Alia Bhatt breaks down as sister Shaheen opens up on her battle with depression to Barkha Dutt
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 ноя 2019
- 'I've Never been (Un)Happier'- Alia Bhatt & Shaheen Bhatt in an extraordinary conversation on Women, Mental Health, Shaheen's personal battle with depression and her chronicles in a just published book. The two sisters talk like never before to Barkha Dutt
18:50 Alia: I didn't want to cry because all of a sudden it will be all about Alia shedding a tear
Title of this video: Alia Bhatt breaks down ...
ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html Veenjhar Memon
For no obvious reason
I was thinking exactly the same thing.
Seriously 👍
Omg seriously! I was thinking the same!
A very young girl was trying to ask a question but unfortunately used the wrong word "Criticism", could be because of less exhaustive English vocabulary. Barkha shut her down so badly. Maybe if we had listened to her patiently, her question might have had made sense, maybe better than other generic questions. We are talking about depression which builds up slowly. (Shaheen was asked to be out of the frame and that affected her at so many levels). Barkha shushed that girl in public. We do not know what kind of effect that is going to have on that girl. She might feel afraid to speak up again in public. She may become super conscious of her English Skills. Her peers may make fun of her when goes back to school or college. I just hope that if something happens to her as what happened to shaheen, she gets a stage to share her story.
Namrata Nimmi Yeah I felt bad for her too . I understand they are running on limited time, but I hope that girl is alright. ✌️✌️
I 100% agree with you
It pissed me off too.
Absolutely right.
I was also thinking about it. So insensitive. Atleast she should have given a chance to complete the sentence.
Barkha, please don't shut down anyone from asking questions, because it really needs a lot of courage to stand. Trust me! Just to stand.
So true, so very true. And the person might not be able to stand again for a questions ever again, or it might take them years to get the courage.
Blessings❤
At what did this happen?
How ironic that they titled this video as “Alia Bhatt breaks down....” when she said that she didn’t want the media to say like Oh. Alia cries...
So wonderful to see Alia being visibly supportive of her sister's mental health journey. Meaningful social connections are very important when one is going through any illness be it depression, anxiety or something else.
The story is about Shaheen not Alia. The way video has been captioned is itself quite offending.
Yeah, even the title
@Lilly Illy its very easy to judge people like Alia. But you have to understand how young she was when this was going on. Dont need to put someone down.
Simran Tab sorry but she’s an adult, stop babying her
May be to get more clicks! But any kind of marketing to get more people watching and listening about mental illness is a good thing especially in this country where this is a big tabboo.
@lilly u r bombing each comment with anti Alia comments and distracting from the main topic which people should focus
Shouldn't the title be 'Shaheen Bhatt opens up about her battle with depression'? It's wonderful that Aalia is supporting Shaheen, but would've loved for the focus to remain on Shaheen as this is HER story, not Aalia's.
Vee Modha Yes, but people know Alia and will watch. They don’t know Shaheen. A lot of people like me was recommended to this video by RUclips because we are subscribed to Alia Bhatt RUclips channel. so they had to used Alia Bhatt name in the video title to get people to watch.
Totally agreed
Telling Alia to be at the shadow for a while whilst Shaheen receives the award and yet not convinced that putting Shaheen in the title wouldve gotten them as much views as with Alia. This shows the level of hypocrite these host/organisers are, masala seeker..
Shaheen talks so well. Came here to watch just 2 minutes of this but ended up watching the whole video of 40+ minutes.
Same
Same
They are both wonderfully articulate
Same
Same
Six minutes into this video and I'm already crying. Kudos to shaheen for writing about it and alia for literally being so emotionally real about it as well.
in 3 :(
Mehroze Waseem ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
Holding a conversation about Shaheen's experience and the first question is to Alia....wow👏
Alia actually mentioned that she didn't want this to be about 'Alia shed a tear', and wow, look at the caption.
Wonderful. Loved this raw and beautiful story of two siblings going through quite different experiences. Much love, compassion, joy and gratitude to Shaheen for shining her light...💓🙏
As someone who’s going through depression as well, i just want to applaud her for saying it as it is and not sugarcoating it at all. And hats off to her family for hearing her and always being there for her. I am def going to buy the book and read it. I cried through the whole interview and now I am a mess but crying really made me feel better
wingardium leviosa hang in there! We are all in here together! Talking about it helps!!!
may you find peace soon
I cried too😭😭 fighting depression and anxiety.
Hey. i hope things get better for you. Talk to friends around you and people around you and let them know you just want them to hear you, go to a therapist if it's someone you can afford. Thank you for being here. Please continue to stay. ♥️
Same here. I cried throughout t video cuz it brought back so many unpleasant memories which I had buried deep in my soul.
