The Black Paintings by Goya (Part One): Great Art Explained

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 окт 2022
  • Please consider supporting this channel on Patreon, thanks! www.patreon.com/user?u=53686503
    Or if you prefer a one-off donation - www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
    Merchandise here - crowdmade.com/collections/gre...
    To understand Francisco Goya's Black Paintings, we need to understand how he went from a popular well-loved royal portrait artist to painting deeply disturbing imagery on the bare walls of his house in total isolation.
    In 1819, Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes, commonly known as Goya, was a successful and celebrated artist. Then suddenly, he withdrew from public life, left Madrid and the Royal Court behind, and moved into a farmhouse in the countryside.
    His wife and most of his friends were dead and he had become isolated. He was 73-years old, sick, and completely deaf. His long life was coming to a close… BUT he wasn’t finished yet. The man who had once painted crucifixions, miracles, saints, and priests, now painted terrifying, demonic, raw and brutal works - works without even a hint of God.
    Subscribe and click the bell icon to be notified! ruclips.net/channel/UCePD...
    I would like to thank all my Patreon supporters, in particular Alan Stewart, Alexander Velser, Christa Sawyer, Erique K, Griffin Evans, Jennifer Barnaby, Julio Cardenas, Karim Hopper, Nicholas Siebenlist, Pavel Juszczyk, Theresa Garfink, Toni Ko, and Tyler Wittreich.
    "What a brilliant series this is" - Stephen Fry on Twitter 12 December 2020
    CREDITS
    SUBTITLES
    I input the English subtitles myself but I rely on volunteers to do subtitles for other languages and I really appreciate it - just contact me at jamespayne33@hotmail.com
    Spanish Subtitles by Tomas Iriarte
    French Subtitles by Ludivine Desriac
    Chinese Subtitles by Charles Xiu
    Title Sequence by Brian Adsit (instagram brian_vfx?... and Behance www.behance.com/badsit88)
    Special thanks to Drone Footage (Madrid aerial shot) - a brilliant RUclips channel (please subscribe) that allowed me to use some of their beautiful footage - ruclips.net/channel/UCKoK...
    Special thanks to Goldmark Gallery for allowing me to use a clip from this video - • Incredible Goya Disast...
    All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and I or this channel do not claim any right over them.
    FILM CLIPS
    Napoleon Footage Ⓒ Gaumont Films
    Reign of Terror Ⓒ Eagle-Lion Films
    BOOKS
    Goya: A Portrait of the Artist by Tomlinson and Janis
    Goya by Rainer & Rose-Marie Hagen
    Goya by Robert Hughes
    Goya`s Graphic Imagination by Mark Mcdonald, Mercedes Cerón-peña, et al.
    MUSIC
    Asturias by Isaac Albéniz
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 601

  • @GreatArtExplained
    @GreatArtExplained  Год назад +263

    Please like and comment. It really helps promote the channel. Many thanks, James

    • @Easyn_
      @Easyn_ Год назад

      Comment

    • @Rapha_Carpio
      @Rapha_Carpio Год назад

      😊

    • @handenazozkal7237
      @handenazozkal7237 Год назад +1

      thank you for the vıdeo. please do Albrecht Dürer - Melencolia I too one day, ıf you're ınterested.. keep up the great work.

    • @rainnyme
      @rainnyme Год назад +3

      I'm a patreon, but I still watch public videos so you can get the ad rev and view stats up (:

    • @GreatArtExplained
      @GreatArtExplained  Год назад +3

      @@rainnyme thanks so much for all your support!

  • @thuhuong8838
    @thuhuong8838 Год назад +466

    The editing, the attention to details, my man doing god work by doing the whole black paintings collection. The black painting was such a stepping stone for art history. What happened when you stripped an artist bare of status, standard, wealth and just left him with darkness and isolation. Well, he created monsters

    • @nandokart2830
      @nandokart2830 Год назад +12

      The monsters already existed, he put them in canvass.

  • @jacksonvanmatre
    @jacksonvanmatre Год назад +266

    These works have always scared me down to my soul. I've always thought it would be interesting to make a series of horror films based on each painting.

    • @Toetbeornottoetdbe
      @Toetbeornottoetdbe Год назад +13

      Few paintings have actually caused an emotional response in me, but Goya’s work and especially the black paintings certainly did.

