Staccato XL VS Masterpiece Arms DS9 VS SA Prodigy!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 янв 2025

Комментарии • 111

  • @theemikeymike
    @theemikeymike 10 месяцев назад +2

    Failed to mention $350 dollar difference but the MPA comes with a metal grip and metal trigger. That’s hundreds more in value added

  • @bryanduchane2371
    @bryanduchane2371 2 года назад +8

    MPA has really stepped up to the game and will only get better!! Looking forward to their first Micro Compact much like the newest Staccato released this week!!!! Very nice shooting!!!

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      I really like that MPA>. its almost cheating hahaa a

  • @thamesford1433
    @thamesford1433 2 года назад +9

    Love my DS9. Best 2011 bang for buck, IMO.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад +3

      For sure. have you seen their raced out version.. MAN.. its cool

    • @armenchuck
      @armenchuck Год назад

      Super amazing things happening right not as MPA right now with the DS 9

  • @thenewgunguy4870
    @thenewgunguy4870 2 года назад +6

    Lovely video. I own a Staccato XL in chrome/dxl black and it’s a beast. It’s my EDC. Never shot a better pistol. Worth very Penny

    • @archerious1972
      @archerious1972 7 месяцев назад +1

      That’s a large gun to EDC. Too hot in Texas for me to carry daily, and many would likely freak out if I was printing nowadays in Houston.

  • @WestPat23
    @WestPat23 Год назад +4

    Just got a DS9 Hybrid today. Cant wait to light it up!

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад

      David.. how do you like your DS9? what color did you get?

  • @jeffw9888
    @jeffw9888 2 года назад +2

    wow smash the start of your video is like star wars in side a spaces ship . I do like the design of the pistols also

  • @ScientificRanking
    @ScientificRanking 5 месяцев назад +1

    Great unbiased honest review on these pistols!

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  5 месяцев назад

      its hard to do as I am very biased hahahaaa.

  • @wendellhatcher7011
    @wendellhatcher7011 Год назад

    Just got my MPA DS9 hybrid ported and it is amazing. Fit and finish easily better than anything outside of an Atlas or that price level. Plan to get a DS9 commander next year.

  • @071Tom
    @071Tom 2 года назад +3

    The problem with the SA is two fold, 1 quality control, of the 4 that my shop has sold 3 had to be shippid back to springfield for problems. 2. all of the parts on it ar MIM tell me how it holds up in several thousand rounds as compaired to the other 2 that use milled bar stock parts.

  • @lifewithob
    @lifewithob 2 года назад +5

    I would definitely say the DS9 is better than the Staccato also.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      for sure. .. When you coming back on the live bro?

  • @gair1944
    @gair1944 3 месяца назад

    I enjoyed your comparison of the Staccato XL versus MPA DS9 (and Prodigy was cool too) But I came for the comparison of the MPA DS9 versus Staccato. I just picked up a Staccato XC and the trigger is measuring 2lbs 1.0 Oz on my Wheeler digital trigger gauge *5 pull avg. Dang. BUT ...I want to get a DS9 and I am leaning toward the DS9 LOC version that is supposedly even more finely tuned and fitted. Great stuff.

  • @evaneason6906
    @evaneason6906 2 года назад +2

    Heard about the 30 super round? Maybe I'm late hearing about it.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      I really trying not to get into too many new rounds.

  • @bryanduchane2371
    @bryanduchane2371 2 года назад +12

    Great pair of guns. The Springfield doesn't belong on the same table/review....

