Osteoporosis Results From the WHI - 223 | Menopause Taylor

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Remember the fateful WHI study, with all its ominous, scary, and negative results? Well, you never heard about the results for osteoporosis. But, you will in this video. And you’ll see that the negative reporting overshadowed the positive results so much that it resulted in a complete blinding of the facts.
    Visit my website: menopausetaylo...
    Click here to print the worksheet: menopausetaylo...
    Click here to find the outline notes: menopausetaylo...
    Watch every Menopause Taylor episode from the beginning: • Watch the Menopause Ba...
    Check out my book, Menopause: Your Management Your Way ... Now and for the Rest of Your Life: menopausetaylo...
    Click to listen to my Radio Show: The State of Menopause in the World Today - www.iheart.com...
    Connect with me on social media:
    Facebook: / menopausetaylor
    Twitter: / barbietaylormd
    Instagram: / menopausetaylor

Комментарии • 84

  • @knackfulknitter
    @knackfulknitter 3 года назад +24

    I was made to fear the thought of HRT by other women. I tried to live with the symptoms for one year and tried all the vitamins and herbs suggested. Nope, they did not work for me!
    I went to my doc and told her I could not live like this so she prescribed a low dose of estrogen and progesterone...just enough to make the hot flashes go away.
    Since becoming a student of Menopause University (and watching your videos in order!), I have been taking the required dose to prevent those diseases.
    Fear can definitely make you freeze and do nothing...like the ostrich with its head in the sand.
    I will never be like that, again.
    I continue to put the word out there for women (and some men) to watch and learn the truth about menopause.
    Love you to the moon and back! XO~Maria

    • @AntidoteX2
      @AntidoteX2 3 года назад

      How much is the required dose, Maria, if you don’t mind telling me?

    • @knackfulknitter
      @knackfulknitter 3 года назад +3

      @@AntidoteX2 Thank you for your question. I am only summarizing my experience.
      The best way to get the answer, and understand it, is to watch Dr. Taylor’s videos in order...or schedule a consultation with her for a personal one on one just for your situation.

    • @AntidoteX2
      @AntidoteX2 3 года назад +2

      @@knackfulknitter, thank you. She talks about it in the video 159 - I’ve just found it.

    • @knackfulknitter
      @knackfulknitter 3 года назад +2

      @@AntidoteX2 I am so thankful you were not put off by my reply. I’m glad you found it...and found it faster than I would have! 💕

    • @geriannstanley2249
      @geriannstanley2249 3 года назад

      Qq

  • @reneeelias7168
    @reneeelias7168 3 года назад +15

    Thank you for the info. My sister is freaking out after I told her I was taking HRT treatment. She made me promise to read up on it. I think between a book I bought and your videos I am confident taking it.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +6

      The whole key to this education is to give you the tools with which you can be confident in your menopause management decisions. All that matters is what's right FOR YOU. No one else's opinion matters.

  • @brennakohlhase4194
    @brennakohlhase4194 3 года назад +6

    Whoa!!! Fear really is like a tidal wave!...63 was the age?? How in the world was this a competent study?? How many of them got a baseline at 45-50??

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +3

      It WASN'T a competent study. It was the worst study ever done. But it was so big and expensive that everyone treats it like the Bible. And look what its done to women! When you learn these truths, you realize more than ever that you really have to fend for yourself.

  • @charlottemann3352
    @charlottemann3352 3 года назад +5

    Thank you for being a beacon in the night! I love your outfit too. Victorian and Chanel! You are brilliant and beautiful!

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      Oh, Charlotte, you are so kind. Thank you for always being so supportive and appreciative.

  • @mariadejucilene7659
    @mariadejucilene7659 3 года назад +1

    This really is fantastic. 47 osteopetrosis, on HRT, unable to take other medication for bone loss. I nearly teared when I heard this good news. I can not tell you what you have contributed to my life and my health. I am now equip to make the right decisions FOR ME. My new Dr loves you too 🤗🤗

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      What a kind comment. Thank you so much. I like to think that everybody wins with this education: You, your doctor, your family, etc.

