Zhuoxuan live is queen level ✨✨✨ Btw the sound of her mic in particular is really bad. Her voice is drowning and she's forcing so she can be heard. Curley gao... No words. God is a woman indeed. Her voice has that rock/jazzy power and feeling that most pop vocalist lack.
Yo no se porque eligieron a las 3 que ni siquiera saben cantar , lo horrible las akira desafina , lo que quiero decir que no tiene talento para canatr y su baile es mas o menos , habia algunas chicas en chuang 2020 si se merecian estar en ese grupo , ser seleccionadas (porque saben cantar y bailar )
Akira's been in the industry before the others but her singing is really not stable. She can't even control her voice. Also, she has a lot of parts but doesn't really give justice to it.
@@caroml2598 xiening literalmente es la bailarina principal del grupo y ha sido bailarina desde q estaba en gugudan, son un grupo si necesitan bnas vocalistas pero tmb necesitan bailarinas, las 3 no son bnas vocalistas pero esa no es la función d ellas en el grupo así d fácil nmas djdkdjkd si las 7 fueran bnas vocalistas a qn le darian las líneas fáciles o d rap...
Xilin sound so stable with an open mic while dancing not only for 1 song but 3 song wow, knowing she never had idol training background before join chuang2020 make me more amaze with her, she must be worked so hard in short period to be at this level
I’m loving the support and positivity in this comment section. In another comment section they were all hating on the girls, made me feel really sad. Even though it wasn’t perfect the energy was there and micon requires a lot of courage and sincerity, especially for the dancers who aren’t that confident and know that they still have to improve
Indeed. Also, I think this is their first time singing live without back track. I'm so proud of them and I know they will definitely improve in the coming months💙💙💙
Curley XILINNAYI GAO is indeed an ACE. What a vocal queen. Omygod. That sounded almost like the real CD that’s edited. YOU JUST SHOWED US HOW DESERVING YOU ARE TO BECOME A CENTER! Deeym! THAT STABILITY! 💙💙💙💙 it’s hard to dance and sing at the same time. This performance just proves how amazing she is. In fact, all the girls did their best. Kudos! 💙
Xie Ning and Zhao Yue, omg, they NEED to work more on their vocals, especially Zhao Yue...... Compared to the other members her vocal is too weak, almost problematic.
Is Zhao Yue the second girl that sing? If that is her then she the worst one in the group. She need to practice her singing more. XieNing for being in Gugudan I would expect her to have at least stable vocal but I guess not although her dancing and stage presence is one of the best in the group.
Although this is not perfect. This and hanclap are still my favourite performance of them because they performed it live without any back track or auto tune. I love the vibe here💙💙💙
yes this isn’t a flawless performance but at least the girls gave their all and sang 100% live at a countdown event, it’s considered a big event and they are bold enough to do it. hope that in 2021, we’ll get more open mics performance too. 出发吧 Bonbon Girls!
I know they trying to prove that they can sing live but they should consider that some members can't really do that. At least don't make it 100% live without backtrack. It's dangerous
Surprisingly the members asked them to do it without backtrack, even the dance line. According to a staff member they wanted to be truthful and real on the last day
全開咪, Wow ... 這些 硬糖女孩膽子真大。It really show off those who has the ability. However, for those who don't ... it really show them up. Time for more hard work I think.
Really love their courage. As we know BonBonGirl303 is an 'Idol Group' not a 'Vocal group'. So, i think we need to respect the '3 Non-vocal' girl who has that courage, especially Yifan (she is the least experienced girl) but I think she did better than Sally and Akira. She improved a lot. But yeah sally, yifan and akira need to work really hard in term of vocal. Jiayo 💪
Was there a mic issue, why’d two of the girls voice died down? Curley and Yijin was so stable 😳. There was one part during handclap I though Curley was singing and it was Yijin wow.
I just noticed the HUGE symphony orchestra behind them. why didnt tencent made them sing the ballad version of this song with live instruments it would've been iconic.
not all sang so well but this is normal and it is not just because of some mistakes that they will be terrible artists. i hope they don't get hate just because of mistakes that practically all artists have already made or will make someday.
?? I don't understand why everyone is saying nene singing is stable when it's actually not as stable as compared to curley?? Or am I the only one who think that way? Welp nvm
I wonder if the song's key is too high outside of Zhao Yue's and Xiening's vocal range -- they need more vocal backing in the song for Zhao Yue and Xiening's parts with a song that has a lot of jumping and if they're not comfortable with the breathing control yet.
