Person : changez *muslim* Friend : dayaram *hindu* Helped : bhagat singh *sikh by birth* This is the level of love between the religions in my country India ❤️
Allah ho Akbar . Waahe Guru da Khalsa Waahe Guru ji di Fateh . I am a muslim doctor .... and we saved Sikh sisters and sikh brothers during anti-Sikh 1984 riots .
Dr. U.A. Bharti., Sir , you did a good job inshallah.. you saved sisters, Sikh brothers , on the way of " Allah"** going to "zannat", .. May you have a prosper life, dear Dr. Sir. Thanks indeed.
Asif Shab,, khan ho aap ,, appke jaise logo ki bhut jaroort hai iss mulk ko ,, Iss zazbe ko aage bdhao....we need Ashafak Ullha khan,, Changazi khan ,, wo app ho Asif bhai,, Aap ko salam ,, sacche deshbhekt ko salam , acche inshan ko salam,,
bhagat singh you are great ,, how great patriotic you are in such a small age by knowing everything that you will not alive at the time of independence.. but unfortunately brother , we lost the independence you had fight for , and the worst thing is that present politics don't accept any bhagat singh in the country now..
I'm from Afghanistan I'm really excited about Nd interested about all brave ppls in world and any society it's fact bhagat singh was really brave person I HV read abt him and very few people we can find true and honest brave and any society :
भाई जी आप ने शहीद भगत सिंह के साथी से मुलाकात कर जो बात सामने रखवाई है धन्यवाद,,, but,, आप उस महान सख्सियत को धर्म के साथ जोड़कर उनकी मानवता के लिये दी गई क़ुरबानी को छोटा कर रहे हो ,,,वो विश्व के महानतम नास्तिकों में आज भी सुमार हैं,,,,
Q ki unhe pata tha bhagwan ya aalha nahi ayenge niche .......shub karam khud hi karane padta hai vastan me hum sab nastik hai Q kya hum sab upar wale ke niyamo par chaltey hai ...........
Shaheed Bhagat Singh sahib, all other Shaheeds and freedom fighters sacrificed their youthness, assets, family lives, friends are real heroes of Indo-Pak freedom. We salute them. We are enjoying life of freedom because of their sacrifices. If they have not sacrificed every thing for freedom then we would have been slaves even today. Freedom needs sacrifice. Bhagat Sing and all freedom fighters Zindabas.
very old man, probably he even can't hear properly, got to speak bit loud and give him time to recollect past memories. still very glad to know about freedom fight. Jai Hind
this reporter should learn reporting...he is irritating and interrupting the interview...veerg aage se dhyan rakhna. nice coverage..salute to ur channel..jai hind...Jai bharat
Oh my God this is very irritating to see this reporter interrupting the old Changezi sahib. Old guy is trying to recollect his memory to answer his question but this guy is pelting on him question after question before he can answer one. Let them speak until they stop then you ask the next question. You have to have more patience with the oldies please.
ji bilkul reporter ne ye bataya ki vo sikh swaroop mein they kyoki aisa changez ji kaha..ab rahi point out krne ki baat ,to us se pahle shreaam unki pagri ko chhipaya bhi to ja rha h na.kyu hamein unki pasand nai h unka pagri mein hona.....but this reporting should have to be more in length so that more things about bhagat singh came to from old baba ji
Apka Bahot Dhanyawad Sikh Bahi o . Apne Bahot Accha kam kiya . Kafi Jankari Desh Ko Di. Muje Bhi Rajkot Mai Bhagat Singh ke Chote Bahi Kultar Singh Ka Charan Spars karne Ka Moka mila hai. Sat Shree Akal . From USA.
Baghat Singh was also our hero,we have to forget bitterness of 1947 & forgive each other on killing of innocent immigrants. We Pakistani/Punjabi must recognize him as our hero.
