Tap to unmute
She Killed Her Family at 16 | The Erin Caffey Interview | Piers Morgan
Embed
- Published on Mar 12, 2026
- At just 16 years old, Erin Caffey orchestrated the brutal murder of her entire family.
ep1 • She Killed Her Family ...
ep2 • Piers Morgan meets Ama...
She should never get out. She’s a psychopath.
Even for pure justice sake, she should never get out.
Totalmente psicópata
@robk1310 то же самое подумала, что её нельзы выпускать на свободу. Она милая, красивая, говорит об эмоциях, плачет. Нюрна способна на что угодно, любую манипуляцию ради достижения своей цели. И никого ей не жаль, даже парня, который ради неё убил. Она должна сидеть пожизнено. А её отец принять, что он воспитал такую часть себя, убийцу.
@robk1310 psychopaths have feelings too. Wait
I don't know man. Even psychopaths don't usually kill their caregivers, unless the caregivers don't really give them proper care and education, or maybe even emotionally/physically abuse them. Without knowing how she grew up and what happened behind the closed family door, it's not our position to judge.
My parents often boasted to their friends that I never cried as an infant. And I just smiled when they talked about how good a baby I was. But little did their friends know, for example, once when I was crying, my father was so annoyed and he put a pillow onto my mouth to try to quiet me. Families are often much more sinister than what are presented to the outer world.
Wrong choices is stealing sweets from the corner shop not murdering your entire family 🙄
Do not judge !!! You never know why she did it, what went through her mind at the time, the human mind is mostly unknown. Some people just snap. I feel sorry for such people.
@grahamt19781 There haven't been corner shops with sweets in her entire lifetime. It's not 1950. At 16, I was tripping acid and sleeping around. Those are more real world wrong choices that people make than your outdated analogy.
@grahamt19781 so true
Yer think!!
☹️ True
Look at her eyes. There’s no soul there No emotion. Never a straight answer. She’s a complete psycho!
@aleiorgu I hate the fact that I like this comment but it’s overwhelmingly true
@aleiorgu OMG! That's the first thing I've noticed about her "SOUL-LESS EYES"!!!
If you cannot emotionally connect with anything resembling love or what we consider 'good' etc, then it would be easy to do what she did, and then lie about it all without the micro expressions we all have, especially with our eyes.
she only pays attention to herself and her situation when answering questions. no empathy.
She never even mentions her poor brothers
That's the definition of a psycho.
Right!? Not once 😢
ITS CALLED EDITING.
@darrenmullally766 never once.
@darrenmullally766 Those people...they never change!
I’d sooner kill myself than hurt my family like this, especially my baby brother
Bc you my dear are a human being with love in your heart for those other than yourself, empathy, and a moral compass. I hope there are a lot more of us than the demonic people walking among us
There absolutely bonkers 😮
❤❤❤❤❤
@pinkrebellionxyz1567 suicide is not the way either. Etenal payment in hell
Because you don't have abusive parents. I, as example, wouldn't shed a tear if someone kills my parents.
How did it go from "I want my parents killed" to "Kill my brothers, too". That little boy hiding in the closet made me so sad.
@mrscnln my only guess is to not leave any witnesses as sickening as that is.
😢
I cried when I heard how Tyler died. I just imagined my own little boy hiding scared in a closet and then being brutally stabbed. So freaking evil!
behind Erin's eyes there is nothing, empty, void
yes, she tries to use her blonde hair and blue eyes for innocence
that is not the truth
Totally no emotion all forced
Same as Piers
@gitanorobacobre4061 Before they said she said she was physically abused - I was thinking I bet she said that. Like Jodi Arias & Casey Anthony...
She is another level of evil. Nobody cares that you can sing, absolutely never be released ever.
I skipped that song cause i knew it was bs
Avec la nouvelle l'oie sur les mineurs elle sera libérée
@MichaelJ_OM How is it BS? It's a real song and she really sang it.
@folksurvivalshe was singing it to put a front on to look good.
