@@michaeljohnston-ul1vi In my humble opinion your statement makes no sence. Art is not measured in kilograms, centimeters, seconnds, etc. Strictly speaking we even cannot prove to each other that your color vision is exactly the same as mine, or what you are hearing is exactly the same as I am hearing.And so on. All what is left for us, is to express our feelings. But then, we must accept each other' s opinions. You are humbly NOT willing to accept opinions of others.
@@michaeljohnston-ul1vi Wrong again! This time, is even more so.Everybody is entitled for his / her opinion. The autorities are surrounded by layers of subordinates. Their opinion is the opinion subordinates are presenting to the authority. Hitler had no opinion about strength of Russian economy.Therefore he invaded Russia in 1941.But at the beginning of 1942 he complained to Mannerheim ( Findland) that only because of wrong information about Russian economy he invaded Russia.
Оба удивительны!!! Вновь и вновь слушаю эту запись!!! Необыкновенная музыка и прекрасные исполнители и оркестр! И Анна и Роландо отдавали нам свои сердца без остатка. Спасибо!
All the comments indicate the high regards accorded to both of them Her acting so realistic honest and one feels the pain and joy without histronics but deep undetstanding of her role which she executes perfecty what more can one add to this snd certainly a very taxing duet. Perfectly sung by the tenor whose passions sre well suited to this very Strenuous duet. I doubt whether any other voukd match this beautiful aria. Bless ❤️ them for the magnigicence hiven to us via RUclips THANK YOU SOOO MUCH
Esta parte de la ópera tan dramática, cuando Iolanta oye por primera vez la palabra LUZ, queda magníficamente interpretada por Anna y Rolando....BRAVISSIMO!!!!!
"Что значит видеть?" Любовь совершает чудеса. Слезы сменяются счастьем. П. Чайковский фантастически опередил своё время. Сейчас зрение многим возвращает медицина, вскорости будет электронное время. Главное это музыка гениальной оперы и чудесные певцы!
Such a beautiful, sad and deeply touching composition! Awesome, pure and so strong voices of these unbelievably talented and handsome singers performing the magnificant Iolanta by great Tchaykovsky! Bravo!!!!
Un de los dúos más hermosos en la historia de la ópera, una obra de arte del gran Tchaikovsky. Muy bien interpretado. Magistralmente orquestado y dirigido.
Необыкновенная, чудесная музыка Чайковского в таком непревзойденном исполнении! Уникальные, завораживающие голоса солистов и прекрасная работа оркестра заставляет пересматривать это видео много раз! Браво!
Para mi, Rolando Villazon, que lo he descubierto no hace mucho tiempo, es uno de los tenores mas brillante de la juventud actual. Muy parecido a Plácido Domingo del que es muy amigo. y Anna Netrebko, guapisima y con una excelente voz. "Magnífico, solo eso, insuperables.-
I love this piece. Anna's performance is superb. While Rolando would not pass as a Russian, amongst non-native singers of Russian, he is remarkably good. I cannot recall, offhand, a non-Russian who sings Russian this well. They are both great. A very moving performance. Bravo!
FANTASTIC DUO !!! FANTASTIC MUSICIANS !!! FANTASTIC MAESTRO !!! GOD BLESS ALL YOU !!! GOD BLESS YOUR FANTASTIC TALENTS !!! THANK YOU FOR THE BIG PLEASURE !!! YOUR ETERNAL FAN NADYA MIRKOVA FROM SOFIA - BULGARIA
Это абсолютно шедевральное исполнение этого дуэта. Какой у Анны мягкий и выразительный голос. И Роландо здесь очень хорош, он отлично чувствует эту музыку и текст, несмотря на легкий акцент.
@@Alenagorby Только сопрано уже не лирическое, а искусственно переделанное в драматическое, чтобы иметь больше партий и зарабатывать больше. И слушать её теперь неинтересно. Она вульгарна. Во всем.
Just saw this at the MetHD broadcast yesterday -- Netrebko and Piotr Beczala -- what a hidden gem and wonder of Tchaikovsky! This duet reminds me a little of the finale of Tchaikovsky's Fifth Symphony with its march-like nature.
