I just love how aespa lead vocalist and main vocalist blend so well, in black mamba and forever bridge. Winter and Ningning has that "Bada voice" but ningning is like the bada of today's generation. Stop shocking me winter on ur vocal! I can't wait for more! Aespa fighting!
They make it look so easy. Especially Ningning and Winter. The surprise here though is Giselle and Karina, who knew they also could sing that well. They are all amazing vocalists. With great tones. SM signature here. They never fail.
i see a lot of people are saying they don’t like this song and isn’t as good as black mamba, but aren’t aware that this isn’t an official comeback song, it’s only a remake that shows off their vocals :))
Ningning's voice is so matured for a rookie. IDK but sometimes she's sounds like BADA from S.E.S I also notice that on her SYNK teaser. And Winter sometimes like BOA, maybe I still have a hang-over from her cover on MAMA last year haha
NingNing looks so gorgeous and i still can't believe Karina's voice is that beautiful Giselle's live vocal is unbelieveable and Winter is just so beautiful
@Toxic Positivity Yes sure, VMA is everything matters in life. No VMA no opinion 💅🏻 even a president don't matter cause they own zero of that damn thing. Even world leaders is unimportant 😭😢
MYs please always be humble. We are still a small fandom but we already experience lot of things just to protect this 4 precious girls! Stop the nonsense fanwar and just stream! Being the main vocalist does not mean she get the most lines! This is just a cover not official comeback! More comeback in the future, so more lines to come for Ningning so please just support four of them.
Ning Ning is the lead vocalist and got lines according to her position. I don't really see the problem. The line distribution of Forever is as perfect as a line distribution could be.
they can all become a soloist. SM did a good job selecting such good vocalists and debuting together. their lineup reminds me of SNSD's four main vocalists. good luck with their good future. they deserve a good and successful career.
SNSD only have 2 main vocalist Taeyeon and Jessica. The 3 lead vocal is Seohyun, Tiffany and Sunny. 5 vocalist but the dancer line (Hyo, Sooyoung, Yuri and Yoona) can sing pretty well too
@@miloisbaeee exactlyy. We wont be able to see a GG like SNSD anymore, they are on a whole new level. What kind of girl groups with more than 7 members have this many main vocal calibre singers in one group ? None. No hate here, Twice is the closest thing to SNSD for being a 9 members + super high popularity girl group, but their vocal line is not even 50% of SNSD's.
@@jasons4045 no need to compare. but 9muses have nice vocal line too (Sera, Hyemi, Hyuna, Kyungri and Sung) and they have Min ah as the visual and 3 rappers.
@@jasons4045 no need to compare. but 9muses have nice vocal line too (Sera, Hyemi, Hyuna, Kyungri and Sung) and they have Min ah as the visual and 3 rappers.
I love how Giselle got more lines, and her black hair like Ugh gorgeous queen go off. Edit: omg 800 of Giselle's gf are present ;D !! Keep supporting our queen
this performance is another proof as to why sm has the best vocalists. even tho karina and giselle are sub-vocals, they can sing. and i mean, sing really good. aespa vocal queens indeed!
right?? and karina & giselle’s singing isn’t anything average or below average, they’re REALLY REALLY good vocalists. they could all have a successful vocal solo career
@@ghostaround8977 the fact that giselle is the main rapper, and karina is the lead rapper and main dancer.. u know its mean the 4th generation has found out their all rounded group!
The fact that Giselle is main rapper, Karina is main dancer, and their vocals are so good. They could easily be lead vocalists in any other group. Love you Aespa❤️
@@ivyloey4019 no need to throw hate. I agree that toxic positivity was being REALLY rude, but let’s not throw hate ok? I love both groups, so let’s just not spread toxicity
@@jenniestaronhiatus505 it's the truth though. We all know YG artists are good at rap, so Aespa could never rap like BP but in term of vocals Aespa are way ahead of BP
You can't deny that SM don't disappoint people with their artists especially when it comes to vocals. They can sing in live and you won't notice a difference or changes.
