Hello Pakistan,, Exmuslim RUclips Channel Arabic Allah Muhammad Ki Boss Hai,,, Exmuslim Sameer RUclips Channel,,, Islam Producer of Terrorist and Disgusting Over Population Growth,,,, Islam has wasted my many years,, can anyone call me a natural example,, proud to be a Muslim,, I can give six thousand examples, I was ashamed to be a Muslim,,, now I am a non-Muslim
Being a lums graduate myself who always saw the inequality of resources and networks even within the uni and other unis as well, I'm proud of you my man for bringing this up in a coherent and articulate manner
I am an Indian and about 10 years back when i was doing my MBA from ISB, we had a few students from LUMS who came on an exchange prog. Honestly we were shocked with how far behind these guys were in their academic prowess. They never scored even average grades. I now get why true talent never gets recognised in pakistan. Sad.
@@worldgeography2229 to be honest some of them are really smart, but the smart ones are always those who exited pakistan decades ago and are basically american or british
Well, its not quite true. I've been researching Pak-India relations for 2 years. But when it comes to Indians, I found them very irrational and proudly where they've fantasized that Indian soldiers have somehow superpowers and Pak is Bhikari etc. And surprisingly, where Israelis themselves don't bother to defend themselves, Indians find it their moral duty to support Israelis and abuse Muslims.
@@worldgeography2229 what talent would you expect from a country where landlords killed a French Phd holder teaching in IBA Karachi just over a feudal fight? Where son of an elite killed a middle class ACCA medalist. Where a qualified professor is kicked out and immediately hired by Harvard? Where even the noble prize winner was not appreciated. I’m a teacher and I have a student who learnt game development from YT out of interest. He is just 13. His parents are forcing him to go in military. People will watch 3 idiots but not learn any lesson. Circumstances and opportunities matter a lot in making you genius. Even I had to take additional courses online to make my math foundation to be admitted to a foreign university. I’m sorry, revolutionists are afraid of being born here.
To safe guard the Zamindari system, Jinnah wanted a separate country. India moved on with New Land Reform and abolished Zamindari System by 1951. We can see the outcome of this two System.
Man keep doing it. Repetition will open mind of these frogs of wells. Keep up the Good work. Heard something worth watching after a long time on social media. Cheers
- Colonialism never left us. Bas sirf chamri ka rang tabdeel hua hai. - Hum idhar (DHAs and Bahrias) aour tum udhar (Slums and Ghettos) ka naara aaj bhi relevant hai har roz ki zandagi main. - The Cover of the Book says it all. Thanks Shahzad Bhai. May ALLAH Bless you
I think pakistani people need to stop beleving india and pakistan have same issues. We do not have the same issues. If we were simmilar, india would also be a failed state like pakistan.
Unfortunately, you are true. Increasingly, that right theory is now valid ONLY in this obscene aspect. This explains why Pakistan was never allowed to become a TRUE ISLAMIC state ! The excellent Pakistani peoples suffer as a result and the mercenary agenda of the elites ensure that Islam too suffers along. After fighting a "jihad" against the Afghan communist, the elites moved on to tarnish the jihadist they cultivated and abused ! 😢
"Elites" a generation which funded movement of Pakistan and hired a lawyer from London who did not speak Urdu nor did a namaz, enjoyed sipping whisky smoking cigar. Jiski Lathi Uski Bail,
Every one of us is against these elites but deep inside wish to be the part of this circle. Everyone is agianst the illegal & immoral practice of law but deep inside practices the same / wish to practice. Unless and untill we don't deal with our psychological biases we can't break the chain. You are doing the best from your side but this nation has lost senses & consiousness to unchain their selves from elites(parasites).
Brilliant podcast . I love your style of topic selection & presentation. my Q is why awam of Pakistan full of talent & passion (Zazbah) can not REVOLT when 70% of Banking, insurance & industrial assets are owned by 22 families
Excellent vlog 👍 Thank God India went thru land reforms soon after independence and Manmohan's opening of the economy, resulting in a very strong middle class today.
Although i dont like this man for many reasons but m watching this video for 5th time. Kia zbarrrrdast topic behtreen tareeqey se explain kia hy. I really admire it !!!
MY GRAND FATHER WAS ENGINEER LIKE MY DAD,HE WAS GIVEN THE TITLE OF "SIR" FOR HIS WORK , HE WORKED WITH SIR GANGA RAM. AND I HAVE NO REGRETS, BUT I WILL TAKE MY AVENGE.
1. I hear a few interesting things about Pakistan. The "experts" are primarily "military" type. 2. They interpret everything in military terms. 3. "Elite" always dominates the public discourse including diplomacy. Famous leftist Bhutto was a core elite. 4. In spite of all perverted policies, Pakistan's economic performance was comparable to India's till 1990. 5. Javed Akhtar observed that unlike India (say Mumbai) Pakistani poverty is not visible to an ordinary visitor to say Lahore. 6. The poetry- Gazals- that we listen to do not make much mention of socio-economic conditions? Can you throw some light please?
pakistan from early 1960 to 1985 received billions of dollars aid from usa thats why pakistani economy performed well but all this money is not used for education and development of country all this money went in hands of army for purchasing militery hardware and building business empire of army. So in short as billions of dollars are being pumped into pakistani economy each year during these years but private sector didnot grew at all
Even as per lastest oxform report pakistani top 1 percent elite controls 24 percent whealth mean while indian top 1 percent elite owns 40 percent whealth thats why poorty is not visible in pak as in india but due to current economic crises this is changing now poor in paking is getting poor as nd poor and rich is becomming richer every day. Dollar in last 5 years went from 115 pkr to 284 pkr and gold in last 3 years went from 50 thousand pkr to 2lakh pkr per tola. Intrest rate in pakistan is above 20 percent So rich in pakistan become 3 times richer in just 3 years meanwhile cars bikes and homes become unafforable for poor and lower middle class
Pakistan just about any country needs a French or Mao revolution that comes from within, not from kids eating McDonalds ice cream asking for revolution but garmi mein kharab honay ka darr.
Bravo bro, It takes courage to choose some sensible and sensitive issues like this. I say we need more educated people to come to terms even to listen to this type of material.