  • @yvettebennett6170
    @yvettebennett6170 3 года назад

    Fear is everywhere. Now more than ever. It is horrible how fear drives people and how the media does not report the truth. Shameful actually but here you as re reporting the truth. I am grateful for you.

  • @vyvyienewalser6798
    @vyvyienewalser6798 2 года назад

    Doctor T ...Thank U.U are a blessing to every female.Every female needs to have this info.If possible , this should be included as a school subject.Yip..its that important.A woman's life ,depends on this info. Why have we, not been given this info before.We are so misinformed.I was also told , if I choose hrt's , it can be only for 5 years or less.What utter rubbish....as we have fortunately learnt from U.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  2 года назад

      Thank you so much for appreciating my efforts to give you the menopause education you deserve. I love doing this for you.

  • @lorraine8573
    @lorraine8573 3 года назад +8

    This is just a terrible report from the WHI but we are so lucky because we have Menopause Taylor. This is where I have learnt so much thank you.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      The key is to know the whole story, even the parts that upset you. And, when it comes to menopause, there are many parts that will upset you.

    • @lorraine8573
      @lorraine8573 3 года назад

      @@MenopauseTaylor Oh I know so well thanks

  • @jennieoh8543
    @jennieoh8543 3 года назад +5

    I have used this analogy for the word FEAR...False Evidence Appearing Real!!!! Thank you so much for this education!!!! You are so generous with all of your time and knowledge for women out there who do not have a single clue!!!! Hugs to you Dr. Taylor :*)

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      You learned that acronym from Tony Robbins. And it is so true.
      I love giving you this education, and I thank you so much for appreciating it so.

  • @rebekahraymond4412
    @rebekahraymond4412 3 года назад +1

    Love the education & the outfit!!!😀

  • @Cristina-qn2in
    @Cristina-qn2in 3 года назад +3

    My 75 year old mom has osteoporosis and needs a hip replacement. Talking with her the other day and telling her about your videos, she was telling me 30 years ago when she started feeling like she was “going crazy” her doctor told her, she just needed to endure menopause and wear light fabric clothes for the hot flashes 😡😡, her doctor put her on estrogen for only a couple of years and then told her she needed to stop taking it as soon as possible. 😳😳 so she did.
    She told me I was very lucky I had this information available ! I feel the same way !! Thankyou Dr. Taylor

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      You are so very welcome, my dear.
      Some women tell me that their mothers cry when they discover that their daughter has the benefit of this education. Hopefully, one of these days, all women will get this education ... in their 20s & 30s.

  • @elizabethbarranon622
    @elizabethbarranon622 3 года назад

    I’m hoping I can get Hrt for treating my osteoporosis . I’m 12 years post menopausal. Total hysterectomy and BSO 3 years ago. I will watch your next video about medications. A bit fearful of them though. Just recently diagnosed with OP. I have to decide what to do. So thankful for your videos. Was hoping to try “fixin “ with exercise, diet and supplements, but I am learning that option is not enough.

  • @loriepayne2506
    @loriepayne2506 Год назад +1

    What I just heard makes all the difference. Estrogen can still help prevent fractures even if your window of opportunity has closed!

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  Год назад

      Estrogen can MAINTAIN bone no matter when you start taking it.
      But it cannot REPLACE the bone you have already lost no matter when you start taking it or how long you take it.
      The key to success is to know what each option CAN do and what each option CANNOT do.
      I look forward to your consultation next month. I'll be eager to meet you and help you.

