No. The Captive animals cannot be rehabilitated for life in the Wild. To replace them with robot might SEEM humane, but all it accomplishes is condemning them to a slow death in a barren tank.
@@3rdtimesthecharm376 Ofc, they should still take care of captive animals that have been raised in an aquarium for most of their life, but the ones that they put out to do performances should be replaced with robotic ones.
In new parks: definitely. If these robots prevent more wild animals getting captured and enslaved, they should definitely be used instead. Replacing animals already in captivity is tricky, as mentioned before. However every animal dies at some point. So they could definitely be replaced over time.
I remember watching a dolphin trainer doing her thing in the Caribbean, and I asked her where she kept the dolphins. She said they aren't held, they just show up and have fun doing their thing and getting their treats, and then they go back to the ocean. I asked what if they don't show up? She said, "then they don't. I don't want to make a dolphin do something they don't want to do." It reminded me of what I learned in India, that the villages used their elephants to help them with a great deal of tasks, but the elephants always went home to their families at the end of the day. They weren't kept, and they always came back to interact some more.
Something similar happened in a small town in Sinaloa, México. There was a dolphin people called "Pechocho" (a cute way to say "Precioso", which means "Precious"). This dolphin lived in a mangrove forest. He allowed visitors and people went there to swim and play with him. There were some activists that tried to "save" him, by moving him back to the sea, but he managed to always returned there. You could visit him by paying fishermen to take you there, and since it was their main income, everyone at that town took care of him as much as possible. This was so many years ago; I don't know if "Pechocho" is still alive :(
didn’t expect you here wow, but yes this is amazing! Imagine every zoo and marine park did this, so many animals would be free and happy living their lives instead of being trapped in a cage
that sounds great in theory but I feel like execution would be rocky for many reasons. Not only would it be insanely expensive but also I feel like kids love dinosaurs until they're life-size, free roaming, and right up close. While it'd be cool for some, in other kids might instill some type of PTSD LMAO
@@strigzs5681 Well, clowns also cause PTSD in some kids, but that doesn't mean clowns are bad! Parents just need to know their kids tolerance for those types of things before exposing them if possible.
@@Astherizino well yeah duh but it’d still be cool to see what it would’ve looked like life sized and moving. Sure you can look at a statue in a museum but that doesn’t move lmao
Just imagine a huge realistic animatronic megalodon swimming in a huge enclosure, that you could safely swim in, that would be absolutely terrifying yet awe-inspiring.
That I was going to say that too but like dino era who lived in the sea *Spinosaurus* that would be cool and terrifying to experience up close moving in front the big glass is what I want to see in future if they made that happened (゜o゜;
Something to consider, I worked at a zoo and a lot of the animals there were rescue and could no longer survive in the wild alone. We had a bald eagle that poachers injured so bad, she could no longer fly so we had her living at the zoo. We had lions who were declawed and found in someone’s back yard (could no longer survive in the wild). There are special considerations. People should always educate themselves before jumping to conclusions. But I do like the idea of robot animals.
There is a need for conservative and rescue but that is not what SeaWorld was/is about, they literally took healthy animals out of the sea for money and kept them in awful tanks way too small and broke them to obey. Conservation and rescue zoos aren't performing shows for the public for money, forcing the animals to put on a show either....
And even in these zoos that are about conservation and rescue there needs to be regulations as no matter the amount of good will in helping, if their not able to thrive bc they aren't in a zoo that is truly able to help them thrive they need to be in one that will, whether that be in one with more room or better care requirements met.
@@Me_1983- I study conservation science and policy, and accredited zoos, at least in the U.S., are regulated and generally try to go above and beyond those regulations. They're also one of the primary outlets for breeding animals for future ESA recovery plan releases. As an example, if zoos like the NC Zoo (with their giant enclosures) weren't able to keep animals, the red wolf most likely would have gone entirely extinct. For marine park dolphin shows and similar things, though, I'd look forward to the eventual swap to animatronics!
@@Enviro_Girl I'm applying to graduate school to study the exact same thing, couldn't of said it better myself! Not all programs are necessarily "bad", and work on taking on either endangered or animals that cannot be simply returned to the wild.
This! So many people scream "get rid of the zoos" yet do not understand how many animals they have saved. I grew up visiting the Bronx Zoo and so I fully support conservative zoos that not only save these animals, but also work everyday to bring so many species out of extinction. The answer is not to get rid of Zoos, it is to work with them to save these animals and show people why they aren't meant to be pets and why poachers must be stopped.
It would be interesting to incorporate cameras in the eyes so they could respond to visual (and even audio) cues. Letting trainers and people interact with them easier. This could also let them communicate with other robots underwater using frequencies above human hearing to act as a social group and work together like actual animals would
Right now I think it is direct remote control but eventually I am certain they will incorporate artificial intelligence into it so there will be a real time responsiveness to it.
@@lorefreak94 i mean they could just have active animations, which would cost much less than connecting five robots directly, just telling them to move in a certain way that looks just like interaction. Wouldn't want to be too roundabout.
This will open up more tech jobs because someone needs to maintain the animals, and with robots, there is always a level of coding. The level of realism is crazy.
@@anikai2449 quite a long time because that's more of a philosophical paradox. As of right now there no such thing as a self - maintained product in any industry. But even if product B is created to maintain product A then someone has to maintain and be job trained for product B recursively. Even A.I which fundamentaly is suppose to be "autopoiesis" has to be created "first" and models trained with data which requires people to do it.
@@thanosianthemadtitanic that's a good point, I'll admit, but I'll also admit I'm nervous, far enough in the future, hang with me on this, can you think of any job that ISN'T maintaining or making robots? What else will there be? Because companies are going to be pushing them everywhere, sure they're kinda dorky now, but when they have them where they want them which are you gonna choose, a human who either doesn't want to work and is bound to mess up, or a robot that doesn't care and is specifically made for that one job
Just imagine the kind of zoos that could be made with these. Not just conventional animals, but with giant squid, great whites, mosasaur, dinosaurs, dragons, etc.
I'm not sure the technology is quite there yet to get alot of the terrestrial stuff right (locomotion is obscenely difficult and it's only recently starting to get worked on) but if we got a really high end aquarium/park that had giant tanks with things like specific prehistoric environments that would be cool. Imagine coming through an underwater tunnel inside a cretacious coral reef, and you got things like hybodus and mosasaurus prowling around.
Man that will still be a site to see. My biggest worry is that there will be conspiracy theorists claiming that some animals don’t exist, that they are just robots. That’s going to be annoying.
True true, but it will be cool to see none the less. But if they create attractions based off of speculative evolutionary concepts, then it would add a level of education and realism to the experience. I hope that’s the case one day.
@@tiktaalik7160 I mean, it's not like there aren't theme parks with stuff like that. I don't see why it would be a serious stretch so see mythological stuff. I can think of alot of ideas. Countries could have culturally relevant parks to teach people about the regional mythologies (in Scotland they could have one that has things like the Kelpie and nuckleavee)
I think this is a great idea! But the animals can’t be released after being in captivity for so long, so the answer to that problem would be to send animal sanctuary, the reason I think this is because if they have been taken care of their whole life by humans, they wouldn’t be able to survive in the wild. That's why I think sanctuaries could solve this problem
@Lady of the Orka’s Hi, I didn’t know that, also I was mainly talk about land animals because there is many places where the animals could have larger enclosures.
One thing I hope we don’t lose is places for animals who can’t be rehabilitated to live as close to their wild homes as possible. Where they have access to medical care and enrichment. This video is phenomenal, as is the technology behind it. A Jurassic sea park would have me in tears. But I hope we continue to keep as much good as possible
the point of it is to stop people from taking animals from the ocean to create profit at the animals demise. rehabilitation centres for animals exist, but unfortunately places like seaworld are not in it to benefit anybody else but them.
The difference is that at sea world their tanks are really small compared to the amount of movement they need. They also need a lot of stimulation. And while learning tricks is good and fun... Doing the same tricks ovrr and over for 10+ years makes them board. They will bash their heads in boardom on the walls of their tanks. Having them in big bodies if water without ever having to please the public will be more benifical for them in the long run and since robots don't get tired or decided they don't want to do something... In the long run they could potentially host more shows with significantly less "animals".
What i think about it: dude jt would lose grace, it's like having a robot dog, you know that his emotions are not real and they are programmed, his movements are also programmed, what he wants to do is programmed, it just doesn't work, I don't know if everyone is like that, but I don't go to a zoo or an aquarium just to see the beauty of the animals, i don't know how to say it but i go to the zoo to see its wildness, cool no more animal slavery but it wouldn't work, man the fun of swimming next to a dolphin is not only appreciating its beauty up close, but also seeing real action, what it really wants to do, you marvel that it really is a living beautiful creature swimming on your side, his naturalness is that it makes it really cool to swim on his side, it's not like it's really there either, if you think about it, it's just metal and a lot of technology behind it, not saying that I support making animals as slaves, but I'm saying that for me it wouldn't work
I’m not so sure about that. Sure you could replace them with robots but that makes it lose a zoos charm. Which is to be able to see wild animals behave as they would in the wild and learn more about them because we would never be able to see them on our own. If they aren’t the real thing and are programmed by humans, then everything they do is what humans make them do. It’s really no different from before except the robots aren’t alive. How could you learn anything new about that animal when it’s behaviors are programmed? You might as well just shut down the zoo
This is the worst idea ever. Why would anyone want to go to a zoo or aquarium only to see a bunch of fake animals of metal and wires instead of experiencing the REAL deal in the flesh(unless something extinct like dinosaurs which probably would make sense)? It should also be noted that it may be expensive to go to places like Africa or South America to go see animals in the wild, so this is the closest for anyone to get access to seeing and experiencing these animals. Plus, and most importantly, zoos and aquariums have saved the lives of dozens of species from any human activities like pollution, deforestation, or over-hunting, which can lead them from endangerment to extinction(these activities are sadly still continuing), so putting them all back out there would be a very, very, very bad idea. In the words of Jurassic Park,”your scientists were so preoccupied on whether or not they COULD, they didn’t stop to think if they SHOULD.” Anyone agree?
@@MrJackRAA it could also lose the purpose of zoos and aquariums If you make an orca Robot it would be to heavy to breach Did you know in free Willy they were originally going to use a robot to play Willy but used an orca named Keiko instead there’s a book on him called K!ll!ng Keiko I’ve heard of it but never read it I heard it’s sad.
@@MrJackRAA Humans-raised captive animals' behaviors and wild animals' behaviors are two different things. I just witnessed the difference between the wolves in the Zoo and the Wild northern Mongolian wolves. Two different worlds. These eyes, body stance, walking in free motion, and curious but careful. Especially their eyes.
I don't know if someone has mentioned this yet, but imagine an entire zoo filled with animatronic creatures that are extinct. Imagine walking around and seeing things like the dodo bird, the woolly mammoth, quagga, tasmanian tiger, irish elk, baiji dolphin, etc. Think of the wonder behind it all. Not only would it be incredibly fascinating to see these once extinct creatures moving around and acting how they would've hundreds of years ago, but the possibility of research and future studies we could learn and develop from it would be extraordinary! Edit: i think some people are missing the point i was trying to make :/
They are. I watched a video on how they make these. They are trying to make them the ultimate AI where they evolve and are as dolphin like as real ones. Even sharks they've been making since they can't keep a great white alive in captivity.
I'm so proud of everyone in this comment section sharing their nuanced perspectives. I worked in a zoo for 4 years and they did so much good to help animals who couldnt survive in the wild, educating the public, breeding animals that had been extirpated in the wild, and donating so much to conservation and habitat preservation/restoration. Yes, there is good and bad about zoos and marine parks, but I'm so glad so many people know the issue isnt straight black and white.
@@izzymoon4436 We're generally speaking the ones killing the animals though, that's not nature's cycle😶 Most animals that we're trying to conserve are not going extinct naturally, but because people kill them just because they can, because they want to wear them, or as a by-product of industrial expansion. We are taking away their habitats and their food sources, and with the accelerated climate change, the heat is starting to kill off animals, plants and people as well.
Who else wants to see a reaction of real dolphines with this robot one Also imagine seeing what you think is a normal person just walking, but then you slowly start seeing there's something off about them 💀💀
Okay end marine parks, cool. However DO NOT close credited zoos, they are essential for conservation and breeding programs to save species. Proper zoos are not like roadside zoos! edit: Wildlife Sanctuaries DO NOT have active breeding programs, they just let animals do their own thing without closely monitoring or interfering. Zoos keep extensive records of animal family lineages to prevent inbreeding and allow for careful monitoring of pregnant animals and young. This especially important for animals that have genetically bottle necked like Amur Leopards and Cheetahs where Zoos have to try and get the least related animals as possible to breed. Not to mention proper zoos are important for the public to have empathy for endangered species and acquire funding for these breeding programs, the ignorance and shortsightedness in the comments is disappointing.
@IAN HEINE the main problems with dolphins and other cetaceans in captivity is that they are extremely high maintenance. they simply do not have the space to roam like they would in the open ocean, so they're cramped into a relatively small space. they're incredibly intelligent so they need extensive enrichment to keep them from getting depressed or stressed. there's cases where just the sound of the filtration system is enough to make dolphins and orcas miserable and hurt themselves. other animals we could mimic their natural environment and provide proper stimulation to keep them calm and happy, but we simply cant with whales and dolphins.
