In terms of performing and dance, Shuhua looks so much more confident. Her facial expressions have more emotion and her moves look more refined. Good job!
What's on my mind is that Shuhua's lines stood out to me the most, her appearances in the MV was my most fave and the fact that she had decent center distribution is what makes my life complete…
I agree. Of course it would have been great to see Shuhua singing more, but the whole time watching the MV, I kept thinking Shuhua is the main character.
@@hanmira probably because it's a high pitched tone and Shuhua must've recorded it too many times to get it right but the radio is pretty much singing on the spot. And as of now, KBS confirmed it's Shuhua's HWAA on the final part.
Some neverlands are blaming Soyeon for the “Unfair” line distribution to Shuhua, Yes. Soyeon made the song and gave the lines, But she wanted shuhua to sing soojins part but shuhua said not to give her much lines because she isnt confident with her korean speaking, Shes still learnig, a lot of people from shuhuas countey even said that they wont buy the album because if shuhuas lines and screen time they keep blaming soyeon, Pls stop blaming her, it was shuhuas choice shes not confident lets just cheer for Shuhua maybe the time will come where shes confident
@@PrincessDaisyFan lol are you implying that everyone after a 3 year period should be confident? lol whenever Shuhua is ready to have her lines in the title tracks, she will sing them. For now, she sings in the b-sides so luckily you don't have to suffer for long.
@@PrincessDaisyFan Not u assuming the insecurities have an expiration date. I have a bad self-esteem for seven years now, why should she overcome it in three years? :p lmao stfu
@@PrincessDaisyFan if you’re a fan of shuhua, you need to support her no matter what. If you can’t wait for her, there are other groups you can listen too. If you don’t like them, there are a lot of options.
i think that was just a mistake; miyeon doesn't move her mouth at all during that part and theres only one voice. its like how they put "taolla taolla" as an all part in the chorus because they're just carrying the previous nametag over, even though thats just soyeons voice
@@teenysss I think the reason why they put the ttaolla as All because it's background vocals. Soyeon is the one composed the song so ofc most of background noise and line are all hers.
Thank you for this! I was so glad to see that Shuhua got more lines when watching the Mcountdown performance, I hope she attempts to sing the hwaa live soon so we can hear how confident her voice has gotten.
the chorus of the songs and, in general, the songs "hwaa" and "hann" are somewhat similar, because of the intro at the end I thought it was the same song ... 😳
@@dandaraandrade7656 .I do not know in what sense this song is a continuation of "hann", since I am a foreign fan (I am from Kyrgyzstan), therefore I did not know, _--lol-_-
@@nctzensomnia3929 No problem, I'm also a foreign fan (I'm from Brazil) despite not understanding what this has to do with knowing or not knowing this fact :)
No she doesn't...everyone sings the first two chorus but the last chorus is lead by Shuhua. It's confirmed in their performance (I forgot which) but in the lyrics they wrote the first two choruses are sang by "all" and in the last chorus it was written it was lead by shuhua. And the choruses sounds different it's very clear only the last chorus is lead by her (even in the MV)
@@user-oe1un3wi6d if u listen and compare you would know theres only one voice in the first 2 chorus but theres something like an echoing effect. and the pronunciation is exactly the same with the so called “shuhua lead part”.
@@sidekicks1403 If it's sang by only one, then why does the official lyrics says it's sang by all? And in the last chorus why it's shown as Shuhua leading? Personally I hear like 2-3 voices harmonizing (and two of them being Miyeon and Shuhua) in the first 2 hwaa but in the last one Shuhua leads it. Even in the MV only in the last chorus Shuhua was shown singing that hwaa part. And if it was sang by only one person, then she would have sang alone when they were asked to sing the chorus in shows but all of them sang it instead.
