All we miss Syb, but with Syb, David probably never joined to the band and the band will be other band that we have know . I don’t know (and nobody) if it will be better or worst, but for sure different.
It's funny you say that because I come here once inna while when I feel like my dad is with me again god I miss that man never have i connected with a person so much as with my dad he bought me my first stereo I just wish I didn't get his stereo so god damn soon wish you were here grant my dad my friend my brother my inspiration to keep on moving
@@rickyjiggens2180 Wow I am so moved by your story and how music conntected and still connects you and your dad. I only wish you the greatest things in life. And I am sure that your dad was a great man who loved you more than anything ❤️
Pink Floyd AND Stephane Grappelli, fantastic. I saw Grappelli at a concert in the Opera House St Hellier, Jersey on my birthday in 1977, what a fantastic gig. Happy days.
Pink Floyd =85% of my tee shirts Lol I grew up with my dad playing this music and I have him to thank because without pink Floyd I would have never picked up a guitar
Most people ignore this but it is the great Stéphane Grappelli that plays the violin on this version. He was recording in another studio close by and the band ask him if he would play on that song. He accepted but the band finally decided for another version of the song.
If they had used this version on the album it wouldn't have been "wish you were here" anymore, it would have been "violin song" by ~ Pink Grappelli Waters definitely did not want to share the spotlight (and royalties ) on what was probably their best song. Grappelli takes it to another level.
@harryh.2464 It's always Waters' fault huh?, the reason they didn't use this version is due to the violin being muted. They didn't realize until years later that it's buried really low under the mix.
Was it also he who played violin on SOYCD? I remember reading an interview where one of the band said they had a small violin part near the beginning but later nearly completely mixed it out so it's just audible.
Claro que existe, lo sabrás cuando sientas que puede acabar tu patetica vida, no preguntes porque lo se, me he dado cuenta por tu patetico comentario. Puedes negarlo, pero cuando llegue ese dia espero para tu alivio no estes sordo.
arturo meza hahahah wow ... tu dios te dijo que fueras tan agresivo, al oído ? Quien te hizo tanto daño como para venir a comentar algo tan incoherente, con con una de las canciones más emblemáticas de la música como testigo. Estás dañado amigo ...
wait, this is a version of a Pink Floyd song I've never heard . . . that's impossible, that's not possible! What's going on?! Where the hell am I?!!! MY ENTIRE LIFE IS A LIE!!!
Give "Trader's Den" and "DimeaDozen" a Google - those two sites have been around for years. Users on there share some really good bootlegs and outtakes. If you are a music fan you will in love with music you never knew existed.
to my cousin who passed from an overdose, you’re in a better place and i’m glad you no longer spend the nights out in the cold and dangerous streets. i miss you so much. wish you were here.
Dark Side I was in Jr. High in the early 70's, graduated HS in '77. I still talk about those days, they were special, unique, an 'easier' time (even with the Vietnam war raging on--the draft lottery on tv at night) and full of amazing music. The Floyd was the soundtrack to my life. Their music brings out every emotion there is. No other band comes close! 💖 Pink Floyd 💜
So you think you can tell Heaven from hell? Blue skies from pain? Can you tell a green field From a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell? Did they get you to trade Your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange A walk on part in the war For a lead role in a cage? How I wish, how I wish you were here We're just two lost souls Swimming in a fish bowl Year after year Running over the same old ground What have we found? The same old fears Wish you were here
Little did I know it at the time, but I grew up in the best years of Rock and Roll. Pink Floyd... Rolling Stones... Led Zepplan.. so many more, too many to name here. Each song brings back so many good memories.. Still love them all.
Why is it 40 plus year old tracks still getting hits , yet more recent stuff none for 2 or 3 years ? .... no answer needed really . Better music in every way
Any version Pink Floyd does is great. You don't see talented musicians who can play and have deep meaningful lyrics anymore. Passion is what made them so great!!!!
The visuals of the camera panning left and right and a lot of other excerpts are from the film Live at Pompeii. It shows them recording some of Darkside of the Moon at Abby Road Studios as well.
