How to Pronounce the Israeli Hebrew Resh (ר) | UlpaNoya
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Want to improve your Hebrew / Israeli accent?
In this video: 3 killer tips! To find your natural Resh (ר)!
Master the 4th most used letter in Hebrew.
Click play to start sounding like a native Hebrew speaker!
👉🏼Contact Noya for online lessons: www.ulpanoya.com/
👉🏼Subscribe to UlpaNoya on RUclips: bit.ly/3LhzxKI
👉🏼Join UlpaNoya on Facebook: / ulpanoya
👉🏼Students say about UlpaNoya: www.ulpanoya.c...
![How to Pronounce the Hebrew Resh [ר]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yNJtAibUeOc/mqdefault.jpg)
![The best trilled [r] video yet!](/img/1.gif)
Oh my God. After years of trying, you literally taught me exactly how to easily pronounce Resh in one video. Thank you!
I'm so happy to hear! Have fun with it!
Yes it's great. That association with the guttural Chet was key.
My roommate in Israel had spent a year in the US with her parents and she told me she found the American R sound the hardest. But - here's the interesting part - she pronounced the American R like the Israeli Resh, with air and a soft rolling R. And that showed me exactly how to pronounce Resh as an Israeli does!
Thank you for making this video.The ר and ח sound really confused me a lot.It's really nice to have a simple description between them.
01:22 start
03:07 intensive
todah raba!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks for the tips ^^, I can pronounce it now even though I've to hold my tongue first
That's awesome Efraim!
Thank you from Indonesia :)
:o I can roll with the back of my tongue now!! I still have to roll for a little bit first to get the resh out after it, but I've never been able to roll the back. I was learning French a few years ago and I was told it was okay to use the front roll motion to make the r sound. Since this was easier for me, I never learned with the back. Thank you, it was so cool to learn this :D
Hi Raernian, it's so great to hear! Enjoy your new Resh ;-)
I've never had trouble with pronunciation myself. I find the phonetic sounds of Hebrew to be quite gorgeous.
Just poppin' onto RUclips to do a little preening, eh? 🤣
What a great tips, that helped a lot thank you!!
This also happened when I learned Spanish....I kept at it and only finally got one tiny (r) pop sound. Even if I used a towel it just is one teeny tiny mini (r). oh well
(But ר is not like the Spanish r. It's like the French r.)
Shalom .Thank you. Watching from Australia. 73 Praise the Lord 137. 26 Praise the Lord 86.
I love it!! And yes the resh is one of the hardest to pronounced right like ח
Thank you so much for the tips
I've noticed that the ר has different difficulties (at least for me) at different times. For example, for me I feel like my ר sounds a lot more correct when it is an "ehr" sound (as in friend, חבר) as opposed to an "ahr" sound (as in room, חדר). Also, I feel like it's near impossible to pronounce when it follows another consonant. For example, I can say flower פרח but not really too good at saying flowers פרחים , kinda sounds like pwahim.
Hi Darkslide820, it is very natural to experience different levels of difficulty when pronouncing the Resh (Or any other sound we're not used to), in different locations in words, or after/before different sounds.
In your case, I would recommend repeating the word חָבֵר a number of times, and try to feel what's happening in your mouth, in the back of your throat, when you create a proper Resh. Only then, move to חֲדַר and try to do it the same way. You can also alternate: Say CHAVER and then CHADAR.
CHAVER and then CHADAR, and so forth. Or you can do it with חֶדֶר (CHEDER) and then(CHADAR) חֲדַר. That might be even better. Less room for confusion.
For words like פְּרָחִים, first practice it, as if the word starts with the Resh. Like there's no פ in front of it: RA CHEEM. Repeat it a few times, until the Resh feels and sounds good to you. Only then, try to add the פ at the beginning: PRA CHEEM. If it's still hard, separate the P from the RA: First make a P sound with no vowel (should sound something like a punch). It's basically built up air being pushed out of your mouth at once (a bit like how beatboxers do). Then say: RA. Practice a number of times: P. RA… P. RA….etc. When that feels comfortable, and the Resh sounds good, try to put them together: PRA. PRA…etc. Then add the rest of the word: PRA CHEEM.
Hope that helps 😊
This video: Exactly what I was looking for, Thank you for this
Absolutely BRILLIANT tips. Thank you soooo much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! Happy I could help! 😊
Thank you. I learned something today. :)
אוהבת! את ממש עוזרת לי. אני מדברת עברית שנים .בעלי ז"ל היה צבר ועדיין ה "ר" היה לי קשה!!
