Since not many comment them as a *group* let me drop one: This group is truly deserves a title as the most talented produce group ever!!! Like omg look at K Lu switching her high pitched voice to low voice rap, I got goosebumps. Shaking is a rap queen but she nailed vocals too. Kiki tends to struggle on her vocal before but hear her out now, she sounds angelic and confidence with her singing. Anqi and Shaking never disappoints me as an all rounder. Snow Kong is really improving her vocals too and don't even underestimate her versatility, girl can look sexy and cute back and forth. Xiaotang may lacks on vocal but she ate every her rap parts and she's one of variety queen of the group. Yu Yan's vocal is always slays and her dance deserves on the top place. Esther proves she can sing, she kills it in the raw live vocal singing. And Yuxin as the center is the most kind talented and kind hearted, she seems not greedy at all and wants others to shine as well I'm gonna miss them when they're disbanding soon. The9 is the best!!!
The day they dissolve I'm going to cry they really love them, I started to watch the program already because of the battles but I was delighted with all 8 of 9 but with Lu Keran I love more the group was varied in all categories rap, dance, sing and visual and all of them are versatile, a very good group configuration in the time that they are together, I will always support them and also individually. NINECHO forever. long live THE9 they are the best.
Yeah! In YWY Anqi is my bias but becoming a group,I love and support all of them.I don't want The9 to disband.Each of them have the their unique style and attractions
Yuxin has a really nice voice that blends nicely with others when they sing in unison. But if you know her voice and you listen closely, you can also hear it well.
shaking can rap, sing, dance and even compose her own lyrics. she loves her members and always vlogs them and have a close relationship with all them, and appreciative of her fans. she really is a gem and a talented, down to earth and mature artiste.
Surprised!.. Xin Liu's vocal is a Real Deal, she's so amazing! XIN Liu's vocal is no joke! it's soothing and so unique. She's indeed the ultimate ace! center of the group! This's the best version from the 9... .I love this version better. Love xin liu and all of them so much.
I dont know how many times ive repeated xin lui singing part 0:42 and 1:28 ... I love shaking rap and sing .. she has that husky type of voice .. And also Lu keran change her voice from singing sweetly to rap ..
All of them were so good in terms of delivering this highly emotional song, well executed, as expected from the9, I like all of them especially Liu Yuxin, the intro was really great💙💙💙💙
Ahhh Liu Yuxin's soothing to powerful vocals sends me goosebumps & her visuals, she looks like a character from anime. I can listen to her part over & over again.. BEST CENTER QUEEN ^^
@@hengsovanmakara379 That's actually not true. When the lineup for The9 was finalized, there was a lot of comments that said the group was too rapper and dance heavy. People even said the group was doomed because the group lacked strong vocals other than Yuyan (which isn't true because as the original commenter said, Anqi, Yuxin and also Shaking are also great lead vocals.) However, the other members of The9 still have great vocal too!
Liu Yuxin is the real definition of ACE. She can slay in dancing, singing and rapping. Top 3 in those 3 skills. She truly deserves center spot. A QUEEN indeed!! 💙💙
Ace - Xin Liu Vocal - Yuyan, Babymonster Dance n Visual - Kiki, Snow Kong Sweet - Esther Yu Rapper - Shaking Cool n Deep Voice - XiaoTang, Keran Every member of The9 have their own character and charming parts. I like all 😉
OMG Liu yuxin's vocals is insane she sang the chorus so clean👏 i love the arrangement of parts for this, quite fair but too bad for yuyan, but overall Ot9 Promise was sooo good😭 please include this to their album
I’m so proud of them!! All of them have improved so much! Yuxin has so much emotion in this stage, Esther’s voice has improved so well, Kiki has such a soft and angelic voice, K lu’s switch from vocals to rap was so smooth, Anqi’s strong voice gave me goosebumps, Shaking’s vocals is amazing, Snow Kong has a really beautiful voice, I can’t get enough Xiaotang’s rap and Yu yan’s harmony ay the ending chorus is wonderful! 💙💙💙
X-Queen slayed. Her parts hit my heart directly. She can dance, do popping, write her raps and rap then she can compose songs and sings with an angelic voice. She can bbox too. SHE IS AN ACE. Ily SOOOO much QUEEN!! Shw's extraordinarily talented. And people who watched ywy will know about her PURE GOLDEN HEART. ilysm :) edit: HOW COULD I FORGET?? X- Queen is an 8th grade pianist and can play guitar
Xin Liu I'm fallin for you angelic and unique voice, I need more of your singing!!!! If you got time plz post more singing vids on tiktokkkkkkk, we love hearing you and seeing you
Yuxin was born for the stage! We know many people come and praise her dancing skills, and now when they hear her voice, they also praise her vocal skills. She is All rounder! ACE! Our C! I just hope IQIYI doesn't hide her talent anymore for some stupid reasons! Please let her shine 刘雨昕优秀!