This is fantastic. I always felt incomplete when the album version finished because it was too damned short. To have a song reach you so deeply yet not allow you the time to let the feelings wash over you was a crime. This version let's it sink in and gives you the time to experience the emotions it stirs.
La simplicidad de esta cancion y su armonia la hacen la mejor cancion de los ultimos 100 años... Dedicada a su compañero que se quedo en las nubes despues de ingerir acido es profundo....
One thing to listen to this incredible version, I never knew existed (I’m 40 yo), and the other is much elevated experience to watch, listen, while reading the comments. RIP Syd RIP Rick Long live this culture and the love that drives a god-level music.
I think this version would have been nearly as memorable BUT the version they went with is more simple, more harsh in its solitude and that is the effect that I think they were after. The Violin actually gives it too much life, for me at least.
I absolutely agree. The power of this song stands in the fact that it’s raw, it’s direct and simple. As if someone suddenly took the guitar and started singing his sorrow, pouring the words directly from his heart, without filters.
I am 62 and I have goose bumps running down my legs-I have been listening to this song for 45 yrs and today I hear an alternative version with a violin!! (And thanks for this version in time for my 63rd birthday ♥) We never thought great, new music would ever stop coming out _every single week!_ Now, we exist with autotune, ProTools, sampling and FREE concerts, tutorials and FREE music. >sigh< Cheers, from Toronto ☮
@@ayeyobossman6151 you misunderstand dude. He isn't complaining, he is being amazed in an appreciative way cos back then nothing was free. Main thing is we all love this magic. Peace out from Ireland Bro. 🤒
This has long been my favorite Pink Floyd song. Now ya pop this version on me. I’m blown away, the violin does so much to enhance it,it’s amazing. Thank you so much. God bless
Lucky you that you were born at that time. I was born in 1999 and seriously I hate today's music and love Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin and more of 70s music. I wish that I was born in 50s
Love Pink Floyd , this was one of the first songs I learned how to play on guitar , I will always cherish this song , when I was in a dark place This song helped me out , for the better
I have loved this song since it came out when I was a small child. Naturally a song this sad was difficult to hear at times. (For all of us)! As a child - It was about my dad. Divorce blows. As a teenager - It was so romantic! Good old teenage angst. (I'm gonna die! I haven't seen him in 3 days! Is he mad at me)? Age 26 - Why can't we spend more time together? (When we met my husband worked 6 days a week. I only saw him on Sundays for years. But they were damn good Sundays)! Age 54 - My husband passed away in 2019. Just now is the first time I've actually been able to listen to the whole song without having to turn it off. It wasn't easy, but at least now I have my song back again. 🥲 Thank you for the memories... #pinkfloyd😘
What a gift to have heard a violen solo tk wish you were here from the original sessions. It's still the same feel. You can tell . it caught the same magic as the original. What a diamond that record was. Pierces deep. Love it.
No song will never compare to this one we all have lost someone or something we all have been alone at least once we have got pain more than once and the need to have someone next to us heals like nothing else This song connects with someone and something love everyone
Its funny when I was a kid I had no idea who syd was. And now that im older I understand the pain of not having some or your favorite ppl around. Cherish every moment. Good and bad. It's a sick,and crazy world and no one can truly live it alone. Cherish your soul mates even if they're friends they are still bound to your soul,and memory. Nothing is an accident we are meant to connect/reconnect with old loved ones from past existences Life is truly strange. Stay up!
The violinist was Stéphane Grappelli, an excellent jazz musician. He recorded in the adjacent studio in the same time as Floyd recorded this song and he was invited to play with the band. The judgement/reception of this version by the band members was mixed so this is why you can not hear the violin clearly on the "official" version.
Awesome! Great version of my favourite song from my favourite Pink Floyd LP, their last real collaborative effort. Great after four plus decades to finally hear Stephane Grappelli's "country fiddle" playing, as it's pretty much buried in the mix on the 1975 LP track.