@@rosalindhershkovitz4390 איזה יופי! אני ממש שמחה לשמוע 😊
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn! אמשיך איתך. תמיד רציתי להוציא את המבטא שלי . אולי סוף סוף.
@@rosalindhershkovitz4390 יאללה, מוזמנת ליצור קשר ולהתחיל לפתח מבטא ישראלי כמו שצריך ❤️😊
I love this video and it was so helpful. It is on my favorites so I can return again and ag
Thank youuuuu❤❤❤
I actually jumped up and down when I just learned this trick like omg I can do it now!!!!!!😂
Woohoo!!!😀 That's awesome daniel!
Which trick worked for you?
Thanks for this, as a native speaker of European Portuguese, understanding the difference between ר and ח is so hard. In Portuguese, our R is always fluctuating, sometimes it comes stronger like a ח, most times softer like a ר, and many times comes so soft that it sounds similar to an English H even. So when I started learning Hebrew I couldn’t even tell the difference between ח and ר. I thought they were pronounced the same like ט and ת. I wasn’t even aware of how “fluctuating” our pronunciation of RR is here in Portugal, until I started paying close attention to it recently. I always thought it sounded the same 😩 To me, pronunciating the ר is the hardest, I need to have so much mental control to not turn it into an ח or an H 😩 not easy at all, but I’d say I’ve been making progress!
Hey Sabrina :). First of all well done. On keeping at it, not giving up, and developing awareness. Changing your pronunciation can take time, but with persistence and attention, the change gradually happens. I have a Portuguese student who has EXACTLY these issues you've described, so I've created a special exercise for her to solve this. A tip I can give you from afar is to focus on the main (and almost only) difference between ח (chet) and ר (resh) . For ר we add voice. We activate our vocal folds. For ח we don't. So to make the ר, you need to go: חחחחחח and add voice: ahhhhhh. Together they make ר. Try alternating between them. Go: חחחחחח and add voice= רררררר. And again: חחחחח and add voice: רררררר. Try not to change anything in your mouth except for adding and removing the voice. That way you will physically and audibly experience the difference between ר and ח. After you manage to do this, you will probably just need to "refine" your ר sound a little bit, to make it softer and more natural. By the way, you said that your ר is soft. That's good. ר is supposed to be soft. It's so soft it's almost like a vowel. The blocking of air and friction are very mild. (As opposed to ח). But be careful- there must be SOME blocking of air, otherwise, you will get a vowel. (Or ה- h).
I hope this helps :)
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn Hi, thanks a lot for your response and explanation!! 🙏🏻 it’s reassuring to know this is a normal struggle for people who speak my language. Your tip was definitely helpful, now I need to practice more, especially words with both letters, like אחרי 😅. Also, what you said about the main difference between both letters has cleared my understanding. תודה רבה!
@@sabrinagilmusic Wonderful! I'm so happy to hear 🙂. You're right about אחרי. It is a challenging one, but actually this kind of words (with ח and ר one after the other), is very good for practicing and understanding the subtle differences between the two. And you'll see that if you keep practicing, it will suddenly click! and it won't be challenging anymore. It will become natural. Remember that ר is very soft. It's just a light and quick touch. (of the back of the tongue raising to the soft palate/uvula). It should (eventually) be effortless. I had a student who was really struggling with the resh, and when she realized she was making too much of an effort, it suddenly clicked. And her pronunciation of it became SO natural. It was very exciting and moving. I'm looking forward to hearing about your breakthrough Sabrina!
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn you’re right, it’s perfect for practicing! Thanks again for all the advice, is very much appreciated and helpful. Just subscribed to your channel to keep up with the content :) 💛
@@sabrinagilmusic Yeay! That's great! Thank you Sabrina😊 There is a new video "in the oven" 😉
Ok, NOW I can say it. Thanks!
So helpful, many thanks.
Excelent!!!!!! Todah Rabah!!!!
Thank you so much! Holding the tongue really helps and I had never thought it. Shalom!
You're so good! Thanks!
Thank you Noya. Yes, the resh is my most difficult sound. Especially when there are 2 close together like in L'shachrer/ to release.
I know what you mean :) Try to pronounce it first only with the first Resh but change the second one into a vowel sound: leshachre לשחרה try to say it like that a few times, and then bring back the second resh instead of the vowel sound, but keep in mind, that the Resh is an extremely subtle and gentle sound. It's barely there. (Especially at the end of a word). So there's only a slight difference between leshachre and leshachrer. For leshachrer the back part of your tongue needs to rise a little bit towards the uvula. I hope this helps!
