I tried not to be too specific on when each event takes place, besides Sonic Forces for, since I don’t think it matters too much one each event happens. Though I like to think Sonic and Caliburn would either have their falling out during Sonic Generations or Lost World with sonic colors being where the tensions start to appear. Depending on how early Shadow gets the sacred sword, maybe he could have a full adventure with the blade? I’ll let you imagination fill out the rest. If I ever make this a full blown what if, I’ll probably be more specific on when each event takes place.
Sonic: “Why do you care about my love life, man?” Caliburn: “Your friend Cream introduced me to this strange modern phenomenon known as SHIPPING. And ever since then, I found myself compelled to bring people together.” Sonic: “Can’t you just watch a soap opera?” Caliburn: “In case you forgotten, I am a sword.”
I do agree Shadow would be considered worthy and Sonic's morals would clash with Caliburn's However I dont think Sonic would even be deemed unworthy, Caliburn respects Sonic far too much despite their differences for that to the point he was willing to give Sonic the crown, so I believe he simply would ask Sonic for them to part ways after a particularly heated exchange and Sonic would agree to that, he wants Caliburn to be free too after all
Honestly, that bit at the end where he accidentally leads to the creation of infinite honestly gives me the idea to allow infinite/zero to wield him for a time in an attempt to make amends and possibly guide the jackal along the right path? I feel like that would be a very fun character dynamic, one person who feels completely inadequate in terms of his status as a weak or strong person, and another who has seen the consequences of being too rigid in upholding black and white morality would be interesting foils to each other, as well as complementing zero's prestablished ability with the blade. Also, how do you think ascalon would get along with sage? I honestly think sage would at least benefit from having another figure in her life who's also an artificial intelligence/creation yet is not inherently aligned with eggman, showing her that even machines can change (assuming she didn't already learned that from reviewing metals' shenanigans during the events of Sonic heroes)
I'm really disappointed that Shadow the Ultimate Lifeform doesn't use sword in Sonic the Hedgehog series anymore. (After Shadow the Hedgehog 2005 video game, and Sonic & the Black Knight)
I mean Caliburn chose to give sonic when nickname “Nave The Hedgehog” just because Sonic mildly annoyed him. This sword is not above a bit of holier-than-thou trash talking.
@@ThomasFangthe-j3d Speaking of, I’m curious how the chaos emeralds would affect Caliburn. Unless sonic brought the rest of the sacred swords with him, his Excalibur form likely wouldn’t be an option anymore, but maybe the chaos emeralds could act as a substitute? Otherwise perhaps the power of the chaos emerald give Caliburn a crystal emerald appearance?
calaburn also mate showed up in The murder of sonic the hedgehog celebrating Amy‘s birthday and also he could stop sonic broke the paradox prism in Sonic prime👍🏻
Honestly, I’m not sure. I could either see the sword’s blade into pure light, kind of like the light construct Super Sonic is able to make in Sonic Frontiers thanks to his cyber energy. Otherwise, perhaps the sword takes on a crystal form to match the emeralds that is super charging it. Or of course, if we want to keep the Excalibur sonic form around, you could just say the chaos emerald act as a substitute for the Sacred Swords
Well I love your good work and your theory is very good. So may I ask you what if Tails has Took Robo Fiona to go freedom fighter Secret base after first meet? Well Robo Fiona she is no longer work with serve Eggman empire and Robo follow love with Tails. will Fiona Fox keep with Sonic heart and how freedom fighter react to Robo Fiona. That’s gonna be super cool Robo Fiona and Fiona Fox become a twin sister!
I don't believe that Shadow is worthy to use the sword because he is a damn anti-hero . Shadow is a 100% anti-hero . Caliburn doesn't choose anti-heroes , you can't convince me otherwise .
Regardless of his status as an antihero, like I said in the video, I believe Caliburn and Shadow would agree on several points. Both of them believe in using their power to protect the innocent, even if that means taking down their opponents permanently. So I do believe that Caliburn would consider Shadow worthy. Also, from Caliburn’s perspective, Sonic could be just as much of an anti-hero since back in the medieval times if you were a warrior who served no king you weren’t recognized as a hero. If anything Shadow might be seen as more of a traditional due to his connections with G.U.N.