Amazing I miss Many Books which you interviews last Personalities Podcast like "HH" books and "Dr ishtiaq" and this "Dr Rosita Armyage book" not found here in PAK thanks for This
Alien government in India is a veritable chameleon. Today it comes in the guise of the Englishman; tomorrow perhaps as some other foreigner; the next day, withoutabating a jot of its virulence, it may take the shape of our own countrymen. -- Rabindranath Tagore
The main issue is higher education. Higher education is not for everybody. Most people require skills to get jobs. Academic education does not guarantee jobs. It is high time jobs are delinked from academic degrees.
Likewise, I guess I am the only Pakistani with an allergy to elites. And maybe I am the only one born and raised abroad and still very much a Pakistani.
Not all Gujarati Muslim families belonging to Saudi Vohras, memons, Ishmaelis and others left for Pakistan. Lots many left behind in Mumbai and Gujarat. Many got into legitimate business while many joined Daud gangs. India got worst of both world.
It is well known fact for the last 70 years,, my grandfather and my father talked about that for years. She wrote about something that may surprise you but not the masses.
Shehzad bhai agar in Rosita sahiba se koi pehchan hai to book ko thodi affordable range me lane ko kahiye. Over 3000 rs on Amazon india, not affordable for most people. Thank you. Great review by the way
I really hope that the current generation that derives its patriotism from Nehru bashing, realises what Nehru did for India. He had his own shortcomings and has made mistakes; but as an ardent student of history myself (not WhatsApp educated), I can suggest that history cannot deny what Nehru did for India. Of course there have been others too, but my comments are directed more towards who love to bash Nehru. Similarly for PVNR, Dr Manmohan Singh and AB Vajpayee. Nehru's socialism was very unique, different from what was being practiced in post WW II year. Whilst the Europe gravitated towards Keynesian model, Nehru and his rota of bureaucrats transformed socialist idea to India's demands and what stemmed out of it was Nehruvian Socialism. Most Nehru bashers may be tempted to call me a communist history student; however as a matter of truth I have more preference for Von hayek's economic model that Germany pursued after WW II. We as citizens of India have lot to thank and indebted to Nehru for his foresight and contribution in making modern India. Having said this, it of-course Nehru cannot be acquited of some geo-political blunders that he made but neither can he be painted as a historical villain what current ruling party of India would like people to believe in.
Well only one I found bashing nehru and Gandhi are these rape jihad born islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistani porkistani bhikharistani Pakistanis for whom nehru and Gandhi were jahanumis and from whom they had to snatch control of porkistan. Do u know what derogatory names these filthy Islamist terrorist 💩 write for nehru and Gandhi in there randikhana madrassa curriculum?😂😂😂
Nehru is no bashed simply or blindly the list of territories he distributed are too huge to list here 😅 when the time came for decisive action he fumbled he had feuds with various other leaders before and after independence most famous of which were S.C Bose Sardar Patel and Dr.Ambedkar he was not the man of his own values see the case of Manju Sultanpuri he was easily influenced as in the case of V.K Menon (he was India’s first commissioner to UK and did fairly bad job mentioned in the Memoirs of K.M Panikkar) but despite that he supported him bringing crony culture he did take heed of elders words as in the case of China(Despite the warning of Sardar Patel) he led India through failed industrial polices backstabbed J.R.D Tata by forcing nationalisation on India’s industrialists under him India grew at only 4-5% he started failed foreign policies like the hilariously named non alignment movement which backfired spectacularly in the 71 war when Indonesia despite being a member of the movement aided Pakistan in it’s misadventure India under a hardcore communist like Netaji or the free market capitalist Rajaji would have been far better than democratic Nehru regime(I am not against democracy) to sum up here are some of gifts to the nation: 1)Coco islands and Kabo valley were given to Burma 2)The Kashmir issue 3)Giving up Aksai chin and parts of Arunachal almost without a fight 4)He and Sardar Patel can jointly responsible for the security lapse in the case of Gandhiji(Tushar Gandhi has written an interesting book on that called let’s kill Gandhi) 5)Rejected the UN permanent seat(this was also mentioned by Dr.Sashi Tharoor) 6)He did complete the desire of Gandhi which is dissolving congress
Now some argue his regime was not that bad but for he every good he did two wrongs frankly I am apolitical but the truth is objective not subjective facts are facts and yes he was a different type of socialist a Fabian one perhaps
Thank you very much for your very informative and very interesting program Very nice to know about the details Gorey chaley gaiye aur brown masters have taken over 75 years have passed but you will not find any major changes Elite class is still ruling over the country Presently PTI led by Imran Khan has pledged to change the status co Personally I am very much confused about the motives of Imran Khan Is he really sincere Or is he working on foreign agenda
Nice to see an academic channel in Urdu. Whereas the overview of the book is fine but as a Pakistani delving into the causes of things that happened in the first ten years will give a better a understanding. From 1947-1957 the Pakistani government didn’t have many options. Jinnah insisted the muslim industrialists of Bombay to come to Pakistan to establish Industry. At the time of partition there were only 3 factories in geographical Pakistan. Some of these industrialist were promised monopoly in some sectors. You have highlighted that most projects housing etc were done in Karachi but you fail to mention that Karachi accounted for more than 70% of the economic output. It was also the Federal Capital thus deserving further investment. Most of these guarantees were broken with nationalization of Bhutto and subsequent marginalization of the urdu speaking muhajirs - the group most responsible for the early decades of relative success of Pakistani Economy.
India was fortunate that it is too large to be captured by a small elite such as the Aitchison College gang (although we did have a Doon School elite that was very active in politics, and is still active in Media). A Stephens College/JNU/ Delhi University group still is active in the Congress and Leftist circles, but 8 years of Modi's rule has defanged them. But the effect of these groups was certainly significant in the first 40 years of independent India's history. Nowadays, no one gives a damn which school you studied in.