I have been trying to improve my ר for a long time. Thanks to your tips (and the comment section!) I have finally realized how. P.s. my ר was too guttural, like the German r and I wasn't sure what exactly was wrong with it.
I am still struggling a lot with the words with רר like מתעוררת.
I'm very happy to hear this helped you with your resh :)
Try prolonging the vowel sound between those two reshes (mitoreeeeeeeeret), say it like that several times, until it feels right, and then gradually reduce the gap between them, (the duration of the vowel sound) as you keep repeating the word, until you manage to say 'mitoreret' naturally.
soooooooooo perfect! Thank you so much! Shalom 🙌
Thank You so much these tips are genius!
Cool tips for the resh pronunciation.
Wow thank you so much!!!
Thanks. Very helpful video
Thank you so much!!
This was great thank you
Luv it 😂
מעולה!
You're smart and funny! I love you!
this was very helpful. thank you!
Thank you =)
Great video!!
To add briefly, Hebrew has five phonetic groups of letters. ח is a gutteral, and ר is a dental.
Your videos are excellent, and I do appreciate them. 👍
Resh is absolutely not dental in this video or in Israeli Hebrew. It is guttural/uvular but voiced (vibrates).
It is at most alveolar as far as how front it goes. Dental would mean we made it with our teeth like English
Hi Hillel, thank you 😊. In Modern Hebrew ח is velar and ר is uvular. (In traditional/older Hebrew ר was alveolar and ח was indeed guttural).
@@carpexomnisHi! In Modern/Israeli Hebrew, ר is indeed uvular. The back part of the tongue rises towards the uvula.
Great edutainment! Thank you.
Thank you Devorah 😊
Question: considering Hebrew is pretty much a reconstructed language, how did we derive the "french/German" R sound for "resh" vs a "Spanish/Italian" R sound, which seems more common in modern semitic languages?
Hi DonVoghano, Israel is a melting pot of immigrants from many different countries in the world, including European countries like Germany. During the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century, German and Yiddish speaking immigrants were among the main creators of Modern/Israeli Hebrew. That can explain how the German/French "Resh", took over.
What the person said above is correct Yiddish influenced this a lot but ALSO ... Arabic has the same sound often transcribed as ... 🤷♂️
Jews have been speaking Hebrew in prayers for thousands of years and the modern Hebrew was just adding a few words in like window and television.
@@bookmouse2719 That's like saying that Italians speak Latin because the Vatican still writes it and has services in it.
A good lesson
I'm not a Hebrew native nor an American English native but for me Resh is 1000 Times harder than the American r.
Thanks for this video, my resh always comes out really harsh! How do you soften it? For example rechov and rotza I’m putting so much emphasis on the resh
You are right. There shouldn't be any emphasis on the Resh. It is a very soft and delicate sound. Unfortunately how to make it softer is not something I can explain in passing. There are different techniques and approaches to learn and practice this sound, and I use different ones with each student according to their specific needs and the unique starting point each brings to the table. It's about tailoring the approach to each student, and then practicing and fine-tuning together.
“Why have letters if you’re not going to pronounce them?”
*Laughs in א*
Seriously, though, awesome video and great tips!
not true, א is a glottal stop. It makes the difference between שלה ("shela", hers) and שאלה ("she-ela", question)
But Israelis rarely pronunce the ע sound, because we're just too lazy
Is the difference more than just voicing? In the word חבר, it sounds much shorter at the end of the word.
Hi Adam. I'm not sure I understand your question. What difference are you referring to? In any case, Resh is pronounced the same, anywhere in the word.
Buem video eres una excelente maestra
Gracias!
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn por favor pon subtitulos en español ya que estoy estudiando hebreo
When I was speaking Hebrew in Israel, I thought I was pronouncing the "resh" properly -- but people kept telling me I was speaking *with a "French accent"!* Sometimes older people would hear me speak and immediately switch to French. What's the difference between the French and Hebrew "R" sound?
The difference lies mostly in the level of friction. In French, for the [r], the back part of the tongue rises higher and gets closer to, or even touches the uvula. (or the area behind it). This creates friction when air is expelled from the mouth. In Hebrew, for the Resh, there's normally no contact between the tongue and uvula. The back part of the tongue rises, but just a little bit. So there's minimal obstruction of air and no friction. This creates a noticeable difference between the French and Hebrew sounds.