- 今天的節目趙越和劉希寧唱出了扭曲的聲音。為樂隊做得最好的人是柯利·高·內內·陳卓軒·王一錦，做得好，聲音沒有失真。 - การแสดงของวันนี้ Zhao Yue และ Liu Xining ร้องเพลงเพี้ยน คนที่ทำได้ดีที่สุดสำหรับวงคือ Kolly Gao Nene Chen Zhuoxuan Wang Yijin ที่ทำผลงานได้ดีไม่มีผิดเพี้ยน ฉันว่าน่าจะมาจากการฝึกซ้อมนะ ดูการออกเสียงเสียงไม่ถึงเลยจ้าวเย่นี่เด่นเลยเสียงหลง หลิ่วเซี่ยหนิงเสียงไม่ถึง แต่ต้องเข้าใจเขาไม่ได้มาในสายVocal อาจจะมาสายDancโดยรวมเต็ม10เราให้โชว์นี้6คะแนนทำได้ออกมาไม่ดี - Today's show zhao yue and liu xiening sang a distorted voice. The person who did well for the band is curley gao nene chen zhuoxuan wang Yijin. Well done, the sound is not distorted
Yuss this is why I love my kings (bigbang) and queens (2ne1) although we should support this group too because they are still improving and I love how real they are
Zhao Yue..... Now.... Zhao Yue Now.... Shown Us your Break, Pump, Urban, Jazzy, Your Helicopter Break Dance style.... Also It's Time... Your Trully Ability in Dance.... Your Wushu Somersault.... Akira!!!!!!!! Jiayo!!!!!
RESPECT💪💪💪 This is how Real Live performing is... IDOLS nowadays rely of backing tracts. With difficult choreography today it is impossible to sound perfect live. The dance line needs to improve their vocals... But I think Sally and Zhao Yue should focus on rapping. In Totality this is a great LIVE performance. Especially the 4 Vocals!
![[Live] 前方超A预警（改编版） Ahead of Super A Warning - 硬糖少女303 BonBon Girls | 毕业演唱会 Graduation Concert 220724](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o0h04Au0uns/mqdefault.jpg)
![[BonBon Girls] "Ahead of Super A Warning" Official Dance Performance Video](/img/1.gif)
Zhuoxuan live is queen level ✨✨✨
Btw the sound of her mic in particular is really bad. Her voice is drowning and she's forcing so she can be heard.
Curley gao... No words. God is a woman indeed. Her voice has that rock/jazzy power and feeling that most pop vocalist lack.
Well nice to know they’re singing live...props to xiling, zhouxuan, yijin and nene for the stability and sounding like the official audio
@Emmargu so trueee! Im sorry to their fans but I literally laughed when Yifan's voice cracked and i cant really hear their voice when they sing
Yo no se porque eligieron a las 3 que ni siquiera saben cantar , lo horrible las akira desafina , lo que quiero decir que no tiene talento para canatr y su baile es mas o menos , habia algunas chicas en chuang 2020 si se merecian estar en ese grupo , ser seleccionadas (porque saben cantar y bailar )
Akira's been in the industry before the others but her singing is really not stable. She can't even control her voice. Also, she has a lot of parts but doesn't really give justice to it.
@@caroml2598 xiening literalmente es la bailarina principal del grupo y ha sido bailarina desde q estaba en gugudan, son un grupo si necesitan bnas vocalistas pero tmb necesitan bailarinas, las 3 no son bnas vocalistas pero esa no es la función d ellas en el grupo así d fácil nmas djdkdjkd si las 7 fueran bnas vocalistas a qn le darian las líneas fáciles o d rap...
😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Xilin sound so stable with an open mic while dancing not only for 1 song but 3 song wow, knowing she never had idol training background before join chuang2020 make me more amaze with her, she must be worked so hard in short period to be at this level
She had something better... She was at berklee. The girl isn't an idol. Actually calling her like that is an insult to her studies xD
She's a natural. I love her so much
😅😂😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅🎉🎉😅🎉😅🎉😅😅😊😊😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😅😂😅🎉😅🎉🎉
希林和王艺瑾真的稳 惊艳到我了。nene和璇姐有一点点瑕疵 可以忽略不计 凡凡大白嗓 无功无过 问题大的是赵粤 气息的问题 她不太会唱。刘些宁的问题不是气息 是音压 声音唱不了很大声。
趙粵真的很誇張
趙粵之前在的體系就是不需要磨練唱歌的地方，而且就連以實力著稱的韓團現在的打歌舞台基本都會有墊音幫忙襯著。
她是舞擔又不是vocal，為了襯托其他人的好而場場全開麥，對她的人氣真的很傷--因為全開麥大眾視線就不會focus在硬糖三輩子都跳不齊的舞蹈和軟綿綿的力度。
這麼說吧，如果今天硬糖不主打全開麥，而是主打刀群舞的話，大家會不會拿vocal的身份幫忙緩頰呢？
@@emdiana20 vocal 的舞蹈是有进步的 舞蹈比声乐容易学 声乐需要天分 但是如果之后赵粤作为舞担可以全开麦做得好的话 是一个出圈方式
@@emdiana20 另外你说的主打刀群舞 其实这不是他们能决定的 你要跟编舞师说一说
@@emdiana20 身为idol 不管是以唱还是跳而成功出道 唱跳都要会这不是很正常吗 舞蹈担当唱不好其实真的很正常 但都是可以学习 可以进步的 而不是说因为是舞蹈担当就不用增进自己的vocal 是这么说没错吧 而vocal也是一样 舞蹈也是需要进步的。至少以现在的赵粤来说 她唱副歌真的太跨了 唱不好其实真的没事 你看刘些宁 她唱不怎么好但她唱的不多所以还算可以接受吧。只能说 她自己也需要加油 把vocal再练练， 毕竟她以第二名出道 分到的part也不会太少 在这样拉垮下去 怕是真的会没part的。
Curley Gao & Nene & Chen Zhuoxuan 💗
All three beautiful and great singers that need no autotune
Wang yijin too ♥
Main vocal👍
I’m loving the support and positivity in this comment section. In another comment section they were all hating on the girls, made me feel really sad. Even though it wasn’t perfect the energy was there and micon requires a lot of courage and sincerity, especially for the dancers who aren’t that confident and know that they still have to improve
Indeed. Also, I think this is their first time singing live without back track. I'm so proud of them and I know they will definitely improve in the coming months💙💙💙
第一次听硬糖无修音的
我觉得张艺凡很棒❤️她虽然没有其他人那么有经验，但也不比其他人逊色，而且还算得上很好了
希林和王艺谨没有太大差别
nene和陈卓璇如想像中有点差别
(纯粹个人意见)
毕竟nene和陈卓璇不是学的这个专业都是半路出家的可能会比想象的差一点，而且陈姐还是自学的，不过肯定以后还会进步的啦
真心覺得進步了很多 高音那裡破了一點 但整體來說還是穩的 期待繼續進步啊
nene She did a great job today, her voice was amazing. Dance is very good. Beautiful dress, good hair, all good. ❤️🍓
She looked like an angel
能不能给希林 nene 陈卓璇来个歌唱表演啊 不能浪费啊这实力 真牛啊唱歌是
希林有上歌唱节目，跟容祖儿搭档唱歌真的很好听
还有王艺瑾
@@emilyyou1569 哈哈哈哈哈
加油女孩们！可以感觉到你们舞台的魅力，刚出道就勇敢尝试放弃backup，现在已经很棒了，相信你们未来会更棒！
趙粵跟些寧加油吧 很少全開麥翻車的這麼明顯 趙粵那part真的很可怕 希林是真的唱的很不錯
艺凡那个破音😂
看了今天金曲青春的平凡之路 感觉是因为唱跳的关系吧 边唱边跳真的好难🤣然后加上赵粤和些宁都是dance 然后艺凡你们也知道实力不是那么强 每次都在进步啦
@@xintongchek3018 女团唱跳是必备技能的吧 对平常人来说很难 对女团来说也很难的话 怎么配叫唱跳歌手呢 除了赵粤 些宁 艺凡以外 其他四位成员都做得很好 希林 艺瑾 卓璇 nene唱跳稳稳的 有发现什么吗 舞担全开麦车祸 vocal担当因为舞也跳得不错 所以很稳 不过我觉得她们只是这次发挥没那么好 毕竟唱不是她们最擅长的 跳舞她们会比较好 但是我还是希望她们可以在唱方面进步进步 这样就不用担心全开麦会车祸了 只唱好叫歌手 只跳好叫舞者 边唱边跳也很好才叫唱跳歌手 加油吧bonbon
@@xintongchek3018 艺凡赵粤和刘些宁都是dance
@@茶香-e8u 这个舞台基本都是四个vocal在撑着
Curley XILINNAYI GAO is indeed an ACE. What a vocal queen. Omygod. That sounded almost like the real CD that’s edited. YOU JUST SHOWED US HOW DESERVING YOU ARE TO BECOME A CENTER! Deeym! THAT STABILITY! 💙💙💙💙 it’s hard to dance and sing at the same time. This performance just proves how amazing she is. In fact, all the girls did their best. Kudos! 💙
I love to see the girls show live singing mic on like this. Hope they have more chance to do it in future.
全开麦真的很有勇气
Curley just amazed me so much😍
Nene u did well too❣️❣️
😂😅😂😊😂😊😂😊😂😊😂😊😂😊😂😊😂❤😊❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
😂😅😊😊😂😂😊😂😊😂😂😂❤😊❤
😅😂❤😊❤😊😂😊😂😊😂😊😂
The 4 lead vocals are so stable...