Yuxin voice so soft and unique, you could know it immediately that it's Yuxin voice .. My ear being fed well.. Thank you baby.. Yes OK yo~ Fighting THE9 ! all of you are amazing!
shaking's rap was truly beautifully written and conveyed so much emotions, especially for people who can understand chinese and can feel the emotions she put into writing these lyrics. she did an absolutely amazing job performing her parts as well! she's literally a gem there's nothing she can't do!😭
Yuxin makes my heart melt again and again, so warm so sweet baobeiii :3. I really like this song from the final stage, ah I miss YWY so much. Yuxin love u!!! The9 jiayou!!!!
XIN Liu has it all..Full Pakage! Multi-Talented, Her vocal is so angelic and unique! ..Her dancing is on professional Level.. Her Visual is just so handsome yet beautiful. XIN Liu can write and compose and produce the music so well, but iQIYI just don 't want her to outshine other members too much. XIN Liu is just ultimate Ace! She's just PERFECT!
This is heartwarming. They sang it beautifully. Shuxin voice is soothing. Love her sweet tone. I love Anqi's voice so much too. Sultry. Aahhh I love to hear Anqi more. I also love that Yuxin started the song, very suited to her voice and sets the mood. Yuyan is good of course. It's a fresh thing to hear her sing a sweet song. Xiaotang, Shaking, Lukeran raps. I'm in love. Honestly I'm not the type of person who listens to rap, but because of them I came to love listening to it. Xueer and kiki too who are given the chance to sing more. Soft voice. I love them all. I'm gonna cry when they'll sing this the day they'll,,,, okay not gonna go there yet. Love The9
Youth producers chose Yuxin as CENTER isn't for nothing but she is truly a gem as a singer, dancer and rapper. There may be many talented trainees in YWY but the most attractive one who can easily attract viewers'/ public's attention most is her. X QUEEN truly makes u crazy!!! 💙💙
@@linkskyline4728 she meant youth producers are public. Since they debuted from Youth With You 2/ Idol producer 3 survival show which means the ones who voted for them are called youth producers (public). They chose the right queen indeed, our X Queen, Liu Yuxin.
The song is so emotional, feel like crying while listening to my X-Queen Liu Xin part. She is such an ACE. I hope that she would do a solo singing to this.
I feel like Lukeran is very good at expressing emotions, you just want to keep looking at her face because she draws you in. Imagine what it would be like if the camera showed closeup shots of her more often. Her face is able to tell a story.
Can we just appreciate how Esther, Anqi and Yu yan on this performance, Esther improved so much, she is stable and her breathing is much better. Anqi is probably the most stable out of them. Yu yan even though she has a powerful voice she can still sing touching songs and change her tone.
Love how Yuyan, Anqi and Xin's vocals bring colours to the song 😭❤️ Ohh can we take a moment to praise Jiaqi and Esther's vocals too. They've improved a lot! Overall the did great! LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!
Yuxin ah.. your voice so smooth & so beautiful . Love iit💙 Wish to hear U sing moŕe after this.
