Yuri Soloviev and Natalia Makarova performing a pas de deux from 'Chopiniana' (1964)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • It’s a wonderful companion piece to my upload ‘Yuri Soloviev, Natalia Makarova - 'Zephyr et Flore' (Evocation of a Pre-Romantic Era Ballet)’ of the same year (1964) which came from the Russian documentary ‘The History of Russian Ballet’.
    • Yuri Soloviev, Natalia...
    This footage is of course Yuri Soloviev and Natalia Makarova performing a pas de deux from 'Chopiniana' (1964).
    I was prompted to upload my footage seeing the performances documentary, again, from which it comes posted by Ralph Sayers on a ballet site I belong to 'Les Balletomanes'.
    Particularly strange I’ve not posted it before as as I’ve had the footage for some time.
    I guess it’s a case of better late that never!
    Enjoy!
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 195

  • @junewheeler2669
    @junewheeler2669 Год назад +7

    Wow! Makarova is as light and ethereal as thistledown, but a brilliant partner is essential for the ballerina to create that illusion. Soloviev is that partner. Brilliant !

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад +1

      they are both all you could want for dances in this ballet

  • @rlatimer10
    @rlatimer10 2 года назад +8

    This clip captures the essence of ballet

  • @rlatimer10
    @rlatimer10 2 года назад +15

    Two extraordinary dancers in their prime, just ballet at its best. Thank you for sharing! ❤️

  • @JB-cp3bh
    @JB-cp3bh 3 года назад +18

    The amazing musicality and exquisite phrasing of Yuri remain unmatched to this day

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  2 года назад +3

      i totally agree - this PDD is near perfection for me

  • @beentheresawthat3982
    @beentheresawthat3982 3 месяца назад +4

    Бесценная запись. Макарова - настоящий лирический дар, грёза, душа, сама музыка. Гениальный, несравненный Соловьев

  • @jarmanka009
    @jarmanka009 Год назад +4

    A felt, beautiful, delicate ballet by Soloviev and Makarova.

  • @simaraft7373
    @simaraft7373 8 лет назад +58

    Holy Mother Of God! What in the world can one say? Makarova at her best. But Soloviev... He dances the ballerina's part as well as his own. No need to even watch the ballerina. No need to hear the music either. He is a miraculous dancer.

    • @felixdevilliers1
      @felixdevilliers1 7 лет назад +10

      Yes it's true that Soloviev is expressive in a way male dancers don't usually allow themselves to be but we don't see much of him, Anyway here his part is inseparable from the woman - and for once the music is really great.

    • @simaraft7373
      @simaraft7373 7 лет назад +8

      Your comment made me watch this again. Just can't take my eyes off Yuri! And what you say is so true --about the music too.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад +1

      agreed!

    • @felixdevilliers1
      @felixdevilliers1 7 лет назад +2

      Dear John - I looked for you on the internet in case i could find a way of getting in touch with you - for one reason only: I wrote an essay on Fonteyn with great love and concentration and I have no idea where I might be able to get it published. It took me ten years to arrive at my interpretation. Do you have any idea of a suitable magazine? I'm willing to give you my e-mail address but not without your permission and to send you the essay which you are free to like or dislike.. Not the magazine produced by Dance Books that used to be at Charing Cross.- Most ballet magazines deal only with current events.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад +2

      sadly i am not as familiar as i sued to be about dance publications - my area is semiotic theory and i know the mainlines that publish things in that area. i'd be very interested in reading your essay on Fonteyn - i would return my email address if you care to send me yours. :)

  • @user-tk7zf4he9r
    @user-tk7zf4he9r 4 года назад +21

    Видела на сцене Макарову в Жизели с Барышниковым, это уникальное исполнение. Соловьева видела в Спящей с несравненной Аллочкой Сизовой. Помню всю жизнь, вот это были настоящие спектакли, с настоящими АРТИСТАМИ балета.

    • @user-mm2kc9pd4p
      @user-mm2kc9pd4p 3 года назад

      А мне повезло в Мариинке увидеть танец других королев Вишневой, Лопаткиной, Захаровой и Махалиной, Вагановыми скучать не дадут...

    • @user-ld7rq3by1y
      @user-ld7rq3by1y 3 года назад +1

      @@user-mm2kc9pd4p Понимаете, одно дело смотреть танец, другое дело - прыжки. Да, прыжки Вам повезло увидеть.