Phle congress k paaltu the.. ab Modi k paaltu h.. fark kuch nhi h.. media me sab wahi log h jo modi k aane se phle the.. aur aadhi BJP me Congress wale hi MLA MP bne hue h.. dimag ki batti jala bro.. 😂😂
The narrative of Gujarat or Gujaratis is incorrect and misleading. Muhammad Ali Jinnah was born in a small village called Jhirrik in Thatta district of Sindh, he was a Sindhi and Sindhi speaking and got his primary education from a Sindhi primary school in that village, which is on the record in the school's general register. During 1970's his domicile was changed by establishment because of been in inferiority complex for his being born in an undeveloped rural area. I have read myself about his place of birth in the government published text book for perhaps 4th primary class in the late 1960's in the lesson titled "Quaid-e-Azam". Later the syllabus was revised and this also got changed along with Lahore's "Yadgar-e-Pakistan" to "Minare-e-Pakistan". Moreover he belonged to my ancestors some from whom still live in the aforementioned village, where I had also visited the ruins of his family residence some 30 years ago.
WHEN MY FATHER TOOK RETIREMENT HE DID WORK FOR THEM FOR FEW YEARS, AND QUIT THE JOB WHEN THEY ASKED HIM, TO GIVE A REPORT THAT ALL WORK WAS DEFECTED TO SAVE "INCOME TAX", MY FATHER DID NOT LIKED TO WORK FOE "BECO" BECAUSE HIS "EGO" WAS TOO STRONG.
Wesay hi nafrat hy in elites se. Idhar 90% population ko 2 time ko khaane ko nahi mil rha or ye elites ko koi faraq nahi parhta roz whiskey or clubs me moj marte rahte hen.
10:07 mjhay samjh nhi ai k ZAB na jb nationalise ker dia. Tou us nationalisation ko BB na q disown ker dia tha? Yani elite capture ka wo bh hissa bni thin? Ya ZAB (jamhoori marshal law administrator) ki trha sb kch hathya gae thy? Jisay bb na accept ker k wapas denationalise kia
I agree with almost ALL of your take on the book, except when you end with Karachi has no connection with the State, because Karachi's have their own security, their own electricity, their own water. That is not just limited to the "upper class" it is also in the middle classes. If individuals cannot afford security they pitch in and get a guard for the street. Your narrative paints Karachi like it doesn't want to connect with the State. That isn't true. Karachi collects 35% of Pakistan's tax revenue, and generates approximately 25% of Pakistan's entire GDP, and Karachi has a major share of 41.39% in the total income tax collection of the FBR - karachi has the population of 16,840,000 (2022) - The State and the Govts do not provide the security, the water, the gas, the electricity but has massive bills, and more taxes on the same - Please speak to someone from Karachi who does not belong to the "rich class" you're referring to. I am not sure you know very much about the Karachi of today.
It's good to see history from different perspectives. While it is true that in 50s, 60s a selected group was enjoying most of the benefits, but it's also true that growth happened and there was investment in new technologies and industrialisation. With nationalisation and resulting mismanagement, these industries didn't grow anymore or even ran into big losses, and there was no investment in new technologies, thus today these organisations have become redundant. One shouldn't forget that one has to grow first in order to redistribute later. BTW you skipped Zia, howcome there wasn't a privatisation drive under him ??? Who were the beneficiaries?? so things are not as clear-cut as being put. In social democratic countries, redistribution of wealth is done by taxation of the elites. Talking of taxation, the biggest economic sector of agriculture, doesn't pay taxes. Also, there were no REAL land reforms in Z.A Bhutto times. So was nationalisation really about social justice, or was it about targeting certain people in a power play...so a much more nuisanced approach is required if one wants to learn from history..
Some of the names you mentioned, of the old money families, are no longer as powerful as they used to be before 1971. Bhutto's nationalization ended their dominance.
Hello Shehzad, doing a wonderful job. It would be amazing if you could invite interesting guests from across the border...... Shekhar Gupta, Tavleen Singh, Smita Prakash. J Sai Deepak, Vikram Sampath and Sanjeev Sanyal have written interesting books recently.
@Football-Pundit J Sai Deepak is not historian but if you want to prove him wrong why don't you do with facts ? And talking about Vikram Sampat, what ever he has written in his books is well referenced and u can see that in his book at back
@Football-Pundit hahah I can see the how j Sai Deepak is downplayed these days . I am regularly seeing these kind of comments but nobody provides any counter evidence to what they say it’s just are they are on the face of Muslims and antinationals, they can’t just handle him.
@Football-Pundit what is the bias of j Sai Deepak? Don't In India ,only temples pay taxes and not mosque churches? Don't waqf act 1995 gave power to waqf board to capture any land of India? Don't indian history books have overglorified invaders and shown them as heroes and giving a clean to their endless atrocities and gen0cides of Indian civilians? Whereas showing indian rulers as villains?
Allah said, Muhammad is the last prophet, no more new prophets. Allah dropped quran from heaven and said this is the last book, this contains every possible knowledge which human beings will require for generations to come. Then how can some one dare to write new books? Think over it.
Shehzad bhai i disagree with u on ZA bhutto as just do a single podcast with someone who has been a victim of bhutto’s doing whether people of balochistan, workers party members, hostility towards india etc though obviously I’m in favour of civilian supremacy and it was sad how bhutto and bhuttos died but it doesn’t mean authoritarians can be label as good for democracy.
@@ThePakistanExperience naah shehzad bhai for me there’s no difference except for the system, as I can’t…..there’s no difference between treating the common man, inflicting your personal ideas to the whole society and in doing so the worst oppressions by each of these whether yahya, zia or bhutto…..i guess it’s easier for a lot of us to blame zia and move on but the reality is these ideas were already being glorified or promoted throughout our society for the sake of elite and majority of the middle class….even in zia’s era majority of Pakistan was behind this “jihaad idea”, hell majority of the muslim world because common person doesn’t have much time to think about all these things but it is always the elite of every region who decides the identity and ideology of that region but in Pakistan’s case our elite doesn’t love, own, respect and they are themselves very cheap, confused, slaves etc that’s why we have a society that majority of us doesn’t wanna live in.
If sanskrit came from outside of India, then how come there are 4 million manuscripts most of them not translated yet, and almost none found outside of India. How come such a depth literature and philosophical work was produced more than a 1000 year ago ? There must have been some cultural presence of that.