A good idea, but I’m wary of the anti-captivity message. A lot of animals are in zoos for a reason (injury, breeding programs for endangered species, other circumstances), and painting a negative picture of zoos as a sad place where animals go on display and suffer, that benefits no one- not even the animals. Credible modern zoos put real effort and care into animal husbandry, providing enclosures with enrichment and settings that suit an animal’s individual needs. They’re a necessary tool for teaching the public about animals, and for animals that are struggling in numbers, and injured with no hopes of survival in the wild- they’re fantastic. Some animals are disproportionately mistreated in captivity- dolphins and orcas absolutely- but I still think it benefits no one to sell this idea by painting that old line about zoos being awful. We can respect and recognize accredited zoos while also recognizing that some animals do not do as well in captivity, or have been exploited beyond what is typically seen of display animals.
Some zoos, like the Denver Zoo hire botanists and other plant people to buy plant and maintain literal plants that the zoo animals have in their original habitat and have animals that can’t survive on their own
It benefits the animals to spread the message that zoos are nothing but glorified animal jails. Wild animals belong in the wild and humans need to stop treating other species as entertainment.
@@Tracydot3 I’m sorry you seem to think all zoos are animal jails. You’re pretty damn misinformed by all the garbage animal activists shoved down your throat. There are plenty of zoos that are made to protect animals that cannot live in the wild. And here you are saying “they should live in the wild”. You’re wishing death on animals that cannot live a day in the wild. That or go extinct. You really are pretty evil yourself
@@Tracydot3 I would literally rather live in a zoo than a prison any day. Animals in AZA accredited zoos get 24/7 care. Healthcare, meals, enrichment, outside and inside access (depending on the animal and thier needs) and animals in managed care live longer than the wild ones. You can say "humans need to stop" but the fact of the matter is they don't they won't and they will never. We NEED zoos to protect endangered and vulnerable animals. Laws don't stop poachers. Laws and prison and even death will not stop poachers. Please PLEASE research AZA zoos and see for yourself the benefits they have and the lives they saved and the conservation efforts they strive for.
The uncanny Valley is mostly a human problem we can't tell the differences between dolphins so it less of an issue. I'm sure regular dolphins if we could talk would be pretty off-ed by these robots.
that cause ur brain, through both evolution and also life experience know what a human is and how the behave to a an almost inperceptible degree, which is why robot and cgi human faces just dont cut it for us, and i imagine that dolphins, being as smart as they are, are also capable of this
This skin is good and it has not much sudden movements. If they manage to smooth the movements and let it swim alone, there is a good chance of success.
Thé Mom should not breed anymore, sure everyone makes mistakes, but this is life on our hands, a gorilla and a child. Her child. If you fail to take care of a child which is life you should not breed. Thanks for listening to my rant
I've had this fantasy of huge fucking dragons being available for rides... of 'safaris' with dinosaurs... I know it will be years before stuff like this can even be considered feasible, but just imagine!
Imagine a perfect balance: using these robots for shows and display, while still using those profits for the vital conservation that many zoos currently contribute
Imagine instead if that money went to nature reserves to help them with conservation so animal species can be protected while remaining in the wild. I honestly don’t understand the ideology that keeping a species alive is more important than the quality of life it has.
@@dianekilloughy1795 I agree that nature reserves are ideal, but maybe some species are so close to extinct that they need help finding mates and food, which zoos could provide? I’m sure the zoos could always release them too, but I don’t know too much about this.
Moral issues aside, i think the greatest plus here is the fact that they can actually create prehistoric and even fictional beasts that people could actually peacefully interact with. The potential here is limitless, just imagine a real life "Skull Island" with King Kong and the other giants animals, that is a real game breaker right there.
Also you can’t keep real great white sharks in captivity they simply can’t survive. But if people created robot great whites it would give people a chance to see them.
They actually had that in the game. Certain animals at that time went extinct so they were replaced in zoos by android replicas of those animals, like the polar bear which you can unlock at some point in the game
I love this idea, and Del is beautiful. Not past that uncanny valley yet, her skin texture is clearly a big issue, but the movement was really nice and fairly natural looking. The movement of the water helps enormously.
Imagine you are a kid an your entire life you thought that the dolphin was real... The realisation of the kid that it was just a robot must be lifechanging haha.
A big issue that they don't address in this video is that you can't release marine animals that have already been born and raised in captivity. That includes orcas, dolphins, etc...as they would die in the wild, not knowing how to fend for themselves. Therefore, none of them will ever be "freed" in their lifetimes. That also includes permanently disabled marine animals that are unable to be released back into the wild.
this is where sanctuaries come into play. rather than being small, artificial environments where animals are locked up inside glass cases and treated poorly without sufficient room, they can rather be transferred to a sanctuary that is large, free roaming and natural, while still being under the care of humans.
and although people are still allowed to visit, they go in in small groups and are required to follow strict rules and limitations. they're also often sent into the enclosure in protected vehicles or on boats, so instead of these animals being forced to sit and look pretty, they're allowed to walk or swim away from tour vehicles that are just visiting from time to time.
I’d say the best solution would be to keep,them in captivity and let them live there lives as happy as we can make it for them but don’t breed anymore so as they get older and start to die of old age then put the robots in
This actually seems like the optimal idea for the future. I was at a zoo the other day, and except for the bears, most animals were hiding, sleeping really far away or just staring. My brother even asked if they were real. Imagine robotic animals, like tigers, lions, leopards and you could have them actually do things. You wouldn't have to feed them so it would cut the costs for zoos during low seasons. PETA wouldn't have activists going crazy about it. Also imagine bringing back extinct animals with robotics, it would be like going to a museum, but instead of looking at dead, stuffed animals, you could have prehistoric animals walking around, and it would be a much more fun way of learning about them. Like one of those 3D rides at universal studios, you know harry potter isn't actually there on a broom, but it's still an amazing experience and so fun!
@@felixbaumann7103 they've even gone crazy about pokemon go in germany. Virtual animals also deserve to be free. Sounds like a joke so im sure they'll come up with: electronic animals deserve to be free
I think of shows where an animal is domesticated it's ok to have robots but If this goes forward with every animal who will want to go to the zoo, and how can be sure animals are safer and have a better living in wildlife with hunters pollution, etc?
I worked for two years as a host of a circus show in a dolphinarium and I can say with confidence that this robot is a real work of art and the pinnacle of technological progress. The future belongs to this. If we also add artificial intelligence to it, which would predict the behavior of a machine based on a billion videos of real dolphins, then it would not be distinguishable from the real one even more.
I mean, I'm all for getting rid of captive animals used purely for entertainment purposes, especially marine parks, but let's also not demonize the zoos that actually do really important conservation work. Just make sure you're doing your research before looking at a random zoo and demonizing it since not all zoos are created equal
Yusss some people rlly think it's so easy to just yeet the animal off to the wild again without no practice of survival whatsoever. Imagine you being a modern man just being yeeted to an island with no supplies or food or knowledge to survive. Just luck and instinct✨
Yep there’s a zoo near me which have these lions which were rescued from a circus which was keeping them in small cages and they have started taking in even more rescued animals which wouldn’t be able to survive in the wild most likely.
I get that the robots would be good for the entertainment purposes. But there are zoos and aquariums that are for conservation/rescue places for animals becoming extinct or injured. Let's not give a bad name to all of them. I still say yes for the robots bc itll be safer for the guests to interact with.
That’s what I’m saying! And I also think that since animals in captivity and being fed by humans wouldn’t work out for them to hunt on their own if they were released since they might go to humans for food :(
@@Kheluichollow captive animals can't be released. This is not a short term fix. This would be a slow transition and as animals in captivity pass away, start replacing them with robots instead of capturing more. Or all the current captive animals could be used for breeding and release programs. There are many options and the current animals would not be forgotten about
Recues usually don't refer to themselves as Zoos. They are different things. Some zoos do have breeding programs and we see this a lot in china with Panda exhibits. But they're not trying to give zoos a bad name. Its just to change the fact that some perfectly healthy animals end up in captivity their whole life.
@@katelynderbidge3166 yes, and if they decide to release the animals in captivity for the robots to replace them the reals ones released will die Because they won’t be able to hunt for themselves Although some zoos rehabilitate their animals so they can hunt on their own and release them is cool but Majority of the animals in captivity can’t do that it be wise they either are injured or cannot be able to move/hunt properly it would be better for them taken care for them because of them getting poached and killed from not getting food in their own is a problem I do like the idea of robotic animals but if we try to replace real ones and release them none of the animals that are on the brink of extinction or in general will die which can cause some harm for the economy :-:
The places that take them for no reason should let them go and turn to animatronics But the ones that rescue them should stay cause they help them then let them go
I think the best option would be to use these for shows and stuff while genuine rehabilitation happens for endangered/injured animals. They could constantly be doing that alongside having these robots. Also, i swear I heard that some of the animals like performing so a limited amount of that I don’t think is necessarily a bad thing
That is true but maybe animatronics can last longer than the real animals (in terms of age) which could potentially even out the price (Correct me I’m wrong I’m not to knowledgeable in this kinda thing)
The problem is people, animals are loosing the habitat. Some animals are only alive because of zoos. There is no where to send them. If we didn’t have breeding programs in place we wouldn’t have the bald eagles. And that because of zoos
Almost happened before if I'm not mistaken, Mark Zuckerberg made robots I think that creepaly looked like humans and were also smarter than normal humans but the organization of these robots was stopped because they started communicating in their own language. Correct me if I'm wrong or if this was fake
K this is one of the coolest things I’ve ever seen, just everything about it, the release and stuff of trapped animals, the education, and the possibility of more animals that won’t hurt you but have the same mannerisms INSANE
@@Gaeldx because in fact in zoos and aquariums animals are used to maintain and preserve the species the animals reproduce there and then reintroduce their offspring in a natural state in order to save that species that is in danger an example of this is pandas Besides that zoos and aquariums serve in a very good way in that sense in which we people can inform each other, interact, learn from these animals, study them in order to protect them for much longer, however, if you start to To say that with a robot you are going to be able to interact in the same way as with a living animal you are completely wrong since that robot does not think, does not feel and therefore does not interact with you since it is not an animal what that damn robot is doing is move Because a person behind a wall is controlling it, you are not interacting Since that person cannot think like a dolphin does not feel like a dolphin and does not know how the dolphin is going to react therefore it cannot interact in the same way that a real dolphin would with that person also people get bored of robots Why do you think that the dinosaur animatronic parks began to happen fashionable They became boring Why a person did not interact with them it was repetitive the same is going to do with these animals it will be monotonous boring at some point people start to stop going to see it because they will say "Why am I going to see them? They are not real, they are just controlled robots "
I think something needs to be adressed... There are many zoos out there that ARE keeping animals in captivity, but a lot are atcually rescueing animals and giving them a secound shot at life. I have been to countless zoos thats animals are there becuase they CANT be returned back to the wild, not becuase they want to keep them for show.
Not only that, some of the best zoos in the world do an awesome job yo preserve some animal species, and prevent them from extintion with breeding and conservation programs. Ofc there are also zoos which are lame and still work like they are in the XIX century
mhm like you know keiko was the inspiration for free willy, and i took a wild animal course with someone who used to work with keiko and they were saying how the reason they didn’t want to free him was cause he had grown up in captivity and loved humans and they were scared that if they released keiko he would swim up to a fishing ship and get himself killed.
This opens up many new options for less invasive animal studies on top of helping water parks entertain. You better bet itll be weponized as well. Governments can't help themselves.
Probably would work better if there was some other large, non aggressive marine animal to follow dolphins, since as was said in this video, real dolphins can tell the difference between a robot dolphin and a real one. Even if it was more advanced, I don't think they'd be able to make a robot dolphin use echolocation like real dolphins do.
Am I the only person who watched this and thought immediately of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? A world where we’ve wiped out most animals and have built robot versions to make ourselves feel better about the ecocide. Of course, humans would never be that short sighted.
EQUAL RIGHTS FOR REPLICANT Ai CITIZENS AND ANIMALS! - Presidential debate year 2221 🇺🇸 6pm, July 21 lunar time Space X Musk memorial public convention lunar colony *Delta City 5.2* 'Your lunar horizon is here next stop Mars and beyond!' 🍷
The animals got shelter, food, and top notch medical facilities in the zoo. You think they will be happy when suddenly they got released into the wild? Also, some animals are so stupid, they don't want to breed normally in the wild. Lets doom some species of animals to extinction because a bunch of ignorant people think human values translate well into animal
@@blushingralseiuwu2222 The robots won’t be replacing zoos that actually protect animals just to eliminate ones that force them to do acrobatics and photos.
Please don’t try and close credible zoos though because they’re essential for preserving endangered wildlife. Animal sanctuaries are important too but they let the animals do their own thing and only monitor them from a distance. Sea world can burn though
I'm all for Zoos maintaining Wild Animals if it means there's no other way for it to survive - I.E - it has a deformity or is incapable in some form of re-acclimating to life in the Wild. A few people in the comments mentioned things like Sanctuaries or large Preserves - which I'm in favor of. Sea World needs to step into this new territory especially. No more Orcas, Dolphins or any live animal being locked up for Entertainment.
why should they burn? animals have no right...they exist only to eat and be eaten, and to become humans' entertainment and to support ecosystem...so long they are being managed so that not driven to their extinction, all is good...