    • @user-mm2kc9pd4p
      @user-mm2kc9pd4p 3 года назад +1

      @@user-ld7rq3by1y крайне удивлен, вы же с Питера и хорошо знаете, что Лопаткина западными критиками признана лучшей Одеттой, если вы смотрели этот балет, а я сомневаюсь, то там прыжки не основные, Вишнёва носит титул Божественная, наверное тоже прыжки не на первом месте, Захарова и Махалина в представлении не нуждаются, есть у нас гимнастка в балете - Осипова, но со временем выпускница московского училища не только будет удивлять прыжками...

    • @user-mm2kc9pd4p
      @user-mm2kc9pd4p 3 года назад

      @@user-ld7rq3by1y извините, почему то я подумал, что вы из Питера, ну слава богу я ошибся...

    • @user-ld7rq3by1y
      @user-ld7rq3by1y 3 года назад +3

      @@user-mm2kc9pd4p Да, я не "С Питера", как Вы изволили выразиться. И своим высказыванием, не думаю, что оскорбила настоящих питерцев. Мнение западных ))) критиков для меня не важно. Главное, что несёт в себе балерина - одухотворенность и актерский дар или... ничего... Если Вы этого не видите, то даже Бог не поможет...

  • @jengirl2
    @jengirl2 8 лет назад +42

    Immediately went on my Favorites. Truly ethereal, romantic, poetic, dreamy...just lovely. Thank you!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +11

      +jengirl2
      i think almost my favourite performance of the ballet - everything works together, technically and expressively - it's a tricky ballet to express as it is a general feeling - romantic reverie - rather than emtions and feeling related to a specific story.

    • @user-dg9yd6bh4u
      @user-dg9yd6bh4u 4 года назад +1

      Стандарт , ничего выдающегося.

    • @user-dg9yd6bh4u
      @user-dg9yd6bh4u 4 года назад

      @@JohnRaymondHall Вы увидели то, чего там нет.А может Вы не видели и действительно выдающихся артистов .Извините , это мое личное мнение Вы имеете право на иное.

  • @Elenaelok
    @Elenaelok Год назад +3

    Какая нежность и грация! Без ненужного запирания ног лишь бы продемонстрировать растяжку. Техника без души ничто!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад +1

      именно - техника без экспрессии мертва!

  • @herecomesthesun21
    @herecomesthesun21 3 года назад +4

    May i just say that i appreciate so much the intelligent and ballet-loving comments here. I'm binging on ballet clips lately, remembering my old dear passionate dancing time. I always learn something new from the comments. Thank you so much for the videos, John Hall! I wish it was possible to comment also on the newer videos...

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  3 года назад

      :) I would like to put more newer videos on my channel but had to narrow my focus to give the channel an 'identity' - a pity in a way. glad you are binging - a good thing to do!

    • @herecomesthesun21
      @herecomesthesun21 3 года назад +1

      @@JohnRaymondHall I see. Glad you're still putting some videos here. It's a really wonderful & important channel, I'm so happy to see the old masters dancing and learn about dance history. All the best for you!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  3 года назад +2

      @@herecomesthesun21 thanks for those very kind words - appreciated! I've had a bit of a break from my channel but am excited to be uploading new things

    • @herecomesthesun21
      @herecomesthesun21 3 года назад

      @@JohnRaymondHall you're welcome!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  3 года назад

      @@herecomesthesun21 :) hope to hear from you in a comment/s again

  • @marie-claudedumelie8113
    @marie-claudedumelie8113 2 года назад +3

    Yuri Soloviev un artiste très inspiré et un très grand danseur, partenaire attentif
    Natalia Makarova une ballerine habitée, une technique sans faille
    Merci pour ce film de haute qualité
    Je suis très émue
    Ce sont des images que je rêvais de voir quand j'avais 20 ans...💕

  • @Toy1976
    @Toy1976 8 лет назад +16

    So absolutely wonderful in it's rarity and timelessness!
    Thank you for sharing.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +Toy M yes, one of my favourite performances of this ballet - quite perfect in its way. :)

  • @opensecret51
    @opensecret51 8 лет назад +13

    Divine....The tenderness is beyond !!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +Masha.M. S
      yes, it is hard to imagine the ballet performed better - totally satisfying. and the perfect atmosphere is created - essential to make the ballet work properly, don't you think?

    • @opensecret51
      @opensecret51 8 лет назад +1

      +John Hall Yes ...it is poetry !

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +4

      +Masha.M. S
      yes, as it rarely is in ballet - or any art form for that matter. :)

  • @kabardinka1
    @kabardinka1 6 лет назад +17

    It's worth mentioning a biography of Yuri Soloviev is coming out in 2018 by Joel Lobenthal and Lisa Whitaker (who was a close friend of Yuri's). It's high time this great artist is given the detailed history of his life and career that he deserves.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  6 лет назад +1

      thanks for the alert - much appreciated - it's on my 'to buy' list! sounds the best there is to date.