Que melodia mas bella y que interpretacion que nos dan estos dos artistas geniales. Tchaikovsky nunca falla con su poder de inventar tan preciosa musica. Gracias, maestro!
Ang Ganda! That's a compliment by the way in Filipino... Love Netrebko & Villazon... I do think they perform the best duets & offer the best interpretation of any piece... That's my opinion... :-)
Cada vez que escucho a Anna Netrebko y Rolando Villazón, lo debo hacer con un pañuelo en mano, porque su actuación me llevan al llanto, con tantas emociones y dulzura con que lo hacen, realmente son voces que acarician mi alma....Muchas gracias Anna y Rolando..........
I love them both ! They are a fantastique couple. Rolando's russian sounds sooo good ! (And his german is fantastic, too ! I know what I'm talking about I am German ^^)
This is historic recording. Both singers are at the top of their capacities.Nobody ever was singing better this duet
They are simply fantastic when singing together with their gripping dramatic expression and stage presantation just wonderful
In your humble opinion.
@@michaeljohnston-ul1vi In my humble opinion your statement makes no sence. Art is not measured in kilograms, centimeters, seconnds, etc. Strictly speaking we even cannot prove to each other that your color vision is exactly the same as mine, or what you are hearing is exactly the same as I am hearing.And so on. All what is left for us, is to express our feelings. But then, we must accept each other' s opinions. You are humbly NOT willing to accept opinions of others.
@@SuperArkleo but YOU are not any authority ,so it is in your humble opinion
@@michaeljohnston-ul1vi Wrong again! This time, is even more so.Everybody is entitled for his / her opinion. The autorities are surrounded by layers of subordinates. Their opinion is the opinion subordinates are presenting to the authority. Hitler had no opinion about strength of Russian economy.Therefore he invaded Russia in 1941.But at the beginning of 1942 he complained to Mannerheim ( Findland) that only because of wrong information about Russian economy he invaded Russia.
These two were at the height of their art at this time, a perfect coupling
Anna is so good at acting combined with talented singing.
How can performers of this calibre garner so few views? They are beyond marvellous
Thrilling. Anna's power and emotion are unmatched. Rolando was great too 💓
Оба удивительны!!! Вновь и вновь слушаю эту запись!!! Необыкновенная музыка и прекрасные исполнители и оркестр! И Анна и Роландо отдавали нам свои сердца без остатка. Спасибо!
J adore ses deux chanteur
@@jeaninefournier733 tiittioooooooooooot łyopoooop
Я их обожаю!!!
Iolanta is a wonderful and under-appreciated opera. Anna is spot on and Rolando is excellent as well, even his Russian is passable!
My favourite couple of opera singers
All the comments indicate the high regards accorded to both of them
Her acting so realistic honest and one feels the pain and joy without histronics but deep undetstanding of her role which she executes perfecty what more can one add to this snd certainly a very
taxing duet. Perfectly sung by the tenor whose passions sre well suited to this very
Strenuous duet.
I doubt whether any other voukd match this beautiful aria. Bless ❤️ them for the magnigicence hiven to us via RUclips THANK YOU SOOO MUCH
Esta parte de la ópera tan dramática, cuando Iolanta oye por primera vez la palabra LUZ, queda magníficamente interpretada por Anna y Rolando....BRAVISSIMO!!!!!
The obvious chemistry between them adds so much emotion to their performances. I love them also in "L'Elisir d'Amore."
And in Traviata ❤
Этот дуэт - эталон! Ничего лучше не слушала!
Обожаю прекрасных исполнителей муз. ЧАЙКОВСКОГО. БРАВО, БИС!!!
5:50 Beautiful solo by Anna Netrebko; she allows us to feel a lot of emotions. Merveilleux. Bravo depuis Montréal.
Dichosos los que los vieron y escucharon en vivo fue un tiempo mágico en ellos y en la opera que muy pocas veces pasa eran únicos los dos
Ну что тут скажешь, божественный голос, божественная музыка!!!🙏🙏🙏💕💕💕
Una Joya lírica en la voz del mas grande duo lirico que ha dado el Siglo xxi!!!Anna y Rokando
❤
Such a beautiful opera. Don't know why it doesn't get performed more often!