  • @daisyjo5358
    @daisyjo5358 3 года назад +2

    Thank you so much with your helpful message I will be having my 5 th an 6 th vertebrae fused an disk replacement with bone spurs removed. From two bad Neck injuries over the years an I interviewed 4 doctors till I had one offer to have my bone test done as part of the information we needed to make the best decision on this surgery. I had my first one tell my , “ O bone testing wasn’t needed an I said Why an he flips the Your not old enough an it would make any difference 😳🤬 ya I said I feel we are not an never would be a good fit Thank you . .

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      This education on menopause and osteoporosis will help you manage your post-operative course.

  • @tzanoudakiioanna4212
    @tzanoudakiioanna4212 3 года назад +1

    Fear fear fear! It's obvious my beautiful dr. Barbie that this is exactly what they want...to be unhealthy and die sooner!
    Thank you again for being in this life and for making it BETTER!!!❤

  • @Candleflower42
    @Candleflower42 Год назад

    Thanks for all your info Dr. Taylor. (Don’t know if you see this years later.) I was taken off HRT by a NP but I know it kept my bone density from worsening and am putting myself back on it. I’ll probably get a consult with you at some point.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  Год назад

      I would love for you to schedule a consultation. I can help you a lot by tailoring everything specifically to YOU. Go ahead. Schedule it. I do them all online.

  • @Cristina-qn2in
    @Cristina-qn2in 3 года назад +1

    Also I forgot to add she also had uterine cancer too ! My ob did tell me that considering that my mom had uterine cancer I would benefit from low dose birth control, taken continuously skipping the placebo week. Watching Dr. Taylor videos confirmed that !!!

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      Isn't it wonderful to feel confident in your management choices!

  • @nadajabbar921
    @nadajabbar921 3 года назад +3

    Hello beautiful lady and teacher. Tomorrow my bone density test @ 2pm Age 50 . I took your recommendation seriously .I will share my result later on to get advice from you if need it. Love you

    • @lourdeslayton332
      @lourdeslayton332 3 года назад +1

      Hello Nada. Will your insurance be paying for your bone density test, since your not age 65?

    • @nadajabbar921
      @nadajabbar921 3 года назад +2

      @@lourdeslayton332 No , my own money $250 Canadian Dollars.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      You will be so glad you did this. Schedule a consultation with me and submit it for interpretation. I assure you that you will understand its implications precisely if I assess it.

    • @angiebailey8884
      @angiebailey8884 3 года назад +2

      @@lourdeslayton332 I had one done at 50 and 52, my insurance paid for both!

    • @lourdeslayton332
      @lourdeslayton332 3 года назад

      @@angiebailey8884 Thank you. Did you requested from your OBGYN or your PRIMARY DOCTOR?

  • @christinealix7664
    @christinealix7664 3 года назад

    What a llame study but how cool these 63 year old woman protected their bones most of them probably past the opportunity window you think the medical industry would learn to better help people but promoting health isn't how they make most of their money

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      Knowing the whole story is always the key. Never assume you get the whole story from any resource, though. You have to really analyze the actual study itself (or rely on me to do it for you).

  • @svgilkog8181
    @svgilkog8181 3 года назад +1

    Thank you, appreciate your work

  • @bigtenfans5831
    @bigtenfans5831 2 года назад

    Did the WHI study publish T scores of the women over the 5 yrs of the study? You shared the fracture prevention metrics-curious to know if the study contained BMD values. Also at 14:22 you stated that estrogen can replace bone loss. By how much? Does that vary by age group?

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  2 года назад

      No two women are alike. So you cannot predict or generalize.
      The WHI did not set out to address osteoporosis at all. They tacked it on as an afterthought and did not design any aspect of the study for addressing it.
      Estrogen PREVENTS bone loss. It does not replace it. And age is irrelevant.

  • @carriespackman762
    @carriespackman762 3 года назад

    Thank you for this video I thought because I’m 66 my window was completely closed.....my grandmother started hrt at 75 because of her bones she died at 101 still had her patch on didn’t have a heart attack or Alzheimer’s or broken bones

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      Your window has nothing to do with your age. It is all about the aging process inside your heart arteries.
      You should seriously consider scheduling a consultation with me at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I will tailor all the facts specifically to YOU and help you weigh your benefits and risks of all the options.