karina is so pretty, i dont know why people is hating on her. i saw some comments who called giselle fat. excuse me, are you blind? she's so healty and pretty at the same time. she is a main rapper and her vocals... winter's visual is killing me for sure. her voice tho. and lastly, ningning... her voice is like an angel. she is so cute at the same time. stan karina, winter, ningning and giselle. stan aespa for a better life people
No way Giselle is fat! Her body has a very beautiful feminine silhouette.I mean,she has all the right forms in all the right places, which makes her look skinny and healthy at the same time ♡
Actually no, the outfits are really tacky and they look like any other gg, their stylist really need to step up or something, the outfits have been a mess since debut. And if you wanna know how a gg with luxury aura looks like, go watch any BLACKPINK video 😉
A lot of Kpop idols are beautiful but aespa is not just visuals that’s what makes them special ! EACH member carries their own weight and prove why they got the debut spot :D
the highest compliment i can accord to Aespa is that they are the most talented SME group in terms of well-balanced vocal ability in all members since TVXQ5..
ningning's vocal is the best and she looks so gorgeous. karina's voice is so amazing. giselle is literally their hidden main vocalist and winter slayed this with her beautiful vocals.
They came to stay! We weren’t ready for such Angelic angel vocals! I’m so proud of these girls :’) I will Stan them until the end of time!!! aespa have confirmed! They’re the evolution :D
Winter, a perfect main vocal quality and outstanding dancer with the best visual and strong stage presence. How can she blessed with such talent for a baby chick?
NingNing has idols looks but she has her Chinese essence of beauty as well and it not only looks like chinese but her make up looks like it will go well in any country especially like her eyeliner has wings most if times at the end which is famous in India and pak I think. And her vocals are one of my favourite
This is my favorite song of Aespa so far because it expresses or show off their own vocal skills to us, not only they can rap and dance! Aespa is a talented girl group that they are all in one, they can do everything… ❤💖🥰🤧😭
@ot4gang queen only. wth, even if u support the girls you shouldn't downgrade TWICE. Coming from a multistan😌 If ur gonna be like this, ur not welcome in this fandom
I know that we all have biases in aespa but let's not drag other members just to praise our biases, Let's not be just a solo-stan MYs. In the future , aespa will have an established name in the industry,I just hope MYs won't fight on each other,bash the other member just to praise their biases. I hope that won't happen 😔 Let's support AESPA as a group not just a solo stan. They deserved their respective positions in the group, SM didn't choose them if they aren't deserving. All of the members deserve recognition, we may have each other's biases but let's not forget to support them as a group 🥰
you can't force someone to stan the whole group if they are stanning 1 or 2 of the members though. we all have different likes and preferences. just saying
Ningning stage presence is no joke although when she's not at the center. Her facial expression is always on point. Her vocals doesn't need any further explanation. Excellence!
What makes winter's voice so special is that she have that 'cutesy' and cheery sound like most gg singer have, but in the same time her vocal is strong and can pull of adlibs and sing high notes easily. Kudos to sm for helping in polishing her skill for this type of voice
After listening a thousand times, I can confidently say Ningning definitely is the main vocalist. Her runs and riffs are solid and her voice is supported. I can't wait for her to grow more as a singer, she's definitely got a good future ahead if she continues to practice and improve her vocals.
Yes. This song if you hear for a few times and you can recognise that NingNing is main vocal, because all the hard part she handle it and she is very stable among them. The 'forever' part she sing with more round and stable note compare with other. The turning notes she hits after the first chorus u think in this performance were better and perfect compare with the official music ones, she already has that singer feels, she is only 18 years old and has many times to improve look forward to her!
Ngl, her voice is sooo good omg🥺 oh and i don't know much about vocal technique, can you explain to me about the "her voice is supported" ? I don't understand what it means :(
Seriously I think we should appreciate whatever things that aespa provide to us right now. Since the pandemic is not over yet, and we haven’t meet our girls so I guess our girls really tried the best to give us many new contents 💙💜
Giselle suits this concept so well. Her smile in this song looks really kind and sweet in a natural way and her moves looks so graceful (I don't know if this is the right word). Everyone was talking about her hair, but I think without black hair she still can be attractive in this song.
@yoo jiminator i know your karina biased and me too but that doesn't mean you should hate on others. As far as i see she has one of the best stage presence in aespa.
