What an absolute joy to watch and hear. I love that Amira and Alma have met and performed together. Two of the most talented kids of their age on the planet.
Too much talent on one stage! Singing is absolutely gorgeous.This composition is so sophisticated, it has counter point, key changes, beautiful dynamics etc. everything you need in a opera...Alma is a genius! it's performed so beautifully by both of them...Amira and Alma can skip music conservatory or the they can teach there. Amazing!!!!!!
10-23-2019 ran across these two... read the comments below... A duet...a singer and a composer why would ANYONE compare these two in this effort??? the singer was great...the composition was great... one could not ask for more other than an ENCORE... Both in their field ... boggles the mine, they are so good I would buy tickets to hear these two perform together these two will put there stamp on their field of work hope I'm around when the two PEAK... great show ladies, hope to see you two grow into the footsteps that your talent promises...
What I love about Alma, other than her amazing talent, is the joy she gets from and gives to her music. Her sense of fun is evident here, as it is in the third movement of her piano concerto, which surely exemplifies 'mischievous joy'.
Astonishing!! Her obvious talent comes first before her huge self-confidence, which is so wonderful to see. I can only attribute that to her parents who supported and encouraged her every step of the way.
These two young ladies are going to take over the musical world!!! Alma the superb composer, pianist and violist. Amira the superb opera singer. A tag team that hits you with a right and then a left that knocks you out. My heart is filled with joy! Comparing the two though is like comparing apples and oranges. Alma's focus is on the composition, the score and then the musical performance and she does all three with an ease that makes brain surgery look like childs play. Amira's focus is on the vocal performance for which she does with a natural talent that brings us all to our knees. To say that one is better than the other is misguided. They both compliment each other. Both of them are perfectly suited for this performance because they are playing the dueling step sisters. Both with talents that the other does not possess and arguing about it. Perfect for the two of them.
+tom ten Are they? They seem to work very well together, especially since this performance was kind of a "spur of the moment" deal. I would love to see them collaborate more often. They really do seem to compliment each other very well.
Phillip Crews Dear Blessed Mother please keep her safe from all the evil and the wolf, she is heaven sent to this universe this is what this planet needed Amira our earth Angel.
One of my favorite composers (Alma Deutscher) and Amira one of the wonderful angelical voice in this world, I cry any time I heard Maria Callas singing Mio Bambino Cara, Amira produce the same wonderful effect. I hope I will be alive when Alma write her Symphonies, and Amira will sing the most beautiful Arias in this world.
Wow! What a joy to watch and hear two young talents perform together. I really do think that those two girls have a very bright future ahead. In my humble opinion they could be a good duo, with Alma on the piano or violin and Amira singing opera they would work very well together. Heart-warming performance!
As a more recent update, in November 2021, 16 year old Alma stepped in and sang the role of Cinderella (in German), on 3 hours notice, after the singer who was supposed to do it tested positive for Corona . This last November, she conducted performances of the opera in San Jose, California (after earning a degree in conducting and spending the summer conducting concerts of Vienna's Strauss Cappele Orchestra)
I have been following the musical journey of both girls from the beginning, and I often thought how wonderful it would be if they could meet and collaborate. Therefore, I was pleasantly surprised to see this video come onto my screen. I have the feeling they will collaborate again over the years. They are both so talented!
how beautiful to see such a successful collaboration of such a young talents! Way to go, we will expect in future more music and singing from you too :)
I have both of these wonderful girl's album's And said that they should collaborate . Amira is amazing her voice brings me to tears each time I hear it . Alma music will make you smile cry all in one movement. Alma Amira I will try and see you both live this year.
What we see here is what I stated a long time ago: Music knows no boundaries - here we have a little Dutch girl joining musical talents with a little British girl. In the history of mankind, have there ever been such Wunderkinder ?
Para mí la música clásica y el bel canto son de las creaciones artísticas sublimes pero verlo en niños o niñas lo hacen plus ultra. congratulations wonderful girls.
Eu também! Que coincidencia! Ela é maravilhosa mesmo! Fico feliz em saber que tem gente que sabe apreciar as coisas elevada da vida! Essa menina é um fenomeno da musica clássica! E não há outra igual!
