U-534 - Time Capsule Submarine

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 янв 2025

Комментарии • 144

  • @louiehooper5623
    @louiehooper5623 6 лет назад +131

    I had the good fortune of touring U505 in Chicago in 2009. The restoration was very well done.

    • @BAZZAROU812
      @BAZZAROU812 6 лет назад +13

      Rookie Trucking 101 My friend said it was pretty awesome as well.. Chicago seems like a weird place for a u boat

  • @alexwild4350
    @alexwild4350 5 лет назад +18

    To the commentators who ask why she was cut up - There never was a plan to restore it. The move to the museum was the boats final hope else being cut up for scrap was the final solution. The company that owns the sub and the museum moved it off the mainland to the spit of land where she now lays because their business is the operation of the cross river ferry, as Mr Felton suggests in the video. Therefore the exhibit of the sub is to encourage people to take the ferry....to see the sub. This is how she is earning her keep now. Missing from Mr Feltons narrative, is the U534 was travelling in the company of two other subs at the time of her sinking. The other two subs did crash dive - as Mr Felton points out, U534 as a wreck came to rest in a little over 200 feet of water which is enough to submerge the boat in. The reason for U534 staying afloat is clouded by time, other than its suggested with her heavy anti aircraft guns, she was best placed to fend off the aircraft.
    Its worth noting that aircraft travelling in pairs did become more "worrying" than perhaps 24 months earlier when they tended to be alone. This might sound obvious, but it hides the allied technology, revealed by history. The first of the pair of planes to attack dropped plain depth charges as you'd expect. The whole point of this aircraft attack was to intimidate the Sub and get her to crash dive. If they sunk it with a lucky strike, all well and good. But the real weapon was carried in the second aircraft. This was the Mark 14 mine which was the allied code name for our first acoustically homed torpedo. Now it becomes apparent why the first aircraft role was to get the sub to crash dive. With the sub in crash dive and engines thrashing to get the boat under quickly, noise was the last thing on the crews worry list and this provided the perfect sound source for the homing torpedo to home in on, do its job, and kill the crew and with them the sub.
    Missing from Mr Feltons production is that I think one of the depth charges might have landed on U534s deck, rolled off the side and exploded by one of the prop shafts, bending this sizeable chunk of metal. It also ruptured the pressure hull in the engine room, and this sealed the fate of the sub. The crew were lucky or unlucky perhaps that the second aircraft was not carrying a Mark 14 mine, but plain old depth charges. The Mark 14 mine became Fido, which you can find on RUclips as an American training video. One of the video's is a US Navy training film about how they work, including the later versions which go into search patterns under water listening for their prey. There is also a recording of a real 1945 attack by Corsairs if I remember right, using Sonar Buoys dropped in the Atlantic which are equipped with small radio transmitters allowing the overhead air crew to listen into the ocean and track the target submarine, before once again, dropping a Fido Torpedo in the right spot, which they do. This is about as close as you can get to "being there" to listen to this recording made in real time.
    Bdu in Germany, with Mr Donitz, knew they were losing Uboats but they had no idea why, simply because there were no survivors who made it back to tell the tale.
    Late in World War 2, being on a Uboat was a seriously bad choice for a long and prosperous life.

  • @herbwag6456
    @herbwag6456 6 лет назад +142

    Too bad it couldn't have been preserved in it's raw rust form. But this far better than scrapping.

  • @nachtjager77
    @nachtjager77 5 лет назад +47

    Cutting this boat up was an absolute sin - whoever had this idea needs to be slapped repeatedly. Such an outrage to do this to such a historical artifact.

  • @fastboy5557
    @fastboy5557 6 лет назад +24

    This reminds me of the time I went to visit the Museum of Science+Industry and saw the U-505 captured on June 4th 1944, 2 days before D-Day

  • @chriscarbaugh3936
    @chriscarbaugh3936 6 лет назад +8

    I was in the in about ‘99 as well. There was a great picture of the man who paid to raise the boat, he had this fantastic smile. I will never forget it. Gold, diamonds, probably not, but that smile. For me it’s a shame they cut her and up and preserved U-534. I did 6 years in the US Navy and served on boats.

  • @charleskettering2626
    @charleskettering2626 6 лет назад +21

    Really enjoy your videos, it's amazing that you can put as much information in four minutes that others take fifteen.

