I think the answer is simple enough.Who will benefit by hiding the body of Hemraj in the terrace and leaving Arushi's body in her bedroom.By hiding Hemraj's body ,they could confuse the police by pointing elsewhere.No murderer will stick around the crime scene to dress it up and have a drink ,when the parents are just sleeping in the next bedroom.The Talwars did it.
Hemraj had received a call from an unknown person at around 8:30 pm on the same night This person called him from a PCO which was within 1km radius of the Talwar residence It’s possible that he wanted to see Hemraj It’s important to note that Hemraj was in fear of his life and he had shared it with this lady who gave an interview to the media Hemraj was not sending money back home for a year as told by his wife Maybe he owed this person quite a lot of money and he was getting threats regarding the same The two men meet at Talwar residence unbeknownst to the family This person asks for more alcohol and Hemraj gets some from Rajesh’s bar revealing its location They go to the terrace to catch some fresh air and then a heated argument leads to a scuffle between the two This man attacks Hemraj with this khukri Slits his throat and then covers his body He locks the terrace and then goes back to the house to take his belongings Being rattled by the altercation he thinks of taking one more sip of the alcohol This is when Aarushi sees him and he immediately attacks her Drags her to the bed and slit her throat He then dresses up the crime scene so as to give an impression that someone had murdered her while she was asleep He then fled I am saying this cause Hemraj was wearing slippers indicating he went alive to the roof He was murdered first and the alcohol bottle had both of their blood and an unknown fingerprint There was no forced entry as he was let in by Hemraj Someone should’ve investigated this angle
@@Amk-ks9mh i also think the same But people are saying that the door was locked from inside Why would talwars lock it from inside ? Murderer could have kept it open Who called arushi so many times that night. Why was krishna talking about dr.talwar n dr.anita's affair
@@anvesh12 no You need to watch the movie again the first team believed that the servants are the murderers i am just stating the possibility of a third person being the real murderer ( not the parents and the servants )
No one is raising these following questions including Arnab. 1) Why did NCW chairman Girija Vyas called an NCW team at Arushi's home and told them not to visit the crime scene and told specifically to back-off? 2) Why did Hemraj contact Usha of an NGO along with ringing up CBI office multiple times and tell his wife on Phone his life was in Danger?He knew about a threat to his life BECAUSE HE KNEW SOMETHING what was that secret? 3) What was KK Gautam's role(A former UP Top Police official) with respect to this crime?He was the person who told to check the roof and break the lock?Why did Talwar's brother call up KK Gautam? KK Gautam is known to be very close to BSP supremo Mayawathi as well as SP Supremo Mulayam. 4) Why did UP police official during a press conferance on this case say "If we get permission of MayawthiJi we can solve this case in a day"? 5) What evidence did UP Police find out on Talwar's involvement with another lady Doctor Durrani who shared his clinic which was the reason claimed by UP police for Talwar eliminating Arushi and Hemraj? 6)Why didn't Nupur Talwar refuse to attend the court proceedings and later forced/Warned by the court to attend the same? 7) According to Post Mortem/Forensic report Arushi's hymen was gone and vagina path was found to be bigger than normal. Why was Arushi's sexual organs found cleaned at the crime scene? Why was doctors pressurised to remove the word "Rape' from the report? 8) Why was that specific photos were deleted from Arushi's laptop? These incidents point out a bigger conspiracy and involvement of few bigwigs who don't want the truth to come out and that's the real reason of helping Talwar to escape.Talwar was part of a bigger network.
my only question is if they talwars r innocent(which i m never ever sure)so y dont they fight for their daughter for jsutice for her , they just fight for themselves,which is always so wierd for me n prove them gulty.
The points you are mentioning are found nowhere in the allahbad high court verdict, these are nothing but just rumours that you have heard. Infact there are lot many that perhaps you don't even know of. What you are absolutely unaware is the magnitude to which the investigating agency has manipulated and literally botched up the investigation just to implicate the parents. That is, infact, the most important part in this whole story. Truth they say is stranger than fiction, is so applicable in this case.
Talwar's might be powerful... But they were so powerfull why did they suffer so much... They were fighting for their daughter in 2010 when cbi gave closure report than it was aarushi's parents who ask to continue this investigation and they want justice for their only daughter... They could do many more things if they were that much cunning or planners. Why would someone do all that and say all these things when it was clear all the situations are going to go against them... No point... Aarushi's parents are innocent
talwar's lawyer should shut up if he wants his clients to not be accused again. he comes across as extremely pompous, loud (like Trump), fake and trying too hard.
Hana Hana vo banda mereko bohot fake laga I never grasped anything he said Not about his insanely good English skills No I felt like he was talking bullshit for some reason
Absolute bullcrap! Imagine if you one day wake up to see your daughter murdered in her room with the servant being nowhere to be found and when you try to call him his phone is cut after two rings and later switched off you would obviiously suspect the servant.