Luiz Carlos Guimarães Sim Luis,é muito bom saber de pessoas de bom gosto assim como vc. Um abraço e sigamos assim sempre fã de Amira Willighagen!!! Um abraço.
Me he dado cuenta que tanto André Riu y Alma, aportaron en el perfeccionamiento de Amira, bueno, por decirlo asi: le dieron unos buenos consejitos de vocalización y listo... el resultado: una diosa de la ópera, y estoy feliz por ella y por mí, porque no me canso de escucharla.
Amira no sólo es una de las mejores cantantes de estos tiempos, Amira es grande como persona, Amira tiene talento, arte, humildad, corazón, no cambies nunca, porque la soberbia, la petulancia por más talento que haya no genera empatía, puedes tener mil habilidades pero sin humildad seras parte de un triste espectáculo como persona. Tu no eres así, eres lindísima para ser tan pequeña. Soy a partir de hoy tu fan oficial.
La considero una voz de otro mundo fantástica y carismática, Dios quiera que conserve esta voz por muchos años para deleite de todos nosotros, muchas felicidades y mucho éxito para ti.
Ame o Brasil Ele é peça importante no cenário mundial. acredite voçes não vão gostar dele deixar deexistir. EU SONHO COM UMA INTERNET BRASILEIRA. ESPERO UM DIA NÃO PRECISAR SABER INGLES PARA VER INTERNET
Only use 1 hour rehearsal, not easy for Amira , Alma is composer, she know very well about Melody, very interesting opera Cinderella stepsisters song! Both cute in act!
Alma is anticipating that Amira will sing her music in the future. Because Amira is the greatest potential female opera singer in the world. And she knows this. This little girl is very VERY smart and can become anything she likes. But since she likes music most she will not become the future PM of Britain or Israel.
It reminds me of Deeana Durbin and Judy Garland when they sang together in their 1937 movie Every Sunday. They were both 14 (a little older than these 2 geniuses)
Almira, from watching a few videos of you singing - you have amazing classical potential. Leave pop to those who can't, or don't want to, do better. Looking forward to seeing/hearing more opera from you.
Beautiful. I doubt if Alma could write an ugly, grotesque piece even if she tried. I feel they are both unsuited for the part, for neither of them can be called ugly - indeed they are both quite pretty. Now, how do these two mini-divas get on with each other?
When asked about it recently Alma said that Amira stayed at her house and that they took mattresses to the treehouse and had a sleepover. When asked if they would be friends she said "We are already!" and told the story of the sleepover. They have very different demeanors but I hope they keep the friendship going as they clearly belong together creating the most beautiful music the world has ever heard.
Actually the original definition of diva is that of someone supremely gifted or a "divine one". So to call them divas is a compliment. Unfortunately the usage over time has come to have a different negative meaning as well and it is that meaning that most people think of. Prima donna is also a compliment to a singer but that word has come to have a different meaning as well.
Has no one noticed? The first stanza of the Ugly Stepsisters Duet is based on the Act 1 trio of the Three Ladies in the Magic Flute. It's as if she has omitted the Mozartean curlicues and left the bare bones of the music in her duet. I'm sure this is unconscious. Alma's part is original and has no derivation from the Mozart. But the opening that Amira sings is clearly based on the opening trio of the Magic Flute.
I don't see it....Mozart's trio is far more complex .. though Alma's duet is wonderfully accessible and with it's diminished 7th "marry's him I'll die"
Alma begint een beetje Emily Bear (aug 2001 USA) achterna te gaan met haar muzikale talent en het componeren. (professioneel componist met 4 en professioneel concert pianist met 5 jaar) Voor wie nog nooit van Emily Bear heeft gehoord is hier een voorbeeld van haar. ruclips.net/video/Y-xbPlBqoOg/видео.html
Words written by me not to insult Alma. These are the words of indignation. Alma is a very talented child, she really can not hear the dissonance? I see Alma simple and it has a sore throat, then why sing? Amirа could easily sing itself. I do not understand your indignation. Such objectivity.