ท่อนแรกของเนเน่ คิดว่าน้องคงลดคีย์ลง เพราะไม่นั้นหลิวเจ้คงลำบากแน่นอน
I love this live versssion. I can get the feeling of the stage, not perfect but that very lively, i like this version.
Xie Ning and Zhao Yue, omg, they NEED to work more on their vocals, especially Zhao Yue...... Compared to the other members her vocal is too weak, almost problematic.
Add yifan to that list too lol
@@iMosi Yifan didn't do good nor did she do bad. But Zhao Yue and Xie Ning, you can CLEARLY tell they can't sing
Is Zhao Yue the second girl that sing? If that is her then she the worst one in the group. She need to practice her singing more. XieNing for being in Gugudan I would expect her to have at least stable vocal but I guess not although her dancing and stage presence is one of the best in the group.
@@lzi7622 if you dont think singing shaky and crack bad then im not gonna argue with you on this lol
@@long8240 Yep, Zhao Yue is the second girl that sings.......
Yijin may not dance as well, but she's stable while dancing, her musical background really helps
希林确实稳，觉得dancer唱的时候其他的成员应该帮忙垫一下。
我想這一定是一起唱的歌。跳舞時，每個人都應該累，聲音不會匹配。
单人的part
全开麦就是一个进步 期待你们往后给我们的惊喜💙
Curley g希林這女人太厲害！邊唱邊跳還能穩成這樣 不愧是我看上的人😎
Curley voice is awesome.💙💙💙💙💙🍭🍭🍭🍭🍭👑.great performance Bonbon Girls.👏👏👏👏👏👏
they want micon in the last show of theyear.They chose this themselves because they wanted to show their sincerity.
Although this is not perfect. This and hanclap are still my favourite performance of them because they performed it live without any back track or auto tune. I love the vibe here💙💙💙
yes this isn’t a flawless performance but at least the girls gave their all and sang 100% live at a countdown event, it’s considered a big event and they are bold enough to do it. hope that in 2021, we’ll get more open mics performance too. 出发吧 Bonbon Girls!
I know they trying to prove that they can sing live but they should consider that some members can't really do that. At least don't make it 100% live without backtrack. It's dangerous
They use too much backtrack until they lost their confidence to sing live.
Exactly!!!
Surprisingly the members asked them to do it without backtrack, even the dance line. According to a staff member they wanted to be truthful and real on the last day
U know if they don't take risks they would never improve and I don't think it was that bad actually it was pretty good
整体不错的 因为希林这个定海神针的存在 听到觉得oh no的时候 希林一唱 就被拉回来了 还有王艺瑾的表现也蛮惊喜的 很稳 Nene和卓璇的表现就有一点和想象中的不一样了 不过还是稳的 张艺凡的表现也还行 只听到了一句破音 些宁和赵粤就垮了 but也没啥好计较的 她们是舞担嘛vocal不稳也在所难免 好好练以后肯定能更好 最后小姐姐们全开麦真的值得表扬了～ 继续努力ฅ۶•ﻌ•♡
Curley/Xilin sounds amazing!
The God 4 vocals, are all stable even after dancing. the 3 dancers, needs to improve on LIVE performances, Nonetheless, Overall they are great.
Who is the 3 dancers?
@@crunchychestnut761 akira sally and yifan
@@Nuyoah_eliauk yifan? Since when?
@@crunchychestnut761 yifan has always been in the dance line together with akira and sally as she has been dancing ballet since young for many years
全開咪, Wow ... 這些 硬糖女孩膽子真大。It really show off those who has the ability. However, for those who don't ... it really show them up. Time for more hard work I think.
