Vocal Coach Reacts to Demi Lovato's Best LIVE Vocals (Technique Analysis)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- Work with me: www.masteryourv...
Sign Up for Music Theory for Singers: www.masteryour...
My other channels:
Simple Blessings: / @simpleblessings
Healthy Minimalist Mom: / singermom2012
Watch all my videos about BELTING: • All About Belting
Support & Breath Support Playlist: • Support & Breath Control
Warm-Ups Playlist: • Warm-Ups
28-Day Challenge - Expand Your Range: • Expand Your Vocal Rang...
Listen to my weekly podcast on iTunes: itunes.apple.c... (also available on Google Play and iHeart Radio - "Freya's Singing Tips")
Connect with me on:
*** Twitter: @MusicalFreya
*** Instagram: / freyacaseymusic
*** Facebook: / freyacaseymusic
*** Pinterest: / stbingen
#HowToSingBetter #FreyaCasey #SingingTips
This is a really old video, I think you deserve to see a 2016-2018 vocals video
Up
My opinion which is not professional but she is not over pushing in every performance. Emotion can play a powerful role in vocal qualities. She’s a singer who connects fully to what she is singing. The only person that truly knows if she is pushing is Demi herself. Look at other videos not just this one and then it may change your mind on her technique
She pushes a lot. Its fact. Demi is not a great singer
In 2013 she got her tonsils taken out it changed the tone and color of her voice
An girl from little mix got her tonsils taken out too and her voice becomes more lighter. Somethin that isnt "normal" to happen. So... Definitely this isnt the most important thing that affect demi's voice.
@@suggarberry7293if you check out the last concert before her tonsils got taken out and the concert right after it, you will hear the difference in tone and you will also see how she struggles to sing with her previous technique.
I haven't seen one good Pop Crush "best vocals" video. Check out a newer, fan-made video and be surprised
Tobias Henrik Brendon Urie's is good
I understand why vocal coaches believe people shouldn’t belt out big notes, but in reality that is how so many singers have fun with things and show emotion. When she tried to show the difference between Demi’s method and her own, her version didn’t sound bad really, but it didn’t have the proper emotion. She sounded like she was doing a musical play version. That’s not the type of music Demi sings. there’s different ways your voice can change when singing to match the occasion. That wasn’t it. That’s why people who think like that tend to sound so bland when they sing, because while they’d sound amazing doing something like “somewhere over the rainbow”, they fall short and miss the mark on songs you hear on the radio.
Have you not heard her sing father? This is what aggravates me about you tubers this are really good . She can hold out all of those notes and she has proven it before.
Father has been sung after she improved a lot !
Almost all of these clips are before 2015. Demi has improved a lot since 2016
Demi Lovato has suffered with eating disorders for years and this was the reason for losing her voice at times. Purging does damage to your vocal chords
3:52..... EXCUSE ME?!! Not supported?!!!! It was way more supported than the one you tried to make....
and don’t get me started on 6:57
@@melaniebean608 You made me click and watch it again!! 😭😭😂😂😂
Fantard lol
It's not supported.
Not supported
I have to disagree with the Stone Cold part.There’s a reason Stone Cold is hard to sing, even though the technique you showed might be better technically, it takes the emotion away.Demi’s voice and her emotions intersect and of that means pushing, then so be it.
Emotion is not a technique. Emotion dousnt save the voice. Singing and performing are two separate things that go hand in hand. And performing is emotion based that's where you connect with your audience not the singing wich is technical based. Without one neither one can work.
I'm not a pro but I think her voice is just like this and that's what makes her charm...
Tbf this compilation really wasn't the best showcase of Demi's voice. Her voice has definitely changed over time, whether it be due to technique or other factors. For a lot of her career Demi was also using quite hard drugs, so I'm not sure if that had affected her voice in any significant way. Thankfully after her near overdose she's now sober again. I'd recommend checking out a fanmade version instead of PopCrush's as 2017-2018 was one of the best years vocally for her and this video didn't show that x
May I add that she was mainly using for the early stages of her career like 2009-2012, and was sober for 5 years until she released her song 'Sober' where she'd confessed that she relapsed x
shaneywaney2 True. She was 17 in 2009.
