@@NoobNotFoundDev is this the first time you hear about Google or sth? They are notorious for discontinuing products after putting a whole bunch of money and effort into them.
Alternatively, VSCode's Codespaces does the exact same thing as IDX, even down to its extensions where most of IDX's extensions still reference VSCode. I believe the only benefit of using IDX over Codespaces is that it's completely free.
"This is a code editor, a code editor with AI assistance, user collaboration, environment customization, web previews, and Android emulation." That's a weird way of describing VS Code with a few extensions
VScode is just an editor without any extensions. But it also is completely trivial to install extensions (5 seconds of very low effort that can be done by someone with mere minutes of VScode experience) Google has two types of services. Those they kill off, and data harvesters.
While the product has many promising features, it's still plagued by significant bugs. IDX struggles with handling large traffic volumes and consumes excessive RAM. It frequently reloads itself, particularly when multiple files are opened in the editor, leading to lags and sometimes even self-reloading. These performance issues must be resolved before considering any promotion. Fix the core problems first to ensure a stable and reliable product.
IDX is literally VSCode for the web with a gemini plugin. That's it... not sure what is exactly revolutionary here. Copilots been around for ages and we all know how well Gemini performs compared to OpenAI to this day
@@lone.wo1f but VS code isn't available locally on any device, and the web version sucks. I want to be able to work and review on a phone or a non Windows tablet
@@lone.wo1f I meant for mobile (tablets, Chromebooks, and phones) which VScode doesn't have a local option for. Also the web version of VScode is bad, or was when I tried it.
This is what I'm thinking too. Not a programmer although I do have some of the skills due to web app security research I have done. Can probably guarantee it's gonna be snooping a bit at least and at most, all the time. Will reserve judgement until that's officially determined, but as with almost anything else, it seems rather prudent to assume it will train itself on the backs of users even if it actually isn't. Better to be safe than sorry imo.
Imagine a million dollar deal and this shows up Error opening workspace: IDX is currently experiencing increased load. Please come back and try again later.
AI is not a new feature, but now it is a bullet world to sell more "value". Create something, inject "AI," and sell too. Don't fight with this; next year, the bullet world will change to a Biological CPU or Quantum Computing.
This is interesting and impressive but it might not stay long. For those looking for something industry-specific, Immersive Translate now allows you to customize your own AI expert, it also allows translations in the technology field become more accurate and professional.
To everyone saying its just like VS Code clearly have no idea what they're talking about. IDX is more like Replit. Your entire dev environment is on a nix vm running on the cloud, and can run on your browser.
@@hilmyakatsuki1665 Where you can setup an environment, install dependencies and run code all on the browser? Where can I find this I'd love to try it if its true
I’ve always wondered why we haven’t used LLMs to show a more understandable response to error in code instead of some intensely cryptic error message. And then google comes up with this video.
hard disagree, web apps are useful for certain people. If i wanted to, I could pull up with an android tablet and connect an external keyboard and it would still have all the functionality of desktop coding because of the fact that I can access IDX from almost any browser, and still have tools like node, bash…
As a programmer this seems pretty interesting and might try it out but never gonna make the switch from my current editor cause I can already see IDX getting discontinued not even 6 months after launch
In the near future after they got all the data they need : Oops your library can't be larger than 1Go, you have to upgrade to premium it's just 50$ a month or you can't see your code anymore.
I'm now using Chromebook for development, it's a life change. And Chromebooks are so efficient I have so much battery life and low consume This is how the future looks like
Heyy i have a problem ,Error opening workspace: We’ve detected suspicious activity on one of your workspaces. Please contact support 1 for further assistance. Can. You help me to resolve this . I cannot open it in all of my device
I’d love to use this. Specially since I don’t code anymore and don’t want to have to be downloading or updating any tool. But I can’t feel the emails to export my code because Google is discounting this by September 20- -
Only reason anybody would use this, is if it does what Roblox does. It should have a "plug and play" functionality to it. By default it should FORCE you into using a certain paradigm. It should force standardization. It shouldn't require a whole afternoon to setup your build environment. Screw compatibility. People will only use this if it replaces garbage like cmake and standardizes everything while making it easy to use. Eitherway Im actually kinda hyped for this.
