I Tried Socratic Questioning

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024

Комментарии • 163

  • @hoever-k3o
    @hoever-k3o 6 дней назад +2

    what’s a KING without a kingdom!!!!asking the question why a god would create is like asking an artist why do you make art 😅🤷‍♀️😊
    he is simply showcasing his greatness otherwise for what reason is he called god

  • @dark_attack7896
    @dark_attack7896 15 дней назад +5

    ❤Thankyou for Your Reaction, Peace and Happy Always.
    INDONESIA LOVE YOU.❤

  • @panof2852
    @panof2852 День назад +1

    At the end; why?
    -God said so.
    -Why are you doing what god said?
    -cuz the reward is heaven
    -why do you want heaven
    -I want to be happy forever
    Well... Yea i got to the same point. Something still feels flawed...

  • @elleash3888
    @elleash3888 15 дней назад +21

    God created humans to worship him, as stated in the GlorIous Quran.

    • @trinitymatrix9719
      @trinitymatrix9719 15 дней назад +1

      according to a simple hate speech book created by 7th century arabs with not even 1 single piece of evidence or proof. Its just blind faith in its purest form

    • @markorbit4752
      @markorbit4752 14 дней назад +1

      why would he do that?????why would an all-powerful, all-knowing , self-sufficient god desire to be worshipped? All other gods which were created by huans have this same desire for worship. Thats how i know allah is also man-made

    • @naimahbidin2751
      @naimahbidin2751 14 дней назад +2

      ​@@markorbit4752You don't know all about your Creator but your Creator know all about you his creation. That so simple👍😊

    • @OmarAlkhatib-c8z
      @OmarAlkhatib-c8z 13 дней назад +1

      @@markorbit4752allah put us on this earth to test us, if he “needed” worship he would’ve made us angels becuase they have no free will

    • @markorbit4752
      @markorbit4752 11 дней назад +1

      @@naimahbidin2751 That´s a meaningless statement. First you have to show that allah created me. I could equally make such a meaningless claim and say that you don´t know all about your creator Vishnu, but Vishnu knows all about you. Still think its so simpl?

  • @amaama2137
    @amaama2137 11 дней назад +2

    "The question should actually start from here;
    Who am I? What am I? Am I a feeling? Am I intelligence?
    Am I a body? Am I a soul?
    Undoubtedly, the more logical answer is: I am a human being.
    Then we need to understand what it means to be human.
    Not always should one start with God; rather, one should start from within, first recognizing oneself...
    There are many religions and sects in the world, each calling for peace, a life of good deeds, justice, etc., etc.
    But Islam is a complete religion. To understand this, you have to be honest-not with me, but with yourself, yes, with your own self...
    And I agree with many of Lucas’s thoughts...
    Anyway, one day death will come to all of us, and blessed is the one who has recognized their true self!"

  • @fatemaWali-sh3cv
    @fatemaWali-sh3cv 13 дней назад +2

    Socrates was a theist.
    # I have known one thing that I don't know anything.
    " one of Socrates Advice"

  • @HeshamMa7moud
    @HeshamMa7moud 13 дней назад +1

    I've reached a conclusion within that stream that all these questions will lead back to either "I don't know" or "I feel good about it" both have this vague and unknown nature to them, and when you ask why "I feel good about it" will lead back to "I don't know". But either way both have God missing from them. When both contain God's decree in his wisdom and knowledge. A life without God to guide us is meaningless and without purpose. Basically following your desires and Nafs as all religions say not to follow.

  • @TruRedCRIME
    @TruRedCRIME 15 дней назад +11

    If you need help in philosophically proving islam is the truth using reason alone lmk I can help you

    • @SacramentUnleash
      @SacramentUnleash 15 дней назад +2

      if you need help proving islam as false. its easy let me know.

    • @certifiedcib7958
      @certifiedcib7958 15 дней назад

      @@SacramentUnleashlmao what a d**khead 😂😂

    • @arafatmarius331
      @arafatmarius331 15 дней назад

      Mashallah you got a subscriber

    • @MW_3
      @MW_3 15 дней назад +6

      @@SacramentUnleashislamaphobes only help Islam grow brother ❤

    • @SacramentUnleash
      @SacramentUnleash 15 дней назад

      @@MW_3 why do you follow an evil false God?
      By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if you were not to commit sin, Allah would sweep you out of existence and He would replace (you by) those people who would commit sin and seek forgiveness from Allah, and He would have pardoned them.
      Sahih Muslim 2749
      In-book reference : Book 50, Hadith 13

  • @jka3062
    @jka3062 9 дней назад +1

    Read the sealed nectar grayson and make a video on it. It is nessesary

  • @abbasSharulshanzcool
    @abbasSharulshanzcool 15 дней назад +4

    Good talk.