It is NOT about entertainment! We need zoos/aquariums/safari parks for conservation. Some in the wild to keep the ecosystem going. Some in good captivity for conser Proper accredited zoos, aquariums and safari parks help endangered species and take good care of their animals! What is bad and cruel: Circuses, Some owners of some wild animals as pets, Trophy hunting, Canned hunting,l Sport hunting, The illegal pet trade, The legal pet trade, Poaching, The bushmeat trade, Factory farming, Intensive crop farming/horticulture, Killing animals destroying/killing livestock pets and people and property, Habitat destruction the soy particularly palm oil industries are huge part of that, BAD zoos I. e. Roadside zoos. Human overpopulation! Many animals are born in zoos/aquariums/safari parks so don't know any different. Good zoos/aquariums/safari parks do: Captive breeding for conservation, Have bloodlines to prevent inbreeding,k Education about endangered species and conservation, Reasonably large enclosures, Make enclosures similar to the wild, Vet care, Enrichment like hiding food or hanging it up a pole for an animal to jump up and catch; or putting food in balls to fall out when rolled about, Good diets, Rehabilitating so animals can live in the wild again, Also some help to heal and release when there is a disaster like wildfires and oil spills. Sadly bad 'zoos' and 'aquariums' and 'safari parks' do exist and give the good ones a bad name. Zoos that allow petting lion cubs etc are not good zoos. Some 'sanctuaries' are bad! And in general sanctuaries don't breed for conservation; they are more for keeping animals that can’t be released a good life for as long as they live. Zoo associations some of the good ones www.goodzoos.com British/Irish en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_and_Irish_Association_of_Zoos_and_Aquariums www.eaza.net/about-us/ (Europe Association of zoos and aquariums) www.waza.org/en/site/home (world Association of zoos and aquariums) en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_zoo_associations And some aquariums: www.conservationinstitute.org/10-largest-biggest-best-aquariums-in-the-world/ www2.visitsealife.com/london/conservation/ www.national-aquarium.co.uk www.zaccconference.com www.livingcoasts.org.uk www.livingcoasts.org.uk images I've been here and it has huge nets suspended by poles s the birds have lots of space to fly. Its easy to see the netting so it's not a hazard to birds as they are visual animals like humans. Palm Oil has over 200 names! Source: orangutanalliance.org/whats-the-issue/alternative-names-for-palm-oil/ 10 animals saved from extinction by zoos: Arabian Oryx, Przewalski’s Horse, California Condor, Corroboree frog Bongo, Regent honeyeater, Panamanian golden frog, Bellinger river turtle, Golden lion tamarin, Amur leopard. Source: medium.com/taronga-conservation-society-australia/10-endangered-species-saved-from-extinction-by-zoos-682c454d0125
Hmm that could actually replace those who hunt for sports, they could still feel the thrill of hunting a "beast" but still be able to not affect the real animals..
@@Username-le4eq that still encourages the idea of hunting foxes and ultimately sicking ur hunting dogs on them to rip them apart (because shooting the actual foxes yourself is illegal where they do the fox hunts). We shouldn’t be feeding weirdo’s lust for blood, they should just learn to respect wild life.
I don't think they would thank the humans. Captive dolphins only get dead fish (= allows more control over quality and parasites) but with is highly unnatural for them. They are not scavengers, they avoid dead animals in the wild. They exclusively eat live fish which provides them with the fluid to stay hydrated. That's why captive dolphins need to be watered and supplemented with ice cubes and jelly to prevent dehydration.
That awkward moment in time when the mechanically engineered individual who pretends to be something they biologically are not is acting in a manner that draws great suspicion to their being. In other words.. when the impostor is sus ! 😳
This is not a known dinosaur species, so my guess is that they're building an Indominus Rex (a fictional dinosaur from the 1st Jurassic World movie) animatronic for Universal's Jurassic World theme park.
I mean if the AI is designed to mimic animal consciousness, and aren't given access to the internet. If they gained consciousness, it would probably just make them seem more realistic in all honesty.
It costs 10 million just to upkeep the environments the animals live in yearly, SeaWorld isn't gonna do this, you're right, but they aren't going to do it because the animals they keep are injured animals they help aid or animals raised in captivity that could've never lived in the wild anyway or endangered animals that need to live in captivity for genetic safety nets.
@@switchgear100 At that point you're spending millions of dollars all to put some fake animal in the park and billions into maintaining it. On top of that you're also spending millions on new tanks and new sections to house the robots because if you even think about putting the fakes with the reals you've got a million dollar lawsuit on your hands. And all of that could've gone to increasing the experience and the enclosures/programs for the actual animals, kinda defeats the point all together. I can see this totally being a Disney thing, the amusement parks can do a lot with it, but mixing it with the animal parks and zoos really muddies water quick.
@@ThatBugBehindYou they literally said in the video that it SAVES tons of money over time since you don't need to feed or upgrade the housing of robots. You could also have way smaller enclosures for robots then the actual animal since they won't care about space. Also why can't you have robotic and real together? They showed how a robot dolphin interacts with fish just fine. I could see robot sharks or dolphins in giant aquariums with real fish easy and even interaction events where they can't do those sort of things with real animals due to safety. Or large animatronic animals interacting with real birds in an aviary or other combos like that. No idea where the lawsuits would come from?
@@SohiHien That was just a straight up lie, I've worked around animatronics specifically that interacted with the water and the feeding cost is nothing compared to what you need for these things to keep going smoothly. As for the smaller enclosures and lack of "upgrade" need, that is completely ignorant to how aquariums work, you don't just "upgrade" a freaking tank it's a process that always revolves around the layout of the viewing areas and it's only done when the area itself is being reworked, something that would still require a new tank to be built even if they placed robots in. The smaller enclosure part is just odd because you still need to get a good view of the robot which requires full motion, AKA, there's no reason for the robots to be "realistic" if they don't have the room to be actually realistic. I'm not going to even touch on the lawsuits part, to be honest I shouldn't have put it in my argument because it takes so much to actually detail what the issue is. If you want information you need to look into the laws regarding aquatic life safety and the safety of animals in enclosures in general, in short, you can't have an animatronic with that much independent motion in with the other animals. The potential safety issues in the water only make the problem twice as bad. It's an actuary issue and an animal safety issue thus the origins of the lawsuits would be independent and government animal care orgs.
@@ThatBugBehindYou I'm pretty sure this guy knows the upkeep costs of his own invention and the costs of current marine animal keeping. Regardless of viewing areas they could easily be in much smaller places or could simply use the old enclosures once the live animals are rehomed. Large areas of current enclosures are not easily viewed from viewing areas for the animal's privacy so that size portion would no longer be needed since there would be no regulations surrounding the appropriate size of enclosure for robots or their care. Not to mention land animals could have much cheaper fencing set ups since escape is not a factor.
In blade runner (the book) there are robotic animals because they're almost extingueshed and there are robot pets vets. Humans ended up worshipping that few life that is surviving on the planet, there's a religion that says each family needs to have a live real animal in the house but they're so rare people just pretend robots are real and create bonds with them.
There's more to this, animals in zoos and aquariums for the most part can't be released and a lot of the work zoos do is breeding programs to save endangered species and provide greater genetic diversity in animal populations, not every animal is suffering and for many being in zoos is saving their species. Remember this before you say all animals should be freed as many would die young.
Imagine a future with an entire park dedicated showcasing all of the animal kingdom in indistinguishable, life-like animatronic animals you can interact with and touch in simulated natural habitats. Imagine playing with elephants, lions, dolphins and even dinosaurs instead of ripping animals away from their natural homes to display them in a cage. I really hope this goes big and expands into a massive industry.
@Mac I see it as being a problem because of the inability to distinguish one from the other. There will come a point where it will be really hard telling them apart. What happens if someone makes a mistake or with ill intent, tells u it’s AI but it’s actually the real deal or they disguise the AI as something else. I have a real problem with this. I’m done with zoos of any kind, circus acts, bird cages, pools for sea animals….the concept of this for our entertainment and pleasure, without considering the animals rights, needs to go. Someone needs to advocate for them. Clearly some humans are not educated in animal behavior and how they communicate stress and pain.
I think that the wording "Ripping out of their natural homes to display them in a cage" is a bit harsh, as these animals are usually captive bred, and the so called 'Cages" are usually run by state of the art institutions and have everything that the animals need. We also still need these places for conservation. Take the panda into consideration, without us these beautiful animals would be completely gone from china.
Showing wild animal animatronics as friendly can have consequences tho. Imagine a kid petting an animatronic bear and then they saw a real one and also tries to pet it.
@@GriseWeisshark Was thinking that too. Like for performance or caged attraction this could get away with it, but imagine getting up close or a malfunction. Human error is always a prevailing issue with AI: "cannot compute error error" All it takes is one open animatronic jaw to close on a kid's arm to scrap this project. That being said, interacting with a "friendly" predator vs. a real-life predator are 2 VERY different things. Don't get me wrong, this is an amazing thing they're doing, but it's rather ambitious to get people interactions solely relying on AI or a manned controller.
I know that a lot of aquariums have dolphins that are actually rehabilitated and can't go back into the wild. They should 100% have a LOT of space but they still can't go in the wild most of the time
I feel it’s only a matter of time before biotechnology and actual technology merge. Imagine a dolphin where it’s all tissue except it doesn’t have a nervous system, instead it has an artificial computer based nervous system so it’s not actually alive.
@@spunkyflunkrdoodle467 they can grow it around scaffolding now to create some pretty interesting stuff. Nowhere near as advanced as what Sydney is talking about but simple things like heart valves and such. They hope to be able to grow working organs from stem cells that can be transplanted into people who need them without requiring donors.
Wait till technology advances to the point where they can put an AI into Delle, and then she figures out about what her kind usually do to humans. _These violent delights will have violent ends...!_
This is so innovative! Not only would it help with conservation since zoos could put a lot more of their profit towards that instead of feeding and caring for animals, but this has a HUGE learning possibility. This could help schools teach their kids in a far more hands on way and really has such a big potential to pave the way to better ways to conserve the animals in the wild and not have to put them in cages to raise funds to help their wild counter parts. I really hope this goes somewhere and they really get the lift off they need to make this a reality. I'd absolutely donate towards something like this.
This is actually a great technological advance and support for everyone and the animals as well. Especially during these times that extinctions are occurring in some animals, it’s very sad but it will help animals to be wild and free from humans.
Except that animals are going extinct because of loss of habitat (e.g. climate change, growing cities, etc.), and ones that have come back from being endangered (such and Pandas and Bengal Tigers) have done so because of zoos... The bad guys are the politicians rolling back regulations
The comments here are really frustrating. This video and the people involved went out of their way to highlight to good aspects of marine parks and zoos and it’s like several commenters here just elected to ignore that. They explicitly stated in this video that they hope to “keep the good of these facilities while alleviating the bad”. AKA: replacing the cetaceans used for entertainment shows being kept in less that satisfying tanks. No body involved in this project said they want to eliminate the rehabilitation efforts, preservation, and endangered animal protection and breeding, and nobody suggested releasing the current captive cetaceans to the wild just carelessly to die. The idea has always been to rehabilitate the animals currently in captivity in sea pen sanctuaries to live out the rest of their lives in more suitable living conditions. This marvel of engineering could do wonders for ending the harmful captivity industry, NOT the good conservation efforts.
Yes I think this is a great idea! Though some animals are in zoos for a reason, such as; they could be endangered and they are starting a breeding program, the animal could be injured for life , or the rescued a baby animal from the wild. These things are a good thing in zoos,
The ones that use animals for entertainment and for shows is different from the ones that save animals and just let them do their own things in big nice enclosures without humans being a bother, obviously the ones that save the animals are great, however the places that use them for shows without a care for the animals themselves should be taken down, they don't care if they die during shows or training, they just want the money that comes from "wow!!! Super cool animals doing cool tricks!!"
I don’t think people would like to pay lots of money just to watch a bunch of robotic sea animals do their tricks that they were programmed to perform.
@@ceazria2499 I already replied to this in another thread, so gonna give a different pov this time. Sure they would! Aside from people paying lots of money to see robots doing cool things in movies, people also pay to see said robots up close! Whether a backstage pass at a movie studio or as attractions in theme parks, animatronics are cool and quite beloved by a lot of people. Some people prefer authenticity, but others will pay to be immersed in a mock-up sci-fi setting, and I'm sure both groups could appreciate life-like animatronics promoting the natural world and conservation.
The cost of trying to replace captured animals would be astronomical. How can a human-controlled machine display the same level of excitement, believability, and unpredictability? People expect animals to mess up from time to time, and I believe that's part of the charm. I feel as if people would become bored knowing that it's only a machine.
Just remember that zoos around the world play an incredibly important role in animal conservation, and without the work of good zoos many of our favorite species would already be extinct. Captive orcas is one issue, but maybe we shouldn't be replacing Przewalski's horses or Sumatran tigers in captivity.
@@cursedGalataea Agreed. I think sanctuaries are the perfect solution. sanctuaries both educate people and properly accommodate to the animal's needs. By sanctuary, I mean no human intervention and let nature take it's course.
zoos are a mixed bunch. they trap animals needlessly too, not just ones for conservation. The animals also dont breed successfully in zoo prisons. That aside, there are wildlife sanctuaries as alternatives to zoos, and animals arent imprisoned there
0:54 I love that they have an indominus rex in the background, almost looks like that's another animal they plan to make into a robot I'd love to see jurassic world with realistic animatronics
This is one of the coolest things I've seen in years, if you can do this with all the super dangerous animals and prehistoric animals it will be world changing
The majority of the animals in captivity now can never go back into the wild, though I feel this is a step in the right direction. This will probably take years to be able to be used in the way we hope, but maybe it can keep them from putting more in captivity and someday the only real animals in captivity are the rescue and release animals
@@NA-cr7up Good point. That is also a possibility. I find these robots very cool, but I think they should keep zoos and conservancies in existence because they do a hell of a lot to keep animals from going extinct.