@@gillianomotoso328 Yeah it's awful how young she started using. She said it herself in her documentary that she was 17 the first time x
She also suffered from
Bulimia
You have to see another videos like 2017-2018 she's amazing
First of all, she DID support the high note at the 3:43 and the belts on hello as well, she was just chesty, the way you sing is with a heady mix. And second, the "now" vocals are all from 2015 and that wasn't her best year vocally, watch the 2018 or 2017 performances. nice video but stop being rude wtf with the thumbnail.
Supported and chest-resonant C#5 which gives it power.
Matias - Vocals omg look who i found here lmao
That was my exact thought. Every time she went ro show the "right" way it was always heady and never used her chest.
@@jordanranker5508 That is because Freya is an opera singer.
@@annisaurus that's what annoys me, just because she "sings" opera she thinks that that's the only right way to sing and it's clearly not.
pop crush is trash, react to a fan made best vocals from 2018
Ive seen a ton of other vocal coaches react to the same video and all of them were praising Demi's voice🙃
Each singer has a particular tone and a different way to control her notes, it seems to me that you were very hard and judged her vocal ability a lot, regardless of whether her style is not your favorite or you think her notes have no support, she has made it incredible in this time by the way she operated on the tonsils in 2013 and also in many of these performances she was sick bu her voice is very good, there are many singers who do not really hold their notes and does not have a technique and a little more. Do not judge an artist by a video that they did a while ago.
Dude, shes simply pointing out unhealthy technique. It's clear demi pushes her voice , its fact. Deal with it
@@I_Am_Midnight-i she improves a lot and one of her stronger influences is Christina Aguilera so you can see the clear connection between those tso awesome singers.
Alright kids, let's keep in mind that Demi has dealt w/ drugs which could have some affect on her voice and in 2013 she got her tonsils taken out, she gets sick a lot as well and puberty.. her voice is obviously going to change over time....
Oh and her vocal range: C3, BB5 & EB7 = 4 octaves (which is the same amount of octaves as Selena Gomez and Taylor Swift combined) 1 note and a semi tone.... js
You're the first "vocal coach" to disrespect Demi's voice. Delete this😂
Also you do realize the vocal change if from her tonsils getting taken in 2014.
Also watch Tristan Parades' video on this same video.
For your information Demi has delt with eating disorders and substance abuse for years so a lot of what your saying is right for most singers but for Demi you need to realize that some for the problem with Demi’s voice. Is from the damage from eating disorders and substance abuse
So?
@@Mimi-nr6jx bitch what do you mean "so"??
@@Mimi-nr6jx bulimia fucks your voice from the acid and constant use, yours makes her voice weak over time. drugs?? do i need to explain?
Lol her voice changed cause she changed her style, her voice is still bright and light, also ..that c#5 was supported. This video is so wrong.
I'm a singer and I can sing jazz, pop, opera, country, folk, soul, blues and more. And technique dousnt determine the style FAct lady Gaga is a prime example of using the classical technique in pop and she is this generation golden girl
What an eye opening video. I realized how much I'm pushing my vocals by hearing her. I thought it sounded cool but boy is it harsh. Thanks so much!
i noticed how this woman says resonance is to the limits.
I think you should've done more research back then she took a lot of drugs and it damaged her voice after that she stopped and her voice became better and her being breathy is to make the audience feel the emotion in her voice
Dude , doesnt make a difference. Demi PUSHES her sound, its fact. Deal with it. Her technique simply lacks .
ByRTD yO Demi “PuSHes” her sound 😂😂💀 wtf
@@I_Am_Midnight-i BUT WHY DO YOU CAREEEE? Lmfao
Emotion is not a technique and dousnt make the way your singing healthy. Bring out the emotion through your performance not your technique. Singing and performing are two completely diffrent things.
@@I_Am_Midnight-i nah
This video is a mess. How are you not gonna research her entire career vocals and claim her vocals are declining? She had a rough patch for a few years due to tonsil removal.