  • @jvz1448
    @jvz1448 2 года назад +3

    Have you shot an Atlas ? If so how does it compare to the DS9? I have a staccato xc and have the opportunity to trade for an Athena but might end up just adding a DS9 instead.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад +2

      ohhh man.. thats a tough one.. seeing how the Atlas is almost twice a DS9.. I would go DS9. Its neck and neck

    • @CandMTactical
      @CandMTactical Год назад +1

      Trade. Take the atlas all day it's on another level

    • @jvz1448
      @jvz1448 Год назад +1

      @@CandMTactical I now have all three. Athena, DS9, and XC. Athena is the best build quality but it’s not a significant difference. My XC is still my favorite because of the comp. I put a steel grip and it’s insanely flat Shooting. The DS9 is very close to the Atlas but I’m probably going to end up selling because I don’t like full size guns all that much typically and the XC and Athena are plenty. I prefer commander size. I’m either going to save for an ares or get the DS9 commander.

    • @dsxz
      @dsxz Год назад +1

      the xc will be flatter, you cant compare a compensated gun to a non comped one no matter how expensive it is.

    • @jvz1448
      @jvz1448 Год назад +1

      @@dsxz I was never comparing the two in terms of how flat they shoot .

  • @timothygarrity5181
    @timothygarrity5181 Год назад +1

    Do you have any issues with activating the safety by accident on the ds9, and have you had any feeding issues with ds9.I have heard mixed things about the ds 9.I was looking at getting one.Also is the grip aggressive enough.The prodigy i won't touch because i have heard of issues luke the slide getting hung up moving slower than it should.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      I love the DS9. I shoot with my thumb holding the safety so its not an issue, but usually no it does not flick it up

    • @timothygarrity5181
      @timothygarrity5181 Год назад

      @SMASHTIME so you come over the top of the safety with your thumb on the draw?.Also is the reset very short, and does it the recoul come straight back without much muzzle rise? I think i might get it.

  • @richki.24
    @richki.24 2 года назад +2

    is this the Springfield MAC had issues with ?

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      yes it was.. Chamber is super tight. as long as your shooting factory ammo your good to go. does not like reloads

    • @Alop777
      @Alop777 2 года назад

      MAC has issues with everything they test. 😁

  • @dr.william.a.horton
    @dr.william.a.horton Год назад +1

    So you’re in North Houston ?

  • @aarsenalfan
    @aarsenalfan 2 года назад +1

    What about that new . 2311ish from Oracle that's coming out in a week or so after Shot Show.?

  • @paulh6101
    @paulh6101 2 года назад +2

    Did u say pocketbook great grandma?

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      I could have said coin purse lolzz.

  • @andycole5957
    @andycole5957 7 месяцев назад +2

    I doubt that Prodigy is completely stock; I have one and had to do a lot of work to get it to run even semi-reliably. Would have to send it to a real 1911 specialist to get it to actually run reliably. I also have an MPA Open for competition and and MPA Commander 4.25" for carry and I would take them over a Staccato any day of the week, especially the Open since Staccato stopped making theirs when they took over from STI. I find Staccato to be too mass produced for the price; they want true custom price, but only offer semi custom quality. I think if Staccato was $1,000 less it would be a hard decision; nicer and more reliable than the Prodigy, but not on the same level as the MPA.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  7 месяцев назад

      I agree.. the Staccatos are very mass produced.. Love my MPA. Also the Prodigy is bone stock.

  • @TheAndrewc5120
    @TheAndrewc5120 Год назад +2

    all i'd be worried about is if i should buy a new ds9 right now or a used one off gunbroker. my only concern is making the choice that lets me use the gun immediately after I receive it instead of going through finding all the bullshit malfunctions that have plagued that gun in the past. I know that if your gun is fucked up, you can send it back and get it taken care of properly. just want to make the right choice.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      For the DS9 the first year was rough.. but its almost all in house now so the QC is great. Mine has been 1000% flawless. well over 4k rounds through it

    • @armenchuck
      @armenchuck Год назад +1

      When MPA switched production facilities, the DS 9 had issues for sure but they have ironed those issues out!
      Exciting things happening at MPA with the entire DS 9 right now!!!

  • @scottnutter1916
    @scottnutter1916 2 года назад +1

    Where would you rank the CZ Parrot in this lineup? Thanks in advance.