    • @jacksonvanmatre
      @jacksonvanmatre Год назад +5

      @@Toetbeornottoetdbe The dog one scares me the most. It's so haunting and tragic.

    • @startrooper3502
      @startrooper3502 Год назад +6

      Attack of Titan anime have taken inspiration from Goya

    • @hoenn4ever829
      @hoenn4ever829 Год назад +2

      @@startrooper3502 From the painting Saturn Devouring his Son, I'm guessing? I didn't know that, to be honest, although I do notice the inspiration if it really was inspired by it. Then again, did Isayama ever confirm that, though?

    • @sunflowerlove60
      @sunflowerlove60 Год назад +2

      I just started scrolling to get away from the image that’s how powerful they are!

  • @javierplumedsantos7620
    @javierplumedsantos7620 Год назад +213

    Thank you so much for this video. As a Spaniard, I've always thought of Goya as underappreciated in the international panorama. So I am really excited to finally see him get the recognition he deserves

    • @GreatArtExplained
      @GreatArtExplained  Год назад +13

      Gracias 🙏

    • @snooze6650
      @snooze6650 Год назад +7

      El tres de mayo de 1808 is one of the most significant/moving paintings ever to me. Goya has always been treasured in my art classes in California. Much love

    • @epbarrera
      @epbarrera Год назад

      Sólo por curiosidad, en España ustedes se llaman “Spaniards” en inglés en lugar de “Spanish”? Gracias!

    • @guillermo907
      @guillermo907 Год назад

      @@epbarrera" spanish" para referirse a los españoles esta mal dicho. "Spanish" se utiliza como un adjectivo, "Spanish people" o "I am spanish"

    • @epbarrera
      @epbarrera Год назад

      @@guillermo907 Gracias. Tenía entendido que era correcto el gentilicio “Spanish”

  • @varunv565
    @varunv565 Год назад +73

    I hope you know the impact you have on most of us, those who never studied art, but have learned a great appreciation of it through these videos.

  • @michaeld1889
    @michaeld1889 Год назад +85

    Your channel is like a master class on art. Thank you so much. Please keep up the great work.

  • @blondebimbowannabe
    @blondebimbowannabe Год назад +69

    I clicked as soon as I got the notification. I love each and every video covering Goya's black paintings! Thank you for covering this

  • @paulstokes677
    @paulstokes677 Год назад +13

    I went to the Museo Nacional del Prado in Madrid in September 2019. Which seems like a lifetime ago now. I went to see The Black Painting by Goya they were absolutely mind-bending to look at in real life, the thickness of the brush strokes and darkness of each painting. I honestly think that some people left that room in pure horror!

    • @alejandroojeda1572
      @alejandroojeda1572 Год назад

      Honestly you can't convince me people can look at Saturn devouring his son and NOT be terrified

  • @rosiem.532
    @rosiem.532 Год назад +78

    I love this channel so much it's so good how everything is so nice and clear and yet includes all the little details. I was hoping Goya would be covered at some point, so my day has absolutely been made by this video. Can't wait for part 2!!

  • @isacj81
    @isacj81 Год назад +12

    My Lord... This channel is so underrated! Your videos have added so much richness to my life and how I view the world. Being a patron is the least I can do to retribute. Thank you, James!

  • @zairazaira_
    @zairazaira_ Год назад +8

    the quality of your videos is always unmatched

  • @DenisMark1
    @DenisMark1 Год назад +9

    As someone who loves videos on art and artists, no one does this better than you. Your hard work and attention to tone, sequence and how much information to provide your viewer is so good that it can be taken for granted. Here in the States we are so accustomed to the Ken Burns approach (which has its place) that to see something WITHOUT talking heads or self-indulgent tangents is not only a breath of fresh air, but so appreciated. Know that there are many of us who appreciate the hours of editing and perfecting these gems and look forward to every one. I never know what you will tackle next but usually my response is "yes!" before clicking and watching. In a word: Bravo.

  • @lauraparker108
    @lauraparker108 Год назад +15

    I wish you had thousands of videos on important art. I devour each one you put out. They are masterfully done and really help me understand the time period, the significance of the pieces and artists, and the art itself. Bravo on another wonderful video!