    • @kevinanderson3849
      @kevinanderson3849 5 лет назад +1

      Unfortunately, his "info" is sometimes nearly trash...like that assertion "Adolf Hitler had died 6 days before"...Mr. Felton, update your 1940s/50s info... Read the FBI reports of June/july '45 stating that Hitler had fled Germany and had reached southern Argentina, where he had an estate ready for him and his entourage. The dictator lived out the rest of his life down there till he passed away in the early '60s.

  • @amfriendly6723
    @amfriendly6723 6 лет назад +32

    i lived right next to it for a while i used to pass it on the way to school it just sat there for a while till one day it just vanished and i later saw it being moved into place in the ferry terminal

  • @SupesMe
    @SupesMe 6 лет назад +144

    Those guys died just days from the end of the war, Britts and Germans alike 😞

  • @johnlowell5905
    @johnlowell5905 6 лет назад +5

    Mark, I used to think I had a pretty extensive knowledge of military history having read at least a thousand books on the topic, but you continue to amaze me with your videos. Great job!

  • @daqt6079
    @daqt6079 6 лет назад +3

    I just recently discovered this channel. Simply wonderful. The subject matter, narration, music. Each of these videos come together to form a perfect little gem. I look forward to many more.

  • @Mikey-pq4zf
    @Mikey-pq4zf 6 лет назад +33

    My dad went scuba diving and saw the sunken U-260 off the coast of county cork here in Ireland

  • @kaltonian
    @kaltonian 5 лет назад +3

    Wow, amazing, I love submarines and have had this love for them since watching Das Boat with my dad, I play a computer game called silent hunter 3 and my god its so accurate, what a crazy hard life to live and serve on a uboat,
    You were indeed very lucky to have walked through this historic time piece

  • @MrChizbiz
    @MrChizbiz 6 лет назад +6

    That museum was a big part of my childhood i couldn't wait to be 18 just so i could walk through the u-boats, i was very sad when the museum went bust. I walk by on my way to work and i cant help but fell sorry for the old bastard chopped into chunks like that.

  • @littlejimmy8744
    @littlejimmy8744 6 лет назад +52

    Being the AA crew must have been a rush especially when they shoot down a bomber.

  • @greyone40
    @greyone40 6 лет назад +11

    Another interesting video well done. This might sound funny, but I really like the seashore sound you put on the end, a nice touch. Would really love to see one of these boats in person, yet if I don't it is great to have this kind of documentary to look at. Thanks.

  • @venustus129
    @venustus129 5 лет назад +7

    I agree with just about every comment , it’s a bloody crying shame they chopped it up just to save money. It would of been much better to have restored her in one piece and opened it as a museum that you can walk through. There’s a British sub you can visit in gosport at hms dolphin , I’ve been on it , and it’s also a travesty that the government didn’t keep at least one of our battleships instead of scrapping them all. 😢

  • @andydavidson
    @andydavidson 6 лет назад +7

    i saw u534 in birkenhead in the 90's great to see the terror of the sea's close up, it is a shame it had to be cut up.

    • @MarkFeltonProductions
      @MarkFeltonProductions  6 лет назад +1

      It was quite a sight.

    • @rustykilt
      @rustykilt 5 лет назад

      Was a shame but no choice owing to condition and moving complications..

    • @kevinanderson3849
      @kevinanderson3849 5 лет назад +1

      @@rustykilt - But once it was moved to its present site, they could have welded its three sections back again, at least to look like the original...It wouldn't be too expensive a job, I guess.

  • @belchnasty
    @belchnasty 6 лет назад +4

    Love your videos, short and well researched. Keep them coming please.

  • @seventyfivemm
    @seventyfivemm 6 лет назад +3

    i love your videos mark! i’m so happy to see these videos in my subscription feed

  • @peter-jm1pu
    @peter-jm1pu 6 лет назад +31

    A super rare U boat. What should we do? Let's cut it up why keep it in the original form?

    • @MarkFeltonProductions
      @MarkFeltonProductions  6 лет назад +33

      Yes, the powers that be had some kind of collective stupid moment!

    • @lewisparker4488
      @lewisparker4488 5 лет назад +7

      I do not know but suspect they had to cut it in sections to soak it in tanks to neutralize the salt contamination. Otherwise they would have had to build a tank big enough for the whole thing.