@@comicfan1324 Didn't Caliburn name Sonic "the new Arthur" at the end of the game . And I am convinced Caliburn would hate G.U.N and some politicians because in the case he finds out about the events of the Space Colony Ark that happened 50-ish years in the past and it's consequences being the events of Sonic Adventure 2 and Shadow the Hedgehog spin-off game , Caliburn would despise Rouge the Bat for being a petty thief and Omega for being a mindless killing machine with out a noble goal . He would be more likely see Knuckles or Silver or Blaze as better alternatives in case Sonic stops being worthy to use legendary blade .
@@Vrabsher_-Supreme_Perhinther- True, Caliburn would be disgusted if he learned what G.U.N did. But that’s a BIG if. It’s not all knowing after all, so he would only know what happened if Shadow told him. As for Silver & Blaze, for the same reason as Sonic, Caliburn would believe Silver can’t do what’s needs to be done. Yes, Sonic tried to kill Sonic once, but he very quickly came to the conclusion killing someone, even to save the world, is wrong. Caliburn would disagree. Although, Blaze on the other hand is very willing to kill her enemies. Blaze & Caliburn would be pretty much perfect partners, but due to their dimensional distance, it’s unlikely they’d cross paths (outside of Colors DS & Generations).
I tried not to be too specific on when each event takes place, besides Sonic Forces for, since I don’t think it matters too much one each event happens. Though I like to think Sonic and Caliburn would either have their falling out during Sonic Generations or Lost World with sonic colors being where the tensions start to appear.
Depending on how early Shadow gets the sacred sword, maybe he could have a full adventure with the blade? I’ll let you imagination fill out the rest.
If I ever make this a full blown what if, I’ll probably be more specific on when each event takes place.
Mister sword is just going to annoy sonic until finally goes out on a date with Amy.
Sonic: “Why do you care about my love life, man?”
Caliburn: “Your friend Cream introduced me to this strange modern phenomenon known as SHIPPING. And ever since then, I found myself compelled to bring people together.”
Sonic: “Can’t you just watch a soap opera?”
Caliburn: “In case you forgotten, I am a sword.”
@comicfan1324 Ah yes caliburn the shipper. I'd imagine he gets along well with blaze.
I love the idea of Shadow and Caliburn having debates after a battle of whether to kill their opponent or not. That just sounds hilarious 😂
I do agree Shadow would be considered worthy and Sonic's morals would clash with Caliburn's
However I dont think Sonic would even be deemed unworthy, Caliburn respects Sonic far too much despite their differences for that to the point he was willing to give Sonic the crown, so I believe he simply would ask Sonic for them to part ways after a particularly heated exchange and Sonic would agree to that, he wants Caliburn to be free too after all
I love to imagine someone like Tails or Knuckles taking Calibur during Eggman's world domination in Forces
Honestly, that bit at the end where he accidentally leads to the creation of infinite honestly gives me the idea to allow infinite/zero to wield him for a time in an attempt to make amends and possibly guide the jackal along the right path? I feel like that would be a very fun character dynamic, one person who feels completely inadequate in terms of his status as a weak or strong person, and another who has seen the consequences of being too rigid in upholding black and white morality would be interesting foils to each other, as well as complementing zero's prestablished ability with the blade.
Also, how do you think ascalon would get along with sage? I honestly think sage would at least benefit from having another figure in her life who's also an artificial intelligence/creation yet is not inherently aligned with eggman, showing her that even machines can change (assuming she didn't already learned that from reviewing metals' shenanigans during the events of Sonic heroes)
Awesome Sonic,Shadow And Caliburn Video 💙🖤❤️🤍💛
I'm really disappointed that Shadow the Ultimate Lifeform doesn't use sword in Sonic the Hedgehog series anymore. (After Shadow the Hedgehog 2005 video game, and Sonic & the Black Knight)
I think Silver and Caliburn would come to the same conclusion at their relationship like how Sonic and him did in this what if
Shadow would definitely be more worthy of Caliburn in the long run.
I loved this episode!, and honestly I would also like to see a continuation, to the, What If? Eggman Gave Up series.