She is very Christ-like. ❤
her dad is downplaying everything but that girl is NOT innocent. She's cold, calculating and never needs to be let out. Ever.
That’s his coping mechanism. To accept his daughter for who she is would mean his entire family is dead. His delusion allows him to keep one family member alive.
He is her father, some level of denial is just natural. His brain needs to protect itself.
Like a lot of religious people he thinks if he can forgive the pain will go away. It won’t, it’ll just hide and come back to bite him hard. It must be so hard to face it. Poor man.❤
@Rose-jr5eu her dad, seems a bit none too bright too
@Rose-jr5eu er ist ihr Vater. Mehr kann an dazu nicht sagen.
She won't ever answer a question directly.
Psychopaths never do. Watch the Casey Anthony interrogation videos. If you can stomach it
Very telling.
She's a very evil woman.
Just thought the same
@AmberNimmons Just like a politician.
That's kinda one of the tell tell signs for abused children.
Her little brother hiding in the closet 😢
@joeylaird77 I know !! It’s sickening to think what that poor child went through. It takes a very dangerous individual to hunt down a small defenceless, terrified child and slaughter them with a samurai sword! He should never be freed. He needs the death penalty. Regardless, hell awaits him one day.
@joeylaird77 crying 😭
@joeylaird77 😭😭😭
😭💔
💔
I cannot even imagine the pain the father must feel. How heartbreaking.
I bet he was thninkg "what did I did wrong"
Yes. But he is supporting her . Saying she's not evil you know your children.
Hearing him breakdown when the police tell him his daughter was greatly involved 🥺🥺
And her father is in denial, she is the only one left in his family and he dose not want to believe she is responsible. This is so very sad and shocking 😢🙏
She loves herself so much that she has no feelings for others. She's a sociopath
Psychopath
She’s a psychopath, said by many professionals that met her
She doesn't love herself either.
@danieldelbravo1781 psychopath
@danieldelbravo1781 wrong… psychopath… no remorse… no emotion… self absorbed… good at manipulating… but due to the sheer brutality of her actions she’s a psychopath… NOT a sociopath!
She is just as big a monster as the boys that did the killing
@Darthritus1 aren't you emotional?
Absolutely
@davidformica1969 no sirve más ella ..es un demonio
@Darthritus1быть эмоциональным это быть жевым, а он такой иза ужаса переживает, это нормально, ваш вопрос дикий, почему эмоцеональный😮
@Darthritus1 Why are you so weird asking such a strange question. what is emotional about that comment.
She sounds like a clinical psychopath. And a remarkable liar.
@Mimicassreads No one can be diagnosed as a psychopath because it’s not a medical disorder that exists. Maybe you’re thinking of antisocial personality disorder
She’s saying about wrong choices all kids make wrong choices but to slaughter your whole family that’s a psychopath
Yeah, most likely.
Sadly there is a small percentage of people on this planet that literally are born Psychopaths.
I just wanted to mention that. For a quick explanation I put "psychopath" and "prefrontal cortex" in Google this is the Ai summary that comes up:
"Psychopaths often show structural and functional differences in the prefrontal cortex (PFC), particularly the ventromedial PFC (vmPFC), leading to impaired impulse control, poor decision-making, and reduced empathy, as this area normally regulates emotions and social behavior. This dysfunction, along with weaker connections to the amygdala, disrupts moral judgment and planning, manifesting as the hallmark traits of psychopathy, such as aggression and lack of guilt."
So yeah. The world is sometimes a hard, painful and complex place to live in.
I couldn’t believe it when she was talking about wrong choices. That makes it sound like she did something accidental, not planned the murder of her parents!
She is saying what she heard from others, from the counselor. her head is empty so is her heart. She is underdeveloped mentally it’s kinda being disabled in the head.
Господь ,бедный отец,потерял любимых и нашел прощение в своем сердце к психопатке дочери.просто нет слов как его жаль.дай бог ему сил и здоровья,и пусть он обретет счастье❤
@brettknight2314 Exactly, what happened to running 🏃♀️ away
Not one ounce of ownership . She is a complete lunatic.