To my shame, I heard this version for the first time. I liked it! It has the right to exist, as well as any creation of these great musicians. I love them!!!
![Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cWGE9Gi0bB0/mqdefault.jpg)
One thing is certain. The United Kingdom pumps out some of the best musicians ever.
Couldn't agree with you more brother
60s British Invasion is best invasion ever.
Luis Barrera they produced and still producing the best artists ever. Of course by artist I don’t mean signer, big difference between the two
The UK does everything ace, compared to the yanks who constantly pump shit out
At least we don't add useless consonants to our words
I wish Syd was here.
R.I.P. Syd.
R.I.P. Rick.
jaba borg shit yes! Rip:(
Let's keep this Pink Floyd RIP list as short as possible for a very long time. Long live nick David and Roger!
MCline93 what about nick lmao
All we miss Syb, but with Syb, David probably never joined to the band and the band will be other band that we have know .
I don’t know (and nobody) if it will be better or worst, but for sure different.
Arturo Hernández Martínez thank you my thoughts exactly , I like syd and all but David gave them their sound that everybody recognizes and loves
For my brother. Robbed of his brilliance by schizophrenia. Rest in immortality, Ron.
Larry McCauley and yk LSD
Who is ron?
Krisco Dangus his brother
Hear..hear...
💕🌠
To my brother I lost from cancer. Wish you were here 💕
RIP
Floyd and Zeppelin un comparable to any other bands.will listen forever!!!
And Deep Purple And Rainbow And Dio And Black Sabbath
and queen
Floyd, no Zeppelin
@@ГамзатГрозный Zeppelin and Floyd
Agree
This long hair, this smilin faces, how was a good time
L' Altra Musica if we could only go back in time!
I miss this time...
This awful english..❤️
I think that's the best version that I've ever heard
Was a god* time
This is magic... pure MAGIC!! No other band can touch your soul like Pink Floyd can... truly the greatest band ever.
Artha Potdar no.. The Beatles is...
Amazing pink Floyd for ever
Artha Potdar you're 100% right
Truth!!
Rizaldy Chaniago lol. Beatles.
This version is like an old friend I come back to once in a while and we pick up where we left off.
It's funny you say that because I come here once inna while when I feel like my dad is with me again god I miss that man never have i connected with a person so much as with my dad he bought me my first stereo I just wish I didn't get his stereo so god damn soon wish you were here grant my dad my friend my brother my inspiration to keep on moving
Brings tears to my eyes while the whole time I can't stop smiling .
@@rickyjiggens2180 Wow I am so moved by your story and how music conntected and still connects you and your dad. I only wish you the greatest things in life. And I am sure that your dad was a great man who loved you more than anything ❤️
Well it has me crying remembering old friends who are gone wish you were hear
Pink Floyd AND Stephane Grappelli, fantastic. I saw Grappelli at a concert in the Opera House St Hellier, Jersey on my birthday in 1977, what a fantastic gig. Happy days.
My brother Bobby turned me on to Pink Floyd when I was 8 years old after bringing home the album "Ummagumma".
I wish you were here brother.
🤗
❤
Abnormal Toy?
That David Gilmour is one divine looking individual.
GILMOUR. Can you not read or spell?
swinetrek thank you for helping me. I am gong to fix it for you now. I am sorry.
Now he looks like a potato.
Johan Jimenez yeah, I'm a hypocrite.
@@swinetrek Gylmoore
I want to see the documentary movie pink floyd like a queen bohemian rapsody
it would be very interesting
Adam driver as roger obviously
I kinda don't. You know they'll make Roger the hero or villain of the story. No in-betweens.
Roku channel has a pink floyd documentary
@@MrLCGO thats true
Pink Floyd =85% of my tee shirts Lol
I grew up with my dad playing this music and I have him to thank because without pink Floyd I would have never picked up a guitar
Linkarion1243 21 pink floyd equals 85% of my posters
@@shreddykrueger2408 Pink Floyd makes up 85% of my lost brain cells in my you youth
You're so lucky because you have great t-shirts
Same with me!:)
Oh wow
It’s like hearing it for the first time all over again
I wish , we ALL were here !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you Pink Floyd !