劉老師 喻言 安崎 欣欣真的唱的好好聽啊 Shaking超棒！！ kiki和雪兒進步好多！小棠柯柯很棒！The9真的很強💟💟💟
真的是一個女團的樣子了......有顏有實力有人氣！💟
XIN Liu is the most perfect, kindest, prettiest and lovely girl I have ever seen. I really really really love her!!!
Agree 🤛🥺
Since not many comment them as a *group* let me drop one:
This group is truly deserves a title as the most talented produce group ever!!! Like omg look at K Lu switching her high pitched voice to low voice rap, I got goosebumps. Shaking is a rap queen but she nailed vocals too. Kiki tends to struggle on her vocal before but hear her out now, she sounds angelic and confidence with her singing. Anqi and Shaking never disappoints me as an all rounder. Snow Kong is really improving her vocals too and don't even underestimate her versatility, girl can look sexy and cute back and forth. Xiaotang may lacks on vocal but she ate every her rap parts and she's one of variety queen of the group. Yu Yan's vocal is always slays and her dance deserves on the top place. Esther proves she can sing, she kills it in the raw live vocal singing. And Yuxin as the center is the most kind talented and kind hearted, she seems not greedy at all and wants others to shine as well
I'm gonna miss them when they're disbanding soon. The9 is the best!!!
Yes! I only see liu yuxin in the comments. I really like her performance but I feel like the other members deserve attention too.
The day they dissolve I'm going to cry they really love them, I started to watch the program already because of the battles but I was delighted with all 8 of 9 but with Lu Keran I love more the group was varied in all categories rap, dance, sing and visual and all of them are versatile, a very good group configuration in the time that they are together, I will always support them and also individually.
NINECHO forever. long live THE9 they are the best.
Yeah! In YWY Anqi is my bias but becoming a group,I love and support all of them.I don't want The9 to disband.Each of them have the their unique style and attractions
Sadly it’s the same as izone right now, the more successful they get the more their company wants them back :(
umm yuxin seemed pretty greedy to me
The way you can hear XIN’s voice clearly even when all the girls are singing together- such a blessing to the ears💙☔️✨
True
Periodt
I thought its just me .. so its truly xin voice ... 😍
💙💙
Yuxin has a really nice voice that blends nicely with others when they sing in unison. But if you know her voice and you listen closely, you can also hear it well.
XIN Liu so cute and look forward for her performance
Shaking is the kind of artist that we all need. She is genius at writing lyrics look at how beautiful her lyrics are
Agree
@@blackbluegrey5928 lol, laoshi = teacher/coach
@@elaineloo610 0
xin liu omg XD i love her so much uwu
shaking can rap, sing, dance and even compose her own lyrics. she loves her members and always vlogs them and have a close relationship with all them, and appreciative of her fans. she really is a gem and a talented, down to earth and mature artiste.
Love K Lu’s part and she definitely kills it!! Love the switch of her voice!! She improved so much♥️
OMG, I tears came to my eyes while listening to K Lu's part. Her voice, her look were sincere... perfectly fit the lyrics.
+++
Omg the most surprising part is Xin liu and shaking’s part❤️❤️❤️ so gorgeous!!!
Lu Keran captivates a lot!! I love how she started with a soft voice and changed to rap omg that was *cheff kiss*
Wow I love Liu YuXin’s dance so much that I didn’t realize her vocals are also great. Unique and enticing
Xin Liu 😍
Want to hear she sing a whole song 😍
Surprised!.. Xin Liu's vocal is a Real Deal, she's so amazing! XIN Liu's vocal is no joke! it's soothing and so unique. She's indeed the ultimate ace! center of the group! This's the best version from the 9... .I love this version better. Love xin liu and all of them so much.
I dont know how many times ive repeated xin lui singing part 0:42 and 1:28 ...
I love shaking rap and sing .. she has that husky type of voice ..
And also
Lu keran change her voice from singing sweetly to rap ..