How can karina sings and dances like that.... not fair.... she is really confidence in both singing and dancing... even the little moves and gestures... man i'm proud, AESPA THE BEST
@ot4gang queen only. YOU FREID CHICKEN STOP STARTING A FANWAR THIS NINTH TIME I'M SEEING YOUR COMMENTS STOP HATING TWICE AND STOP BRINGING OTHER GROUP AND YOUR TYPING HATE COMMENTS ON EVERYONE'S COMMENT YOUR JUST A GIRL WHO HAS A WHOLE DAMN DAY TO HATE OTHER GROUP
I was surprised first at how good Giselle and Karina's vocals are so good, them being the rap and dance line, but discovered Giselle was an alto in a choir for many years and Karina was also part of a choir, she studied song and piano. This group is made of very talented members. But again why be surprised, SM's only standard is excellence.
This is not a comeback, this is actually a game, a game called "guess who's the main vocalist?".
the main vocalist is aespa
Agree!
This is actually not their comeback
It's actually not a comeback, it's a cover
@@jenniesmandu7404ikr
When Boa said aespa can do everything she didn't lie.
When did she say that
@@blackpunk374 on her radio interview sometime ago
SM Entertainment are always alrounder.
aespa is a K-Pop girl group with the best vocals in generation 4.
wheres the lie?!
them and purple kiss (mamamoo sister group that will debut soon) are super good
chef's kiss.
@@agassetiamulya5358 That's right, in fact all AESPA members are main vocalists
@@tmmoonlight78 Yes, I also follow purple kisses, but I think aespa's vocals stand out more than purple kisses
This is not a comeback, SM just wants to flex aespa vocal
Yup,as SM idols vocals are *no joke*
this is joke or true?
@@muizz8312 both lol
exactly
And Flex they did....I am completely blown away!!! Their vocal abilities are beyond the imagination!!
I just love how aespa lead vocalist and main vocalist blend so well, in black mamba and forever bridge. Winter and Ningning has that "Bada voice" but ningning is like the bada of today's generation. Stop shocking me winter on ur vocal! I can't wait for more! Aespa fighting!
Yess, its like no gap between the main and lead vocal...
Yess truee
@jnnyy if im not mistaken she got trained by both taeyeon & wendy :)
@jnnyy That's not true, Wendy said in January at a Vlive that she met Aespa the first time after their debut.
@@sofialalala5159 Sunday, Lina, Jae, and Jinyoung are the only former SM idols who actively train their trainees.
Forever with aespa
emoji delete pls
@@Mia-vr4hv why?
@ot4gang queen only. no way in hell
@@ksnfile it freeze views , thats why .
@ot4gang queen only. troll.. pls stop spamming under aespa vids
FACT: All of æspa's members are main vocalists
And all of them are main dancer
@@bluesky-nt5fv and visuals ✨
@@memauria_1364 yeah all of them are visual. Total package group
Co-buddies Stan Aespa! Right now!
SPILL
Ningning's voice is so unique.
Sweet but strong
Cute but powerful.
Her voice is perfect for SM main vocal.
They make it look so easy. Especially Ningning and Winter. The surprise here though is Giselle and Karina, who knew they also could sing that well. They are all amazing vocalists. With great tones. SM signature here. They never fail.
winter’s voice is like winter season personified 🥺❄️
Winter’s vocal tone is so addictive
Yass true. I cant stop replaying her part
Karina's beauty is so different, swear I'm straight girl but I can't take off my eyes of her
why saying that you're straight as if liking girls is something bad?
No one cares of you are straight
@Toxic Positivity go away blonk
@@Chatshirre no one cares if you're lgbt either
@@user-jh4zz4up6f let her comment what she want
Winter is just too pretty, plus her insane soothing and soft vocals melts my heart.
i see a lot of people are saying they don’t like this song and isn’t as good as black mamba, but aren’t aware that this isn’t an official comeback song, it’s only a remake that shows off their vocals :))
because its lipsync lol
@@minothemapohipster608 lipsync or not they're still the ones singing so?
Who said that..?
omg they are tasteless fr
Why are they so pressed about lip syncing? Like duh? It's still their own voice? Be mad when it's not theirs lol pffft
Ningning's voice is so matured for a rookie. IDK but sometimes she's sounds like BADA from S.E.S I also notice that on her SYNK teaser. And Winter sometimes like BOA, maybe I still have a hang-over from her cover on MAMA last year haha
Bada and ningning sound alike cuz of the headynnes of their mix and their habit of letting it out too much.
What does a rookie sound?
my thoughts exactly
Yess
Lacking the voice like Taeyeon 😭 If there are new members, hopefully the voice is similar to Taeyeon
SM debuts girl groups with less girls each time, truly means they select the best of the best
Winter's vocal really suits how she looks though, sweet and gentle.