  • @jeanetteraichel8299
    @jeanetteraichel8299 3 года назад

    I'm on a Facebook page for women who had/will have hysterectomies. Many had hysterectomy with BSO, but refuse to do hrt because of the study. I try to send them to Menopause University and let them learn that they have options to pick and if it means fighting their doctor for HRT, then fight....I'm hoping some found your videos
    As for me, I ASKED for if ag surgery follow up. I will insist that my doctor keep me on estrogen forever! I feel better, but work makes me depressed and cranky.....no respect.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      Work is not menopause-friendly. I published a video on that long ago. Hopefully, this menopause movement will change that for the better.

  • @arescue
    @arescue 3 года назад

    This whole series on osteoporosis has only confirmed my decision to use both a systemic form of estrogen in addition to the cream for my vagina. I don’t want any of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse visiting me: heart disease, osteoporosis, Alzheimer’s, or vaginal/bladder atrophy. One of the symptoms of my teratoma was bone loss in my jaw that my dentist noticed when I was 28 years old. That darn tumor stole my estrogen ha ha ha.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      You are really learning what you need to know to have the kind of future you want. That's what this education is all about. I applaud you, my dear.

  • @sirleimartin5476
    @sirleimartin5476 3 года назад

    Dear Menopause Taylor, can you please explain why sex drive declines during menopause?

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      It's because your estrogen decreases. As a female, estrogen is to you what testosterone is to a man. 2 years after you lose your estrogen, you lose your testosterone.

  • @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245
    @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245 3 года назад +1

    I wish you were practicing in NY or that other doctors understand what you do! Every doctor I have known of all kinds are super scared of hormones because of that stupid study! My uterus is in trouble and I want a hysterectomy but I am having a hard time because my new GYN is mad at me for having fibroids and a thick uterus. It is hard to find a true menopause specialist on the east cast. There is one in Boston but she has a years waiting list! But anyway no doctor understands what you are explaining in this video! The media is pushing fear for the virus too and its the same tactic! Yes the ability to think is missing in the US and the world today!

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +4

      Yes, I have been thinking a lot about the parallel between HRT and Covid lately.

    • @suzy1750
      @suzy1750 3 года назад +1

      The ability to think isn't missing in the USA (or in other countries) - there are plenty of people all over who are bewildered and angry at what is happening with the whole 'covid situation' - the problem is anyone who tries to speak the truth is vilified and shut down - look at what happened to Dr. Scott Atlas...lives are being ruined and there is no end in sight. This whole situation is scary and I'm not talking about the covid virus.

    • @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245
      @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245 3 года назад

      @@suzy1750 I understand what you are saying. But those who watch main stream media are consenting to be brainwashed because they refuse to think!

    • @suzy1750
      @suzy1750 3 года назад

      @@theoneandonlypinkypinky8245 I don't want to take over Dr. Taylor's thread about something unrelated to her channel like covid but I just have to say that I think that some people - at least people I know - are consenting to be scared because it is in their interests to do so. While I don't doubt some people are genuinely frightened (the media certainly tried its best to make them so), other people I know are doing quite well in this situation - they are able to work from home and don't want to go back to slogging into an office (or wherever) five days a week. While the lockdown might have its downside and inconveniences for them, it's more than outweighed by the benefits. These are the people that sigh about how we all must make sacrifices and are 'in this together' while they head to their living room in their jammies for a day's work. Meanwhile local, family-owned businesses that have been around for decades are shutting down for good. To be clear, I am lucky enough to be able to work from home myself and hope to be able to continue to do so when (? if ?) this ever ends but I don't want this ridiculous situation to continue just so I can do so! It's disgusting. I apologize for the rant - I am just so angry and sickened by this. I will stop for good now.