Mere veer ji Why doesn't this matter? Today people are portraying Shaheed Bhagat Singh's image as Comrade, they are saying he was not believes in GOD. Which is wrong. He was True sikh, he was true follower of his religion also , he loved his religion. Many people on RUclips spreading wrong information about Bhagat ji. As a sikh we cannot accept this.
Jaisi aazadi ke liye saheed huwe aaj wo azadi khatam hori h aaj Hindu Muslim Aapas me hi lad rahe h aaj insaniyat ka katal hora h or zaanwar ki hifazat ki jari h..
Hey reporter you should learn how to communicate with old age people they are not much quick like you. They need recall their brain , they speak slow their all activities are slow you seems in hurry please try to learn old people behaviour. You irritated him you annoying reporter.
Aap sahi hain. Ye barbar sikhi ki bat boli jabki changezi sb ne ekbar bhi nahi kaha ki mai muslim hun ya unhone allah ka nam liya ho. Ye bahut khas interview tha koi dharmik nahi tha. Inko sikh prove karna chahte the jabki vo communist the aur nastik the. Ye barbar hat pagdi par jor dia aur hatwala photo galat bataya jo sahi hai . Sandars bonbkand ke bad jab pakde jane ka khatra tha isliye delhi se Calcutta bhage the to bhash badalkar dadi moonchh katakar hat lagakar train se gaye the taki pahchane na jayen. Doosari bat changezi sb ne teenbar kaha ki pagdi thi aur muh par kapda tha, ye nahi kaha ki dadhi moonchh nahi thi
Good interview unfold many secret.like who is responsible for the partition of India.while Panjab and Bengal was crying and having blood bath. But some people were laughing in Delhi.
BAHUT ACHA LGA BHAGAT SINGH JI KE BAARE MAI S U N KE AAJ PHIR KISI AISE INSAAN SE JO UNKE SATH REH CHUKE HAI. JI LEYA BHAGAT SINGH JI KO AAJ. INQALAB ZINDABAD.
bhagat singh verge shaheed hoe tan bharat nu azaadi mili bhagat singh shaheed ji jindabad,ih bajurg dian gallan dassde han bara changa lagda hai,shaheedan nu parnaam
He was indeed Sikh. You may read the book "Jail Chitthiyaan" by Bhai Randhir Singh who was also a freedom fighter. He was the person whom Shahid Bhagat Singh wanted to meet while in prison. You will get to know the truth. Yes Bhagat Singh was an atheist for 4 years, but at the time of his martyrdom he had again become a theist. "Why I am an atheist" was written by him before this meeting with Bhai Randhir Singh. And this is all if we give the discount of accepting that he did write the article which is highly doubt-worthy. I say so because he was classified as a terrorist and NOT a political prisoner (for bombing parliament and killing Saunders). Inmates classified as terrorists were NOT given writing material and other facilities that were given to political prisoners, so how could he have been able to write in the first place?
Also, Why I'm an atheist is laden with FACTUAL FALLACIES. For example, it states that Bhagat Singh's father was Arya Samaji (LOL). In reality he was not just a Sikh, but a Khalsa (amritdhari Sikh). This is evident from the autobiography of freedom fighter Sardar Ajit Singh (Bhagat Singh's uncle) in which he states that he with his brother (Bhagat Singh's father) had undergone the Sikh baptism ceremony called Amrit Sanchar at Anandpur Sahib. So how can Bhagat Singh's father be Arya Samaji when he is in fact an Amritdhari Sikh? This is a classic Hindu supremacist right-wing type of proaganda trying to undermine the Sikh sovereign identity by trying to doctrine our history, since it is also the fact is that Why I'm an Atheist was published in "The People" which was of Lala Lajpat Rai, who was linked with Savarkar who we all know basically is the father of the poisonous Hindu Rashtra ideology. And it's been a modus operandi of the RSS to dilute or distort the history and scriptures of the Sikhs in order to make us weak. (Not to mention they also target all minorities and dalits) Since it's full of cowards who can't grow a pair and need such low actions to achieve their even lower motives.