If a mother saw her child was slaughtered then c would collapse or may be run for the help but in this case c was normal crying n told the maid to call the neighbour. It made me think again.
No, watch the entire series on Talwars on Hotstar and I believe that the parents are guilty. Because when Aarushi was murdered, they were the only ones in the flat and no-one else. 1. Investigation never found that there was any forced entry in the house. 2. Aarushi's mom played her part so well to convince the maid that the door is locked and she throws the key so that maid can come from other door and as soon as the maid enters both the parents do drama of crying in Aarushi's bedroom and telling the maid see what happened. This scene somehow does not convince me that anybody tried to rape Aarushi or murder. 3. Both the parents very cunningly call the police but they make sure that lot of people arrive in their home before police and the relatives and people were roaming in their house, clearing all the evidence as more footprints get in their house, forensic will have a hard job to track the traces of people. (You can watch the footage in the series where parents actually allowed lot of people in thier house.) 4. When police asks the key for terrace, Aarushi's dad never gives them but in fact buys time and misguide them. Then next day the key is given and the body of Hemraj is found. 5. Lastly, I believe they are hard-core criminals and they are very strong mentally. After the arrest of poor servant Krishna, when it proves that he wasn't the criminal but he went through such torture that he never recovered from the trauma and he is under going under medication. Now tell me, how a weak- hearted person can kill Aarushi? I was so angry and surprised that the parents got free of conviction. In fact, the second CBI team always believed that the parents are the real murderers and I too believe that. Parents did a lot of cover up and you can actually see with your eyes in the series. You must watch this series on Hotstar.
@@fictional.musings1704 The cleaning of Aarushi's body is proof the parents killed her. The father telling the cops to find Hemaj is further proof. Who else could have dragged that poor man up those steps
Bruh, She maybe be guilty, but everyone's response is different, there r people who love someone very much but don't faint after there death because they can control there emotions or sometimes the emotions don't exist...
@@shub09oj Four people are inside the house and two are dead. The only person who could have stage the crime scene was her parents, it doesn't make sense for outsider to stage a crime scene.
@@johnylalrina1451 4 person yes. One died in the room and the other on the terrace…..no blood of Hemraj in arushis room….that rules out the theory of both the deceased being in a comprising position which led to Talwar killing them…..
I dont know the motive thought, maybe the father was drunk and was angry and on a rage and accidentally killer her with a blunt object. So, they stage the crime scene and cut her throat to make it look like someone killed her. Like i said, Hemraj witness all these. But they cant trust him completely, so they go up to the terrace and they hit him from the back and slit his throat too. Thats my theory.
Why is nobody talking about Arushi and Hemraj’s phones which were founded on a railway track and the other never found? The watchmen said he didn’t see nobody go in and out. Then how the phone was gathered from a railway track?
I Think "The First Police Investigative Team Must be Punished at least for 7 Years for what they did" if not i would happen again and again. it should not be end like that.
Why? You are saying this because you believe parents didn't commit murder.. parents are blaming police from the start..I watch one interview of senior journalist of Aaj Tak..he said I talk with the police and police told him we have completed 70% case and we know parents did it and we are in progress to collect murder weapon(golf stick) but all of a sudden case transferd to CBI. And CBI starts framing servents..if local police got more time with parents in station police was sure parents will tell us story why and how they did it..
Just observe the hyper fake attitude talk of talwar's lawyer(*looks like he trying to portray something which is not completely true*) and also look for other 3 who were so cool, composed attitude(*they were not trying to hide anything ,seems genuine*). This on evidence is enough to come conclusion who was murderer*
That's true..His arrogance after winning a false case is brimming over. Hope the supreme Court puts them back where they deserve to be. Had this been the U.S. the parents would have been give a double life term based on circumstantial evidence.
He talks like that, in all his interview he speaks the same way even when talwar were in jail. Plus if you see the Krishna 's narco test, he admitted that he killed both
Are u a professional? People looks at me and say i have so much of attitude. Now you may also think the same but i am quite under confident about myself so there's no chance of having attitude. Infact my friends asks me to have some attitude atleast. People in the beginning thinks like that about me And when we become friends they are like i never thought you will be so nice to me. Maybe bcz my facial expressions were like that. Which i didn't make intentionally It looked something else Maybe i am like that Maybe i look like that. We don't know these people in person So we can't say anything about them
Talwars lawyer words are as foolish as talwars explain how hemrajs body landed on roof the terrace door locked and arushi was found dead in her room those who had the key to terrace has the answer
Talwar's lawyer, Tanveer Mir at first said that according to the police officials who were investigating when Hemraj was 'missing', a khukri was used to kill Aarushi and a nepali is suspected to be the killer. Then later on the same Tanveer Mir goes to say that the talk about a khukri being the weapon came into the picture when the first CBI team took over. But at the time when the first CBI team took over, it was already well established that Hemraj himself was killed. So isn't this lawyer contradicting himself then? Or did I make a mistake in understanding his statements?