Wow I didn’t expect Caliburn agree with Shadow call Infinite weak pathetic warrior!😮
I mean Caliburn chose to give sonic when nickname “Nave The Hedgehog” just because Sonic mildly annoyed him. This sword is not above a bit of holier-than-thou trash talking.
@@comicfan1324 thanks for explain me.👍
sonic Will use calaburn to defeat the end
Imagine him slicing The End clean in half Metal Gear Rising Revengeance Style
yes 🤤
@@ThomasFangthe-j3d
Speaking of, I’m curious how the chaos emeralds would affect Caliburn. Unless sonic brought the rest of the sacred swords with him, his Excalibur form likely wouldn’t be an option anymore, but maybe the chaos emeralds could act as a substitute? Otherwise perhaps the power of the chaos emerald give Caliburn a crystal emerald appearance?
Oh boy I wish that could be a reality
calaburn also mate showed up in The murder of sonic the hedgehog celebrating Amy‘s birthday and also he could stop sonic broke the paradox prism in Sonic prime👍🏻
How would caliburn be affected by the chaos emeralds when sonic goes super?
Honestly, I’m not sure.
I could either see the sword’s blade into pure light, kind of like the light construct Super Sonic is able to make in Sonic Frontiers thanks to his cyber energy.
Otherwise, perhaps the sword takes on a crystal form to match the emeralds that is super charging it.
Or of course, if we want to keep the Excalibur sonic form around, you could just say the chaos emerald act as a substitute for the Sacred Swords
@@comicfan1324 how would caliburn react to the end or even the zombots from idw?
Dang, now you gotta make one where Shara is with him now too
Jk...Unless-
Well I love your good work and your theory is very good. So may I ask you what if Tails has Took Robo Fiona to go freedom fighter Secret base after first meet? Well Robo Fiona she is no longer work with serve Eggman empire and Robo follow love with Tails. will Fiona Fox keep with Sonic heart and how freedom fighter react to Robo Fiona. That’s gonna be super cool Robo Fiona and Fiona Fox become a twin sister!
Oops I almost forgot say Robo Fiona she is follow love Tails.
Let's hope Sonic and Tails don't mix them up
I don't believe that Shadow is worthy to use the sword because he is a damn anti-hero .
Shadow is a 100% anti-hero .
Caliburn doesn't choose anti-heroes , you can't convince me otherwise .
Regardless of his status as an antihero, like I said in the video, I believe Caliburn and Shadow would agree on several points.
Both of them believe in using their power to protect the innocent, even if that means taking down their opponents permanently.
So I do believe that Caliburn would consider Shadow worthy.
Also, from Caliburn’s perspective, Sonic could be just as much of an anti-hero since back in the medieval times if you were a warrior who served no king you weren’t recognized as a hero. If anything Shadow might be seen as more of a traditional due to his connections with G.U.N.
@@comicfan1324 Didn't Caliburn name Sonic "the new Arthur" at the end of the game .
And I am convinced Caliburn would hate G.U.N and some politicians because in the case he finds out about the events of the Space Colony Ark that happened 50-ish years in the past and it's consequences being the events of Sonic Adventure 2 and Shadow the Hedgehog spin-off game , Caliburn would despise Rouge the Bat for being a petty thief and Omega for being a mindless killing machine with out a noble goal .
He would be more likely see Knuckles or Silver or Blaze as better alternatives in case Sonic stops being worthy to use legendary blade .
@@Vrabsher_-Supreme_Perhinther-
True, Caliburn would be disgusted if he learned what G.U.N did. But that’s a BIG if. It’s not all knowing after all, so he would only know what happened if Shadow told him.
As for Silver & Blaze, for the same reason as Sonic, Caliburn would believe Silver can’t do what’s needs to be done. Yes, Sonic tried to kill Sonic once, but he very quickly came to the conclusion killing someone, even to save the world, is wrong. Caliburn would disagree. Although, Blaze on the other hand is very willing to kill her enemies. Blaze & Caliburn would be pretty much perfect partners, but due to their dimensional distance, it’s unlikely they’d cross paths (outside of Colors DS & Generations).
What if disussion idea
What if shadow was never created?
“What If Shadow The Hedgehog Never Existed?” Sonic What If? Response
Vídeo nice love 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 👍 ❤ 🙃🙃🙃🙃🙃🙃🙃