lipped from 2:40. It's a pre-recorded track so it seems live. The most annoying about Mariah is that she can do the song just fine so I don't know why she lips, maybe because it is an entire show (many songs) so she doesn't want to overdo it?.
Oto Kage I think because shes being professional. Her songs r obviously too hard (to sing completely live) and itd be awkward to give a flawed performance to the audience
If she lips who tf really cares? Like I said she's been performing and giving her all since the 90s and on top of that she's has nodules for forever. Give her a break she's in her late forties for crying out loud. Let her live. I'm so sick of these so called "lambs" crying and bashing her because she lips.
i was thinking this is going to be lipped towards the end but the voice crack on 2:48 made me think other wise! i was like WOW.. proves she really has her on and off times.
@ 0:19 "if you know it sing along OK" part was actualy on her higher range and after hearing that i knew that night was def not a bad day for her voice. it did not sound 'dry' just like the other recent perf. i'm kind of thinking about the climax though-if it was live. i wish it was coz she sanggg it effortlessly.
shit Mariah's haters say "She lipped". You just have never heard someone so good at singing that it sounded as good as the recording or even better. Mariah has nothing to prove, and don't need your acknowledgement when she has got it from the greatests.
when Mimi is gone all these haters will be the ones saying "she was the greatest of all time rip :(" how about everyone shows her love when she's alive instead of doing when she's gone
Her codition that night could definitely do the last part live, but she didn't... This was the best night of her #1 To Infinity show, the only thing lack is she lipped the last part of WBT😭
I swear it's the only song that she sings good even in her bad period of singing because it's like she talks and not really sing it's just the end (climax) who is really hard though ! But you can pré-record it ! Love Mariah 😘 !
the best thing she could do now is to write new sets of songs with accordance to latest trend and apply her magical composing skills. enough for doing the Classic Mariah Thingies. it was never to late for her to win back her chance to hit Billboard's top.
she soounds good better than her other performances in the past she lost weight and got her voice in shape about time she can she but she has to keep her voice in shape
WTF are people talking about this not being LIVE??? This shows how F*CKING GOOD SHE IS!!!!!!!!! Now stop talking crap!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
shut it all up people! the song wasn't peroformed 100% Live! the verses were Live yet the last chorus (climax) wasn't. "when you left" was Live then followed by the pre-recorded audio. i'm a Fan and i Love her most BESTS and WORSTS.
don't pretend that you all are fully capacitated to tell she did it totally Live. Mariah has had her voice matured and can no longer hit E5 up to G5 comfortably without squeezing and forcing her cords so much. she more often had her songs nowadays lowered to best suit her current vocal range comfort zone.
age is like death for these stars, she is fighting to improve, and solve age effects on her voice, others like Britney are using lipsync since before even being 30... if she ever was able to sing actually.
IDon't 22 and it's not even that she couldn't hear, it was also because if you noticed the audio, you didn't hear her singing in the audio, which means she never planned to lip anyways, and all the delusional haters will never see that truth😡
It's actually way more tiring and way more prone to errors if she lipped these performances. Imagine the amount of variances she'd had to remember through countless performances. This is definitely not lipped.
it is nothing compared to memorizing an entire choreography for a show like some ultimate performers like mj madonna britney. she definitely is lipping the high parts now but i love mariah shes got nothing to prove
in this comment section there is two type of comment . when the performance of mariah carey is great they say it lip sync and when mariah carey is in trouble they say she cant sing annymore . like if you agree
i would say that this was her 2016's vocal range: Chest (D3 to D5) and Flute or Whistle Register (C7). looking for notes D#5 to G#5 (Chest)? these are the notes she CAN NO LONGER HIT ANYMORE. caused by maturity and hormonal development (after gving birth to her two children).
she had lost people's trust after being caught lipsyncing myriads of times. still have the time to gain back people's trust by having an another "comeback" with new set of music singing styles and songs!
I know she doesn't like POP. I hope she do POP song for her to have another no.1 hit. I am afraid Rihanna will surpass her..her latest single with carvin harris is currently no.3 at hot 100, I have a feeling that it is gonna be her 15th no.1, Mariah need to step up. Do more current and updated tune songs.. EDMA is currently IN. She needs to collaborate with famous DJ's ASAP. Leave the hiphop/R&B for now. Go to POP. PLS
This is 100% LIVE, and goodness she looks like 2005 Mariah!!! Love it, amazing performance!
Living Legend
Yes.
True.
True.
Yes Yes Yessss(in planktons voice)
Aaliyah Haughton it's skinny legend
Live 100% incredible!
lipped from 2:40. It's a pre-recorded track so it seems live. The most annoying about Mariah is that she can do the song just fine so I don't know why she lips, maybe because it is an entire show (many songs) so she doesn't want to overdo it?.