If you've read "Why I'm an Atheist" then you should read the following the following 2 books as well and you'll come to know of the fallacies: 1. Jail Chitthiyaan (by Bhai Randhir Singh) 2. Pagdhi Sambhal Jatta To'n Azadi Wal (AUTObiography of freedom fighter Sardar Ajit Singh- uncle of Sardar Bhagat Singh)
Person : changez *muslim*
Friend : dayaram *hindu*
Helped : bhagat singh *sikh by birth*
This is the level of love between the religions in my country India
❤️
Bhai ye Mohabbat ab Netao ke Aankhoo Mai khataktee hai, kursee paane ke liye devide and Rule Karke un shahido ke shahdat bhee bhul Gaye hai, 😭
Pseudo sanghis destroyed this beauty
@Nasiruddin Kumar Khalsa But his identity is sikh.... Faith and Religion is different, faith is personal belief but religion is identity
@Nasiruddin Kumar Khalsa Mafi mange vale..😮
Bharat Ka AhoBhagys 💞🙏🙏
Allah ho Akbar . Waahe Guru da Khalsa Waahe Guru ji di Fateh . I am a muslim doctor .... and we saved Sikh sisters and sikh brothers during anti-Sikh 1984 riots .
@@karanbansal7458 right bro
Dr. U.A. Bharti., Sir ,
you did a good job inshallah..
you saved sisters, Sikh brothers , on the way of " Allah"** going to "zannat", .. May you have a prosper life, dear Dr. Sir.
Thanks indeed.
Ameen ji .
thank you dr sahab. aap ka bht bht abhaar. apne humaari sikh bheno aur bhaiyo ki raksha ki..🙏🙏🙏
God bless u
I just love the moral values and respect the Sikh people have, they are humble and brave at the same time.
Pura focus Bhagat Singh par hai, aur kuch kahna chahte hain bujurg par reporter sahab focused hai.
@@anilbhatt7208 अजय डाउनलोड
@@anilbhatt7208 qq
kash aise hi muslim sikh hindu mil kr rhe kitna acha lgta
Asif Shab,, khan ho aap ,, appke jaise logo ki bhut jaroort hai iss mulk ko ,, Iss zazbe ko aage bdhao....we need Ashafak Ullha khan,, Changazi khan ,, wo app ho Asif bhai,, Aap ko salam ,, sacche deshbhekt ko salam , acche inshan ko salam,,
Dr. Rajdeep Singh bhai daesh kya hota hay? 100 saal phelay kya desh hota tha. jaha raho azaad raho. in sub pabindio. AZAADI BOHOT BARI CHEEZ HAY
Muhammad Asif hum sath hai mere Bhai☺
Kaas log aapki tra Dharm or Rajnete se upr uthkr is Desh ke liya bhi soch ska...
Welcome all of you....Aap scha insaan ho is Desh ke
Muhammad Asif
Hindu aur Sikh to Sath reh lenge
Lekin Muslim always want to Live Alone Forever
भगत सिंह का नाम और जीवन सदियों तक देशभक्तों को प्रेरित करता रहेगा ऐसे शहीदेआज़म को कोटि कोटि नमन।
धन्य हो गया मैं एक स्वतंत्रता सेनानी के दर्शन करके
Salaam and respect to our great Changezi Saheb who sheltered our Saheed e Azam BHAGAT SINGH Saheb during Delhi stay .
Shekhar
NEW DELHI
INDIA
Shaheed bhagat singh ZINDABAD ......inquilab zindabad
WE MUST REMEMBER HIM EACH YEAR WITH JOY AS THE REVOLUTIONARY.
कैसे कैसे दुःख झेँले हमारे क्रांतिकारियो ने,अपनी पहचान छुपाकर रहे और गुप्तरुप से अपने कार्य को अंजाम दिया। बहरे ब्रिटिश अधिकारियो के कान खोलने के लिए।
Dukh hota hai.