Alia is lucky to have a sister like Shaheen and Shaheen is lucky to have a sister like Alia
@@pinkimahanta4811 lol... Kya hua be?
@@pinkimahanta4811 fucker has came . Fuckers has no shame😂😂😂😂
Wish i had a bond that with my sis , we are 2 sister siblings too 😂😒😒
I started tearing up seeing alia cry . Reminds me of my mom crying when i was depressed. Alia saying that ' there's always something new to learn because depressed person suffers everyday ' helped me so much . Because i used go to therapists, feel better that day have my questions answered, and the following I'd have new questions and concerns and get depressed again. So i stopped going to therapy.
Alia is so down to earth.So pure hearted.
I see realness in Aliya's emotions. She is just so real in comparison to so many other actresses. Hats off to her.
Why does there always have to be comparison? I always wonder! Every comment i read under such videos, there's always comparison more than appreciation for the real thing said in the videos. Just appreciate the beautiful relation these two sisters have. Other actresses are real in their own way!
@Lilly Illy yeah by dating kat ex - bf
@Lilly Illy who cares! katrina who slept with salman for fame & ranbir when he was still with deepika ! Give us break. Karma is bitch now she is alone with her botox..fake woman
Just here
@@lilabakir8419 hahaaa everyone will face karma katrina has already got her karma and ranbir also she will also get her karma if she deceived her
The host is super unprofessional . She doesn’t slow them to finish their sentence and she tries to control the whole conversation. The purpose of inviting people is to allow them talk... and if they say something she tries to make it sound the way she wants it to sound
Hate these Indians loathe them
Naheed we love you though.
Alia is so fast with words 🤣🤣
ruclips.net/video/0W1s5mKxqDE/видео.html
Barkha was a news reporter not a host, you can't expect that
Sending lots of love for Shaheen Bhatt. Thank you for sharing your story and for raising awareness about depression. Mental health in India needs to be talked about more and addressed so people can get help without feeling like an outcast. Love you Shaheen and bless you with good days ahead.
15:10 - 15:14 “Being depressed is very hard but loving someone who is depressed is equally hard.”
I have so much love & respect for Shaheen. She truly is a diamond and I’m so glad that throughout her tough journey she had someone like Alia beside her. Also can Barkha shut up and listen to people until the end for once?
I could not agree more.
Depression is real. Mental illness is real. Hard to know, no medication heals it. I break down every morning.. its haunting and the suffer is painful.
I love both of you❤️
@@ChandanaCTV I am suffering from ocd intrusive thoughts can I dm u
My sister has screzopheni and I take care of her
@@Vashnavi369 How's she now
@@Vashnavi369 how you deal with ur sis? And what sort of situation is she goin through?
She is really a brave and strong girl....even i was going through the same condition....now i am the way more happy to see....luv yoy Alia....you are soo emotional.🤘😍🤘
Oh pls stop assumptions! Let the focus about mental health and it’s importance and encourage people to come out and talk about it. Whatever the real story would have been, think about the ppl suffering in silence and ignorance. Both girls helped in that sense and your focus as an educated person should be this as you should understand what the forum was about. So pls refrain from making the comments about Alia
Vishal Singh Yes indeed, it’s very brave of her to share her mental illness in a world full of judgmental people. Shaheen is lucky to have a loving 🥰 sister like Alia. I hope you feel better too and I also hope you have a good support system. I wish you the best ✌️✌️💚💚💚
Lilly Illy Please stop it ✋ 🛑 the discussion is about mental illness which affects a lot of people and it’s very lovely of them to share so other girls feel it’s ok to talk it about too . You don’t know Alia personal relationship unless she spoke to you about it. Your gossiping imagination is running very wild 😜😜
@@hanah3401 thank you 🙂
Awwww this interview was so emotional.kuddos to her for bringing her story foreword and encouraging and motivating everyone who is dealing with depression to not feel alone and to know that it’s okay to seek help and see a therapist . It takes a lot of courage to share about depression and mental health. I can understand and relate to some of the feelings she goes through. It is defintely not easy. I can’t wait to get my copy of this book.
The saddest thing about this show is, that young girl was left embarrassed. The instance may turn her under confident because she was behaved that way in public. Host could handle her compassionately.
Leena Duwadi where is it???
@@TheMjforeva watch at last
SAS that part has been removed
@@AnjaliSingh-fj9zo What did the host actually say?
Don't let your pain go to waste !!!! Loved it
We need more talk-shows like this in public domain.