Boss I just read the whole book last night and came to your video now. You've an efficient talent of summarizing key topics in a easy way. Great effort ❤
Hello shehzad i am a regular follower of your channel and i admire your work a lot . Recently i read tehmina durrani's book my feudal lord and it was heart breaking but now i found that she is married to shehbaz sharif. Is she also from this elite circle or fighting for a real cause . What's your take on it?
U should know one thing he was there for his biometric when the rangers arrived to arrest him , He is not willing to surrender he is informing public from the day one ,unlike anyother leader who was lauched by establishment according to u . Nab has nothing to do with this arrest we all know so the intentions r v clear , thays why we need to protest against this so we can stop this cycle of power . Otherwise this rotten system will continue like always
Yar elite class wali bat tkriban ab her jagah he ....Mecca Madina tk me he ...jo elite paise wala he wohi 7 star book kr skta he.halaanke Mecca khana kaaba k andr se b ho k aa skta he full protocol me....elite class he r jagah hein india america franc england pakistan ....establishment me b inhi ki involvment he..... Jisko abhi b thora paisa aae wo unhi me rehna pasnd krta he..ap or hum jaise hazaro lower middles class bs sari zindgy mehnt he krte rehte hien.... Laikun sb k liye sb enjoy kro Pakistan se niklo agr yahan guzara nhi ho rha he to niklo dubai jao ....mehnat kro ...
You must study the history of before partition .the treasure bank pakistan had no any accout in bank this was the donation of some peples which they deposit in the bank .no any progress was in pakistan for awam education and india was liked by the long time from mughlia kingdom all the professinal peoples lived in india .because British Government almost lived in Dehli and othe countries .
@@tahirraza941 Muslims bachhe ko Bachpan se hi khuda ke khauf se bachne ko kaha jata hai...buzdil banaya jata hai...kab tak ye log sahen karenge?? Aur zinda murdo ki tareh jiyenge?? Imrann khan sach hi kehta hai...aapko ghabarana nahi hai😊
@@tahirraza941 Muslims bachhe ko Bachpan se hi khuda ke khauf se bachne ko kaha jata hai...buzdil banaya jata hai...kab tak ye log sahen karenge?? Aur zinda murdo ki tareh jiyenge?? Imrann khan sach hi kehta hai...aapko ghabarana nahi hai😊
The intriguing nexus of Lahori group has been down played Big land holdings have not been contained by feudal since 1947 in present day Pakistan whereas Congress under Nehru and Bengali leaders introduced land reform Hari report by Masood Khadder Posh were thrown in trash confusing it with religious injunctions and the unholy alliance is continuing on and on
Watch the podcast with Dr. Rosita Armytage here:
ruclips.net/video/SCgueX5TGGM/видео.html
Hello Pakistan,, Exmuslim RUclips Channel Arabic Allah Muhammad Ki Boss Hai,,, Exmuslim Sameer RUclips Channel,,, Islam Producer of Terrorist and Disgusting Over Population Growth,,,, Islam has wasted my many years,, can anyone call me a natural example,, proud to be a Muslim,, I can give six thousand examples, I was ashamed to be a Muslim,,, now I am a non-Muslim
ruclips.net/user/shortspyWOcF72pAc?feature
Dear Shehzad I want to buy this book
Where I buy this like in your hand
Not a cellphone
Being a lums graduate myself who always saw the inequality of resources and networks even within the uni and other unis as well, I'm proud of you my man for bringing this up in a coherent and articulate manner
Good to see this brave attempt. Even better that you reviewed a book this time. Thank you.
🙌
I am an Indian and about 10 years back when i was doing my MBA from ISB, we had a few students from LUMS who came on an exchange prog. Honestly we were shocked with how far behind these guys were in their academic prowess. They never scored even average grades. I now get why true talent never gets recognised in pakistan. Sad.
@@worldgeography2229 to be honest some of them are really smart, but the smart ones are always those who exited pakistan decades ago and are basically american or british
Well, its not quite true. I've been researching Pak-India relations for 2 years. But when it comes to Indians, I found them very irrational and proudly where they've fantasized that Indian soldiers have somehow superpowers and Pak is Bhikari etc. And surprisingly, where Israelis themselves don't bother to defend themselves, Indians find it their moral duty to support Israelis and abuse Muslims.
India Pakistan ever had exchange program?😳
@@worldgeography2229 cause smart ones are either butchered or they leave the country.
@@worldgeography2229 what talent would you expect from a country where landlords killed a French Phd holder teaching in IBA Karachi just over a feudal fight? Where son of an elite killed a middle class ACCA medalist. Where a qualified professor is kicked out and immediately hired by Harvard? Where even the noble prize winner was not appreciated.
I’m a teacher and I have a student who learnt game development from YT out of interest. He is just 13. His parents are forcing him to go in military. People will watch 3 idiots but not learn any lesson.
Circumstances and opportunities matter a lot in making you genius. Even I had to take additional courses online to make my math foundation to be admitted to a foreign university.
I’m sorry, revolutionists are afraid of being born here.
What she have said is a tip of the iceberg. Its a must must read. Thanks for the video.
🙌
To safe guard the Zamindari system, Jinnah wanted a separate country. India moved on with New Land Reform and abolished Zamindari System by 1951. We can see the outcome of this two System.
Man keep doing it. Repetition will open mind of these frogs of wells. Keep up the Good work. Heard something worth watching after a long time on social media. Cheers
🙌
- Colonialism never left us. Bas sirf chamri ka rang tabdeel hua hai.
- Hum idhar (DHAs and Bahrias) aour tum udhar (Slums and Ghettos) ka naara aaj bhi relevant hai har roz ki zandagi main.
- The Cover of the Book says it all.
Thanks Shahzad Bhai.
May ALLAH Bless you
Bahrias means ?
@@anuragpatil4073Bahria Town search karlo.
@@anuragpatil4073 'Baharia town' is a high profile area of elites in Islamabad.
I think pakistani people need to stop beleving india and pakistan have same issues. We do not have the same issues. If we were simmilar, india would also be a failed state like pakistan.