NOT a laughing matter but that was hilarious !
@t4oomf442 What is hilarious ?🤔
@irenemorley75 to me the singing of amazing grace was pretty funny. She comes across as a little narcissistic.
@traceyraybould7148 i agree
True. She didn’t shed one tear. Her mouth moves but her eyes are dead.
She complete monster. Poor father is in complete denial. Absolutely got him.
Yes she is.
Exactly, thought the same thing. He has too otherwise would go crazy
The thoughts of that boy hiding in the wardrobe and those horrible evil creatures murdering him like that with a sword. Breaks my heart
Even in this interview she is obviously lying!
she deserves life to rot in jail for what she did
I agree
Her design was to annihilate her whole family. Money and lust motivated the monster.
She should then burn in hell for eternity.
yeah my question is why tf isn't she? And why are the pawns in her game copping life in jail? She told them her parents abused her ffs HOW
That's not a just punishment. Execution is.
skipped as soon as she started singing girl shut up 💀
Lmao yess😂😂
Me too! 😂
@trinaesthetic1 same here, I skipped
@trinaesthetic1 jealous?
I hadn't made my assessment of her guilt or innocence within the first 15 seconds of the documentary.
But I didn't want to be subjected to some nobody I'd ever heard of singing some religious shit @ me.
So I skipped the song too.
She should never be released or never be allowed near those graves, that would be an insult to her mom and those poor boys. Pure evil with a sweet voice
Зло в красивой упаковке...
@tommurphy3671 hated her singing
Oh get over yourself 😊
I agree with you I can't believe she said she wants to visit the graves. That made me sick to my stomach
She's empty
I wish he’d asked her more about her baby brothers. Those sweet boys.
Since my little sisters were babies (adopted) I felt fiercely defensive if them. I cannot imagine anyone hurting them. 😒 💔
The brothers were killed for their share or the family inheritance!
She’s 16 i doubt she gives a shit about inheritance
@hanagannat3873why not???!!!!
@hanagannat3873 If Erin Caffey did not have her innocent little brothers killed to steal their inheritance then she is more psychotic than anyone imagined! But I do suspect she wanted it all!!! All that Satan had to offer!!!
Zero emotion. The fact that her 9 year old brother was stabbed to death with that sword whilst trying to hide in a closet and for literally 0 reason -- horrific. She then had sex with the guy that did it. Evil.
Being interviewd about murdering your family and being comfortable enough to sing a song before hand is absolutely insane... Straight up nutter
Not just a song. A song that is used to honor fallen firemen. She put other lives in danger that night too, not just her family. How low can she go singing THAT song.
Right??!! 🧐🧐😬😬😳😳
@PaulJones-g2k agreed 💯 I was shocked it did not sit well with me at all
I'm pretty sure she sang it at the end, when she got more confortable. Not saying she's fine but editing is a very powerful tool.
Wear makeup. Sing like she was at an audition!
She has been diagnosed as a psychopath . She feels no remorse and is considered very dangerous . She should never be set free . In other interviews she is frightening to watch . Pure evil .
@Onel756 Really ? Where does it say she was diagnosed as a psychopath . Not that I disagree with that diagnosis but I'm just wondering where/what/who diagnosed her
She's not dangerous.
@tomburke6642 Thank you for that compelling argument. You've convinced me
@tomburke
Elle a tué sa mère et ses frères et elle n’est pas dangereuse?
I think 10 years enough for Erin and her Father miss her and she miss him!
voice of erin's therapist tells you everything
Wow , Shes Cold !! Been inside for 8 years and still processing !! Really !!! , No Regret , No Remorse , No feelings for her Mother and Brothers . Cold , Calculated , Murderer .
this is what i found in her no remorse, just a cold blooded murderer
@markstow9981 the singing at the beginning 🙄 I'm only a couple minutes in
insanity?
Exactly!
She was suppressing a smile more than once and tried to make it look like she was upset. Chilling.
no sympthy for her whatsoever. murder is murder.