I mean 10 years down the road she still amazing tho and better
Yes, 2015 was Demi's change in the voice, she had surgery in her vocal cords
I guess she just doesn’t like Demi that’s it 🤷🏻♂️
I’ve always thought that whoever out this video together really did her an injustice. You’ll notice that all the vocals you really love are her original songs while the ones she “struggled” with were covers. There are so many more shining examples of her best vocals.
At 7 minute mark... you lost me. The stone cold performance is supported tho. You are the first vocal coach I have heard say that it is not.... I’m not trying to be rude but I’m just saying you are wrong.
It’s really not. It’s painful to listen to because it’s so strained
@@ITSMERlVER since I have been studying music I can most definitely say it is supported . It is her style. No it’s not the healthiest but it is supported. She can hold that for hours ... it’s supported with air from her diaphragm. She can hold that for long periods of time. It might not be your favorite style of singing but just because you don’t like how it sounds doesn’t mean it’s not supported. Make sure you know what you are talking about before trying to tell me I’m wrong sweet cheeks 🥰
@@ITSMERlVER there is a difference in you not liking it and it not being supported. You have a preference that you don’t like the way she sings. BUT it doesn’t mean it’s not supported .
How dare you say she’s screaming? Like seriously, you say your professional but you don’t even know what twang is?
She doesn't even know the meaning of "sob"!!!
Lol... belting is screaming. It’s just supported. And when it’s not, it’s strained.. and Demi strains
@@ITSMERlVER Demi doesn't strain, look at any of her 2020 preformances
Your version of a supported note is weak and soft where as Demi’s voice is powerful and Jesus she belts yes she takes her voice to the limits because her voice is so good so why waste that talent DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING GOOD TO SAY ABOUT HER 😠😠😠
Your definition of powerful is a pushed high volume nasal sound? Cause that's all demi's voice is lol
Is it by force?
You need to react to demi lovato live vs studio update 2017-2018
You take the fun out of singing, litrerally vocal coach channel I've ever seen. Have a bit of fun.
yeah... but i think that's the point in her channel, taking singing technic seriously
@@gabciafangirl7691 but even her technique stuff is wrong. Like the supported C#5s
I really enjoyed her analysis I feel like it makes the music more enjoyable when you know what the singers are doing...it’s like you can hear their REAL voice and what they are doing to AFFECT their sound...I just feel like that’s where their artistic choice lies...
Demi supported the c#5 in Lala land lady. And her rasp doesn’t mean she wasn’t supporting her notes in stone cold cuz she was. You really need to know what you’re talking about and you raise your larynx so....
This video does not come even close to show casing her best vocals in recent years.
Please react to react to the newer one and father by her. You will be surprised demi lovato is one of the best singers there is in this generation.
I would love to see you reacting to her singing "Father"
If you guys just want complements & shallow analysis, go to another channel🙄
She's not a Stan, she's a coach!
Shut the fuck up lmao literally no other vocal coach agrees with ANYTHING this woman is saying.
👏👏👏
@@F0URL34FCL0V3R All the other “vocal coaches” just want subscribers. They make sure to never say anything negative about a celebrity because they don’t want to anger the fans.. This woman has major guts to actually share her honest opinion (which is absolutely true whether you like it or not)
Amazing analysis very informative!!! A lot of people are talking about how you should have picked a better video to show her technique but that would disregard the point of you analyzing the good and the bad if there is only good technique on display. If the videos were completely solid examples of singing such as Dimash or Beyoncé then it would be difficult to give any feedback on fundamentally healthy technique. Also some people talk about emotion and preference yet demonstrating FULL control over the entirety of ANY instrument which includes voice is extremely difficult and pretty rare so as much as I think people like to believe celebrities always choose to do things stylistically such as push or strain or tighten, they should know that most of the time it’s truly just healthy habits and imperfect technique.
P.S. style is usually something that branches off after and from good technique and control
I 100% agree emotion is not a technique. Emotion dousnt save the voice. Singing and performing are two separate things that go hand in hand. And performing is emotion based that's where you connect with your audience not the singing wich is technical based. Without one neither one can work. And your technique dousnt change just because you change styles I can sing nearly every style and my technique always remains the same
Emotion is not a technique. Emotion dousnt save the voice. Singing and performing are two separate things that go hand in hand. And performing is emotion based that's where you connect with your audience not the singing wich is technical based. Without one neither one can work. Also technique dousnt change just because the genre does. I can sing nearly every genre yet my technique never changes ever I may alter the way say some words or my tone but never my instrument that never changes.