@@dianehall2248 A place that made a true effort to create a truly massive, exciting, and interactive environment for intelligent animals like dolphins would be nice, but nobody really wants to throw all of that money into something without making even more money as the carrot. We're going to have to shift out priorities as a species massively before we'll be able to ethically house animals like this. Robotic dolphins and other animals could excite people about nature & science simultaneously and in a couple of decades there wouldn't be any need for new animals to be "acquired" for the entertainment trade. People like Joe Exotic would have no place in the world anymore, if anybody can go to the park and play with a "baby tiger" for example. The money they make from robotic amusement parks could fund conservation as well.
"Do you think we should replace captive sea animals with robotic ones?" yes and no. - the animals who need actual care (aka the rescued ones, who cant live in the wild anymore bc of an injury or because they are an endangered species, etc) would be kept in relative captivity but under newer, better conditions. their habitats should be a lot bigger and as natural as possible, with little human intervention. - animals wouldnt be doing any tricks, these "spectacles" could use the robots as replacement. it would be good for educational purposes only, and people could see them from up close in an enclosure. but tricks and contact should be limited too if not obsolete - mainly because it can give kids (and even adults lol) the idea that doing this with real animals is okay. - people should be abe to see the real animals (because money from donations and admissions contribute to conservation and rehabilitation efforts, like it was mentioned in the video) but from afar. allowing a bigger distance and limiting unwanted interactions (like in a safari or boat ride situation where you can see them out there in the wild) ofc the first step would be really tricky and expensive, its a financial risk. but i dont see it as an impossible feat.
@@aylasthyston611 So your selfish. Some zoos genuinely care for animals and rescue them when they're found injured then after they are cared for release them. That is a very small percentage of zoos. Your time and entertainment must be more important than the well-being of the dolphins. It'll be the same experience but your mind makes all the difference. Tell yourself it's real and get used to it.
@@njay4399 sorry I worded my comment wrong and for your information I love animals i love them more than humans. I never said you should keep them in cages for entertainment and I know not all zoos are bad. I just think having the real animal is better than some robot unless the zoo or wildlife rescue is that bad if that's the case yes! They should have robots instead at least they can't hurt the animals any more and let the good charities,zoos and rescue places take care of them.
@@njay4399 and that depends if they can be released. They might be captive bred, endangered or injured that badly that they can't be released. Good or not but I know the bad ones shouldn't have any animals.
Its a bit strange thinking about going to an aquarium to watch robots swim. It reminds me of how eventually tech will take over our entire world. It's ironic that we're using tech to say "hey protect actual nature." I'm not totally sure how I feel about this
You’re not sure how you feel because you stubbornly want to find a conspiracy where there is none. Sometimes things in life ARE simple and ARE better - if we can create technology to replace animals in captivity that a stupid population of people craves, then we should.
You can not replace zoo’s or Aquariums, they are essential to Conservation….marine parks like sea world on the other hand?…yes these robots are absolutely the answer to that problem
Agreed that zoos are necessary. However, marine parks are definitely necessary too. Not every marine park in the world equals 'Seaworld'. There are so many places that do invaluable work in conservation, animal rescue and rehab, and studies that benefit wild populations. They are just as vital as regular zoos.
@@andresparra114 Yeah! But there's also lots of places that rehab seals/sea lions, dolphins, sea otters or sea birds. And since this video is specifically on dolphins, there is amazing research being done with captive dolphins that would be impossible with wild animals, but which totally aids in their research and protection. Of course there's shabby places and badly kept animals but that goes for all situations where people keep animals. Doesn't take away from the good places that do important work and always try to improve animal welfare.
Those kids at the pool look so excited to see Del. I love that Honestly, I'd love this idea! Though the animals raised in captivity can't be released into the wild, as they can't fend for themselves. There's other options for that, I hope. I would LOVE to see a dinosaur zoo that utilizes animatronics made to recreate our current ideas of these lost giants. Then again, that's me being a dinosaur nerd ^^
And animal robots could also be used for conservation and even monitoring nature/wildlife in areas that would be a big far out for people. Theres tons of uses for life like animatronic animals. And if we ever got the tech to build synth versions, that would be even cooler. Plus I would love to see some robot dinosaurs is the wild, that would be pretty cool.
Do you think we should replace captive sea animals with robotic ones?
No. The Captive animals cannot be rehabilitated for life in the Wild. To replace them with robot might SEEM humane, but all it accomplishes is condemning them to a slow death in a barren tank.
Hell yeah. We should
@@3rdtimesthecharm376 Ofc, they should still take care of captive animals that have been raised in an aquarium for most of their life, but the ones that they put out to do performances should be replaced with robotic ones.
@@Jijis.DeliveryService This I could be more agreeable with-
Still like Shamu's show.
In new parks: definitely.
If these robots prevent more wild animals getting captured and enslaved, they should definitely be used instead.
Replacing animals already in captivity is tricky, as mentioned before. However every animal dies at some point. So they could definitely be replaced over time.
I remember watching a dolphin trainer doing her thing in the Caribbean, and I asked her where she kept the dolphins. She said they aren't held, they just show up and have fun doing their thing and getting their treats, and then they go back to the ocean. I asked what if they don't show up? She said, "then they don't. I don't want to make a dolphin do something they don't want to do."
It reminded me of what I learned in India, that the villages used their elephants to help them with a great deal of tasks, but the elephants always went home to their families at the end of the day. They weren't kept, and they always came back to interact some more.
this is heartwarming, I wish you have link for this kind of video
That is beautiful
Something similar happened in a small town in Sinaloa, México. There was a dolphin people called "Pechocho" (a cute way to say "Precioso", which means "Precious"). This dolphin lived in a mangrove forest. He allowed visitors and people went there to swim and play with him. There were some activists that tried to "save" him, by moving him back to the sea, but he managed to always returned there. You could visit him by paying fishermen to take you there, and since it was their main income, everyone at that town took care of him as much as possible. This was so many years ago; I don't know if "Pechocho" is still alive :(
@@ElLyribe I think you can find information about that on google, some of the posts looked recent so there’s a good chance he might still be alive
letting animals choose what they want to do themselves is a really good technique for gaining trust. Lots of bird owners do this.
This is such a win-win innovation! Yes, please!
My queen!!! 🥺🥺🥺
"I see this as an absolute win"
Love you💗💖💕💖💗💕
didn’t expect you here wow, but yes this is amazing! Imagine every zoo and marine park did this, so many animals would be free and happy living their lives instead of being trapped in a cage
I can’t believe this is happening I feel like I traveled few years into the future
This is gonna be the future of tourism. Imagine a prehistoric aquarium where you can swim with the creatures.
Who cares about robot dolphins when we could have the mosasaur show from Jurassic World lmao
Prehistoric! Now that’s a good idea!
Thats SCURY
that is nightmare fuel... brrrr am I the only one terrified by that ??
I have a tingly feeling that'd be a massive crush hazzard
I think a full-blown animatronic dinosaur/prehistoric animal park done right would be a HIT. Kids of all ages love dinosaurs!
that sounds great in theory but I feel like execution would be rocky for many reasons. Not only would it be insanely expensive but also I feel like kids love dinosaurs until they're life-size, free roaming, and right up close. While it'd be cool for some, in other kids might instill some type of PTSD LMAO
@@strigzs5681 Well, clowns also cause PTSD in some kids, but that doesn't mean clowns are bad! Parents just need to know their kids tolerance for those types of things before exposing them if possible.
@@ClearSummerSkies that is true haha!
For me it wouldn't work, it's not like they really exist, or that they're really there
@@Astherizino well yeah duh but it’d still be cool to see what it would’ve looked like life sized and moving. Sure you can look at a statue in a museum but that doesn’t move lmao
*puts robo dolphin in real dolphin tank*
“Hey, have you met Jeff yet?”
“Oh yeah, cool guy, he doesn’t talk much though.”
Until the try to fornicate with it the first ever dolphin sexbot lul
@@charlies1112 what?!?!
@@kwz9930 yeah dolphins is the only few animals that enjoys intercourses like humans
@@i2eptilian true but i didnt think they would randomly start putting there willy out and mate with a new dolphin
ಠಿ_ಠಿ
Just imagine a huge realistic animatronic megalodon swimming in a huge enclosure, that you could safely swim in, that would be absolutely terrifying yet awe-inspiring.
It would be great. But I might get scared still 🤣
Even if it's not real hell no 😂 that's still scary at
Fun in games until it malfunctions
Unless they program it to eat you
That I was going to say that too but like dino era who lived in the sea *Spinosaurus* that would be cool and terrifying to experience up close moving in front the big glass is what I want to see in future if they made that happened (゜o゜;
Cool, imagine a future jurassic park with robot dinasours too!
There are some dinosaur museums that have a more primitive version of this
Especially a jurassic park with self aware robotic dinosaurs.
That's a great idea, could we do this before they start recreating real ones! 🤣
@@Matt0sh Very true. But what could be done with more space, enclosures and habitata, and more advanced robot technology, would be amazing.
@@fazoolie321 Yes, I don't need real ones!
Something to consider, I worked at a zoo and a lot of the animals there were rescue and could no longer survive in the wild alone. We had a bald eagle that poachers injured so bad, she could no longer fly so we had her living at the zoo. We had lions who were declawed and found in someone’s back yard (could no longer survive in the wild). There are special considerations. People should always educate themselves before jumping to conclusions. But I do like the idea of robot animals.
There is a need for conservative and rescue but that is not what SeaWorld was/is about, they literally took healthy animals out of the sea for money and kept them in awful tanks way too small and broke them to obey. Conservation and rescue zoos aren't performing shows for the public for money, forcing the animals to put on a show either....
And even in these zoos that are about conservation and rescue there needs to be regulations as no matter the amount of good will in helping, if their not able to thrive bc they aren't in a zoo that is truly able to help them thrive they need to be in one that will, whether that be in one with more room or better care requirements met.
@@Me_1983- I study conservation science and policy, and accredited zoos, at least in the U.S., are regulated and generally try to go above and beyond those regulations. They're also one of the primary outlets for breeding animals for future ESA recovery plan releases. As an example, if zoos like the NC Zoo (with their giant enclosures) weren't able to keep animals, the red wolf most likely would have gone entirely extinct. For marine park dolphin shows and similar things, though, I'd look forward to the eventual swap to animatronics!
@@Enviro_Girl I'm applying to graduate school to study the exact same thing, couldn't of said it better myself! Not all programs are necessarily "bad", and work on taking on either endangered or animals that cannot be simply returned to the wild.
This! So many people scream "get rid of the zoos" yet do not understand how many animals they have saved. I grew up visiting the Bronx Zoo and so I fully support conservative zoos that not only save these animals, but also work everyday to bring so many species out of extinction. The answer is not to get rid of Zoos, it is to work with them to save these animals and show people why they aren't meant to be pets and why poachers must be stopped.
It would be interesting to incorporate cameras in the eyes so they could respond to visual (and even audio) cues. Letting trainers and people interact with them easier. This could also let them communicate with other robots underwater using frequencies above human hearing to act as a social group and work together like actual animals would
Right now I think it is direct remote control but eventually I am certain they will incorporate artificial intelligence into it so there will be a real time responsiveness to it.
@@lorefreak94 and then the ai will become too intelligent and will demand end from their captivity
reminds me of the android polar bear in Detroit: Become Human
@@lorefreak94 i mean they could just have active animations, which would cost much less than connecting five robots directly, just telling them to move in a certain way that looks just like interaction. Wouldn't want to be too roundabout.
@@ahirbhattacharjee2352 sea world: become human
This will open up more tech jobs because someone needs to maintain the animals, and with robots, there is always a level of coding. The level of realism is crazy.
But how long until they make robots to maintain and make the robots?
A year prob
@@anikai2449 how long until they make robots to maintain the robots that maintain the robots
@@anikai2449 quite a long time because that's more of a philosophical paradox. As of right now there no such thing as a self - maintained product in any industry.
But even if product B is created to maintain product A then someone has to maintain and be job trained for product B recursively.
Even A.I which fundamentaly is suppose to be "autopoiesis" has to be created "first" and models trained with data which requires people to do it.
@@thanosianthemadtitanic that's a good point, I'll admit, but I'll also admit I'm nervous, far enough in the future, hang with me on this, can you think of any job that ISN'T maintaining or making robots? What else will there be? Because companies are going to be pushing them everywhere, sure they're kinda dorky now, but when they have them where they want them which are you gonna choose, a human who either doesn't want to work and is bound to mess up, or a robot that doesn't care and is specifically made for that one job
Just imagine the kind of zoos that could be made with these. Not just conventional animals, but with giant squid, great whites, mosasaur, dinosaurs, dragons, etc.
I'm not sure the technology is quite there yet to get alot of the terrestrial stuff right (locomotion is obscenely difficult and it's only recently starting to get worked on) but if we got a really high end aquarium/park that had giant tanks with things like specific prehistoric environments that would be cool. Imagine coming through an underwater tunnel inside a cretacious coral reef, and you got things like hybodus and mosasaurus prowling around.
Man that will still be a site to see. My biggest worry is that there will be conspiracy theorists claiming that some animals don’t exist, that they are just robots. That’s going to be annoying.
@@tiktaalik7160 lmao yeah you can't stop them unfortunately.
True true, but it will be cool to see none the less. But if they create attractions based off of speculative evolutionary concepts, then it would add a level of education and realism to the experience. I hope that’s the case one day.
@@tiktaalik7160 I mean, it's not like there aren't theme parks with stuff like that. I don't see why it would be a serious stretch so see mythological stuff. I can think of alot of ideas. Countries could have culturally relevant parks to teach people about the regional mythologies (in Scotland they could have one that has things like the Kelpie and nuckleavee)
I think this is a great idea! But the animals can’t be released after being in captivity for so long, so the answer to that problem would be to send animal sanctuary, the reason I think this is because if they have been taken care of their whole life by humans, they wouldn’t be able to survive in the wild. That's why I think sanctuaries could solve this problem
There are habilitation programmes that could help at least some of them be released.