When I read Dr Stephen Lyon in the acknowledgment section, I immediately knew that Dr Rosita knows the depths of this topic.
Very genuine and very very informative! I’m so glad I clicked this. More power to you!
Its two nation theory
1.elite nation
2.poor nation
Jinnah's 'TWO NATION THEORY' has failed successfully in 1971.
Unfortunately, you are true. Increasingly, that right theory is now valid ONLY in this obscene aspect. This explains why Pakistan was never allowed to become a TRUE ISLAMIC state ! The excellent Pakistani peoples suffer as a result and the mercenary agenda of the elites ensure that Islam too suffers along. After fighting a "jihad" against the Afghan communist, the elites moved on to tarnish the jihadist they cultivated and abused ! 😢
"Elites" a generation which funded movement of Pakistan and hired a lawyer from London who did not speak Urdu nor did a namaz, enjoyed sipping whisky smoking cigar. Jiski Lathi Uski Bail,
Every one of us is against these elites but deep inside wish to be the part of this circle. Everyone is agianst the illegal & immoral practice of law but deep inside practices the same / wish to practice. Unless and untill we don't deal with our psychological biases we can't break the chain. You are doing the best from your side but this nation has lost senses & consiousness to unchain their selves from elites(parasites).
Damnn
When you first uploaded the book name, it intrigued me a lot and got the book Alhmdulillah!!!
India also have big business families.
But they have contributed in building the nation, from every day items to cars and military equipment
that is true of every country. look at wealth inquality stats. India is far worse.
The days we are seeing today is because of these elites. And they are not ready to learn. They are simply incorrigible!
Malabar Hill and Nariman Point used to be like this till 10 plus years back until true democratisation happened
Brilliant podcast . I love your style of topic selection & presentation.
my Q is why awam of Pakistan full of talent & passion (Zazbah) can not REVOLT when 70% of Banking, insurance & industrial assets are owned by 22 families
Bcoz they have been drugged in the name of islam
🙌
They have the army to protect them Sir
Nice way of trolling.😉
Sorry to break your troll but that’s beCause no one wants to ride Vigo.
I hope you don’t get that ride in India.
Very educative and informative shehzad bhai. Keep it up.
It is absolutely true that only a few families have ruled Pakistan
True
Excellent vlog 👍
Thank God India went thru land reforms soon after independence and Manmohan's opening of the economy, resulting in a very strong middle class today.
Although i dont like this man for many reasons but m watching this video for 5th time.
Kia zbarrrrdast topic behtreen tareeqey se explain kia hy. I really admire it !!!
🙌
This guy speaks a lot of truth.
🙌
Yehi wo log hain jo sabse pehle Pakistan se baher bhag jayenge jab country Sudan ki tarah destabilize hone lagega.
MY GRAND FATHER WAS ENGINEER LIKE MY DAD,HE WAS GIVEN THE TITLE OF "SIR" FOR HIS WORK , HE WORKED WITH SIR GANGA RAM. AND I HAVE NO REGRETS, BUT I WILL TAKE MY AVENGE.
A book much needed for our innocent nation
Soha
dont call pakistan innocent .
it had done all the crimes knowing ly
I bought this book two months ago unfortunately yet to give it a read. I will surely finish it as soon as possible because it seems very interesting.
Man your channels is one of the gems of RUclips. Thankyou for your dedication to truth
❤
Elites! Churchill predicted that rogues and freebooters would step into the space left by the British when they departed
1. I hear a few interesting things about Pakistan. The "experts" are primarily "military" type.
2. They interpret everything in military terms.
3. "Elite" always dominates the public discourse including diplomacy. Famous leftist Bhutto was a core elite.
4. In spite of all perverted policies, Pakistan's economic performance was comparable to India's till 1990.
5. Javed Akhtar observed that unlike India (say Mumbai) Pakistani poverty is not visible to an ordinary visitor to say Lahore.
6. The poetry- Gazals- that we listen to do not make much mention of socio-economic conditions?
Can you throw some light please?
Yes till 4. Javed Akhtar stayed in a posh home and travelled with the elite.
pakistan from early 1960 to 1985 received billions of dollars aid from usa thats why pakistani economy performed well but all this money is not used for education and development of country all this money went in hands of army for purchasing militery hardware and building business empire of army. So in short as billions of dollars are being pumped into pakistani economy each year during these years but private sector didnot grew at all
Even as per lastest oxform report pakistani top 1 percent elite controls 24 percent whealth mean while indian top 1 percent elite owns 40 percent whealth thats why poorty is not visible in pak as in india but due to current economic crises this is changing now poor in paking is getting poor as nd poor and rich is becomming richer every day.
Dollar in last 5 years went from 115 pkr to 284 pkr and gold in last 3 years went from 50 thousand pkr to 2lakh pkr per tola.
Intrest rate in pakistan is above 20 percent
So rich in pakistan become 3 times richer in just 3 years meanwhile cars bikes and homes become unafforable for poor and lower middle class
Very interesting clip by an enlightened and brilliant host.
🙌
I really don't care now if Modi scraps Indus water treaty.Actually he has my blessing.
Pakistan just about any country needs a French or Mao revolution that comes from within, not from kids eating McDonalds ice cream asking for revolution but garmi mein kharab honay ka darr.
Bravo bro,
It takes courage to choose some sensible and sensitive issues like this. I say we need more educated people to come to terms even to listen to this type of material.
Amazing I miss Many Books which you interviews last Personalities Podcast like "HH" books and "Dr ishtiaq" and this "Dr Rosita Armyage book" not found here in PAK thanks for This
Alien government in India is a veritable chameleon. Today it comes in the guise of the Englishman; tomorrow perhaps as some other foreigner; the next day, withoutabating a jot of its virulence, it may take the shape of our own countrymen. -- Rabindranath Tagore
The main issue is higher education. Higher education is not for everybody. Most people require skills to get jobs. Academic education does not guarantee jobs. It is high time jobs are delinked from academic degrees.
Likewise, I guess I am the only Pakistani with an allergy to elites. And maybe I am the only one born and raised abroad and still very much a Pakistani.