Товарищ Кошкина Amira may sing better than Alma but they are not competing with each other, so no one loses. It is a duet and they are singing together, not against one another. Reading the description you will find, Alma is not normally a singer, though she does sing. This performance is a special treat for the people in the audience from both girls and was not a normal part of the performance. It is purely for enjoyment, not for competition, nor with the intent of being critiqued, simply for the fun of performing being fun, for the audience, the performers themselves and their patron, Sir Roger Moore. Being that they are both so accomplished at such a young age, they garner the entitlement to include an additional performance with amusement and pleasure. I am one to believe that they are entitled to have any fun they wish together as they are only children. Keeping in mind, most children their age are not doing such things that they do. I can't be sure what lilianwriter is bothered by, but I would assume it was your saying "In a duet with Amirа she will always lose." This happens to come off as a bit snide, and as a duet is not a competition, but rather, a musical composition for two performers in which the performers have equal importance to the piece, it is uncalled for and unbefitting to even bring up in such a way. Though, it would be more proper a statement if you had said "In a singing competition against Amira, Alma will always lose." I believe you also are mistaking your words meanings, as objective is unbiased and subjective is biased. Their indignation is more than likely stemmed from your lack of tact in your comment, brought on presumably, only through a misunderstanding of the words you are using. To be sure, I may be wrong, as your original comment that was replied to has been edited since, and so I am only able to glean information from what now remains there to be seen. In all probability, English is, to all appearances, not your native tongue, in which case, your comment is excusable. I've just one more thing to bring to your attention. You seem to imply Amira could perform this perfectly fine by herself, and while she may be able to sing all of the words in the proper pitch, timing, etc.. this is a duet, it requires both voices to complete this piece, as there are two distinct characters written. If she were to perform it herself, it would be more suitable for a tale of one person with dissociative identity disorder.
At 2:07 Amira made a funny face to someone in the audience lol. Sorry but I feel Alma`s voice and composition were hideous. She may be gifted, but today the gift was a lump of coal.
They don't realize anything otherwise they wouldn't have posted what they did. I love reading the comments of the under-bridge. They throw such lovely lumps of dung I wonder why they continue living in it.
@@kvercher12 I wouldn'n have given her that much credence. thick I'd say. There is a better version of this, in every way. Not sure it's still on You Tube. this looks to be off the cuff, as in a private party, but unrehearst. and badly recorded
Je bent te goed voor dit meisje waardoor haar stem gewoon en goedkoop klinkt. Laat je niet verlagen door mensen die mee willen liften op jouw succes. Moest wel lachen om je gebaar toen zij begon te zingen. Dus je weet dat zij niet jou kaliber heeft. hahahaha componeren en zingen zijn twee verschillende dingen.
What an absolute joy to watch and hear. I love that Amira and Alma have met and performed together. Two of the most talented kids of their age on the planet.
Too much talent on one stage! Singing is absolutely gorgeous.This composition is so sophisticated, it has counter point, key changes, beautiful dynamics etc. everything you need in a opera...Alma is a genius! it's performed so beautifully by both of them...Amira and Alma can skip music conservatory or the they can teach there. Amazing!!!!!!
10-23-2019
ran across these two...
read the comments below...
A duet...a singer and a composer
why would ANYONE compare these two in this effort???
the singer was great...the composition was great...
one could not ask for more other than an ENCORE...
Both in their field ... boggles the mine, they are so good
I would buy tickets to hear these two perform together
these two will put there stamp on their field of work
hope I'm around when the two PEAK...
great show ladies, hope to see you two grow into
the footsteps that your talent promises...
A delightful collaboration between two wonderful young musicians. Well done!
***** YEAH.
Bravo, Amira and Alma! Wonderful performance! Excellent it! I like it very much!
This is wonderful to watch and hear two such talented and gifted young girls perform live together for a small audience. Bravo.
yes I think so too. it is a very beautifull and successful attempt. 1+1=>11
What I love about Alma, other than her amazing talent, is the joy she gets from and gives to her music. Her sense of fun is evident here, as it is in the third movement of her piano concerto, which surely exemplifies 'mischievous joy'.
