Understanding Bharat - History, Heritage & Hypocrisy with J Sai Deepak | Yuvaveer Talks
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024
- UNDERSTANDING BHARAT - History, Heritage & Hypocrisy - with J Sai Deepak - advocate, Supreme Court
Yuvaveer Talk Series - Organised by Chinmaya Yuva Kendra
What connects a 73 year old constitutional republic to Bharat, a civilization over 5000 years old?
What defines our identity as citizens of Bharat?
How should we view our history and heritage? Is history relevant to the 21st century?
I can listen him 365 days with out break...what a insightful person
+1
Excellent talk.. its always a pleasure to listen to J Sai Deepak speak.. Krishna give him long life and good health for sake of our Civilization
🙏💯
You're here?
Bhagwaan🕉️bless him and give him a long healthy life
Jai Shree Krishna 🙏♥️🚩🕉️
Who else here watches J Sai Deepak's same interview two or three times to grasp entire essence of his points. I always do. 🙏
Not me, got it first time, he is so clear in his thinking and articulation. As always.
So true. Imagine his knowledge base, and we have to go back and read it again to understand and grasp what he is saying.
I agree that his thoughts and presentations have great clarity but some parts have to be heard again to really absorb it
Articulation of crystal clear thoughts in the most lucid manner - Sai Deepak is the best.
Indeed true! 🙏🏻
Thanks.Every point he deals in 100%clarity.His every remark and realisation is prophetic.
He is the chosen son of Maa Bharath. He makes always sense the issues he discusses. Bow to him. Love you thambi. Stay blessed as always dear. Thanks a lot for educating us. ❤️🙏🏻
I think his mother tongue is Tamil but brought up in Hyderabad.
First of all bharat is not mata
Whole dharti is considered as darti mata
I first heard j sai deepak on CAA and ever since hav followed him..wat a brilliant mind..need more people like him in our Bharat.
I'm going to work, live & die for the Sanatana Dharma 🙏
Let’s all pledge to that🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼
my pledge too
This is one of the best interviews of Sai. What a clarity. He is prime example of an unapologetic Hindu .
JSai Deepak is blessed by Goddess Sarasvati. May he continue his explorations and serve Ma Bharati 🙏
He's godsend ambassador for hindu revival... We all must stand by him in his efforts....
Sai deepak sir please include us in your army.
Bloody brilliant. What a gem of a person. What conviction and knowledge. Kudos man. Take a bow.
J Sai Deepak is a serious need of the hour . Need more people like him !
Very informative, insightful & a no nonsense talk that can only be expected from JSD & big thumbs up for the interviewer too. 🙏
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
True. The questioner was equally good. Lovely conversation. We love u both💐💐💐💐
What a scholar! Just the man dharma needs. God bless him with a long and healthy life.
We begin to appreciate “Sumbhavami Yuge Yuge “ as we witness it here 🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼
The passion and conviction that Sai exuberates in dissecting what shrouds Indic civilization is enlightening.. Everytime you listen to him it resonates with everything that happens around you and breaks all misconception that we have been conditioned with, what we have been taught as history, makes you unlearn things that is perceived as right or wrong.. Credit to the interviewer for covering all pertinent topics and steering the conversation towards great nuances..
Until now the best comment I came across. Kudos to you dear brother. 🙏🏻
God bless you son...keep torch alighted and take to dark ages where Indian youth is rottening
In South East Asia, Hindhu civilisation and language thrived, many years ago. In Indonesia and Malaysia, India was then, referred to as Barat, which also meant west, since India was in the west
He is so fast, crystal clear and out of my intellect range that I had to watch few portions in 0.75x..🙄😂
Same here 😂
I kept at 1.75x
Sai Deepak gives us hope that our Dharmic tradition may at last be saved. Sooner than later Sai Deepak should get into active politics. Only such a sacrifice may ultimately contribute to the dharma that he is so passionate about.
No way. He’s better as a spokesperson. Always double down on ur strength. He may not b a good politician. It requires a cunning and viciousness that he might not possess. Especially speaking blunt truth isn’t smart as a politician. And he doesn’t seem the type to parse his words or obfuscate as one needs as a politician.