@@eye63 yes she leads it but only the last chorus. In the official lyrics it's written that the first two choruses are sang by *all* and the last one was *lead* by *shuhua.*
People don't count it since Miyeon's high note is not visible but its in the hidden vocals but yes they do sing together but the high note for "hwaaaa" before Shuhua leading the last chorus Minnie does the high note herself
GUYS! Shuhua's line is correct base on the mentioning/tagging of hangul names in their performance yesterday..her mentioned name includes ALL, which means Shuhua leads the line. Just like in Twice's Yes or yes, all yes or yes parts are mentioned as member+all.. it it also states that minnie + miyeon sang the line in 2:53 and 'taolla taolla' line in the chorus is also counted as ALL but for me its just Soyeon.. Just like FANCY YOU line in Twice Fancy... Mnet mentioned FANCY YOU as ALL part but many Once think Chaeyoung & Nayeon Sang that line.. *NOT FLUENT*
It seems like I this race Soyeon is in the lead by a lot and Shuhua is in la- wait Shuhua is making a run for it will she catch up to the other members Shuhua was in last and still is in last... by a lot still but better then before at least 😂😂😂
This is a perfect line distribution.... All get their iconic line even tho there's a bit huge gap but it's fine cuz it's based of their Vocal and position
@@vanillashakes4275 you mean this one? ruclips.net/video/2njcKe_wweU/видео.html Tbh that cant really mean a lot,bc they all at some point lipsync parts that other members sing live too (Miyeon singing Soyeon burn burn etc) they were enjoying it and singing along alot like always. For me sometimes they all sound same or I hear other members,that could be my problem but I'll choose to believe that,bc many long-time Nevies said it's Shuhua too
@@vanillashakes4275 i know that but that was the different structure of the song and her part happen to be at the end and other members didn't sing the same line at all. You can't really compare it. And yeah,Shuhua voice is hard to recognize bc she can sound like every member.
@@vanillashakes4275 Did you really listen to the song what I mean is the song not any live okay? The song looks like you really dont know that the backgroud voice is shuhua the one who sang it cmon men do a research and I read many comments that shuhua is the one who sang the chorus parts the last part is shuhua right? She sang it all background voice of hwaa okay?
This song was written 1 year ago and shuhua wasn’t as comfortable with her voice and dance moves back then so she would ask soyean to give her less lines so she could be comfortable
@@iztime6500 still the true ofc she still has room to improve but this take time, and even then it's not right give her lines that she can't reach or sing live
I'm a bit angry ... because they make Shuhua biased like we're ot1, and that's not true ... lol Guys, let's respect Shuhua, I'll wait for the day when she's ready.
As it should have been. If you don't know Shuhua, then STFU. That, Hwaa, Hann also has been Shuhua's. From listening on the first time, I knew it was two people singing Hwaa. I don't watch distribution because somehow I know it's wrong or whatsoever. But, I'm attracted to it. Because it's UPDATED.
in the bridge, I found it strange when the m countdown stage said Miyeon and Minnie shared Minnie's "supposed solo line" (the high note part). I don't think I can hear Miyeon or is she backing up Minnie in that line?
YuSooShu should form a subunit. At some point. Minnie had collabs, Soyeon had collabs and solos, Miyeon is still on the better half on the line distribution... I want to see all my girls vocals shining 😥
Definitely not. Hwaa sounds like Hann because it's a sequel, Lion and Oh my god really look alike, but Dumdi Dumdi, Latata, Uh-oh and Señorita have nothing in common.
The part in the chorus “taolla toalla” is sung by everyone, not only Soyeon. Also, Minnie’s part in the bridge is sung by both Miyeon and Minnie. That’s the real line distribution
ikr 💀 I still cannot think how these people still believe that the part of “Fancyy you~~” is sung by Chaeyoung and Nayeon when they literally performed that shit like a million times and it clearly said that is sung by everyone in all of them ¿??
Yall are fake ,pretend to be shuhua stan ,but bashing other members ,but btw where are yall when she being bashed for being "tOnE dEaF" yall suddenly dissapeared lol
Before you jump to line distribution thing, one thing you should know that every member in every group has their POSITION in terms of singing and dancing. So don't blame Soyeon again for the line distribution. Also, title track is a track that you will perform in music shows, which is g idle decide to sing their song live since hann era. Ofc they will choose the most stable person to sing the most part. Not only g idle choose the same way to pick the most stable person to have the most part, many other group do the same. And you know who is that in G idle (not bringing down other member, i know they are stable too, but i said the most) The girls think that these distributions is OK, they are fine with this. So stop doing thing blaming each other just for your favorite cause G idles complete each other. Peace. And love (G)I-DLE *Sorry if my english is bad
I feel like MNET only labeled Shuhua as the lead for the last chorus because of the backlash. Technically all of them still sing the last chorus and that makes me sad. Cube needs to own up to their mistakes and give Shuhua actual lines.