  • @UnKnown-bu3hw
    @UnKnown-bu3hw 14 дней назад +1

    Insanity has a nice touch especially with the touch of suffering and severe ptsd. The man was talented and spoke his truth figured out the horrific truth of reality

  • @endodouble6691
    @endodouble6691 Год назад +10

    You are a legend for using Asturias to accompany the video. And for pretty much everything else you do 😂

  • @curiousworld7912
    @curiousworld7912 Год назад +6

    Thank you, for giving us this. I remember seeing Goya's work, decades ago while in Spain, and being very moved by his paintings. Sadly, they're just as timely now, as then.

  • @SarastistheSerpent
    @SarastistheSerpent Год назад +38

    This was fantastic. I cannot wait for you to explain Saturn Devouring His Son in depth in part 2. That’s one of my favourite works of art of all time

  • @ettajfan5882
    @ettajfan5882 Год назад +8

    Another stellar explanation of a great artist and his art. Thank you!

  • @TechWithSean
    @TechWithSean Год назад +6

    Great video! Goya’s works were my favorite out of everything I saw at Museo del Prado. The dichotomy of his periods is really something, he was able to capture both the light and dark sides of humanity, and even though his style wasn’t photorealistic, his works have a tangible, natural quality to them.

  • @lgeray1
    @lgeray1 Год назад +9

    Makes me sad and angry that despite all of mankind's knowledge and experience throughout history, religions and totalitarian systems still are in much too much power in much too many places in the world today. Goya must have been a very clear-sighted and empathic human being. Thank you for making his and the work of all those other artists known and accessible to us viewers. I greatly appreciate your excellent videos, and after each one I'm waiting impatiently for the next one to be published. Always time well spent.

  • @cathalfeeney3929
    @cathalfeeney3929 Год назад +6

    Superb work James. Really outstanding. Thank you.

  • @WillLiang
    @WillLiang Год назад +1

    This is seriously one of the best channels on RUclips. From now on, I will make any excuse to mention this channel to friends.

  • @kylesmitheram5338
    @kylesmitheram5338 Год назад +5

    Was just thinking about this channel this morning and wondering when the next video would be, and here it is. The meme of Saturn Devouring His Son kind of swept through the internet not long ago, and it's striking, but man, those etchings, especially the Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters is so good, and the message still incredibly relevant.

  • @FlippingPhysics
    @FlippingPhysics Год назад +4

    Loved this video. Shared it with my family, everybody enjoyed it, even my teenage daughter, which is saying much. You do a really good job of explaining the art with a historical context that makes it relatable. I love the beginning where you spend an uncomfortable amount of time zooming in on "Saturn Devouring His Son". It was a perfect beginning. Thanks so much!!

  • @jaska9796
    @jaska9796 Год назад +4

    The amount of joy I have while watching these videos is unexplainable

  • @Lunch_Meat
    @Lunch_Meat Год назад +3

    I am so glad you decided to cover these paintings in your videos. These paintings get to me in the same way that Turners final paintings get to me and the same way that warren zevon's and gil Scott heron's last albums get to me. It's total contemplation of not just "the end" but the totality of life lead up to that end. Those things most on their minds, the way they see and relate to life, and how they are dealing with death.
    I use to work as a janitor/custodian in hospitals, mental institutions, and hospice and it always amazes me how art and music was a person's way of exploring their own thoughts and feelings on things beyond what they could communicate with words.
    There is so much to unpack in these paintings and you are doing an amazing job of it.

  • @DB09198523
    @DB09198523 Год назад +1

    The opening sequence gives me goosebumps everytime I watch this.

  • @dancountyfc
    @dancountyfc Год назад +2

    Congrats on smashing 1 million! This channel is still so underrated

  • @86zerueldososo64
    @86zerueldososo64 Год назад +2

    Another amazing video from one of the best channels on RUclips. Keep up the great work.

  • @jethrotertiusthethird2439
    @jethrotertiusthethird2439 Год назад +7

    Thank you so much for these extremely high quality videos. The editing and research that goes into them is not unnoticed! Please continue making them!

  • @raoultecala9957
    @raoultecala9957 Год назад +4

    All ur vids are wonderful but this one takes it to another level. Cant wait for part II!

  • @adrianbourceanu9145
    @adrianbourceanu9145 Год назад +2

    My birthday is coming soon, and this is one of the best presents I could have asked for: a careful examination of Goya's work by one of the best channels on youtube! I have nothing but respect for the artist, and I cannot wait for part 2!