  • @the5thmusketeer215
    @the5thmusketeer215 5 лет назад

    *Each of Mark’s videos is like a unique, highly prized sea shell, that stands out from the crowd...*
    *As I held this one to my ear, I swear I could hear the sound of waves lapping on the shore!* 😉

  • @CentsTwo
    @CentsTwo 6 лет назад +2

    Wow when mark says please subscribe for more he really means MORE!

  • @WeaselKing1000
    @WeaselKing1000 5 лет назад +1

    Saw it in its original state when I visited the museum in summer 2001. They also had the frigate HMS Plymouth, submarine HMS Onyx, and the former Mersey Bar lightship there at the time. Relatives went aboard the U-boat I think, but due to the hazardous nature of the site there was an age restriction in place - being too young, I didn't get the chance to board unfortunately.

  • @jeremyoftitirangi7770
    @jeremyoftitirangi7770 5 лет назад +2

    I was also fortunate enough to walk though the sub when it was in Birkenhead in it's original rusted state as my Wife's family live nearby, as the commentary says it was very eerie but amazing to look at, i'll see if I can find my photos

    • @howardbowen-RC-Pilot
      @howardbowen-RC-Pilot 5 лет назад

      Yep I went through the u534 too. I even have souvenir sweatshirt. Tight squeeze but I was determined. Fascinating experience. So sad it got sliced up.

  • @icecoffee1361
    @icecoffee1361 6 лет назад +22

    I live so close to this sub and it shame they cut it up 👎🏼 but great vid keep them coming 👍🏼

    • @rustykilt
      @rustykilt 5 лет назад +6

      They had no choice. Badly deteriorating, and the cost and complications of moving in one piece were daunting. At least the boat was saved and restored....

  • @BELCAN57
    @BELCAN57 6 лет назад +6

    An explanation of the HMS Barham tragedy would be most interesting. As always, fascinating video.

  • @kingerikthegreatest.ofall.7860
    @kingerikthegreatest.ofall.7860 6 лет назад +5

    Very interesting. Although not a ww2 or German submarine , I've been been on several tours of the uss blueback. It's amazing how cramped the older subs were.

  • @HRHooChicken
    @HRHooChicken 6 лет назад +9

    We always do things the shit way in Britain. Rather than preserve the whole thing we chopped it up and ruined it to save money.

  • @lonecrapshooter67
    @lonecrapshooter67 5 лет назад +1

    Mark, your videos are very intriguing, informative, and interesting

  • @frankwhite3406
    @frankwhite3406 5 лет назад +3

    They have wrecked a perfect and intact example of a classic U Boot!

  • @TheDeJureTour
    @TheDeJureTour 6 лет назад +19

    Hi. I am upset that your two other recent reupload videos have been tampered with by RUclips. It doesn't sit right with me. Just wanted to throw that out there into the 'net-o-sphere.

  • @johnblue8907
    @johnblue8907 5 лет назад +2

    I remember seeing this U boat in Birkenhead before it was cut into sections. The AA guns were very impressive, as was the deformed hull on the underside near the propellers (obvious site of a depth charge or bomb)

  • @fabianreusch4870
    @fabianreusch4870 5 лет назад +10

    One can also visit U995 near Kiel...
    It just stands there on a beach as a museum, open for visitors 👍

  • @colinwithey1906
    @colinwithey1906 6 лет назад +4

    Love right by it. It was diamond cut and can be rejoind together

  • @mashbury
    @mashbury 5 лет назад +2

    Makes you wonder what type of "Ankers" were at the meeting that decided to chop up a intact U Boat... goes to prove that some museum staff just don't have a clue...

  • @CarLos-yi7ne
    @CarLos-yi7ne 6 лет назад +2

    A real shame that it was cut in peices! 😢😢😢
    And of course you can see the rusty stripes on the grey paint...
    Would have been so much better when it was put inside in the state as it was.

  • @JD-tl7ld
    @JD-tl7ld 6 лет назад +6

    Ein trauriges Ende für ein schönes altes Mädchen.

