I haven’t read the comments…yet…but I’m guessing that there will be a slew of them stating that ‘Purdy is average because he hasn’t won a SB’……..football is a team sport..the team wins, not just the QB…had McCaffrey not fumbled onto the opening drive, would the game have progressed differently?…if Luter,Jr hadn’t been in the wrong spot and the wrong time, would the SB have turned out different?…maybe Burford puts a chip block on Chris Jones, maybe Brock has 1.5 seconds more, and completes the pass to Aiyuk…talent wise..overall talent wise..Brock is among the best..quit raggin on Brock for chrissakes…he’s doing his job
Larry it’s not because he hasn’t one the big one, it’s because he has had the lead in 4th qtr of Super Bowl 3x and blew it. He is great, but he’s also not clutch under pressure. He needs to win to end the conversation
Also, Nick Wrong and that guy who ranked Brock 13th. Erik Dayne posts in many You Tube 49ers threads just to bash Brock. Last night, I was reading an X thread where several were throwing up the old weapons argument. Some were even saying what a great offensive line he had! Then, I realized some of these twits actually thought WRs and RBs were part of the offensive line!
I hate when critics say if Lamar, or Mahomes or Burrow played on 9ers how much better team would be. No one knows that. Maybe Lamar or Mahomes and Burrow would of cracked under being with Shannahan. Pressure to learn the way he teaches the game/offense. No one knows. What matters is Brock is doing great right here right now all the other noise is pure speculation and bullshit!
Yeah but it wasn't just critics saying stuff like that or speculating when Niners lost Super Bowl with Jimmy G it was our fans. When you don't close the deal there's always that kind of talk
Meanwhile Purdy is first in how many categories. I don't understand how you can be more first smgdh. He did better than every qb they said WOULD do better hypothetically lol. They act like other qbs touchdowns are worth 11 points. Purdy had the fourth highest yards per attempt in nfl history, with the top three being from the nineteen forties and fifties, meaning Purdy through it farther, more often, more accurately than any qb any of us has ever seen in our lives, LITERALLY. All these other qbs were in the league at the time lol. Mahomes had tyreek, watkins and hardmam, with kelce and kareem hunt as one of the best backs in the league at the time. He didn't put up these numbers. I dunno what it's gonna take for them to give the man some credit
@@bobbybigfellow8516 Trying to point to any empty stat in some ridiculous attempt to compare him to Mahomes in any way is laughable. He's no fuQen where near Mahomes.
Kyle is the engine. Jimny G also reached a Super Bowl and Jimmy hasn't set the world on fire without Kyle. Brock is QB 1 for now but I'm not convinced he's anything more than a slightly more mobile Kirk Cousins with less arm strength and yeah fair or unfair winning the whole thing is what matters. We're not fuQing Detroit
Jimmy had a ferocious number one defense and a middle of the pack offense with average numbers. Purdy has the number one offense and set multiple records with a middle of the pack defense. What are you talking about
@@bobbybigfellow8516 What are you talking about ? ? Bosa is not a star ? Fred Warner is not a star ? Stop it . And the prolific Purdy offense scored a whopping 2 more points than what Jimmy G put up in the previous Super Bowl. Woo hoo. Purdy hasn't proven shit yet and they'll be doubters because of that and rightfully so
Die hard 49ers Brock Purdy fan!!!
Go back 40 years. I vividly remember the same things that are being tacked onto Brock Purdy today were once tacked onto Joe Montana.
Good point. One thing though…. Joe didn’t lose a Super Bowl. Neither did Bill Walsh. The weak link is Kyle under pressure
1. Shanahan is an asset.
2. Purdy is an asset.
3. Nick Wright is an ass.
People forget he has played a year and a half. He is only going to get better. 😊
Full offseason this year hommie
Agreed. People act like he’s hit a ceiling.