  • @danielschick7875
    @danielschick7875 Год назад +6

    Been looking forward to another Episode. Really appreciate the work you do !

  • @ExistentialistDasein
    @ExistentialistDasein Год назад +1

    One of the most significant (philosophical) messages behind The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters hinges on the double-meaning of "sueño" in Spanish! I'm surprised it is not mentioned in this video. In any case, thank you for your wonderful videos:)!

  • @waterglas21
    @waterglas21 Год назад +19

    Great video, as a spaniard I think you did a good job telling Goya's history. Can wait for the second part.
    9:24 I always take that capricho in a different way. In spanish "sueño" can be interpreted as dream not only sleep. So that way is more like "the dreaming of reason produces monsters". For me it means that there is also a dark side to the enlightenment movement, for example the dark ending of the French Revolution which dreams of perfect reason ended with violence.

    • @fukinsei
      @fukinsei Год назад +1

      to add,
      the monsters that reason produces are born from the dream of itself. Goya always combined classical beauty with the paranoia of silence. Number 43 is an aesthetic oxymoron.
      love your videos!

  • @sharonlmiller
    @sharonlmiller Год назад +4

    I l.o.v.e how art and history are brought together in your videos!

  • @mspacephal3925
    @mspacephal3925 Год назад +1

    My friend your videos are absolutely fantastic, and this one especially. I love Goya and was in Madrid a few days back and had the chance to see this marvellous paintings. Looking forward to watching the second part!! Thank you! ❤

  • @valabakhtiarzadeh9639
    @valabakhtiarzadeh9639 Год назад +21

    Meticulous, breath taking, and absolutely enjoyable to watch! Love your channel and have massive respect for the effort you're putting into this platform in order to educate and raise awareness about great art. Do not ever stop!

  • @DavidS-dw1wv
    @DavidS-dw1wv Год назад +2

    Can’t wait for part two!

  • @alechall7082
    @alechall7082 Год назад +1

    This has become one of my favorite channels, I really look foward to these. Quality stuff, keep it up.

  • @genesseecarini8882
    @genesseecarini8882 Год назад +3

    This channel is one if my favorites. It has nurtured a deeper curiosity and appreciation for art and artists. It has also inspired my own creativity. Thank you so much!

  • @meenakshideshpande3576
    @meenakshideshpande3576 Год назад +1

    The way every art piece is explained and viewed, analysed is just amazing. You are really doing such an awesome job of explaining the Great Art. I am 10000% sure, that those who watch these videos, must have gotten a new view of looking at Art. Thank you sooo soooo much Sir. :)))

  • @rickb3078
    @rickb3078 Год назад +2

    This is an incredible documentary. I have learned so much. Together with Picasso provides a wealth of context for their art and the world they lived in.

  • @gregorycheverall1830
    @gregorycheverall1830 Год назад +3

    Fascinating! Thank you

  • @goschka25
    @goschka25 Год назад +2

    Fascinating video! Thanks for your great job! Many thanks.

  • @jacquelinegibson7420
    @jacquelinegibson7420 Год назад +1

    It's so interesting to hear how these paintings fit into history.

  • @perspicaciouscritic
    @perspicaciouscritic Год назад

    One million subscribers! Well, that didn't take long.
    Congratulations and truly well deserved.

  • @welldonewit5129
    @welldonewit5129 Год назад +4

    It's really telling how drastically his work changed.

  • @johntaggart2014
    @johntaggart2014 Год назад +2

    Yay was waiting for this one. Wonderful stuff.

  • @Keldorek
    @Keldorek Год назад +2

    This felt like the most staggeringly powerful one you've done yet. Stunning video and channel. Thanks for the efforts and the insights.

  • @v0nman
    @v0nman Год назад +4

    My favorite series of paintings, love your work and I'm so happy you are able to keep producing it.

  • @rtk3543
    @rtk3543 Год назад +2

    Great video on a great artist and humanist, Goya is one of my favourite artists. Thank you for telling his story.

  • @jackwalter5030
    @jackwalter5030 Год назад

    My knowledge of Goya has now been increased tremendously. I look forward to Part Two.