"How to kill you voice" more like. "How to sing with emotion"
Pop crush do the worst vocal videos, you should try reacting to one made by a fan or watch a live performance
Amazing job Freya! Thanks a lot! At least someone powerful here telling the truth with a point with not fears to express herself freely. There's a lot to learn!
I think she's just shitting on Demi at this point .... "oh she's not supported... oh shes's almost yelling..... oh that was good but ..... But what ?? Demi's a Queen why you judging her stylistic choice of singing???
the reason her voice changed is because she had tonsil surgery back then in 2013 so her voice become darker
Nope, she still pushes.
Queen Demi❤️❤️❤️👑
These are no where near her best live vocals the video you watched was created in 2015 her technique has changed quite a bit since then
5:16 was ON pitch honey... hahaha it was just because the progession changed but she stayed in the same
Definitely NOT on pitch....
Sterling Lacaden yes it was, she just wanted to do something a little different
Dipping into B4 is NOT on pitch just because she corrected to an in tune C afterwards that's why Freya mentioned intonation. Also someone can be both strained and resonant. The guitarist helped her by shying away from playing the IV until she started correcting and it clearly was a mistake and NOT stylistic because she goes to the B after the C later. The C was to build tension and the B was to resolve but also delay the cadence so if you start with B and then go to C it loses that build up a little when you get back down to B and try and go for the cadence. And Freya's tonal center was probably thrown off because of the intonation because it wasn't supposed to be there in the chord so the C sounded off even though it was technically correct given the accompaniment corrected to the IV. I like Demi but I'm not gonna delude myself into thinking she doesn't make mistakes. Also in the original she's supposed to stay on the B and move chromatically to the Cadence of A to G according to the music video. Of course in live performance you can change it but it must be planned and it did not sound planned.
Sterling Lacaden it was a variant of the key signature! Omgggg
diego LEME welp believe whatever you want I guess, btw a “variant” of the key signature explains literally nothing it actually has no context here...
There's a big difference in the style of singing pop music vs classic. I believe this vocal coach is very classically trained. Nothing wrong with that. However, when you are a pop/rock/r&b/mainstream whatever singer, you have to bend and break some rules to get across the emotion you're trying to portray. No one wants to hear these emotional ass songs Demi sings from someone with a classical or "healthy" technique. They want the nitty gritty. At the end of the day, these stars are here to share their talents, and profit off of it. Not hold back and fit into a box. That's the beauty and vulnerability of this style of music.
Anyone can sing the way they want. It is great to protect your voice, but every now and then, you just gotta let go and sing your heart out. (it sounds better too)
I really don’t get you like for the stone cold performance you said she wasn’t focused but she clearly was she had her eyes closed she was focused
I had to dislike, not because this wasn't fair but because I like how she changed her singing and I feel this fits her more, yes It is a more difficult version of singing but if I try I can sing the same songs without forcing it. There are also multiple factors that changed her voice over the years, she is simply singing with a darker voice then before where you explained it was very bright and focused and I believe that she specifically is singing with a darker voice. That is simply my opinion.
I like Demi a lot, I haven't watch this entire video yet, but based on what I have heard from Demi in recent years in public events and award shows, etc, she does push her voice too hard. It is a sustainable way to sing.
Rosannasfriend not Necessarily most of the time when she sing on live tv and stuff like that she is always sick if you watch her at her live concerts like her tell me you love me tour she sounds way less nervous and sick
Another reason why it wasnt a great reaction is because quite a few of the "push to the limit" clips are from shows where the focus is more on the presentation, or she has been touring. Anyones voice gets a little off while touring
P.s. your also not doing a good job imitating her
Pps. All her Walmart sound tracks are autotuned
LOVE your informative reaction videos!
I love singing coaches that are physiologists in their spare time. When you sing the line Demi does it sounds zzzzz.....thats why most vocal coaches aren't great artists. Demi exudes feeling and heart...that lack feeling you demonstrate doesn't pull in the listener...Demi does, over and over.