all of them still sing the last chorus because Mnet mentioned ALL, Shuhua there.. just like in TWICE's Yes or yes... all yes or yes line is mentioned as Nayeon, ALL ,Jihyo, ALL ,Chaeyoung, ALL ,Sana,ALL ,Jeongyeon, ALL & Momo, ALL
on my opinion,line distribution doesnt matter as long as they work as a team...besides they always discuss everything before recording and doing the actual music video.in every group theres visual,dancer,singer.but each and every member if g idle has it all..we all know theyre very talented...there are other idols who doesnt sing but so good at dancing,and the fans are ok with it.i think shuhua's chinese fans just overreacted about this mv.coz just because she doesnt have long lines it doesnt mean she cant sing.we all know that she has a good voice too.
1. Main Rapper 2. Main Vocalist 3. Main Vocalist 4. Lead Vocalist 5. Sub-Vocalist 6. Sub-Vocalist It's pretty ok, considering thier position in the group
Shuhua has said she like her parts, and in the Behind the scenes for OMG she said her favorite line was "--- fall in love" because is easy to pronounce. Cube doesn't decide wich member is going to sing each line (they can say if they agree or not with the song to be released). Usually the writers of the songs are the people who can embody the lines better, for example if you listen the songs written by Minnie, she is the one who sings the most, and in this case, the 80% of (G)I-DLE songs are written by Soyeon who can also sing well, and when she is writring them she thinks about every member to can fit the song. The girls have said in interviews that they choose their lines according to who suits them better. Also this: twitter.com/yellow_i_ng/status/1295363483974991872
![[DOKKAN BATTLE] Worldwide Campaign Announcement Video Part 2!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JpT5Voak6WA/mqdefault.jpg)
In terms of performing and dance, Shuhua looks so much more confident. Her facial expressions have more emotion and her moves look more refined. Good job!
Greee
Facts!
Now that's way more fair than her 4 sec line
Your name lol
@@lthv____ lmaooo who said that again i forgot
@@heyfelixxxheyyyigottheimpo4560 yeri and wendy lmao
finally a line distribution that shows shuhua’s true lines!
Yes ikr
ruclips.net/video/epauNBE_Tkc/видео.html
Yes, this is better than without the lead line
Shuhuas still last but at least it’s not glaringly obvious now
What's on my mind is that Shuhua's lines stood out to me the most, her appearances in the MV was my most fave and the fact that she had decent center distribution is what makes my life complete…
And though she had short lines, her impact in the MV was remarkable!
I agree. Of course it would have been great to see Shuhua singing more, but the whole time watching the MV, I kept thinking Shuhua is the main character.
Only this one counts for now since M Countdown confirmed it now.
Where :0?
@@thankyou1400 check the lyrics on the bottom right on M Countdown G IDLE Hwaa performance.
@@Thunderbuk1 but why doesn't she sing that part in radio stations
@@hanmira probably because it's a high pitched tone and Shuhua must've recorded it too many times to get it right but the radio is pretty much singing on the spot. And as of now, KBS confirmed it's Shuhua's HWAA on the final part.
@@Thunderbuk1 Why did they give her something she can't sing live
Now it's better because everyone has at least 10 seconds.
Some neverlands are blaming Soyeon for the “Unfair” line distribution to Shuhua, Yes. Soyeon made the song and gave the lines, But she wanted shuhua to sing soojins part but shuhua said not to give her much lines because she isnt confident with her korean speaking, Shes still learnig, a lot of people from shuhuas countey even said that they wont buy the album because if shuhuas lines and screen time they keep blaming soyeon, Pls stop blaming her, it was shuhuas choice shes not confident lets just cheer for Shuhua maybe the time will come where shes confident
It’s been 3 years, she should be confident now! If she’s not she will never be?
How much more should we wait???
@@PrincessDaisyFan lol are you implying that everyone after a 3 year period should be confident? lol whenever Shuhua is ready to have her lines in the title tracks, she will sing them. For now, she sings in the b-sides so luckily you don't have to suffer for long.