Does this include support for things such as LUAU id like to see more diversity and I’d definitely also like to see a fully supported software rather than a in browser code editor IDX seems promising but requires more sustainable systems Giving AI access to your projects DOM and having it virtualise and simplify your tasks is really all we require if not educating us on things it knows for certain
![The moment we stopped understanding AI [AlexNet]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UZDiGooFs54/mqdefault.jpg)
![The moment we stopped understanding AI [AlexNet]](/img/tr.png)
Subscribe to Google for Developers → goo.gle/developers
19 likes is insane
- "anywhere in the universe"
- "IDX AI is not enabled for your region. Stay tuned!"
Are you sure you're not signing up from alternate universe? 😂
@@rudilee😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
my region isn't real 😔
it's because you're out of this world
Project IDX is impressive, but there's always the risk of Google discontinuing it.
@@TechKerala then why do they still posting these videos?
@@NoobNotFoundDev That is True passion for salary, no passion for anything else.
@@NoobNotFoundDev is this the first time you hear about Google or sth?
They are notorious for discontinuing products after putting a whole bunch of money and effort into them.
If its not being used at scale then of course there is no need to continue maintaining it
@@T33K3SS3LCH3N ikr
Imagine depending on project idx and Google discontinue the next day 💀 ☠️
Why would that be a problem? If your code is pushed to a remote repository, you can just switch to VS Code.
Alternatively, VSCode's Codespaces does the exact same thing as IDX, even down to its extensions where most of IDX's extensions still reference VSCode.
I believe the only benefit of using IDX over Codespaces is that it's completely free.
@@_____caseyes! People do not to afraid so much, just use it if you like it, it is not vendor locked in any way! 😊😊😊
@_____case same reason why people don't write code in notepad anymore.. Developer Experience
@@nivethan-me 💀💀
if we disable Gemini, will you still collect every single character we type?
Xd
asking the right question
Vim 😅
The answer is yes. They'll collect anything they can. Come on, it's Google!
@@amine7 who doesn't collect
"This is a code editor, a code editor with AI assistance, user collaboration, environment customization, web previews, and Android emulation."
That's a weird way of describing VS Code with a few extensions
I mean vs code itself is just an editor without any extension, it can only detect codes using extensions
well idx is based on Code OSS, not that different from vscode
VScode is just an editor without any extensions. But it also is completely trivial to install extensions (5 seconds of very low effort that can be done by someone with mere minutes of VScode experience)
Google has two types of services. Those they kill off, and data harvesters.
Interesting, but: this will be dead in 1 year tops
you just created gemini extension for vs code and called it new editor.
It runs on the cloud, all your code is executed on a vm on the cloud. So I think its a little more than that
@@nws551 It is.
Hey, what about GitHub Codespaces? Isn't it the same?
@@nws551but vscode also runs in the browser
@@nws551 You have been able to do this for years by containerizing a VS Code instance and accessing it via the web.
While the product has many promising features, it's still plagued by significant bugs. IDX struggles with handling large traffic volumes and consumes excessive RAM. It frequently reloads itself, particularly when multiple files are opened in the editor, leading to lags and sometimes even self-reloading. These performance issues must be resolved before considering any promotion. Fix the core problems first to ensure a stable and reliable product.
yea but it's a fork of VS Code
No time to look back, need to run forward 😋
Reality check comment.
IDX is literally VSCode for the web with a gemini plugin. That's it... not sure what is exactly revolutionary here. Copilots been around for ages and we all know how well Gemini performs compared to OpenAI to this day
Please. I am happy with my neovim.
Why "please"? They don't force you to quit Neovim for IDX
Sounds bloated. Have you tried ed(1) ?
@@heian17 They can't force you out of Neovim if you don't know how to exit
@heian17 bcz Product managers and companies force you to use anything that comes with the AI tag.
any where in the universe ?? we can't even reach the moon
😅 so you have to prove it that it doesn't work anywhere in the universe
It was released 1 year ago, so it is unavailable anywhere further than 1 light year from earth. So it works only in solar system.
It needs an offline/local app like Google workspace apps and it'll be near perfect
we already have it (vscode).. they just need to launch their gemini & emulator extension
@@lone.wo1f vscode isn't available on any device though and the web version of it sucks, that's the whole benefit of Google cloud based products.
@@lone.wo1f but VS code isn't available locally on any device, and the web version sucks. I want to be able to work and review on a phone or a non Windows tablet
@@lone.wo1f I meant for mobile (tablets, Chromebooks, and phones) which VScode doesn't have a local option for. Also the web version of VScode is bad, or was when I tried it.