Ikr!!
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
Ikr, I love her voice so much
Let's not waste our time to those trolls
Yesss, winter wrecked me a lot
NingNing looks so gorgeous and i still can't believe Karina's voice is that beautiful
Giselle's live vocal is unbelieveable and Winter is just so beautiful
she's so talented
@@user-bv3of1ss9y what the hell is that
Guys don’t click the link
@@joanajaynegardiola9218 you’re right report this person
This song is cute
Giselle: Main vocalist
Ning Ning: Main vocalist
Winter: Main vocalist
Karina: Main vocalist
Valid!
Karina😍
Yess true
Yass
Yes!
Ningning puts in great effort to learn Korean and she articulates the language so well.
True i always forget she's actually not korean
I know that she is not Korean first time
GISELLE MY GIRL
THOSE VOCALS ARE EVERYTHING she's the real deal totally complete
Giselleee my baby deserve it
This song not only show us their vocal talents, they show us aespa is alllrounder for any genre.
@Toxic Positivity Yes sure, VMA is everything matters in life. No VMA no opinion 💅🏻 even a president don't matter cause they own zero of that damn thing. Even world leaders is unimportant 😭😢
@Toxic Positivity why tf they need some irrelevant white awards to prove their talents 😳😳
MYs please always be humble. We are still a small fandom but we already experience lot of things just to protect this 4 precious girls! Stop the nonsense fanwar and just stream! Being the main vocalist does not mean she get the most lines! This is just a cover not official comeback! More comeback in the future, so more lines to come for Ningning so please just support four of them.
Let's make this top comment! Have a good day everyone:)
Those hate comments aren't Mys, they are just spamming
up!!!
Ning Ning is the lead vocalist and got lines according to her position. I don't really see the problem. The line distribution of Forever is as perfect as a line distribution could be.
@@newthings1137 Ning ning is the main vocal
Ningning looks so elegantly beautiful. She looks super cute with this hairstyle.
they can all become a soloist. SM did a good job selecting such good vocalists and debuting together. their lineup reminds me of SNSD's four main vocalists. good luck with their good future. they deserve a good and successful career.
SNSD only have 2 main vocalist Taeyeon and Jessica. The 3 lead vocal is Seohyun, Tiffany and Sunny. 5 vocalist but the dancer line (Hyo, Sooyoung, Yuri and Yoona) can sing pretty well too
Yes that's what I thought earlier. The 4/5 vocal line of SNSD. A legit complete packaged group
@@miloisbaeee exactlyy. We wont be able to see a GG like SNSD anymore, they are on a whole new level. What kind of girl groups with more than 7 members have this many main vocal calibre singers in one group ? None.
No hate here, Twice is the closest thing to SNSD for being a 9 members + super high popularity girl group, but their vocal line is not even 50% of SNSD's.
@@jasons4045 no need to compare. but 9muses have nice vocal line too (Sera, Hyemi, Hyuna, Kyungri and Sung) and they have Min ah as the visual and 3 rappers.
@@jasons4045 no need to compare. but 9muses have nice vocal line too (Sera, Hyemi, Hyuna, Kyungri and Sung) and they have Min ah as the visual and 3 rappers.
Winter's vocals never failed to amaze me. She has this angelic, soft and beautiful voice indeed. SM's hidden ace.
Yes best voice because the cutest
Winter's voice gives me chills every time 💘
Yes all Right
Finally there are some MY who loves winter vocals.her vocals is so sweet and lovely.for me her vocals is the best
We love her! Thats all that matter . The first time i heard her voice im hooked! She rose to the top of my bias list
I love how Giselle got more lines, and her black hair like Ugh gorgeous queen go off.
Edit: omg 800 of Giselle's gf are present ;D !! Keep supporting our queen
period
Yesssss
Yesss
She's hidden card
SM 팝 강렬하게 가다가, 이런 분위기 발라드 한곡씩 내는 거 되게 좋아요.
🌪️🌬️🐲🪐💟🔹🕶️📨🏹🏹🏹🔹🖋️💈🖋️🖋️📦⛩️👕
맞아요ㅠㅠ 너무 좋아요💖💖💖
인정인정
진짜 너무 좋아요❤
"so who's the main vocalist?"