    • @michaellussoro2295
      @michaellussoro2295 Год назад

      Czechmate is an open gun , 4 port comp running major PF it’s definitely flatter less dot movement, felt recoil. Can’t beat the price either, cheaper than most 2011 limited guns available. That being said owning one myself nothing beats a 2011 trigger and reset! But all in all phenomenal pistol !

  • @TheFirearmGuy
    @TheFirearmGuy 2 года назад +2

    Enjoyed the video

  • @JESSEverything
    @JESSEverything 9 месяцев назад

    I've got the DS9 Commander and I very much regret not buying the full size. Still a great gun, but it makes me want the big brother.

  • @randyadams03
    @randyadams03 2 года назад +2

    Brought tears to my eyes. Both please, take $$ from my estate when I'm dead.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      hahahaaa.. Randy. just get them now

  • @PeteRamirez-i2q
    @PeteRamirez-i2q 6 месяцев назад

    I have tried the masterpiece arms and didn’t like it as much as the staccato xl
    I own the staccato XL and was also looking into prodigy- but looks like i might try for a NH

  • @fishthis
    @fishthis Год назад

    If you had to pick one 5 " 2011 ?

  • @T.A.B.Videos
    @T.A.B.Videos 2 года назад +2

    Some fine pistols,

  • @absolute99proof
    @absolute99proof 2 года назад +2

    I'm soooo jealous right now!

  • @SurvivalCoupleTX
    @SurvivalCoupleTX 2 года назад +3

    What a great review

  • @GSUnit21
    @GSUnit21 17 дней назад

    Man, I wish they would do these in DLC!!! for the price of these pistols they have to be DLC!!! I have an XC and 3 Korth revolvers and it’s impossible to get another gun after having the DLC finish.

  • @wesleycameron1034
    @wesleycameron1034 2 года назад +3

    Wow bro what is that like 6-8 grand on that table. That’s insane

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      Wish they were all mine hahahaaa..

    • @fishingolf
      @fishingolf 2 года назад

      @@SMASHTIME Great Review. My DS is on the way. Will have my own shootout with my Staccato, OG STI Tactical, and my Prodigy Commander.

  • @MSKH1970
    @MSKH1970 2 года назад +2

    🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @somethingtactical
    @somethingtactical 2 года назад +1

    One day I will move up to the car notes guns!!

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад +1

      If I were to start getting into guns today I would just get this one and be done. the MPA is just that good

  • @legacybarbell7923
    @legacybarbell7923 Год назад +1

    Man I would love to put some rounds through the MPA. I too shoot at SGA!

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      SGA every friday except this next one

  • @MATTP545
    @MATTP545 2 года назад +2

    I have to say I'm slightly jealous.....ok...a whole lot of jealous

  • @vietdmax6.6
    @vietdmax6.6 2 года назад +1

    The prodigy is a good choice for someone that just uses it for what it is and doesn’t want to modify it any. But to to get it neck and neck to the specs and feel of a Stacatto the Prodigy will end up costing more to own.

    • @tommymorgan9293
      @tommymorgan9293 2 года назад +3

      Uh… its perfect to modify. Replace all internals with egw or atlas and you are at 1800 for a gun with just as good internals

    • @danielhenderson8316
      @danielhenderson8316 2 года назад

      And a better optic system if they can ever get any bloody plates in stock.

    • @noclass2gun342
      @noclass2gun342 Год назад

      @Daniel Henderson better than the Dawson DPO, yeah not likely. Not saying it isn't good, but my money's on Dawson

    • @crakka5150
      @crakka5150 Год назад +2

      I’d disagree. Everyone I know who owns the Prodigy has upgraded all internals with Atlas triggers, Wilson hammer and safety, little heavier spring, Taran tactical extended magwell, etc. and turn an average firearm to one that’ll hang with the best of them.