@@PrincessDaisyFan Not u assuming the insecurities have an expiration date. I have a bad self-esteem for seven years now, why should she overcome it in three years? :p lmao stfu
@@PrincessDaisyFan if you’re a fan of shuhua, you need to support her no matter what. If you can’t wait for her, there are other groups you can listen too. If you don’t like them, there are a lot of options.
When soyeon said that
UP-ING THIS BECAUSE THIS IS THE ONLY REVISION THAT COUNTS. This is the real Line distribution that is according to Mnet and Cube
Really?
@@unaiparamo7338 well, add KBS. They also did it during the KBS G IDLE performance sooo it's 3 now.
shuhua was in the last place and move to the last place
😂😂😂😂don’t know why this was so funny to me
2:53 - Minnie and miyeon.
there at the mnet in today's stage says that they are two
Yeah
i think that was just a mistake; miyeon doesn't move her mouth at all during that part and theres only one voice. its like how they put "taolla taolla" as an all part in the chorus because they're just carrying the previous nametag over, even though thats just soyeons voice
I don't know, but I know it was there
@@teenysss I think the reason why they put the ttaolla as All because it's background vocals. Soyeon is the one composed the song so ofc most of background noise and line are all hers.
Right now, KBS confirmed it too.
shuhua stans: *imma pretend this is the official*
edit: so this is the official now, well i'm glad because 4 seconds did not give her justice
It is official,g idle just posted a music clip 2 hours ago,and its shuhua line
Its on Mnet lyrics so ofc its official.
@@mmmba2804 it is. M Countdown always provide the lyrics with who sings it.
@@mmmba2804 it's Shuhua's line, you can watch their M! Countdown Comeback Stage, it's said that's Shuhua's line
But it's really official after watching their stage 😃
Thank you for this! I was so glad to see that Shuhua got more lines when watching the Mcountdown performance, I hope she attempts to sing the hwaa live soon so we can hear how confident her voice has gotten.
3:03 yes it shuhua voice
the chorus of the songs and, in general, the songs "hwaa" and "hann" are somewhat similar, because of the intro at the end I thought it was the same song ... 😳
Hwaa is a continuation of hann
Hwaa is the continuation of Hann, so it is to be expected that they are similar lol
@@mirabeljt9688 thank you❤️
@@dandaraandrade7656 .I do not know in what sense this song is a continuation of "hann", since I am a foreign fan (I am from Kyrgyzstan), therefore I did not know, _--lol-_-
@@nctzensomnia3929 No problem, I'm also a foreign fan (I'm from Brazil) despite not understanding what this has to do with knowing or not knowing this fact :)
shuhua: breaths
cube: ok! we finished
??? Wtf
Do you consider 13 seconds as just breathing??
@@weareclcgo1374 "aren't memorable" please, even the girls agreed on Kiss The Radio that Shuhua's part is the killing part
@@weareclcgo1374 Shuhua got a really iconic part, in my opinion. The part right before the chorus is definitely the killing part.
Cube isn't involved in I-DLE's musical process. Educate yourself about the group before throwing shade
Some of you don't even care about shuhua and are just jumping on the bandwagon.
They are not even nevies
Even if Shuhua has fewer lines she really killed it in this MV. It's only fair to have her be the center of this video. The visuals just kills
It's actually the same as yuqi's "yufufufu" part in Senorita, but why don't anyone notice it lol
shuhua sings all chorus “hwaa” part. how can ppl not tell? its so obvious
No she doesn't...everyone sings the first two chorus but the last chorus is lead by Shuhua. It's confirmed in their performance (I forgot which) but in the lyrics they wrote the first two choruses are sang by "all" and in the last chorus it was written it was lead by shuhua.
And the choruses sounds different it's very clear only the last chorus is lead by her (even in the MV)
@@user-oe1un3wi6d if u listen and compare you would know theres only one voice in the first 2 chorus but theres something like an echoing effect. and the pronunciation is exactly the same with the so called “shuhua lead part”.
@@user-oe1un3wi6d no she leads the chorus then everyone sings it after her
@@sidekicks1403 If it's sang by only one, then why does the official lyrics says it's sang by all? And in the last chorus why it's shown as Shuhua leading?
