I heard that 4th movement in my dream last night. It was strange because I hadn't listened to this Sonata in many years. I decided to listen to it this morning and it has been playing in my head all day.
Barenboim’s interpretation of Beethoven affects me in ways I can’t even describe. This is beyond everything I could ever imagine, eternally grateful for this.
A bit of Mozart, but only in the slow movement; there’s some Haydn as well, particularly in the compositional technique. Overall though, it’s the harbinger of things to come, and sits at the dawn of a new post-Classical world.
@@modernclassicalmusic8942 yeah, but it may distract the pianist from his sense of rhythm. I have seen pianists who count certain amount of beats in between movements so if you clap, he may have to wait. I've also seen pianists, although rare, start very shortly after finishing the movement so rather than it bothering the listeners it may bother the pianist or risk bothering them.
@@yanbai7380 you can do it ! Mondays are the best days to start. Mondays for music… then you set the tone for the rest of your week. Why not learn 8 bars of music today ?
To think that this Sonata by the young Beethoven is the beginning of a thirty year journey at the piano that resulted in 32 Sonatas that range far and wide over the the ocean of plating all the way from Haydn to the Waldstein and the Appassionata, the Hammerklavier , and the Opus 110 !
Strictly speaking, the three sonatas WoO 47 of 1783 precede Opus 2, as does some other juvenile trivia; Opus 49 which is included in the 32 should be removed as per Beethoven’s wishes leaving us with *30 Beethoven sonatas* which are as you describe, and which represent one of the greatest contributions to the keyboard literature by any single composer ever.
Oh my goodness. I know Barenboim's first recordings of the Beethoven sonatas in the 1970s, and I've now resolved to go through all these live performances. What a staggering musician he is !
i'm currently learning the first piece and i can say firsthand how difficult it is to play with such speed, but also with such interpretation, style, and emotion. great job, barenboim!
first movement haha, but yes! Beethoven is sounds deceptively easy. I only appreciate Barenboim's beautiful performance now that I've tried my hand at the very same sonata.
Two Great "B" s in music! Beethoven & Barenboim! Grateful to them both! Artistic rendering! Enjoyed! Thanks for the post! Jamshed K Delvadavala Mumbai.
YT algorithms clearly suck. Yes, he got copyright claims so YT automatically put ads in this video. I know YT kinda stupid to put so many ads between this masterpiece and fabulous playing. In the middle of the movements....
I don’t understand having ads in between movements. It’s just so wrong. And even more wrong that it’s Beethoven over all the other composers that gets this treatment. My worst experiences listening to Beethoven have been exactly this, ads in between movements and ads in the middle of movements. It’s so bad that I don’t listen to full Symphony no. 5 in C minor videos anymore because it’s either ads or it’s too slow or it’s out of tune. Individual movements is what I have to do for my favorite Beethoven symphony and that’s just sad. Back in like 2016, none of this mid-movement and between movement ads happened and I could listen to the full Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony without interruption in 1 video.
Ikr it’s boggling my mind lmfao, there’s such crisp, strong, defined voicing but at the same time it’s just Barenboim-level buttery smooth legato, like those 2 shouldn’t be able to coexist but they do and it’s amazing
It’s easy if you only play the notes, but if you really need to play it beautifully, then you will need to go through many hard obstacles. Anyway, can you play the first movement now?
@@apianoguy-wx3ch unfortunately not. I haven't been playing for about a year now due to school. Last thing I learnt was a bach invention in July last year i believe. Planning on restarting in a couple months
Wow, mister Barenboim wie poetisch und ohne Schnörkel, Manirismen, genau das richtige Rubato, ich fühle mich an Kempff und Haebler erinnert. In manchen Passagen allerdings wechseln sie das Tempo oder den Charakter ohne nachvollziehbare Motivation, als fielen sie in dem Moment aus ihrer musikalischen Mediation, ihrem Fluss, ihrer inneren Reise ... was soll man sagen: Wer so spielt kann doch nur ein Menschenfreund sein ...