Majority of the schools have teachers like Barkh Dutt
O God
O GOD
True
My english teacher in 5th class
Yeah. This reminds me of my school teachers.
Alia herself said that she doesn't want her shedding tears become the focus of the discussion.
Still they put such title to the video.
Depression has no face even happiest looking people go through depression
salute alia
I self suffering with ocd + depression, it feels dying.. And after watching this interview i hve got so much courage and positivity. Kudos to shaheen for bringing out her emotions so beautifully, i will definitely read this book
You not alone I’m suffering from intrusive unwanted thoughts 💭 and pure O ...
I'm extremely proud of Shaheen. I have been in Alia's position where I thought my cousin was one the most special person in my whole family and I had no idea that he didn't think the same way. I know exactly what she meant when she said that it broke her heart when she found out about that, I felt exactly the same.
Shaheen is such a lovely and a confident speaker.More power to her and I have a gut feeling that she would be as successful as her family.
Wow..this conversation was worth watching!!! One of the bravest interview I have seen so far🤘🤘
Kudos to Shaheen for being so open & Alia to put the voice for this topic💪💪💪 #bhattsisters
Tears in my eyes while watching this..I feel you Shaheen! Kudos to her for telling her story 💖💖💖
37:50 Oh really, Barkha!? Audience can completely understand that you are running out of time but you can't be rude,for God's sake. Most people go through anxiety and stuff coz they weren't treated properly by others at some point of their lives. So you say you can empathise with Shaleen on one side,and on the other side you behave like this? Not cool.
That was horrid of the host to do! Omg! I can't believe that just happened.
She is a shit woman
She is a shit ...gobar host
Yes, I felt so bad for the young girl. It takes courage to ask a question and she gets humiliated for it!
Suvarna Shinde ruclips.net/video/c4wd01Xu-OE/видео.html
Shaheen you are an inspiration , as for Alia's mature acting it always reflects her empathetic vibe, an artist is like a sponge absorbing energies and emotions.
By the way, Alia predicted the title of this video at 18:56 #facepalm Exactly what she didn't want.
Mravina Lol 😂😂😂 exactly 😱 they titled the video as she predicted. Lol 😂😂Someone was listening 👂
Damn 😂
Watching alia cry is making me cry so baddd. Shaheen is so so brave Masha Allah
these girls are global influencers. single handedly they have resonated with an international audience. well done ladies
I feel bad for the young girl who was trying to ask a question and barkha just shut her out saying they were not discussing criticism...... May be she just used the wrong word.. there was no reason for barkha to behave so rudely towards her in front of so many people.... I hope this incident doesn't affect her the way the photographer's behavior affected Shaheen.
👏👏
Well said ..@sunshine 101
True.. I mean first u talk ooo that thing happen to u ans tell that u understand and than repeat that same behaviour with someone else.... I could see the expression in that girls face which made me sad
ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
Sunshine 101 ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
This is a serious matter that is unfortunately not taking seriously. Shaheen had the amazing thought to share her story to spread awareness, and Alia is surely the best version of a sister. Thank you for this valuable content 🙏
Classy Addiction Well said!👍👍👏👏 I Agree.
Classy Addiction ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
@@hanah3401 plzz Hindi me batao Kya story h Shaheen ki plzzz bta do
What I learnt from this interview is that Alia is a good sister
Will surely buy this book.
Its so true when they said that crying is as equally important as being happy.
People who have suffered depression only know the pain and others can not understand it.
Shaheen is so pretty,calm and humble.Alia is a good company for her!
So proud of Shaheen,such a brave girl !! Yes crying is very normal and healthy !! And talking about what it feels inside is brave thing and you gonna inspire so many people!!! Bravo🙌🏻
Dear Shaheen,
you have truly empowered me through this video. I may not have been able to understand you fully but I do feel connected with you. It takes a lot of courage to talk about things that you make you feel miserable every now and then, I just wanted to say that you are doing a great job. You inspire me to be stronger. Just remember that you are imperfectly perfect, even in the most subtle ways, and you may not always feel like the fire, but you will shine on anyway. Loads of love to you and your family.
Did you see at 40:15 ? Shaheen signalled to Alia that she was shivering and Alia held her hand. That's so cute.
Yes and the lady in the uniform was really gracious as well
RG 16 Yes I noticed after you mentioned 👍👍, most likely shivering due to nervousness. I shiver 🥶 when nervous too 😭 . Alia is sweet lovely sister and they are lucky to have each other.