    • @johannesgaida3137
      @johannesgaida3137 6 лет назад +2

      Immernoch besser als die 3 typ 20 uboote in Hamburg

  • @Mick_A_Knuckle
    @Mick_A_Knuckle 5 лет назад +3

    1:40 How the heck did five men escape from a hatch when the boat was under 220 feet of water? The pressure at that depth would be over six atmospheres! Perhaps they escaped from the hatch as the boat was starting to descend. Otherwise, a great clip once again Mark.

  • @Timotheus157
    @Timotheus157 5 лет назад +2

    Brave warriors. Heartfelt salute to all of them!

  • @fasthracing
    @fasthracing 6 лет назад +4

    Been to see it. It is a real shame it has been cut up in this way

  • @felixangellopezalonso3993
    @felixangellopezalonso3993 5 лет назад

    I saw it in Greenå, Denmark, in 1996 all rusty over the supports was awesome.

  • @amesbancal
    @amesbancal 5 лет назад

    Encore une vidéo passionnante ! Merci

  • @russwoodward8251
    @russwoodward8251 5 лет назад

    A great story. Thanks.

  • @filipmilewski7065
    @filipmilewski7065 6 лет назад +1

    Your vids are awesome continue doing them mate ;)

  • @bryanhurd9955
    @bryanhurd9955 6 лет назад +6

    The u boat capt shown here looks like Eric Topp who was never sunk,and ended up the most successful uboat capt

  • @mnemonicsghost1492
    @mnemonicsghost1492 5 лет назад +1

    Yes Germany .. أعشق ألمانيا انا مصري

  • @gravyboat2370
    @gravyboat2370 5 лет назад +1

    I've visited this and it's very good. 🖒

  • @michaelthompson342
    @michaelthompson342 5 лет назад

    An excellent presentation!

  • @johnwrigley1624
    @johnwrigley1624 5 лет назад

    It should be mentioned that while U-534 was at Birkenhead,the conning tower was reskinned,and they did a fantastic job.If you look at pics of just after she arrived,you'll see what I mean.

  • @craftpaint1644
    @craftpaint1644 5 лет назад

    There's a documentary about this U-boat and on it there are a lot of commenters hating on how it had to be cut up but I look at this way - it was brought back from a sinking and that's only happened I think one other time before though no one lied about the cargo.

  • @Red-rl1xx
    @Red-rl1xx 6 лет назад +2

    Great video!

  • @redactedagentdataexpunged9431
    @redactedagentdataexpunged9431 6 лет назад +3

    What is the music during the intro

  • @davidbarlow431
    @davidbarlow431 5 лет назад +4

    I was also lucky enough to go on board before she was butchered. What happened to her was nothing short of archeological vandalism on a massive scale.

  • @yellowboy1866
    @yellowboy1866 6 лет назад +2

    How thick was the pressure hull?

  • @brianpeters7847
    @brianpeters7847 5 лет назад

    So nice to hear a human voice. I'm to the point now that if I hear those Metallic voices I leave site and say why in the comments

  • @kowalski363
    @kowalski363 6 лет назад +1

    Great video

  • @gazlyno
    @gazlyno 5 лет назад +2

    We all hate it being cut up!!!

  • @leary4
    @leary4 6 лет назад

    The Museum of Science and Industry has a u boat u can walk through it's pretty cool. I met a sub sailor that griped about everyone knowing about that sub and no one knowing about the American one at the end of Navy peer (kind of a big Chicago draw). At the time he was right I had no idea. It looks like they've done a good job with this one especially considering how long she was underwater. Preservation takes an insane amount of money it's good to see it found a benefactor.

  • @skny2282
    @skny2282 5 лет назад +2

    I rather see it rusty in whole piece but cut and painted in 3 pcs. Second tragedy to this boat.

  • @sprocket580
    @sprocket580 5 лет назад

    I believe the sections that the sub was cut in was done so it could be welded back together rather early. Ateast that's what I read.

  • @Jason-qx5qr
    @Jason-qx5qr 2 года назад +1

    What a shame they had to chop up that beautiful u boat, i would have loved to see it restored to its former glory

  • @anthonymcdonnell6615
    @anthonymcdonnell6615 5 лет назад +7

    was better intact not in pieces

  • @marcconyard5024
    @marcconyard5024 5 лет назад +1

    Just imagine what turn the war may have taken if the KM had reached the magic figure of 300 Uboats available for service! Wonder if those Liberators were from 224 Sqn?