Oto Kage I think because shes being professional. Her songs r obviously too hard (to sing completely live) and itd be awkward to give a flawed performance to the audience
@@NamNguyen-ls6pb Especially when you have shows every other night. 1 song of hers can be a whole setlist of an amateur singer :)))
Her voice is on point. Queen slayed again
2:47
That shit was definitely LIVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
And thank you SOOOO much for uploading these videos!!!!!
she hasn't done that part live for a long long while
Are you guys talking about the whole climax or just the "When you left" part???
+ianianian she did it live during her last tour in Europe!!!
Ohhhh...
Thanks for letting me know guys,
+Patrick C I was there! She sang it live! Sit down!
"Wait a minute,this is too BLEAK..." LMAO
pcFOREVER89100 in which part?
Isn’t it “ wait a minute, this is too deep” or am I know it wrong? :)
metin kandemir she changed the lyrics on purpose
10/10 would pay to see her live
The real Queen, real talent, real voice! RESPECT
Omg!!! She still can sing
I can imagine 1995 Mariah sing this song perfectly, it's amazing. Even her voice has changed so much, but THIS IS LIVING LEGEND !!!!
Nah 1995 couldn’t sing this with the same emotion or enunciation
If she lips who tf really cares? Like I said she's been performing and giving her all since the 90s and on top of that she's has nodules for forever. Give her a break she's in her late forties for crying out loud. Let her live. I'm so sick of these so called "lambs" crying and bashing her because she lips.
i was thinking this is going to be lipped towards the end but the voice crack on 2:48 made me think other wise! i was like WOW.. proves she really has her on and off times.
The voice breaks are intentional, and the climax is lipped.
Anyone else notice she said "too bleak" at 8:41? That smile kills me.
Where is it?
Oops, I meant 1:48 lol. Instead of saying "this is too deep" she says "too bleak".heartbreaker
yeah. Hahahahaha! proves this is LIVE BABY!!!!
Too bleak dahling :P
@ 0:19 "if you know it sing along OK" part was actualy on her higher range and after hearing that i knew that night was def not a bad day for her voice. it did not sound 'dry' just like the other recent perf. i'm kind of thinking about the climax though-if it was live. i wish it was coz she sanggg it effortlessly.
SO POWERFUL AND IT HIT SO HARD UGH I LOVE THIS PERFORMANCE!!! 😩👌
Slay girl! Slay! This is one of her more lyrically full song. If she lipped this we would know! Go MC! This all you, girl!
Her vocals were on point this evening .... every performance!
Cry Demi with this voice wonderful, Mariah,the best.
Literally gives her all every performance. True artist.
They went IN with the musical ornaments and arrangements!👌🏻 It sounds so cool!
shit Mariah's haters say "She lipped". You just have never heard someone so good at singing that it sounded as good as the recording or even better. Mariah has nothing to prove, and don't need your acknowledgement when she has got it from the greatests.
when Mimi is gone all these haters will be the ones saying "she was the greatest of all time rip :(" how about everyone shows her love when she's alive instead of doing when she's gone
Her codition that night could definitely do the last part live, but she didn't... This was the best night of her #1 To Infinity show, the only thing lack is she lipped the last part of WBT😭
0:19 omg that sounds NOTHING like her really, you can tell by that that her voice was in really great shape this night! No rasp or hoarseness at all
I'm so sick of people saying she lipped. as long as it's her voice, who the hell cares?
She is so beautiful and talented.
just put a ribbon with a brooch on her chest and she could be a sailor senshi with that outfit
HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAH KAWAIIII (n_n)b
they should have her try on a red wig and purple gloves she would look like Jessica Rabbit
I literally just spat out on my screen. I didn't expect this comment! lmao
This was amazing! I saw her love on Tuesday and she put on a spectacular show!
She can sing ever!
song of the decade. my all time jammmmmmmmmmmmmm
I swear it's the only song that she sings good even in her bad period of singing because it's like she talks and not really sing it's just the end (climax) who is really hard though ! But you can pré-record it ! Love Mariah 😘 !
the best thing she could do now is to write new sets of songs with accordance to latest trend and apply her magical composing skills. enough for doing the Classic Mariah Thingies. it was never to late for her to win back her chance to hit Billboard's top.
She's ready for t.v. performances...
EmmanuelxMusic Ya found me lol .. She really is, these Vocals need to be shared with the world
+EmmanuelxMusic She shakes it off it's all good.. Hope your good lamby ;)
EmmanuelxMusic Awww happy belated birthday i got u anything haha.. I'm sorry it was a bust what happened. It's supposed to be your day...
EmmanuelxMusic Awww my bad it's late again haha, but if it makes u feel better my bday sucked too so lol :) Cheers Up my friend XoXo
EmmanuelxMusic I think next year will be better period lol.. I'll have an album from Mariah so I can cope with life lbvs
Thank you very much for uploading all the videos :*
Big Kiss & feel hugged :D
She sounds so beautiful here!
I really love the "When you left, I lost a part of me" in the end *Wig snatched*
She doesnt Lip. So let it go already, damn bitter people.
She does lip lol
Lol she does lip, and uses pre recorded vocals. Yes she does
Not this performance, surprisingly. But she lip syncs about 85% of the time
She sang the climax live but the ending long note was lip synced as always
Yes...she does. But this was live!