I feel bad for some murders depending on circumstances. But not when its out of pure fucjing spite like this 😭
They dressed her in white like she is an angel. Awful person
@kasiawieteska cockroaches have white blood too.
@kasiawieteska and make up!
@kasiawieteska
that's prison attire. White is a shade, not a color. So what color would you prefer?
Yeah, where did she get the make up?
She is in a Texas prison. That is what they wear all the time.
She doesn’t answer ONE question. Not even ONE!! She pretends she doesn’t understand, pretends she’s slow, low IQed. Pure evil in an angelic mask… 👹
Can't saying any better
Apparently the devil doesn't have a forked tail and horns.
feigned misunderstanding
Psychopaths are good liers.
Good what? : s
@SusanTaylor-f3h you think she had no reason to do what she did.. Yes disgusting and inexcusable.. This is one of those things that can only happen in AMERICA (FUCK NO) may she rot in hell on yes.. But it begs the? WHY? Oh me oh oh my.. There is no way out of this mess now, I'd there,??? No so let's as a community of the world let love prevail) some sing zome wail.. Very fucked up.
that good they tell the truth subliminally whilst telling the lies.
Good manipulators maybe, but this isn't Piers' first rodeo with a psychopathic killer, and whether you like him or not, he's certainly not dumb, he's good at subtly drawing these people out so we can see for ourselves the mask slipping. My instinctive reads of people are lousy, but I'd definitely stay well away from her. And I think she's a lousy liar. She's too lazy and complacent to have thought her persona through, she figured she could just wing it, and she's a narcissistic child just guessing at what her persona should feel, she doesn't know. For example, when asked about feelings about her boyfriend, she mentioned his living conditions, but they are hardly going to be the priority consideration for most humans involved in this regardless of their sympathies. I think she's just guessing at ways to pretend she has empathy.
@SusanTaylor-f3h Liars.
No.E.
Her ex boyfriend told police that she tried to convince him to kill her family. Thats why he broke up wth her. She is a true psychopath.
But the father said he told her she couldn't see him again. He broke it up and she said she wanted to but couldn't. Why not, because the boyfriend was so scary? He fits the profile of a psychopath. Why is there no dialogue with him. She was supposed to be sitting in the car, didn't hear shots, was she drugged as she said?????
@carolkhan8081, he was her ex boyfriend, not the one who killed them.
@carolkhan8081 I find it a bit laughable to hear them fixate on the idea that Erin was the "mastermind" behind this. So, did she "force" those 3 people to go into the house with guns and swords and slay an entire family? Does Erin have supernatural mind control over these people? This is ridiculous. Those 3 people made the choice to be cold-blooded murderers. She wasn't holding a gun to their head. This was their choice.
@carolkhan8081 not the boyfriend who killed them, the previous boyfriend she dated before him. He told police that she had tried to talk him into killing her family, thats why he broke up with her. And then she started dating the new guy who she successfully convinced to do it.
Very manipulative little gal there. I feel so sorry for the dad and his murdered family.
Daddy needs the best psychotherapy available!!!
She's manipulating, she lied to cops and her friends
She is a true primary psychopath!
Ah without a doubt
She didn't answer one question...very, very disturbing
Could be that her lawyers advised her to not jepordise her future parole hearings. It could also be that after almost a decade in prison, she's built up some self-protective defenses within herself to be able to keep going, and isn't about to 'break down' for a TV presenter she's never met and a film crew who are there hoping to get some dramatic footage for their doc.
No sympathy for her. family murder wow gross individual
She might look sweet and innocent but I think she is a complete psychopath who isn't really taking responsibility for what she's done. Her poor father. I feel so sad for him😢
she's even manipulated her father! into forgiving her for killing 3 people, so now she's controlling a traumatised bereaved father and husband.
It seems he's trying so hard to convince himself that she's not evil because she's all he has left of his family
he could be like her?
I don't think she looks sweet and innocent at all.
@Gtvsoopivgt neither do I.. she was cold eyes. Despite tjem trying to cake her in make up and dress her in white. Her girly voice isn't fooling anyone
'I haven't intervieuwed many MONSTERS'
'Thank you'
Erin you deserve life without parole, you evil monster
Slow hand clap
Death is not enough for that creature.