Personally I hear like 2-3 voices harmonizing (and two of them being Miyeon and Shuhua) in the first 2 hwaa but in the last one Shuhua leads it. Even in the MV only in the last chorus Shuhua was shown singing that hwaa part. And if it was sang by only one person, then she would have sang alone when they were asked to sing the chorus in shows but all of them sang it instead.
@@eye63 yes she leads it but only the last chorus. In the official lyrics it's written that the first two choruses are sang by *all* and the last one was *lead* by *shuhua.*
I thought Minnie and Miyeon did the highnote 2gether.
People don't count it since Miyeon's high note is not visible but its in the hidden vocals but yes they do sing together but the high note for "hwaaaa" before Shuhua leading the last chorus Minnie does the high note herself
SHUHUAAAAA
Second, I LOVE IT🇧🇷💜
Tbm sou do Brasil
@@Cherry-fp7yf da uma olhada no meu canal, eu faço you as member 💜
At least now it's better balanced btw thanks for the video!!
Finally someone who count shuhua last chorus
Thank you omg I KNEW she was singing that bridge hwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
YES ! Congrats to shuhua because her lines is more than 4 sec 💖
Shuhua miss SNOW 💕
GUYS! Shuhua's line is correct base on the mentioning/tagging of hangul names in their performance yesterday..her mentioned name includes ALL, which means Shuhua leads the line. Just like in Twice's Yes or yes, all yes or yes parts are mentioned as member+all..
it it also states that minnie + miyeon sang the line in 2:53
and 'taolla taolla' line in the chorus is also counted as ALL but for me its just Soyeon.. Just like FANCY YOU line in Twice Fancy... Mnet mentioned FANCY YOU as ALL part but many Once think Chaeyoung & Nayeon Sang that line..
*NOT FLUENT*
thank you
In the last part shuhua sings wow 💞
It seems like I this race Soyeon is in the lead by a lot and Shuhua is in la- wait Shuhua is making a run for it will she catch up to the other members Shuhua was in last and still is in last... by a lot still but better then before at least 😂😂😂
Lmaoo
Yes, I've been waiting for a video like this
I'm so happy Shuhua's last chorus line was noticed :-)
After hwaa, when hann started playing i thought it was the same song😳
thank u for updating 😌
You don’t count Miyeon’s line during Minnie’s final high note
Its like with "maybe" everyone thought she had nothing but she has
it's funny how all the people pressuring shuhua to sing only comment on the 4s ones
A melhor line distribution que já vi até agora
Huhuhu Shuhua😭 btw i am a new fan of gidle
I just saw their music bank performance and when the last Chorus came you can see in the bottom left it says “Shuhua/all”
****Taolla taolla in mcountdown is all
I think at 0:40 and 0:45 the line in the back is Miyeon and not Soyeon and Yuqi :)
I'm glad the last 'hwaa' was Shuhua's line instead
Luv thiss💕
Can you do Center Distribution of TWICE'S I CAN'T STOP ME? also in EDGE?
I mean we can see her singing it in the MV and hear her idk why no one thought it was her from the start.
Funny how fast misinformation spreads.
This is a interesting music!
This is a perfect line distribution.... All get their iconic line even tho there's a bit huge gap but it's fine cuz it's based of their Vocal and position
I clearly hear only Miyeon and Minnie in all the choruses
i hear soojin and shuhua too
Same. Everyone except Soyeon and Yuqi cuz they have strong voice and wouldnt fit singing the HWAAA~ parts
or it could be shuhua because it has been stated shuhuas vocals can sound like 3 members at once
Idle have stated that Shuhua’s voice sounds like a mix of the other members voices so that might be why
Shuhua's voice is definitely it.
Woah
Wait if this is from m countdown then why isn't miyeons part in minnie's bridge counted?
Many people are considering that part a mistake since Miyeon doesn't even move their mouths and only one voice is heard.
@@dandaraandrade7656 ruclips.net/video/5oVfMbS9HtU/видео.html watch this vid. Miyeon is harmonizing Minnies part.
@@Unknown-ie7ps Yes I know. I'm just explaining why many people don't consider it, not saying what I think :)
Every Hwaa is hers
Shuhua is the one who sang the all the chorus part if you didn't know all the Hwaa background voice is shuhua
@@vanillashakes4275 all hwaas sound the same,she did sing all of them
@@vanillashakes4275 and official lyrisc is mnet/kbs? They aren't always accurate. All hwaas sound the same and it sounds all like her.