I haven’t read the comments…yet…but I’m guessing that there will be a slew of them stating that ‘Purdy is average because he hasn’t won a SB’……..football is a team sport..the team wins, not just the QB…had McCaffrey not fumbled onto the opening drive, would the game have progressed differently?…if Luter,Jr hadn’t been in the wrong spot and the wrong time, would the SB have turned out different?…maybe Burford puts a chip block on Chris Jones, maybe Brock has 1.5 seconds more, and completes the pass to Aiyuk…talent wise..overall talent wise..Brock is among the best..quit raggin on Brock for chrissakes…he’s doing his job
For what its worth the College regular seasons are still worth quite a lot easpecially football and basketball.
Both of you have great chemistry in your analysis, without throwing out the click bait, so many luv to throw out!
Larry it’s not because he hasn’t one the big one, it’s because he has had the lead in 4th qtr of Super Bowl 3x and blew it. He is great, but he’s also not clutch under pressure. He needs to win to end the conversation
1. “Purdy’s not so great because he plays for Shanahan for goodness’ sake.”
2. “Shanahan’s not so great because he has Purdy for goodness’s sake.”
Only Grant Cult is arguing
Also, Nick Wrong and that guy who ranked Brock 13th. Erik Dayne posts in many You Tube 49ers threads just to bash Brock.
Last night, I was reading an X thread where several were throwing up the old weapons argument. Some were even saying what a great offensive line he had! Then, I realized some of these twits actually thought WRs and RBs were part of the offensive line!
Montana won a Super Bowl his first year as starter. You would think 9ers fans would know that.
If Trey Lance did what Purdy did nobody in the media would talk about weapons and Kyle. It is not about draft pick.
Been mentioning it
I hate when critics say if Lamar, or Mahomes or Burrow played on 9ers how much better team would be. No one knows that. Maybe Lamar or Mahomes and Burrow would of cracked under being with Shannahan. Pressure to learn the way he teaches the game/offense. No one knows. What matters is Brock is doing great right here right now all the other noise is pure speculation and bullshit!
Yeah but it wasn't just critics saying stuff like that or speculating when Niners lost Super Bowl with Jimmy G it was our fans. When you don't close the deal there's always that kind of talk
Meanwhile Purdy is first in how many categories. I don't understand how you can be more first smgdh. He did better than every qb they said WOULD do better hypothetically lol. They act like other qbs touchdowns are worth 11 points.
Purdy had the fourth highest yards per attempt in nfl history, with the top three being from the nineteen forties and fifties, meaning Purdy through it farther, more often, more accurately than any qb any of us has ever seen in our lives, LITERALLY. All these other qbs were in the league at the time lol. Mahomes had tyreek, watkins and hardmam, with kelce and kareem hunt as one of the best backs in the league at the time. He didn't put up these numbers. I dunno what it's gonna take for them to give the man some credit
@@bobbybigfellow8516 Trying to point to any empty stat in some ridiculous attempt to compare him to Mahomes in any way is laughable. He's no fuQen where near Mahomes.
Roethlisberger won 2 .
Purdy needs to win a Superbowl to be considered a good QB.
Kyle is the engine. Jimny G also reached a Super Bowl and Jimmy hasn't set the world on fire without Kyle. Brock is QB 1 for now but I'm not convinced he's anything more than a slightly more mobile Kirk Cousins with less arm strength and yeah fair or unfair winning the whole thing is what matters. We're not fuQing Detroit
Jimmy had a ferocious number one defense and a middle of the pack offense with average numbers.
Purdy has the number one offense and set multiple records with a middle of the pack defense.
What are you talking about
@@bobbybigfellow8516 What are you talking about ? ? Bosa is not a star ? Fred Warner is not a star ? Stop it . And the prolific Purdy offense scored a whopping 2 more points than what Jimmy G put up in the previous Super Bowl. Woo hoo. Purdy hasn't proven shit yet and they'll be doubters because of that and rightfully so