This primarily looks like the murder done by Talwars. If the servants had committed the murder then they would certainly not have taken away hemrajs mobile with them. And even if they had taken the mobile, nobody would be stupid enough to attend a call in the morning. The behaviour of the Talwars the following morning when the maid came was totally irrational and illogical. Thats not the normal behaviour of a person when a relative is murdered inside your house. The talwars did dress up the crime scene after the murders, tried to implicate the servants and made use of their brother, their friend Mr Gautam and other family friends to shift their blame on somebody else without letting them know the truth. The servants look innocent and are dimwits. They only gave their viewpoint during narco test who could have been murdered first and by which weapon. Never did they say that they had committed the crime. Rajkumar is just a pompous idiot who got carried away by the limelight. Plus the Talwars are doctors. They know how to break loose from narco and other tests.
I feel Arushi was having an affair with servant Hemraj. Talwars found them in bed together. Killed daughter. Hemraj ran to roof where he too was killed.
Parents did not kill. Krishna and Rajkumar (neighbour's servants) were in Hemraj's room that night drinking. During narco test Krishna said he had killed Hemraj first - on the terrace with help from Rajkumar, using a khukri. He also said during narco that Rajkumar killed Aarushi. My theory: Parents were asleep with loud AC. Aarushi was in her room asleep. Rajkumar and Krishna wanted to go to Aarushi's room. Hemraj stopped them. So they got into an argument. Hemraj ran to the terrace (either because he felt threatened by the 2 servants or maybe he went up to continue argument because if he had continued arguing in the apartment, the patents would have woken up). Krishna killed Hemraj using a khukri which he always carried in his pocket. Then Krishna and Rajkumar came down and entered Aarushi's room. Rajkumar tried to sexually assault. Aarushi. She woke up and protested. So he killed her in her bed. There was blood spattered on the walls. Parents probably dressed the crime scene maybe because Rajkumar had managed to rape Aarushi and parents were ashamed that the Police would find out about the rape. I am sure that the parents had discovered Aarushi's body before maid arrived at 6 am. But in front of maid they pretended that they had just discovered the body (maybe they were scared that they would become suspects if the maid knew that they had discovered the body before).
Paps K Had these uneducated servants found so much time to dress up the crime scene and have a whisky after the twin murder. If they had murdered atleast one of them would have fled noida out of fear..Come on even a child can tell it is Talwar's after studying this case..
Hemraj might have had the terrace key and the other servants might have snatched it from him and then killed him on the terrace and locked the terrace door and ran away
Parents might have dressed the scene as they might have seen that Aarushi was maybe sexually assaulted and to prevent shame they might have dressed the scene. I am doctor and I think that the servants killed Aarushi. See the narco analysis video. At the start of narco analysis the servant Krishna spoke the entire truth. After a couple of minutes he started regaining consciousness and then he started lying and said he was forced to own up the crime. Narco analysis questions should be asked very quickly or else the subject starts becoming conscious and then they start lying
Paps K this is also not correct because arushi room could be only opened with key by parents or from inside, because they used to close it, even if parents cleaned aarushi why did they wash off all other blood stains, the mattress found on terrace and blood traces in cooler, and bottle of drink on table don't point to servants, even the security person near apartment didn't see anyone coming or going at night, my confusion is why hemraj didn't have dinner that night nor alcohol present in his body.
10:52 They were more interested in coming on TV.. Who are you talking about Tanveeer? Within a week of the murder Nupur was right in NDTV studio with a stoick and composed look... It's better u learn to talk less ,just because Ur client has walked Scott free doesn't mean they are innocent.. Mir should learn to be less boisterous regarding the innocence of the Talwars..
1. Who's blood was on the whiskey bottle and why didn't the Talwars get rid of it? 2. Who's bloody handprint was on the terrace door, the Talwars said that it's someone else's 3. Who's bloody shoe print was on the terrace which was a size 9 which is not Rahesh's shoe size? 4. Who called Hemrajs phone? 5. What if the police arrived early and secured the crimescene, were the Talwars preparing to get caught anyway seeing as their dna and fingerprints would only be there?
1. incision, cuts seems to b similar to both. 2. especially very very especially aarusis rape evidence is cleared off at d same time hemraj private part was also blotted. if these two issues incision cuts and clearing process is common and similar to both den d accused should have planned to finish both arrushi and hemraj in d same spot on roof top.