@@vanillashakes4275 you mean this one? ruclips.net/video/2njcKe_wweU/видео.html
Tbh that cant really mean a lot,bc they all at some point lipsync parts that other members sing live too (Miyeon singing Soyeon burn burn etc) they were enjoying it and singing along alot like always.
For me sometimes they all sound same or I hear other members,that could be my problem but I'll choose to believe that,bc many long-time Nevies said it's Shuhua too
@@vanillashakes4275 i know that but that was the different structure of the song and her part happen to be at the end and other members didn't sing the same line at all. You can't really compare it. And yeah,Shuhua voice is hard to recognize bc she can sound like every member.
@@vanillashakes4275 Did you really listen to the song what I mean is the song not any live okay? The song looks like you really dont know that the backgroud voice is shuhua the one who sang it cmon men do a research and I read many comments that shuhua is the one who sang the chorus parts the last part is shuhua right? She sang it all background voice of hwaa okay?
lmao why do yall care so much about the line distribution wtf shuhua is comfortable with her lines just understand it.
Yes "fair"...but I expect to see her with more lines because she deserves it
❤️❤️
First
Umm....On ther Bridge of Minnie
Miyeon just sing with Minnie except Minnie's High Note
Thankyou
finally, a correct line distribution
i miss you
This song was written 1 year ago and shuhua wasn’t as comfortable with her voice and dance moves back then so she would ask soyean to give her less lines so she could be comfortable
stop complaining, she's a sub vocalist, that's it
she doesn't has the vocal technique to sing the others part and being estable
That's a bit harsh:(
@@iztime6500 still the true
ofc she still has room to improve but this take time, and even then it's not right give her lines that she can't reach or sing live
I'm a bit angry ... because they make Shuhua biased like we're ot1, and that's not true ... lol
Guys, let's respect Shuhua, I'll wait for the day when she's ready.
As it should have been. If you don't know Shuhua, then STFU. That, Hwaa, Hann also has been Shuhua's. From listening on the first time, I knew it was two people singing Hwaa. I don't watch distribution because somehow I know it's wrong or whatsoever. But, I'm attracted to it. Because it's UPDATED.
Where is link, that Shuhua sing last chorus? I want to see it, please ~
soyeon 37.3s minnie 29.3s miyeon 26.6s yuqi 18.8s soojin 16.8s shuhua 12.2s
I think shuhua sang ad-libs in between yuqi first part too? The one that yuqi use blue umbrella
Can u do AESPA ?
in the bridge, I found it strange when the m countdown stage said Miyeon and Minnie shared Minnie's "supposed solo line" (the high note part). I don't think I can hear Miyeon or is she backing up Minnie in that line?
I honestly think it was a typo
@@cdy7048 its also written on the kbs stage today, so i don't think it's a typo.
The "taolla taolla" should be great if Shuhua sing that bcs soyeon sing a lot
YuSooShu should form a subunit. At some point.
Minnie had collabs, Soyeon had collabs and solos, Miyeon is still on the better half on the line distribution...
I want to see all my girls vocals shining 😥
Soojin has dance videos and plenty of lines in almost every title track though - hann, senorita, uh oh, lion, oh my god etc
2:53 onwards except for high note is also Miyeon
Finally someone Who understands
is it me or their songs sounds mostly the same ?
Definitely not. Hwaa sounds like Hann because it's a sequel, Lion and Oh my god really look alike, but Dumdi Dumdi, Latata, Uh-oh and Señorita have nothing in common.
@@dandaraandrade7656 oh I see
No????
Lol no
2:54 it’s Minnie and Miyeon’s line but the voice of Miyeon is in hidden vocal
@0:40 and 0:45 it's Shuhua
Do you have a source for that?
Finally true lines
The part in the chorus “taolla toalla” is sung by everyone, not only Soyeon. Also, Minnie’s part in the bridge is sung by both Miyeon and Minnie.
That’s the real line distribution
Where did you find the official lyrics?
You can check it on their last stages on Mnet Countdown and Music Bank. There they specified which member is singing !
These videos are so bad I can’t
ikr 💀 I still cannot think how these people still believe that the part of “Fancyy you~~” is sung by Chaeyoung and Nayeon when they literally performed that shit like a million times and it clearly said that is sung by everyone in all of them ¿??