: all of them. periodt.
U not lyin'
All of them except Karina. Her voice is so bad
@@vino4346 and here comes the trolls🙋♀️
@@vino4346 not as bad as your life exactly
i really love karina's voice. rapping and singing. she's just so unique and one in a million. i love her
Her vocal tone is so unique. ♡
My one and only baby.
She is my dumb as well as pretty and good bias
YESS ME TO
Same
interviewer: OKAY SO WHO’S THE MAIN VOCALIST?
aespa: AESPA
@ot4gang queen only. stop and fu*king go away
@ot4gang queen only. shut up please don't be toxic
@ot4gang queen only. stop dragging other group. thats toxic
@ot4gang queen only. Stop making us look toxic. Leave
Agree!!
Can't stop adoring Karina because you know..she has it all
this performance is another proof as to why sm has the best vocalists. even tho karina and giselle are sub-vocals, they can sing. and i mean, sing really good. aespa vocal queens indeed!
right?? and karina & giselle’s singing isn’t anything average or below average, they’re REALLY REALLY good vocalists. they could all have a successful vocal solo career
@@ghostaround8977 the fact that giselle is the main rapper, and karina is the lead rapper and main dancer.. u know its mean the 4th generation has found out their all rounded group!
This group is the new generation of Grace where all the members are not only sing but SING
The fact that Giselle is main rapper, Karina is main dancer, and their vocals are so good. They could easily be lead vocalists in any other group.
Love you Aespa❤️
@Toxic Positivity Lol don't clown yourself. We have ears, Rose can't even sang like Aespa's lead vocalist.
@@ivyloey4019 well duh that's only because their under SM
@@ivyloey4019 no need to throw hate. I agree that toxic positivity was being REALLY rude, but let’s not throw hate ok? I love both groups, so let’s just not spread toxicity
@@jenniestaronhiatus505 it's the truth though. We all know YG artists are good at rap, so Aespa could never rap like BP but in term of vocals Aespa are way ahead of BP
@@ivyloey4019 I know. I love both, but yeah nobody stands a chance against Sm artists
Waw Karina's voice in this live is so cool 😭
Life is so unfair how can she can rap, dance, sing and her visual is amazing
Yeahh. I love her so much
That's why Karina is my bias I love her voice everything about her, stan aespa
Same cuz she’s my ideal girl , and i love everything i see about her
*"Who is your bias?"*
*Who sings the best*
*"All of them is best at singing'*
*Exactly*
Who is yours bias ?
Forever Winter
Forever ningning
Ning ning
Winter
ALL MEMBERS!
They were born to be a start. NingNing is a popular name in the Philippines it means shine. Just like the stars in the sky NingNing shines brightly.
Hi! My nickname is Ningning. Noong nag-trend si Ningning sa twitter, tinanong ako ng ate ko ng, "Ning, bakit ka nagte-trend?" DUH!?😂
@@nagiilusyon HAHAHAAHAHAH yayay hi co Pinoy my HAHHAHAHAH
@@erismisfit6397 😁😁😁 Hello! Proud of the girls!
Memories aaaahh
You can't deny that SM don't disappoint people with their artists especially when it comes to vocals. They can sing in live and you won't notice a difference or changes.
Yes, because there's no difference i love them even more.
Forever Giselle💕
They sang live here and we did not notice 😭
I'm so in love with Giselle's tone and deeper vocal colour, she's amazing
Saammmeee from BM I loved it, her and Karina lower vocal tones 🥰
karina is so pretty, i dont know why people is hating on her. i saw some comments who called giselle fat. excuse me, are you blind? she's so healty and pretty at the same time. she is a main rapper and her vocals... winter's visual is killing me for sure. her voice tho. and lastly, ningning... her voice is like an angel. she is so cute at the same time. stan karina, winter, ningning and giselle. stan aespa for a better life people
It's just that the other members are way thinner than her but she's no way close to being fat
No way Giselle is fat! Her body has a very beautiful feminine silhouette.I mean,she has all the right forms in all the right places, which makes her look skinny and healthy at the same time ♡
you guys are definitely right! giselle is not fat, its just the other members being thinner then her. stan giselle
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
Winter and blackpink Rose's voice is the sweetest voice i've ever heard from K-Pop industry 😩❤️
i have never seen an idol as perfect as Karina before she look like she came straight out of heaven
Exactly
ruclips.net/video/GQLyHKeUshs/видео.html
😙😙😙😙😙😙
Ningning is more beautiful tbh
@@whathappened1756 she is beautiful too but make ur own comment then?