The DIG lady also sensed it and hold Shaheen in tight little hug. Even offered her to be closer to Alia. I guess women have this superpower to read emotions or non-verbal cues better than us. We men would have been standing like dumb fools, not maintaining eye contact with each other. :D
ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html RG 16
I think the scariest think about depression is that people often end their lives because of this. What’s also sad is that sometimes you may never know if someone is depressed or unhappy. Please be kind to all!
Shaheen such a brave girl and still she's living with depression hats off to her
Much needed discussion. I could relate myself too...
the fact that alia explicitly says that she doesn't want her crying to be the focus in a conversation about her sister's book and they decide to title the video this way
This sisters are the best in their own fields kudos to their family for giving birth such a gem like diamonds
shaheen looks like her dad, and alia her mom.. both are brilliant!
Nindya Putri ALIA looks like HER mom and shaheen looks like alia...very much resemblance👯♀️
I bought this book today and it's so good. I just love it! It is quite relatable to my life.
Shaheen's style of speaking, personality is very unique. She's smart. I love her. 😍😍😍😍
I'm so grateful to Shahin and you Barkha, for doing this.. I'm a depression surviver myself... I'm doing extremely well since last four years, I'm completely off medication( thanks to good diet, exercise and most importantly my family) but some days are just too hard and then I come back to this conversation on those days.. my battle always starts feeling like a cake walk then and I feel completely capable of overcoming everything. Just thank you, thank you, thank you!!
I wish the host could have been a little more sensitive and asked better questions. And probably even speak a little softly.
I have read the book online on kindle some months back ... I think I hv nvr been to depression but in many points I cud relate myself to those situations.. I felt like she is telling my story or my feelings in many lines in her book... And it made me cry ...
Nice to hear that u read,I always want to write my biography..I don't have that potential of writing I think..
@Divya Pillai you can download the Amazon Kindle app , u vl get d book over dr , u just need to pay some amount 😊
AAFRIN AZAD ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
Can't hold back my tears...i hv lived with depression all my life....lost my mother at the age of 2...growing up with a step mother and sisters...i hv felt lonely and depressed always...when shaheen admits to the fact that she attempted suicide at the age of 17...i felt Alia's pain...like "sis how could you even think of going away from me" .... its very painful to live with depression...people will judge you instead of trying to understand you...
are you happy(okay) now na,sis?
This sisters love is unspeakable ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ God bless them both abundantly ❤️❤️❤️
I read the book few months back. Wonderfully written, giving a thorough insight in the dark world of depression.
Brave enough to speak about it. I suffered from depression back in 2016 and didnt even knew what it was. Luckily recovered from it. Please check with a psychlogist when you feel directionless and incomplete
By far the best interview I have ever seen .👏👏👍👍👌👌Superb of shaheen bhatt to firstly publish a book like this and hats off to her family and not only to her but I think to all the ppl who are fighting or fought bravely with depression .Hats off to u guys 🙌
Shaheen is a wonderful strong lady. God bless her. Alia is such a wonderful person. God bless her.
Kudos to Shaheen
You are blessed.
Being in the situation, I empathize with Shaheen completely.
But the way Alia says it is understanding and listening and picking up cues and being sensitive, I wish every person has someone like her.
Let's all take a moment to realize one thing. Every human being goes through hard times. Especially celebrities. Let's be kinder to them.
Thank you Shaheen. You have helped people better understand the issues and how to deal with them
I have attended this seminaar n I just loved it the way Shaheen spoke about her journey where she lived her depression when a person nowhere found him or herself she wrote a book I hope each n every one should come up even I have gone through and still going but from such people you get inspiration and courage to fight against our depression...
Alia specifically mentions that she doesn't want it to be about her as it shouldn't be, and well, the caption.
Wonderful. Thanks @Barkha and @Mojostory. A big hug to Shaheen and Aalia
Thanks for sharing your story Shaheen , it take a lot to talk about this. God will see you through. 🙏👍😢
I cried with Alia, she’s such a genuine pure sweet soul 💕🥺
Persian Pearl not really pure if she took her “best friends” man
Oh Raja beta ko rona aa raha hai
I also cried
Persian Pearl ALIA BHATT CRIES AS SISTER SHAHEEN OPENSUP ON HER BATTLE WITH DEPRESSION AT WE THE WOMEN|BARKHA DUTT ruclips.net/video/s4WexhAiKC0/видео.html
The first words which Shaheen gets to speak are when Alia stops to drink some water after about 5 minutes of Alia telling how she doesn't think that Shaheen should feel outshadowed by her because she is the most brilliant person in the family. The irony makes me hysterical. Also, the title of this video is just the icing on the cake.