  • @brettlloyd4446
    @brettlloyd4446 6 лет назад +1

    German u boats were on a roll early in ww2 like during battle of Atlantic sinking many allied merchant ships on their way to england, later allied aircraft and destroyers started attacking the u boats sinking most of them

  • @randomlyentertaining8287
    @randomlyentertaining8287 5 лет назад

    Atleast she's been saved. I'd rather be able to walk through the as there is no reason not to be able to but this is better than being buried like garbage or scrapped.

  • @ahall442
    @ahall442 5 лет назад

    Any idea if a partially sealed sub has been found but due to the depth, too hard to get at..?

  • @gravedigr12
    @gravedigr12 5 лет назад +1

    I remember this sub I was and still am pissed it was hacked to bits ''but it was saved'' I guess if you call chopping it to bits saved when it was in one piece then sure you ''saved'' it. what a sad day when they cut her up.also I notice you didn't show the parts where some chunks of the boat were gutted and had cheesy monitors in them.

  • @bryanhurd9955
    @bryanhurd9955 6 лет назад +4

    If they allow walk through,s of the boat they will get more visitors.

    • @lewisparker4488
      @lewisparker4488 5 лет назад +2

      People would rob it blind of anything that can be unscrewed and carve their names on everything else. Best go see it as the snow flakes will have it junked because it scares them and keeps history alive so they can't live in their dream world!

    • @kevinanderson3849
      @kevinanderson3849 5 лет назад +1

      @@lewisparker4488- Why do you think the Brit people would behave in an uncivilized way ? If the Germans allow their visitors to walk through the interior of the U-995 and U-2540, without anyone stealing or ruining anything, the same correct behaviour can be expected from the Brit citizens, too.

  • @Trillock-hy1cf
    @Trillock-hy1cf 5 лет назад

    I think that submariners must have nerves of titanium to live, work and fight in such cramped quarters.
    I remember visiting HMS Alliance a WWII submarine at Gosport many years ago, where the public get a tour around the inside if it.

  • @Rif_Leman
    @Rif_Leman 5 лет назад

    You were given an opportunity to walk through and only took one photograph?

  • @quasarhi
    @quasarhi 6 лет назад +1

    Brillant !

  • @Davidkxf
    @Davidkxf 5 лет назад

    Have you toured the one in Kiel?

    • @MarkFeltonProductions
      @MarkFeltonProductions  5 лет назад

      No, but I've been on the Type XXI in Bremerhaven and of course the one in Birkenhead before they chopped it up.

  • @memikell
    @memikell 5 лет назад +3

    What a stupid shot sighted decision to chop it up!

  • @flybobbie1449
    @flybobbie1449 5 лет назад

    I think where it is now is a missed opportunity to have a memorial for all that lost their lives at sea. They could list all the boats and subs that operated the North Atlantic seeing as this is just over from the Admiralty museum.
    Could have panels with silhouettes of all the ships lost. I think the US museum has that.
    In fact i know a company that could laser cut the panels. If done free could be some good publicity for his company.

  • @petertimowreef9085
    @petertimowreef9085 5 лет назад

    Isn't a depth charge used to attack a U-boat on the surface just a regular bomb..?

  • @lexington476
    @lexington476 6 лет назад

    Did they find any gold on board?

  • @alanstrong3295
    @alanstrong3295 5 лет назад +1

    It is a shame that Germany did not form an alliance with the US and Great Brittain to defend Europe against the USSR. Old Man Russ would not have gotten too far.

  • @Jeffybonbon
    @Jeffybonbon 5 лет назад

    well worth seeing

  • @adrianlarkins7259
    @adrianlarkins7259 5 лет назад +8

    Much effort went into recovering this U boat intact but typical of British left wing politics and sheer bloody ignorance, they cut it up into bits. I would be fuming had I been part of the recovery team.
    She should have been preserved and the loose contents displayed separately.

  • @shmotown
    @shmotown 6 лет назад +4

    What was the purpose of its mission? Why risk being sunk in the final days of the war?

    • @kevinanderson3849
      @kevinanderson3849 5 лет назад +1

      Because there was a war going on, and Germans fight till the very last second of it ! They're not ITALIANS !