I think the parents murdered both of them and the murder must have happened on the roof. The only possibility is that aarushi & hemraj were caught in compromising position but they were not caught by the parents,, there must be someone who informed them about it as, if one of the parents had seen this, they won't come back to house and take the weapon to go and kill,, no parent will wait and go back to house to bring the weapon. why didn't hemraj tried to save himself?? Proves that parents had some help,,, PS: it's just a theory :p don't take it seriously!
that's why as soon as aarushis murder completed hemraj was injected and carried to some private place and hidden there den after two days he was brought back to d house under very sensitive narcotic drug and alcohol and den murdered to confuse all of us. bcs under drug hemraj cannot shout and escape. and d tool kukri which is used to play dat particular game on ground can be played only on ground. so person who plays dis game till end must be facing and looking into ground till d game gets overed that's why he has collected vertebrate blood for example a reptile or cobra blood in and around hemraj body to extremely confuse us. a guy who seriously plays dat particular game till today should have seen many snakes, bcs vertebrate can easily enter into any ground containing grass. or, a guy who plays or hunts in forest must have done it bcs we may not be knowing many vertebrates, invertebrates blood samples but a pakka well educated surgeon must be acknowledged aware of blood samples of all living beings and creatures through their education.
The Talwar would hv drunk and could hv been in compromise position found by Arushi and knowing this the Talwar would hv murderd aarushi seen by Hemraj and because hemraj seen it He was murderd
as I said yesterday, people who belong to talwar society should have committed dis murder and must have been close to aarushis father Mr. Rajesh sir and his entire family long time back. a person who is very well known to d family can only b aware of keys of all doors and family members work schedule and servants intelligence and work efficiency etc. so, dat close person should have been waiting for d accurate timing and situation. according to my point of view, the small innocent beautiful child must ve brought to the top floor through innocent hemraj. and d accused sent by the family's close person should have raped only once and then dat child is hit and made incision through surgeons knife along with kukri and murdered without any evidence on top floor bcs murder is very pakka Pre planned and then dat child is placed on her room bed, that's why there is no blood stains on aarushis toys, bed covers, bedsheets, school bag and everything is kept as it is in its own place. and dats why aarushis innocent lovable parents were not able to hear noise. on d top floor after aarushi murder done, all the d maximum semens were cleared off. d accused must be either b an surgeon on he or she must have hired help from an well expert gynecologist.
the sole problem is to whom shud be convicted coz if parents are convicted then there are no crucial evidence and if servants are convicted also no crucial evidence. but on the larger part narco test did testify servants role and again its not legal evidence.but the narco team didnt ask krishna that why he did this .they were only stressing on how he did this
Erada na calc karka case solve karna ka. Use the heal of technology and science and solve it. Don't speak Speak with appropriate proves. Will pray for her parents and relatives heal with time.
Is the news channel so dumb not to interview the ones who conducted the INVESTIGATION? Of course the lawyers, social activists and all will give just their side of the view. What a waste of a story you guys make.. c'mon.
I think the answer is simple enough.Who will benefit by hiding the body of Hemraj in the terrace and leaving Arushi's body in her bedroom.By hiding Hemraj's body ,they could confuse the police by pointing elsewhere.No murderer will stick around the crime scene to dress it up and have a drink ,when the parents are just sleeping in the next bedroom.The Talwars did it.
Hemraj had received a call from an unknown person at around 8:30 pm on the same night
This person called him from a PCO which was within 1km radius of the Talwar residence
It’s possible that he wanted to see Hemraj
It’s important to note that Hemraj was in fear of his life and he had shared it with this lady who gave an interview to the media
Hemraj was not sending money back home for a year as told by his wife
Maybe he owed this person quite a lot of money and he was getting threats regarding the same
The two men meet at Talwar residence unbeknownst to the family
This person asks for more alcohol and Hemraj gets some from Rajesh’s bar revealing its location
They go to the terrace to catch some fresh air and then a heated argument leads to a scuffle between the two
This man attacks Hemraj with this khukri
Slits his throat and then covers his body
He locks the terrace and then goes back to the house to take his belongings
Being rattled by the altercation he thinks of taking one more sip of the alcohol
This is when Aarushi sees him and he immediately attacks her
Drags her to the bed and slit her throat
He then dresses up the crime scene so as to give an impression that someone had murdered her while she was asleep
He then fled
I am saying this cause Hemraj was wearing slippers indicating he went alive to the roof
He was murdered first and the alcohol bottle had both of their blood and an unknown fingerprint
There was no forced entry as he was let in by Hemraj
Someone should’ve investigated this angle
@@Amk-ks9mh Admissible.Your theory looks the most convincing.
@@Amk-ks9mh i also think the same
But people are saying that the door was locked from inside
Why would talwars lock it from inside ?
Murderer could have kept it open
Who called arushi so many times that night.
Why was krishna talking about dr.talwar n dr.anita's affair
@@Amk-ks9mh U just told Talwar movie version
@@anvesh12 no
You need to watch the movie again
the first team believed that the servants are the murderers
i am just stating the possibility of a third person being the real murderer ( not the parents and the servants )
What is the basis of the assumption that fifth person was not there ?