Iam from
India but absolutely loved ur podcast .loved analytical approach
Not all Gujarati Muslim families belonging to Saudi Vohras, memons, Ishmaelis and others left for Pakistan. Lots many left behind in Mumbai and Gujarat. Many got into legitimate business while many joined Daud gangs. India got worst of both world.
It is well known fact for the last 70 years,, my grandfather and my father talked about that for years. She wrote about something that may surprise you but not the masses.
Thank you brother! you opened our eyes...
🙌
Janaab kitni videos daalain ge. Kahin burn out na ho jaayen!
Love your content and work
❤
Shehzad bhai agar in Rosita sahiba se koi pehchan hai to book ko thodi affordable range me lane ko kahiye. Over 3000 rs on Amazon india, not affordable for most people. Thank you. Great review by the way
Thank you. I think it hasn't been printed in India yet, when that happens it'll be cheap to get in India.
واھ ڇوڪرا واھ... زبردست
Very well explained thank you plz make videos on real history of Pakistan?
Pakistan British k baad aajad nahi hua ,balki bas charaha badal gya elite k Roop me ,jo ab Pakistani hi dekhta hai.
Pakistan need to get freedom
❤ nice True knowledge. First episode I like
I really hope that the current generation that derives its patriotism from Nehru bashing, realises what Nehru did for India. He had his own shortcomings and has made mistakes; but as an ardent student of history myself (not WhatsApp educated), I can suggest that history cannot deny what Nehru did for India. Of course there have been others too, but my comments are directed more towards who love to bash Nehru. Similarly for PVNR, Dr Manmohan Singh and AB Vajpayee. Nehru's socialism was very unique, different from what was being practiced in post WW II year. Whilst the Europe gravitated towards Keynesian model, Nehru and his rota of bureaucrats transformed socialist idea to India's demands and what stemmed out of it was Nehruvian Socialism.
Most Nehru bashers may be tempted to call me a communist history student; however as a matter of truth I have more preference for Von hayek's economic model that Germany pursued after WW II.
We as citizens of India have lot to thank and indebted to Nehru for his foresight and contribution in making modern India. Having said this, it of-course Nehru cannot be acquited of some geo-political blunders that he made but neither can he be painted as a historical villain what current ruling party of India would like people to believe in.
Well only one I found bashing nehru and Gandhi are these rape jihad born islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistani porkistani bhikharistani Pakistanis for whom nehru and Gandhi were jahanumis and from whom they had to snatch control of porkistan. Do u know what derogatory names these filthy Islamist terrorist 💩 write for nehru and Gandhi in there randikhana madrassa curriculum?😂😂😂
Nehru is no bashed simply or blindly the list of territories he distributed are too huge to list here 😅 when the time came for decisive action he fumbled he had feuds with various other leaders before and after independence most famous of which were S.C Bose Sardar Patel and Dr.Ambedkar he was not the man of his own values see the case of Manju Sultanpuri he was easily influenced as in the case of V.K Menon (he was India’s first commissioner to UK and did fairly bad job mentioned in the Memoirs of K.M Panikkar) but despite that he supported him bringing crony culture he did take heed of elders words as in the case of China(Despite the warning of Sardar Patel) he led India through failed industrial polices backstabbed J.R.D Tata by forcing nationalisation on India’s industrialists under him India grew at only 4-5% he started failed foreign policies like the hilariously named non alignment movement which backfired spectacularly in the 71 war when Indonesia despite being a member of the movement aided Pakistan in it’s misadventure India under a hardcore communist like Netaji or the free market capitalist Rajaji would have been far better than democratic Nehru regime(I am not against democracy) to sum up here are some of gifts to the nation:
1)Coco islands and Kabo valley were given to Burma
2)The Kashmir issue
3)Giving up Aksai chin and parts of Arunachal almost without a fight
4)He and Sardar Patel can jointly responsible for the security lapse in the case of Gandhiji(Tushar Gandhi has written an interesting book on that called let’s kill Gandhi)
5)Rejected the UN permanent seat(this was also mentioned by Dr.Sashi Tharoor)
6)He did complete the desire of Gandhi which is dissolving congress
Now some argue his regime was not that bad but for he every good he did two wrongs frankly I am apolitical but the truth is objective not subjective facts are facts and yes he was a different type of socialist a Fabian one perhaps
Can you make video on Abdul Ghaffar Khan
Thank you very much for your very informative and very interesting program
Very nice to know about the details
Gorey chaley gaiye aur brown masters have taken over
75 years have passed but you will not find any major changes
Elite class is still ruling over the country
Presently PTI led by Imran Khan has pledged to change the status co
Personally I am very much confused about the motives of Imran Khan
Is he really sincere
Or is he working on foreign agenda
Nice to see you r doing book reviews
A big business Muslim family from Bombay didn't migrated to P@kistan "Azim Hasan Premji's" family. If possible please make a video about this family.
Azim Premji was Ismali Muslim hence stayed in India. Ismali Muslim were not taken in Pakistan or treated badly
@@sandeepnerurkar4918 OK 👍
Master peace ✌️ love hogia bhai for exposing these peoples
❤
Great delivery man, keep it up 🎉
🙌
Nice to see an academic channel in Urdu.
Whereas the overview of the book is fine but as a Pakistani delving into the causes of things that happened in the first ten years will give a better a understanding.
From 1947-1957 the Pakistani government didn’t have many options. Jinnah insisted the muslim industrialists of Bombay to come to Pakistan to establish Industry. At the time of partition there were only 3 factories in geographical Pakistan. Some of these industrialist were promised monopoly in some sectors. You have highlighted that most projects housing etc were done in Karachi but you fail to mention that Karachi accounted for more than 70% of the economic output. It was also the Federal Capital thus deserving further investment.
Most of these guarantees were broken with nationalization of Bhutto and subsequent marginalization of the urdu speaking muhajirs - the group most responsible for the early decades of relative success of Pakistani Economy.
What muhajir get by going pakistan ?