  • @LD-wm7jm
    @LD-wm7jm 6 лет назад

    the museum is fucking great its in birkinhead near liverpool

  • @patrickmcleod111
    @patrickmcleod111 5 лет назад

    **Couldn't they have maybe angled the area around the sub's main hatch downward, away from the hatch, so that you don't always get 3 gallons of water dumped over your head and upper body every time you open the damn thing to climb up? That MUST'VE really sucked in winter time in really cold regions of the Atlantic, to have ice-cold seawater dumped onto your head, and all over the floor of the main bridge for people to slip and fall on!**

  • @donavanrupard6219
    @donavanrupard6219 5 лет назад

    I have been on U-505 in and it was very cool but could not be challenged by a raw Boat just raised from the sea

  • @haydendavies8638
    @haydendavies8638 5 лет назад +1

    IT'S A WONDERFUL FIND, IT'S A SHAME SOME IDIOTS CAME UP WITH THE IDEA TO CUT THE U BOAT IN TREE. JUST DISGRACEFUL.😲😲😲😲😲😲

  • @SupesMe
    @SupesMe 6 лет назад +1

    Doc this makes me think 🤔 and if anybody knows the answer you do. Who was the last official guy to die during the war in Europe? I mean before the surrender not at Nuremberg

  • @donjones4719
    @donjones4719 5 лет назад +1

    In a U-boat of that date I'd have been looking for a 4-rotor Enigma coding machine. As valuable as gold and diamonds!

  • @backchat8086
    @backchat8086 6 лет назад +2

    Nice

  • @masterwrench4252
    @masterwrench4252 5 лет назад

    ...so I take it we didn't find any gold 🤗 Hey Mark, ever hear the one about the liberty ship with like 500 Haeley Davidson WLAs all packed in cosmaleene waiting to be found?

    • @masterwrench4252
      @masterwrench4252 5 лет назад

      Wait, my bad, not wla...the more rare xa (harleys answer to the bmw)

  • @johnsonricky007
    @johnsonricky007 5 лет назад

    But was there gold on it??

  • @Anairofdeath
    @Anairofdeath 5 лет назад

    i remember going to this years ago with my dad when i was a kid.....sure there was a destroyer and a cold war submarine too???

  • @kingjamesviscotland241
    @kingjamesviscotland241 6 лет назад +5

    Oh oh, we have the snowflakes reporting this channel to RUclips. Please make a backup channel. Your content is excellent.

  • @checkpointcharlie1788
    @checkpointcharlie1788 6 лет назад +5

    What?! Only four or five U-boats left in existence? Hey, I've got a great idea, let's cut one of them up in to pieces! It would have been better off left at the bottom of the ocean.

    • @wirelessone2986
      @wirelessone2986 6 лет назад

      Really?Shipwreck divers especially around Britain strip them clean...even using explosives on a ww1 uboat to pull out the entire torpedo tube assembly.For decades shipwreck divers have no concern for war graves...they may say they do.ww1/ww2 shipwrecks are a relic hunters dreams.Your lucky she was rescued.

  • @bread5020
    @bread5020 5 лет назад

    i would prefer it being choped rather than scraped. If they didnt chop it, it could be scraped

  • @dookucastro4835
    @dookucastro4835 6 лет назад

    Well? Was gold found or Not?! Don't leave us hanging!

  • @duckman5642
    @duckman5642 6 лет назад

    Any gold?

  • @sassiebrat
    @sassiebrat 6 лет назад +1

    No Nazi gold? Greetings from So Calif, USA!

  • @mcredsox16
    @mcredsox16 5 лет назад +2

    Love your videos make but you even know hitler escaped to South America. He didn’t die in no bunker in Berlin!

    • @zebradun7407
      @zebradun7407 5 лет назад

      Doesn't matter he is dead now one way or the other.

    • @kevinanderson3849
      @kevinanderson3849 5 лет назад +1

      @@zebradun7407 - But it's HIGH TIME the world is told the truth ! It is understandable that in May '45 the Allies didn't want to admit that Hitler had gotten away, but in the 21st century we can't go on with such stories forever...The FBI admitted it in July '45, as can be seen in their files now open to the public.

  • @mrdoge9508
    @mrdoge9508 6 лет назад

    couldnt they sail it there underits own power?

  • @paulvanappeven3340
    @paulvanappeven3340 6 лет назад

    👍🏻