No one is raising these following questions including Arnab.
1) Why did NCW chairman Girija Vyas called an NCW team at Arushi's home and told them not to visit the crime scene and told specifically to back-off?
2) Why did Hemraj contact Usha of an NGO along with ringing up CBI office multiple times and tell his wife on Phone his life was in Danger?He knew about a threat to his life BECAUSE HE KNEW SOMETHING what was that secret?
3) What was KK Gautam's role(A former UP Top Police official) with respect to this crime?He was the person who told to check the roof and break the lock?Why did Talwar's brother call up KK Gautam?
KK Gautam is known to be very close to BSP supremo Mayawathi as well as SP Supremo Mulayam.
4) Why did UP police official during a press conferance on this case say "If we get permission of MayawthiJi we can solve this case in a day"?
5) What evidence did UP Police find out on Talwar's involvement with another lady Doctor Durrani who shared his clinic which was the reason claimed by UP police for Talwar eliminating Arushi and Hemraj?
6)Why didn't Nupur Talwar refuse to attend the court proceedings and later forced/Warned by the court to attend the same?
7) According to Post Mortem/Forensic report Arushi's hymen was gone and vagina path was found to be bigger than normal.
Why was Arushi's sexual organs found cleaned at the crime scene?
Why was doctors pressurised to remove the word "Rape' from the report?
8) Why was that specific photos were deleted from Arushi's laptop?
These incidents point out a bigger conspiracy and involvement of few bigwigs who don't want the truth to come out and that's the real reason of helping Talwar to escape.Talwar was part of a bigger network.
my only question is if they talwars r innocent(which i m never ever sure)so y dont they fight for their daughter for jsutice for her , they just fight for themselves,which is always so wierd for me n prove them gulty.
The points you are mentioning are found nowhere in the allahbad high court verdict, these are nothing but just rumours that you have heard. Infact there are lot many that perhaps you don't even know of.
What you are absolutely unaware is the magnitude to which the investigating agency has manipulated and literally botched up the investigation just to implicate the parents. That is, infact, the most important part in this whole story. Truth they say is stranger than fiction, is so applicable in this case.
Why was there no DNA of victims on the golf club.... Why no blood of hemraj in d bedroom?
Talwar's might be powerful... But they were so powerfull why did they suffer so much... They were fighting for their daughter in 2010 when cbi gave closure report than it was aarushi's parents who ask to continue this investigation and they want justice for their only daughter... They could do many more things if they were that much cunning or planners. Why would someone do all that and say all these things when it was clear all the situations are going to go against them... No point... Aarushi's parents are innocent
@@shefalisahota7220 tumne kbhi jhut bola hai ? Tumhe patta hai jhut ko bhi sacch ki tarah hi bolna padta hai tbhi log yakeen krte hai ? 😗
talwar's lawyer should shut up if he wants his clients to not be accused again. he comes across as extremely pompous, loud (like Trump), fake and trying too hard.
@Rakesh Patel but Talwars are not Muslim. Ridiculous you mixing religion in this case
Wow, you Trump haters can link him to anything. Take your Trump Derangement meds and go to bed.
Except Trump was a president of the USA. Like him or hate him, he did reach the top. Has USA got better after he went? Just curious.
Hana Hana vo banda mereko bohot fake laga
I never grasped anything he said
Not about his insanely good English skills
No I felt like he was talking bullshit for some reason
KTS Tulsi is correct. Blaming Hemraj is proof the parents did it.
Absolute bullcrap!
Imagine if you one day wake up to see your daughter murdered in her room with the servant being nowhere to be found and when you try to call him his phone is cut after two rings and later switched off you would obviiously suspect the servant.
If a mother saw her child was slaughtered then c would collapse or may be run for the help but in this case c was normal crying n told the maid to call the neighbour. It made me think again.
Why don't they just confessed?
No, watch the entire series on Talwars on Hotstar and I believe that the parents are guilty.
Because when Aarushi was murdered, they were the only ones in the flat and no-one else.
1. Investigation never found that there was any forced entry in the house.
2. Aarushi's mom played her part so well to convince the maid that the door is locked and she throws the key so that maid can come from other door and as soon as the maid enters both the parents do drama of crying in Aarushi's bedroom and telling the maid see what happened. This scene somehow does not convince me that anybody tried to rape Aarushi or murder.
3. Both the parents very cunningly call the police but they make sure that lot of people arrive in their home before police and the relatives and people were roaming in their house, clearing all the evidence as more footprints get in their house, forensic will have a hard job to track the traces of people. (You can watch the footage in the series where parents actually allowed lot of people in thier house.)
4. When police asks the key for terrace, Aarushi's dad never gives them but in fact buys time and misguide them. Then next day the key is given and the body of Hemraj is found.