Ummm...fast forward to her most recent live performances...she is stronger and better than ever.
She "goes to the edge" in her a sleep now. She does it effortlessly. so you are wrong.....her voice is actually stronger.
Imagine most vocal teachers in the 80s didnt like Steve Perry? The title of the channel should be "How to preserve your voice so the song nobody wants to hear you sing, sounds the same the 100th time you sing it as it did the first time."
.
I’m sorry but did this bish just call Demi’s voice USED UP AND WHO SAYS DEMI DOESNT HAVE CONTROL YOUR REALLY MAKING ME ANGRY RN 😡😡😡😡😡
Its fact, deal with it
You clearly are a fan of Selena
dimash - love is like a dream
Too much judging , just enjoy along.
React to her 2018 vocalssss
GIRL YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOIRE TALKING ABOUT 😂
Can you react to Sohyang? Queen of mixed voice and supported high notes! "Arirang Alone", "Lean on me" and more. 😍
Great analysis, Freya. Thank you for this and for reminding us how much care and attention should be brought on our vocal chords xx
Hi Freya! She’s listed as one of those four-octave vocalists. What do you make of that?
Wow what a great review Freya, that was just so informative and made so much sense once you explained it, I love you walking the walk and using your voice as an example as you explain things, you have an incredible voice, thank you girl
I have to say I watched this again, and it's one of the best reactions I think I've seen , it was so comprehensive, thank you again.
React to Demi Lovato Anyone live !! ✨🇧🇷
Please check out other vocal coaches guys, this is not right 😂
Oh i think youre an OK teacher and for me OHK means reallllyy Good, just a little closed minded regarding the voice in general. Just my opinion though i could be wrong
And with stone cold... her transitions that is the point it’s supposed to sound emotional ... this is her style ... I just don’t understand it .
Emotion is not a technique. Emotion dousnt save the voice. Singing and performing are two separate things that go hand in hand. And performing is emotion based that's where you connect with your audience not the singing wich is technical based. Without one neither one can work. Also technique dousnt change just because the genre does. I can sing nearly every genre yet my technique never changes ever I may alter the way say some words or my tone but never my instrument that never changes.
@@rosiegiesler4705 cool, good for you.
@@rosiegiesler4705 I agree emotions is not a technique. But would you rather have someone who has great technique but can’t connect to the audience? No you would not. You would much rather have emotion. I am a singer and I have had plenty of vocal coaches who have told me your emotions overpower your technique because who honestly cares about her technique ? They would much rather connect to her emotions. That is what makes a singer good at what they do
@@troyhundley69 no of course not watching someone on stage with no emotion or ability to perform is boring. But what I mean is they both work hand in hand and to have a good performance you have to have good technique for sustainability for any type of singer. Because with no technical and an ok natural voice your voice will only last you so long and you know what is as bad as ono emotional intensity watching a person who dousnt know how to use their voice stand on stage and shreak and scream as if that makes them sound better ( brutal honestly watching bad singers is not fun and as much as I would be polite and praise them I would still be cringing inside) . You cant have one without the other to create a good performance. And a really excellent performer the legends have both and that little seasoning to make it sparkle.
Also technique isnt about other people it's not about what they can see or hear it's about what lasts. They are both as important as each other you wouldnt watch a ballet dancer at the royal ballet dance and with no technique because it would look shit they could have emotion yest but it would look shit if I was just leaping in the air.
Demi has improved a lot now, she is not that pushy anymore and her mix is headier which gave her more ease, you just have to watch more recent performances.
And you should take a look at SoHyang in the next reaction, "Everyone" ( vimeo.com/249195615 ) would be a very good choice, is really a masterpiece and vocal coachs don't react to it that much, you'll be completely amazed, i give you my word.
how old are you? you have a lot of old school views. did you actually go to school for this? your comments are wildly inaccurate and dinosaur aged way of thinking. look up some *new* *real* research.
So clear that you dont like her ahhaha
It's not that deep💀
Please do Christina Grimmie
That was difficult listening to... Not your analysis, that was great! But the vocals... Not sure how this is her best vocals? She can do so much better!
2019 vocals are going to be way better you will be shocked adele quality
React to father or when we were young !!!!!!!!