Does pakistan muhajir bhave empire like wipro cipla lulu group and many more are founded by Indian muslim
India was fortunate that it is too large to be captured by a small elite such as the Aitchison College gang (although we did have a Doon School elite that was very active in politics, and is still active in Media). A Stephens College/JNU/ Delhi University group still is active in the Congress and Leftist circles, but 8 years of Modi's rule has defanged them. But the effect of these groups was certainly significant in the first 40 years of independent India's history. Nowadays, no one gives a damn which school you studied in.
Yes
Sir Mr Jaishankar (EAM) and Nirmala Sitaraman (FM) are also products of JNU.😅
Lol.. bro u are blind in many ways.. 😂
Phle congress k paaltu the.. ab Modi k paaltu h.. fark kuch nhi h.. media me sab wahi log h jo modi k aane se phle the.. aur aadhi BJP me Congress wale hi MLA MP bne hue h.. dimag ki batti jala bro.. 😂😂
@@mrinalinisingh3819 The institutions he mentioned represents the elite Idea and present day Congress is the voice of elites
Colonism never left, this country is still under colonization in different ways.
Two nation theory is mere manifestation of british divide and rule policy in context of subcontinent.
Syed irtiza alvi
From Rudyard Kippling's "The White Man's Burden" to "Elite Man's Burden"
Perfect description of two nations theory.
The narrative of Gujarat or Gujaratis is incorrect and misleading. Muhammad Ali Jinnah was born in a small village called Jhirrik in Thatta district of Sindh, he was a Sindhi and Sindhi speaking and got his primary education from a Sindhi primary school in that village, which is on the record in the school's general register. During 1970's his domicile was changed by establishment because of been in inferiority complex for his being born in an undeveloped rural area. I have read myself about his place of birth in the government published text book for perhaps 4th primary class in the late 1960's in the lesson titled "Quaid-e-Azam". Later the syllabus was revised and this also got changed along with Lahore's "Yadgar-e-Pakistan" to "Minare-e-Pakistan". Moreover he belonged to my ancestors some from whom still live in the aforementioned village, where I had also visited the ruins of his family residence some 30 years ago.
Absolutely You 💞 Your Way with We 🎉
WHEN MY FATHER TOOK RETIREMENT HE DID WORK FOR THEM FOR FEW YEARS, AND QUIT THE JOB WHEN THEY ASKED HIM, TO GIVE A REPORT THAT ALL WORK WAS DEFECTED TO SAVE "INCOME TAX", MY FATHER DID NOT LIKED TO WORK FOE "BECO" BECAUSE HIS "EGO" WAS TOO STRONG.
Where did you do your school and from which school?
The City School
Lyceum for A Levels
Then LUMS
Wesay hi nafrat hy in elites se.
Idhar 90% population ko 2 time ko khaane ko nahi mil rha or ye elites ko koi faraq nahi parhta roz whiskey or clubs me moj marte rahte hen.
I can feel you bcz every other guy is going through it.😢
What Is HSN ?
Aitchison college, Lahore
Lol I also heard HSN
They must have bought the Ferrari and other expensive cars🚘 in the time⌚ of crisis in last few months
10:07 mjhay samjh nhi ai k ZAB na jb nationalise ker dia. Tou us nationalisation ko BB na q disown ker dia tha?
Yani elite capture ka wo bh hissa bni thin?
Ya ZAB (jamhoori marshal law administrator) ki trha sb kch hathya gae thy? Jisay bb na accept ker k wapas denationalise kia
Agar inki annual income 100 million dollars , then why don't they help pakistani dying economy
100 million dollar is nothing. It's like 0.02% of GDP of Pakistan. 100 million me kya hoga?
All India Muslim League leaders were all given cash, land and sir title by the Britsh. The stoy still continues
Very true indeed
I agree with almost ALL of your take on the book, except when you end with Karachi has no connection with the State, because Karachi's have their own security, their own electricity, their own water. That is not just limited to the "upper class" it is also in the middle classes. If individuals cannot afford security they pitch in and get a guard for the street. Your narrative paints Karachi like it doesn't want to connect with the State. That isn't true. Karachi collects 35% of Pakistan's tax revenue, and generates approximately 25% of Pakistan's entire GDP, and Karachi has a major share of 41.39% in the total income tax collection of the FBR - karachi has the population of 16,840,000 (2022) - The State and the Govts do not provide the security, the water, the gas, the electricity but has massive bills, and more taxes on the same - Please speak to someone from Karachi who does not belong to the "rich class" you're referring to. I am not sure you know very much about the Karachi of today.
It's good to see history from different perspectives.
While it is true that in 50s, 60s a selected group was enjoying most of the benefits, but it's also true that growth happened and there was investment in new technologies and industrialisation. With nationalisation and resulting mismanagement, these industries didn't grow anymore or even ran into big losses, and there was no investment in new technologies, thus today these organisations have become redundant. One shouldn't forget that one has to grow first in order to redistribute later. BTW you skipped Zia, howcome there wasn't a privatisation drive under him ??? Who were the beneficiaries?? so things are not as clear-cut as being put. In social democratic countries, redistribution of wealth is done by taxation of the elites. Talking of taxation, the biggest economic sector of agriculture, doesn't pay taxes. Also, there were no REAL land reforms in Z.A Bhutto times. So was nationalisation really about social justice, or was it about targeting certain people in a power play...so a much more nuisanced approach is required if one wants to learn from history..
Yeah .. nuisanced... really
@@parag1210
Ofcourse only if one wants something positive to come out from it
Great VLog!! 1000% Correct Analysis!!!
🙌
Some of the names you mentioned, of the old money families, are no longer as powerful as they used to be before 1971. Bhutto's nationalization ended their dominance.
Hello Shehzad, doing a wonderful job.
It would be amazing if you could invite interesting guests from across the border...... Shekhar Gupta, Tavleen Singh, Smita Prakash.
J Sai Deepak, Vikram Sampath and Sanjeev Sanyal have written interesting books recently.
Are you ready to fund for that? None of the above have to do with Pakistan.
@Football-Pundit J Sai Deepak is not historian but if you want to prove him wrong why don't you do with facts ? And talking about Vikram Sampat, what ever he has written in his books is well referenced and u can see that in his book at back
@@UndisclosedFacts Anyone who writes what these idiots dont like becomes mediocre. Ignore such scum.