5. Lastly, I believe they are hard-core criminals and they are very strong mentally. After the arrest of poor servant Krishna, when it proves that he wasn't the criminal but he went through such torture that he never recovered from the trauma and he is under going under medication. Now tell me, how a weak- hearted person can kill Aarushi?
I was so angry and surprised that the parents got free of conviction. In fact, the second CBI team always believed that the parents are the real murderers and I too believe that.
Parents did a lot of cover up and you can actually see with your eyes in the series. You must watch this series on Hotstar.
@@fictional.musings1704 The cleaning of Aarushi's body is proof the parents killed her. The father telling the cops to find Hemaj is further proof. Who else could have dragged that poor man up those steps
@@jputterman26 yes true!
Bruh, She maybe be guilty, but everyone's response is different, there r people who love someone very much but don't faint after there death because they can control there emotions or sometimes the emotions don't exist...
I don’t think arushi had any illicit relationship with that old man
Me too, Maybe Hemraj witness the murder and he was struck by the golf club from behind.
@@johnylalrina1451 why would the parents kill Arushi? For what reason?
@@shub09oj Four people are inside the house and two are dead. The only person who could have stage the crime scene was her parents, it doesn't make sense for outsider to stage a crime scene.
@@johnylalrina1451 4 person yes. One died in the room and the other on the terrace…..no blood of Hemraj in arushis room….that rules out the theory of both the deceased being in a comprising position which led to Talwar killing them…..
I dont know the motive thought, maybe the father was drunk and was angry and on a rage and accidentally killer her with a blunt object. So, they stage the crime scene and cut her throat to make it look like someone killed her. Like i said, Hemraj witness all these. But they cant trust him completely, so they go up to the terrace and they hit him from the back and slit his throat too. Thats my theory.
Why is nobody talking about Arushi and Hemraj’s phones which were founded on a railway track and the other never found?
The watchmen said he didn’t see nobody go in and out. Then how the phone was gathered from a railway track?
Yes exactly.
What about the death threat hemraj was receiving
What about the unknown phone calls
The golf stick is the backbone of this case
I Think "The First Police Investigative Team Must be Punished at least for 7 Years for what they did" if not i would happen again and again.
it should not be end like that.
Why? You are saying this because you believe parents didn't commit murder.. parents are blaming police from the start..I watch one interview of senior journalist of Aaj Tak..he said I talk with the police and police told him we have completed 70% case and we know parents did it and we are in progress to collect murder weapon(golf stick) but all of a sudden case transferd to CBI. And CBI starts framing servents..if local police got more time with parents in station police was sure parents will tell us story why and how they did it..
Just observe the hyper fake attitude talk of talwar's lawyer(*looks like he trying to portray something which is not completely true*) and also look for other 3 who were so cool, composed attitude(*they were not trying to hide anything ,seems genuine*).
This on evidence is enough to come conclusion who was murderer*
That's true..His arrogance after winning a false case is brimming over. Hope the supreme Court puts them back where they deserve to be. Had this been the U.S. the parents would have been give a double life term based on circumstantial evidence.
He talks like that, in all his interview he speaks the same way even when talwar were in jail. Plus if you see the Krishna 's narco test, he admitted that he killed both
Vinay, i had raised the same. issue . i see that lawyer jumping and trying to protect Talwars
Are u a professional?
People looks at me and say i have so much of attitude. Now you may also think the same but i am quite under confident about myself so there's no chance of having attitude.
Infact my friends asks me to have some attitude atleast. People in the beginning thinks like that about me
And when we become friends they are like i never thought you will be so nice to me.
Maybe bcz my facial expressions were like that.
Which i didn't make intentionally
It looked something else
Maybe i am like that
Maybe i look like that.
We don't know these people in person
So we can't say anything about them
Did she really quoted "India's greatest murder mystery" as if It was something to be very proud of!
😂
Talwars lawyer words are as foolish as talwars explain how hemrajs body landed on roof the terrace door locked and arushi was found dead in her room those who had the key to terrace has the answer
This shows what a great POLICE we have in our country. Shame to the Police department of this nation.
Talwar's lawyer, Tanveer Mir at first said that according to the police officials who were investigating when Hemraj was 'missing', a khukri was used to kill Aarushi and a nepali is suspected to be the killer. Then later on the same Tanveer Mir goes to say that the talk about a khukri being the weapon came into the picture when the first CBI team took over. But at the time when the first CBI team took over, it was already well established that Hemraj himself was killed.
So isn't this lawyer contradicting himself then? Or did I make a mistake in understanding his statements?
Yeah, a made up story to save his clients
This primarily looks like the murder done by Talwars. If the servants had committed the murder then they would certainly not have taken away hemrajs mobile with them. And even if they had taken the mobile, nobody would be stupid enough to attend a call in the morning.