Stéphane Grappelli on the violin. Absolute legend.
I never cry, and I'm not exaggerating with that statement
So when I say that this made me tear up, it really means something
I love this band so much
The violin adds a loving touch. Shine on you beautiful diamond. Syd Barrett.
Most people ignore this but it is the great Stéphane Grappelli that plays the violin on this version. He was recording in another studio close by and the band ask him if he would play on that song. He accepted but the band finally decided for another version of the song.
If they had used this version on the album it wouldn't have been "wish you were here" anymore, it would have been "violin song" by
~ Pink Grappelli
Waters definitely did not want to share the spotlight (and royalties ) on what was probably their best song. Grappelli takes it to another level.
@harryh.2464 It's always Waters' fault huh?, the reason they didn't use this version is due to the violin being muted. They didn't realize until years later that it's buried really low under the mix.
Was it also he who played violin on SOYCD? I remember reading an interview where one of the band said they had a small violin part near the beginning but later nearly completely mixed it out so it's just audible.
@@alexbowman7582 What's SOYCD? Is this an abbreviation used by the younger dumber generation or something you've been smoking?
Young David Gilmour is my forever crush😍 such a babe
Crispy C ditto!
Rick was handsome too
Like a super model! God!! 😍😍
Those eyes n smile though 😍😍😍
And lips lol
The violin strengthens the sorrow. Any way , also a good version.
Eric An exactly
Yes, I feel like a violin and cello duet wouldve been a nice touch as well
It's a little fiddle and not a violin....from a comment made by John Hoot.
Eric An yes it does.
Eric An very good with violin. Shame we didnt catch sight of the violinist
Si Dios existe, el mejor regalo que le ha hecho a la humanidad en los últimos 50 años, se llama Pink Floyd.
Hugo Trejo Anaya totalmente de acuerdo contigo.
Hugo Trejo Anaya y a ti chiquito❤️
Hugo Trejo Anaya de hecho
Claro que existe, lo sabrás cuando sientas que puede acabar tu patetica vida, no preguntes porque lo se, me he dado cuenta por tu patetico comentario. Puedes negarlo, pero cuando llegue ese dia espero para tu alivio no estes sordo.
arturo meza hahahah wow ... tu dios te dijo que fueras tan agresivo, al oído ? Quien te hizo tanto daño como para venir a comentar algo tan incoherente, con con una de las canciones más emblemáticas de la música como testigo.
Estás dañado amigo ...
wait, this is a version of a Pink Floyd song I've never heard . . . that's impossible, that's not possible! What's going on?! Where the hell am I?!!! MY ENTIRE LIFE IS A LIE!!!
Rotor Hed if you dont know this version there's a lot of song you dont know of them lol
Me too. Is this recorded really in '70 or some kind of messing with original tapes + violin addition?
Same here
There are some amazing Floyd and other great bands outtakes in BitTorrent land.
Give "Trader's Den" and "DimeaDozen" a Google - those two sites have been around for years. Users on there share some really good bootlegs and outtakes. If you are a music fan you will in love with music you never knew existed.
to my cousin who passed from an overdose, you’re in a better place and i’m glad you no longer spend the nights out in the cold and dangerous streets. i miss you so much. wish you were here.
Sorry boo.
So sorry for your loss💜lost my youngest daughter due to an overdose 2 years ago- she loved this song- every time I hear this I think of her.
I’m sorry, man.
Sem palavras simplesmente maravilhoso.
o god take me to 70's. please
Dark Side
I was in Jr. High in the early 70's, graduated HS in '77. I still talk about those days, they were special, unique, an 'easier' time (even with the Vietnam war raging on--the draft lottery on tv at night) and full of amazing music. The Floyd was the soundtrack to my life. Their music brings out every emotion there is. No other band comes close!
💖 Pink Floyd 💜
Did it work?
Take me back to the 70’s being 20 years old again and drop me off on David Gilmour’s doorstep have mercy!