    • @lleocttx2326
      @lleocttx2326 6 лет назад +2

      Thank you, Kabardinka1. Excerpted chapters from the upcoming biography, "People's Artist: the Life and Death of Yuri Soloviev" are available at www.YuriSolovievBallet.com

    • @Marta44339
      @Marta44339 4 года назад

      @@lleocttx2326 Waiting for that bio. I've seen the excerpts but I don't think the book has been published.

    • @lleocttx2326
      @lleocttx2326 4 года назад

      Marta, The name of the biography is Red Star White Nights: the Life and Death of Yuri Soloviev by Joel Lobenthal and Lisa Whitaker. It should be available for preorder on Amazon and other Internet sites within the next 60 days. Thank you for your interest.

    • @Marta44339
      @Marta44339 4 года назад

      @@lleocttx2326 Thanks very much for the alert. I can't wait to read it!

  • @user-lw7xb2jm9h
    @user-lw7xb2jm9h 19 дней назад +1

    ВЕЛИКОЛЕПНОЕ ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ. !!!!!!
    ОБА. ВЕЛИКОЛЕПНЫ. !!
    КАЖДЫЙ. ЖЕСТ .
    НЕЖНОСТЬ, МЯГКОСТЬ, Лиричность .
    Пишет бывшая балерина , ныне пенсионер

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  18 дней назад

      абсолютное совершенство - я смотрю это видео довольно часто!

  • @barbaralemere5183
    @barbaralemere5183 4 года назад +8

    A lovely performance by Makarova and Soloviev. This shows Makarova's poeti c, soulful, expression at it's best.

  • @giuliorenzobighin8165
    @giuliorenzobighin8165 Год назад +4

    Sempre in fase d'enfatizzazione questi ballerini che accentuano l'aspetto commediale come fossero dentro
    un'aerea bolla d'afflato leggero e portati da essa.Molto bravi
    BIGHIN GIULIO RENZO

  • @anniemihn
    @anniemihn 8 лет назад +26

    Soloviev and Makarova in Les Sylphides!! It's like a dream no?

  • @Rysanekfan
    @Rysanekfan 8 лет назад +4

    So much beautiful detail that is as delicate as the ballet...

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад

      yes, so beautifully nuanced with the music in mind - unfussed and beautifully leisurely laid out - i find myself watching this over and over. and the 'mood' created is so right for the ballet - i remember the first time i saw this i realized it was pretty much what i imagined the ballet to be in my mind.

  • @user-ru3uw9cv1g
    @user-ru3uw9cv1g 6 лет назад +8

    Смотришь и дышать забываешь

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  6 лет назад +1

      that is exactly it! (i can't copy and paste from my Russian translator at the moment - sorry :( )

    • @user-sv2hv1mf4j
      @user-sv2hv1mf4j 4 года назад

      Это точно

  • @catherineshelef3377
    @catherineshelef3377 3 года назад +7

    Божественно! Непревзойдённая техника исполнения именно русского балета!!!

  • @dennischiapello7243
    @dennischiapello7243 3 года назад +9

    Beautiful. It's a privilege to see Makarova in her younger years. My only complaint is with whoever cut her feet out of frame at 1:30. Arrgh!

    • @jillgooner
      @jillgooner Год назад +1

      I never saw her in her youth but saw her in on your toes in the 80s which obviously completely different was very entertaining. Any chance to see a legend🤷‍♂️

  • @simonaperez1475
    @simonaperez1475 Год назад +4

    Юрочка Соловьев… единственное реальное воплощение Вацлава Нижинского, с такою же трагической судьбой

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      да, параллель бросается в глаза!

  • @angele810
    @angele810 3 года назад +5

    Wonderful! I watch this right after the Baryshnikov/Tcherkassky version and love them both equally.

  • @user-fw5kk2gm1b
    @user-fw5kk2gm1b 3 года назад +5

    Бессмертновп и Годунов прекрасно танцуют эту партию..завораживающе волшебно
    и прекрасно!!!!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  3 года назад +5

      да, да - полностью согласен!

    • @user-vi7kw1oo6b
      @user-vi7kw1oo6b 6 месяцев назад +1

      О да да да. Они бесподобны !!!