What a treat to listen to J Sai Deepak!
The Dharmic discourse is changing from defensive to offensive. A welcome change.
Lest they find us wanting
Very few who can speak about problems and solutions with such clarity ! Brilliant, as usual, is J Sai Deepak !
J sai dipak should be supported and promoted because he is doing so much work..
Young man, you spoke my mind better than what I can ever express with this level of clarity and articulation. And I am no mean communicator. Live long and serve ma Bharathi.
‘So be it, is the straight answer to it’ : blunt, honest and savage answer !
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👍👍👍👍👍
Any video with Sai Deepak on it: I first like it, then watch it, and share it. Biggest boost to his voice on this platform is making use of the algorithm to our advantage.
You said it❗️
Sai Deepak ji has a extraordinary clarity on any issue he talks.
What a brilliant interview - I wud love to see a discussion between Rajiv Malhotraji & Sai Deepak on the former's latest book AI & The Future of Power - it will be explosive.
Yes 😍😍🙌🙌
I just love J Sai Deepak sir What a man n his thought process so eloquent and articulate very well put 😁
Absolute clarity in his thoughts. JSD is not just an invaluable representative of the Indic Wing, but a role model for the upcoming generation as well.
J S Deepak is The Voice for emerging Bharath. Hope more youngsters like him come forward to make our hindu identity strong and stable.
Big fan of Mr. Sai Deepak. Discovered him during the lockdown and listened to most of his commentaries available on youtube.
Sai Deepak’s point on public morality so true. The country with such a small % of police force is still safe because of the public consciousness and adherence to dharma
Happy to see CYK hosting such an event. 🙏🙏
I have heard youth from this group lament the lack of direction or public stand on public social issues.
JSD's speech is always a treat to watch and hear. 👍🙏
Such a great
Discussion
Interviewer was great too🙏
Yes! Indeed. 🙏🏻
Youth needs to listen to him more. He is a great orator. Can be a Source of inspiration to many 🙏
IT'S always a delight and refreshing to hear J Sai Deepak. The amount of knowledge and clarity that defines the confidence in the thoughts and meticulous explaining each answer to the point of discussion. In awe as always.
Your dedication to Dharma n clarity of thought expressed so candidly is admirable. Naman to your pursuit of knowledge and its practical application in life
Sai Deepak is the best, when you listen to him, you don't have choice but to agree with him on every point. Even if he is not clear or needs further information.
What a mindset ........🙏🙏🙏🙏
Really genius man
This man is my Hero, every time I listen to him, I m forced to introspect and relook my roles and my awareness as a South African Tamizh person. I especially enjoy comparing the jurisprudence in Bharat as seen through Sai Deepak's eyes and my own lived experience in South Africa through Apartheid to the corruption of the present day.
Academic scholar & knowledge reservoir ... always learn from hearing him... 🙏
History teachers must listen to his talks and history books have to include chapters like... What... Why... to study history. This kind of talks, lectures have to be included and taken to classrooms. His books must be available in all languages in each and corner of Bharat. 🙏
think the interviewer has also done a great job. right questions are required. Otherwise Krishna was with other people also but only Arjuna gets Geeta.
Who is this Interviewer!!!
Most Inspiring and introspective Talk. !! So very Articulate, Fluent and Powerful in Delivery. which flows Like a River !! Wonderful Oratory Skills and amazing vacabulary. !! Enjoyed listening to it so much, apart from the Content and vast Knowledge on the shastras and Dharma. !!
JSD is always a delight but in this interview full props to the person interviewing him too👍👍
Always a pleasure to listen to you Sai Deepak. Keep talking.
Amazing!! This guy will have a great impact for the next 40 years of our existence.
A Gem of a discussion, the clarity and the depth is simply amazing. Kudos to both, yes I have been following Sai Deepak and adore his knowledge and clarity. God bless.
We all The Indic wing.
I click the Like button just by seeing Sai Deepak's name, before listening the talk.👍
He is a Light House for Indic renaissance. 🙏
Sai Deepak rocks as usual. True tambram Iyer nationalist genius. Godbless.