"Что значит видеть?" Любовь совершает чудеса. Слезы сменяются счастьем. П. Чайковский фантастически опередил своё время. Сейчас зрение многим возвращает медицина, вскорости будет электронное время. Главное это музыка гениальной оперы и чудесные певцы!
I still love this beautiful cupple.
Красивейшая и любимейшая опера Чайковского , БОЖЕСТВЕННОЕ исполнение ! СПАСИБО !!!!
Dos voces en verdad maravillosas; una obra espléndida, como todo Tchaikovsky.
Such a beautiful, sad and deeply touching composition! Awesome, pure and so strong voices of these unbelievably talented and handsome singers performing the magnificant Iolanta by great Tchaykovsky! Bravo!!!!
Просто нет слов. Гениальное исполнение!!!
Geweldig
What a force, this is music at the highiest level, I love Rolando and Anna good look for both.
this is beauty, passion, musicality and quality all spun into one thanks to Ms. Netrebko and Mr. Villazon! love it
Un de los dúos más hermosos en la historia de la ópera, una obra de arte del gran Tchaikovsky. Muy bien interpretado. Magistralmente orquestado y dirigido.
Необыкновенная, чудесная музыка Чайковского в таком непревзойденном исполнении! Уникальные, завораживающие голоса солистов и прекрасная работа оркестра заставляет пересматривать это видео много раз! Браво!
Trop beau ! J'en ai les larmes aux yeux. Bravo Rolando, bravo Anna.
And he sings like an angel.
Unique en ces temps de troubles Merci ANNA NETREBKO .
Para mi, Rolando Villazon, que lo he descubierto no hace mucho tiempo, es uno de los tenores mas brillante de la juventud actual. Muy parecido a Plácido Domingo del que es muy amigo. y Anna Netrebko, guapisima y con una excelente voz. "Magnífico, solo eso, insuperables.-
I love this piece. Anna's performance is superb. While Rolando would not pass as a Russian, amongst non-native singers of Russian, he is remarkably good. I cannot recall, offhand, a non-Russian who sings Russian this well.
They are both great. A very moving performance. Bravo!
Великолепно спето!!! Они прекрасный дуэт, Rolando очень старался, а Анна как всегда великолепна.
Божественная музыка, общественные голоса.
Thaikovsky would be proud of this performance.
Great! Biggest voices&high art!Full energysh developed tarents are miracle!
hybrid!
Ahhh! Tchaikovsky. You always touch my soul. What a sublime performance.
Anna and Rolando, the most magical of all times
qué dúp celestial, qué voces, qué hemosa melodía!!!!!!!!!!!!!
KE MERAVIGLIA! PROPRIO NELLE OPERE MINORI E MENO CONOSCIUTE SI TROVANO LE ARIE E I DUETTI PIU BELLI!
Helt underbar sång av Anna och Rolando💌💘💖💖💗💗
Fantástico! Nunca ouvi nada mais bonito! I've never listened to anything so beautiful....
Гимн ЛЮБВИ! Спасибо Петру Ильичу,Анне и Роландо!
FANTASTIC DUO !!! FANTASTIC MUSICIANS !!! FANTASTIC MAESTRO !!! GOD BLESS ALL YOU !!! GOD BLESS YOUR FANTASTIC TALENTS !!! THANK YOU FOR THE BIG PLEASURE !!! YOUR ETERNAL FAN NADYA MIRKOVA FROM SOFIA - BULGARIA
Анна Нетрепко послана нашей Родине нашей России господам Богом берегите в душах своих ее молитесь за нее!!!!!!!!!!!
За одни Ваши молитвы, Анна бы Вам не пела)
Давно сменила гражданство, так кому она всё-таки послана?
@@ikaenbaпослана всему миру
Que maravillosas voces, gracias
Magnifocent duet ❤Both are amazing singers 💖👌👌😍
How could anyone remain humble after giving a performance like that?
BEAUTIFUL, EMOTIONAL, PERFECTION!!!
Мурашки по коже!
QUE GRANDES VOCES!!!! Feliz fin de semana.🌿🌿
Anna!!! Ich weine wenn ich Sie höre!
BRAVA!!!
Beautiful music well performed.
Это абсолютно шедевральное исполнение этого дуэта. Какой у Анны мягкий и выразительный голос. И Роландо здесь очень хорош, он отлично чувствует эту музыку и текст, несмотря на легкий акцент.