Whoever is sinless pick up the first stone said Jesus
What keep going through my mind watching this is "what kind of people are these? " . Are they even HUMAN? To HUNT for and murder an innocent CHILD hiding in a closet? 😈 👿 🤘 😈 👿 🤘 😈
@rachell2972 they are cold as ice...not human in the full sense of the word imo
Not human at all
@positvgal8it's very difficult to understand...
@natalielamont6955and she seems so calm and normal!
@positvgal8 At this point, it really does not matter whose idea it was; they were extremely cruel. ONE of the 4 could have said NO, let´s not do this. SURE, if it is her idea, it makes it a 100000000000000000000 times worse, but if it wasn´t, she did not stop them. SHE EVEN LAUGHED -she said-when the bf said he had that plan.
She shows no empathy. What a real psychopath. I don't understand how anyone can kill their family.
When asked what she would say at her families graves she couldn't even say sorry.. says it all.
She's incapable of feeling remorse.
@NatiSunbaenim the true act of a psychopath
And a lot of commenters making excuses for her and one even said the brothers may have been abusive. lol. A lot of crazies on here.
She did. I bet in her mind she sorry she didn't get to kill time dad too
ticks all the boxes for a clinical psychopathy diagnosis even over a youtube interview.
Her father, which is a pastor, has remarried and cut off all communication with her. He no longer wants to have anything to do with her. When it first happened, he did try to visit and keep contact with her because he thought it was the right thing to do and he wanted to forgive her. But he realized you can still forgive, but never forget. She still showed no remorse, and he no longer wanted to carry her into his next relationship, and thats completely ok.
He could be the abuser tho
yet some of us go through hell and are still kind
May she never be released!!!
Over 30 years...
My heart breaks for the father 💔💔💔
His view of his daughter's complicity is a defense mechanism! Anything else would be unbearable for the father!!!
It is called the defence mechanism of DENIAL!!! All kinds of afflicted people fall into denial in order to cope! Daddy needs intensive psycho spiritual therapy!
I agree with you. I think that's his coping mechanism to hold on to something that was family. Too bad what's left of his family is pure evil.
He can't allow the truth in. Very sad indeed
She is a true psychopath, no remorse or shame for the lives she took. Scary person! She acts like this innocent little girl and tries to cry during the interview but it’s clearly fake!
Ей жаль себя.
I seen nothing redeemable about this girl. I only see evil
@deemulcahy6553 многих обманывает представление о "невинной" "доброй" овечке которая поет песни
I don’t think it’s fake. She’s upset. Definitely angry and holding the anger back so much that she cannot find the strength to tell the truth. Something is mentally wrong with her. She is angry she was found out and is now jailed for it for the rest of her life. She’s angry she didn’t get away with it. Her manipulation is deep and subversive. She’s not telling truths. Not accepting what she did. She is not confessing after 8 years. That’s sick.
She fakes empathy.
8 years in jail and still processing .. my gosh, may their souls rest in peace 🙏🏻
She hasn't taken any responsibility for anything.. the mind of a cold blooded killer
Some individuals appear human, but in reality, they are heartless monsters, ready to sacrifice their loved ones to satisfy their fleeting, selfish carnal desires
Truth
That’s a fact
Don't understand he (Pierce) give her a forum .
Well if she was a 'demon in human form', then it's a pretty stupid 'demon'. Cos it got locked up for 40 years looking at cell walls. Don't you think that people are capable of barbarous acts, or do you believe they are all nice and only do bad things if they are 'demons in human form'? Just looks like an everyday psychopath to me. But, okay, if you want to bring supernatural beings into it, then go ahead
@VIKTOR-ck3dx It is called 'money'.
I can see her eyes looks like even after 8 years no remorse at all.
I’m currently reading her dad’s book about what happened and I can’t believe that after all of the evidence he doesn’t believe that she was the mastermind. Every professional that has worked with Erin has said she is a psychopath.