Astonishing!! Her obvious talent comes first before her huge self-confidence, which is so wonderful to see. I can only attribute that to her parents who supported and encouraged her every step of the way.
These two young ladies are going to take over the musical world!!! Alma the superb composer, pianist and violist. Amira the superb opera singer. A tag team that hits you with a right and then a left that knocks you out. My heart is filled with joy!
Comparing the two though is like comparing apples and oranges. Alma's focus is on the composition, the score and then the musical performance and she does all three with an ease that makes brain surgery look like childs play. Amira's focus is on the vocal performance for which she does with a natural talent that brings us all to our knees. To say that one is better than the other is misguided. They both compliment each other.
Both of them are perfectly suited for this performance because they are playing the dueling step sisters. Both with talents that the other does not possess and arguing about it. Perfect for the two of them.
+Phillip Crews YEH, Amira and Alma are also BIG friends.
+tom ten Are they? They seem to work very well together, especially since this performance was kind of a "spur of the moment" deal. I would love to see them collaborate more often. They really do seem to compliment each other very well.
i can't agree more . Yes , joy because we feel hope.
Phillip Crews Dear Blessed Mother please keep her safe from all the evil and the wolf, she is heaven sent to this universe this is what this planet needed Amira our earth Angel.
Phillip Crews ,
What lovely duet!!! A
Amira and Alma... I would like to say how it makes me happy...😍from Brasil,🇧🇷🇧🇷with love 💕 🥰
What a combination of incredible talents! May your friendship never falter.
The could be a tour de force. It seems like they're really enjoying each other. God gifted girls.
Salsa boa
Ohhh how much I love Amira and Alma..
So lovely, so sweet... I hope to see you together again. From Brazil 🇧🇷🇧🇷💚💛 with love 💛🇧🇷
Lovely to see such talent in such young girls! Wow will enjoy them for a long time! Spectacular! We are in for a treat! Blessed are we!
Two young amazing talents that make the world undoubtably better. May both of you always shine your light on humanity.
Amira and Alma they both are really really great.they are the future.
I love every Amira's performance!
She an angel singing between us!!
One of my favorite composers (Alma Deutscher) and Amira one of the wonderful angelical voice in this world, I cry any time I heard Maria Callas singing Mio Bambino Cara, Amira produce the same wonderful effect. I hope I will be alive when Alma write her Symphonies, and Amira will sing the most beautiful Arias in this world.
And hopefully together!
es hermoso ver a pequeños talentos como ustedes , gracias por compartir con nosotros este vídeo tan hermoso saludos desde Chile
Wow! What a joy to watch and hear two young talents perform together. I really do think that those two girls have a very bright future ahead. In my humble opinion they could be a good duo, with Alma on the piano or violin and Amira singing opera they would work very well together. Heart-warming performance!
As a more recent update, in November 2021, 16 year old Alma stepped in and sang the role of Cinderella (in German), on 3 hours notice, after the singer who was supposed to do it tested positive for Corona . This last November, she conducted performances of the opera in San Jose, California (after earning a degree in conducting and spending the summer conducting concerts of Vienna's Strauss Cappele Orchestra)
What I'd really like to hear someday is another Alma/Amira collaboration with Amira singing the role of Cinderella!
I have been following the musical journey of both girls from the beginning, and I often thought how wonderful it would be if they could meet and collaborate. Therefore, I was pleasantly surprised to see this video come onto my screen. I have the feeling they will collaborate again over the years. They are both so talented!
¡Fantastic! A delight and happy success to music. Bravísimo!
Pure genius vs pure talent! Love them both :)
2 prodigies on the same stage.......WOW!!🌹🌹
Such confidence from 2 talented young girls.
Bellísimas!!!
Que talento!
Beautiful and adorable!
Mucho mejor Amira es un ángel 😇🙏
Its so nice to see you both... I love ❤️ 💕so cute..: from Brasil 🇧🇷 🇧🇷with love . Amira and Alma... 🥰😘😍
amazing, unbelievable talent. superstars in the making
Both sweet.... and so much talent. All grown up now forging their lives in music.