@Football-Pundit hahah I can see the how j Sai Deepak is downplayed these days . I am regularly seeing these kind of comments but nobody provides any counter evidence to what they say it’s just are they are on the face of Muslims and antinationals, they can’t just handle him.
@Football-Pundit what is the bias of j Sai Deepak? Don't In India ,only temples pay taxes and not mosque churches? Don't waqf act 1995 gave power to waqf board to capture any land of India? Don't indian history books have overglorified invaders and shown them as heroes and giving a clean to their endless atrocities and gen0cides of Indian civilians? Whereas showing indian rulers as villains?
Allah said, Muhammad is the last prophet, no more new prophets. Allah dropped quran from heaven and said this is the last book, this contains every possible knowledge which human beings will require for generations to come. Then how can some one dare to write new books? Think over it.
Are you okay?
Shehzad bhai i disagree with u on ZA bhutto as just do a single podcast with someone who has been a victim of bhutto’s doing whether people of balochistan, workers party members, hostility towards india etc though obviously I’m in favour of civilian supremacy and it was sad how bhutto and bhuttos died but it doesn’t mean authoritarians can be label as good for democracy.
Not being labelled good. Just better than Yahya before him and Zia after him.
@@ThePakistanExperience naah shehzad bhai for me there’s no difference except for the system, as I can’t…..there’s no difference between treating the common man, inflicting your personal ideas to the whole society and in doing so the worst oppressions by each of these whether yahya, zia or bhutto…..i guess it’s easier for a lot of us to blame zia and move on but the reality is these ideas were already being glorified or promoted throughout our society for the sake of elite and majority of the middle class….even in zia’s era majority of Pakistan was behind this “jihaad idea”, hell majority of the muslim world because common person doesn’t have much time to think about all these things but it is always the elite of every region who decides the identity and ideology of that region but in Pakistan’s case our elite doesn’t love, own, respect and they are themselves very cheap, confused, slaves etc that’s why we have a society that majority of us doesn’t wanna live in.
Very good analysis 👍
🙌
Rosita Gori Thi Isliya wo Bach Gayi, Please take care of yourself,
❤
Lot of similarities with India ....we too have elite schools / colleges & families with high pedigree !!
Doon school dehradun comes to mind.
But they are not the top institution of India and thankfully most of the educational institutions are of the government
If sanskrit came from outside of India, then how come there are 4 million manuscripts most of them not translated yet, and almost none found outside of India. How come such a depth literature and philosophical work was produced more than a 1000 year ago ?
There must have been some cultural presence of that.
Boss I just read the whole book last night and came to your video now. You've an efficient talent of summarizing key topics in a easy way. Great effort ❤
❤
Hello shehzad i am a regular follower of your channel and i admire your work a lot . Recently i read tehmina durrani's book my feudal lord and it was heart breaking but now i found that she is married to shehbaz sharif. Is she also from this elite circle or fighting for a real cause . What's your take on it?
She is from an elite and well connected family too.
U should know one thing he was there for his biometric when the rangers arrived to arrest him ,
He is not willing to surrender he is informing public from the day one ,unlike anyother leader who was lauched by establishment according to u . Nab has nothing to do with this arrest we all know so the intentions r v clear , thays why we need to protest against this so we can stop this cycle of power .
Otherwise this rotten system will continue like always
This guy is part of a new elite.
The old school tie network is very much alive in India too. This is a colonial hangover.
All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.
Individual income or company turnover of 100 million usd ?
Company hee hoga
How many companies in Pakistan have a turnover over 100 million usd about 800 cr inr ?
Commendable. Please do more
🙌
Any generous one here who can send me this book on my address?
To buy, in this inflation, is bit difficult for the student.
Yar elite class wali bat tkriban ab her jagah he ....Mecca Madina tk me he ...jo elite paise wala he wohi 7 star book kr skta he.halaanke Mecca khana kaaba k andr se b ho k aa skta he full protocol me....elite class he r jagah hein india america franc england pakistan ....establishment me b inhi ki involvment he..... Jisko abhi b thora paisa aae wo unhi me rehna pasnd krta he..ap or hum jaise hazaro lower middles class bs sari zindgy mehnt he krte rehte hien.... Laikun sb k liye sb enjoy kro Pakistan se niklo agr yahan guzara nhi ho rha he to niklo dubai jao ....mehnat kro ...
3:24 wese sir ka khitab to Allama sorry sir Allama iqbal aur sir syed Ahmed khan k paas bhi tha ...zra sochiye 🤔🤔🤔🤔
دو قومی نظریہ
Two Nation Theory
You must study the history of before partition .the treasure bank pakistan had no any accout in bank this was the donation of some peples which they deposit in the bank .no any progress was in pakistan for awam education and india was liked by the long time from mughlia kingdom all the professinal peoples lived in india .because British Government almost lived in Dehli and othe countries .
Very good analysis
🙌
Hey dude...can you also make a video on ExMuslims in India or Pakistan!!
Blasphemy case bna k Mar den gy.. Aisa radical request nhi Karna plz..
@@tahirraza941 Muslims bachhe ko Bachpan se hi khuda ke khauf se bachne ko kaha jata hai...buzdil banaya jata hai...kab tak ye log sahen karenge?? Aur zinda murdo ki tareh jiyenge?? Imrann khan sach hi kehta hai...aapko ghabarana nahi hai😊
@@tahirraza941 Muslims bachhe ko Bachpan se hi khuda ke khauf se bachne ko kaha jata hai...buzdil banaya jata hai...kab tak ye log sahen karenge?? Aur zinda murdo ki tareh jiyenge?? Imrann khan sach hi kehta hai...aapko ghabarana nahi hai😊
@@tahirraza941 radicals
The intriguing nexus of Lahori group has been down played Big land holdings have not been contained by feudal since 1947 in present day Pakistan whereas Congress under Nehru and Bengali leaders introduced land reform Hari report by Masood Khadder Posh were thrown in trash confusing it with religious injunctions and the unholy alliance is continuing on and on
Department of Irrigation, not agriculture