@xoxobeauty_by_lynne2895 what's book called please
i don't think he wants to believe it, just like she doesn't want to.
You know what psychopaths are really good at? Fooling those closest to them. I can believe that her father believes that she is innocent, she is really good at faking it.
His mind can not comprehend that his little girl could do that
but what if they are wrong?
Her little brothers 😢 how could she !!! Paying her respect to the grave yard not mama or the brothers names.
If she gets out she will still be a danger
Hoping it will ever happen. They are murderers, cold blooded psychopath murderers. 0 regret even eight years later.
Not only a cold blooded killer but a damn liar.
Dad is in denial
I feel terrible for him, my god, i didn't know how he stands it😔
À aucun moment elle regrette
SHE'S A PSYCHOPATH.
@carolrose3367 she's an insecure, scared little girl who can't handle life
That there is one dangerous soleless woman with absolutely no remorse or compassion, evil would best describe it
An evil soul!!!!
I saw a story from a Christian counselor who spoke with her. She said this girl was the most evil person she had ever met. She was not what she seemed. The counselor said Erin still haunts her.
“Fun loving” and “most likely to succeed”. Then kills her family without remorse. Sounds like a malignant narcissist to me. Psychopath.
That's a perfect description of this piece of garbage
Right and most people fall for their BS, hence winning those titles. Wake up people. They come is all packages, but the signs are always there if you look deep enough.
@dorothydrake8838 shes definitely narcissistic
@dorothydrake8838 I guess in her home schooling, there weren’t many candidates
To be clear though, she wasn't the one who did the killing. I didn't hear any part of the story that said that Erin held a gun to those 3 peoples' heads and forced them to shoot, stab, kill and burn the entire family. Those 3 people made a choice to murder a family.
Still working on taking responsibility ….. Girl, you set the house on fire
she's not a girl.
imagine being borne without empathy , i feel sorry for everyone its one of the most devastating stories i heard about 💔
She's a sick sadistic monster!!!
A demon in a human body
@sk-sb6yx so true and unfortunately you have alot of people like her in the world.
I don’t think she really ‘feels’. As a psychopath she seems to struggle to find the emotional responses that would come naturally to other people. She often seems perplexed by questions that she hasn’t had time to digest and concoct a socially acceptable response to.
Exactly! When Piers asked about the family of Charlie if she feels bad for them that she pushed him to kill her parents she said I never thought about it and then she smiled! She was like wtf Piers what are you talking about?? It never even crossed her mind to think that she destroyed his family too! Absolute disgraceful behaviour!
It is a clear evidence that she had se x right after all was killed,show us a true Psychopath!
That's it, in a nutshell, can't be cured, should never be let out, ever😮
She never thought she could have stopped this. She had 8 years to have done that. But she never did.
@dewinchy maybe she's really dumb?! 🤔
Her father has lost so much. I can't imagine the pain. The way he describes Charlie is exactly what I see in Erin. He can't accept it. He can't see because to do so would mean he has lost everything. He is trying to hold on to this fantasy of the only child he has left. I won't be negative about him. She is a monster. She is a liar. She is a murderer. She killed her mother and 2 brothers. She wanted to take them all out of this world. I hope she rots in jail for the rest of her life. I hope her father finds peace.
@nemera34 i think you explain this the best to be honest on the father
I think you say this the best on the father
So true
I read that he went onto re marry and have another child, god bless him
she tried to take the father too but didnt succeed but yet he is protecting her and forgiving her
Shes not the first girl to plan to kill own family out the blue, to get what she wanted by manipulating the BF to do it. . She orchestrated it, but her dad doesn’t want to believe it but deep down knows she did.
It wasnt out of the blue, she had discussed it with the previous boyfriend. She had been thinking about it for a long time
Her dad wrote a book about this. One of the most disturbing things I ever read. She is evil.
How could you even think about loving someone who murdered your mother and brothers. The lack of remorse from this girl is beyond comprehension!
12:10 "When I look back on it now, this was all just stupid."
"Stupid" is not how I would describe familicide.