@@whathappened1756 your opinion but like can't you just let people praise Karina damnnn
Don't they all look like Chaebols?? They exude elegance and Royalty. Literally the aura I could see from every SM artists.
Yes! They look elegant and sophisticated
Yes! They look elegant and sophisticated
ikrr, i feel that too
I mean- give all SM artist a t-shirt and they would still look sophisticated and elegant as ever.
Actually no, the outfits are really tacky and they look like any other gg, their stylist really need to step up or something, the outfits have been a mess since debut. And if you wanna know how a gg with luxury aura looks like, go watch any BLACKPINK video 😉
A lot of Kpop idols are beautiful but aespa is not just visuals that’s what makes them special ! EACH member carries their own weight and prove why they got the debut spot :D
Just our Maknae Ningning showing that she's a sunbaenim trainee among the members. Look how talented this girl was.
She is... I'm agree with youu
this’s proof to haters about their vocal isn’t joke
lmao they're literally lip-syncing
@@xuxi2443 it doesn't change the fact they have good vocals though
@@xuxi2443 yes they lipsync but they really sing. It’s their voice without autotune.
@@bilalahmed8171 yes
@@xuxi2443 when did they lipsync here? Or are you deaf to hear that they are not lipsyncing
Giselle and Karina are really multitalented, they can dance well, sing great, and rapp very well
Let's talk about Giselle i can't see enough of her vocals in black mamba but this song proves her vocals. A hidden gem.
Yes. Giselle is the ACE
@@dayanarodriguez4621 yasss
@dream if im not mistaken, you're new to aespa right?
@dream karina is the brown hair,giselle is the dark brown hair, winter is the blonde hair, ningning is the black hair but her hair is tied
@dream i know,i couldn't find a bias 😂
the highest compliment i can accord to Aespa is that they are the most talented SME group in terms of well-balanced vocal ability in all members since TVXQ5..
ningning's vocal is the best and she looks so gorgeous. karina's voice is so amazing. giselle is literally their hidden main vocalist and winter slayed this with her beautiful vocals.
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
They came to stay! We weren’t ready for such Angelic angel vocals! I’m so proud of these girls :’) I will Stan them until the end of time!!! aespa have confirmed! They’re the evolution :D
I’m being serious tho, this set looks more gorgeous than the set in MV.
Yes
And the clothes
since they want to present winter vibe they did the snow set up
@@JP-wl7nj yes, I want to talk about their outfits as well.
Giselle being a main rapper but serving those vocals 👏
Winter's my ultimate bias but i never knew Ningning also was this beautiful
Yea i agree winning is my bias too
The visuals, vocals, and everything else is perfect.
GISELLE SAYING "MAH BABY" WILL FOREVER BE ICONIC
Winter is so pretty and her vocal just not kidding.
She ate the CD
Anyway aespa Fighting！！
Ikr!! I love her voice so much
Yes fact only
@yoo jiminator can you just shut up 💀 solo stans are the worst istg
Ikr
@@dxnhills That akgae is always coming at Winter related comment. The nerve.
Pretty and talented Winter 🥰
Giselle really be wrecking everyone just because she's change her hair colour the power she holds
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
BLACK HAIR GISELLE IS SUPERIOR
Yasssh. She's a Queen!!!
Her vocals !!! I just can’t speak even karina( I was speaking about giselle coz everyone is speaking about Karina so I thought I should come forward).
it suits her so well UwU
Winter looks like a doll. She’s so gorgeous.
Indeed
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html🤐
Yeahh, she's so so gorgeous
Winter is stealing my 💘
AESPA AND TREASURE FLOP HAHAHAHA 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩🤮🤮🤮🤮💩🤮🤮💩🤮
SM has the best vocalists in every generation no doubt.
Not just vocals, it has the best in every standard
facts! visual, also talents too! also entertaiment
periodt
Winter, a perfect main vocal quality and outstanding dancer with the best visual and strong stage presence. How can she blessed with such talent for a baby chick?