They were on live for two radio and it was minnie who sang it
Yall are fake ,pretend to be shuhua stan ,but bashing other members ,but btw where are yall when she being bashed for being "tOnE dEaF" yall suddenly dissapeared lol
What Change?
Before you jump to line distribution thing, one thing you should know that every member in every group has their POSITION in terms of singing and dancing. So don't blame Soyeon again for the line distribution. Also, title track is a track that you will perform in music shows, which is g idle decide to sing their song live since hann era. Ofc they will choose the most stable person to sing the most part. Not only g idle choose the same way to pick the most stable person to have the most part, many other group do the same. And you know who is that in G idle (not bringing down other member, i know they are stable too, but i said the most)
The girls think that these distributions is OK, they are fine with this. So stop doing thing blaming each other just for your favorite cause G idles complete each other. Peace. And love (G)I-DLE
*Sorry if my english is bad
I can hear Miyeon in the end with Minnie...
is that just me?
Yeah you are right
I feel like MNET only labeled Shuhua as the lead for the last chorus because of the backlash. Technically all of them still sing the last chorus and that makes me sad. Cube needs to own up to their mistakes and give Shuhua actual lines.
This!
And how quickly fans are now changing how they feel is proving they made the right move.
all of them still sing the last chorus because Mnet mentioned ALL, Shuhua there..
just like in TWICE's Yes or yes... all yes or yes line is mentioned as Nayeon, ALL ,Jihyo, ALL ,Chaeyoung, ALL ,Sana,ALL ,Jeongyeon, ALL & Momo, ALL
And the others HWAA~?
on my opinion,line distribution doesnt matter as long as they work as a team...besides they always discuss everything before recording and doing the actual music video.in every group theres visual,dancer,singer.but each and every member if g idle has it all..we all know theyre very talented...there are other idols who doesnt sing but so good at dancing,and the fans are ok with it.i think shuhua's chinese fans just overreacted about this mv.coz just because she doesnt have long lines it doesnt mean she cant sing.we all know that she has a good voice too.
1. Main Rapper
2. Main Vocalist
3. Main Vocalist
4. Lead Vocalist
5. Sub-Vocalist
6. Sub-Vocalist
It's pretty ok, considering thier position in the group
Yuqi is Sub
Thanks vídeo, woo ah bad girl,I don't Miss U ,please
I kinda knew but just waited for everyone to calm down and finally understand :/
Give Shuhua more lines😔
but in chorus, is all the lines "Hwaa" was sang by Shuhua??
Yes
@@fangirlinneverland6335 i mean all the lines Hwaa in whole song was sang by her ,right?
@@oneleeeee yes
@@fangirlinneverland6335 that's so amazinggggg
Shuhua did not sing all the hwaa?
Chorus 1, 2: Miyeon
Final chorus: Shuhua
@@z.yxingnguyen7723 ohhh thanks
@@z.yxingnguyen7723 no one leads the first two choruses, their voices was evenly distributed.
Shuhua lead the bridge.
@@char7160 i dont think so all Singing in 1 and 2 chorous , I didnt heard soyeon at all
@@babyjichu2579 in mcountdown they labelled it as [All] singing
It didn't change the fact that they treat Shuhua unfairly.
it doesnt change the fact she surprisingly beats soyeon in two songs
Shuhua has said she like her parts, and in the Behind the scenes for OMG she said her favorite line was "--- fall in love" because is easy to pronounce. Cube doesn't decide wich member is going to sing each line (they can say if they agree or not with the song to be released). Usually the writers of the songs are the people who can embody the lines better, for example if you listen the songs written by Minnie, she is the one who sings the most, and in this case, the 80% of (G)I-DLE songs are written by Soyeon who can also sing well, and when she is writring them she thinks about every member to can fit the song. The girls have said in interviews that they choose their lines according to who suits them better.
Also this: twitter.com/yellow_i_ng/status/1295363483974991872
ok but 2:53 is also Miyeon line
Why can i hear soyeon in Shuhua's Hwaaa
Shuhua does not sing for these ten seconds on stage ...
Hello i'love You✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨❤️❤️❤️❤️💌💌💌
I think she has only the second hwaa bc the first one is for soojin
Nop