I'm no psychologist, but that line alone terrified me and suggests to me she is incapable of remorse or any emotional or moral engagement with her actions whatsoever.
In other words: truly, truly dangerous.
Maybe prison humbled her but in the original police video she was a monster. That monster (devil) is still inside!
Psychopaths are pathological liars. She’s a lunatic and shows no kind of empathy or remorse whatsoever.
The worst thing is her poor young little bro's...didn't even get a chance at life, and she didn't care...
She still does not care. She said nothing about wishing it never happened, missing her Mum.and brothers. Nothing!!
Says she did not hear the gunshots. Lies
Psychopaths are incapable of remorse. At best they learn the right things to say to avoid detection. They do not feel love whatsoever. I have witnessed this personally within my own family or I would not be able to believe it or understand it. It’s incurable and any tears they have are only for themselves. They are incapable of understanding the pain others have even it they are the cause. They are selfish and only concerned with what they want or need. They will lie, cheat, steal or kill and feel nothing. No amount of love, no amount of understanding or compassion helps. When she killed her family it was nothing to her.
She still has evil in her eyes when she glares
That was very unsettling.
The Narcissism (amongst other things) is what I find disturbing and her comment about "paying her respects" as if she's doing a kind thing... I'm not sure if that's more insulting than narcissistic, or not!? Horrific.
Damn she's cold and calculated, can tell she's thinking before speaking, still trying to spin the victim story, and her eyes, that old saying of when someone is smiling but their eyes aren't
So so sad, I was happy to read he went on to remarry and have another child . What an absolutely awful situation for him which he will never get over 😭 💔
To a knowledge,this tradegy hit him and broken so hard,that he remerried to Bobby Johnson,who was involved somehow into murders...I can think of pain inside him went that deep,so Bobby now is a bridge to his family from before before...I have no other explanation how new wife is connected to him,other then through his grief and pain...She is constant reminder of all of it,but yet she might carry huge burden of responsibility, so they somehow help each other to survive that pain
But he married his second cousin you dimwit!! The father here is living in denial. He is holding out hope for his unrepentant psychotic daughter! Forgive the sinner but not the sin! Erin Caffey must “mercifully” work out her repentance in prison until she dies! That is God’s “justice!” God will not be mocked! Erin Caffey needs to remain in prison until she dies! Daddy Caffey must come to grips with this truth! Poor man!
The father should be concerned for his new family, because when Erin gets out of prison in her late fifties she'll still be a psychopath.
@angelikaparshuto6468 Karen is the name of his new wife
@JeffPearce-j1l If you believe in God, then you must also believe that your God allowed that family to die.
There’s no escaping that - if there is a god it’s either impotent or it allows innocent children to die in misery or terror.
She went and had sex with the guy right after the murders...there was no regret or sadness. She got caught. Her crew turned on her. The only person she has is her dad which is terrible bc she didnt want him just as much as she didnt want the redt of her family. But someone has to pay the books and visit her and pay for phone calls otherwise shed truly be alone. Disgusting in so many ways
Exactly, he's simply of use to her😮
Poor man is broken.
Not broken enough to remarry and start another family.
@jesusisapisces He deserves any amount of happiness he gets in the future after what he's been through!
Why the kids?? 💔 Pure evil. To be able to stab a child to death 😢
those babies are now in heaven with Jesus!
She was 16 at the time of the crime. She is now 34.
@Elizabeth-dw6lc 24
24
@Elizabeth-dw6lc not 34, 24. She's been in for 8years so far.
@Elizabeth.dw6lc so what? She's a stone cold killer
@Elizabeth.dw6lc so what? She planned the murders
Nothing more annoying than seeing a killer crying when 1st in custody for their crimes, you know theyre not crying for the victim, theyre crying because they know theyve been caught & the consequences are going to be, or should be, severe & devastating to their futures, as it should be.😢
I feel so disgusted. Boo booing over their lost futures. Meanwhile they just took the lives of another.
C'est un monstre ! Faire tuer sa famille c'est terrible ! Elle cherche toujours à minimiser son acte !