Adorably fun duet!
My Congratulations to the great small talents, make a good duo and I really would like to hear here in Lima - Peru.
Amira este un talent deosebit si o voce minunata.Mult succens incontinuare.
Charming music! Thank you.
this is natural for the human spirit, blessed with vitality and health.
Those two absolutely need to reunite.
how beautiful to see such a successful collaboration of such a young talents! Way to go, we will expect in future more music and singing from you too :)
Delightful collaboration **********+**********
I have both of these wonderful girl's album's And said that they should collaborate . Amira is amazing her voice brings me to tears each time I hear it . Alma music will make you smile cry all in one movement. Alma Amira I will try and see you both live this year.
Your wish came true!
Semplicemente meravigliose, anzi GRANDIOSE.
The dynamic duo in action. When they have fun, we all have fun! Wait till Amira takes Alma to a cross country running race.
Please God that you work together for many years as both are great together. Angel Talent ;-)
What we see here is what I stated a long time ago: Music knows no boundaries - here we have a little Dutch girl joining musical talents with a little British girl.
In the history of mankind, have there ever been such Wunderkinder ?
Yes, Mozart.
@@henkoosterink8744 Mozart was one wunderkind. And as far as I know, he wasn't much of a singer!
@@malcolmnorton2217 Mozart was a great pianist and composer, mot enough?
Henk Oosterink Chopin and Liszt were friends.
Para mí la música clásica y el bel canto son de las creaciones artísticas sublimes pero verlo en niños o niñas lo hacen plus ultra. congratulations wonderful girls.
Ouço Amira todos os dias.Maravilhosa!!!
Eu também! Que coincidencia! Ela é maravilhosa mesmo! Fico feliz em saber que tem gente que sabe
apreciar as coisas elevada da vida! Essa menina é um fenomeno da musica clássica! E não há outra
igual!
Luiz Carlos Guimarães Sim Luis,é muito bom saber de pessoas de bom gosto assim como vc. Um abraço e sigamos assim sempre fã de Amira Willighagen!!! Um abraço.
Just beautiful!
ohh there adorable and so talented...
What a talented Opera Kids!
Bravissimo💗
Me he dado cuenta que tanto André Riu y Alma, aportaron en el perfeccionamiento de Amira, bueno, por decirlo asi: le dieron unos buenos consejitos de vocalización y listo... el resultado: una diosa de la ópera, y estoy feliz por ella y por mí, porque no me canso de escucharla.
Exactly two are angels.
Amira no sólo es una de las mejores cantantes de estos tiempos, Amira es grande como persona, Amira tiene talento, arte, humildad, corazón, no cambies nunca, porque la soberbia, la petulancia por más talento que haya no genera empatía, puedes tener mil habilidades pero sin humildad seras parte de un triste espectáculo como persona. Tu no eres así, eres lindísima para ser tan pequeña. Soy a partir de hoy tu fan oficial.
Merry Christmas, Amira!
La considero una voz de otro mundo fantástica y carismática, Dios quiera que conserve esta voz por muchos años para deleite de todos nosotros, muchas felicidades y mucho éxito para ti.
Ame o Brasil Ele é peça importante no cenário mundial. acredite voçes não vão gostar dele deixar deexistir. EU SONHO COM UMA INTERNET BRASILEIRA. ESPERO UM DIA NÃO PRECISAR SABER
INGLES PARA VER INTERNET
Only use 1 hour rehearsal, not easy for Amira , Alma is composer, she know very well about Melody, very interesting opera Cinderella stepsisters song! Both cute in act!
Two of the bestest.
check out the new version of this performed in the UK about 3 months ago.
No link?
RIP Sir Roger Moore. He made this happen.
Is that the truth...?
Hello Happy birthday Amira hope you have a very happy day.
Alma is anticipating that Amira will sing her music in the future.
Because Amira is the greatest potential female opera singer in the world.
And she knows this.
This little girl is very VERY smart and can become anything she likes.
But since she likes music most she will not become the future PM of Britain or Israel.
Perhaps Amira would like to be a stepsister in San Jose this year as Alma conducts Cinderella.
