IU is definitely one of the few performers who can just stand still and sing. It’s one thing to sound good but the emotions in her singing is what captivates the audience. So beautiful 😍
They are soo lucky to have watched this live IU performance The audience, the staff, the artist damn they're lucky. I would feel honored if i were one of them. to have watched this beautiful perf hayst. Y'all this is what u call performanance!!
0:40 at first I thought Irene was not really reacting much, then I realized she was just trying not to cry but really, it's more like "Wendy reaction" to me. I was quite shocked at Wendy's reaction throughout the whole performance, she never moved her eyes away... She looks like she's about to cry all throughout. Anyone could tell she was really moved. As everyone should be, honestly.
yes, she did. she was actually singing along with IU the whole time (or maybe mouthing the lyrics) I just did not talk about her because, you know, she was not in the frame of this video.. ^^
Taeyeon can hit an A1000 everything you said is true but this performance and all of MMA occurred before Jonghyun's death. IU sang a song after his death at SBS Gayo Daejun which was dedicated to Jonghyun however.
@@Cr-zo5je no one was talking about blackpink,why do u keep dragging ur faves when it's not even related to them people like u starts fan wars and its so annoying...
кσσкιєѕ ™ This song is a really sad song, honestly. It is briefly about singing to someone who is missing or gone, and trying to call out to them but having no luck. It also addresses promising to find them and remembering dark times being alone. While the song in general is sad with the lyrics, the idols are suffering with the loss of Jonghyun too. Because this song is sad and can have things in common with the loss of him, it can become sadder than it already is.
i believe that some of the idols here wanted to shed tears but can't because their makeup would get affected. IU touched everyone's hearts here not by just her singing but also her pure soul. Irene is emotional I can see and Wendy and Seulgi are in awe (I believe Joy too). Yeri is emotionally singing along.(from other fancams)
All the girls I admire in one video! All props to Hyun and Wan for being able to hold their tears while listening to her golden voice. I will surely cry and shed tears when I hear this live!
The weight of being a Leader and having this Image of being an Ice Goddess pushed to her by SM is too much, Irene is so sweet and caring and funny. She should cry if she wants to because she is Human too
for context, IU invited independent artists of south korea to perform in the biggest stage, biggest award show. thats why the idols got so touched this performance. they all know the struggle of being an artist. what more the struggles of those who never get signed by companies, and IU gave them their moments and exposure
To all the people who are saying Irene is sleepy or reaction less..if you got nothing good to say then just keep quiet I've been fan of Irene since long..and I'm sure that she was not sleepy or tired,she is a type of person who is strong and who don't let her emotions out..but in this video it's quiet apparent to me that she was trying to hold back her tears ..if you can't see that then idk.. Please stop assuming negative things which you are not sure of
I think iu sang this song to remember the victims of the sewol ferry disaster(2014). At that time, many victims were still in the sea without returning to their families. because of Politicians who oppose the salvage of the ship for political reasons. so this song made Red Velvet so sad.
![[마마미누] 2024 MAMA 대기실 판독기🔍부터 찐 VIP의 빅뱅 무대 리액션까지🙊 1초도 놓칠 수 없는 미미미누의 오사카 48시간! | MAMAMINU (JPN SUB)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6xE82Cnv8pI/mqdefault.jpg)
Every artist was amazed by iu performance on mma that time. It's a history. It touches everyone heart :')
Blackpink FOREVER
@@Cr-zo5je not when some idols asked who had the most memorable performance, most of them answered iu ( hyuna, wannaone )
@@Cr-zo5je omg stop, no one asked
@@Cr-zo5je 👉🚪
@@Cr-zo5je no one asked!
IU is definitely one of the few performers who can just stand still and sing. It’s one thing to sound good but the emotions in her singing is what captivates the audience. So beautiful 😍
웬디 뭔가 존경을 담아서 경청하네 ㅎㅎ 이쁘다
DP 잠오는거 아닌가요
chimchim 감명받은 표정인줄알았는데 듣고보니 그런것같기도하네요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
앞부터 풀영상 보시면 아시겠지만 노래 중간에 "제 이름은" 나올 때 소름이 돋는지 팔을 껴안고 경청하는 모습 확인할 수 있습니다^^
Blackpink
@@Cr-zo5je 갑자기?
They are soo lucky to have watched this live IU performance The audience, the staff, the artist damn they're lucky. I would feel honored if i were one of them. to have watched this beautiful perf hayst. Y'all this is what u call performanance!!
@Lamb 4 evahh really 😍😍😍
Iu is LEGEND and they all are lucky to hear iu live that time😭😭 I also want to meet iu once in my life 😫😭😭please God please
I want to be their lol
My love IU touches everyone's hearts 😊
Noshin Rahman me too.... 😃
Honestly, IU's song never fail to make my heart and eyes watery..