Wym how would they be able to collect your data in that case
Look Honey, Another Bloatware Dropped!
its a website no install bruv
@@isaiahpaul56 exactly
@@segsfault Are you referring to ram then?
@@er42069 Web Apps are bloatware in general resource wise.
Then vs code is the biggest bloat ware of all time
LOL vim better.
😂😂 Funniest comment I saw all day
Neovim btw
The only correct answer
True
poopvim is better
r they gonna train their models on the code I write in this editor?
This is what I'm thinking too. Not a programmer although I do have some of the skills due to web app security research I have done. Can probably guarantee it's gonna be snooping a bit at least and at most, all the time. Will reserve judgement until that's officially determined, but as with almost anything else, it seems rather prudent to assume it will train itself on the backs of users even if it actually isn't. Better to be safe than sorry imo.
Short answer: Yes
No! They will also get all the other details they could get from you. Its not just an editor its online keylogger😂
I hope not, that would be quite counterproductive if they want the AI to write good code
If they train on my code. Good luck Gemini
But does it have Vim motions?
And can it run Doom?
its based on vscode so yes.
Imagine a million dollar deal and this shows up
Error opening workspace: IDX is currently experiencing increased load. Please come back and try again later.
Imagine you are given an urgent task and you can't open your workspace due to service issues.
@@DmytroZhyvonitko ahh you can just load the code base from the backup/repo on vscode
Watch google kill the project 6 months after this video
"Powered by Gemini"
-No thanks I'm okay
Vue specifically excluded?
Blackbox on vscode is a charm
no, copilot is.
Codeium baby
Claude Even Better
So like vscode with copilot?
can't wait for this to be abandonned without notice 💜
How many days until Google discontinues it?
Less than 1 year
Till they get enough data to train their code assistant
Stop shoving AI into everythin
You’re howling into the void.
AI is not a new feature, but now it is a bullet world to sell more "value". Create something, inject "AI," and sell too. Don't fight with this; next year, the bullet world will change to a Biological CPU or Quantum Computing.
@@TesterAnimal1 responding kinda disproves that
@@rumfordc Nah, we're all in the void here.
Ai Hype train
I am using IDX and I am happy! Just only small detail, please enable at least 20GB instand 10GB per workspace!
Best workspace for me , been using it . I even made my first bank software with it
Mind sharing for what bank so I can avoid that one?
@@binary_gaming113be nice 😂😭😭
@@binary_gaming113lmao 😂
😂😂@@binary_gaming113
@@binary_gaming113 lol😂
"If you don't pay for the product, you are the product"
What about vscode?
@@tapq2004 same
I tried it for my machine learning projects and it is so great and similar to vscode and I love it.
em isn't that just vs code online with custom extensions? Just askin
Does it work in Firefox?
Yes, I have used IDX for a while in Firefox.
When will you shut it down?
please don't discontinue this google 😭🙏
Now we have Googled vscode! the missing codeoss wrapper we never asked and never needed.
This is interesting and impressive but it might not stay long. For those looking for something industry-specific, Immersive Translate now allows you to customize your own AI expert, it also allows translations in the technology field become more accurate and professional.
When will it be discontinued?
It uses the VS Code’s Web based editor 😅
When will this project be discontinued?
What‘s the privacy like? Can you expect semi-critical business code to not be fed to Google servers and Gemini?
I love Project IDX so far. It's like Codespaces but completely free and have AI integration
Not Gemini😭😭😭
To everyone saying its just like VS Code clearly have no idea what they're talking about. IDX is more like Replit. Your entire dev environment is on a nix vm running on the cloud, and can run on your browser.
Maybe you are not aware that vs code has a web IDE 😅
@@hilmyakatsuki1665 Where you can setup an environment, install dependencies and run code all on the browser? Where can I find this I'd love to try it if its true
Thank you for accepting me in the project idx after 7 month 🙏
Since I started new project in Project IDX I decided to write every line of code in it
I am CS student, i will try this out!
Here before Google kills it.
"We need more data to train our AI models"
I’ve always wondered why we haven’t used LLMs to show a more understandable response to error in code instead of some intensely cryptic error message.
And then google comes up with this video.
I love Project IDX, but when it comes to using it on a mobile device, like a phone, the UI isn't really mobile friendly.