People say this sonata is a lot like Mozart or Haydn, but I disagree. The first movement is more tragic than anything Mozart wrote for the piano, ending with this massive F minor chord. The only Mozart sonata perhaps comparable would be his mother's death sonata in A minor, but even that is not as strong as this one. The second movement is to me very pastoral, an idyllic medieval-style country village, at a time just before industrialization would change the world. It reminds me somewhat of Mozart, but the honey-like sweetness is a very Beethovenian style of sweetness more than a Mozartian one. And the last movement is purest Beethoven, very much like the third movement of the great Appassionata.
Yeah we just play and it comes to us. If u ask me for example to stop playing and name the next note or notes without actually playing them I'll probably struggle telling them to you
Mr. Barenboim is a genius. The sonata is played so perfect, but why is it recorded with so much reverb. You hear the room or hall but not the sound of the piano. Friedrich Gulda´s recordings of the Beethoven sonatas are quite dry, but you hear the touch, the different timbres of every note. It´s time for more clearness of sound in classical music.
Pointing out non-existent and wholly Imagined links between this sonata and Mozart’s Symphony 25 is like trying to say there are links between Picasso and Michelangelo because they both use red and blue paint.
Boris Wiedenfeld Dislikes are probably for interpretation. There are some bits of the 1st movement that I find he understates (he gives all the staccatos that are written on the sheets a miss) Some of his first mv is a bit muddy, but I like the detail and control in his fourth mv You can also hear the dampers slapping against the strings towards the end which is not ideal but I guess it's hard to let them down easily in such an energetic movement like the fourth
I think you're talking out of your rear end. You wouldn't know Puccini from Rossini. You couldn't tell Mozart's arse from Tchaikovsky's face. You couldn't recognise Liszt if Chopin was punching you in your place!!!!
To be honest I stopped liking this performance as there are too many tempo fluctuations especially in the 4th mvt. I wonder why he decided to create separate sound clouds or let’s say sound moments which do not relate to one another with a common link of the pulse.
0:25 Allegro
4:15 Adagio
9:52 Minuetto - Allegretto
13:40 Prestissimo
Why did I not see this earlier? Thank you for this!
Thanks
Tysm
Lol
Thx💜✨
I heard that 4th movement in my dream last night. It was strange because I hadn't listened to this Sonata in many years. I decided to listen to it this morning and it has been playing in my head all day.
I dreamed with the second movement of the piano sonata n° 3
Debe ser hermoso experimentar eso.
Barenboim’s interpretation of Beethoven affects me in ways I can’t even describe. This is beyond everything I could ever imagine, eternally grateful for this.
Shades of Mozart here. But then Beethoven really went off on his own, and the world of piano music became a different place!
A bit of Mozart, but only in the slow movement; there’s some Haydn as well, particularly in the compositional technique.
Overall though, it’s the harbinger of things to come, and sits at the dawn of a new post-Classical world.
I love how the crowd just doesn't clap between the movements!! Yay! lol
LING LING WAS THERE
No applause, just 658 adverts for Squarespace....
People that clap between movements are people not concert goers.
@@modernclassicalmusic8942 yeah, but it may distract the pianist from his sense of rhythm. I have seen pianists who count certain amount of beats in between movements so if you clap, he may have to wait. I've also seen pianists, although rare, start very shortly after finishing the movement so rather than it bothering the listeners it may bother the pianist or risk bothering them.
At least they don't clap along.
The Fourth Movement is absolutely masterful!
It's my favorite... still blows me away... Every time....
True!
If that’s how it is, then I hope I can play it soon…
@@yanbai7380 you can do it !
Mondays are the best days to start. Mondays for music… then you set the tone for the rest of your week.
Why not learn 8 bars of music today ?
@@danielrivera9788 ahaha lol i learnt the first movement in a day😊😊
@@jefferyleung7846 and I thought it was only possible if you learned it a year ago, left it, then picked it back up😂😂
To think that this Sonata by the young Beethoven is the beginning of a thirty year journey at the piano that resulted in 32 Sonatas that range far and wide over the the ocean of plating all the way from Haydn to the Waldstein and the Appassionata, the Hammerklavier , and the Opus 110 !