@@seleuf true very true
A lot of SeaWorld and other marine parks animals were born in the wild and stolen, it is entirely possible to rehabilitate them.
@@lefthanddontknow673 I agree they can be rehabilitated I was just talking about the ones born in captivity
@Lady of the Orka’s Hi, I didn’t know that, also I was mainly talk about land animals because there is many places where the animals could have larger enclosures.
Okay, this is quite literally the coolest thing I've seen all year-. . .
Same
This and the flying car dude.
I'm your 1k like
Jesus Christ gives true joy to all who trust and believe in Him
Must not have seen a lot..
Oh my god. I’m BEGGING them to make a prehistoric sea park.
Same here bro
Oh my goodness that’s amazing.
Robot Mosasaurus?
It would be so cool but so scary my goodness I would die just looking at it let alone possibly swimming in one.
I wanna see those giant Crustaceans
One thing I hope we don’t lose is places for animals who can’t be rehabilitated to live as close to their wild homes as possible. Where they have access to medical care and enrichment. This video is phenomenal, as is the technology behind it. A Jurassic sea park would have me in tears. But I hope we continue to keep as much good as possible
Idc
the point of it is to stop people from taking animals from the ocean to create profit at the animals demise. rehabilitation centres for animals exist, but unfortunately places like seaworld are not in it to benefit anybody else but them.
@@artryg0n497 What?
As a biologist, THIS
The difference is that at sea world their tanks are really small compared to the amount of movement they need. They also need a lot of stimulation. And while learning tricks is good and fun... Doing the same tricks ovrr and over for 10+ years makes them board. They will bash their heads in boardom on the walls of their tanks. Having them in big bodies if water without ever having to please the public will be more benifical for them in the long run and since robots don't get tired or decided they don't want to do something... In the long run they could potentially host more shows with significantly less "animals".
This sounds like a really neat idea. Realistic robots that could still provide entertainment and teach us about marine life.
What i think about it: dude jt would lose grace, it's like having a robot dog, you know that his emotions are not real and they are programmed, his movements are also programmed, what he wants to do is programmed, it just doesn't work, I don't know if everyone is like that, but I don't go to a zoo or an aquarium just to see the beauty of the animals, i don't know how to say it but i go to the zoo to see its wildness, cool no more animal slavery but it wouldn't work, man the fun of swimming next to a dolphin is not only appreciating its beauty up close, but also seeing real action, what it really wants to do, you marvel that it really is a living beautiful creature swimming on your side, his naturalness is that it makes it really cool to swim on his side, it's not like it's really there either, if you think about it, it's just metal and a lot of technology behind it, not saying that I support making animals as slaves, but I'm saying that for me it wouldn't work
I’m not so sure about that. Sure you could replace them with robots but that makes it lose a zoos charm. Which is to be able to see wild animals behave as they would in the wild and learn more about them because we would never be able to see them on our own. If they aren’t the real thing and are programmed by humans, then everything they do is what humans make them do. It’s really no different from before except the robots aren’t alive. How could you learn anything new about that animal when it’s behaviors are programmed? You might as well just shut down the zoo
This is the worst idea ever. Why would anyone want to go to a zoo or aquarium only to see a bunch of fake animals of metal and wires instead of experiencing the REAL deal in the flesh(unless something extinct like dinosaurs which probably would make sense)? It should also be noted that it may be expensive to go to places like Africa or South America to go see animals in the wild, so this is the closest for anyone to get access to seeing and experiencing these animals. Plus, and most importantly, zoos and aquariums have saved the lives of dozens of species from any human activities like pollution, deforestation, or over-hunting, which can lead them from endangerment to extinction(these activities are sadly still continuing), so putting them all back out there would be a very, very, very bad idea. In the words of Jurassic Park,”your scientists were so preoccupied on whether or not they COULD, they didn’t stop to think if they SHOULD.”
Anyone agree?
@@MrJackRAA it could also lose the purpose of zoos and aquariums
If you make an orca Robot it would be to heavy to breach
Did you know in free Willy they were originally going to use a robot to play Willy but used an orca named Keiko instead there’s a book on him called K!ll!ng Keiko I’ve heard of it but never read it
I heard it’s sad.
@@MrJackRAA Humans-raised captive animals' behaviors and wild animals' behaviors are two different things. I just witnessed the difference between the wolves in the Zoo and the Wild northern Mongolian wolves. Two different worlds. These eyes, body stance, walking in free motion, and curious but careful. Especially their eyes.
I don't know if someone has mentioned this yet, but imagine an entire zoo filled with animatronic creatures that are extinct. Imagine walking around and seeing things like the dodo bird, the woolly mammoth, quagga, tasmanian tiger, irish elk, baiji dolphin, etc.
Think of the wonder behind it all. Not only would it be incredibly fascinating to see these once extinct creatures moving around and acting how they would've hundreds of years ago, but the possibility of research and future studies we could learn and develop from it would be extraordinary!
Edit: i think some people are missing the point i was trying to make :/
This is fucking terrifying to me who has Submechanophobia
And then you say to yourself, "too bad they're fake"
And than you realize it’s fake bs
they have stuff like this with dinos all the time, and they usually suck lol
FNAF at its finest
Employees in the future - "Did you remember to plug in the dolphins?"
"Flipper's on 1%, put him on airplane mode"
That's sick, plugging in the dolphins!
*“Quick, tell the crowd they are sleeping!”*
*”Oh no, the dolphins battery is dead!!”*
@@lumiinousity how do they get rid of a dead dolphin? That would be a big toilet.
@@freethink dolphin starts flying
I really didn't believe that was a robotic dolphin, it looked so realistic
I know I was shocked and had a wait what moment!
I was a little confused about a dolphin in a chlorinated pool but yeah, I wasnt sure
True
They are. I watched a video on how they make these. They are trying to make them the ultimate AI where they evolve and are as dolphin like as real ones. Even sharks they've been making since they can't keep a great white alive in captivity.
If it is surely they will use it in the military 100%
I'm so proud of everyone in this comment section sharing their nuanced perspectives. I worked in a zoo for 4 years and they did so much good to help animals who couldnt survive in the wild, educating the public, breeding animals that had been extirpated in the wild, and donating so much to conservation and habitat preservation/restoration. Yes, there is good and bad about zoos and marine parks, but I'm so glad so many people know the issue isnt straight black and white.
But if we wouldn’t have captured them in the first place, they would have died, but that’s just nature’s cycle. It’s still for us.
@@izzymoon4436 We're generally speaking the ones killing the animals though, that's not nature's cycle😶
Most animals that we're trying to conserve are not going extinct naturally, but because people kill them just because they can, because they want to wear them, or as a by-product of industrial expansion. We are taking away their habitats and their food sources, and with the accelerated climate change, the heat is starting to kill off animals, plants and people as well.
"Maybe even dinosaurs"
You're playing a risky game here👥🦖
Lol it can make little boys dreams come true
@@yourlocaltangerine Or end them.
Nobody cares
Lmao
Right
“Mom, the dolphin is short circuiting again!”
Why did I read this in Candace's voice in the Phineas and Ferb theme song
Same
"Mom I want a Dolphin!"
"We've got one of those at home..."
Cue Vacuum Cleaner with a fin cellotaped onto the top
@@anniewolfe2324 same, it fits so well and the show too because they build contraptions
@@rylenstuffsv2 omg true I didn't even think of that, makes it even better 😂
Who else wants to see a reaction of real dolphines with this robot one
Also imagine seeing what you think is a normal person just walking, but then you slowly start seeing there's something off about them 💀💀
dolphins*
@@Legendary_Starlight ye ik idk why i put an e lmao but im not gonna edit it
I imagine it’s like us looking at the robots that imitate humans. I bet they would get an uncanny valley feeling
They showed it in the video. They said the other dolphin could tell it was fake by using sonar
It's at 3:35
This is throwing fuel on the fire of the "birds aren't real" movement.
THE BIRDS WORK FOR THE BOURGEOISIE
birds are drones
OPEN YOUR EYES SHEEPLE!!!
Lolololol
What are you talking about? There are no longer real birds, period! LOL
Birds are real, they are just a decoy for the actual animatronics... the sqirels
Okay end marine parks, cool.
However DO NOT close credited zoos, they are essential for conservation and breeding programs to save species. Proper zoos are not like roadside zoos!
edit: Wildlife Sanctuaries DO NOT have active breeding programs, they just let animals do their own thing without closely monitoring or interfering. Zoos keep extensive records of animal family lineages to prevent inbreeding and allow for careful monitoring of pregnant animals and young. This especially important for animals that have genetically bottle necked like Amur Leopards and Cheetahs where Zoos have to try and get the least related animals as possible to breed. Not to mention proper zoos are important for the public to have empathy for endangered species and acquire funding for these breeding programs, the ignorance and shortsightedness in the comments is disappointing.
Yeah
I was just about to comment about that
Not to mention the animals that have only had human contact are going to suffer if they are released into the wild
@IAN HEINE the main problems with dolphins and other cetaceans in captivity is that they are extremely high maintenance. they simply do not have the space to roam like they would in the open ocean, so they're cramped into a relatively small space. they're incredibly intelligent so they need extensive enrichment to keep them from getting depressed or stressed. there's cases where just the sound of the filtration system is enough to make dolphins and orcas miserable and hurt themselves. other animals we could mimic their natural environment and provide proper stimulation to keep them calm and happy, but we simply cant with whales and dolphins.
Thank you some zoo's keep certain species from fully going extinct.
"We'd love to bring back the Jurassic Seas"
*_sweats profusely thinking about seeing a life-sized Mosasaurus_*
Trust me they are not as big as being depicted in media. ^^
@@CrashdayGamer well that’s no fun
@@NATASHA-jf5hm They're like only half the size of the movie version.
Jurassic world over exaggerated their size to make it look cooler.
The Blue whale is the largest known animal to have ever lived, we can currently witness a real life titan.
A good idea, but I’m wary of the anti-captivity message.
A lot of animals are in zoos for a reason (injury, breeding programs for endangered species, other circumstances), and painting a negative picture of zoos as a sad place where animals go on display and suffer, that benefits no one- not even the animals.
Credible modern zoos put real effort and care into animal husbandry, providing enclosures with enrichment and settings that suit an animal’s individual needs. They’re a necessary tool for teaching the public about animals, and for animals that are struggling in numbers, and injured with no hopes of survival in the wild- they’re fantastic.
Some animals are disproportionately mistreated in captivity- dolphins and orcas absolutely- but I still think it benefits no one to sell this idea by painting that old line about zoos being awful. We can respect and recognize accredited zoos while also recognizing that some animals do not do as well in captivity, or have been exploited beyond what is typically seen of display animals.
I couldn't have said it better!
Some zoos, like the Denver Zoo hire botanists and other plant people to buy plant and maintain literal plants that the zoo animals have in their original habitat and have animals that can’t survive on their own
It benefits the animals to spread the message that zoos are nothing but glorified animal jails. Wild animals belong in the wild and humans need to stop treating other species as entertainment.
@@Tracydot3 I’m sorry you seem to think all zoos are animal jails. You’re pretty damn misinformed by all the garbage animal activists shoved down your throat. There are plenty of zoos that are made to protect animals that cannot live in the wild. And here you are saying “they should live in the wild”. You’re wishing death on animals that cannot live a day in the wild. That or go extinct. You really are pretty evil yourself
@@Tracydot3 I would literally rather live in a zoo than a prison any day. Animals in AZA accredited zoos get 24/7 care. Healthcare, meals, enrichment, outside and inside access (depending on the animal and thier needs) and animals in managed care live longer than the wild ones. You can say "humans need to stop" but the fact of the matter is they don't they won't and they will never. We NEED zoos to protect endangered and vulnerable animals. Laws don't stop poachers. Laws and prison and even death will not stop poachers. Please PLEASE research AZA zoos and see for yourself the benefits they have and the lives they saved and the conservation efforts they strive for.
To be honest .. this dolphin robot looks like they have passed the uncanny valley already .
Pretty sure real dolphins would think this animal is sick.
The uncanny Valley is mostly a human problem we can't tell the differences between dolphins so it less of an issue. I'm sure regular dolphins if we could talk would be pretty off-ed by these robots.
that cause ur brain, through both evolution and also life experience know what a human is and how the behave to a an almost inperceptible degree, which is why robot and cgi human faces just dont cut it for us, and i imagine that dolphins, being as smart as they are, are also capable of this
@@datentigers that makes perfect sense .
This skin is good and it has not much sudden movements.
If they manage to smooth the movements and let it swim alone, there is a good chance of success.
Imagine you fall into a robotic gorilla exhibit and the zookeepers are FORCED to kill Harambot 😔
This comment has no business being as funny as it is
Hahahahah
Ohhh noooo!
Thank you for blessing us with this comment
Thé Mom should not breed anymore, sure everyone makes mistakes, but this is life on our hands, a gorilla and a child. Her child. If you fail to take care of a child which is life you should not breed.
Thanks for listening to my rant
I could imagine a fantasy themepark, with dragons, unicorns, fairies, and sirens, etc.
I've had this fantasy of huge fucking dragons being available for rides... of 'safaris' with dinosaurs... I know it will be years before stuff like this can even be considered feasible, but just imagine!
omggg I've been dreaming of dragons for yearssss they gotta make it pls
That would be so freaking awesome!
AND DINOSAURS OMG
Omg yess dudee
This is actually a really cool idea. With this you can literally make anything. Like sea dragons or an ocean creature that looks like an alien.