Oh yes I'm so with you!!!
@@leavebutdontleaveme59 I agree they in a class of their own, that being the highest.
So you think you can tell
Heaven from hell?
Blue skies from pain?
Can you tell a green field
From a cold steel rail?
A smile from a veil?
Do you think you can tell?
Did they get you to trade
Your heroes for ghosts?
Hot ashes for trees?
Hot air for a cool breeze?
Cold comfort for change?
Did you exchange
A walk on part in the war
For a lead role in a cage?
How I wish, how I wish you were here
We're just two lost souls
Swimming in a fish bowl
Year after year
Running over the same old ground
What have we found?
The same old fears
Wish you were here
Rogers waters,David gilmour,ricky wright as nick mason,powerfull combination,fantastic!
Sylvio Gonçalves don"t forget the gréât SYD please
RIP
Younes Khallad indeed
Pink Floyd, Queen, the Rolling Stones.....three of the greatest bands ever. Pretty hard to beat.
Little did I know it at the time, but I grew up in the best years of Rock and Roll. Pink Floyd... Rolling Stones... Led Zepplan.. so many more, too many to name here. Each song brings back so many good memories.. Still love them all.
Lucky son of a bitch
Uma obra prima, como disse um importante filosofo, '' A vida sem musica seria um erro'' Eu diria : Eu sem as musicas do Pink Floyd seria um erro.
Rodrigo Luís Pereira Nietzsche : )
I like this one! The violin sounds good, i used to like so much songs with violin.
David was so beautiful! wow
Wow what a handsome man!!!
Why is it 40 plus year old tracks still getting hits , yet more recent stuff none for 2 or 3 years ? .... no answer needed really . Better music in every way
Ser Geminiana David 💜💜💜 uhaauu!!!
Ser Geminiana yeah :( 💔 but he still beautiful, isn’t he ?
I would have been a baby mama for David Gilmour dammit but unfortunately I was just a child.
Oh, the days when all 4 of them collaborated. Best music ever!
Any version Pink Floyd does is great. You don't see talented musicians who can play and have deep meaningful lyrics anymore. Passion is what made them so great!!!!
Waou👌‼🔝👏👍✌🏼Awesome Version ☆☆☆☆☆
One of the best versions
Good job on the visuals, creates a lonely atmosphere.
Right in the feels
Stephan Grappelli is the session violin on this I believe
Matches my mood tonight.
The visuals of the camera panning left and right and a lot of other excerpts are from the film Live at Pompeii. It shows them recording some of Darkside of the Moon at Abby Road Studios as well.
Pink Floyd é surreal.
É inacreditável, coisa de outro mundo. 👏👏👏👏
É uma verdadeira reflexão sobre a vida.
This is fantastic. I always felt incomplete when the album version finished because it was too damned short. To have a song reach you so deeply yet not allow you the time to let the feelings wash over you was a crime. This version let's it sink in and gives you the time to experience the emotions it stirs.
Listening to this always reminds me of my father, a big Pink Floyd fan who sadly passed away 19 years ago. " Wish you were here ".
Clearly, the best song mankind has ever conceived.
Cry or no cry , THIS song has defined the rest of my earthly existence. ( now 55...) Bravo P.F.!!!! Athens rocks++++++
❤️❤️❤️
Estoy seguro que en otros planetas del universo amarían esto tambien. La mejor banda del universo.
Sin duda! Son inalcanzables
La simplicidad de esta cancion y su armonia la hacen la mejor cancion de los ultimos 100 años... Dedicada a su compañero que se quedo en las nubes despues de ingerir acido es profundo....
this video really makes me cry like a child
One thing to listen to this incredible version, I never knew existed (I’m 40 yo), and the other is much elevated experience to watch, listen, while reading the comments.
RIP Syd
RIP Rick
Long live this culture and the love that drives a god-level music.
"two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl year after year". That line always kills me. Seek inner peace and destroy samsara.