curley totally nailed the live singing + dancing
No wonder she is an ace! 👍
Curley the best❤️👍
Really love their courage. As we know BonBonGirl303 is an 'Idol Group' not a 'Vocal group'. So, i think we need to respect the '3 Non-vocal' girl who has that courage, especially Yifan (she is the least experienced girl) but I think she did better than Sally and Akira. She improved a lot. But yeah sally, yifan and akira need to work really hard in term of vocal. Jiayo 💪
這場最穩的就是四個vocal了，尤其是希林，她的聲音算是最有厚度的，在這種全開麥無墊音的情況下聲音不容易被吃掉，再加上她的唱功讓她顯得特別的穩。
nene後面有一句聲音有點被吃了有些可惜，不過總體來說四個vocal都很穩，我比較意外的是趙粵，她這場只要是她的部分幾乎全翻車，不是飄了就是聲音被麥克風吃了，我個人不太認為趙粵會是沒實力的人，所以我想有可能她是身體不舒服之類的吧？畢竟全開麥的情況下，她跟劉姐的聲音應該是最容易被麥克風吃掉的，如果再加上身體不舒服之類的情況，唱不好是很正常的，就希望她多練吧，拋開這場不說，趙粵本身的歌唱實力確實是需要多練。
張藝凡這場表現其實我還蠻意外的，我還以為輪到她的部分時會出車禍，結果沒想到前面還蠻不錯的，雖然不太穩，但是她聲音意外的很清晰，也沒有飄的很離譜，不過到後面快結束那裡整個大車禍，聽起來很像是氣不足了，還是要多練習。
劉姐的vocal其實本來沒有很穩定，音準飄掉我是不太意外啦，而且她的聲音總是很容易被麥克風吃掉，不過拋開聲樂上的問題，劉姐的舞蹈一如既往的好看，絕對是全團動作最乾淨俐落的人，希望劉姐可以多刁一下合舞的部分。
整體來說前面還好，拋開個人翻車的部分，後半部分的合唱也翻車了，不知道是不是大家表演到後面氣息不足的關係，只能說多加油了(ง •̀_•́)ง
話說我其實是看到有人說她們跨年直播假唱才找過來的，我實在搞不懂直播要怎麼假唱，而且她們在這種選秀出來的，如果假唱的話通常都會是被要求而不是自己說要假唱的，人家又不傻，沒事砸自己腳槓嘛呢(*’ｰ’*)
张艺凡破音耳聋吗
@@supermango7318 是破音啊，但好歹她有唱的时候的声音没有被吞🤣所以就是还要接着进步，还有进步空间
@@lykm8832 眼泪又不是JIEEEE贼药
@@supermango7318 好生动🤣🤣看字我都能模仿了。首先因为我喜欢张艺凡，所以相对其他人，我对她会有期待，也会包容，而且我是真的觉得她有进步，比之前勇敢了，不希望打击到她。当然张艺凡进步空间很大，所以我会期待接下来她每一个舞台。每个人的优缺点不同嘛，我就是觉得她表情管理特别好，有时候她跳的舞，加上表情，就让我觉得很好看很「入戏」。还有谢谢你有留意到张艺凡，还给予评价，希望下一次硬糖的舞台，你还可以评价一下张艺凡哦🙈
希林 王藝 陳桌 這三個都超穩
Nene還不錯
但其他三都不太行
全開麥真的很強
Curley is a real C , vocal and dance so stable
Nene & Curley 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
有時候半開麥就被說假唱，全開麥又被說唱不好，真的不知道批評的人在想什麼，自己又不會。再說唱跳墊音是正常的，我之前看影片說這是為了保證整個表演的完整性。網民們別再批評了好嗎。（以上是我看了各種講the nine和303的留言總結的，說的不好歡迎糾正）
然後我覺得像303這種vocal比較多的團體，如果麥可以分開調的話可以把唱歌比較不好的成員的帕墊音，這樣就比較不會有人批評吧...？
其实主唱都不错，就是舞担，尤其是赵粤
@@jqxx2538 我覺得還有劉些寧，因為她們是舞擔，vocal相對比較弱
@@sandy-wk4vm 只能说硬糖的运营没脑
@@shinn2303 我jio得你也没脑，在评论区里叫了个半天
我是覺得機會是留給準備好的人，如果還沒準備好，就想辦法藏拙才是王道，這樣全開麥，有些太穩，有些全程飄。。。慢誇張的。
第一次看他們表演 希林真的a爆了 整場表演眼睛一直追著她跑 她唱live比cd好聽很多
看了其他人 真的有些超穩 某幾個加油💪 演唱會開麥實力直接出來...
陈卓璇💐 Chen Zhuoxuan 💮
รุ้สึกตกใจกับเสียงเจ้าเย่.ที่ใด้อันดับ2
กลับกลายเป็นเสียงของอี้ฝานพัฒนาขึ้นเยอะคะ
คนที่เป็นเมนเต้นก็เสียงไม่ถึง ภาพรวมสเตจนี้ไม่ดีเลย
จ้าวเย่ร้องสดไม่ค่อยรอดมาแต่ไหน
希林超棒的耶，光出場那走路氣場就很女王，唱的第一句更是把我電暈😍
Was there a mic issue, why’d two of the girls voice died down? Curley and Yijin was so stable 😳. There was one part during handclap I though Curley was singing and it was Yijin wow.
Because the 2 cant really sing well. They only can dance well.
@@AAo-xt1bk what dou you mean by 'the 2 cant really sing well'?
