she doesn't look at notes constantly, and she goes nicely through the lesson in a solid structure, easy to follow, very adult oriented teaching, I think great teachers should teach like this
It's been years since listening to her live and I never get tired of it...utterly entrancing. Professor Garber and Professor Greenblatt were the reasons I fell in love with Shakespeare
There was this one lecture I was watching from this Professor where she discussed the fact that because men played women characters back in the Elizabethan Era, it may have influenced the way Shakespeare wrote the women characters in his plays. Idk but it was a very interesting topic!
Being sequestered at home as a result of Covid 19, I decided not to waste the time and have been fishing through RUclips for every Shakespeare play. I did this several years ago and found many more versions of the plays than are there now. There used to be the whole series of BBC Shakespeare plays from the 1970s, which had now famous actors, in their first roles and new to television. Then I found these brilliant lectures to flesh them out after watching therm, before watching a second version. While at school back in th 1950s / 1960s, Shakespeare was always on the curriculum - a play a term !! Those of us who are my age, when everyone received a classic education, with Latin from 6 and Greek - if you were bright - from 8 ! We cut our teeth on all classic literature from the age of 6 or 7 ! Our teachers were like this professor, in it to educate and widen our personalities The language therefore, is familiar and not difficult. Then, for French and Spanish 'A' levels at 16 years old, you had 4 classic books in those languages from the 16th century - Racine, Moliere / Calderon etc, to date, so we had to be fluent in the equivalent Shakespearean English, in those languages as well.
Thanks for a wonderful lecture. What a amazing luck we have those lectures at our finger tips. Eternally grateful I am to the professor and the person posted this.
Shakespeare is always connected to innovation processes digging high deeply in Shakespearian plays is no doubt enriching ones horizons and widening the literary perceptions
So glad I stumbled across this excellent series! Out here in the provinces (my small town has six traffic lights) I crave intelligent discussions about the Bard and, alas, there are few opportunities! Thanks for the posting, good friends!
@@jasonyntig717 Good for you! The truth is we moved last year to a larger city and now we have too many traffic lights! But now we can walk to Starbucks!!!
This is exciting stuff, but I don't understand her objection to "seems like." Does she want you to say "is like"? This "seems like" a hard and fast rule for her, which can squelch a meaningful discussion or completely valid ideas one is attempting to express. If I were in the class, I might be too intimidated to express my thoughts for fear I could not meet her standards of articulation.
Please - she must have lectures on the other plays? Would be great to hear them. By the way, I recommend her book. I bought it after finding these videos and it's fantastic.
Good point on the comedies vs the tragedies. It depends on the production, for a low budget Shakespeare in the Park atmosphere, I prefer the comedies. There is a slapstick element and crowd interaction that make them very relatable. The tragedies take more recourses to bring out. I would include the Histories in this. That said, there are some very good movies to watch, the BBC is always good. The Hamlet with Dave Tennent is incredible. I also really enjoy The Hollow Crown for the War of the Roses.
I would like to invite you to a battle of wits, but i see you unarmed. I actually feel jealous a bit when i see someone who is more experienced about Shakespeare than i am. ❤
Well, you started your reading with the very best! I just finished his Richard III and I can highly recommend it. Richard III is one of the very best villains in all of literature, by the way, and yet he has a dark humor. Happy reading!
@@vozamaraktv-art5595 "Of man's first disobedience..." Oh well that will be an experience! I read the poem decades ago and that opening line is all I remember! Enjoy!
Do you have/can you make a playlist for this series. Please please add link in the description of these videos. You’re doing a magnificent public service. God bless.
I will give a thought. Nobody knows who Shakespeare was. He also plagiarized a lot. Almost none of his plot lines did he actually write. Go further, many people question if he even wrote some of the plays he's accredited for writing. Is it possible that Shakespeare was not just one person. Perhaps an editor, with many writers under his study. An analogy, take Walt Disney. That would explain his extraordinary genius.
Yup, because "extraordinary genius" and "Walt Disney" are almost synonymous, aren't they? Everyone thinks Walt drew all those cartoons himself. You really know how to pick an analogy.
Despite her overbearing manner and the inevitable waves of left-wing ideology that listeners will be sitting through, this class on Shakespeare is worth anyone's time. She has obviously done a tremendous amount of work, and she certainly knows her subject.
Dolphins, that deals with physics. It is an old proverb, that any sailor on an island would know, a storm is on the horizon. That is due to atmospheric pressure. There is another saying, when sound travels far and wide, a storm is soon to betide. The clouds form in a high pressure zone. the dolphins react to the pressure by rising to the surface.
she doesn't look at notes constantly, and she goes nicely through the lesson in a solid structure, easy to follow, very adult oriented teaching, I think great teachers should teach like this
It's been years since listening to her live and I never get tired of it...utterly entrancing. Professor Garber and Professor Greenblatt were the reasons I fell in love with Shakespeare
She’s amazing , I am not a native English speaker but I couldn’t stop the video till it’s end !!!