LiuYuxin vocals so soothing to hear 💙 truly an ACE!!!!! no doubt 😍
All of them were so good in terms of delivering this highly emotional song, well executed, as expected from the9, I like all of them especially Liu Yuxin, the intro was really great💙💙💙💙
Shaking vocals are such a blessing. Her rapping skills are amazing her whole aspects are golden
Ahhh Liu Yuxin's soothing to powerful vocals sends me goosebumps & her visuals, she looks like a character from anime. I can listen to her part over & over again.. BEST CENTER QUEEN ^^
XIN Liu's vocal is no joke! She has the most beautiful unique voice that I've ever heard in China! she SLAYED HARD!
Mmm her vocal is no joke but ngl her voice isnt really unique
@@sysysy8637 I find it unique though I wont say most unique. I think it's a mix of feminine and also hint of strength.
@@hoonielifez1936 Totally agree!!!!!
@@sysysy8637 she has a unique timbre for female ..
Omg ,Xin liu. You are so perfect!
Xin Liu. I love your voiceee!!
The9 doesn't lack vocalists, other than yu Yan, an qi, and yuxin are great too. And Esther and Kiki are good lead vocals too
No one said they’re lack vocalist too😉
Ranz Van actually a lot of people did but now they know 😊
Also Shaking!
@@hengsovanmakara379 That's actually not true. When the lineup for The9 was finalized, there was a lot of comments that said the group was too rapper and dance heavy. People even said the group was doomed because the group lacked strong vocals other than Yuyan (which isn't true because as the original commenter said, Anqi, Yuxin and also Shaking are also great lead vocals.) However, the other members of The9 still have great vocal too!
It's really such a pleasure to watch Yuxin sing. Her eyes convey so much emotions. Plus her voice is gentle yet very stable and strong too.
XIN Liu- ACE The9, I love her
Liu Yuxin is the real definition of ACE. She can slay in dancing, singing and rapping. Top 3 in those 3 skills. She truly deserves center spot. A QUEEN indeed!! 💙💙
An qi, yu yan, kiki, shaking and liu xin vocal are the best.
Liu Xin's voice so angelic and soft, I'm melting
Kiki Xu ikr
xin deserves to be center 🙏🔥♥️
I miss when Liu Yuxin and K Lu in the Youth With You2 show😭😍😍
Ace - Xin Liu
Vocal - Yuyan, Babymonster
Dance n Visual - Kiki, Snow Kong
Sweet - Esther Yu
Rapper - Shaking
Cool n Deep Voice - XiaoTang, Keran
Every member of The9 have their own character and charming parts. I like all 😉
Babymonster not an ace? you're sleeping
@@FF2PM calm down it’s her opinion 😂
Sweet?! Lmao 🤣
Yan yu is ACE too
vocal is Babymonster!????? you sure?
Yuxin is a real ACE 💙💙 due to skilled dance, sweet vocal and cool rap.
The best version of the 9💛💛😱😱 ohh x queen,xin liu voice and vocal very nice... Love her so much and members of the 9, always support them🥳🥰
OMG Liu yuxin's vocals is insane she sang the chorus so clean👏 i love the arrangement of parts for this, quite fair but too bad for yuyan, but overall Ot9 Promise was sooo good😭 please include this to their album
I’m so proud of them!! All of them have improved so much! Yuxin has so much emotion in this stage, Esther’s voice has improved so well, Kiki has such a soft and angelic voice, K lu’s switch from vocals to rap was so smooth, Anqi’s strong voice gave me goosebumps, Shaking’s vocals is amazing, Snow Kong has a really beautiful voice, I can’t get enough Xiaotang’s rap and Yu yan’s harmony ay the ending chorus is wonderful! 💙💙💙
Nice comment 💕 this suits THE9 so much ♥️
XIN LIU has a good voice!
Does anybody watch liu Xin performance battle of mask king of dance? Oh my god that was so lit it's like it's her hidden self when she dance.
Me mee
I have only one word for that performance “WOW!!”
劉雨昕唱歌好好聽🎵開口跪💙
An Qi is doing so good. So proud of her. And Esther is improving a lot.