He is INDIAN - BHARATHIYA - Please do not label with anything else - That will create a divide
I download all his talks and interviews and watch them over and over again.
Sai j Deepak vocabulary
On another level 😌
He should use simple words
Not really. It is quite easy to understand for anyone with even rudimentary acquaintance with English.
Over the years I've followed this man, I've gone from being an admirer and a fan to a shishya, always in awe of his grasp over issues and the brilliant articulation. The man just leaves his detractors in shock and awe by the conviction and force of his arguments.. More power to JSD.
Brilliant comment brother. Hats off. 🙏🏻
@Dirigo Diaboli i appreciate your comment. But lets not only concentrate on the' peacefuls' only. There is another threat fron the ' religion of love'. You know who i am talking about
Generations to come will look up to Shri Sai Deepak and thank him for all his contributions.
I wish him all the health and happiness.
Voice to text of the Conversation : 00:00 - 10:00 mins,
Voice to text, Introduction : J. Sai Deepak, Involved in land mark cases in the Country : As a student, his blog post in the patent dispute between Bajaj and TVS is something that was quoted extensively and was included as a part of the Judgment delivered by the Madras High court. Contribution in Cases between Green peace and Tata Sons, Basmati Rice producer case are some of his other contributions, In 2018 his defense of Lord Ayappa's celibacy is very well appreciated, well mentioned in Media across the country.
He is very much involved in promoting the idea of Indic awareness.
Voice to text of conversation with J. Sai Deepak.
Q) You actually spoken about the need for common perception of the History and we are actually living in a time where even a common perception of current events seems to be little challenging to attain, so in a Nation as diverse as India, When we try to attempt to have a common perception of History, you would invariably find one section being blamed and one section taking the position of the victim. Unlike homogenous characterization of the way it happened in Germany, where they took on the blame or say China where they took the position of Victim by Japanese aggression, so how do you see this whole idea of common perception of History getting developed in a Country like India, where without creating divisions.
Answer : I will keep my answer tentative, there is a decent chance that perhaps reflect my understanding at the current moment. It may change in the future & this is the truth of my moment. The idea of Nationhood has confounded me for a long time & only over the last few years, I’ve realized it perhaps, you understand Bharateeyata before you decide let’s say the political entity what you look at, the political entity what you look at today corresponds/approximates to let’s say a Nation state, that’s how we have decided to mould ourselves. But for all practical purposes it’s a triangulation of sorts, which has been required by the History, perhaps you are unshackling yourselves from an European colonizer, there was a certain legacy you have inherited which you chose to continue with, in the interest of continuum so that there is a vyavastha, there is a some kind of system in place, so that a common person has some kind of system to look at, this is something that you have inherited as part of colonial legacy, But do you want to continue with there is a question which you have never asked yourselves. Perhaps even if you asked yourselves during the framing of the constitution those discussions have never reached out to the common people subsequently & therefore I believe that what we understand the country today is a curious mix of myth reality, fact & fiction without any serious effort being invested by the level of the state, there I say at the level of the society. To perhaps make sense of our past and see how is it that we have straight jacketed our past into the concept of Nation state.