They said nobody's perfect. Then there's Winter proving people wrong 😋
Indeed ✍️
Aespa's visuals and vocals are no joke
as expected for SM artists
NingNing has idols looks but she has her Chinese essence of beauty as well and it not only looks like chinese but her make up looks like it will go well in any country especially like her eyeliner has wings most if times at the end which is famous in India and pak I think. And her vocals are one of my favourite
yess ningning vocal very amazing...
She did so well
Yes her vocal just so different very unique, love it.
ruclips.net/video/GQLyHKeUshs/видео.html
😚😚😚😚😚
@@Momo7jo someday wish can to hear her solo in future...
go shinning ningning ❤❤❤
This is my favorite song of Aespa so far because it expresses or show off their own vocal skills to us, not only they can rap and dance! Aespa is a talented girl group that they are all in one, they can do everything… ❤💖🥰🤧😭
Karina is a real-life angel that heals people’s hearts😭
ruclips.net/video/GQLyHKeUshs/видео.html
😭😭😭😭😭
🤮🤮🤮🤮
She's a goddess
aespa forever!!!
@ot4gang queen only. pls go away
@ot4gang queen only. shut up and go away
@ot4gang queen only. wth, even if u support the girls you shouldn't downgrade TWICE. Coming from a multistan😌 If ur gonna be like this, ur not welcome in this fandom
@ot4gang queen only. leave
@ot4gang queen only. This the second time imma Kick your _________ your gone mad your just a toxic fan give respect and take respect
I know that we all have biases in aespa but let's not drag other members just to praise our biases, Let's not be just a solo-stan MYs. In the future , aespa will have an established name in the industry,I just hope MYs won't fight on each other,bash the other member just to praise their biases. I hope that won't happen 😔 Let's support AESPA as a group not just a solo stan. They deserved their respective positions in the group, SM didn't choose them if they aren't deserving. All of the members deserve recognition, we may have each other's biases but let's not forget to support them as a group 🥰
Yess all of 'em deserve all the love
you can't force someone to stan the whole group if they are stanning 1 or 2 of the members though. we all have different likes and preferences. just saying
@@jamesrholdanpiedad2171 if that's the case then no prob,just don't drag the other members just to uplift their biases 🤗
if there are toxic solo stans, that means they're not MY's
Up
Winter is the best SINGER of this GROUP ❤❤
This slap anyone who said they can't sing live
Edit: ok so it wasn't live but their prerecorded vocals sounds heavenly✨
they just don't want to admit it
Slap online😄
They are chosen by SM. So shouldn't be even questioned lmao 😁
It's not live
@@GoneGirl-pw4iv You can literally hear them breathing.
@@GoneGirl-pw4iv lol its live, you can hear the breath, haters always saying sm artist aren't singing live lmao
Ningning stage presence is no joke although when she's not at the center. Her facial expression is always on point. Her vocals doesn't need any further explanation. Excellence!
AGREE
Facts only ❤️
@@errric I don't think so, I like these two bands. I do not blame you for this, because I do not know what is happening to you. Good luck.
@@errric u can compliment a group w/o bringing down the others. such a negative life u have
@@errric both of them better than you bish
What makes winter's voice so special is that she have that 'cutesy' and cheery sound like most gg singer have, but in the same time her vocal is strong and can pull of adlibs and sing high notes easily. Kudos to sm for helping in polishing her skill for this type of voice
You said it way better than anyone could! I'm literally speechless. She's really amazing!! 💘
My firt stan girl group😍😍
Karina with that hairstyle , with that dress , and skirt is AWESOME
After listening a thousand times, I can confidently say Ningning definitely is the main vocalist. Her runs and riffs are solid and her voice is supported. I can't wait for her to grow more as a singer, she's definitely got a good future ahead if she continues to practice and improve her vocals.
And to mention she's only 18 yrs old
Yes. This song if you hear for a few times and you can recognise that NingNing is main vocal, because all the hard part she handle it and she is very stable among them. The 'forever' part she sing with more round and stable note compare with other. The turning notes she hits after the first chorus u think in this performance were better and perfect compare with the official music ones, she already has that singer feels, she is only 18 years old and has many times to improve look forward to her!
She's 18? I thought she's 20+
@J yes! You are right!