Same
Yes, I feel the same way. And despite the difficult topic it is easy to understand
There was this one lecture I was watching from this Professor where she discussed the fact that because men played women characters back in the Elizabethan Era, it may have influenced the way Shakespeare wrote the women characters in his plays. Idk but it was a very interesting topic!
It's a bit Shakespearey. But I think of her with no clothes and it makes me less nervous.
This professor is a true intellectual. Her lectures truly nourish my mind.
Delighted to have access to these. Thanks for posting, whoever was responsible. Dr. Garber is a wonderful, thoughtful guide through these plays.
Did you study in Harvard University ? I have some questions for the University.
Being sequestered at home as a result of Covid 19, I decided not to waste the time and have been fishing through RUclips for every Shakespeare play. I did this several years ago and found many more versions of the plays than are there now. There used to be the whole series of BBC Shakespeare plays from the 1970s, which had now famous actors, in their first roles and new to television. Then I found these brilliant lectures to flesh them out after watching therm, before watching a second version.
While at school back in th 1950s / 1960s, Shakespeare was always on the curriculum - a play a term !! Those of us who are my age, when everyone received a classic education, with Latin from 6 and Greek - if you were bright - from 8 ! We cut our teeth on all classic literature from the age of 6 or 7 ! Our teachers were like this professor, in it to educate and widen our personalities The language therefore, is familiar and not difficult. Then, for French and Spanish 'A' levels at 16 years old, you had 4 classic books in those languages from the 16th century - Racine, Moliere / Calderon etc, to date, so we had to be fluent in the equivalent Shakespearean English, in those languages as well.
You should compile a playlist of what you did for those of us who are following in your footsteps later in time.
Thanks for a wonderful lecture. What a amazing luck we have those lectures at our finger tips. Eternally grateful I am to the professor and the person posted this.
Shakespeare is always connected to innovation processes digging high deeply in Shakespearian plays is no doubt enriching ones horizons and widening the literary perceptions
So glad I stumbled across this excellent series! Out here in the provinces (my small town has six traffic lights) I crave intelligent discussions about the Bard and, alas, there are few opportunities! Thanks for the posting, good friends!
We only have two traffic lights :-). Yes, wonderful to have this.
We don’t have traffic lights lol
@@jasonyntig717 Good for you! The truth is we moved last year to a larger city and now we have too many traffic lights! But now we can walk to Starbucks!!!
@@mikesnyder1788 good… i live in a very small province tho lol 😂
Thank you so much for sharing this with us . Listening to you in between patients at work; Makes my day so much more joyful .
Superb lecture, she somehow touches on all the key issues in a way that is concise yet substantive. Such a useful perspective expressed brilliantly.
Great lecture! I really learned a lot about the time and background of Shakespeare's plays! Thank you!
Thank you for choosing to share with us, something we could not have attained on our own.
onk bhalo laglo class ta,,jodio porata dekhi nai,,but onk interesting lagse
Thank you so much for posting these lectures. This is exactly what I've been looking for ❤❤❤
Absolutely terrific. Thank you for posting.
0:00 personal bookmark
5:39
7:50
9:33
15:15
"Let's not do seems like" - Thank you for the impartial, intellectual approach.
This is exciting stuff, but I don't understand her objection to "seems like." Does she want you to say "is like"? This "seems like" a hard and fast rule for her, which can squelch a meaningful discussion or completely valid ideas one is attempting to express. If I were in the class, I might be too intimidated to express my thoughts for fear I could not meet her standards of articulation.
Amazing teacher. Thank you so much for the course.
Great lecture. Her pendant caught my heart 😍
wow. thank you very much for posting all the lessons! brilliant. restores faith in the internet ;)
thanks to all whoever have searched for enlightening knowledge to enkindle the dying blind .
Useful for school college students
Please - she must have lectures on the other plays? Would be great to hear them. By the way, I recommend her book. I bought it after finding these videos and it's fantastic.
Good point on the comedies vs the tragedies. It depends on the production, for a low budget Shakespeare in the Park atmosphere, I prefer the comedies. There is a slapstick element and crowd interaction that make them very relatable. The tragedies take more recourses to bring out. I would include the Histories in this. That said, there are some very good movies to watch, the BBC is always good. The Hamlet with Dave Tennent is incredible. I also really enjoy The Hollow Crown for the War of the Roses.
I would like to invite you to a battle of wits, but i see you unarmed. I actually feel jealous a bit when i see someone who is more experienced about Shakespeare than i am. ❤
I liked your lecture on Shakespeare.
Vivid lecture indeed .....
I have only read 'Hamlet' and I liked it. I'm planning to read more works by Shakespeare, Milton etc.
Great lecture!!
Well, you started your reading with the very best! I just finished his Richard III and I can highly recommend it. Richard III is one of the very best villains in all of literature, by the way, and yet he has a dark humor. Happy reading!
@@mikesnyder1788 Awesome! Thanks for the recommendation! I'll read it soon.