Direct way of answer - The understanding of the premise that you have to be a Nation, you need a certain degree of homogeneity is not our way of thinking at any circumstances. That is an inherited legacy & if a Nation is supposed to have homogeneity to the extent that there are no fights, there are no internal wars at all, never has a History of battles between communities, I don’t find there is a single society or a single Country that can rise up to those standards, Even between the Japanese there were fight, the identity within China is a created identity, it’s an artificial identity, it has been created over centuries perhaps for the last 200 years. So I think to try and start with the assumption that for you to be a Nation, you must be homogenous, there is a serious problem because the first question that needs to be asked is homogenous at what level? What is the metric, is it ethnicity? Is it Religion? Or is it something else? Is it Culture? These are the questions we must ask ourselves & there I believe, that Bharat subscribes to a slightly different yardstick, because for all practical purposes, What we know is Hinduism, What we know is Dharma, What we know is Sanaatana Dharma is for all practical purposes, agglomeration of multiple Sampradayas , multiple faith systems that are perhaps tied by the notion of Dharma to some extent, I don’t want to go beyond that, because I’m not expert in the subject, but my limited understanding tells me that the connect that you are looking at the tie you are looking each of this identity is not the Religious connect, is not an ethnic connect, but it’s a spiritual connect & this is not something that can ever be understood if you try and Bharat from European experience. Bharat’s experience is Unique, it’s identity is unique, it’s understanding of Samskriti and Sabhyata is Unique, therefore it makes very little sense to try and impose the trappings of the European thought from Nation statehood or let’s Constitutionalism or anything else on this particular Civilization, because it’s almost trying to understand the Father by the yardstick of the Son, makes really no sense. So therefore I would suggest that even if perhaps don’t have an answer, we atleast thought with the understanding that What we know today is insufficient, inadequate, incomplete and certainly doesnot do justice to Bharat as an entity. So how do we define ourselves? There are enough Historians who were grappling with this particular Question around the time of independence movement, because when you start clamouring for independence the first response from the Christian colonizer was, you were not even a Single Country before I came to this particular land, so What is your claim to fame & how can you actually make a case for Nation state & Independence? If you were not stitched together as a political entity prior to my entry what makes your case stronger after my exit and how can you ask me as a single political unit to give you independence as a single political unit. So, Historians around that period first of all tried to understand this under civilization sense.
So a Civilization whether it’s an advanced stage of decay or it is a stage of resurgence as for as History and time to decide, but a civilization which has telescoped itself into the narrow prism called Nation Statehood, when it struggles to straddle between its identity as a civilization and its political reality as a Nation Statehood, the kind of confusion that an entity is suppose to go through, Bharat is a live example for it & as long as it doesn’t strike a balance between its past and its presence, its future is bound to be confused and confounded. Therefore there is a decent chance that , the values that tie you together which tie you to the land of this particular country and basically says that this is the History that inherit, there is a decent chance that consequence of adoption of that identity that you will other a few people because quite a few people may or may or may not subscribe to it so be it is a straight answer to it, because the process of formation of an identity using any yardstick is bound to result in creating an other who does not conform to the identity or subscribe to the identity or who is not part of the identity. That is no reason to alienate or abandon your identity. If you say that someone is your Mother, it also means that person is not the Mother of someone else. Doesn’t mean that you alienate your Mother simply because the other doesn’t relate to that particular Mother, So that I think it is the clarity that is required, but I think we are valuing in a certain misplaced understanding of Universalism & we confuse Spiritual Universalism with political, Geo Political realities & as we continue to conflict between the two & I think we will neither be spiritually Universal or will be real political according to me, that confusion will continue for some time.
Bro that is some work that you've put here.. Kudos to the efforts you're shown 🙏🏽🎉❤️
Excellent clarity. The force, articulation and clarity is reminiscent of Sri. Chandra Praskash' Chanakya! God bless you Sai Deepak ji.
Wow! Thoroughly enjoyed and learned a few things. I have been longing to hear someone not just speak boldly but the brutal truth. A riveting conversation on the idea of Bharat, assault on civilization, religion & politics. A thundering response to Brahmanical hatred imposed by the British for their gains, dividing the Bharatiya society based on existing EU social structure. And the clear agenda to colonize, convert and enslave via christianity.
don't forget the wisdom of interviewer also ❤️..both r equally good 🔥
I respect and accept words of J sai Deepak jee because he is honest and bold....
Love and respect to him....
बहुत सुन्दर प्रस्तुति , जितनी भी प्रशंषा की जाए कम है।
More and more discourses on same subject with many other indic scholars. Best wishes to jSD and moderator.
We need more j sai in every states and field ... this is how very few drive a civilization and others just follow. Many and every Bharatiya after listening to him will trust him. Indian looks at intentions more than anything else.