X-Queen slayed. Her parts hit my heart directly. She can dance, do popping, write her raps and rap then she can compose songs and sings with an angelic voice. She can bbox too. SHE IS AN ACE. Ily SOOOO much QUEEN!! Shw's extraordinarily talented. And people who watched ywy will know about her PURE GOLDEN HEART. ilysm :)
edit: HOW COULD I FORGET?? X- Queen is an 8th grade pianist and can play guitar
Liu laoshi
She is not only ACE, but she also deserve "the best center" ever ..
Xin Liu I'm fallin for you angelic and unique voice, I need more of your singing!!!! If you got time plz post more singing vids on tiktokkkkkkk, we love hearing you and seeing you
You can really tell how good shaking is in acting and the way she deliver herself onstage
This is the first Chinese group I follow, they attract me with their voices, I love their voices ❤
Yuxin was born for the stage! We know many people come and praise her dancing skills, and now when they hear her voice, they also praise her vocal skills. She is All rounder! ACE! Our C!
I just hope IQIYI doesn't hide her talent anymore for some stupid reasons!
Please let her shine 刘雨昕优秀!
雨昕唱得真好。。song's on repeat to listen and look at yuxin..love this song
they sing very guddd
YU XIN I LOVE U
Every xin liu sang this song i feel want to cry memories of the final even.....😭😭
Shaking really slayed this song! 😍
The9 The Best!!!! All of you are amazing!!!
Liu Yuxin I love you ♡♡♡
Xin.. her voice is so gentle😍
Yuxin voice so soft and unique, you could know it immediately that it's Yuxin voice .. My ear being fed well.. Thank you baby.. Yes OK yo~
Fighting THE9 ! all of you are amazing!
Shaking is just keep on getting better and better evertime. There would be a time were shaking will bloom like a beautiful flower
Xin liu & baby monster An-Qi still my luv
xiaotang and Kerans' rap have stolen my heart! love shaking's vocal too!
shaking's rap was truly beautifully written and conveyed so much emotions, especially for people who can understand chinese and can feel the emotions she put into writing these lyrics. she did an absolutely amazing job performing her parts as well! she's literally a gem there's nothing she can't do!😭
Yuxin makes my heart melt again and again, so warm so sweet baobeiii :3. I really like this song from the final stage, ah I miss YWY so much. Yuxin love u!!! The9 jiayou!!!!
Yuxin's whole existence and Keran's deep voice are what keeps our whole planet alive, everyone say thank you queens
i love keran
XIN Liu has it all..Full Pakage! Multi-Talented, Her vocal is so angelic and unique! ..Her dancing is on professional Level.. Her Visual is just so handsome yet beautiful. XIN Liu can write and compose and produce the music so well, but iQIYI just don 't want her to outshine other members too much. XIN Liu is just ultimate Ace! She's just PERFECT!
Liu YuXin 💙💙
Louder!!
Liu yu xin X Queen perfect!!!
💙💙💙
Love xin liu's vocal 💙💙💙
Ahh Babymonster An did SO WELL. So smooth and so much control. Every time she sang I squealed
This is heartwarming. They sang it beautifully. Shuxin voice is soothing. Love her sweet tone. I love Anqi's voice so much too. Sultry. Aahhh I love to hear Anqi more. I also love that Yuxin started the song, very suited to her voice and sets the mood. Yuyan is good of course. It's a fresh thing to hear her sing a sweet song. Xiaotang, Shaking, Lukeran raps. I'm in love. Honestly I'm not the type of person who listens to rap, but because of them I came to love listening to it. Xueer and kiki too who are given the chance to sing more. Soft voice. I love them all. I'm gonna cry when they'll sing this the day they'll,,,, okay not gonna go there yet. Love The9
Xin Liu I'ts sooooooo Perfect💙💙
Shaking is perfect she has it all to be a superstar
Xin Liu💙
Youth producers chose Yuxin as CENTER isn't for nothing but she is truly a gem as a singer, dancer and rapper. There may be many talented trainees in YWY but the most attractive one who can easily attract viewers'/ public's attention most is her. X QUEEN truly makes u crazy!!! 💙💙
You're right she really balance the group...