Strictly speaking, the three sonatas WoO 47 of 1783 precede Opus 2, as does some other juvenile trivia; Opus 49 which is included in the 32 should be removed as per Beethoven’s wishes leaving us with *30 Beethoven sonatas* which are as you describe, and which represent one of the greatest contributions to the keyboard literature by any single composer ever.
I admire Barenboim so much, his Beethoven is absolutely astounding. Breath taking!
Oh my goodness. I know Barenboim's first recordings of the Beethoven sonatas in the 1970s, and I've now resolved to go through all these live performances. What a staggering musician he is !
I meant, "I got to know"
16:27 i can feel the satisfaction when the octaves finally arrived
Beethoven's masterclass Prestos and Prestissimos are usually the longest in the Sonatas
i'm currently learning the first piece and i can say firsthand how difficult it is to play with such speed, but also with such interpretation, style, and emotion. great job, barenboim!
piano finqers wdym the " first piece " there is only one piece do u mean movement??
mateus romagnoli or did I understand?!?????
I’m learning it too and you’re right, the first movement is hard to play with such marvellous style, speed, interpretation, articulation and dynamics.
first movement haha, but yes! Beethoven is sounds deceptively easy. I only appreciate Barenboim's beautiful performance now that I've tried my hand at the very same sonata.
I am playing the whole sonata and must say I always use this as a reference. BTW you think the first movement is hard? Try the fourth
Barenbolm is the authroity in the interpretation of Betthoven's Music.
Beethoven*
Andras Schiff is beyond measure and comparison when it comes to the interpretation of the Beethoven piano sonatas.
What about Ronald Brautigam?
And you are not in the Authority of spelling
I spelled Barenbiom wrong
Two Great "B" s in music! Beethoven & Barenboim!
Grateful to them both!
Artistic rendering!
Enjoyed! Thanks for the post!
Jamshed K Delvadavala
Mumbai.
Way too many ads in the video! I understand putting an ad between movements but not in the middle of it!
YT algorithms clearly suck. Yes, he got copyright claims so YT automatically put ads in this video. I know YT kinda stupid to put so many ads between this masterpiece and fabulous playing. In the middle of the movements....
buy youtube premium
@@userape be gone with you bomboclaat
I don’t understand having ads in between movements. It’s just so wrong. And even more wrong that it’s Beethoven over all the other composers that gets this treatment. My worst experiences listening to Beethoven have been exactly this, ads in between movements and ads in the middle of movements. It’s so bad that I don’t listen to full Symphony no. 5 in C minor videos anymore because it’s either ads or it’s too slow or it’s out of tune. Individual movements is what I have to do for my favorite Beethoven symphony and that’s just sad.
Back in like 2016, none of this mid-movement and between movement ads happened and I could listen to the full Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony without interruption in 1 video.
No one has played the 4th movement as clean as he did right here.
Look at his sweat!! How did he played these music so perfectly?
Ikr
It's like Beethoven having wordless conversations with God!!!! From 4:17 .....what a blessing to Hear this....
The trio from the 3rd movement is one of my favorite trios from Beethoven.
This was my audition piece in high school. I remember being worried that it wasn’t hard enough. Lol. Such a beautiful piece, love the drama of it.
@adeline middleton It was for a scholarship, and I did get it. Sadly quit playing seriously by the time I was 20.
Never quit
@@Flyingtaco82 what’s the reason why?
@@eunice7010 I had my daughter
The left hand of the last movement is honestly pretty hard no?
I love it!!! It reminds me of those golden times I went to Vienna EXACTLY 1 Year ago
Same! My trip to Vienna wasn’t a year ago, just 10 months ago, but I can still feel that.
Gracias por compartir.🇨🇱
2:31 not only that he voices it he also makes it smooth HOW??????!!
Ikr it’s boggling my mind lmfao, there’s such crisp, strong, defined voicing but at the same time it’s just Barenboim-level buttery smooth legato, like those 2 shouldn’t be able to coexist but they do and it’s amazing
Very good playing. Honestly
Quelle interprétation magistrale !
I’m playing this piece right now and this is such a good song! Thank you!
Baranboem. From one PianoForteist to another: Here I come!
His name confuses me?🤔
@@mr.anonymous299 Barenboim?
Learning this piece(only first movement) rn. Mesmerizing.