Amira just graduated high school as Valedictorian.
It reminds me of Deeana Durbin and Judy Garland when they sang together in their 1937 movie Every Sunday. They were both 14 (a little older than these 2 geniuses)
Wonderful performance
You are the bést, congratulations
Милые девочки и поют божественно.
Almira, from watching a few videos of you singing - you have amazing classical potential. Leave pop to those who can't, or don't want to, do better. Looking forward to seeing/hearing more opera from you.
Her latest, playing in Salzburg, features an opera girl and a guitar guy, not to mention a non melodic creep. Musical rather than opera.
AMIRA, ERES LA NINA MAS ADORABLE DE TODO EL MUNDO. SIGUE ASI. TE VEREMOS EN UNOS ANOS CONVERTIDA EN UNA DE LAS GRANDES. UN ABRAZO DE ANO NUEVO.
Bravo! São incríveis, parabéns!
...são elas, as incríveis crianças que estão chegando, que podem salvar este planeta...acreditem nelas...
Obrigado por este presente de NATAL AMIRA & ALMA.....peço que cantem o "DUETO DAS FLORES"
Beautiful. I doubt if Alma could write an ugly, grotesque piece even if she tried. I feel they are both unsuited for the part, for neither of them can be called ugly - indeed they are both quite pretty.
Now, how do these two mini-divas get on with each other?
+Curlytop1955 they are two Big friends right now.
Neither of them is a 'diva'. They are both very modest actually. They wear their greatness very lightly. That's what makes them so lovable.
When asked about it recently Alma said that Amira stayed at her house and that they took mattresses to the treehouse and had a sleepover. When asked if they would be friends she said "We are already!" and told the story of the sleepover. They have very different demeanors but I hope they keep the friendship going as they clearly belong together creating the most beautiful music the world has ever heard.
Actually the original definition of diva is that of someone supremely gifted or a "divine one". So to call them divas is a compliment. Unfortunately the usage over time has come to have a different negative meaning as well and it is that meaning that most people think of.
Prima donna is also a compliment to a singer but that word has come to have a different meaning as well.
Well, listen to the traffic jam at the beginning of Siren Sounds Waltz.
Are they coming from England? They're really great and wonderful. When I see them, I see 2 grilfriends out the time of Jane Austen.
Me encanta esta pequeña gran mujer alguien podría traducirme las canciones en español .de antemano gracias.
More of Cinderella - Duet with Amira: ruclips.net/video/8zNEomxmUPQ/видео.html#t=21 :
Then watch everything else Amira has done !
Fantásticas❤
Ik ben normaal geen fan van opera, logisch met mijn leeftijd, maar dit vind ik echt prachtig❤❤❤❤❤
Linda um anjo. Fenomenal
Has no one noticed? The first stanza of the Ugly Stepsisters Duet is based on the Act 1 trio of the Three Ladies in the Magic Flute. It's as if she has omitted the Mozartean curlicues and left the bare bones of the music in her duet. I'm sure this is unconscious. Alma's part is original and has no derivation from the Mozart. But the opening that Amira sings is clearly based on the opening trio of the Magic Flute.
I don't see it....Mozart's trio is far more complex .. though Alma's duet is wonderfully accessible and with it's diminished 7th "marry's him I'll die"
@@hugobodiam4065 The trio is complex, but I mean the first of the three ladies music. I hear it perfectly.
Genial....
¡Wow!
I wish the sound quality was better.
There is another performance recording, seen on you tube, not sure it's still available, but the sound was far better.
Wauw, het klikt...
Alma begint een beetje Emily Bear (aug 2001 USA) achterna te gaan met haar muzikale talent en het componeren. (professioneel componist met 4 en professioneel concert pianist met 5 jaar)
Voor wie nog nooit van Emily Bear heeft gehoord is hier een voorbeeld van haar.
ruclips.net/video/Y-xbPlBqoOg/видео.html
Emily Bear performed two miles away from my home and I didn’t find out until two months later. Hope she comes back.