  • @akcnerico
    @akcnerico Год назад +2

    The only thing I don't like about your videos is that they actually end. Thank you, and please don't ever stop 😊

  • @Misspol222
    @Misspol222 Год назад +2

    Stellar content, as always! Late Goya looks astonishingly like 20th century art to me. His art is just so strikingly modern. A true visionary. I've had the pleasure of seeing the black paintings in Prado a few years back and I was fascinated. Thank you for covering them!

    • @GreatArtExplained
      @GreatArtExplained  Год назад +1

      Its what first struck me about him - they are so modern!

  • @shad3465
    @shad3465 5 месяцев назад +1

    I saw his paintings at El Museo Prado in Madrid back in 1996. That tour changed my view on art forever. Goya, Velazques, El Greco gave me such appreciation for real art.

  • @discotetka162
    @discotetka162 Год назад +1

    i really admire all the work put in this channel!

  • @MerTheMan
    @MerTheMan Год назад +1

    I’ve been waiting for this one for a extremely long time your my favorite art channel thank you for the video

  • @jakobwarmare5333
    @jakobwarmare5333 Год назад +1

    My favourite series of paintings in the world! Amazing video as well!

  • @alyssa01825
    @alyssa01825 Год назад

    saw these in person this past year. they really stuck with me.

  • @mexicanpumpkin
    @mexicanpumpkin Год назад +2

    What a great art class! Thanks also for the subtitles for us who don’t master English

  • @101Linkisawesome
    @101Linkisawesome Год назад +2

    Mindblowing stuff. I love the sound effects and the levels have been so GOOD

  • @teddysterriertales
    @teddysterriertales Год назад +7

    YAY!!! A new one! These videos are genuinely so amazing. The amount of information and effort is massive!

  • @damianmiranda2985
    @damianmiranda2985 Год назад +29

    Goya's art did not undergo an "unexpected revolution from dark to light", many of his earlier paintings have dark and disturbing undertones, he just became less subtle about it as he became more jaded.

  • @SM-fz3et
    @SM-fz3et Год назад +1

    So incredibly excited for part 2

  • @Katrina.for_art
    @Katrina.for_art Год назад +1

    I love learning history through the artists at that time. It makes it more real, makes more sense. Thx for sharing.

  • @glytterboi9416
    @glytterboi9416 Год назад +3

    Thanks a lot for the video, it's just as insighful and interesting as the others published by you. Probably one of my favourite channels on YT

  • @judgeholden9942
    @judgeholden9942 Год назад

    Can’t wait for the next in this series, Goya had such an Interesting life, long time favorite artist

  • @getvivekshinde
    @getvivekshinde Год назад +1

    Wonderful series about Art. Please keep it going. I'm enjoying it very much and learning a lot!

  • @De4dPoo1
    @De4dPoo1 Год назад +2

    Im a engineer and my whole life was about numbers and coding since i can remember. But i saw this video today and my god. This made me feel alive for the first time in many many years. Thank you, this video was something else.

  • @narizota
    @narizota Год назад +1

    Everytime a great art explained video drops i run to watch it he always slays

  • @carolinaroveroni8101
    @carolinaroveroni8101 Год назад +1

    Hi, I'm Brazilian, and a few days ago I saw some of the Caprices in a exposition in partnership with a museum in Vienna, and I saw The Dream of Reason Produces Monsters right in front of me, and I immediately remembered your video, it was really nice to be able to explain the context to the people around me.

  • @eddardstark5034
    @eddardstark5034 Год назад +3

    YAAAAAAAAASSSSSSSSS!!!!! I'VE BEEN WAITING SO LONG FOR THIS EPISODE!!!!

  • @jasminemccullough9230
    @jasminemccullough9230 Год назад +1

    I look forward to any video you put out ❤ I’m thankful for your channel

  • @Charleston90110
    @Charleston90110 Год назад +2

    Finally! Great way to end my night!

  • @ulicirebeca4038
    @ulicirebeca4038 Год назад +1

    Incredible research!! This video was so well put together, thank-you so much. Oh how I wish your videos were at least an hour long! I share them with family and friends and they all love them!