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn : Thank you for the explanation!
תודה, עזרת לי להבין סוף סוף איך עושים את הר' הזאת. תמיד הייתה עושה ר' tap או trill
יה....איזה כיף! 😊 שמחה לשמוע!
Her ח sounded more like what I though was a soft ך or כ. I read the כ was uvular (from the back of throat) and ח was velar (from wherever a velar comes from) like the Dutch g in van Gogh.
זה כל כך קשה אבל אני עדיין מנסה ללמוד. 😢
Está complicado pronunciar la resh, no lo logro.
of course you can :) You just need to practice, until it will suddenly come out :)
At work, we had Israeli visitors who struggled to pronounce the English/American R while speaking English and theirs sounded like the Israeli one. 😁
Excellent. I enjoyed it a lot. The r in hebrew has just one pronunciation?
Basically yes. There can be different "styles" of pronunciation for different people, and also there is a minority of Israelis who use the traditional Hebrew Resh, which is a trill/alveolar Resh (like in Arabic), but generally there is one standard sound for the modern Resh used by native speakers today. (The one demonstrated in this video).
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn thanks.
I love the angry dog idea! :D
Very helpful..and entertaining too!
When I was in Israel, resh sounded like native speakers were imitating Elmer Fudd the Looney Tunes cartoon character.
Is it kind of like trilling an r but in the back of the throat?
I guess that's a way of looking at it🤔
The problem is, I can do it but not continually or when trying to speak. I try to practice words like גרא to get the feel for it. Lol it’s so frustrating when I’m in class and I think I can make the ר sound but it just comes out “rrrrhhhhh” 😅
It's a matter of practice. You might need some guidance as well. I'm here 🌹
My understanding of the Hebrew R is twofold: a) the sound that you teach in your video and b) the R that I believe is the RP pronunciation which you hear when listening to the Israel news. What is your opinion on this?
Hi dear Jonathan,
I'm not sure what you're referring to, because they've stopped using the traditional resh on the news, years ago. (That is an alveolar tap, like in Spanish).
As far as I'm aware, the modern resh (uvular- the one I'm teaching in this video) is used (almost) everywhere, including the news. I can't remember when was the last time I heard a newscaster using the tap resh. Could you tell me what news source you were listening to, when you came across a different resh than the one used in Modern / everyday Hebrew?
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn : Dan Khaner used to read the news using the traditional resh and pharyngealized ayin. I thought it sounded very artificial. He's changed now, though, in language courses he has recorded (like Duolingo).
There are singers who used to use the trilled R, who now use the modern one, even when singing the SAME SONG. I have two CDs by David D'Or, recorded years apart, and I wondered why and when the "new" sound became the one recommended. How was that decision made?
(BTW, I used to have Yemenite friends who always used the traditional one, like in Arabic.)
@@stevecarson4162 That is absolutely correct. Both about newscasters (not only Dan khaner) and singers.
As far as I know, the transformation to the uvular Resh wasn't an official decision. It was just a natural development that evolved among Israeli Hebrew speakers.
And yes, it's not uncommon to hear Yemenites using the traditional alveolar/tap Resh. :)
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn : I notice that Sarit Hadad uses the trill when she sings and the uvular one when she speaks.
I wondered if it's for the same reason that French opera singers use a trilled R when they sing, but the usual French R when they speak. EDIT: I'm thinking of operas written in French, like "Lakmé", where they use the trilled R when they sing, like it's supposed to be more "classical" or something.
@@stevecarson4162 😄 Right! She does! I don't know about the opera 🤔 Isn't it because they're singing in Italian? Regarding Sarit Hadad, that IS curious 😊
Are you sure the uvular trill is universally easier to acquire than the retroflex approximant?
Hi orhoushmand85,
No, I am not sure 😊. I was just trying to make a point.
However, based on the fact that the great majority of Israeli children have no problem with the Resh, while American English-speaking children often struggle with the r, I would definitely assume that the Hebrew Resh is easier to achieve than the American r.
Regarding the phonetic definition of Resh, it isn't a trill. It is an approximant. There shouldn't be contact between the tongue and the uvula or soft palate.
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn But the uvula vibrates. Maybe your Resh is not a trill, but mine is.
@@orhoushmand85
It's not the end of the world if your Resh is a trill.
The standard Resh is an approximant, not a trill. Of course, like most sounds in a language, there are variations in its pronunciation among different speakers.