:')
와 진짜 아이유는 넘사벽이다..
0:40 at first I thought Irene was not really reacting much, then I realized she was just trying not to cry
but really, it's more like "Wendy reaction" to me. I was quite shocked at Wendy's reaction throughout the whole performance, she never moved her eyes away... She looks like she's about to cry all throughout. Anyone could tell she was really moved. As everyone should be, honestly.
Apparently, Yeri actually did cry
yes, she did. she was actually singing along with IU the whole time (or maybe mouthing the lyrics)
I just did not talk about her because, you know, she was not in the frame of this video.. ^^
Taeyeon can hit an A1000 everything you said is true but this performance and all of MMA occurred before Jonghyun's death. IU sang a song after his death at SBS Gayo Daejun which was dedicated to Jonghyun however.
Blackpink is the best
@@Cr-zo5je no one was talking about blackpink,why do u keep dragging ur faves when it's not even related to them people like u starts fan wars and its so annoying...
I always crying when heard this song
Susanti Namgil can you tell me the meaning of this song?
кσσкιєѕ ™ This song is a really sad song, honestly. It is briefly about singing to someone who is missing or gone, and trying to call out to them but having no luck. It also addresses promising to find them and remembering dark times being alone. While the song in general is sad with the lyrics, the idols are suffering with the loss of Jonghyun too. Because this song is sad and can have things in common with the loss of him, it can become sadder than it already is.
Tea Spill :'( aw Thank you x
This performance was before Jonghyun passed away though.
Blackpink
i believe that some of the idols here wanted to shed tears but can't because their makeup would get affected. IU touched everyone's hearts here not by just her singing but also her pure soul. Irene is emotional I can see and Wendy and Seulgi are in awe (I believe Joy too). Yeri is emotionally singing along.(from other fancams)
This is the most memorable performance of IU..makes everyone watching touch and almost cry...
irene dont want let other knows that she is crying too
Blackpink is
@@Cr-zo5je ?????
@@Cr-zo5je wut
@@Cr-zo5je 🤡
@@Cr-zo5je 💩🖕🏻
i literally crying right now. if you read this. just you know that 2020 have been the hardest year for red velvet. we love you irene.
I just want to hug all luvies:")
Queen IU voice is so mesmerizing!!!
U can’t tell Irene is trying not to cry because she always blinks and moves he head or her eyes💗
내가 지금까지 노래에 감동 해 우는 건 없었는데
IU 언니 노래는 곧 울어 버릴……
사랑해요…💜
Oh no wendy look like she's going to cry
Irene trying to hold back tearsss
the fact that Irene is 2years older to IU
Rossevelle Legisniana omg
Rossevelle Legisniana omg
My god
Rossevelle Legisniana 1year
Shinyoo Youn 2 years, irene 1991, IU 1993
Bae is so deep in her mind.. Stay happy Baechu ♥
This performance really made my tears burst everytime I watched thisㅠㅠ
why
No lie I cried watching this performance
I always feel amazed with iu performance. It really touched you heart
In other fancam I see our maknae hold his tears too. IU performance so beautiful in there 🥲
아이린 울음참는거..
자기보다 잘나가서 배아픈가봄
@@뭉-o5n ? 전환한적이 없는데?
@@뭉-o5n ㅇㅈ 누가봐도 울컥한것 같은디
제일 중요한 끝부분들을 왜 자르지.. 당시 이름에게 무대중에 아이유가 제일 예뻤고 여운있었던 부분이 제일 마지막 '끝나는 곳으로' 할때 '~으로' 부분에서 클로즈업 할때인데
All the girls I admire in one video! All props to Hyun and Wan for being able to hold their tears while listening to her golden voice. I will surely cry and shed tears when I hear this live!
Irene look so pretty by just sitting there 😍😍
아이린은 최선을 다하고 있다..
IU voice is really soothing 😌😌
Me watching IU MMA performance multiple times and still crying
IU did amazing.
Here and it's April 2020, Irene kept holding her tears.💔
Irene holding back her tears but I think Wendy already cry
Irene lúc nào cũng thế luôn cố nén nước mắt vào lòng...
Irene is my most favourite girl and iu is my 2nd. Love them both sooo much through the whole music industry
La musica de IU transmite demaciado.. es toda un artista en todo el sentido de la palabra ... la amo demaciado 😍😍
We love you Irene :) will always support you
웬디 왜이리 귀엽낰 ㅋㅋㄱㅋ
The weight of being a Leader and having this Image of being an Ice Goddess pushed to her by SM is too much, Irene is so sweet and caring and funny. She should cry if she wants to because she is Human too
우리 감성리더 힘든일 슬픈일도
많았죠?5명 캐리하고 엄마역할 하는거
보기 좋고 고마워요.