  • @shelleynobleart
    @shelleynobleart 8 лет назад +7

    That was absolutely exquisite! I love the choreography especially. Perfectly captures the fairy realm of their encounter. She is my favorite of all time. Chiefly because of the deliberateness with which she draws lines in space with her hands throughout, never once dropping their vibratto. Brava!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +6

      +NobleDesignMedia
      yes Makarova is particularly exquisite here - and captures the atmosphere of the ballet, that Tamara Karsavina called 'romantic reverie'.
      yes, she marks out the chore with her hands in a way that defines and articulates the space in which she moves.
      one of my favourite performances of both these extraordinary dancers.

    • @Marta44339
      @Marta44339 7 лет назад +1

      Thank you for this extraordinary glimpse into another time. Makarova is truly exquisite and so is Soloviev ialong with being a wonderful partner. Both express the elusive perfume of this ballet. Makarova is the reason I love ballet. I first saw her in 1971 in Boston and several times later in N.Y. as well as hundreds of times here on YT! This is one of the best ever treasures on youtube.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад

      i can't imagine a more perfect performance on so many levels. i first saw her here in Australia in 1974 with Baryshnikov - 'Giselle' and 'Don Q' - really unforgettable!

  • @susanbaskerville5239
    @susanbaskerville5239 8 лет назад +12

    The beautiful airy Miss Makarova on of my favorite ballerinas BRAVA so expressive no matter what she danced she made you believe !!! BRAVA SIMPLY WONDERFUL !!!!!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +3

      +Susan Baskerville yes, expressive is the word - i feel lucky to have seen her on stage as much as i did - here, it's hard to image the 'role' danced more beautifully and poetically.

    • @susanbaskerville5239
      @susanbaskerville5239 8 лет назад

      Hi John I always loved her so beautifuly expressive and always beautiful to look at for me she really was the first ballerina to give the swan queen wings she was way above her time just simply amazing BRAVA!!!!!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +Susan Baskerville i like your 'the first ballerina to give the swan queen wings'! all her body was alive and contributing to expressing the character, situation and as realized in the music. i loved her Juliet - a real flesh and blood girl/young woman - very satisfying to watch!

    • @susanbaskerville5239
      @susanbaskerville5239 8 лет назад

      +John Hall OH her Juliet is wonderful to watch Makarova La Bayadiere is wonderful too i was there when she took a curtain call at the ROH a few years ago still beautiful and elegant wonderful lady !!!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад

      +Susan Baskerville so many wonderful performances and characters created - curiously i saw her with Nureyev dancing 'SL' out doors at the Cour Carrée at the Louvre in Paris - the dancers huddled round outdoor gas fires to keep warm when not on stage - we were to the side and could interestingly see the performance and in a sense 'backstage' at the same time.

  • @micheladessanti4278
    @micheladessanti4278 2 года назад +2

    Magnifici!!!!! Natalia ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @louisesmedley-hampson1828
    @louisesmedley-hampson1828 8 лет назад +17

    Dear Alex, Another absolute gem. You are so right, Makarova captures the 'romantic reverie' so well in this pdd. She used to dance with Yuri Soloviev a lot and they made an attractive dance couple. It is interesting to compare this version with the colour film of Galina Ulanova in 'Les Sylphides' that we talked about previously. Something I love about ballet is how the same steps can look so different when performed by two different ballerinas.

    • @susannevollmer2347
      @susannevollmer2347 2 года назад

      I find Karsavina in Sylvia very romantic! Much more than this chopin/Fokin part.

    • @user-qn7wd1gl3g
      @user-qn7wd1gl3g Год назад

      @@susannevollmer2347 Had you saw it ? Karsawina's Video ?

  • @tkoran
    @tkoran 7 лет назад +4

    Beautiful! I love Makarova! They are divine together!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад +2

      two of the greatest dancers of the C20, same schooling ... what more could we want! :)

  • @user-fd1vq3rz4g
    @user-fd1vq3rz4g 2 года назад +3

    !!!!!!!!!+++ БОЛЬШОЕ СПАСИБО ЗА ЭТО ВИДЕО !!!!!

  • @marygoodson4920
    @marygoodson4920 Год назад

    How perfect!

  • @ZenGrammy
    @ZenGrammy 8 лет назад +14

    Too beautiful for me to even try to describe my sensations. Thank you.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +7

      +Penthesilea
      honestly ... sheer perfection - i watch it each time with the baited breath of wonder!

  • @GIOBODAN
    @GIOBODAN 3 месяца назад

    Oggi i ballerini pensano solo a tatuarsi e non più a emozionare il pubblico. Che involuzione.