It’s easy if you only play the notes, but if you really need to play it beautifully, then you will need to go through many hard obstacles. Anyway, can you play the first movement now?
@@apianoguy-wx3ch unfortunately not. I haven't been playing for about a year now due to school. Last thing I learnt was a bach invention in July last year i believe. Planning on restarting in a couple months
Tout simplement parfait😍
WOW 😍😍😍
That’s the best 😊 I ever heard you
adoro
The first movement is like symphony no 25 g minor mozart
Exactly! I'm glad I'm not the only one who hears that.
Yes that is the piece that inspired this theme.
@@keatk_ yes, I hear it, so hip hop didn't invent sampling, lol
Red Rakham your profile picture tho, so cute
Edit: this aged badly XD
Yeah it's like no. 25. I guess its just an arpeggio with a flourish at the top lots of writers need to use that in their music I figure.
SUBLIME.....!🎹👑🎇
Wow, mister Barenboim wie poetisch und ohne Schnörkel, Manirismen, genau das richtige Rubato, ich fühle mich an Kempff und Haebler erinnert. In manchen Passagen allerdings wechseln sie das Tempo oder den Charakter ohne nachvollziehbare Motivation, als fielen sie in dem Moment aus ihrer musikalischen Mediation, ihrem Fluss, ihrer inneren Reise ... was soll man sagen: Wer so spielt kann doch nur ein Menschenfreund sein ...
aşığım sana ne güzel çalıyosun be
素晴らしいですね。
People say this sonata is a lot like Mozart or Haydn, but I disagree. The first movement is more tragic than anything Mozart wrote for the piano, ending with this massive F minor chord. The only Mozart sonata perhaps comparable would be his mother's death sonata in A minor, but even that is not as strong as this one. The second movement is to me very pastoral, an idyllic medieval-style country village, at a time just before industrialization would change the world. It reminds me somewhat of Mozart, but the honey-like sweetness is a very Beethovenian style of sweetness more than a Mozartian one. And the last movement is purest Beethoven, very much like the third movement of the great Appassionata.
It’s distinctively Beethoven but I think that it definitely bears some resemblance to Mozart’s great piano sonata in C minor, k. 457.
very good
Nice 👍
Wunder in jeder Hinsicht aber wieso dann vorgestern das 5. Klavierkonzert so verzerrt? Wo blieb die einfache Freude?
ma nigga barenboim sure does know how to play them prestissimos
💀💀 he played tf outta the prestissimo coda at the end of the Waldstein 🗣️‼️
I hate how randomly in the late 90s early 2000s there was this tend of filming through milk
It's amazing that he can remember the whole piece. 😁👍👍👍👍
I’m playing piano myself and we actually don’t remember the notes and stuff like that in our memory, it’s more muscle memory.
Yeah we just play and it comes to us. If u ask me for example to stop playing and name the next note or notes without actually playing them I'll probably struggle telling them to you
Привет @@user-zk9by4jb4x
good
❤
Mr. Barenboim is a genius. The sonata is played so perfect, but why is it recorded with so much reverb. You hear the room or hall but not the sound of the piano. Friedrich Gulda´s recordings of the Beethoven sonatas are quite dry, but you hear the touch, the different timbres of every note. It´s time for more clearness of sound in classical music.
goat
Очень красиво
♡
What hall is this ? Where is he playing?
@adeline middleton I actually think I figured it out (my teacher lent me DVD of the concert + some masterclasses) it's supposedly in Berlin
7:48
👍👍👍👍👍🎹🎶
4:15 - piano music from September 1999 game.
Zo'r chalibdi
I was thinking this could be a nice thing to learn on the side... then the last movement came
Lol 😂
15:53
Tell me...
Does this Sonata lift you up?
i have to play the first movement for my grade 8 piano exam 😳
Good luck
how did it go?
Brian Gray i haven’t done it yet 😬
Lmao
me too
Anyone else hear that tiny bit of homage to mozart?😢
❤😂❤
이 멋진 영상 올려준분 감사합니다.... 바렌보임 몇살때였는지 궁굼하네요.... 저 나이에 베토벤 전곡이라니.....