    • @noclass2gun342
      @noclass2gun342 Год назад

      @@crakka5150 that's like dudes who have 2k in a glock 17 talking about glock perfection. Springfield had an opportunity and chose profit over quality. End of discussion

  • @SanteeTV
    @SanteeTV 2 года назад +2

    Omg! Very nice!!!!!

  • @rogerray2545
    @rogerray2545 2 года назад +2

    👍

  • @Aviation_Professional
    @Aviation_Professional Год назад +1

    Looking for a DS9 hybrid as i type this...lol

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      Its my absolute favorite pistol. Shoots so sweet and its such a nicely made gun

  • @tommymorgan9293
    @tommymorgan9293 2 года назад +3

    Should of had the bul armory instead of the prodigy

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      I have shot the Bul Armory.. its my least favorite

  • @richki.24
    @richki.24 2 года назад +3

    Just by the way they look I can't afford either ...

  • @105Flintrock
    @105Flintrock 2 года назад

    To bad you didn't have a Bul Armory Tac 5 to include in your lineup.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад +1

      shot it. I like it the least.

  • @westtexas3041
    @westtexas3041 2 года назад +1

    Great video.

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад

      Thank you. I worked hard on it and it seemed to not really catch on yet lolzz

  • @carsoncrush2963
    @carsoncrush2963 2 года назад +2

    Cool

  • @RSpracticalshooting
    @RSpracticalshooting Год назад +1

    it's no comparison between the MPA and Staccato imho, the MPA is leagues better.

  • @chgofirefighter
    @chgofirefighter 2 года назад +4

    Sadly, the Prodigy has way too many MIM parts, Staccato is just a dressed-up STI and if you truly want to go custom, MPA leads the way!

  • @jht05016
    @jht05016 Год назад +1

    to build a $3,000+ 2011 with a polymer grip should be a hate crime.

    • @CandMTactical
      @CandMTactical Год назад +1

      Neither of the 3k plus guns have polymer grips that I know of.

    • @jht05016
      @jht05016 Год назад +2

      @@CandMTactical pretty positive that the XL is a polymer grip from the factory and over 3K.

    • @CandMTactical
      @CandMTactical Год назад +1

      @@jht05016 you are correct. My apoligies

  • @tobberfutooagain2628
    @tobberfutooagain2628 8 месяцев назад

    The Prodigy is what the Stac & DS9 shit out……

  • @Sagittariustoo
    @Sagittariustoo 3 месяца назад +1

    I wouldn't want the Prodigy for free.

  • @al-eteos-imhotepheru-bey3271
    @al-eteos-imhotepheru-bey3271 2 года назад

    Prodigy doesn't belong in this review. There, I said what most were thinking.

  • @xdivineHART
    @xdivineHART Год назад +1

    Ehhhh you're from Houston

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      I am a California refugee hahaha

    • @xdivineHART
      @xdivineHART Год назад

      @@SMASHTIME as long as you support the constitution we welcome you🥳🥳🥳

  • @tommymorgan9293
    @tommymorgan9293 2 года назад +2

    The prodigy is hot garbage. Replace all the internals and buy mbx mags and it will run

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  2 года назад +1

      The one i was shooting has smoothed out a lot. Runs nice.

  • @bryanramos9932
    @bryanramos9932 Год назад +2

    That prodigy flatter than the staccato

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +2

      No.. but its less than half the price.

    • @wendellhatcher7011
      @wendellhatcher7011 Год назад

      I have a prodigy customize it and there is no comparison with still a smaller price. I sent mines to Dscgunworks. I am getting or ordering this MPA man this thing is nice looking!

  • @DaveandDebe
    @DaveandDebe Год назад

    The Prodigy is complete trash.,, waste of money. 😊

    • @SMASHTIME
      @SMASHTIME  Год назад +1

      I dunno.. Some have worked flawlessly

    • @DaveandDebe
      @DaveandDebe Год назад

      @@SMASHTIME 👍