Full of information! The manner and articulation of the message conveyed is Excellent! Being an Advocate I fully agree with Sai's idea of NJC, which he has conveyed with clarity and in a beautiful manner !! Though Sai is younger than me I acknowledge his maturity, patriotism and clarity in thoughts! Hats off to Shri Sai Deepak!!! 🙏🏻👏🏻👌🏻🕉️
K R Vijayakumar, Advocate, Chennai.
Listening to J Sai Deepak is always a pleasure and learning opportunity. So many takeaways from this talk. Will have to keep coming back to grasp some of his excellent points. Such an inspiration!
I know he's been quite busy but please ask him to be active on social media
Maybe his book will be a bang
@@Articulatekarein if his book does come out , every follower of the Indic wing will come forward to help it grow ❤️
@@saumyajitbhaduri1083 I hope that🙏
the minimum he posts all his interview on the same platform(any one Social Media)
Man, how does he have so much clarity?
What a wonderful discussion.... Sai Deepak as always is absolutely clear about his thoughts. Yes there should be a clear distinction between nation-state and civilisational state.if india has to protect it's nation statehood it has to cherish it's civilisational statehood.
Yes.... Superb definition for the words brahmanathva and ksahtrathva..... A true meaning... 👌👌
This interviewer is so excellent. His questions were very precise to bring the best and very blunt responses from JSK👌
Dear Anchor, Listening to Adv Sai Deepak is an educational experience. Thank you Chinmaya Yuva Kendra And the speaker. SC Panda
So glad to see some one like Sai Deepak working so well for Dharmic causes.
Are’nt Dharmic phiosophies more of influential nature than of coercive and proselytization?
I am under the impression that the spread of Dharmic philosophies outside of India are simply because of Dharmic influence and not coercion.
I haven't heard a more realistic and intellectual discussion in a very long time. I can completely understand that Constitutional Reforms is the way out of this ideological slavery that we are still bearing a burden.
Perfect elaborative rational remark by JSD sir 🙏💙
Great...! his clear thoughts are need to go every state and village of the Bharat and that's why this needs to get translated in every regional language.I request organizer to upload it with subtitles in atleast all state languages we have.I know it's definitely a difficult job but if anyone does it, will be a great contribution to the society.
Dub in all Major indian languages
J Sai Deepak sir...kudos..I wonder if he would have stood second in any of the debate competition during school and college days
Wonderful round of questioning. Responded eruditely by the brilliant Sai Deepak. A gem of our nation. Thank you for the thought provoking discussion.
Answers are like reading from book .. just flows .. it’s just crystal clear ..awesome
"We confuse spiritual universalism with political and geopolitical realities" 👏
The one and only Sai Deepak! I believe he is an avatar of Chanakya for modern Bharat.
Yes I totally agree with you ma'am
A traet to listen to Sain. Deepak👌🏽👌🏽🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
My Favourite Lawyer. Bravo from Malaysia!
Sri Sai Deepak is doing more than his part. What are we doing? Apart from watching the game from the stands and clapping and cheering for our team? One suggestion.
Everyone of us can trace our ancestry back to some remote village of our Land. Every village has its share of very ancient temples. Can we just take up the repair and rejuvenation of one in or near our ancestral village? If one person cannot afford to, a ten or a hundred can. Nothing grand. Just simple repairs, chunam and kaavi wash, a simple kumbabishekam - and the people around will keep it alive and thriving with their devotion.
Excellent idea
A scholarly prescription to the present day Indian mind facing an identity crisis. What defines indianness? J Sai Deepak answer this question brilliantly.
Hope this would reach every thinking Indian mind.
Amazing discussion, very insightful.
Deep and profound questions and brilliant answers!!!
Excellent discussion👌🏻
Adv Sai is Brilliant, will ALWAYS B A Winner, since NAME SAI is connected. Hare Krishna ❤️🙏
Superbly articulated and very timely 🕉🙏🏼
Voice to text Conversation : 10 mins - 15:34 mins
Q) When you spoke about the confusions that would come as a result of we not being very clear and in terms of rather not reconciling between the Cultural identity of the past and the political identity of the present, while I agree that there is good amount of confusion which you see in the society as you speak, but when we do this othering that happens there is going to be a good amount of conflict as well, & the Hindu response to the conflict in last few years has often seen to be inadequate or its not been effective enough to assert some of the basic aspects of equality which the constitution is actually suppose to promise, So what do you think those conflicts (Kinds) would come out of it & how best you think can be addressed in a way that, the broad cultural premise of Universal Secularism, which is fundamental to Hinduism is not compromised?