Well this 2 are quite stable from the start till the end 'i like you song'
@@thinair6338 they were talking about Zhao Yue and Xiening lol
@@daeechrism3176 lol..🤣 sorry my bad. I thod it was about curley and yijin
这全开麦的实力真的很厉害，这几个vocal单独solo唱歌就好了，这广场舞的编舞真的笑死了
那你来编舞啊
拜托the9的粉丝就滚，不需要你来评价
chiawan wang沒有the9這個團是THE9請尊重好嗎
You are the best, please cheer up and support them !!!!!! BONBON GIRLS !!!!!
舞跳得不错👍🏼👍🏼 气势还是有的
P/S: 如果有2022年的选拔 主办方可以考虑开始让有兴趣参赛的艺人开始各自练习歌唱＋跳舞了 毕竟女团成员需具备的能力看起来是缺一不可的 如果以 后天努力来说 舞蹈可能会比唱歌容易练成
隔壁粉慕名而來的，這個舞台...是來告訴我希林的唱功嗎？
nene 卓璇的唱功也很好，仔細點聽吧
@@jenlrdf 不好意思我剛好硬糖最喜歡的就是卓璇跟nene但是光是聽歌唱實力希林的唱功跟別人比真的有壁
@@巫月-n6j 你說有壁我認證，我只是想說其他人也沒那麼差，尤其我就是前幾天被卓璇的打開圈到才認識硬糖的，唱功真的沒話說
@@jenlrdf 我是從創就喜歡陳姐跟nene的，只是我這條評論單純評論唱功，還有我留言也表示過我並不是硬糖粉而是折粉😂而且是獨唯，完全沒有要偏袒硬糖任何妹妹的意思😭我只偏袒我正主
Nene 💗💗💗
I just noticed the HUGE symphony orchestra behind them. why didnt tencent made them sing the ballad version of this song with live instruments it would've been iconic.
Vocal line’s so stable!!!
陳姐真的唱的太好了！！！
not all sang so well but this is normal and it is not just because of some mistakes that they will be terrible artists.
i hope they don't get hate just because of mistakes that practically all artists have already made or will make someday.
Tbh they're getting a lot of praise for having the guts to sing without backtrack, hell it trended
WOI LIVE WOI 😮,TANPA BACK SOUND🥹🍭🍬
KEREN SIII
?? I don't understand why everyone is saying nene singing is stable when it's actually not as stable as compared to curley?? Or am I the only one who think that way? Welp nvm
I wonder if the song's key is too high outside of Zhao Yue's and Xiening's vocal range -- they need more vocal backing in the song for Zhao Yue and Xiening's parts with a song that has a lot of jumping and if they're not comfortable with the breathing control yet.
Truee 🥲 but they too brave to sing without back up vocal live with mic on
@Emmargu umm that trended in weibo most ppl said the9 uses heavy autotune
วงนี้ center คนเดียวแบกทั้งวง ถ้าคนอื่นไม่พัฒนาขึ้นตอนแสดงสดบอกเลยลำบาก
希林真的稳，我觉得一凡也不错，因为她是一位dancer，可是是不错的
Yifan seem work hard and improve her self. !
硬糖這次表演是首次全開麥+無墊音，聽說是靠她們自己爭取回來。雖然還有很大進步空間，但看得出她們是對自己很有要求，才會作出這個選擇。這事業心這態度實在太棒了！期待下次還能見到全開麥無墊音的舞台，亦很期待能見到更完美的妳們！萬丈光芒不一般，硬糖少女303！
其他还是建议带耳麦，垫一点音比较好，王艺瑾，希林和陈卓璇可以全开麥，没问题
เกาเสียงไปได้กว่านี้ แต่มาเดกรุ๊ปเลยคิดว่าต้องดรอปพลังเสียงลงเพราะเมมเบอร์ทุกคนเสียงค่อนข้างเล็ก อาจิง+อี้จิน+เนเน่ไม่ใช่เสียงไม่ดีร้องไม่เพราะนะ แต่โดนเกากลบหมดไม่แปลกใจที่ทำไมคนถึงเชียร์เกาให้เดเดี่ยว สายเต้นนี่หนักใจเพราะไลน์เต้นก็ไม่ได้โดดเด่น ไม่มีช่วงให้โชว์ไลน์เต้นมาก ต้องพัฒนาเสียงร้องกว่านี้ สู้ไปปปป
Nene is doing great! I am looking forward to next mic on performance from Nene&Bonbongirls!
I agree 💯
我非常喜歡希林，
但是今天真的把她的妝畫老了
超不適合她！
对这个舞台基本都是四个vocal在撑着
Curley always continues to amaze me🥺💗
So proud of Yifan she really improved. Sally and Akira need to work on their vocals
Not agree with you
Leave Zhao Yue alone!