But the standard Resh, according to both linguistic definitions and the pronunciation used by most native speakers, is an approximant and does not involve contact between the tongue and the palate or uvula. Therefore, the uvula should not be vibrating in its production.
A small minority of native Hebrew speakers pronounce the Resh as a uvular trill, but as an accent teacher, when I teach Hebrew learners how to pronounce a specific sound, I make sure to teach them the common pronunciation, not the exceptional one.
Another example-if a native speaker has a lisp and therefore pronounces the sounds: s, sh, z, ts differently from me, and it's not hard to find other speakers with the same lisp, I still wouldn't teach language learners that pronunciation, as it is also incorrect, even though there are speakers who use it.
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn The uvular trill is more common among Hebrew speakers than you think, I hear it everywhere.
@@orhoushmand85 This clarifies that you simply don't know what a uvular trill sounds like. Period.
I rarely hear speakers actually vocalizing the vocalized uvular fricative in Resh or R, be it in french, Hebrew or Portuguese.
It's a uvular trill in hebrew, not only is it voiced, it also has less friction and more vibration than a fricative.
i keep pronouncing resh like russian r and i cannot break out of that habit
not like i want to but
Correct regarding the way many or most native Israeli's say it. However, the Russian and American pronunciations are the accurate, authentic ones in the Hebrew language. Some Israelis also pronounce it this way. I like your videos, which are very helpful, in any case.
Talk about the French ‘R’…
i grew up in israel but in russian family, russian R is very different form hebrew R, so im struggling my whole life with that hebrew R, literally impossible for me
Hi Syoma, I hope this video will make a change for you!
I pronouced like arabic غ (ghayn), is it the same sound? Sometimes I feel it's the same, but sometimes I feel ר has more rrr to it than غ
I think you described it just right. They're close but I think resh does have more rrr. Also, maybe sometimes it sounds to you like they are closer sounds than other times, because the Arabic one has different pronunciations in different words?
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn
Well the غ pronunciation is pretty standard in Arabic, no variation, I used the gargling method you described and I feel I'm starting to say ר correctly, but I think it's messing up my Arabic غ now😂😂
@@manetho5134 haha 😁 It's good, it means you're getting into it 😀. And I'm sure it's temporary and you'll get your غ back :)
Whats wrong with american resh pronunciation? ? I think it sounds way better
❤️❤️❤️🖖🖖🖖🌸🌸🌸
Por eso a los hispanohablantes nos resulta tan facil el hebreo
"How is somebody supposed to pronounce something when it's not even there" is the definition of Israeli Hebrew ה. 😂😂😂😂
you're great
Can you tell me the difference between, רמש and שרץ
what is the meaning please.
thank you so much
I think they are synonyms 🤔 They mean- insect, bug. But not in modern everyday Hebrew.
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn
thank you
do some research
I think it depends on the classification of arthropods
thank you so much!
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn
your videos are great
explains very well
I learned on my own by just adding a little extra spit in my mouth and make a gargling sound. Or when Austin powers try’s to sound like a tiger 😂
Awesome! 😄 Just don't forget to make it a bit "softer on the edges". Not that "wavy".
That’s the way Ashkenazim pronounce Resh, like a French R. But Sephardim pronounce it differently.
Hi Rolando,
What you wrote was relevant for the beginning of the previous century.
Today both Ashkenazim and Spharadim use the guttural Resh (like the French or German one). And that is the conventional Resh used in Israel today, regardless of the speaker's Ashkenazi or Spharadi roots.
It is possible to find Hebrew speakers in Israel, who use the Arabic/Russian/Spanish Resh (produced with the tip of the tongue), but people who use it would be, in most cases, either non-native speakers, or Spharadi elders. (Some of them kept the traditional Resh). In any case, a Hebrew native speaker who hears someone speaking with that Resh, would say that they have an accent.
Actually, all Orthodox Jews agree that the original resh was a trill. In fact Hasidim (not including lebuvitch), use a trill resh in their Hebrew and Yiddish.
Hello,@Zaashtill 1 . It is commonly assumed by linguists and language researchers, that the alveolar Resh (trilled, where the tip of the tongue touches the top palate), was used in ancient Hebrew, (like Arabic uses it today), but this Resh has almost completely disappeared among Israeli natives. Today, the conventional placement for pronouncing the Resh, is the soft palate, close to the uvula. I don't know about Hasidim, but if they do use the trilled Resh, as you say, they are the exception. (And just for general information: Only about 14% of the Jewish population in Israel is Orthodox. And less then that is Hasidim).
