Ryobi P238 vs NEW Ryobi HP (Impact Drivers)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024
- I thank you for checking out this video, Im just your average guy having Fun with tools. I test tools out to see what these tools can do, and what they can't do. Please Subscribe to the channel and get that tool fix here. Have a great day!
As someone who upgraded from ryobi to Milwaukee the one thing I miss is that magnetic tray. Was always nice to drop a handful of whatever I was driving onto that tray, or when taking something apart it is nice to put the hardware on it instead of pockets or the floor. I wish other manufactures would adopt that. I think there are aftermarket solutions for this but it’s nice when it built into the tool
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I work off ladders a ton and can confirm, the magnetic tray is the best feature
I just bought the P258 from direct tools for $53.00 bucks. For me it is still an upgrade.
I’ve never tried to drive a 10 inch lag. So for my needs thinking I’m go to go.
Great comparison video.
I got both of them and my newer on have the hp prongs but I love the older one because of the magnetic and bit holder. Plus I don’t a the 3 speed adjustments on my newer model.
Just wanted to say I signed up to your channel after it being recommended for a ryobi tool I was looking for. Your honest product reviews with 0bs hype just facts is what I like about you and your channel ... thank you for the content and keep up the great work
I thank you for viewing :)
the magnet is one thing that the old Ryobi tools had that I love
Do you miss the belt clip
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@@ManCaverTools no problem man
@@jamesomara8036 You just have to get your own clip. The hole is there for it.
I think the issue with the adapters is they haven't caught up with the increased power and increased frequency of impacts the newer impact drivers have. They need to increase the strength of the adapters to match the power of newer impact drivers.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Thanks for the comparison of these 2 brushless brothers. I got in a bind last week and had to go grab 1/2"drive impact and I grabbed the P262 after seeing your evaluation and couple other's, I felt it had all the balls needed for the particular job, and it smacked that axle nut loose in less than 2.5sec. I know I could've gotten the high torque for roughly $30.00 bucks more, but new mid torque is no slouch. It'll remove Simi lug-nuts without breaking a sweat, but I wouldn't normally ever use it that way. Just happy as hell it worked out.
in most cases the mid range will take care of most tasks so good choice
Wow I'm impressed. That's the first test of one of the HP tools that I've been really impressed by.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I'm kind of late but knowing you were up early for this, warms my heart
I’ve had the p238 for years. Even though I switched to Milwaukee when I started side hustling, I still have it and use it on my personal vehicles. If it had a 3/8 or 1/2 freak style anvil it’d be a perfect diy mechanics tool.
Another great video. Try using the Husky impact bits without the torsion zones. They should hold up longer.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Great video! I’ve noticed those adapters breaking a lot also. I believe the guy who does “Shop tool reviews” said he used the regular Husky brand from Home Depot. He said they were cheaper and withstood more punishment. Try them out. I know Milwaukee can’t be cheap brother. Thanks for the video!
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@@ManCaverTools i would try getting a cheap adapter and put 10 different kinds of epoxy putty over it like project farms. I'm sure it won't ever break
Picked this up with the hammer drill back when they started showing up at HD. Had about 14 beams (a few triple beamed) to drill through and a bunch of 3” nails to run in some electrical, and figured it’d be the perfect time to run the new impact. After about 7 holes, the metal casing was super hot to the point I let it cool of for about 20 minutes, and it was still hot
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Tbf a impact was never designed to drill through anything let alone steel beams
I had purchased a Ryobi brushed impact and drill driver set nearly a decade ago and they have taken a beating and I actually gave them to a guy who worked with me a while back. They were well work the money.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Let me get this straight - the HP driver doesn't have the extra HP battery connectors, but the non-HP one has the extra connectors for the HP battery ... Makes perfect sense Ryobi, thanks.
The Torque channel sent me. Keep up the content!!
Cheers
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I'm definitely thinking that the old HP connectors are a non-issue on the new tools. They probably figured a way to get the full pull of the battery without them.
Magnetic tray holds metal slivers very well so you can forget it and jam slivers in your fingers. I won't miss it. 👍👍
I wish they release one with the tri beam hp impact driver I like the old brushless but I love the new ho impact driver that has three speed with the assist mode the assist mode is awesome to use I just wish the impact has the tri beam lights.
Any way you can include model numbers of the tools/batteries in the video descriptions? Really helps out, especially with, like you said, the crazy model numbers tool companies are using nowadays. Look at a Bosch tool model number and try to figure out which tool is the newer/better version, near impossible, lol. Same with Milwaukee, and now apparently Ryobi is doing it. Then they have the "kit model numbers" which is where is give up and go to Harbor Freight treat my depression, lol
Bosch i thought had the answer to that problem but bought a freak the chuck broke first day. Would barely hold socket on and the 1/4 quick connect wouldn't hold a bit
We love the P238 and the Tri-LED. I don’t think I need that max power. Also I don’t like the metal front especially if it falls or slips onto you work ark areas. Plus with all these new drill coming out I can get the P238 at amazing prices.