The behaviour of the Talwars the following morning when the maid came was totally irrational and illogical. Thats not the normal behaviour of a person when a relative is murdered inside your house. The talwars did dress up the crime scene after the murders, tried to implicate the servants and made use of their brother, their friend Mr Gautam and other family friends to shift their blame on somebody else without letting them know the truth. The servants look innocent and are dimwits. They only gave their viewpoint during narco test who could have been murdered first and by which weapon. Never did they say that they had committed the crime. Rajkumar is just a pompous idiot who got carried away by the limelight. Plus the Talwars are doctors. They know how to break loose from narco and other tests.
Talwaar's lawyer is very defensive. Talwaars did it.
Excellent analysis.
Good job news x team and priya.👍
Raat mai sound bhut clear sunai deti hai bhiya...
I feel Arushi was having an affair with servant Hemraj.
Talwars found them in bed together. Killed daughter. Hemraj ran to roof where he too was killed.
Wow very helpful theory
Parents did not kill. Krishna and Rajkumar (neighbour's servants) were in Hemraj's room that night drinking. During narco test Krishna said he had killed Hemraj first - on the terrace with help from Rajkumar, using a khukri. He also said during narco that Rajkumar killed Aarushi.
My theory: Parents were asleep with loud AC. Aarushi was in her room asleep. Rajkumar and Krishna wanted to go to Aarushi's room. Hemraj stopped them. So they got into an argument. Hemraj ran to the terrace (either because he felt threatened by the 2 servants or maybe he went up to continue argument because if he had continued arguing in the apartment, the patents would have woken up). Krishna killed Hemraj using a khukri which he always carried in his pocket. Then Krishna and Rajkumar came down and entered Aarushi's room. Rajkumar tried to sexually assault. Aarushi. She woke up and protested. So he killed her in her bed. There was blood spattered on the walls.
Parents probably dressed the crime scene maybe because Rajkumar had managed to rape Aarushi and parents were ashamed that the Police would find out about the rape. I am sure that the parents had discovered Aarushi's body before maid arrived at 6 am. But in front of maid they pretended that they had just discovered the body (maybe they were scared that they would become suspects if the maid knew that they had discovered the body before).
Paps K I feel this argument has many missing link why did talwar lock up the terrace door and hide it, because they where guilty
Paps K Had these uneducated servants found so much time to dress up the crime scene and have a whisky after the twin murder. If they had murdered atleast one of them would have fled noida out of fear..Come on even a child can tell it is Talwar's after studying this case..
Hemraj might have had the terrace key and the other servants might have snatched it from him and then killed him on the terrace and locked the terrace door and ran away
Parents might have dressed the scene as they might have seen that Aarushi was maybe sexually assaulted and to prevent shame they might have dressed the scene. I am doctor and I think that the servants killed Aarushi. See the narco analysis video. At the start of narco analysis the servant Krishna spoke the entire truth. After a couple of minutes he started regaining consciousness and then he started lying and said he was forced to own up the crime. Narco analysis questions should be asked very quickly or else the subject starts becoming conscious and then they start lying
Paps K this is also not correct because arushi room could be only opened with key by parents or from inside, because they used to close it, even if parents cleaned aarushi why did they wash off all other blood stains, the mattress found on terrace and blood traces in cooler, and bottle of drink on table don't point to servants, even the security person near apartment didn't see anyone coming or going at night, my confusion is why hemraj didn't have dinner that night nor alcohol present in his body.
Nice documentary
10:52
They were more interested in coming on TV..
Who are you talking about Tanveeer?
Within a week of the murder Nupur was right in NDTV studio with a stoick and composed look...
It's better u learn to talk less ,just because Ur client has walked Scott free doesn't mean they are innocent..
Mir should learn to be less boisterous regarding the innocence of the Talwars..
Why didn't they check the garbage areas around.
Kachre se itna saboot mil jata hai ki aur kuch nhi krna pdta
The advocate of the talwars is just denying every logical question.
I am totally convinced that Talwara killed their daughter.
6:26 "got himself murdered"???
What about the alcohol level in the blood of the servants and the parents? Who consumed that whisky?
We need Joy Peace and Contentment
Who is the murderer?
Tks tulsi looks great
But there was no blood of hemraj in her room
Nobody can specifically clean blood
Parents did it! Of course! 😡
How was the golf club found?
Aarushi was killed by raj kumar and hemraaj was killed by father because he believed hemraaj killed aarushi
Actually the blood stain
Why a child would have an illicit affair
Police botch up,
CBI followed the same
Evidence collection was not done properly
Very very informative video. Why have not talwars confessed
1. Who's blood was on the whiskey bottle and why didn't the Talwars get rid of it?
2. Who's bloody handprint was on the terrace door, the Talwars said that it's someone else's
3. Who's bloody shoe print was on the terrace which was a size 9 which is not Rahesh's shoe size?
4. Who called Hemrajs phone?
5. What if the police arrived early and secured the crimescene, were the Talwars preparing to get caught anyway seeing as their dna and fingerprints would only be there?
cbi and cops paid off to keep shut...