It that Google's version of Visual Studio Code? (VSCode)
Will it support vim mode and motions?
What's the countdown timeframe for this showing up on Killed by Google (Google Graveyard)?
"Anywhere in the universe"
"Imagine the server is 3 light years away."
something running in the browser is not something to flex
hard disagree, web apps are useful for certain people. If i wanted to, I could pull up with an android tablet and connect an external keyboard and it would still have all the functionality of desktop coding because of the fact that I can access IDX from almost any browser, and still have tools like node, bash…
Project IDX as is github dev right? right? RIGHT?
Is it going to be opensource ?
As a programmer this seems pretty interesting and might try it out but never gonna make the switch from my current editor cause I can already see IDX getting discontinued not even 6 months after launch
In the near future after they got all the data they need :
Oops your library can't be larger than 1Go, you have to upgrade to premium it's just
50$ a month
or you can't see your code anymore.
I see an opportunity for more job cuts at Google.
I'm now using Chromebook for development, it's a life change. And Chromebooks are so efficient I have so much battery life and low consume
This is how the future looks like
That's how the "future" looked like 50 years ago; People used terminals (Chromebooks) to connect to large and powerful server.
bot ahh comment
@@EngerJimenezthis is so true 😭 once the personal computer (PC) era came around power efficiency went 📉
@@EngerJimenez lets go back to the stone age then hahaha
@@golangthebest7746 History repeats itself.
VS code copy, just gemini extra
The fact that they claim that the is "+20 templates" when it doesn't cover even all the js framework is weird
Is it open source 🧐
Like VS Code
I remember a similar video from Google, just a different use case/audience. Stadia. RIP.
It will be great with desktop version.
my fav. java is supported or not?
This is one of the most beautiful presentations from Google period.❤
This is more than just a code editor... This is a fork of code-oss
It will be very convenient for those who don't have a laptop like me❤❤❤
Love this Design here
The mention of AI is exactly why I won't use it. Just like Samsung's headline this year "Galaxy AI is here", no more Samsung for me.
A year and we are still waiting for andriod studio
I have been using it for the last 2 months, and it's great
Oh this is cool, cool as Stadia
Android Studio can do like half of that
so its not like vsCode, you can not download idx ?
Yep, it's online-only.
@@paulzarudnev sadly.
Let's bet under this comment.
How much time do yoh think it will take google to discontinue this new project? 😅
My guess is 1 year.
Heyy i have a problem ,Error opening workspace: We’ve detected suspicious activity on one of your workspaces. Please contact support 1 for further assistance. Can. You help me to resolve this . I cannot open it in all of my device
Helpp
Where's the part where this isn't a new model of information harvester
Does it have a vim mode?
I really like the idea of enabling android for such dev tools.
I’d love to use this. Specially since I don’t code anymore and don’t want to have to be downloading or updating any tool. But I can’t feel the emails to export my code because Google is discounting this by September 20- -
when we can sync our setting and extensions ?
Ye but does it support vim?
Only reason anybody would use this, is if it does what Roblox does.
It should have a "plug and play" functionality to it. By default it should FORCE you into using a certain paradigm. It should force standardization.
It shouldn't require a whole afternoon to setup your build environment.
Screw compatibility. People will only use this if it replaces garbage like cmake and standardizes everything while making it easy to use.
Eitherway Im actually kinda hyped for this.
This is a code editor. Also known as a vscode reskin with preinstalled codium 💀
I hope it doesn’t end up in "killed by google" website...
project IDX extension in vcode
It's a good project. We are using it with my students, but last week we have problems in all our projects using express
Me knowing that I'll be using emacs instead
"You don't have that feature yet?" Wait how many programmers from this earths outside our planet?
Does this include support for things such as LUAU id like to see more diversity and I’d definitely also like to see a fully supported software rather than a in browser code editor IDX seems promising but requires more sustainable systems
Giving AI access to your projects DOM and having it virtualise and simplify your tasks is really all we require if not educating us on things it knows for certain
Now a days Google's these kind of product became a prank.
What does IDX stand for?
Built on NixOS thing for more complexity, add with more security constrains !
Ground zero, from the bottom to the top 🔝 Al Gemini ♊ 2.0 now you know 10/4😊❤
Bruh I just got heavily invested in nvim. This field is so overwhelming
tried it recently it's amazing
this is the future
voice of andrei??
One year less of IDX before google kills it