Imagine a perfect balance: using these robots for shows and display, while still using those profits for the vital conservation that many zoos currently contribute
Imagine us going on a date and it ending in a midnight kiss. Interested?
@@freikinnewb122 omg… you’re asking me out
Yes!
Imagine instead if that money went to nature reserves to help them with conservation so animal species can be protected while remaining in the wild. I honestly don’t understand the ideology that keeping a species alive is more important than the quality of life it has.
@@dianekilloughy1795 I agree that nature reserves are ideal, but maybe some species are so close to extinct that they need help finding mates and food, which zoos could provide? I’m sure the zoos could always release them too, but I don’t know too much about this.
Moral issues aside, i think the greatest plus here is the fact that they can actually create prehistoric and even fictional beasts that people could actually peacefully interact with. The potential here is limitless, just imagine a real life "Skull Island" with King Kong and the other giants animals, that is a real game breaker right there.
*stares in Jurassic park*
You mean a 'Deal Breaker' or a 'Game Changer', I believe.
Bruh now I’m just thinking about dragons! We could have DRAGONS
I SMELL COCAINEEEE
Also you can’t keep real great white sharks in captivity they simply can’t survive. But if people created robot great whites it would give people a chance to see them.
The long awaited sequel to Detroit: Become Human we are proud to announce
Sea World: Become Dolphin
Oh no real dolphins are going o be racist to robot dolphins 😭
Return to dolphin
"Blend in with the Dolphins"
We'll see "28 bite wounds"?🤔
They actually had that in the game. Certain animals at that time went extinct so they were replaced in zoos by android replicas of those animals, like the polar bear which you can unlock at some point in the game
I love this idea, and Del is beautiful. Not past that uncanny valley yet, her skin texture is clearly a big issue, but the movement was really nice and fairly natural looking. The movement of the water helps enormously.
well animals will never be uncanny, it's only the humaniods that are!
Imagine you are a kid an your entire life you thought that the dolphin was real... The realisation of the kid that it was just a robot must be lifechanging haha.
Thats what I was saying
eh not really tbh. just teach em how helpful the robotic ones are to the real animals.
Learning that the animals in the zoo were fake at a young age would say a lot about modern society
I don’t think it would be much different from learning that the mall Santa wasn’t real
@@msgen02 LOL point
A big issue that they don't address in this video is that you can't release marine animals that have already been born and raised in captivity. That includes orcas, dolphins, etc...as they would die in the wild, not knowing how to fend for themselves. Therefore, none of them will ever be "freed" in their lifetimes. That also includes permanently disabled marine animals that are unable to be released back into the wild.
this is where sanctuaries come into play. rather than being small, artificial environments where animals are locked up inside glass cases and treated poorly without sufficient room, they can rather be transferred to a sanctuary that is large, free roaming and natural, while still being under the care of humans.
and although people are still allowed to visit, they go in in small groups and are required to follow strict rules and limitations. they're also often sent into the enclosure in protected vehicles or on boats, so instead of these animals being forced to sit and look pretty, they're allowed to walk or swim away from tour vehicles that are just visiting from time to time.
this still means that after these captive live ones have passed that they wont need more
@@elliechandler1848 Don't the animals get bred to maintain a genetic backup to animals that might be endangered?
I’d say the best solution would be to keep,them in captivity and let them live there lives as happy as we can make it for them but don’t breed anymore so as they get older and start to die of old age then put the robots in
This actually seems like the optimal idea for the future. I was at a zoo the other day, and except for the bears, most animals were hiding, sleeping really far away or just staring. My brother even asked if they were real. Imagine robotic animals, like tigers, lions, leopards and you could have them actually do things. You wouldn't have to feed them so it would cut the costs for zoos during low seasons. PETA wouldn't have activists going crazy about it. Also imagine bringing back extinct animals with robotics, it would be like going to a museum, but instead of looking at dead, stuffed animals, you could have prehistoric animals walking around, and it would be a much more fun way of learning about them. Like one of those 3D rides at universal studios, you know harry potter isn't actually there on a broom, but it's still an amazing experience and so fun!
That is such a great idea!!
PETA would still find a way to go crazy about it though
@@felixbaumann7103 they've even gone crazy about pokemon go in germany. Virtual animals also deserve to be free. Sounds like a joke so im sure they'll come up with: electronic animals deserve to be free
@@MakerMonkey01 I’m reminded of an episode of futurama and a robot fox hunt.
I think of shows where an animal is domesticated it's ok to have robots but If this goes forward with every animal who will want to go to the zoo, and how can be sure animals are safer and have a better living in wildlife with hunters pollution, etc?
I worked for two years as a host of a circus show in a dolphinarium and I can say with confidence that this robot is a real work of art and the pinnacle of technological progress. The future belongs to this. If we also add artificial intelligence to it, which would predict the behavior of a machine based on a billion videos of real dolphins, then it would not be distinguishable from the real one even more.
This is a hologram of a tree,
In memory of a real tree. - The Simpsons.
this is probably the most bizarre and dysfunctional thing ive ever seen. the fermi paradox is looking less like a paradox every day.
What tree
@@hotsausage1888 *the tree*
@@e4rlygames oh…
@@no-xr8wv what does this have to do with our inability to find intelligent life we know should be out there?
I mean, I'm all for getting rid of captive animals used purely for entertainment purposes, especially marine parks, but let's also not demonize the zoos that actually do really important conservation work. Just make sure you're doing your research before looking at a random zoo and demonizing it since not all zoos are created equal
Yusss some people rlly think it's so easy to just yeet the animal off to the wild again without no practice of survival whatsoever. Imagine you being a modern man just being yeeted to an island with no supplies or food or knowledge to survive. Just luck and instinct✨
Well said!!
True, sanctuaries trying to save almost extinct species should be exluded from these demonizations.
@Main Ahri You'd be surprised how many people don't know the difference
Yep there’s a zoo near me which have these lions which were rescued from a circus which was keeping them in small cages and they have started taking in even more rescued animals which wouldn’t be able to survive in the wild most likely.
I get that the robots would be good for the entertainment purposes. But there are zoos and aquariums that are for conservation/rescue places for animals becoming extinct or injured. Let's not give a bad name to all of them. I still say yes for the robots bc itll be safer for the guests to interact with.
That’s what I’m saying! And I also think that since animals in captivity and being fed by humans wouldn’t work out for them to hunt on their own if they were released since they might go to humans for food :(
@@Kheluichollow captive animals can't be released. This is not a short term fix. This would be a slow transition and as animals in captivity pass away, start replacing them with robots instead of capturing more. Or all the current captive animals could be used for breeding and release programs. There are many options and the current animals would not be forgotten about
Recues usually don't refer to themselves as Zoos. They are different things. Some zoos do have breeding programs and we see this a lot in china with Panda exhibits. But they're not trying to give zoos a bad name. Its just to change the fact that some perfectly healthy animals end up in captivity their whole life.
@@katelynderbidge3166 yes, and if they decide to release the animals in captivity for the robots to replace them the reals ones released will die Because they won’t be able to hunt for themselves
Although some zoos rehabilitate their animals so they can hunt on their own and release them is cool but Majority of the animals in captivity can’t do that it be wise they either are injured or cannot be able to move/hunt properly it would be better for them taken care for them because of them getting poached and killed from not getting food in their own is a problem
I do like the idea of robotic animals but if we try to replace real ones and release them none of the animals that are on the brink of extinction or in general will die which can cause some harm for the economy :-:
The places that take them for no reason should let them go and turn to animatronics
But the ones that rescue them should stay cause they help them then let them go
I think the best option would be to use these for shows and stuff while genuine rehabilitation happens for endangered/injured animals. They could constantly be doing that alongside having these robots. Also, i swear I heard that some of the animals like performing so a limited amount of that I don’t think is necessarily a bad thing
I agree wholeheartedly. It doesn't have to be one or the other, I'm not sure why people are fighting in these comments.
The rehab animals shouldn't be on display at all. And able to live life normally.
Ok obviously this is a genuinely good idea.
But also I love that our solution to have less lawsuit making zoos was to just make fake zoos instead.
The price is the only drawback
That is true but maybe animatronics can last longer than the real animals (in terms of age) which could potentially even out the price
(Correct me I’m wrong I’m not to knowledgeable in this kinda thing)
@@sergioolvera7603 for sure that matenance a dolphin its pretty more expensive
The problem is people, animals are loosing the habitat. Some animals are only alive because of zoos. There is no where to send them. If we didn’t have breeding programs in place we wouldn’t have the bald eagles. And that because of zoos
It makes me think of the original Westworld ... Scary .... Machines going crazy 🤣😂
So, the rise of robot overlords begins in a marine park……….wasn’t my first guess.
Someone’s never heard of Boston dynamics
@@tylerberg4832 But those machines actually look like robots. The most dangerous ones are the robots you can’t recognize 👀
I mean, we can't just create human tier intelligence at first tries. Gotta start somewhere lower
@@ren8436 True. Mr. Krabs was the first one and now they’ve moved up to dolphins.
Almost happened before if I'm not mistaken, Mark Zuckerberg made robots I think that creepaly looked like humans and were also smarter than normal humans but the organization of these robots was stopped because they started communicating in their own language.
Correct me if I'm wrong or if this was fake
K this is one of the coolest things I’ve ever seen, just everything about it, the release and stuff of trapped animals, the education, and the possibility of more animals that won’t hurt you but have the same mannerisms INSANE
Auto erotica dinosaures soon
A robot cant replace a animal.
@@flaviosulcaflores3295 well not in our ecosystems, but in our zoo why not
@@Gaeldx because in fact in zoos and aquariums animals are used to maintain and preserve the species the animals reproduce there and then reintroduce their offspring in a natural state in order to save that species that is in danger an example of this is pandas Besides that zoos and aquariums serve in a very good way in that sense in which we people can inform each other, interact, learn from these animals, study them in order to protect them for much longer, however, if you start to To say that with a robot you are going to be able to interact in the same way as with a living animal you are completely wrong since that robot does not think, does not feel and therefore does not interact with you since it is not an animal what that damn robot is doing is move Because a person behind a wall is controlling it, you are not interacting Since that person cannot think like a dolphin does not feel like a dolphin and does not know how the dolphin is going to react therefore it cannot interact in the same way that a real dolphin would with that person also people get bored of robots Why do you think that the dinosaur animatronic parks began to happen fashionable They became boring Why a person did not interact with them it was repetitive the same is going to do with these animals it will be monotonous boring at some point people start to stop going to see it because they will say "Why am I going to see them? They are not real, they are just controlled robots "
@@flaviosulcaflores3295 Only read the last sentence, you bring good point👍.
I think something needs to be adressed...
There are many zoos out there that ARE keeping animals in captivity, but a lot are atcually rescueing animals and giving them a secound shot at life. I have been to countless zoos thats animals are there becuase they CANT be returned back to the wild, not becuase they want to keep them for show.
Not only that, some of the best zoos in the world do an awesome job yo preserve some animal species, and prevent them from extintion with breeding and conservation programs. Ofc there are also zoos which are lame and still work like they are in the XIX century
@@MadneSSat4 exactly
mhm like you know keiko was the inspiration for free willy, and i took a wild animal course with someone who used to work with keiko and they were saying how the reason they didn’t want to free him was cause he had grown up in captivity and loved humans and they were scared that if they released keiko he would swim up to a fishing ship and get himself killed.
Without zoos many species out there (rhinos, sumatran tigers, etc) would already be extinct
@@madcap3450 exactly!! so many zoos are great at taking care of animals tho there are bad zoos too
“Version 3.0, Swimming completely on AI”
So this is how robots take over the world. The dolphins…
So long... and thanks for all the fish
i immediately thought of hitchhikers guide to the galaxy
GET THE DOLPHINS BEFORE THEY GET US!
@@britishsongbird my thoughts exactly!
Just like the Simpsons predicted
I kinda hope to someday also use this to spy on REAL dolphins in their habitat someday so they can study dolphins like never
This opens up many new options for less invasive animal studies on top of helping water parks entertain. You better bet itll be weponized as well. Governments can't help themselves.
That's what I thought this video was going to be about
Probably would work better if there was some other large, non aggressive marine animal to follow dolphins, since as was said in this video, real dolphins can tell the difference between a robot dolphin and a real one. Even if it was more advanced, I don't think they'd be able to make a robot dolphin use echolocation like real dolphins do.
@@mews8812 believe it or not, this conversation is happening now. Using the dolphin as an ROV camera platform is definitely possible.
"How do you do, fellow porpoises?"
Am I the only person who watched this and thought immediately of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? A world where we’ve wiped out most animals and have built robot versions to make ourselves feel better about the ecocide. Of course, humans would never be that short sighted.
My exact reaction!
Yeah, maybe we'll all be getting robot sheep. Of course robot humans will be quick to follow.
same, i sent it to my husband with the message "pre-blade runner"
EQUAL RIGHTS FOR REPLICANT Ai CITIZENS AND ANIMALS! - Presidential debate year 2221 🇺🇸 6pm, July 21 lunar time Space X Musk memorial public convention lunar colony *Delta City 5.2* 'Your lunar horizon is here next stop Mars and beyond!' 🍷
I just read that last month too
"Or maybe even dinosaurs"
*Jurassic Park theme intensifies*
People with robots taking their jobs: “THEIR GONNA TAKE OUR JOBS!”
Animals with robots taking their jobs: “bye bye have a good time!”
The animals got shelter, food, and top notch medical facilities in the zoo. You think they will be happy when suddenly they got released into the wild?
Also, some animals are so stupid, they don't want to breed normally in the wild. Lets doom some species of animals to extinction because a bunch of ignorant people think human values translate well into animal
Animals are smart, they can live in the wild freely
@@hokutonoguy true exept sloths and koalas and pandas i guess
@@blushingralseiuwu2222 The robots won’t be replacing zoos that actually protect animals just to eliminate ones that force them to do acrobatics and photos.