@@mikesnyder1788 I have also bought Milton's 'Paradise Lost', I'm planning to read it next.
@@vozamaraktv-art5595 "Of man's first disobedience..." Oh well that will be an experience! I read the poem decades ago and that opening line is all I remember! Enjoy!
Don't forget to read the bible it is the passport to the eternal life /john 3:16
Whether India or US..The teacher is same everywhere
i was 12 yrs old when this lecture was recorded
I was 5
เราลองแวะมาฟัง...แต่เราฟังไม่ค่อยทัน...ต้องฟังหลายๆรอบ
What about Shakespeare in Love?
fascinating that all the female characters in shakespeare's time were played by male actors
I wonder about that. They say they were men, and yet how many women in the plays disguised themselves as men?
+BaseMetalMusic ... How can an adolescent be prepubescent?
John is
Ukulele Masters in
Does Shakespeare inventSKIMS?
Backformation even more originally: from linguistics. (Like "to laze" from "lazy").
Would you please somebody tell the name of the book which she has in her hand while she is talking about Shakespeare?
ons ons thank you so much :)
A truly great book.
Shakespeare after all
Why delete ur comment ?
Why Shakespeare is so important in American knowledge?
Changing Shakespeare's characters' gender? Would they like to be all women? What about Shakespeare? Would he agree?
Do you have/can you make a playlist for this series. Please please add link in the description of these videos. You’re doing a magnificent public service. God bless.
ruclips.net/p/PLaLOVNqqD-2HhqQG1BxUaQr0GpG8oN0DV
Here
hi can any one help me I want to study master english literature
me too
Prof. Marjorie Garber seems to bring to her lectures the theatrical experience and device which Prof. Maynard Mack epitomized at Yale during the 60's.
Frank Cacciutto and Galileo in his time
Plz tell me the book name???
I don't know how students take notes with professors talking at this speed!
TYSM FROM INDIA❤❤
Excellent course
I would like to know the name of her book please.
Shakespeare After All
Shakespeare after all
This is excellent.
Just wow and thanks
The "O" at the end of the lecture. Impressive explanation.
You’re giving up for me I’m nine and watching this
THIS IS A PIECE OF JEWELLRY !!!
interesting background lecture. do you have the lecturer's name?
Marjorie Garber
Wonderful
Could anyone please write the name of the lecturer? thank you in advance
Екатерина Асаулова Marjorie Garber
bookmarking!
9:15
12:18
Brilliant mind she has.
Can you please mam give me some ideas of what kind of research I can do on Shakespeare, can you give me some possible topics?
51:00-57:00 note
Please share link to whole playlist of this series.
ruclips.net/p/PLaLOVNqqD-2HhqQG1BxUaQr0GpG8oN0DV
Hi
Anyone here student of English literature
yes
@@alaamoutia where..?
@@alaamoutia I want discuss you on English if you don't mind
@@alaamoutia I'm student of Sargodha University , Punjab, Pakistan in 4th term
@@muhammadhamzawarraich1630 morocco
May I get your lecture on Hamlet?
"To give you things that you haven't seen before. " It's not the only truth". Lego et scio? Nice.
Very helpful
What was the title of the book?
Kate Noto please get contact with us my whatsapp 8469585561
Darshan A. Goswami how do I do that
Dont you use whatsapp ?
Or facebook ?
1:02:57 What 😂
Just a random math major passing by...
Beware of secret misogynists in the comments
beware of secret misandry in the comments
any one can help with modern criticism
I will give a thought. Nobody knows who Shakespeare was. He also plagiarized a lot. Almost none of his plot lines did he actually write. Go further, many people question if he even wrote some of the plays he's accredited for writing. Is it possible that Shakespeare was not just one person. Perhaps an editor, with many writers under his study. An analogy, take Walt Disney. That would explain his extraordinary genius.
+KozzmoKnight ... Yes. The most complicated hypothesis is always the best. Who cares about Occam's razor?
Yup, because "extraordinary genius" and "Walt Disney" are almost synonymous, aren't they? Everyone thinks Walt drew all those cartoons himself. You really know how to pick an analogy.
Despite her overbearing manner and the inevitable waves of left-wing ideology that listeners will be sitting through, this class on Shakespeare is worth anyone's time.
She has obviously done a tremendous amount of work, and she certainly knows her subject.
Arnold Klett-Bader Accurate estimation.
How do you know she is left?
Literature!! #bigliterature!
I think I'll stick with Mr Men books.
58:00
WrittencultureYea!
oh, she's dry
She's approximately 80% water actually
😂😂
Marjorie Garber
English literature...old pattern...
enough with the meta claptrap...get to it...
hi
zzzz
Dolphins, that deals with physics. It is an old proverb, that any sailor on an island would know, a storm is on the horizon. That is due to atmospheric pressure. There is another saying, when sound travels far and wide, a storm is soon to betide. The clouds form in a high pressure zone. the dolphins react to the pressure by rising to the surface.
I failed GCE English from college with a D.