I always thought Alia was a bimbo and very privileged but seeing her break down when she heard Shaheen talking about her struggles with depression was sad. As someone who is going through chronic depression, I could clearly relate to Shaheen, I was crying throughout the whole video.
I can understand what she was going through.
May every family have a good time.
Now Please don't Compare who is Best
They Both are best in their own field
Kudos brave girls so proud of being Their fan
@@pinkimahanta4811 spreading hate and being jealous of successful peoples is the only job you losers got .
I wish this segment had a different host. I was so engaged throughout when the sisters were talking but I didn't like the tone of the host. Other than that, the conversation was beautiful! It was so real and relatable! It's very hard to talk about depression and I am so proud of Shaheen for sharing her struggle! Cant wait to read the book 🖤
Thank you for bringing this topic to the fore. People largely still are getting to be aware what is depression..... And I think to be able to just acknowledge one is at that place that depression seems to hold you at... And be there to just listen and not judge is a starting point towards support. And please do not ever say 'sab thik Ho jayega'
I always wondered why people are suicidal or why they just give up on life like that but when depression and anxiety really hit me I could relate to those. It's easy to call out oh he's rich has a good job or oh she's a celeb or a member of the royal family everyone has their own issues and I feel it should be out to the young ones and should be given at least one class a week on health and well-being kids should know it's okay to feel low it's okay to fail it's okay to be yourself... When I was in school I was captivated by this whole family and relatives pressure that you always have to win.... People need to understand that not everyone is same after all it's a human being and each will work in their own way they aren't horses of a racecourse to always win.... mental health is a big issue and so many people aren't aware of it.....
So true
You know what I have also gone through it and you can control...
I had same feeling as Alia for my elder sister.
People are afraid of being vulnerable because you get thrashed and humiliated for being "weak".It has become easier to trample on someone's feelings but tough to walk in their shoes.
Deepa Lall True ! Well said 👏👏👏👏👍👍👍
Shaheen is beautiful, inside-out. It takes more than bravery and courage to do what she did. It's a reach and call for meaning. It takes heart to write your own story - it's more than just bravery. It's much deeper than that.
And now, whenever and every time I would see Alia Bhatt, whom I admire, I would also think of Shaheen, and hope that she's doing good.
I love the fact that this family is just so raw and non pretentious. Also in support to all those who are closed. Honestly very few people are humans. Good to know this family has held up strongest in these days.
Dear Shahin Bhatt her sister Alia Bhatt,
very good done to dare speak out about depression
such subject.
Glad to watch sister Bhatts stand by each other.
Shaheen Is MORe Adorable and near to us. so sweet she is.
I am also a depression patient but this made me comfort that around this world so many in this world are like me..
Rajiv Masand interviewed Shaheen! 👏🏾 what a girl and what an interview it was!
After the way barkha behaved with that girl, I think barkha was only listening and not understanding what shaheen was saying throughout..
This discussion was so important .
In India if a young woman talks about depression,most people start commenting that it may be because of a breakup or boyfriend.The worst thing is when people tell you to "get over it" or say it's "attention wh@ring".
THIS IS WHAT NEEDS TO BE SAID LOUDER!! When i quote something sad to my friends they're like "Did some guy do something?" 😵
Absolutely, on point ! I still get questions on my depression. That’s so rude ! They think everything revolves round boys and shit. Which ain’t true ! Anyone can be depressed due to any reason, doesn’t need to be a dumbfounded boyfriend!
Both sisters are amazing...
people should stop posting negative comments( I have in the past)
Everyones life is different and looks and money is not everything
Who else cried looking at her
Aaliya is so sweet and very protective about her sister.❤️
The talk about depression can be heard from these celebs family but not of the common people who are going through depression
Shaheen is beautiful, inside and out. And so so brave!
I love Alia for her acting in films ❤️for her beauty 🥰 for her cuteness ❤️for a wonderful person she is🥰but after watching this I also just love shaheen ❤️Shaheen is really a good person and my alu also🥰
I feel like writing a letter to you. Thanks so much for coming in public and expressing your feelings. Whether big shots or small shots many of them go through this. And by your voicing it you'll are helping others to come or of this negativity. Dear alia and Shaheen thanks n God bless you sisters.
18:53 alia says she does not wanna cry because then it'll be about she shedding a tear, as obviously the video is about her sister, shaheen's battle with depression, but so ironically, the video title starts with "alia bhatt breaks down.....". Yeah i am sure that helps getting views but....seriously??
Hats of to Shaheen.... There are many people going through this in life thank you for coming out with your story it is going to help so many more people and your this step will help us as a society to talk about this more openly and not hide what people go through