    • @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245
      @theoneandonlypinkypinky8245 3 года назад

      @@suzy1750 I was not only talking about the CCP virus (it's what Chinese people call it) my hubby is Chinese but the media is brainwashing people and if they are watching mainstream news at all they are believing the view of the world they are paid to push. It's not news its Propaganda. CNN did a story on me that was 100% false and they said I was a drug addicted whore suffering from anorexia. People have a theory that there is fake news. But I have experience! Not one person from CNN contacted me and its too much of a complicated long story to get into but I know from experience most news 99% on TV is fake! Other stations around the world as well as news paupers and magazines picked up the fake news story. Not one person bothered to contact me! It ruined my ability to make a living! So if people watch the news they are consenting to be brainwashed!

  • @amommyof2637
    @amommyof2637 3 года назад

    Hi. I've been listening BOTH in chronological order but i also bounce around all the subjects. I actually just messaged you on Facebook today. So glad i got notification of this video too and heard it also this afternoon. Wow!... Such timing; played right into my question. I would so like a consultation with you real soon here, but want tobe prepared. My doctor put in a request for the Dexa bone density test so i hope to have insurance approve and i should be getting a call in a week - so they said - so i can schedule. I'd like to have all the test done that you would require I take to discuss results. I just got blood results of vitamin D. Is there anything else that you would ask of me as far as what could be found in a blood test? I can always send this question on your Facebook page if I do not see in answer here.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      The only labs pertinent to a consultation are (1) Lipid studies (cholesterol, etc.), (2) Thyroid labs, (3) DEXA bone density test, (4) Mammogram, and (5) Any abnormal tests or labs that you wish to address in the consultation. None are mandatory, but I will not address anything you have not submitted in advance.
      I look forward to meeting you!

    • @amommyof2637
      @amommyof2637 3 года назад

      Thank you so much. I will go ahead and ask for the remaining two. It so happens i just underwent the mammogram... ouch🙄... youd think with all the advancement they could come up with something else! Anyway i have 2 autoimmune diseases i struggle with - neurologic and skin. ... I'm looking forward to this visit as well 🙂 . I wish id found you 10 years ago.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      @@amommyof2637 Well, at least I'll be here to hold your hand for the rest of your life.

  • @christinehoffman1825
    @christinehoffman1825 2 года назад

    😃😃😃

  • @rosalindadavila7468
    @rosalindadavila7468 3 года назад

    Hi Dr. Barbara! I have a Question.. taking HRT causes cyst,calcification or limps in the breast?

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +7

      You have a lot of misinformation here, Rosalinda. Your breasts have always responded to estrogen and progesterone, since you went through puberty. But it has never been a reason for worry. HRT is nothing but a replacement for the same hormones your ovaries used to produce. Why would you think HRT causes these things if the estrogen and progesterone that has been surging through your body for the last 40 years doesn't?

    • @angelmuscledoc
      @angelmuscledoc 3 года назад +1

      @@MenopauseTaylor 🙌

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      @@angelmuscledoc Kisses to you, Angel.

    • @angelmuscledoc
      @angelmuscledoc 3 года назад

      @@MenopauseTaylor 💌🥰

  • @mariaborges4451
    @mariaborges4451 3 года назад

    Why does the vagina cream estradiol does not contain progesterone?

    • @AntidoteX2
      @AntidoteX2 3 года назад +3

      I think because the cream stays in the vagina and doesn’t travel throughout the body.

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад +1

      Because your vagina does not need progesterone. Only your uterus does. And the vaginal estrogen creams do not travel to your uterus, or anywhere. They consist of molecule that ate too large to enter the blood stream.

    • @mariaborges4451
      @mariaborges4451 3 года назад

      @@MenopauseTaylor Thank you !

    • @MenopauseTaylor
      @MenopauseTaylor  3 года назад

      @@mariaborges4451 It's my pleasure.