Crazy girls..)) ,but I like it..)) Together good team..))
me gusta pero me encanta también xD
What happened to Alma's voice? In a duet with Amirа she will always lose. No offense, Alma.
That is an awfully mean thing to say. Both young ladies are brilliant.
tommy lee xhando
No need to be rude!
Donald Freeman - take easy donald duck
Words written by me not to insult Alma. These are the words of indignation. Alma is a very talented child, she really can not hear the dissonance? I see Alma simple and it has a sore throat, then why sing? Amirа could easily sing itself. I do not understand your indignation. Such objectivity.
Товарищ Кошкина
Amira may sing better than Alma but they are not competing with each other, so no one loses. It is a duet and they are singing together, not against one another.
Reading the description you will find, Alma is not normally a singer, though she does sing.
This performance is a special treat for the people in the audience from both girls and was not a normal part of the performance. It is purely for enjoyment, not for competition, nor with the intent of being critiqued, simply for the fun of performing being fun, for the audience, the performers themselves and their patron, Sir Roger Moore.
Being that they are both so accomplished at such a young age, they garner the entitlement to include an additional performance with amusement and pleasure. I am one to believe that they are entitled to have any fun they wish together as they are only children. Keeping in mind, most children their age are not doing such things that they do.
I can't be sure what lilianwriter is bothered by, but I would assume it was your saying "In a duet with Amirа she will always lose." This happens to come off as a bit snide, and as a duet is not a competition, but rather, a musical composition for two performers in which the performers have equal importance to the piece, it is uncalled for and unbefitting to even bring up in such a way. Though, it would be more proper a statement if you had said "In a singing competition against Amira, Alma will always lose."
I believe you also are mistaking your words meanings, as objective is unbiased and subjective is biased. Their indignation is more than likely stemmed from your lack of tact in your comment, brought on presumably, only through a misunderstanding of the words you are using. To be sure, I may be wrong, as your original comment that was replied to has been edited since, and so I am only able to glean information from what now remains there to be seen.
In all probability, English is, to all appearances, not your native tongue, in which case, your comment is excusable.
I've just one more thing to bring to your attention. You seem to imply Amira could perform this perfectly fine by herself, and while she may be able to sing all of the words in the proper pitch, timing, etc.. this is a duet, it requires both voices to complete this piece, as there are two distinct characters written. If she were to perform it herself, it would be more suitable for a tale of one person with dissociative identity disorder.
9 years old?????
At 2:07 Amira made a funny face to someone in the audience lol. Sorry but I feel Alma`s voice and composition were hideous. She may be gifted, but today the gift was a lump of coal.
milestoneman You realize that she is acting right? It's an opera, she is acting the part of the stepsister who believes she is better than the other.
They don't realize anything otherwise they wouldn't have posted what they did. I love reading the comments of the under-bridge. They throw such lovely lumps of dung I wonder why they continue living in it.
@@kvercher12 I wouldn'n have given her that much credence. thick I'd say. There is a better version of this, in every way. Not sure it's still on You Tube. this looks to be off the cuff, as in a private party, but unrehearst. and badly recorded
mira steekt haar tong uit als dat andere meisje begint te zingen! Hahhahahahahahhahaha!!!!
Si Alma était la réincarnation de Mozart, Amira serait celle de Haydn.
Amira makes even Paul Potts look like a lesser talent, so it's very brave of Alma to sing with her, but she probably should stick to composition.
Definitely. Alma was screeching today. Listen to it again. The performance was a mess.
Crusader1815 Alma has a nice voice, but it’s not her ballpark.
She sang as Cinderella in Salzburg in German when the star was suddenly ill.
Keine Duet !!
Je bent te goed voor dit meisje waardoor haar stem gewoon en goedkoop klinkt.
Laat je niet verlagen door mensen die mee willen liften op jouw succes.
Moest wel lachen om je gebaar toen zij begon te zingen. Dus je weet dat zij niet jou kaliber heeft. hahahaha componeren en zingen zijn twee verschillende dingen.
피아노치는애목소리거슬림
Amira looks bored.I can undrestant. Alma sings so wrong.
Pascale looks bored. I can understand. He comments so wrong.