  • @sana11sana19
    @sana11sana19 2 года назад +1

    Прекрасный танцовщик партнёр!!!музыкален необыкновенно артистичен ,пластичен,очень похожи с Рудольфом Нуреевым в манере танца!!!💖💖💖🌹🌹🌹✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨

  • @kabardinka1
    @kabardinka1 8 лет назад +7

    This was on the Yuri Soloviev Facebook page a while back. Time marches on and I wish some documentary filmmaker would interview remaining persons who knew/danced with Yuri and make a coherent film about him and his life and art. Too much of his legacy is in a few videos and the fact of his death rather than his greatness as a dancer.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +kabardinka1
      yes, seeing it on FB was what prompted me to upload it - i've had the footage for some time and can't imagine why i hadn't posted it till now.
      it makes a good companion performance to my upload ‘Yuri Soloviev, Natalia Makarova - 'Zephyr et Flore' (Evocation of a Pre-Romantic Era Ballet)’ of the same year (1964)
      i have more on Soloviev that i want to upload tomorrow from the doco 'Yuri Soloviev 'The concert №3". Leningrad TV, 1968'

    • @kabardinka1
      @kabardinka1 8 лет назад

      +John Hall Lovely! Is this the footage with Fedicheva or something else altogether? I still want to see that documentary partly about Yuri called ""I am tired of living in my native land" which was shown in 1995 at Lincoln Center but I can't find any subsequent distribution of it.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +2

      +kabardinka1
      the film 'Yuri Soloviev 'The concert №3". Leningrad TV, 1968' has a strange pot pouri of things including:
      Alfred Petruchio Shargorodskii Song from the musical "Kiss Me, Kate." Music - K. Porter, words - M. Spivak, B. Spivak. Russian text - Yuri Korneev, P. Melkova.
      "Take care of your love." Music and lyrics - T.Babaev.
      "And you love it, my girl." Music - D.Tuhmanov verses - M.Nozhkin. Sings the vocal ensemble "Zori"
      Tatar dance. Artist is not set.
      Kaleria Fedicheva Yuri Soloviev, soloists from Leningrad Opera and Ballet Kirov (i do not recognize the ballet)
      "Romance." Music - Kirchner. Dance soloists from Leningrad Opera and Ballet Kirov Inna Zubkovskaya and Svyatoslav Kuznetsov.
      someone on 'Ballet Alert!' has identified for "I'm Tired of Living In My Native Land" the distributor, and the producer's name:
      Producer: Galina Mshankaya
      Distrib: Russian State Tele-Radio Company

  • @EVZYL
    @EVZYL 4 года назад +2

    I was privileged to see her twice in Swan Lake in South Africa in the 70's partnered by Ivan Nagy & Anthony Dowell.

  • @michelleregis1795
    @michelleregis1795 7 лет назад +2

    such beauty touches my soul, perfection,!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад

      yes, perfection - i just hold my breath as i watch this performance.

  • @kabardinka1
    @kabardinka1 4 года назад +3

    There was another version of Les Sylphides/Chopiniana posted on RUclips (in color) which looks as if it was done for tv and I think it's from not that long before Yuri died. Really wish it would make a "re-appearance" because I'd love to see it again. These two are magic here.

  • @michelboudot2882
    @michelboudot2882 3 года назад +1

    This is the best of the best done...by the best

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  2 года назад

      agreed - sheer perfection - i've watched it so many times!

    • @Marta44339
      @Marta44339 Год назад

      @@JohnRaymondHall Exquisite performance. I never tire of watching it. Makarova sculpts the space with her beautiful port de bras. It's just incredible. Thank you!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      @@Marta44339 yes, she sculpts the space in a way that is unique to her - and the way she phrases the movement to the music is so expressive

  • @alis-m22
    @alis-m22 Год назад

    Как же это прекрасно!

  • @garnwalkerstables
    @garnwalkerstables 3 года назад +2

    So lovely. Before ballerinas became gymnasts.

  • @michelleregis1795
    @michelleregis1795 7 лет назад +3

    Another TREASURE from russia ! many thanks for this extraordinary upload of Les syplhidesl! Ill probably never see it so wonderfully done again.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад +2

      yes, i think it''s the perfect performance against which all others need to be judged

  • @oldoperafan_in_London
    @oldoperafan_in_London 8 лет назад +11

    What is even more 'beyond comprehension' is that this was 51 years ago...

  • @svetademina2206
    @svetademina2206 Год назад

    Божественно, часто пересматриваю этот шедевр и всегда в восторге. Александра.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      да, это бесконечно восхитительно - особенно выделяются ли их выступления, которые вы рассмотрели?

  • @frannieo1707
    @frannieo1707 4 года назад +1

    Soloviev's lyrical dancing brings the great Anthony Dowell to mind.

  • @isabeldiezlangre9411
    @isabeldiezlangre9411 2 года назад +1

    Maravillosos bailarines; una pena que Yuri muriese tan joven, fue un gran bailarin al igual que la exquisita Makarova.