@@blushingralseiuwu2222
only the explored animals are gonna be released
I swear every time I see cool innovations like this I’m like I want to go back 5 years back when I was 14 so I can live to see what the future holds
Are you dying?
5 years will maybe let you see a new smartphone version, 50 on the other hand..
Dude you're 19 why are you acting like you're gonna die tomorrow
I’m 14 right now
Glitch Addiction, it's you from the future!
Please don’t try and close credible zoos though because they’re essential for preserving endangered wildlife. Animal sanctuaries are important too but they let the animals do their own thing and only monitor them from a distance.
Sea world can burn though
I'm all for Zoos maintaining Wild Animals if it means there's no other way for it to survive - I.E - it has a deformity or is incapable in some form of re-acclimating to life in the Wild. A few people in the comments mentioned things like Sanctuaries or large Preserves - which I'm in favor of.
Sea World needs to step into this new territory especially. No more Orcas, Dolphins or any live animal being locked up for Entertainment.
They died in a fire...? At Seaworld...?
why should they burn? animals have no right...they exist only to eat and be eaten, and to become humans' entertainment and to support ecosystem...so long they are being managed so that not driven to their extinction, all is good...
@@Iacedarling oh ok, I'm wrong simply because you say it is so...right...clap...clap...clap...
@@Iacedarling i agree but im afraid that’s called an opinion, guess people can’t have them now according to you
It is NOT about entertainment!
We need zoos/aquariums/safari parks for conservation.
Some in the wild to keep the ecosystem going.
Some in good captivity for conser
Proper accredited zoos, aquariums and safari parks help endangered species and take good care of their animals!
What is bad and cruel:
Circuses,
Some owners of some wild animals as pets,
Trophy hunting,
Canned hunting,l
Sport hunting,
The illegal pet trade,
The legal pet trade,
Poaching,
The bushmeat trade,
Factory farming,
Intensive crop farming/horticulture,
Killing animals destroying/killing livestock pets and people and property,
Habitat destruction the soy particularly palm oil industries are huge part of that,
BAD zoos I. e. Roadside zoos.
Human overpopulation!
Many animals are born in zoos/aquariums/safari parks so don't know any different.
Good zoos/aquariums/safari parks do:
Captive breeding for conservation,
Have bloodlines to prevent inbreeding,k
Education about endangered species and conservation,
Reasonably large enclosures,
Make enclosures similar to the wild,
Vet care,
Enrichment like hiding food or hanging it up a pole for an animal to jump up and catch; or putting food in balls to fall out when rolled about,
Good diets,
Rehabilitating so animals can live in the wild again,
Also some help to heal and release when there is a disaster like wildfires and oil spills.
Sadly bad 'zoos' and 'aquariums' and 'safari parks' do exist and give the good ones a bad name.
Zoos that allow petting lion cubs etc are not good zoos.
Some 'sanctuaries' are bad!
And in general sanctuaries don't breed for conservation; they are more for keeping animals that can’t be released a good life for as long as they live.
Zoo associations some of the good ones
www.goodzoos.com
British/Irish en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_and_Irish_Association_of_Zoos_and_Aquariums
www.eaza.net/about-us/ (Europe Association of zoos and aquariums)
www.waza.org/en/site/home (world Association of zoos and aquariums)
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_zoo_associations
And some aquariums:
www.conservationinstitute.org/10-largest-biggest-best-aquariums-in-the-world/
www2.visitsealife.com/london/conservation/
www.national-aquarium.co.uk
www.zaccconference.com
www.livingcoasts.org.uk
www.livingcoasts.org.uk
images I've been here and it has huge nets suspended by poles s the birds have lots of space to fly. Its easy to see the netting so it's not a hazard to birds as they are visual animals like humans.
Palm Oil has over 200 names!
Source:
orangutanalliance.org/whats-the-issue/alternative-names-for-palm-oil/
10 animals saved from extinction by zoos:
Arabian Oryx,
Przewalski’s Horse,
California Condor,
Corroboree frog
Bongo,
Regent honeyeater,
Panamanian golden frog,
Bellinger river turtle,
Golden lion tamarin,
Amur leopard.
Source:
medium.com/taronga-conservation-society-australia/10-endangered-species-saved-from-extinction-by-zoos-682c454d0125
This reminds me of futurama, the episode where they were hunting a fox robot.
Hmm that could actually replace those who hunt for sports, they could still feel the thrill of hunting a "beast" but still be able to not affect the real animals..
@@Username-le4eq that still encourages the idea of hunting foxes and ultimately sicking ur hunting dogs on them to rip them apart (because shooting the actual foxes yourself is illegal where they do the fox hunts). We shouldn’t be feeding weirdo’s lust for blood, they should just learn to respect wild life.
@@Crow23346 Weirdos? Mankind has been all about the hunt since the dawn of mankind 😆
@@Jake-iw3tl just for sport is messed up
You eat what you kill , and you don't kill what you don't want to eat - unless it's self defense against another human
Dolphins: “So long and thanks for all the fish!”
I loved that movie.
You have made my day
@@Averiiie the only movie that everyone can say "the book was better"
Dolphin is mammal
I don't think they would thank the humans. Captive dolphins only get dead fish (= allows more control over quality and parasites) but with is highly unnatural for them.
They are not scavengers, they avoid dead animals in the wild. They exclusively eat live fish which provides them with the fluid to stay hydrated.
That's why captive dolphins need to be watered and supplemented with ice cubes and jelly to prevent dehydration.
Imagine controlling this dolphin with virtual reality and looking socially awkward to real dolphins.
OHMYGODYES
i wanna be a squid -
@@alligator_with_internet_access huh
Other dolphins: “Do you think that guy might be on the spectrum” …
Him: ō.ø … bēëp bõôp …
“Yes, definitely”
That awkward moment in time when the mechanically engineered individual who pretends to be something they biologically are not is acting in a manner that draws great suspicion to their being.
In other words.. when the impostor is sus ! 😳
hahhaaaa!! Poor robo-phin. It just wants to play too.
It would super lower the costs of the parks too - no animal food, no pen cleaning, no medicine, less specialists needed
0:55 - they have a diagram of a dinosaur in the background….. Do they plan on doing this with DINOSAURS?!?!
A robot Jurassic park would be so cool….
Especially if its Spinosaurus
This is not a known dinosaur species, so my guess is that they're building an Indominus Rex (a fictional dinosaur from the 1st Jurassic World movie) animatronic for Universal's Jurassic World theme park.
@@valentinmitterbauer4196 I think it's one of those Jurassic Park animatronics. Those already existed for a long time.
Real looking robo Dino's would be cool for a park, i do agree.
@@valentinmitterbauer4196 yeah it's an indom
“all of the fish in the entire aquarium believed the dolphin was real!
the sharks avoided it,
the turtles were TERRIFIED of it”
Yep, like real life lmao
When the ninja turtles say it's not good, then it's not good :D
Let’s just hope the robotic animals don’t unlock Consciousness 🥲
Ghost possessing robots
Or someone hacks them and commit a genocide...just sayin-
These violent delights..
@@Bibibiceratops uh oh we know how that "ends".
I mean if the AI is designed to mimic animal consciousness, and aren't given access to the internet. If they gained consciousness, it would probably just make them seem more realistic in all honesty.
“We could replace anything.”
Endangered animals: 👀
Yare yare daze
Humans
That’s why the world degenerate
“It cost 3 to 5 million to make”
And that’s why SeaWorld isn’t gonna do this.
It costs 10 million just to upkeep the environments the animals live in yearly, SeaWorld isn't gonna do this, you're right, but they aren't going to do it because the animals they keep are injured animals they help aid or animals raised in captivity that could've never lived in the wild anyway or endangered animals that need to live in captivity for genetic safety nets.
@@switchgear100
At that point you're spending millions of dollars all to put some fake animal in the park and billions into maintaining it. On top of that you're also spending millions on new tanks and new sections to house the robots because if you even think about putting the fakes with the reals you've got a million dollar lawsuit on your hands.
And all of that could've gone to increasing the experience and the enclosures/programs for the actual animals, kinda defeats the point all together.
I can see this totally being a Disney thing, the amusement parks can do a lot with it, but mixing it with the animal parks and zoos really muddies water quick.
@@ThatBugBehindYou they literally said in the video that it SAVES tons of money over time since you don't need to feed or upgrade the housing of robots. You could also have way smaller enclosures for robots then the actual animal since they won't care about space. Also why can't you have robotic and real together? They showed how a robot dolphin interacts with fish just fine. I could see robot sharks or dolphins in giant aquariums with real fish easy and even interaction events where they can't do those sort of things with real animals due to safety. Or large animatronic animals interacting with real birds in an aviary or other combos like that. No idea where the lawsuits would come from?
@@SohiHien
That was just a straight up lie, I've worked around animatronics specifically that interacted with the water and the feeding cost is nothing compared to what you need for these things to keep going smoothly. As for the smaller enclosures and lack of "upgrade" need, that is completely ignorant to how aquariums work, you don't just "upgrade" a freaking tank it's a process that always revolves around the layout of the viewing areas and it's only done when the area itself is being reworked, something that would still require a new tank to be built even if they placed robots in. The smaller enclosure part is just odd because you still need to get a good view of the robot which requires full motion, AKA, there's no reason for the robots to be "realistic" if they don't have the room to be actually realistic.
I'm not going to even touch on the lawsuits part, to be honest I shouldn't have put it in my argument because it takes so much to actually detail what the issue is. If you want information you need to look into the laws regarding aquatic life safety and the safety of animals in enclosures in general, in short, you can't have an animatronic with that much independent motion in with the other animals. The potential safety issues in the water only make the problem twice as bad. It's an actuary issue and an animal safety issue thus the origins of the lawsuits would be independent and government animal care orgs.
@@ThatBugBehindYou I'm pretty sure this guy knows the upkeep costs of his own invention and the costs of current marine animal keeping. Regardless of viewing areas they could easily be in much smaller places or could simply use the old enclosures once the live animals are rehomed. Large areas of current enclosures are not easily viewed from viewing areas for the animal's privacy so that size portion would no longer be needed since there would be no regulations surrounding the appropriate size of enclosure for robots or their care. Not to mention land animals could have much cheaper fencing set ups since escape is not a factor.
imagine in the next 100 years where everybody has died and the dominators of this world are robotic dolphins
I'm getting "Horizon, Zero Dawn" flashbacks
In blade runner (the book) there are robotic animals because they're almost extingueshed and there are robot pets vets. Humans ended up worshipping that few life that is surviving on the planet, there's a religion that says each family needs to have a live real animal in the house but they're so rare people just pretend robots are real and create bonds with them.
The simpsons would have predicted it (almost)
In the words of the dolphins from hitchhikers guide to the galaxy, so long. And thanks for all the fish
@@princessleia2187 damn, was just gonna say this, General!
There's more to this, animals in zoos and aquariums for the most part can't be released and a lot of the work zoos do is breeding programs to save endangered species and provide greater genetic diversity in animal populations, not every animal is suffering and for many being in zoos is saving their species. Remember this before you say all animals should be freed as many would die young.
Imagine a bugged dolphin doing weird things like a Skyrim npc
Or Skydiving!!!😂😂 or doing splits!!😂😂
AND HERE WE HAVE A DOLPHIN IN HIS NATURAL HABITAT DOING THE MATING SPIN
If it starts fus-roh-dah-ing then im getting on land so quick
Imagine a future with an entire park dedicated showcasing all of the animal kingdom in indistinguishable, life-like animatronic animals you can interact with and touch in simulated natural habitats. Imagine playing with elephants, lions, dolphins and even dinosaurs instead of ripping animals away from their natural homes to display them in a cage. I really hope this goes big and expands into a massive industry.
@Mac yes because an programmed AI is obviously the same thing as a living breathing animal.
@Mac I see it as being a problem because of the inability to distinguish one from the other. There will come a point where it will be really hard telling them apart. What happens if someone makes a mistake or with ill intent, tells u it’s AI but it’s actually the real deal or they disguise the AI as something else. I have a real problem with this. I’m done with zoos of any kind, circus acts, bird cages, pools for sea animals….the concept of this for our entertainment and pleasure, without considering the animals rights, needs to go. Someone needs to advocate for them. Clearly some humans are not educated in animal behavior and how they communicate stress and pain.
I think that the wording "Ripping out of their natural homes to display them in a cage" is a bit harsh, as these animals are usually captive bred, and the so called 'Cages" are usually run by state of the art institutions and have everything that the animals need. We also still need these places for conservation. Take the panda into consideration, without us these beautiful animals would be completely gone from china.
Showing wild animal animatronics as friendly can have consequences tho. Imagine a kid petting an animatronic bear and then they saw a real one and also tries to pet it.
@@GriseWeisshark Was thinking that too. Like for performance or caged attraction this could get away with it, but imagine getting up close or a malfunction. Human error is always a prevailing issue with AI: "cannot compute error error"
All it takes is one open animatronic jaw to close on a kid's arm to scrap this project. That being said, interacting with a "friendly" predator vs. a real-life predator are 2 VERY different things.
Don't get me wrong, this is an amazing thing they're doing, but it's rather ambitious to get people interactions solely relying on AI or a manned controller.
"Plug your animals in at night to charge"
Boy that's a sentence I never thought I'd hear
lol
right? imagine a robot dog pet :o
I really hope this becomes the future! I hate seeing animals in cages
I know that a lot of aquariums have dolphins that are actually rehabilitated and can't go back into the wild. They should 100% have a LOT of space but they still can't go in the wild most of the time
I think theyre talkibg abt those who can, but you also have a good poiny in the other sense
-"Do you like our owl?"