The Queen is back, y'all!!!
the looks in BREAKDOWN video...epic performance
Wtf. She's a goddess. Like this is amazing
Always rase,wonderful.
Luv luv mariah!
she fucking SLAYED that ending. period.
It's so easy to believe she lip syncs because when she's in good voice - like this performance - she sounds perfect! Just like studio!
Legend!!!!
she soounds good better than her other performances in the past she lost weight and got her voice in shape about time she can she but she has to keep her voice in shape
you are so amazing
My queeeeennnn!!!!!
None of this was lipped or prerecorded .. You can clearly hear organic Mariah and raspyness
Mariah Carey a mais linda Cantora Internacional Beijos
l love her
love thissssss
Nice voice only queen in my life
Omg... She's amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't care what anyone thinks!!!! She got me through Junior High!!!!
WTF are people talking about this not being LIVE??? This shows how F*CKING GOOD SHE IS!!!!!!!!!
Now stop talking crap!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Awesomeness! and Beauty ! 💜💜🌸💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜👼🌸🌸💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
shut it all up people! the song wasn't peroformed 100% Live! the verses were Live yet the last chorus (climax) wasn't. "when you left" was Live then followed by the pre-recorded audio. i'm a Fan and i Love her most BESTS and WORSTS.
don't pretend that you all are fully capacitated to tell she did it totally Live. Mariah has had her voice matured and can no longer hit E5 up to G5 comfortably without squeezing and forcing her cords so much. she more often had her songs nowadays lowered to best suit her current vocal range comfort zone.
age is like death for these stars, she is fighting to improve, and solve age effects on her voice, others like Britney are using lipsync since before even being 30... if she ever was able to sing actually.
Diva😻
The climax may be lipped, but "when you left" is not!
Yeah, that sentence is always love
+Lichy Guevara I mean live lol
so perfect
lipped or not at the end of the day its her own voice so who cares if she is or isnt does or doesnt ITS MARIAH SINGING her own songs
wow so many vocal experts here ha!
good breath support
linda diva ❤❤
Oh god dam❤️
ETERNA LINDAAA A MELHORRR
FACT - MARIAH CAREY IS A FLAWLESS QUEEN WHOSE VOCALS HABE NOT FAULTED FOR THE PAST THREE DECADES
And because of that NYE performance these stupid people think she can no longer sing.
IDon't 22 and it's not even that she couldn't hear, it was also because if you noticed the audio, you didn't hear her singing in the audio, which means she never planned to lip anyways, and all the delusional haters will never see that truth😡
divvvvaaaaa!!!
this one was good
100% live!
She sounds sooo amazing y'all think it's lip singing!
Lipped or not, mother slays!!!!
if i were her and if i had such a voice like that, i write new set of songs then record it. who knows? she might win another #1 spot in Billboard's.
I'm feeling EOM vibes!
divaaaaa
First live after 2010???
she sang it every year after 2011
💙
It's actually way more tiring and way more prone to errors if she lipped these performances. Imagine the amount of variances she'd had to remember through countless performances. This is definitely not lipped.
it is nothing compared to memorizing an entire choreography for a show like some ultimate performers like mj madonna britney. she definitely is lipping the high parts now but i love mariah shes got nothing to prove
1:49 this is too bleak !
Climax is lipped dahlings. It's just a different pre-record.
I love the voice 2:45
Shit, there goes my weave again..!
in this comment section there is two type of comment . when the performance of mariah carey is great they say it lip sync and when mariah carey is in trouble they say she cant sing annymore . like if you agree
i would say that this was her 2016's vocal range: Chest (D3 to D5) and Flute or Whistle Register (C7). looking for notes D#5 to G#5 (Chest)? these are the notes she CAN NO LONGER HIT ANYMORE. caused by maturity and hormonal development (after gving birth to her two children).
nice this real voice not lipped
😍👑❤❤❤❤
no other
Why would she lip sync a prolonged C5? She is a soprano people its live get over it lol!!
LIVE
she had lost people's trust after being caught lipsyncing myriads of times. still have the time to gain back people's trust by having an another "comeback" with new set of music singing styles and songs!
SKINNY 😍
❤Dear sweet beautiful angle carey❤ honey am❤ missing ❤ you so❤ very mouh❤ ho yes girl❤ am so❤ last with❤ out nice❤ nice you❤
Who wants to see Beyonce and Avril Lavigne and fifth harmony cover this?
At 1:49 she says "This is too bleak" lol
okay, so...where's the proof that she's lipping?
2:45 threw 3:03
I know she doesn't like POP. I hope she do POP song for her to have another no.1 hit. I am afraid Rihanna will surpass her..her latest single with carvin harris is currently no.3 at hot 100, I have a feeling that it is gonna be her 15th no.1, Mariah need to step up. Do more current and updated tune songs.. EDMA is currently IN. She needs to collaborate with famous DJ's ASAP. Leave the hiphop/R&B for now. Go to POP. PLS
agree