이또미 인정이요 전 4악장으로 대회 담주에 나가는데 미국 올스테이트 대회라서 예선 겨우 통과했는데 잘 할수있을지 너무 걱정이네요 바렌보임 나이가 몇인데 완벽하게 전곡연주..
멋진연주..
Others are also very good: Gilels, Arrau,
💜
😀😀😀😀😀😀
1st movement 4:07 2nd movement 9:47 3rd movement 13:39 4th movement 18:42😊😊😊
I sometimes wonder if the old music masters (Beethoven Mozart Bach) just did this show that they were awesome
That's pretty much exactly what they were doing.
Of course, otherwise they would simply starve to death
Which level this movement is, grade 6 or 7?
9 but depends on the movement idk search it uo
너무 잘친다 저렇게 칠수 있으면....
o homi até suou, diferenciado
Kkkkk
4:10
This is nut worthy playing
Such a sanity check! I was totally off. Music was so much part of Neurology. Einstein was probably doing sanity checks on his violin every day.
Nunca tinha reparado como ele parece o Pedro Bial 😂
7:02 Casta Diva?
18:14 hahaha WhAt!
Can we get an original rendition with out interpretation
18:59
"B B"
Listen to Mozarts 25th Symphony
Pointing out non-existent and wholly Imagined links between this sonata and Mozart’s Symphony 25 is like trying to say there are links between Picasso and Michelangelo because they both use red and blue paint.
@@elaineblackhurst1509 Smart answer
19:00
I want to know who the 22 people are that voted it "thumbs down". Really? You can play it better than Barenboim? Oh, dream on...
Boris Wiedenfeld
Dislikes are probably for interpretation. There are some bits of the 1st movement that I find he understates (he gives all the staccatos that are written on the sheets a miss)
Some of his first mv is a bit muddy, but I like the detail and control in his fourth mv
You can also hear the dampers slapping against the strings towards the end which is not ideal but I guess it's hard to let them down easily in such an energetic movement like the fourth
C'est RUclips...
51 now
최고다
Beethoven: Can i copy your homework?
Haydn: Sure, just make it look a bit different
Beethoven: Got ya!
😂😂😂
Lololol
I think you're talking out of your rear end. You wouldn't know Puccini from Rossini. You couldn't tell Mozart's arse from Tchaikovsky's face. You couldn't recognise Liszt if Chopin was punching you in your place!!!!
Adam Nonymous ok easy there tiger damn
Ggrrr!!! Hehe
woahh that rubato. i think it's a bit too much
Hi
Che il Conte
barenboim is alright
ALRIGHT? Only ALRIGHT? I would say he's a master
Daniel Zhang
Says the idiot who doesn't understand sarcasm
Bruh
0:25
4:15
9:52
13:40
Thank me later!!
Btw you could also just go to where there are ads
Stop omg
too much ad..:X
2:50 the image of Beethoven
Did Beethoven die of Covid-19 too?
진짜멋지다
근데채플린과의인연은일찍끝나두
음악가로써는대단하군요
Well, this 4th movement is far, far from prestissimo...
did he play all fucking 32
Yep. In 8 concerts over 2 weeks' time.
stewart goodyear played all 32 in a day. it was glorious.
MaskedWalnut23 show more respect to Beethoven ok he worked hard in these sonatas and they’re not there for you to use vulgar words on them
@@easzy6925 DONT JOKE BOUT THAT BO
You bet... Many times 😂
Shame on RUclips and intrusive adds. I would suggest to boycott advertisers’s products.
More face dammit!!
To be honest I stopped liking this performance as there are too many tempo fluctuations especially in the 4th mvt. I wonder why he decided to create separate sound clouds or let’s say sound moments which do not relate to one another with a common link of the pulse.
mi amigo Mauro lo toca mejor, lejossss.
Crétin !
𝔼𝕤𝕡𝕖𝕣𝕠 𝕢𝕦𝕖 𝕤𝕖𝕒 𝕖𝕝 𝕡𝕚𝕒𝕟𝕠😂
😂😂😂😂
@@Rigobarrios😂😂😂😂
@@yiminyi😂😂😂😂
Maurizio Pollini was much better.
Better how? Nonsense!