Wo aazaadi nahi mili jo bhagat singh chahte the.
Agar wo aaj zinda hote toh unko bahut dukh hota😭😭😭
bhagat singh you are great ,, how great patriotic you are in such a small age by knowing everything that you will not alive at the time of independence.. but unfortunately brother , we lost the independence you had fight for , and the worst thing is that present politics don't accept any bhagat singh in the country now..
I'm from Afghanistan I'm really excited about Nd interested about all brave ppls in world and any society it's fact bhagat singh was really brave person I HV read abt him and very few people we can find true and honest brave and any society :
Kuwait dulvan
Farid Khan right bhai jaan
Hey, are you still alive?
Big salute to entire Shikh Community which only believes in giving services to humanity.
Shekhar
NEW DELHI
This video is a gem, i am saving this just in case time comes.
भाई जी आप ने शहीद भगत सिंह के साथी से मुलाकात कर जो बात सामने रखवाई है धन्यवाद,,,
but,, आप उस महान सख्सियत को धर्म के साथ जोड़कर उनकी मानवता के लिये दी गई क़ुरबानी को छोटा कर रहे हो ,,,वो विश्व के महानतम नास्तिकों में आज भी सुमार हैं,,,,
Q ki unhe pata tha bhagwan ya aalha nahi ayenge niche .......shub karam khud hi karane padta hai vastan me hum sab nastik hai Q kya hum sab upar wale ke niyamo par chaltey hai ...........
maane aur janne me farak hai aallha ko janne k liye unpar wishas ke liye ye ummar kam pad jayegi
Bilkul sahi kaha apne bhai
Karamvir lamba ki bat se sahmat hu mai
A great witness by Haj Chengeji, a great service rendered by freedom fighter.Government must honour him.
This is the rich culture of humanity in the land I will call India, will always be inspired by and be a patriot to!!
Shaheed Bhagat Singh sahib, all other Shaheeds and freedom fighters sacrificed their youthness, assets, family lives, friends are real heroes of Indo-Pak freedom. We salute them. We are enjoying life of freedom because of their sacrifices. If they have not sacrificed every thing for freedom then we would have been slaves even today.
Freedom needs sacrifice.
Bhagat Sing and all freedom fighters Zindabas.
mubharakh hai Bhagat Singhji Sukhdevji Rajguruji te hir saare freedom fighters.
Waheguruji ka khakse waheguruji ki fateh.
Thank you for bringing out this video! Never imagined, could ever be able to see someone, even if in a video, who spent time with Shahid Bhagat Singh!
I am thank full to u for withness and listening mr Chanzege Saheb
From heart thank u to Changezji
Salute from Bengal !!!
Salute Shahees Bhagat singh 🙏
Salute Shivram Rajguru 🙏
Salute Sukhdev Thapar 🙏
Salute all Revolutionaries 🙏
Salute indian army 🙏❤
Khush kismat hn hum jo yah video dekhne mila. dhanyawaad 🙏
my inspiration Shaheed Bhaghat Singh
Hero of Humanity ❤️
very old man, probably he even can't hear properly, got to speak bit loud and give him time to recollect past memories. still very glad to know about freedom fight.
Jai Hind
Salute from Bengal!!!
Not suprised Changez ji was honoured by arvind kejriwal govt.Some things dont need to come in media ..but they happen.
Sardar Bhagat Singh Zindabad zindabad zindabad zindabad zindabad 🙏🇮🇳🙏❤️❤️♥️🙏🇮🇳
saheeed sardar bhagat singh ji ..zindabad
Salute from Bengal .
क्रांतिकारियों को क्रांतिकारी ही रहने दो उनको सिक्ख,हिंदू,और धर्मों मे बाँटकर उनका अपमान न करो।
जय हिन्द🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Aajadi aur Aman pasand in swatanterta senaani Changeji ji aur Bhagat Singh ji ko koti koti naman..