Parents are the culprit....
That guy in white shirt is too sure of himself. The servant did not run away he was dragged upstairs..
1. incision, cuts seems to b similar to both. 2. especially very very especially aarusis rape evidence is cleared off at d same time hemraj private part was also blotted. if these two issues incision cuts and clearing process is common and similar to both den d accused should have planned to finish both arrushi and hemraj in d same spot on roof top.
Hemraj was not murdered on the roof!!!!! Bcz the blood stains were found on the stairs as if somebody dragged his body to the terrace
I think the parents murdered both of them and the murder must have happened on the roof. The only possibility is that aarushi & hemraj were caught in compromising position but they were not caught by the parents,, there must be someone who informed them about it as, if one of the parents had seen this, they won't come back to house and take the weapon to go and kill,, no parent will wait and go back to house to bring the weapon.
why didn't hemraj tried to save himself?? Proves that parents had some help,,,
PS: it's just a theory :p don't take it seriously!
Cause they done it..the house was locked up...only 4 ppl inside
8:36
8:47
11:22
15:34
22:20
Talwars were the murderers.when they saw their cook with their daughter they hit him from behind and then hit the daughter before she could get up.
that's why as soon as aarushis murder completed hemraj was injected and carried to some private place and hidden there den after two days he was brought back to d house under very sensitive narcotic drug and alcohol and den murdered to confuse all of us. bcs under drug hemraj cannot shout and escape. and d tool kukri which is used to play dat particular game on ground can be played only on ground. so person who plays dis game till end must be facing and looking into ground till d game gets overed that's why he has collected vertebrate blood for example a reptile or cobra blood in and around hemraj body to extremely confuse us. a guy who seriously plays dat particular game till today should have seen many snakes, bcs vertebrate can easily enter into any ground containing grass. or, a guy who plays or hunts in forest must have done it bcs we may not be knowing many vertebrates, invertebrates blood samples but a pakka well educated surgeon must be acknowledged aware of blood samples of all living beings and creatures through their education.
The Talwar would hv drunk and could hv been in compromise position found by Arushi and knowing this the Talwar would hv murderd aarushi seen by Hemraj and because hemraj seen it
He was murderd
watch the documentary named "arushi beyond reasonable doubt" and after watching this i do feel that the servants were the murderers
Yes
as I said yesterday, people who belong to talwar society should have committed dis murder and must have been close to aarushis father Mr. Rajesh sir and his entire family long time back. a person who is very well known to d family can only b aware of keys of all doors and family members work schedule and servants intelligence and work efficiency etc. so, dat close person should have been waiting for d accurate timing and situation. according to my point of view, the small innocent beautiful child must ve brought to the top floor through innocent hemraj. and d accused sent by the family's close person should have raped only once and then dat child is hit and made incision through surgeons knife along with kukri and murdered without any evidence on top floor bcs murder is very pakka Pre planned and then dat child is placed on her room bed, that's why there is no blood stains on aarushis toys, bed covers, bedsheets, school bag and everything is kept as it is in its own place. and dats why aarushis innocent lovable parents were not able to hear noise. on d top floor after aarushi murder done, all the d maximum semens were cleared off. d accused must be either b an surgeon on he or she must have hired help from an well expert gynecologist.
Hi
Talwar's lawyer looks like BJP's politician Gaurav Bhatia
I think most mystery is of SSR.
@Riya ghosh same way both were murdered
the sole problem is to whom shud be convicted coz if parents are convicted then there are no crucial evidence and if servants are convicted also no crucial evidence. but on the larger part narco test did testify servants role and again its not legal evidence.but the narco team didnt ask krishna that why he did this .they were only stressing on how he did this
Let's say dr. Hit aarushi or hemraj with a golf club, wouldn't the other struggle to free. Where re the bruises.
M/S Hemraj apko insaf milagi dakhna.........
Talwar dampatti hi kattil hai 😭😭
no
Talwar's lawyer-why he is always jumping ... he is completely sold... why cant he put the effort to find out the murderers ..
Her mother had open affair with apartment owner he else he killed both of them are else culprit is still is in apartment
Erada na calc karka case solve karna ka.
Use the heal of technology and science and solve it.
Don't speak
Speak with appropriate proves.
Will pray for her parents and relatives heal with time.
it's obvious the parents killed both .
Mar mar k hadia toor de is k maa bap ki khudi btye gy k mara hy k nai
Is the news channel so dumb not to interview the ones who conducted the INVESTIGATION? Of course the lawyers, social activists and all will give just their side of the view. What a waste of a story you guys make.. c'mon.
Parents are innocent....no parents can do this...its the compounded the culprit...
imagine if your daughter is killed and you also have a servent in your house and he is not here now you will probably say that servent did it