My bias is sally, but i think she need work on her vocal
@Emmargu ikr they need to improve their vocal skills
Emmargu yifan was pretty stable tho, she did crack a note but generally she did good
Nene she sings very well.❤🍓
希林 艺瑾 卓璇一如既往的好 nene开口不稳 但是之后还是很好的 只能说粤粤子需要多加强vocal吧 她唱第二段 才开唱不久就不稳 声音还消失 作为个idol其实蛮差了的 （个人意见啊不是故意针对） 凡凡各方面都要加油 但是在我看来凡凡进步真的很大呢 sally vocal也要加油她是不自信不敢唱吧 可是个人觉得sally比粤粤子好点吧 毕竟是女团 唱跳都要好吧
Nene sound good😍😍😍🤟🤟🤟
Nene 🌷💖
Curley's voice😌😌😌, love 😘😘😘
- 今天的節目趙越和劉希寧唱出了扭曲的聲音。為樂隊做得最好的人是柯利·高·內內·陳卓軒·王一錦，做得好，聲音沒有失真。
- การแสดงของวันนี้ Zhao Yue และ Liu Xining ร้องเพลงเพี้ยน คนที่ทำได้ดีที่สุดสำหรับวงคือ Kolly Gao Nene Chen Zhuoxuan Wang Yijin ที่ทำผลงานได้ดีไม่มีผิดเพี้ยน
ฉันว่าน่าจะมาจากการฝึกซ้อมนะ ดูการออกเสียงเสียงไม่ถึงเลยจ้าวเย่นี่เด่นเลยเสียงหลง หลิ่วเซี่ยหนิงเสียงไม่ถึง แต่ต้องเข้าใจเขาไม่ได้มาในสายVocal อาจจะมาสายDancโดยรวมเต็ม10เราให้โชว์นี้6คะแนนทำได้ออกมาไม่ดี
- Today's show zhao yue and liu xiening sang a distorted voice. The person who did well for the band is curley gao nene chen zhuoxuan wang Yijin. Well done, the sound is not distorted
张艺凡叫kolly gao柯利?
@@Xy-lp5zk 他沒有提到藝凡呀
@@Xy-lp5zk 是curley 高
@@Xy-lp5zk 打擾一下，我的意思是Curley唱得很棒。
@@annischan7187 是的，是的，我不是在說一帆。張藝凡在這個舞台上唱歌。另外，他們以100％的自信跳動優美。
You are always number one in my heart, Nene. I will support you, don't be afraid.💓
Chen zhuoxuan voice was very stable
Truth Mic on/live singing gives us stage feels. The very reason why I love bigbang and 2ne1. I'm glad BBG did it live.
They too brave to choose sing without back up vocal 🥰
Yuss this is why I love my kings (bigbang) and queens (2ne1) although we should support this group too because they are still improving and I love how real they are
@@p.rodriguez7279 Yes I'm a big fan of Bonbongirls too. Been supporting/voted them since chuang days 😊
鼓勵！！就是要給他們全開麥啊⋯⋯又不是開不起，每次都墊那麼多 聽得很爽 但是舞擔們要再加油！！看好你們
兩個破音了
你是认真的吗？我看里面也只有四位可以、其他的太划水了
จ้าวเย่ เธอได้ที่ 2 นะ omg เพี้ยนอะไรขนาดนั้น
เนเน่ทำได้ดีมาก สู้ต่อไปนะ เป็นกำลังใจให้เสมอ
ใช่ค่ะ+1
เนเน่ควรได้ที่สองมากกว่า ผลงานเห็นได้ชัดเจนมาก😁
เราคิดว่าลำดับขึ้นอยู่กับฐานแฟนคลับ
เมนแดนซ์คือเพี้ยนทุกคนอะ เสียงหลงมั่ง ไม่ถึงมั่งนั่งขำทั้งเพลง5555
เอาจริงๆคือ เมนโวคอลคือช่วยทั้งวงเลย
让刘姐和赵粤全开麦还是有些吃力了，但给全开麦一个大写的赞
对，艺凡赵粤和刘些宁都是dance这个舞台基本都是四个vocal在撑
Nene Zheng Naixin 🤟❤️
Curley & Zhuoxuan the best ,so stable vocal!!!