언니우니깐 맴찟ㅜㅜ
지은언니 진짜 노래잘부르고
유애나 레베럽인 1인은 반하고가요
@@챙-m3e 굳이 옜날 영상에다 그런댓 쓰고 다녀야 되나
@@챙-m3e 그게 웃겨서 정신연령 떨어지는 댓글 다는게 더 웃기네
She is Soo strong..I respect her so much
Proud of u my queen IU❤️
0:30 am I the only one who saw wendy streaming a tear down
IU 💟 ILoveyou ❤️
wendy looks transfixed every time watching other musicians
for context, IU invited independent artists of south korea to perform in the biggest stage, biggest award show. thats why the idols got so touched this performance. they all know the struggle of being an artist. what more the struggles of those who never get signed by companies, and IU gave them their moments and exposure
Look at Wendy!
推しが推しをみてるのは、最高すぎます😍
ㅠ̑̈진짜 이린언니 완언니 슬기언니 분위기에 취해있어
역시 아이돌 1인가수 원탑..
Wanna see Wendy and IU collab in stage together even cover any song or just special program like 'IU Pallete' or 'Idol Weekly' i dont care. 🥺
IU😍😍
To all the people who are saying Irene is sleepy or reaction less..if you got nothing good to say then just keep quiet
I've been fan of Irene since long..and I'm sure that she was not sleepy or tired,she is a type of person who is strong and who don't let her emotions out..but in this video it's quiet apparent to me that she was trying to hold back her tears ..if you can't see that then idk..
Please stop assuming negative things which you are not sure of
Acho que vou chora que musica mais linda
But why am I crying?? :'(
Wendy felt like crying
Wendy cry😭😭
😭 it touches everyone's hearts
Wendy is literally crying too
Irene dont cry
Wendy is so touching I think she's so cute.
Waw iu i love you
Iu 😭🤧😌😌
生で聞いたら絶対感動するわ😂
もう号泣やろな
Awww wendy😭
😭
Healing song
I think iu sang this song to remember the victims of the sewol ferry disaster(2014). At that time, many victims were still in the sea without returning to their families. because of Politicians who oppose the salvage of the ship for political reasons. so this song made Red Velvet so sad.
I can't believe that IU is Younger than Irene 😱
Is wendy crying or she is just holding her tears?
My poor wendy!!! Don’t cry! It makes me cry! 😭
I love them
My babies being strong.....it breaks my heart
Seulgi was trying to hold her tears too
Two beauties of Korea
My feelings same to irene
Wendy’s crying
ㅇ와 이게 바로 진정한 눈정화..
웬디우는거에요?
레드벨벳 귀여웡❣️
Oh no no no no 😨😨
Looks like she's holding back her tears
Wendy crying cute
웬디♡슬기♡는 아예빠졌고,ㅋ이린이♡는 감동을받았네ㅋㅋ
웬디 무슨 표정이 "아이구..(흐뭇)내새끼,,, 노래 너무 잘부르네((엄마미소"같음ㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋ
아이유는 웬디보다 한살 언니이에요. 그리고 선배이고.
she wanna cry
OMG! Irene está llorando?
Belen JeonPark Yep, junto con Wendy.
이름에게는 정말 명곡이다 ㅠ ㅠ
아이린 피곤해서 저런다고 하시는 분들 있는데 아이린 감정에 북받쳐서 눈물 날려는 거 참고 있는거예요 아이린 특유의 울음 참는게 있는데 그 모습이랑 똑같네요 눈도 시뻘게져 있고
평소 태도를 봤을때 피곤한게 맞는것같군요
@@김스-k1b ㅋㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@김스-k1b 누가봐도 울컥한거 참는거 같은데요?ㅋㅋ 잘못한거에대해서만 뭐라해야지 이런 영상에서까지 그런말해야하나 0:43
What are those names behind
걸그룹 5대여신 에이핑크 손나은 레드벨벳 아이린 아이유 블랙핑크 지수 트와이스 미나
소녀시대 윤아
fX 크리스탈
아이유는 걸그룹이 아닙니다 독보적인 싱어송라이터이며 배우인 아티스트 입니다
Strong silent type
baechuuu uljimayoooo~~~
Tại sao cắt phần kết thúc !!!!!!
goosebumps
i think they're crying
Wow they even had people in the back translating in sign language
짬밥은 아이유가 대선배님 나이는 아이유가 아이린 언니라불러야함 ~
Giá như không cắt phần engding
I think she was thinking of the moment Johyun's death.
Red Velvet Best Idol Group Alive