I think this version would have been nearly as memorable BUT the version they went with is more simple, more harsh in its solitude and that is the effect that I think they were after. The Violin actually gives it too much life, for me at least.
It's all about opioins
But just come back from Hyde park something special am 57 been a fan since in school
I don't like this one either.
I agree. Reminds me of when I heard a version of Always Look On The Bright Side done flawlessly which ironically took a lot away from the song
I absolutely agree. The power of this song stands in the fact that it’s raw, it’s direct and simple. As if someone suddenly took the guitar and started singing his sorrow, pouring the words directly from his heart, without filters.
My parents gave me a Pink Floyd album for my birthday and I have been fallen in love with this band since then ♥️♥️
I am 62 and I have goose bumps running down my legs-I have been listening to this song for 45 yrs and today I hear an alternative version with a violin!! (And thanks for this version in time for my 63rd birthday ♥)
We never thought great, new music would ever stop coming out _every single week!_
Now, we exist with autotune, ProTools, sampling and FREE concerts, tutorials and FREE music. >sigh<
Cheers, from Toronto ☮
whats wrong with it being free? weird thing to place emphasis on
I guess ayeyobossman is too young to remember when we had to pay for everything... there y'are now.🤒🤒🤒
@@JohnDoe-yn3eo but why is it a bad thing that musicians put music out for free?
@@ayeyobossman6151 you misunderstand dude. He isn't complaining, he is being amazed in an appreciative way cos back then nothing was free. Main thing is we all love this magic. Peace out from Ireland Bro. 🤒
@@JohnDoe-yn3eo no it definitely spund like he is complaining based on the fact he put in a list of bad things about modern music
Heard the song thousands of times but never saw this vid or this version Thumbs up
This version is so wonderful. So powerful. The violin adds to the magic - oh it's beautiful for the soul 💖
This has long been my favorite Pink Floyd song. Now ya pop this version on me. I’m blown away, the violin does so much to enhance it,it’s amazing.
Thank you so much. God bless
gracias pink floyd gracias por su tremendo aporte al mundo
Boy this one gets you right in the feels. Every single time.
estoy tan agradecida con mi tio por enseñarme su música y poder ahora sentirlo aún en cada canción.
This song makes my dad think about my grandpa who I never got to meet. He died two years before I was born.
Oh my God I love this version! Why the hell wasn't this ever on the album. It's amazing. I love the violin in this song.
Right that man... Really amazing
Musical Genius;s they were. I have loved Pink Floyd since 1969! Still my most favourite band and have every Album, in Vinyl.
Lucky you that you were born at that time. I was born in 1999 and seriously I hate today's music and love Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin and more of 70s music. I wish that I was born in 50s
Love Pink Floyd , this was one of the first songs I learned how to play on guitar , I will always cherish this song , when I was in a dark place This song helped me out , for the better
I have loved this song since it came out when I was a small child. Naturally a song this sad was difficult to hear at times. (For all of us)!
As a child - It was about my dad. Divorce blows.
As a teenager - It was so romantic! Good old teenage angst. (I'm gonna die! I haven't seen him in 3 days! Is he mad at me)?
Age 26 - Why can't we spend more time together? (When we met my husband worked 6 days a week. I only saw him on Sundays for years. But they were damn good Sundays)!
Age 54 - My husband passed away in 2019. Just now is the first time I've actually been able to listen to the whole song without having to turn it off. It wasn't easy, but at least now I have my song back again. 🥲
Thank you for the memories...
#pinkfloyd😘
What a gift to have heard a violen solo tk wish you were here from the original sessions. It's still the same feel. You can tell . it caught the same magic as the original. What a diamond that record was. Pierces deep. Love it.
No song will never compare to this one we all have lost someone or something we all have been alone at least once we have got pain more than once and the need to have someone next to us heals like nothing else This song connects with someone and something love everyone
The alternative versión is just amazing with that beautiful violin. Thanks.
I saw Pink Floyd live at the roundhouse many many years ago still my favourite band. This song will be be played when I die
Stephan Grappelli. Brilliant jazz violinist!