  • @cbooth2004
    @cbooth2004 8 лет назад +2

    Maria Kotchetkova posted this a few days ago. I had not ever seen it before. Within a few seconds it became one of my favorite things ever. :-)
    I was about 18 or 19, a callow American kid with no interest in ballet. I turned on the TV to the local PBS channel and they showed the brief introductory clip announcing the program that was about to be aired, which was, I believe, "Baryshnikov at the White House". It was very brief, an excerpt or out-take from a moment from the dance. One sweep of her leg and I was transfixed. It was Makarova. From that moment I loved ballet. I feverishly watched the program--"Who is she?--and seized on her name to remember it.
    ...Makarova is still my favorite. The lyricism of her line. Rubatto, musicality, lyricism, tone, narrative flow--her phrasing reminds me of my favorite pianist, Benno Moiseiwitsch.
    This performance is exquisite. And Soloviev is magnificent--power, delicacy, superlative partnering, musicality.
    Indeed, as you say, poetic reverie.

    • @cbooth2004
      @cbooth2004 8 лет назад

      Sorry, you said "romantic reverie". I agree either way. :-)

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +Christopher Booth
      i have a lot of old footage and looks over it regularly for things to post - i had forgotten to upload this footage as it had been on my old YT channel and i thought i'd put it here already
      me too - one of my favourite ballet performances on film - quite perfect on every level - just watched it again with renewed pleasure - i think it is Makarova's best performance in this ballet.
      i grew up with the Fonteyn-Nureyev performance on film - till i saw this and my imaginings of what the ballet could be escalated exponentially - atmosphere, phrasing [which you detailed so well] - with technique to be able to realize the chore in a way that Fonteyn could not do fully at that stage of her career).

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +2

      +Christopher Booth
      both work for me too :).
      on my upload 'Tamara Karsavina Talks of Performing in Le Prelude in 'Les Sylphides' with Pavlova and Nijinsky' the ballerina used 'romantic reverie' probably referencing back to it's original title in St Petersburg 'Rêverie Romantique: Ballet sur la musique de Chopin' - before it was presented there again as 'Chopiniana'
      but then the National Ballet of Canada on their site currently uses 'poetic reverie' saying "Les Sylphides is a poetic reverie brought to life by ballet technique that is evanescent and timeless".
      six of one half a dozen of another don't you think?

  • @mariadolorescastrillonferr1536
    @mariadolorescastrillonferr1536 3 года назад

    Con esas condiciones naturales y esa técnica, es extraordinaria, pero sobre todo su elegancia interpretativa ,natural y bien cultivada que es lo que echo de menos en general .Gracias por compartirla

  • @Bnesque
    @Bnesque 8 лет назад +6

    Because, I believe a poetic perfection is very rare and elusive. If you look away some seconds, you loose the momentum. That's why I'm still pestering around Mariinsky performances though it's decline is obvious.

  • @nicolehourcade
    @nicolehourcade 5 лет назад +4

    A lot of thanks to have the opportunity to see Soloviev who was a amazing dancer, not a star like Noureeiv, il did not leave Soviet Union and of course he was not in Paris’ nights with some “people”.

    • @jillgooner
      @jillgooner 5 лет назад +3

      never seen that version before, pure heaven. She was like a little feather and he was a perfect match. Hope here is more footage of him hiding somewhere. Many different versions out there they all dance the same steps but make it thier own peice but this one is exeptional.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  5 лет назад +2

      pleasure - yes not a 'pop' star dancer but a great professional one :)

  • @kv6268
    @kv6268 8 лет назад +2

    heavenly.

  • @Feliandyx16
    @Feliandyx16 8 лет назад +3

    Perfect partnering

  • @bkwendy1
    @bkwendy1 6 лет назад

    Thank you John Hall....quite exquisite!

  • @nancydionisi9346
    @nancydionisi9346 4 года назад

    Lovely video John!, many thanks for sharing it!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад +1

      pleasure Nancy - the performances of this video are so perfect!

  • @lucilenedegeus2837
    @lucilenedegeus2837 4 года назад +1

    The best! 😍

  • @jillgooner
    @jillgooner 2 года назад

    like butterflies! what more can be said? perfect duo

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      what more indeed! :)

    • @jillgooner
      @jillgooner Год назад

      @@JohnRaymondHall just watched her with Dowell who evidently was her favourite partner at the rb, clip from manon bedroom scene, again 2 wonderful dancers complimenting each other. Noticed no ear whacking, didnt need to when your that graceful.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      @@jillgooner yes, Dowell had a great reputation as a partner - i remember in an interview him saying he had to work at this aspect of dancing. Makarova spoke about Dowell's partnering in that four part series 'Ballerina'

  • @mingdynasty112
    @mingdynasty112 6 лет назад +3

    Such a delight to see Makarova when she was so young, but a lot of the affectation in her performance that was appropriate to this type of ballet was something she had to shed when she came west. I think she became an even more powerful dancer because she defected.