Realy feel to b cry
Nice video. My hero is bhagat singh.baba ji nu salaam
Dhan ne oho bnde jinha ne sardaar ji saheed bhagat singh ji de darshan kite jinha ne ohna nu vekya...
ਸਾਡੇ ਦਿਲ ਤੇ ਭਗਤ ਸਿੰਘ ਲਿਖਿਅਾ
ਕਾਗਜ਼ਾਂ ਦੀ ਲੋੜ ਕੋੲੀ ਨਾ।
this reporter should learn reporting...he is irritating and interrupting the interview...veerg aage se dhyan rakhna. nice coverage..salute to ur channel..jai hind...Jai bharat
Oh my God this is very irritating to see this reporter interrupting the old Changezi sahib. Old guy is trying to recollect his memory to answer his question but this guy is pelting on him question after question before he can answer one. Let them speak until they stop then you ask the next question. You have to have more patience with the oldies please.
deepender singh and only thing he noticed was that Bhagat singh shud b shown as a sardar.... idiot reporter
ya..infact no need to show..he was born sardar...and we are proud of our komm.
ji bilkul reporter ne ye bataya ki vo sikh swaroop mein they kyoki aisa changez ji kaha..ab rahi point out krne ki baat ,to us se pahle shreaam unki pagri ko chhipaya bhi to ja rha h na.kyu hamein unki pasand nai h unka pagri mein hona.....but this reporting should have to be more in length so that more things about bhagat singh came to from old baba ji
Muje to nhi kar rhe vi irritate...
Brave Bhagat Singh ji🙏🙏🙏 thanks for this valuable video.... Love from Nepal🇳🇵
I am vry big fan of bhagat singh jo ohna ne desh lyi kita ohnu assi kde bhul nahi skde 🙏
Waheguru AP ji nu chardikala bakhshey waheguru
Changej ji sahab Salam hai aapko, aapki yaadasht ko
Bhagat Singh haar Bhartiya k Dil ka andar zinda rahega
Bhagat singh kabhi haar nhi saaktaa naa kabhi karein hai. Bas kuch gaardaro ke karan wo saheed huyee thae
Bhagat Singh je Amar rahen.
Jai Hind
The legend Bhagat Singh, he is my role model. Love u Bhagat Singh.
🙏🙏🙏please keep uploading some much such videos
I loved it...
Apka Bahot Dhanyawad Sikh Bahi o . Apne Bahot Accha kam kiya . Kafi Jankari Desh Ko Di. Muje Bhi Rajkot Mai Bhagat Singh ke Chote Bahi Kultar Singh Ka Charan Spars karne Ka Moka mila hai. Sat Shree Akal . From USA.
Chacha ji tusi great ho aap ne to wokaam kiya jo koi nhi ker saka
Saheed bhagat singh ko meri taraf se salute
I proud of Bhagat Singh I miss u
Comrade Shaheed bhagat singh Amar rahe
yar bai reporter saab tusi ena kyn bolde o? Changezi saab bol rahe aa tusi ave vich boli jane o??
Mani Sappal tu bolla
shat shat naman to Bhagat Singh
Bhagat Singh mahan insaan hai
Har bhartiye ke dil me hai
Aise mhapurush ko sunana k liye reporter badhai k patra h. Weldone prajee.jai hind.
Baghat Singh was also our hero,we have to forget bitterness of 1947 & forgive each other on killing of innocent immigrants. We Pakistani/Punjabi must recognize him as our hero.
Great babaji.