Just the photo of her with Piers advertising the show was seriously chilling 😬
@blackeagle6268 he's a narcissist and psycho too , disgusting
Maybe in his world monsters only take on a male form
assassina mentirosa.
arquitetou tudo com o namorado e diz q não estava envolvida.
Só pensou nela pra ficar com o namorado.
Mentirosa fria e demoníaca.
and i can guarantee being that ive been to tdcj and actually housed right there at the same unit as she is in this interview, that not 1 woman in there would hold her accountable for this horrific act of violence!! and by the fact that people told the interviewer that she can sing amazing grace lets me know that her crime has more or less made her prison famous. and im sure her poor dad is supporting her financially which is no small fee when your are footing the bill of a spoiled self righteous child who wound up in prison. this is all a "game" to her. fubar?? gtfooh!! and she would laugh it off? i mean how ridiculous she sounds.. and no feelings about it whatsoever. its really heartbreaking her parents just wanted better for her, and for that, her family paid a heavy price. my heart goes out to the dad who is obviously doing the best he can to keep it together after such a horrible horrible thing to happen. i need to pray for forgiveness now just for hearing the story im having a hard time not judging the girl and her friends for what they did. smh
Lots Erin is not saying..
The Dad must stay away from Erin...
Ur weird for implying the dad abused her with no evidence
I think you misunderstood this comment
The boys did this murder at her request.
Similar case to Gypsy Rose
Rose had a good reason.. this girl is just disturbing
dad survived but still visits her
WHY is she even given the spot light? The media is the biggest criminal!
@swell_galПолностью с Вами согласна! Делают из них звезд
@swell_gal Because people like you and will watch these. So we are to blame as much.
@swell_gal yeah...out of all the topics and people out there to feature not sure why Piers would choose this...🤔
what if the accused is muslim girl ?what will be the narrative mainstream media play?
Because you are watching it and commenting it.
He will be grieving forever poor father
He forgave the killers. Don't understand that.
Immeasurable pain and mental suffering 😢
@FrankyHaemmer - As strange as it sounds it gives the victim a modicum of peace.
@FrankyHaemmerif u do not understand about forgiveness it's because u need to talk to a lady therapist and ask her what this means
@FrankyHaemmermaybe because he is a TRUE human being just not doing what the average person would expect...A dying breed .. God bless America.. I'm glad I'm an Englishman.
What a monster, may she never be released🙏
“This so called daughter wants to pay her respects to the graveyard”
Is that even a thing..
Does she mean pay her respects to the mother and brother she helped slaughter!!!
Wow what a complete and utter narcissist!
My heart finds her Pappa may he find true peace and grace!
What tragic story !
She's just guessing at what an empathic person would feel, and she hasn't got a clue.
Some murderers like to re-visit their victims, They get a thrill out of it.
I think that is called denial lol she clearly has dissociated from what she has done.
I’m narcissistic but I’m not a fucking psychopath, and pure evil is even worse than psychopathy, she’s fucking like some doll out of a horror film
She doesn't even know what she might say to them at the grave site? Dark.
Just the saddest thing I've ever heard this poor man not only did he lose his whole family his home just to know that your daughter was behind it all i would have had a breakdown myself what a great man his only child left os the one that wanted him killed just so she could be free with a loser
Like Job, god took everything and returned it multiplied 2 fold! Yep that’s the reward of a faithful servant!👹
@JackieHerron-p4k should of been down like a rabid dog.
Wow Piers. What an interview . The strength of the father. His unconditional Love. What a faithful man.
She’s a true monster. My fear when asked what she’ll do when she leaves prison and that she wants to reconnect with her dad, if I was her dad, there would be no way I could trust her not to try to kill me again. She does not deserve to ever be free again
Does not deserve to be on this Planet.
I watched her face during the interview. Absolutely no emotions. Zero. EVIL
Demon
did you watch it with your eyes closed?
@ConicalRamirez she showed emotions but psychopaths are good liars and her emotions were probably all for herself.
@michaelmiller7160 She could only show a little emotions when she felt sorry for herself,that is a real psychopath