  • @ioannal5042
    @ioannal5042 Год назад +1

    I wish you would post more often 💕 I’ve watched all the videos on your channel & i love how you explain all of the great artists & artworks

  • @TheOptikin
    @TheOptikin Год назад +1

    I recall requesting a Goya video from you quite awhile ago and I’m so happy that this is the path you have chosen to explore him. Excellent video!!! Anxiously awaiting the next installment

  • @GabrielGarcia-cs2gv
    @GabrielGarcia-cs2gv Год назад

    Excellent video. I found the context in which these impressive pieces were painted enlightening. I’m looking forward to part 2!

  • @victoriamovchan8470
    @victoriamovchan8470 Год назад +1

    I really appreciate that you use your voice to cover difficult topics like war. And yes, today Goya is as relevant as ever

  • @jamiller9044
    @jamiller9044 Год назад +1

    This has to be one of your most invigorating, well-informed, and harrowing reviews yet. I was engrossed the whole time. Thank you for these videos!!! I can't wait for the next one! (Btw... I bought one of your shirts. I wear it proudly! 😎)

  • @alijamshidi8410
    @alijamshidi8410 Год назад +1

    Such a well made video and professionally scripted. I wasn't an art person but watching these series makes me truly appreciate the depth of each artist and their works. Well done for bringing culture to the internet.

  • @Swampratatta
    @Swampratatta Год назад +2

    Just what I needed!

  • @davidkent2804
    @davidkent2804 Год назад

    Have to say, these scholarly introductions and images are profound. Much appreciated

  • @timebird78
    @timebird78 Год назад +1

    This channel is such a diamond!

  • @jr4isawsome
    @jr4isawsome Год назад +1

    Another brilliant video James, keep it up!

  • @monicab8400
    @monicab8400 Год назад

    Incredible! Very informative. I’ve always found De Goya’s work both captivating and haunting

  • @whyamilikethis1998
    @whyamilikethis1998 Год назад +1

    I was so excited to see this notification come up- I was working in the library, and couldn't wait to get home so I could watch! My excitement was not misplaced - thank you for another fantastic video! Can't wait for part 2.

  • @NikunjBhartiaLP
    @NikunjBhartiaLP Год назад

    Can't get enough of your videos! Simply the best art content on RUclips

  • @27limes
    @27limes Год назад

    This is fascinating, can't wait for part two! I love the way you put these videos together

  • @feildpres
    @feildpres Год назад +1

    Another fantastic video!
    One of the best Channels on youtube, I always love to see a new video

  • @biancabalan4263
    @biancabalan4263 Год назад

    I visited Prado almost a year ago and these paintings were a standout among many masterpieces!
    Your videos make me love art more every time.

  • @martijnkeisers5900
    @martijnkeisers5900 Год назад +2

    Looking forward to part two!

  • @alexturtwig5029
    @alexturtwig5029 Год назад +1

    Already one of your classic episodes the black paintings are my favorite

  • @TheKate2212
    @TheKate2212 Год назад +1

    I can't wait for part 2! Your channel is my favorite on youtube! I love your format!

  • @nicholasfrundt4125
    @nicholasfrundt4125 Год назад +1

    I'm so glad you chose to cover these pieces! Thanks for making such informative videos.

  • @danag812
    @danag812 Год назад +1

    Very interesting. Absolutely top notch video as usual. Thank you so much❤

  • @YulianaChiPhotography
    @YulianaChiPhotography Год назад

    Your videos are always such a treat! Thank you so much for all your time and effort which you put into your work.

  • @Dashingdiva73
    @Dashingdiva73 Год назад +1

    I'm watching this while on my treadmill. But I have to stop. Goya has always been one of my favorite artists. I remember when my mother went to the Norton Simon, she brought back an art book of goya's paintings. The third of May was a painting I stared at endlessly in my youth. When I was in high school we studied an art history. And as an opera singer who had the opportunity to sing Fidelio, I always referenced that painting when I studied that music that Beethoven wrote about the Spanish prisoners. The central figure, the christ-like figure, always reminded me of Florestan. Watching your narrative on that painting moved me to tears. I echoed every word that you said which helped me to realize that I too understood the pain and the suffering and the drama that occurred in that painting. Thank you for this video it just reinforced my thoughts on Humanity, my thoughts on pain and suffering that Goya expertly created for us as a record of what he went through in his life. This was an amazing video.

  • @shanecadden7914
    @shanecadden7914 Год назад +1

    Oh, that zoom in on the eyes gave me chills