Зато как сейчас поёт отвратительно. Казачка Аня. Старые записи смотрю с удовольствием.
@@ВераВанидовская Вильясон сейчас уже практически не поет. Время часто бежалостно к голосу. Но Анна все еще в форме.
@@Alenagorby Только сопрано уже не лирическое, а искусственно переделанное в драматическое, чтобы иметь больше партий и зарабатывать больше. И слушать её теперь неинтересно. Она вульгарна. Во всем.
Поёт отвратительно? Обратитесь на себя--возможно, вам отказывает слух@@ВераВанидовская
wonderful
Роландо блестяще ведет свою партию!!!!
I agree - This duo has no equal indeed! Watch the La Boheme DVD with these two- Sublime! It inspired me to learn to sing this song myself
Enchanting!
Dos voces maravillosas!!
A once in a lifetime pairing...Miss them in this time frame.
what a beautifull text and what a great voice ....emotion very strong to listen to such a thing thanks
Thank you for this video... I love this opera... lovely and emotive performance...
merveilleux, sublime, les deux sont magnifiques et forment un couple unique. je les adore.
Jackilen57
Just saw this at the MetHD broadcast yesterday -- Netrebko and Piotr Beczala -- what a hidden gem and wonder of Tchaikovsky! This duet reminds me a little of the finale of Tchaikovsky's Fifth Symphony with its march-like nature.
браво!!!
God this was beautiful. And I LOVE what she's wearing
Que melodia mas bella y que interpretacion que nos dan estos dos artistas geniales. Tchaikovsky nunca falla con su poder de inventar tan preciosa musica. Gracias, maestro!
THANK YOU FOR POSTING THIS AMAZING MASTERPIECE! I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS FOR SOOO LONG! I LOVE THIS OPERA SO MUCH!
Enfin un extrait sous-titrés en français ! Belles voix !
OMG!!! Only Tchaikovsky could pull off a finale like this and only Anna & Rolando could do it justice. BRAVO!!!
Seeing this has taught me I know a lot more French than I thought I did
i've seen today ms. Anna singing this aria. she is goddes of opera
Anna est splendide, comme toujours!
What a perfect match!
Wonderful!! I love these two
Wonderful in every aspect!!
Ang Ganda! That's a compliment by the way in Filipino... Love Netrebko & Villazon... I do think they perform the best duets & offer the best interpretation of any piece... That's my opinion... :-)
La mejor soprano del mundo. Es pura emoción lo que nos traslada al corazón y a los sentidos.
y el mejor Tenor del mundo
Это можно смотреть бесконечно.
Великолепно ! Гениально ! Браво !
Послушайте запись "Иоланты" с Головановым от 1940 года. И Вам все станет ясно, надеюсь...
Cada vez que escucho a Anna Netrebko y Rolando Villazón, lo debo hacer con un pañuelo en mano, porque su actuación me llevan al llanto, con tantas emociones y dulzura con que lo hacen, realmente son voces que acarician mi alma....Muchas gracias Anna y Rolando..........
I love them both ! They are a fantastique couple. Rolando's russian sounds sooo good ! (And his german is fantastic, too ! I know what I'm talking about I am German ^^)
La musica exquisita. El mensaje: de primera,porque en verdad con o sin luz para ver las maravillas del Universo,un ciego es capaz de sentirlas.
Amazing music. I've never heard this duet before.
Qué maravilla!. Han escuchado su disco de arias rusas?, es realmente fenomenal. Es una tremenda intérprete de este repertorio.
Thank God for Tchaikovsky
Anna Netrebko & Rolando Villazon - Jolante (tchaikowsky)
What a triumphal performance success!
Это и моя любимая оперная пара!
I love it how Tchaikovsky takes the last word here.
Вилазон, поющий по русски- это что то! Но голос прекрасно звучит, акцент невелируется, браво, молодцы!😊
Perfektno !!!!!!
His voice is very similar to voice of Domingo.He is very good tenor,I like him.
Subline Performance. What more can one say !!!!!!
I like the way he hasn't put on weight that way he'll last out my life time 🎉
Thank you for this video.
A dream team!!!♥
SIMPLY THE BEST!!!!
If only she still sounded this great