Cool. Is that true ? Suddenly i remember "gentle on my mind".
@@Don_Camillo It is absolutely true. There’s an interview with David and Roger who both confirm it!
Simplesmente salvaram-me de uma adolescência conturbada. Thanks a lot guys! C´est Magnifique!
Versão espetacular de uma música excepcional de uma banda eterna 👍🤟🇧🇷
I LOVE this version. I played the violin, maybe that's why
This is the only song I listen to when I want to think about the people that have left. Truly untouchable piece.
Si tu estuvieras aqui. Increible version, con los ojos cerrados. Alucine viendoles en 1988 Vicente Calderon. Viva Pink Floyd
Its funny when I was a kid I had no idea who syd was. And now that im older I understand the pain of not having some or your favorite ppl around. Cherish every moment. Good and bad. It's a sick,and crazy world and no one can truly live it alone. Cherish your soul mates even if they're friends they are still bound to your soul,and memory. Nothing is an accident we are meant to connect/reconnect with old loved ones from past existences
Life is truly strange. Stay up!
Roger & David both voice
Roger lyrics
David guitar riffs
Combine these 2 and u get some really good fucking shit.
Primo
Love this! The violin or fiddle, almost gives the song a ‘Waterboys’ sound
Gracias por compartir buena Música Saludos
It's been two years since my mom passed away. I use to be able to listen to this song without out falling apart.
Love this version ... and may I add wow was David Gilmore gorgeous
And so is his guitar playing
The violinist was Stéphane Grappelli, an excellent jazz musician. He recorded in the adjacent studio in the same time as Floyd recorded this song and he was invited to play with the band. The judgement/reception of this version by the band members was mixed so this is why you can not hear the violin clearly on the "official" version.
Maravilhosa inspiração! Nao poderia existir melhor.
Nigel Planter simm
Awesome! Great version of my favourite song from my favourite Pink Floyd LP, their last real collaborative effort. Great after four plus decades to finally hear Stephane Grappelli's "country fiddle" playing, as it's pretty much buried in the mix on the 1975 LP track.
Very nice and memorable song ever
Thanks for posting. Long time Floyd fan and have never heard this version. Amazing!
Holy crap. A violin? Interesting to hear this version. Prefer the one that made it on to the record but still great to hear this.
Not heard this version before. I think it stands well alongside the original. Adds another dimension to a great song
Love the emphasis on the strings towards the end of this really good version of an iconic track.
Esta versión con el violín es espectacular.Son unos genios.David Gilmour es guapísimo!!!😍
En la versión que quedó, con unos buenos auriculares se puede escuchar el violín al final
Damn you mason you're making me hungry
Mr33223322 "No crust please"
Mr33223322 didn't smoke for a long while and rich made me wanna smoke lol
Sad news is that he died from Cancer... I dont know if from the cigarette but, from cancer after he smoke his entire life.
stop saying that he's not dead at all it was just rumors
Danaé Saby Rick Wright died in 08... let the legend rest in peace
I'm glad they ultimately stuck with the album version.
It's official; This is my favorite version and should have made it on the album.
How has this gem not shown in my recommended before? Listening in 2019!
To my shame, I heard this version for the first time. I liked it! It has the right to exist, as well as any creation of these great musicians. I love them!!!
Wish you where here Dad and Brother... Godspeed to Eternity
Amo esta versión 😍
Love that Abbey Road was where they recorded and used in this video.
Sublime and perfect. This song always speaks to me.
Undoubtedly skillful musicians. Thank you guys!
Adoro essa música. ❤ muitas lembranças
This makes me sad. Rick is gone, Syd is gone... I miss them and I didn't even know them personally...
Omg, Roger Waters and David Gilmour smiling.........
RIGHT?!?!
Thanks for this version. I'm a fan of Pink Floyd but I hadn't heard it. After more than 40 years of publication, I still like it. Old School 4 Ever!
Definitiva e indudablemente, esto es placer puro para los oidos...😌👏 Gracias por dejarnos este legado PINK FLOYD!