UlpaNoya Noya Einhorn Not the Israeli Hasidim, specifically the American ones, which are in exes of 150,000. And they use the trill In their Yiddish, and Biblical Hebrew.
I got to tell you, The Idiot Connoisseur, I have no clue as to how Americans in the states speak Hebrew, especially not biblical Hebrew. (And Yiddish is a whole other language completely). I teach Israeli modern Hebrew. The Hebrew spoken in Israel, by native speakers.
שלום ילדים lol I’m a native Hebrew speaker I think she is one too idk
איייי מה קורה
ישראלית אבל לא אומרת ר טוב, תודה לך
Is this the same as the German r?
Very very close to it 😊
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn What's the difference? 😀
@@thememaster7 The best way to understand, is to watch You Tube videos by German teachers on how to pronounce the German R, and hear and see the difference.
In Greece where i live there are many Jews and they roll the Resh at the alveolar ridge rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
Of course they do.🙃Why wouldn't they? They are Greek. 🇬🇷
Could you please do a video on ח? It's so hard
Hi :) What language do you speak?
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn Hello! My native language is English, I'm trying to learn hebrew
Great. So think for example about the sound English speakers might make when they express disgust. It's hard to write down this sound, but sometimes it's spelled like this: Ugh, or like this: Eughh. Or the sound English speakers might make to express contempt. A kind of a snort. Like: "You think you can beat me at basketball?! [snort sound] no way!"
Or simply make the sound you would make if you had something stuck in your throat, and you were trying to get it out. Or when your throat itches, like from an allergy, and you want to kind of scrape it.
That's the Chet sound.
I hope this helps :)
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn werid, thanks for telling me!
Why hard? You should just make friction in the uvula.
i think i got it thanks 😆, i press both edge of my tounge up my upper side teeth,
Hey there Seaweed :) Actually all you need to do is raise the back part of your tongue towards the soft palate/velum and touch or almost touch the uvula with it. No need to touch the teeth. Keep up the good work!
:)
This pronunciation of Resh is actually wrong and comes from Yiddish, in real Hebrew the letter Resh is a rolling sound similar to Spanish or Russian.
French/German style R sound became so commonplace that it became a typical feature of an Israeli accent, but ir is just wrong and sounds bad...
Hello שלמה מ,
I understand that some of the many changes that ancient Hebrew underwent throughout its long history upset you.
I hear you… but the fact is that languages evolve. They are always changing and developing, whether we like it or not. This Resh sound, is not wrong. It's just different. It has changed, in a natural process that happens in most languages, if not in all of them. Certainly, in a 4000 year old language. If you are a Hebrew speaker, I am 100% sure, that you don't speak ancient Hebrew as your everyday language. Hebrew speakers today, speak modern Hebrew.
Countless things have changed in this language, and modern Hebrew is very different from what it used to be. It's almost like another language.
Why is it specifically the Resh pronunciation that bothers you? Are you also bothered by the fact that Hebrew used to have a [th] sound, and it doesn't anymore? Are you bothered with the modern sound of the letter [ט] which is pronounced today like [ת], even though they used to be different, and [ט] had a pharyngeal sound, like Arabic still pronounces it today? Does it seem wrong to you that today when we talk about an action that happened in the past, we actually use past tense and not future tense, as it used to be in biblical Hebrew?
Some features of Hebrew were kept, and some changed. Do all of these changes I mentioned sound bad to you?
@@UlpaNoyaNoyaEinhorn I am bothered by all of the above mentioned, but French Resh just sounds BAD
As a matter of fact I am verymuch pro tendency of reviving ancient Hebrew in its original form
@@user-cu3yt2uv6k I think it's a matter of taste :) I happen to like the way it sounds. Both the French R and the modern Hebrew Resh.
@@user-cu3yt2uv6k Interesting. I can understand that. Do you actually implement all of these ancient features that I mentioned when you speak Hebrew?
שתיים..שלוש..שגר
ככה לא מבטאים ר
הריש היא לא אות גרונית
אני חושב שיותר נכון לומר שזו אות ענבלית אם כבר.
@@orhoushmand85
יש כאלו שאומרים שזו אות גרונית
יש מי שאומרים שזו אות לשונית או אות שמוצאה מהשיניים,
הריש הישראלית בכל אופן לא קרובה לשתי האפשרויות האחרונות
ריש wrong
Tell that to 7 million Hebrew speakers in Israel 🤣