kontento at masaya nlng tayo. I think proud naman si Sarah sa performance ni Kat. Kahit di same sa performance eh naitaguyod din naman po. Peace yo'all!
kanya kanya nmn ng gusto. but Sarah Geronimo prin ako ung galaw nya. tapos ung character nong voice nya. dinagdagan pa nya ng super headstone.
Mas naramdaman ko si Sarah dito ❤
Bakit mas ramdam ko yung kay Sarah G, lalong lalo na yung gigil nya sa kanta at yung boses buong buo.
Simple lang, die hard fan ka.
@@romyeohgarrido5558 well, adik talaga ako sa kanya😂
Madalas tong sabihin ng mga vocal coach ung line na to - "Singer are like an Actor" si Sarah mas nag focus sa pag kwento ng meaning ng kanta, si Katrina focus sa pag sustain ng note un Ang pinag kaiba, Sarah can sustain long note ,pero pinili nyang i interpret ng maganda ung song, kaysa mag focus sa vocals lang, lahat ng mga vocal coach sinasabi itong line na to Singer are like actors, at ung kanta na anak ung lyrics nun un Ang script mo , depende sa singer kung mag fofocus sya sa technical, or sa Meaning ng song, sa case ni Sarah nag focus sya sa dalawa ,iba Ang atake ni Sarah sa song , combination ng acting, delivery at great phrases plus vocals, Vs Katrina Vocals lang , Ang ginagawa ni Sarah na parang kinakapos ng hininga is artistic choice, special mabigat ung meaning Nung song, ma drama, kaya ganun Ang tunog Kay Sarah, crying, kinakapos , breathy , anger, pag susumamo, at ung Ang kulang Kay Katrina, pero maiintindihan nman un Kasi Di nman sya actress. Like Sarah, Tandaan mo sabi nga ni Regine, kaya nga pina kuha sya ng acting course dahil Wala syang ka emo emotion kumanta ng baguhan pa sya, same Kay Katrina ngaun, technically, no questions, pero delivery, pare parehas lang tunog ng mga biriterang singer ngaun, puro ingay lang maririnig mo, parang latang walang laman. Kaya dun palang malalaman mo, na mas magaling at mas matalino si Sarah Kay Katrina , when it comes to singing and portraying the character,. And giving true message ng kanta.
Dami mo sinabi Katrina pa din
@@meganzaldariagga7396 😂😂😂 Katrina , kaya nga Wala syang mapasikat na kanta😂😂😂
@@ROCK77733magaling si kat ayw mo lng s knya...kaya ganun coment mo..
@@meganzaldariagga7396 magaling nman talaga si kat, Di ko nman sinabinh hindi
@@meganzaldariagga7396 at ung mga sinabi ko un Ang Wala sya, technically no question, magaling tlaga sya as a typical singer sa pinas / biritera, pero as an Artist, Hindi, kung totoong magaling syang artist, why Wala sya super Hit, song, madaming nag sasabing magaling sya but , walang bumibili sa quality ng voice nya may may original song sya pero walang puso pag kumakanta, dun palang patunay na impressed nya lang mga ibang tao sa TaaS ng boses nya, pero Hindi Ang mga puso nila, phrases plang obvious na, dun plang sa part Ang at Ang tanng Anak, bakit ka nag ka ganyan, semplang na sya delivery plang, may ganun bang magaling na artist, o singer, , tinalo pa sya nila kz, yeng , Juris at Moira,
hindi raw kaya ni sarah ang mataas but sarah hit D6 note (headtone) in this video. saka nilagyan lang ng runs at may sustained notes mas magaling na agad? lol no hate kay kat she was also amazing here but the audacity ng sa comsec to compare her to THEE sarah geronimo??? saka ibabash niyo pa??? u better stop. sarah aint won best asian performer at the classic rock awards in japan for this version for nothing.
Mas gusto ko pa rin original version ni Freddie Aguilar. Parang nagpapayo, nagkikwento sa halaga ng anak.
Sara g parin
Alam mo kung gano kababaw ung ibang supporter d2, Reaction nila, - gabeh ung Long Notes, Lung Power, Birit, Ang TaaS ng boses😂😂😂
Huh talaga ba, Yan Ang basehan nyo pagiging magaling,
Di nga alam pano ibigay ung message ng kanta, to think na Ang bigat Nung kanta, bawat lines, kahit anng birit Gawin nya, pag nawala ung kahulugan nung kanta , mawawal din pati galing mo sa pag kanta, kaya nga Di sya sumisikat ng husto, mas sikat pa si Moira, Kz, Juris , mas maraming nabentang album, at kanta, - Tama nga ung line , na aanhin mo Ang dilata kung Wala nman laman, ganyan mga singer ngaun na biritera, parang lata Ang iingay, . Kasi nga walang laman pag Kumanta.