Answer :- Based on my very limited untrained understanding of Dharma & its philosophy, chaos is a reality, chaos is to be accepted and chaos is permanent. Chaos leads to change or may be it’s a cycle where both feed of each other and if chaos takes the form of conflict, the Question is, is it for right reasons? What is the end goal that is been aimed at? What is the motivation here? I don’t think conflict is something that we are to be worried of or be scared of, if Saagar Manthan itself is a text book example , Pouranic example or an ithihaasic example of conflicts, it was nothing but a conflict, I don’t see how is it that we try and evade conflict not possible, the question is are you undertaking it for the right reasons? Are you doing your best to avoid that conflict? Have you employed every possible means to offer the olive branch? & if left with no other options & forced to take a position do you first of all have the guts? & second to bear with all and embrace it? & therefore believe in at each of these levels perhaps we need serious introspection but all of this calls for two very specific treats according to me, While it is a politically incorrect terminology to use, I will use it for Whatever its worth regardless of the reactions. “Brahmanatvam & Kshatratejam”, both are required & Brahmanatvam I won’t use it in the sense of caste.
Bramhanatvam : Pursuit of knowledge and the guts to speak the truth regardless of the number of people arrayed against you and even if the rest of the World is arrayed against you, if you believe that you are right, do not part from your position under any circumstances come Hell or high what, that is the essence of the Brahmin, that is the essence of Brahminhood, that is the essence of Brahmanism there I say it, that is Brahminical, the much malign word.
Kshatram : effectively means, once you have decided this is the truth you are fighting for? Are you willingto protect it? Are you willing to push it? Are you willing to defend it under any circumstances? Because of all the four varnas that the Chaturvarna system effectively believes & puts stock in, the Kshatriya is perhaps the most important because his Sword that effectively ensures that everybody else has the freedom to live and practice there own Dharma, the Brahmin perhaps teaches you What is Dharma? But the practice of Dhrama is made possible by Kshatriya who wields the Sword & says, I’ll protect the rest of the Society & I’m willing to sacrifice my life & my longetivity so to speak at the altar of Dharma & therefore as much as you need lot of people who propagate the truth, the truth is always bound to inspire responses & nine out of ten times violent responses. Which I think effectively what’s going on & as long as your response is churning out this misplaced pacifist sense of Hindu Dharma. I’m sorry to say that you have not understood the meaning of Shastra and Shaastra going together & today I believe that we have perhaps a surfeit of Shaastra in several ways with a lot of people talking but a serious deficit of Shastra & that’s where I think Indian state has done a fantastic job or a great job of giving people the confidence that if they speak the truth, the state will stand by them and protect them, the state effectively has failed in its duty to protect those who wish to seek the advance, the truth of this landdom & therefore I think the state is pushing people into looking into alternatives, non state state alternatives, So may be its for the State perhaps this is the best possible time to ask for these questions, may be because I believe the Stars are aligned in a particular fashion & therefore given that there is a certain thought process at play, that process must empower the advancement of Dharmic truth in every manner possible, at every front possible, at every level possible.
brilliant, articulated. I watch all his videos.
Saw him without glasses for d first time for a min... Noticeably they are the same for over 4 years😁 God bless u, the stalwart of dharma...
Honestly, when I start listening JSD, even 1 hour lecture seems very small...
Dear JSD, please speak for atleast 5-6 hours... You're speech is A.w.e.s.o.m.e. SIR
What a genius mind we have! Iq seems like 180 or above.
I am huge fan of Mr Sai Deepak God bless him.
Brilliant, thank you both.
Amazing talk, 🙏🙏🙏
Judiciary reforms need to happen. It's time necessity
Point-blank ..in 10 mins of this video I clicked Like.
Excellent talk and clarity of mind