Ngl, her voice is sooo good omg🥺 oh and i don't know much about vocal technique, can you explain to me about the "her voice is supported" ? I don't understand what it means :(
Seriously I think we should appreciate whatever things that aespa provide to us right now. Since the pandemic is not over yet, and we haven’t meet our girls so I guess our girls really tried the best to give us many new contents 💙💜
Winter & Karina 's voice is so beautiful.
i didn't saw many coments about giselle's vocals, SHES A QUEEN PERIODT
Lol literally most of people praising her
That's every where tho and she deserves it
That's true🔥
Bruh everyone is praising her
And she deserves it
Yaazzzz, indeed!! No doubtt
Giselle suits this concept so well. Her smile in this song looks really kind and sweet in a natural way and her moves looks so graceful (I don't know if this is the right word). Everyone was talking about her hair, but I think without black hair she still can be attractive in this song.
im with youuu! note it every1 'without black hair she still can be attractive in this song'. we stan talents
She has a really calm and chill aura about her like I can't explain but yes it really suits her
Agree. She's really attractive tho even before
INDEED!!!!
ÆSPA doesn't realize this, but they are making everyone's day better.
Yaa
That's so true
@ot4gang queen only. Wdym😐🤨
wherever i go, i see this comment -,-
@@messymagulo same
Even there’s not so many shoots on Ningning, her voice still caught me.
Winter's vocal is no joke
Yes..she pretty too
Yes.
Yeah!! She's my bias
Yes
Winter’s stage presence is insane, she doesn’t look like a rookie. I can’t wait for actress Winter soon.
Yeah we have karina as a actress . Waiting for winter but i wish they don't have real kiss scene cause i will be jealous. Even though i am a girl. :))
YASS
@yoo jiminator stfu
@yoo jiminator i know your karina biased and me too but that doesn't mean you should hate on others. As far as i see she has one of the best stage presence in aespa.
And Giselle will make her debut acting first
This song made me fall in love with Karina’s voice even more omg
same!!
Me too omg 😭😭😭
Same 😍😍
다너무귀엽다ㅠ 다들미모뭐야진짜ㅋ 어이없어서웃음만나오네.. 윈터야개이쁘다 선녀니? 자꾸그렇게이뻐지면 내심장책임져
OK, but Ningning with this outfit looks like IU when she was dancing and singing with ITZY 🤩
For real that’s what I thought
How can karina sings and dances like that.... not fair.... she is really confidence in both singing and dancing... even the little moves and gestures... man i'm proud, AESPA THE BEST
Her singing is not that good
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle but atleast she can do it
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle So as your Jihyo.
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle she slayed it, dont be jealous and chill 😝
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle troll acc mind your own faves.
aespa proving to everyone that they're all amazing vocals.
@ot4gang queen only. YOU FREID CHICKEN STOP STARTING A FANWAR THIS NINTH TIME I'M SEEING YOUR COMMENTS STOP HATING TWICE AND STOP BRINGING OTHER GROUP AND YOUR TYPING HATE COMMENTS ON EVERYONE'S COMMENT YOUR JUST A GIRL WHO HAS A WHOLE DAMN DAY TO HATE OTHER GROUP
That was a beautiful song I've Ever been
Ningning's main vocalist colours are showing...and she's so pretty 🥺
At this point, dragging aespa's vocals are just like asking for a public humiliation.
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
aespa and treasure >>>>>>>>enhypen
stay salty 😩
I love Giselle
I see no lies here
@@scottobryan1018 no need to bring other groups down tho, the people that hate on aespa are just dumb
I was surprised first at how good Giselle and Karina's vocals are so good, them being the rap and dance line, but discovered Giselle was an alto in a choir for many years and Karina was also part of a choir, she studied song and piano. This group is made of very talented members. But again why be surprised, SM's only standard is excellence.
I don't know about other countries but for my country(US) NingNing is a beauty Queen.
Popular opinion: Everyone agrees that æspa is the main vocalist.
And stop spamming...
Upopular opinion: I see you everywhere.
*Why Winter is so cute🥺 ? She looks like a small puppy in a blanket.*
Ikr🥺
BB GIRL
I really like Winter and Giselle's voices when they take turns to sing, giving me different vibe and goosebumps
ruclips.net/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/видео.html😊
@@Marstatoy ooh look who's talking here
@@Marstatoy once talking about vocal??? are u sure???
@@Marstatoy yeah your comment also makes me pity you because you seem deaf 😭😭😭😭
@@Marstatoy oh please !! Isn't the person in your profile picture who actually needs vocal training? opss😊🤣...
Their vocals are all so pretty and unique, love them