Next time your in Home Depot try the Husky brand adapters you'll be surprised.
I already did, they lasted 2 episodes
@@ManCaverTools yep
I would recommend the DeWalt adapter
Surprised at how shit they are?
@@VacMaster2020 i twisted mine like a pretzel with lug nuts on a 80s ranger lol, also wait a minute I know you.
So I am a 5 year electrician and honestly digging the new ryobi stuff. I am thinking about switching from dewalt I would like your thoughts.
I’m not an electrician so I don’t know if it will cross over but I’m a garage door service tech and the guy how trained me did exactly that swapped his dewault for ryobi
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I'd do it, although I'd still keep a few batteries around for the new cable stapler
Very impressed with the new HP, Dave. It’s probably safe to say that Ryobi used some of the internal components of the M18 Gen 3 when they designed the new HP impact.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
What's the size difference between the compact driver and the PBLCK01K?
Was the P238 switch set at #3 like the Hp one was? Just doesn't make sense that if the P238 has a higher torque rating and higher rpm capabilities that it would perform slower unless the switch setting wasn't at #3
Hi, I'm curious if I don't need a hp battery for my HP impact driver since it doesn't need or have those HP prongs?
you can use any Ryobi battery on them. HP doesnt require HP to use them
I’ve heard that the DeWalt Max Impact adapters are pretty much the best ones in terms of strength, if you pick up a couple of them you should be set
Gedore
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Have you tried the HUSKY brand? I hear they purdy guud
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Impact drivers are not designed for lag bolts. I use my impact wrench for that. Of course if you want to lesson the life of your impact driver, use it for whatever you want.
Wow the new one puts the old one to shame. It's a pity they lost things like the tri light
I do thank you so much for viewing :)
Two things about adapters, look at the size of the bolt that it drives. Second, the fact is that the tools are making more power now. They do have to make stronger bit's for the increase in power. Of course they will cost more!
The magnetic tray is what keeps me using the p238 over the hp model
Me too!
Facts bro. Either way i have no problems with it it does everything i need and i out it through some hardcore stuff daily
Impact drivers should just have a combination 1/2" anvil with a 1/4" collet, like on the Bosch GDX.
But they'd probably have to license it from Bosch, and that would add cost. Instead they can just sell you adaptors that break easily, or another tool, which adds profit instead.
Just put a 1/4 collet adapter on the anvil.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
yoo kimo made a new brushless impact driver and im seriously considering it, do you mind if you do a review on it?
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Is the light automatic? For the tribeam? Mine for some reason doesnt turn on.
I would love to watch how both the HP impact drivers do against each other. I look forward to seeing how the other batteries compare too
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
you should use washer on the lag bolts to prevent them from sinking into the wood to much
I do thank you so much for viewing :)
have you tried the dewalt 1/2 solid shank adapter? runs around 8 bucks at tractor supply and with stained the most abuse on projectfarm's video.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
But it's still 1/4 inch at the end
Great review apples to apples and answered my question, glad i have the new hp and compact hp
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Just got a P238 which was discounted at HD for $59. Does battery Ah size contribute to driver power? Confusing with all the battery options.
Yes it does, normally for most tools I'd use a 4AH or bigger 2AH at the minimum
Is it possible to compare ryobi with any of the big boys ?
those videos wil becoming up
I want see if it is possible you can take the 3/8 in anvil off the imp t wrench and exchange it with the 1/4 in hex on the dewalt and see if the 3/8 in anvil is better on the dcf887. Just like what Dave did with the Milwaukee impact driver
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
supposable the huskey adapters work wonders
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I'm curious that since the new HP impact driver doesn't have the extra HP connection, would the regular battery perform the same as the HP battery?
more tests will be coming in the future on it
Do you think they are good for changing rotors on a sedan ?
that depends if you can fit the tool into the space
They need to start making impact adapters better. Have you tried dewalt adapters?
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
They should of kept the 3 lights on the front of the drill. It's way better. It gives you the light EXACTLY where you need it. They should of kept the magnet tray as well. Why change something when it works perfectly smh.
Probably because the oem body is just some Chinese company pumping out frames from multiple company’s. Random guess. I’m sad about it too.
Lol love the man caver tools Einstein driver from torque test channel
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Great video once again :) REAL TEST :) FLEX 24v vs M18GEN3 I CANT WAIT
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
The magnet always got full of rust chunks and random grinding dust and the bit holder fell out in 6 days lmao.