เซียหนิงกับ อี้ฝาน ประคองคีย์ได้อยู่ ส่วนจ้าวเย่...... ในรายการตอนเขาให้แรพนางบอกนางสายโวคอล เป็นไงล่ะ เห็นตั้งแต่ตอนร้องเพลงรายการเสียงทุกคนละ เปิดมาเกา เนเน่ จั๋วเสวี้ยน ดีหมดพอถึงคนที่สี่จ้าวเย่ แบบเพี้ยนไม่ไหว งง ดีไม่เอาเพลง we are young มา จ้าวเย่ไฮโน้ตด้วยหนิ ไม่งั้นคงพังหนักกว่านี้แน่
แต่พอไปเห็นวงอื่นขอชื่นชมวงนี้นะ กล้ามาก แบบร้องสด100% ไม่มีแบคกราวน์เสียงofficialรองรับ คือสุดยอดอ่ะ มันให้ความจริงความซื่อสัตย์ออกมา อันนี้ชอบ อยากเห็นวงอื่นๆมีร้องแบบmic on 100% แบบนี้บ้าง
ในความคิดเรา นักร้องไทยทำไมร้องสดเพราะจังและร้องสดจนเป็นปกติ จนว่าตามไอดอลจีนเหล่านี้ รู้สึกว่าการร้องสดมันยากเย็น เรากลับเทียบคนไทยร้องเก่งกว่าเยอะมากร้องสดทั้งนั้น จนบางครั้งเราคิด หรือว่าไทยเราลิปซิ่งเนียนมาก เราเองที่ไม่รู้ถึงคิดว่าไทยร้องสดกันเป็นปกติแล้วร้องไปเต้นไปเพราะอีกด้วย
Nene 😻
Nene i love you🥰🥰🥰
Nene.
四个大vocal，就是要给她们真唱机会，三个舞担就算不是太好，但是跳舞好看。
舞都不齐，还能好看，i服了you
@@shinn2303 小妹妹回家耕田不要出来秀智商昂。就这还不齐？人家后面handclap的舞台你看了吗？dance break部分你看了吗？啥都没看来这里说人家跳舞不齐给我整笑了
@@OngJiaYangBrandon 看完了哦，依然不齐呢，不过4个歌担真心不错，继续加油哦
@@shinn2303 这叫不齐？那你来跳吧，我看看你跳的怎样再来说话
@@happyday2373 真的不齐 看the9的吧
Zhao Yue..... Now.... Zhao Yue Now.... Shown Us your Break, Pump, Urban, Jazzy, Your Helicopter Break Dance style.... Also It's Time... Your Trully Ability in Dance.... Your Wushu Somersault.... Akira!!!!!!!! Jiayo!!!!!
4 singers sang well and the others I don't like, as they sang, supposedly singing well😢😢😢😢☹️☹️☹️
สู้ๆนะคะสาวๆBon Bon Girl 303 #lovenene 🎀
Such a fan of Curley!😍
vocal line did great
四大vocal只有五字是完美的，其她走音的的走音不稳的不稳，三个非vocal可怕
四大vocal都很好，请勿对比，其他三位糖妹都是舞担，他们都很好
五字在handclap的第一句进得不好吧，也算不上完美
一斤唱的也不錯啊
twwuwu ？你只会听第一句吗？没有希林带着节奏那晚被骂的更惨了
@Zhen Zhen Chen 他不是在說你吧，你誤會了
Nene💕
她们很努力了! 卓璇和希林vocal最稳，艺瑾和nene都有一些走音的地方，赵粤和张艺凡要多练练哦~ 加油↖(^ω^)↗第一次开麦不错了
你忽略劉姐了~她也要加油💪但是其實這次藝瑾比陳姐還穩！陳姐唱到後來氣有點虛
@@謙謙-q8n 嗯刘姐也要加油 不过不得不说 舞蹈挺稳的
Curley voice 🥰
唱功立见高下，几个vocal都表现很稳定。👍
些宁粤粤唱歌还要再加油呀~！老父亲担心.jgp
nene，璇璇，一斤发挥的很不错呀，虽然有些瑕疵，但是很不错(^▽^*)
小艺凡比起创时只能靠滤镜来听的大白嗓算进步了（老父亲安心！
来表扬下希林！！希林太强啦！唱歌稳得一批suki！( ˶´v`˵ )
啾啾女儿们
RESPECT💪💪💪
This is how Real Live performing is...
IDOLS nowadays rely of backing tracts. With difficult choreography today it is impossible to sound perfect live.
The dance line needs to improve their vocals... But I think Sally and Zhao Yue should focus on rapping.
In Totality this is a great LIVE performance. Especially the 4 Vocals!
剛成團半年就敢開全麥 硬糖少女真的很相信自己的實力 我記得火箭少女開全麥是場悲劇 希林是真的很強
其实也没有想象中的那么垮，希林和王艺瑾很稳，张艺凡这次也是有进步，刘姐可能一开始没那么好，不过到后面其实很不错。硬糖少女是最棒的💜💜💜
喜欢希林可以看一看 m.douban.com/group/topic/204146526/
里面是她的翻唱跟原创
@@xinbeileeyau5566 谢谢，其实我是个团粉，但最喜欢的就是希林💙
@@xinbeileeyau5566 找到了好多没听过的，希林好棒💙
Nene Sound so great ❤️❤️❤️
Zhang Yifan ❤