She wasn't chosen by the producers though... Technically, she was chosen via votes which is of higher achievement. ❤️
@@linkskyline4728 she meant youth producers are public. Since they debuted from Youth With You 2/ Idol producer 3 survival show which means the ones who voted for them are called youth producers (public). They chose the right queen indeed, our X Queen, Liu Yuxin.
@@linkskyline4728 "youth producers" is the name the show gave to its audience
She is the best center of survival show gg
Omg they are so beautiful!! 💕
Anqi is actually such a strong vocalist.
Also Yuxin’s side face is perfect as usual. 🥰
Xin Liu vocal very good
Liu yu xin 💙💙💙
The song is so emotional, feel like crying while listening to my X-Queen Liu Xin part. She is such an ACE. I hope that she would do a solo singing to this.
I want a XIN Liu solo cover too!
I love you Xin liu💜
Esther Yu voice is so good in this song
Shaking, Kiki❤️
Eather yu is so good❤
I love XIN LIU
Esther be like❤️❤️mygud I love her voice
😍😍ilh
Yess💓💓💓
XIN Liu is an angel!!!! Her vocals take me to heaven!!!!!!!!! I love you XIN!!!! 💙
As always shaking is so passionate about rapping she even wrote the lyrics her self
Love Yu Xin’s voice!!! Our X Queen ~
I feel like Lukeran is very good at expressing emotions, you just want to keep looking at her face because she draws you in. Imagine what it would be like if the camera showed closeup shots of her more often. Her face is able to tell a story.
She is!!! Her aura and her stage presence r the most perfect! 😍😍😍
I just love Xin Liu so so much, so much talent!! Can't wait to see what the group has in store in the future!
Yes Ok Yo... Yu Xin's voice truely catch my heart. OMG she looks so lovely 💙
Everyone looks pretty & the rest of the girls' vocal improve a lot 👍🏼
I see so few praises of anqi but I think she was the most outstanding in this stage🥺 her vocals really shined
esther's voice is beautiful...just wow
It's just so powerful when Esther use her real voice. TT💖
Love Yuxin voice
With Shuxin, she done more and more better than before. So happy that she is a part of THE9, she althought make everyone laugh a lot.
Shaking Chloe gonna make you moving!! She really made us moving 💗 谢可寅未来可期！绝美rapper，词都自己写的!
I like Esther's voice, it's amazing, she's improving a lot
God..YUXIN voice is so amazing.😍😍
And shuxin i love your voice baby.
My 2XIN😍😍
shaking, anqi and xin liu proving they're main vocal material
Liu yuxin i love you
Omooo LIU YUXIN I'm so highly in with your attractive voice... you're my Fevorite person ever...wô ái ni....💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Liu Yu Xin talent was no joke, she was ACE. MY X QUEEN💙
Kiki
If you are only liking one of them, then please dont call yourself as NINECHO
@@purivanple6742Sorry? What makes you understand that I'm ninecho ? , I'm um.
Can we just appreciate how Esther, Anqi and Yu yan on this performance, Esther improved so much, she is stable and her breathing is much better. Anqi is probably the most stable out of them. Yu yan even though she has a powerful voice she can still sing touching songs and change her tone.
Yes it's Anqi ㅠㅠ
The way jiaqi looked at yuxin when she's singing "baby i promise you" makes me 🙉🙉🙉😍😍😍
XINQI💗💗💗💗
Yess😪😭🔥🔥❤️
Hahhahahaha..... but me Im XinSnow
hahhahaha...but me im KiSnow
Welp, this group is basically Xin and her harem
lui xin!!!!i miss you so much. i want more of you.
Shaking her own rap is so damn!!The amazing vocal too
When Anqi sings at some part of the chorus it's beyond imagination!! Her vocal was stable and her diction was so good!
Yuxin no matter what let's go all on and leave no regrets 💙
I'm crying like...😭😢These girls are one of my best memories of 2020
Ikr
Same ❣️
We love you our X QEEN👑👑👑and❤❤ THE9❤
Love how Yuyan, Anqi and Xin's vocals bring colours to the song 😭❤️ Ohh can we take a moment to praise Jiaqi and Esther's vocals too. They've improved a lot! Overall the did great! LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!