Can these impact drills drive a nut 1-5/8
I'm upset with Ryobi they could've atleast left the bit holder, and not even a belt clip, all of the old drill models even have them. Another thing im upset with Ryobi is with their super charger. They should make one that can charge all the batteries at one time. Other brands have them and it's so sweet. I know if Ryobi did the demand would be very great
They just made a new super charger, and it work just the same as the old one 👎
@@cerealkiller4341 there's not really much of an upside to that cause what if you're working on a project that involves multiple tools or drills that drain battery power fast. Ryobi can do it it's not rocket science
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Try the hf ones... I saw a test that the low end HF Warrior one work well. I think project farm...
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
I use husky adapters there tough I love my p238 impact driver
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
The Impact Driver is no designed to perform the tasks of an Impact Wrench. I wish that people would just learn and take heed to the phrase, THE RIGHT TOOL FOR THE RIGHT JOB.
Great vid man
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
So the actual HP impact doesn't have the HP contacts? Weird
Next year we will get a update with half the things we want so they can sell more then another year and half we will get what we want but it'll be to late.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Do you think this new impact driver is the toughest of them all as of right now? I feel like it can go head to head with Milwaukee and the new flex !
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@@ManCaverTools YOU keep it real with us and show us true results thank you !
You use only one hand and on the handle of the driver. Actually the way most will. BUT by doing this you are not pushing straight down, but are putting a bending force on the adapter. If you want to not break so many adapters then when using high downward force put the palm of your hand on the body of the impact wrench. Your technique is what is breaking the adapters. Some people could break an anvil.
I don’t know if I got a good batch of what but I have a set of the ryobi adapters and I can’t seem to be able to break the things.
I do thank you so much for viewing :)
Great video, Dave. Rip to those adapters.
I thank you for viewing :)
Awesome vid. The new dewalt flexvolt batteries do have 21700 cells.
I thank you for viewing :)
why the hell are they getting rid of bit holders
do you have a vid on haw you made that Milwaukee
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Really like your channel right here is good
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Ryobi needs to put a 3/8 anvil in that thing and call it an impact wrench
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Hey @mancavertools maybe you could help settle some rumors/ theories. Ive heard at least 4 times from 4 different people at 4 different places that the Milwaukee and Dewalt power tools sold at The Home Depot and/or Lowes are different, quality wise. Meaning that the ones bought from big box stores contain parts not built to the manufacturer's usual quality standards. Is this true??? Can you do a video clarifying this conspiracy theory???
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
The same model tools are all the same no matter where you buy it. HD and Lowes sell 2 different DeWalt drills the 998 power detect and HD has the 999 Advantage
You should use dewalt adapters they are much thicker and can withstand more torque
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Doesn't Bosch make a changeable anvil line?
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
What do you do for a living?
im a security officer as a full time job. this video is very old
less than a minute into the video..... do you really think that they are making adapters cheaper?, or do you think its an issue of the tools keep geting better and stronger?
I thank you for viewing :)
Have you ever tried malco bits
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Love their flip-bits!
They should make impact drivers less powerful so they dont make the adapters crapout! lol 😂
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@@ManCaverTools yessir
Tim from Canada you should not be worried about the speed of the RYOBI TOOLS I only watch the show to see if these cheep RYOBI TOOLS CAN DO THE JOB Most of the time the answer is no
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
No more magnet???
The dewalt adapters are the strongest. Shockwave or anything that removes metal is not the way to go.
Bosch makes impact driver/wrench
👍👍👍.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@2:04 THAT WHAT SHE SAID 🤗
lol
those adapters will never be strong be realistic it's a 1/4 inch shaft you can only put so much torque on it and it will snap thats like making a house out of toothpicks and then complaining that it blew away with a gust of wind smfh
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
But then You forget the drill and impact drivers used to be less powerful.
I do thank you so much for viewing :)
eh? for a dyi homeowner, upgrade when it breaks -- no need to chase the best unless you are a pro ....
You having a flex watch party ?
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Those adapters are such a horrible design because why put a thin spot in it?
You’re making an intentional weakest link. The ones that have the 1/4 hex as the thinnest part just seem to be better and making the hex shank thicker is impossible without completely changing the product. I have some by neiko and they seem more substantial
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Top
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
🤩🍩☕☕😊
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Husky adapters bro!!!!!
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
a new toy is coming out called flex from chervon 2 beat and b better than the big boys like Dw Mw, mkta, bsch, ridgid, hlty, metabo (htp).
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Yeah it’s called a bosh freak
I never seen a stupid test. this tools are not designed to drive a big bolt. is common sense. if I drive a big bolt ill use the impact for tires.
Удивительно, как один и тот же бренд в США может считаться годным и востребованным, а в России - мусорным. Вот как это возможно?
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
@@ManCaverTools you are welcome
Put some respeck on Ryobi name
Gedore impact sockets
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Totally not an equal comparison... aside from that... why would even post a comparison where the other tools fail.... waste of time...
All these companies are good for is power tools all the separate bits and shit are trash
Theyre just too noisy
Try the ryobi chuck it won't break