  • @lill12
    @lill12 3 года назад +3

    Совершенство!!!

  • @alainspiteri502
    @alainspiteri502 5 лет назад +2

    Wonderful Makarova , dance is for the youngs and not after 40 Y old , this is the proof , a man dancer is the best at 28 Y old : there are two youngs famous dancers here and for good reason , very difficult To write this !

  • @murielbelmondo7074
    @murielbelmondo7074 3 года назад

    Beau et émouvant

  • @smartstone8432
    @smartstone8432 Год назад

    Нельзя сравнивать, но шопениана Улановой и Преображенского -это диво дивное, замирание сердца и слезы восхищения.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      я согласен - каждый может наслаждаться для себя

  • @hernandogomez573
    @hernandogomez573 3 года назад

    que hermosura, parecen flotar

  • @Carlosopinion1
    @Carlosopinion1 5 лет назад

    Un gran acompañante para un hada de sueños.

  • @user-ld7rq3by1y
    @user-ld7rq3by1y 3 года назад

    Божественный танец!

  • @Rociofr10
    @Rociofr10 8 лет назад +4

    Just saw this video on Facebook! A fan of Yuri Soloviev uploaded! Do you have the complete documentary (The History of Russian Ballet)? Thanks!

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +1

      +Rfr10
      in the notes i added to this video i mentioned that having seen it on FB i realized i had not yet uploaded it though i had had the doco for some time. do not know why i had not posted it till now - but better late than never i guess.
      yes, i have the video 'History Of The Russian Ballet' - it came originally from Balletoman.com - there are in fact five films covering the history of ballet in the country.
      cheers

    • @Rociofr10
      @Rociofr10 8 лет назад

      +John Hall Yes, i totally agree! It's never too late ... And do you upload the video to YT? I can't find it in your channel. Thanks and please continue upload this kind of videos, specially from Soloviev :)

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  8 лет назад +2

      +Rfr10
      just uploaded another video - 'Yuri Soloviev and Kaleria Fedicheva in Performance (1968)' - Soloviev was such a great dancer it is hard not to upload everything of his on film!
      i have not uploaded 'History Of The Russian Ballet' - in fact there are five films in a series following the development of ballet in Russia. actually i am not sure i am able to upload longer videos like these. so i tend to upload bits and pieces.
      :)

  • @angele810
    @angele810 3 года назад

    Was just able order the book Red Star White Nights: the Life and Death of Yuri Soloviev by Joel Lobenthal and Lisa Whitaker.

  • @lirard
    @lirard 4 года назад +1

    what is this...
    out of this world

  • @alainspiteri502
    @alainspiteri502 5 лет назад

    J don't remember Soloviev , j did't not known his name and j saw in 1960' Vyroubova R Hightower Liane Dayde in first before Noureev , why ?

  • @alainspiteri502
    @alainspiteri502 5 лет назад

    Three Sylphide at Paris-Opera : Noella Pontois and Ghislaine Thesmar in 1972 and Elizabeth Platel , j don't see others dancers with " les sylphides " at Paris .

    • @alainspiteri502
      @alainspiteri502 5 лет назад

      Error : j remember j saw also in the Sylphide Dominique Khalfouni with Peter Schauffus perhaps in 1980"

  • @user-kj7hc8ub4s
    @user-kj7hc8ub4s 3 года назад

    Нравится.очень жаль Ю.Соловьева

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  3 года назад

      я тоже - печальный конец большой карьеры

  • @user-xr8wp3wq5g
    @user-xr8wp3wq5g 3 года назад +4

    Это "Шопениана", а не "Сильфиды". А танцуют прекрасно.

    • @vladimirbaum3527
      @vladimirbaum3527 3 года назад +2

      "Шопениана" - это и есть "Сильфиды". Почитайте, если не знаете.

    • @user-ew5ll1xl7m
      @user-ew5ll1xl7m 3 года назад

      Бесподобны!