Compare mo ba naman ang may network at sa wala? Totoo nga sabi nila di lahat ng tso maraunong magsalita may laman ang utak.
Ang Original shempre..soulful at Ramadam mo talaga ang kwento.🍺🍺
No questions SG really nailed this version
As far as I know, yong number ni Katrina intended talaga kay Sarah. Siguro may emergency and need ng replacement para sa prod na to and lucky si Katrina napili, which is grabe naman talaga vocal range ni girl. Ayon nabasa ko lang sa isang post ni Katrina. Pero ANGAS talaga ng kay SG. Bute nga bumalik na sa ASAP at may sarili siyang prod. Miss it so much, SARAH GERONIMO forever 😍😍😍😍
Both are great ❤ kay SG tong original
I agree...SG is the original...KV is the improved.
Both of them ,our pinoy pride.
I was Very Entaintained, Sarah is great for story telling of that's song.. and sinabayan pa ng mga high notes ni Kat . wla naku hahanapin pa.. nasa kanilang dalawa na Ang hanap ko.. I'm so proud to be Filipino...
Dito mo talaga makikita ang character ng boses ni Sarah. It may not as high as Kat's rendition pero 'yong storytelling and emotion ay talagang top-notch para kay Sarah G. Siya iyong klase ng performer na may wow factor talaga.
Yong batang basag tama ba
katrina's take was great but no one beats the original (sarah g) sarah even won best asian performer at the classic rock awards in japan because of her performance of this song anak.
May pagka rock yong kay idol Sarah...magaling pareho pero mas gusto ko yong kay Sarah🥰😍❤️
@@ellacrillon3972 pangit ng kay sarah
@@Happygolucky8597 yung version na yan original kay Sarah parehas naman sila magaling ang hilig niyo magkumpara ..
Ansk by sg
ruclips.net/video/7T9zOtcHqHs/видео.html&feature=share
Tigilan nyo nga ako sa ganyang paniniwala na NO ONE BEATS THE ORIGINAL. hahaha. Ang tanging lamang lng ng original ay dahil sya ang naunang kumanta ng song na yun but that doesn't mean na yun na ang best rendition. Ampaka tanga naman kung ganyan magisip. Hahahahaa. Isip isip naman pag may time. Hehehehe. 🤗🤗🤗❤❤❤👍👍👍😍😛😛
Wow!!! Sarah G. super amazing!!!🎶🎺🎤🎵✨🌠
Mas maganda parin ang version ni Sarah..kumbaga yung message talaga ng song para sa anak mararamdaman mo.mas mataas lang ang version ni Kat.tapos mas madaming birit kay Kat ..kay Sarah kasi pure rock..hndi nman kasi rock version kay Kat.yung growl pa lang ni Sarah rockstar na rockstar ang dating...tsaka FYI yan ang nagpanalo sa Japan classic Rock award na kasabayan nya magperform Aerosmith,Johny Deep.and many more na Rockstar sa international.
Freddie aguilar is the best...
Sarah g Ang may highest version kung high notes lang basehan nyo haha mga di marunong makinig naka-hit sya ng D6 Notes with angas story basta walang makakapantay kahit sino pa itapat nyo mga hunghang🤣
I’m proud for both of them. They’re both amazing Filipino performers. God’s gift to the world! I love both of these singer!
Both are great and unique singers! Pinoy Pride! They have their techniques for singing the song "Anak" sung by Freddie Aguilar.
Sarah g sympre..walang katulad quality boses ni Sarah at emotion pag kmakanta..magaling si Katrina pero iba si Sarah g
Wow.napaka galing.gandang sapat naman talaga.super cute 😘 ng nag iisang super mega 🌈 diamond 💎 for all season 💞 concert 🎶 dancing queen 👑 Asian pop Royalty 🙌 super star ⭐✨ pretty pantastic idol.9,999stars yan.🤩👋💯👏🌌🌟🌠💫👍✨⭐🙌👑🎶💞💎🌈😘
1. Galing kumanta. Taas ng boses. Pangmalakasan. Nakakamangha. 😮
2. Kinausap at pinagalitan ako. Pinamukha sa akin kung gaano ako kasira ulo. Pinamukha sa akin kung gaano kahalaga yung mga magulang ko. Sa isang kanta, rock pa. Nakakaiyak. 😢
Strength talaga ni Sarah G Ang head voice.. they are both great.. magaling din si kat pero iba Kay Sarah G may angas.. pagbumibirit talaga sya may pagka Celine Dion talaga Ang tone nya..Basta I can't explain..
Pareho Silang magaling walang tapon..
Galing