*Thanks you all for being a persistent viewer.*
*For more updates , please Share n Subscribe to Akaal Channel.*
*ਅਕਾਲ ਚੈਨਲ ਨਾਲ ਜੁੜੇ ਰਹਿਣ ਲਈ ਆਪ ਜੀ ਦਾ ਧੰਨਵਾਦ |*
*ਹੋਰ ਅੱਪਡੇਟ ਤੇ ਜੁੜੇ ਰਹਿਣ ਲਈ Akaal Channel ਨੂੰ Subscribe ਤੇ Share ਕਰੋ ਜੀ ||*
love u bhagat singh
Very nice information sahide Bhagat Singh Amer rhe Jai Hind Jai Bharat Subhash Chandra BOS Chandrashekhar Azad Amar rahe Jay Hind Jay Bharat
Excellent reporting
very nice share
Changezji love u sahab. INQUILAB ZINDABAD
Thanks changezi chacha🙏🙏.
very good efforts we r so lucky love u bro
20:15🔥🔥🔥
Iswer inhe lambi aaue de Swasth sharir de !! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😣😣😣😥😥
How does that matter if Bhagat Singh wore a turban or a hat? Let's think beyond his attire, and pay homage to this great personality
Mere veer ji Why doesn't this matter? Today people are portraying Shaheed Bhagat Singh's image as Comrade, they are saying he was not believes in GOD.
Which is wrong. He was True sikh, he was true follower of his religion also , he loved his religion. Many people on RUclips spreading wrong information about Bhagat ji. As a sikh we cannot accept this.
Yes he was insisting again and again for hat or pagdi. His balidan was so important then be a sikh. Very low mentality
You are right sir
The graeat personality Bhagat Singh ...,,, bhagat Singh zindabad
Meri jindagi da hero saheed e Azam sardar Bhagat Singh 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Pai Sabh just Bahut hi vadya kamm Kar rahey ho
Highly respect for bhagat singh.
Salute from Bengal .
Iove bhagt singh
House looks the same as it mustve been in 1920s.Fantastic.
Jaisi aazadi ke liye saheed huwe aaj wo azadi khatam hori h aaj Hindu Muslim Aapas me hi lad rahe h aaj insaniyat ka katal hora h or zaanwar ki hifazat ki jari h..
I am also big big fan of our real hero of india shahide Azam Bhagat Singh ji
Bhagat singh inklab jindabad🎉
S: Bhagat Singh ji Zindabaad
Bhai me jab jab bhagat Singh ki khani sunta hu rungte khade ho jate he
baar baar us ser ki sahaadat mai namn karty hai. or nam ho jaati ankhy jab us saheed ko yaad karty hai. jay hind
Hey reporter you should learn how to communicate with old age people they are not much quick like you. They need recall their brain , they speak slow their all activities are slow you seems in hurry please try to learn old people behaviour. You irritated him you annoying reporter.
Aap sahi hain. Ye barbar sikhi ki bat boli jabki changezi sb ne ekbar bhi nahi kaha ki mai muslim hun ya unhone allah ka nam liya ho.
Ye bahut khas interview tha koi dharmik nahi tha. Inko sikh prove karna chahte the jabki vo communist the aur nastik the.
Ye barbar hat pagdi par jor dia aur hatwala photo galat bataya jo sahi hai . Sandars bonbkand ke bad jab pakde jane ka khatra tha isliye delhi se Calcutta bhage the to bhash badalkar dadi moonchh katakar hat lagakar train se gaye the taki pahchane na jayen.
Doosari bat changezi sb ne teenbar kaha ki pagdi thi aur muh par kapda tha, ye nahi kaha ki dadhi moonchh nahi thi
Sheed Sardar Bhagat Singh ji Vatan ki aazadi k lie SHEED hue the unka sara parivaar hee aazadi ki jung me shamil tha ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਸ਼ਹੀਦੀ ਦੀ ਪ੍ਰੇਰਣਾ ਉਹਨਾਂ ਦੇ ਪਰਿਵਾਰ ਤੋਂ ਸਿੱਖ ਗੁਰੂ ਸਾਹਿਬਾਨਾਂ ਤੋਂ ਅਤੇ ਸਿੱਖ ਸ਼ਹੀਦਾਂ ਤੋਂ ਹੀ ਮਿਲੀ ਇਸ ਗੱਲ ਨੂੰ ਕੋਈ ਵੀ ਲੁਕਾ ਨੀ ਸਕਦਾ
Pinder Brar very nice
Pinder Brar video DESH NAAL PYAAR SI .....TE GURU SAHIBANA DI PRERNA .........DESH NAAL BOHT MOHABBAT SI OHNA NU
Good interview unfold many secret.like who is responsible for the partition of India.while Panjab and Bengal was crying and having blood bath. But some people were laughing in Delhi.