Thank you for actually analyzing and not just sitting there and watching like a lot of other people do
🙄🙄 bye
I think I know who disliked the video.
Air fans that blow.
Fresa, watch out.... There are fans out there.... They have claws-and sharp teeth!
I just discovered your channel and I looove what you're doing :)
It could be interesting to do reactions to Christina Aguilera's live :)
this vid is really old and that wasn't her best vocals tho
So basically what youre saying is dont actually use your voice.... got it
well this was annoying...
Can you do Amy Lee from Evanescence
Sorry, but a technically perfect performance is just boring. The video you reacted to is a compilation of every song's climax. Listening to it for 6 or 7 minutes straight may (or may not) be painful to the ears, but that's just because that's the part where the emotion gets to you. Demi did pop rock in their early years and singing how you suggested is not how to sing rock music. You also mentioned about their breathiness, but breathiness may be a stylistic choice that makes the performance more emotional and raw. Again, if every performance is technically perfect, it is boring.
This is so bad
I mean the video
And the lady talking
Hey
Can you do an analysis on Lana del reys best live vocals
Thanks
Non existent
I cant...firstly your some parts mix wasnt a mix, most of it was just head voice. Ypu did have some good points but there was more bad, im noooo professional but i dont need to be to know when someone is talking $#*$. Yes demi adds alot of weight to her voice sometimes even though her natural voice in my OPINION is more of an equal mixture between weighty and light hence its power. And just so you know, in most of those videos demi placed her voice elsewhere in comparison to your nasal placement. Also it would be less annoying of some you vocal coaches did some deep research and analysis of the singers before you come on here and blab off the top the little that you know and it would also be nice if you(and by you i mean other vocal coaches) were more open to the fact that there are other techniques apart from the ones that you use or know of. Yes some techniques tires the voice alot faster than some but they wont "KILL" your voice. Just so you know i agree with your point regarding preserving the voice which i assume meant keeping the voice from tiring so quickly especially when you have to perform multiple times back to back and im not hating on you or anything and leave these singers alone, its not thatvthey dont know how to sing "properly" that is with " "healthy" technique, most are more concerned with expression and connection to their audience, some of you people should try it sometime (im guilty of being a technique geek too). Im not saying to go blow out youre voice, just divery your concerns a little from technique and connect more with your true feelings and their link with the music, youd be surprised, why do you think demi and alot of other singers are so reputable in the music industry.👋
This video doesn’t show demi potential and shes known for being such a beast vocalist, her voice has gotten better you seem very bitter with demi
There's no one more calm and rational than Fran. There's nothing bitter about her in this video. I understand you don't like what she's saying, but that doesn't mean she's bitter.
@@Rosannasfriend I just feel like if your going to react to someone's voice look at the date of the video and find a more recent video.
So many people come to Demis defense but the amount of thinning and flatness to her voice in just 3 years is abnormal. Does she sound awesome still? Yes but doesn't excuse faults in technique
5:16 - A flat C5
Everyone has different ways the sing. There isn’t one perfect way to do it in my opinion.
What a bunch of nonsense. Yea, everyone has a particular style or tone but the FUNDAMENTALS have to be there.
1) Support
2) right closure
3) resonance
4) Open throat
5) No pressure on the voice
Etc
You cant properly sing if you dont have all of those. Now, go back to the kitchen pls.
Lovato stans are always big mad when you point on that loud & high singing doesn't automatically mean good singing
as she is reacting to old clips of demi doing covers
coitada! nunca será!!
tenta dnv pq escolheu a cantora errada
I don't know, I'm a crazy Lovatic, she is my favourite singer
But let's keep it real, what she said is true
no hate but my headphones were on full volume and i think i am deaf in one ear :D
i think its from all the drugs more than anything tbh which is sad
That comment was unnecessary
@@Aggiefan9942 not really i think it's the thing thats changed it the most
ִ do you know about aging ?
And she had a vocal surgery!
@@lilwombat I know Demi personally
Shes a mediocre singer...pop has lowered the bar tremendously
Ha shes in top 5 best singers
you should’ve done demi lovatos real best vocals video (it’s called that)