-"It's artificial?"
-"Of course it is."
-"Must be expensive."
-"Very."
me-cool
me too-cool
-"It seems you feel our work is not a benefit to the public."
soooo spooky, spot on.
I feel it’s only a matter of time before biotechnology and actual technology merge. Imagine a dolphin where it’s all tissue except it doesn’t have a nervous system, instead it has an artificial computer based nervous system so it’s not actually alive.
I think I have read a book or watched a movie at some point about that.
@@Fstop313 the original novel that coined the term "robot"?
Where would they get the tissue?
@@spunkyflunkrdoodle467 they can grow it around scaffolding now to create some pretty interesting stuff. Nowhere near as advanced as what Sydney is talking about but simple things like heart valves and such. They hope to be able to grow working organs from stem cells that can be transplanted into people who need them without requiring donors.
@@Fstop313 wow cool I had no idea that was possible thank you 😊
Imagine walking through a zoo when all of a sudden a pack of free roaming robo alligators walk past you
“We’d love to bring back the Jurassic seas!”
*thinks about swimming with a life size mosasaur*
They were actually pretty small
@@yeetusdeleteus3292 bruh they were 17 or something feet long and carnivore but it's a robot and it's programed do it can't hurt u so yea
Yeah in year 2077
But it would just be a machine. Where's the authenticity?
Fucking re-poster
Dolphin at 3:28 - "Bro, I know a terminator when I see one..."
Lol
Another day, another step closer to Westworld becoming a reality
Oh god
It’s a puppet.lol
Wait till technology advances to the point where they can put an AI into Delle, and then she figures out about what her kind usually do to humans.
_These violent delights will have violent ends...!_
@@danballard7405 the guy that's making them said in this video that the next generation of them would ideally be controlled by A.I.
is it bad?
This is so innovative! Not only would it help with conservation since zoos could put a lot more of their profit towards that instead of feeding and caring for animals, but this has a HUGE learning possibility. This could help schools teach their kids in a far more hands on way and really has such a big potential to pave the way to better ways to conserve the animals in the wild and not have to put them in cages to raise funds to help their wild counter parts. I really hope this goes somewhere and they really get the lift off they need to make this a reality. I'd absolutely donate towards something like this.
This is actually a great technological advance and support for everyone and the animals as well. Especially during these times that extinctions are occurring in some animals, it’s very sad but it will help animals to be wild and free from humans.
Except that animals are going extinct because of loss of habitat (e.g. climate change, growing cities, etc.), and ones that have come back from being endangered (such and Pandas and Bengal Tigers) have done so because of zoos... The bad guys are the politicians rolling back regulations
Bring back the meg. just imagine having a couple of beers and then go swimming with a meg lol
Nooooo!! I would die of a heart attack lmao 😆
Now that's a film that I would watch lol
@@donspider1 same lmao
n that’s called stupidity lmao😭
Swimming after a couple of beers?
Please never do that.
Plot Twist:That's a real dolphin and they're just trolling us.
don't you mean plot twist?
@@SmirkSavvy yeah thx
That'd be hilarious
@hajja and I didn't see the wire they said it was attached to
For real cause I want this to be real but I don’t know
The comments here are really frustrating. This video and the people involved went out of their way to highlight to good aspects of marine parks and zoos and it’s like several commenters here just elected to ignore that. They explicitly stated in this video that they hope to “keep the good of these facilities while alleviating the bad”. AKA: replacing the cetaceans used for entertainment shows being kept in less that satisfying tanks. No body involved in this project said they want to eliminate the rehabilitation efforts, preservation, and endangered animal protection and breeding, and nobody suggested releasing the current captive cetaceans to the wild just carelessly to die. The idea has always been to rehabilitate the animals currently in captivity in sea pen sanctuaries to live out the rest of their lives in more suitable living conditions. This marvel of engineering could do wonders for ending the harmful captivity industry, NOT the good conservation efforts.
Imagine the robot dinosaur uprising hahahaa... utterly terrifying
Westworasic park
Cyborg trex with rocket launchers
Let's see how long this riot lasts when we shut down the power supply :)
Yes I think this is a great idea! Though some animals are in zoos for a reason, such as; they could be endangered and they are starting a breeding program, the animal could be injured for life , or the rescued a baby animal from the wild. These things are a good thing in zoos,
True. Like Pandas for example.
Not for the purpose of exhibiting to humans of course
The ones that use animals for entertainment and for shows is different from the ones that save animals and just let them do their own things in big nice enclosures without humans being a bother, obviously the ones that save the animals are great, however the places that use them for shows without a care for the animals themselves should be taken down, they don't care if they die during shows or training, they just want the money that comes from "wow!!! Super cool animals doing cool tricks!!"
I don’t think people would like to pay lots of money just to watch a bunch of robotic sea animals do their tricks that they were programmed to perform.
@@ceazria2499 I already replied to this in another thread, so gonna give a different pov this time.
Sure they would! Aside from people paying lots of money to see robots doing cool things in movies, people also pay to see said robots up close! Whether a backstage pass at a movie studio or as attractions in theme parks, animatronics are cool and quite beloved by a lot of people. Some people prefer authenticity, but others will pay to be immersed in a mock-up sci-fi setting, and I'm sure both groups could appreciate life-like animatronics promoting the natural world and conservation.
Dolphins: They're taking our jobs!!!
Pretty sure their salary is better in the oceans.
I'm pretty sure that's not a job, it's just a prison.
"These foreigners come over here... " Jaja
It’s not a job they never wanted it in the first place
They took our jobs
The cost of trying to replace captured animals would be astronomical. How can a human-controlled machine display the same level of excitement, believability, and unpredictability?
People expect animals to mess up from time to time, and I believe that's part of the charm. I feel as if people would become bored knowing that it's only a machine.
What about those great anamatronics at Disney? We love those because we are so amazed they aren't real.
Just remember that zoos around the world play an incredibly important role in animal conservation, and without the work of good zoos many of our favorite species would already be extinct. Captive orcas is one issue, but maybe we shouldn't be replacing Przewalski's horses or Sumatran tigers in captivity.
@@cursedGalataea Agreed. I think sanctuaries are the perfect solution. sanctuaries both educate people and properly accommodate to the animal's needs. By sanctuary, I mean no human intervention and let nature take it's course.
@@teha17 If all we had were sanctuaries practicing zero human intervention that would condemn many species to extinction.
@@cursedGalataea zoos barely break even with the money they get from donations and admissions as it costs a lot to take care of the animals day to day
@@cursedGalataea URGH THEY WILL DIE IN WILD 😜
zoos are a mixed bunch. they trap animals needlessly too, not just ones for conservation. The animals also dont breed successfully in zoo prisons.
That aside, there are wildlife sanctuaries as alternatives to zoos, and animals arent imprisoned there
Getting us use to robotic animals, due to the fact that in the future, most will be extinct.
In 2100 everybody will think of a tank when hearing tiger.
Assuming these parks can afford to replace all their animals with robots
0:54 I love that they have an indominus rex in the background, almost looks like that's another animal they plan to make into a robot
I'd love to see jurassic world with realistic animatronics
There is something called "Jurassic Wolrd The Exposition" with animatronics
This is one of the coolest things I've seen in years, if you can do this with all the super dangerous animals and prehistoric animals it will be world changing
It's kinda naive to think these animals are going to be set free, that's just gonna end up as another free willy situation but magnified x3000...
The majority of the animals in captivity now can never go back into the wild, though I feel this is a step in the right direction. This will probably take years to be able to be used in the way we hope, but maybe it can keep them from putting more in captivity and someday the only real animals in captivity are the rescue and release animals
@@NA-cr7up Good point. That is also a possibility. I find these robots very cool, but I think they should keep zoos and conservancies in existence because they do a hell of a lot to keep animals from going extinct.
You can make specialised places for breeding projects, the animals don't need people to look at them.
@@dianehall2248 A place that made a true effort to create a truly massive, exciting, and interactive environment for intelligent animals like dolphins would be nice, but nobody really wants to throw all of that money into something without making even more money as the carrot. We're going to have to shift out priorities as a species massively before we'll be able to ethically house animals like this. Robotic dolphins and other animals could excite people about nature & science simultaneously and in a couple of decades there wouldn't be any need for new animals to be "acquired" for the entertainment trade. People like Joe Exotic would have no place in the world anymore, if anybody can go to the park and play with a "baby tiger" for example. The money they make from robotic amusement parks could fund conservation as well.
They won't be. But they will stop breeding them and buying them. That's what Sea World has moved toward. They no longer breed their Orcas.
"Do you think we should replace captive sea animals with robotic ones?"
yes and no.
- the animals who need actual care (aka the rescued ones, who cant live in the wild anymore bc of an injury or because they are an endangered species, etc) would be kept in relative captivity but under newer, better conditions. their habitats should be a lot bigger and as natural as possible, with little human intervention.
- animals wouldnt be doing any tricks, these "spectacles" could use the robots as replacement. it would be good for educational purposes only, and people could see them from up close in an enclosure. but tricks and contact should be limited too if not obsolete - mainly because it can give kids (and even adults lol) the idea that doing this with real animals is okay.
- people should be abe to see the real animals (because money from donations and admissions contribute to conservation and rehabilitation efforts, like it was mentioned in the video) but from afar. allowing a bigger distance and limiting unwanted interactions (like in a safari or boat ride situation where you can see them out there in the wild)
ofc the first step would be really tricky and expensive, its a financial risk. but i dont see it as an impossible feat.
A dolphin robot is something I never knew I needed so bad lol. How adorable.
I would prefer the real thing not some metal tin can with flippers.
@@aylasthyston611 I wouldn't want to (or be able to) keep a live dolphin in captivity. A dolphin robot would be cool and you could keep it in a pool.
@@aylasthyston611 So your selfish. Some zoos genuinely care for animals and rescue them when they're found injured then after they are cared for release them. That is a very small percentage of zoos. Your time and entertainment must be more important than the well-being of the dolphins. It'll be the same experience but your mind makes all the difference. Tell yourself it's real and get used to it.
@@njay4399 sorry I worded my comment wrong and for your information I love animals i love them more than humans. I never said you should keep them in cages for entertainment and I know not all zoos are bad.
I just think having the real animal is better than some robot unless the zoo or wildlife rescue is that bad if that's the case yes! They should have robots instead
at least they can't hurt the animals any more and let the good charities,zoos and rescue places take care of them.
@@njay4399 and that depends if they can be released. They might be captive bred, endangered or injured that badly that they can't be released. Good or not but I know the bad ones shouldn't have any animals.
Its a bit strange thinking about going to an aquarium to watch robots swim. It reminds me of how eventually tech will take over our entire world. It's ironic that we're using tech to say "hey protect actual nature." I'm not totally sure how I feel about this
I will send my own surrogate robot to experience the other robots in captivity.
You’re not sure how you feel because you stubbornly want to find a conspiracy where there is none. Sometimes things in life ARE simple and ARE better - if we can create technology to replace animals in captivity that a stupid population of people craves, then we should.
You can not replace zoo’s or Aquariums, they are essential to Conservation….marine parks like sea world on the other hand?…yes these robots are absolutely the answer to that problem
Can you imagine, Just imagine for a second that back in the bushfires season of 2020 Zoos didn't exist, Koalas GONE!
@SugarCanines And who knows what pther animals!
Agreed that zoos are necessary. However, marine parks are definitely necessary too. Not every marine park in the world equals 'Seaworld'. There are so many places that do invaluable work in conservation, animal rescue and rehab, and studies that benefit wild populations. They are just as vital as regular zoos.
@@NamuTheOrca Sure, I mean Sea Turtles REALLY benefit from them!
@@andresparra114 Yeah! But there's also lots of places that rehab seals/sea lions, dolphins, sea otters or sea birds. And since this video is specifically on dolphins, there is amazing research being done with captive dolphins that would be impossible with wild animals, but which totally aids in their research and protection. Of course there's shabby places and badly kept animals but that goes for all situations where people keep animals. Doesn't take away from the good places that do important work and always try to improve animal welfare.
I wanna hug whoever invented this project we need more humans like you who creates technology and cares about nature and environment.
i am right here waiting for u baby
what about the animals that were born in captivity that cant be released into the wild because they dont know how to behave?
@@PhillipAmthor after all those animals pass away, then they will use robots instead of actual ones.
@@tenet748 it's sad they can't release them now. I understand why they don't want too, but animals shouldn't be locked up.
@@PhillipAmthor sanctuarys probably
I hope the technique is improving and we can make dinosaurs that feels and move realistically. That would be awesome 🙏🏼
What about when it eats what do you think about that? And drinks?
@@nakaithomas8519 it’s a robot
@@nakaithomas8519 its a robot.
It’s a robot
Boi xD
But anyways, that would be so cool!
Those kids at the pool look so excited to see Del. I love that
Honestly, I'd love this idea! Though the animals raised in captivity can't be released into the wild, as they can't fend for themselves. There's other options for that, I hope.
I would LOVE to see a dinosaur zoo that utilizes animatronics made to recreate our current ideas of these lost giants. Then again, that's me being a dinosaur nerd ^^
And animal robots could also be used for conservation and even monitoring nature/wildlife in areas that would be a big far out for people. Theres tons of uses for life like animatronic animals. And if we ever got the tech to build synth versions, that would be even cooler.
Plus I would love to see some robot dinosaurs is the wild, that would be pretty cool.
Me: Whoa, cool!
Also me: *Hears Jurassic Park theme music playing in the distance* 👁️👄👁️
oh crap