BAHUT ACHA LGA BHAGAT SINGH JI KE BAARE MAI S U N KE AAJ PHIR KISI AISE INSAAN SE JO UNKE SATH REH CHUKE HAI. JI LEYA BHAGAT SINGH JI KO AAJ. INQALAB ZINDABAD.
Zahe naseeb hmare kinapji da deedar hoea e, dhanwad ji Veer ji
Good job veer ji
🙏 babaji 🙏
MAIN FAN BHAGAT SINGH DA.........
Conspiracy to divide india is clear from this mans testimony.
शहीदे आज़म भगतसिंह अमर रहे।
jai bhagat singh ji
bhagat singh verge shaheed hoe tan bharat nu azaadi mili bhagat singh shaheed ji jindabad,ih bajurg dian gallan dassde han bara changa lagda hai,shaheedan nu parnaam
Baba jee is an InsPiration for good health
Waheguru ji
Very nice video Khan sahib
Sach da sath den waleya de chrna vich prnam
If I were there, I would have let so elderly to speak only. Its so distracting.
Very correct
ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧੀਆ ਜੀ ਧੰਨਵਾਦ
Good search. Please continue to keep your effort . Thanks.
Salute from Bengal!!!!
What a fantastic memory
Salute from Bengal .
Bhagat singh jindabad salute you. 🙏🙏
He was indeed Sikh. You may read the book "Jail Chitthiyaan" by Bhai Randhir Singh who was also a freedom fighter. He was the person whom Shahid Bhagat Singh wanted to meet while in prison. You will get to know the truth. Yes Bhagat Singh was an atheist for 4 years, but at the time of his martyrdom he had again become a theist. "Why I am an atheist" was written by him before this meeting with Bhai Randhir Singh.
And this is all if we give the discount of accepting that he did write the article which is highly doubt-worthy. I say so because he was classified as a terrorist and NOT a political prisoner (for bombing parliament and killing Saunders). Inmates classified as terrorists were NOT given writing material and other facilities that were given to political prisoners, so how could he have been able to write in the first place?
Also, Why I'm an atheist is laden with FACTUAL FALLACIES. For example, it states that Bhagat Singh's father was Arya Samaji (LOL). In reality he was not just a Sikh, but a Khalsa (amritdhari Sikh). This is evident from the autobiography of freedom fighter Sardar Ajit Singh (Bhagat Singh's uncle) in which he states that he with his brother (Bhagat Singh's father) had undergone the Sikh baptism ceremony called Amrit Sanchar at Anandpur Sahib. So how can Bhagat Singh's father be Arya Samaji when he is in fact an Amritdhari Sikh? This is a classic Hindu supremacist right-wing type of proaganda trying to undermine the Sikh sovereign identity by trying to doctrine our history, since it is also the fact is that Why I'm an Atheist was published in "The People" which was of Lala Lajpat Rai, who was linked with Savarkar who we all know basically is the father of the poisonous Hindu Rashtra ideology.
And it's been a modus operandi of the RSS to dilute or distort the history and scriptures of the Sikhs in order to make us weak. (Not to mention they also target all minorities and dalits) Since it's full of cowards who can't grow a pair and need such low actions to achieve their even lower motives.
If you've read "Why I'm an Atheist" then you should read the following the following 2 books as well and you'll come to know of the fallacies:
1. Jail Chitthiyaan (by Bhai Randhir Singh)
2. Pagdhi Sambhal Jatta To'n Azadi Wal (AUTObiography of freedom fighter Sardar Ajit Singh- uncle of Sardar Bhagat Singh)
He wanted to tell still more