  • @DCFunBud
    @DCFunBud Год назад +1

    They were both fabulous. Soloviev was achingly poignant.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      absolutely. and so great seeing Makarova at the beginning of her career. i was lucky seeing her on stage as much as i did

    • @jillgooner
      @jillgooner Год назад +1

      @@JohnRaymondHall its a shame that a lot of dancers now dont appear to be as graceful and are so athletic. Different era i suppose but i do miss it. We have some great dancers in the royal ballet now and pleased many are brits. Yasmin naghdi is wonderful and as for men William bracewell is tall but so elegant. But miss the good old days.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  Год назад

      @@jillgooner yes, with the development of extreme technique sometimes expressiveness and artistry gets lost. some dancers do have both, like Natalia Osipova whose 'Giselle' is one of the greatest of all time, in my opinion

    • @jillgooner
      @jillgooner Год назад

      @@JohnRaymondHall i think nunez is still a wonderful dancer no matter who she dances with even though they are often 20 yrs her junior. Her acting is wonderful and always lights up the stage. Popping out tonight to see swan lake at enb
      See how that goes! There productions arnt quite on par with the royal. Alina cojocaru was another one who was a beautiful delicate performer but no longer dancer as you know . Another dancer who gave the impression of weightlessness.

  • @nataliedelagrandiere4022
    @nataliedelagrandiere4022 4 года назад +3

    It's nice.
    But I prefer Rudy and Margot dansing les Sylphides: exquisite.

  • @ivmile
    @ivmile 7 лет назад +1

    Well, this is so different from original Fokine. Have to see Alicia Markova documentary film in Paris Opera Ballet couching principal POB dancers as she was couched in Les Syphides by Fokin in New York during 2WW. Les Sylphides`s POB dancers are Elisabeth Platel and young Herve Moreau.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад

      being filmed at the Kirov i wonder if the differences reflect that it is the original 'Chopiniana' for the Kirov rather than the ballet reworked for the West and Diaghilev's Ballets Russes as 'Les Sylphides'? speaking of changes to the work, i saw a version with three poets: aleximageshare.blogspot.com.au/2017/03/blog-post.html

    • @ivmile
      @ivmile 7 лет назад

      "Three Poets", that is Cleo Nardi and he was producer of "PAVLOVA AND HER COMPANY" film 1930 and that was FOKIN arrangement. So Fokine by Fokine. It is only important what is Fokin idea for this ballet and his strong demands. That is possible to see only in film "Alicia Makarova in POB". Today that is only autentic interpretation of Fokine from leg to leg ....Chopinana is only SOVIET version of Fokine ballet and is so different from original. It is not is it better, it is only how close is to original. There is no problem with every new version of his ballet but must be AFTER FOKIN not BY FOKINE. That is my point.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад

      thanks for that background - appreciated. i was wondering who had made the version with the three poets - in a Facebook group we had been discussing the differences between the 'Chopiniana' Fokine created for the Kirov and 'Les Sylphides' which was in a sense a re-working for the Ballets Russes. was the Markova POB film you mentioned Dominique Delouche's 'Markova, la légende' ? you make a very good point - that Russian versions are 'after Fokine' as the original is lost. :)

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад

      yes, it's so interesting seeing her coach Elisabeth Platel and Herve Moreau - her memory seems very good - so whatever version she was taught she probably transmitted it accurately.

    • @alainspiteri502
      @alainspiteri502 4 года назад

      @@ivmile there is on Y T no Les Sylphides by Fokine but " la Sylphide ' reconstitution by Pierre Lacotte 1972 j don't known if this ballet in on Y T in others countries nobody talks about Ghislaine Thesmar j don't understand this because she's a Sylphide , j saw in 1972 Les Sylphides with Pontois-Noureev by Fokine also a true french Sylphide but it seems Ghislaine Thesmar is by her work in lightness sensitivity slow movements in précisions in her work her person her expressive face in the sensibility with a surnatural expression of all her body to be what that means the name of Sylphide ; same thing for Galina mezentseva , j do.'t like Alonso j don't like to see her face too near about Alonso better in audience than on a video . why nobody talks about this Artist discret perhaps Thesmar is to very far from the mediatic-world no another expkanation when we see La Sylphide-Kacotte on Y T (.dhe's also one Sylphide of Foki e but not on Y T )

  • @ritanicosia
    @ritanicosia 4 года назад +1

    Unbelievable, sylphides exist

  • @DCFunBud
    @DCFunBud 7 лет назад +2

    This was wonderful, but no one could touch Ulanova in my opinion.

    • @JohnRaymondHall
      @JohnRaymondHall  7 лет назад +1

      yes Ulanova was sublime - it was the total commitment to creating a role and a drama

  • @Toy1976
    @Toy1976 8 лет назад +1

    For you!
    instagram.com/p/-wvUgiP2d7/?taken-by=toymusa