  • @akessi4755
    @akessi4755 День назад +1

    Watch Omar Suleiman's Meeting Muhammad series Grayson

  • @michaelscarlino1590
    @michaelscarlino1590 7 дней назад +1

    Allah has predestined every person to sin, then beg for forgiveness, so that clearly makes the muslim allah the progenitor of ALL SIN, no getting around this one, impossible!!!

  • @zoltan506
    @zoltan506 8 дней назад

    The surest path to True Knowledge is to start from within, by asking yourself, "Who am I?"
    Are you the body? Are you the mind? What is your true essence?
    By meditating and contemplating over this question, it becomes obvious that God, the Absolute, is all we can be sure of, and the existence of other than God is what comes into question.
    〔لا تدركه الأبصار وهو يدرك الأبصار وهو اللطيف الخبير 〕
    Vision does not encompass Him, but He encompasses all vision, and He is the All-Subtle, the All-Aware. -The Quran
    من عرف نفسه فقد عرف ربه
    "Whoever knows himself knows his Lord." -The Messenger of Allah
    كنت كنزاً مخفياً فأحببت أن أُعرف فخلقت الخلق لكي أُعرف
    "I was a hidden treasure wanting to be known, so I created the creation in order to be known." - Hadith Qudsi

  • @oandsseedat
    @oandsseedat 10 дней назад

    Ultimate why is you are here to serve god and the creation of god and thats ultimate purpose of why. When finding your truest why thats the most objective why
    God is the start and the end

  • @elleash3888
    @elleash3888 15 дней назад +6

    When we do this thought experiment as Muslims, ultimately our end goal or answer is to please God and make it to paradise. Adam was a Muslim, Moses was a muslim, Jesus was a Muslim. Islam is not new. There only ever was Islam, submitting to the One True God. Follow the Book that has never been distorted and you will be guided. Peace

    • @nor7435
      @nor7435 15 дней назад

      @@elleash3888 give me one verse in the Quran were isa says “I am Muslim”, the name Jesus isn’t found once in the Quran

    • @elleash3888
      @elleash3888 15 дней назад +1

      @@nor7435Jesus, peace and blessings be upon him, is mentioned 187 times in the Quran😊 More than Mohamad, peace be upon him.

    • @sitiahmad429
      @sitiahmad429 14 дней назад

      @@nor7435OMGGGGGG
      READ!READ!READ!
      Read the Quran.
      READ is the firsttt wahyu from Allah to prophet Muhammad pbuh

    • @sitiahmad429
      @sitiahmad429 14 дней назад

      @@nor7435Quran do has story about our beloved Maryam, jesus, moses, abraham,sulaiman,john and manyyy prophets.
      READ ok.PLEASE

    • @nor7435
      @nor7435 14 дней назад

      @@sitiahmad429 the Quran get mary completely wrong. In the Quran Mary is brothers with Moses and Aaron which makes Moses Jesus uncle which is absolutely not true. Moses was alive 1500 years before Mary and Jesus were alive they are not sibiling . Allah got it wrong!

  • @loveacacia8173
    @loveacacia8173 2 дня назад

    Jews also have the Mishna and The Talmud, they have a very different view, including women, people only talk about Islam, which has Hadith while the Jews also have it. Jews, for example, are allowed to go to the mosque but not to church, why? no one talks about it. Jews do not believe in 3-1 pagans, just like Muslims, while Christians do

  • @SchabanaRezaei
    @SchabanaRezaei 15 дней назад +2

    Best idea ❤ Allahu Akbar

  • @nobody77791
    @nobody77791 7 дней назад

    Session with Sheikh Uthman

  • @AmiraMostapha
    @AmiraMostapha 9 дней назад

    أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وحده لا شريك له وأشهد أن محمد رسول الله

  • @zahrahaidari2380
    @zahrahaidari2380 14 дней назад +4

    Being submissive makes us to be in peace of our inner self

    • @mhnv9436
      @mhnv9436 14 дней назад +4

      Yes submissive to God

    • @ALMAHDl
      @ALMAHDl 14 дней назад +2

      @@mhnv9436 absolutely, Naturally, surely, certainly, Yes

    • @markorbit4752
      @markorbit4752 14 дней назад

      why would i submit to allh when i believe that he was created by men because of the evidence i have seen?

    • @mhnv9436
      @mhnv9436 14 дней назад +2

      @markorbit4752 peak ignorance and selective nonsensical reasoning using god knows what supposed *evidence*. Search up the inimitability of the Quran and its prophecies actualised. Bro has not studied the seeerah, Quran, torah or the Talmud. Or is even logically aware if the diestic philosophical word view on the basis of the contingency argument, or even teleological arguments.

    • @mhnv9436
      @mhnv9436 14 дней назад +1

      @markorbit4752 wdym created by men ? At the time the pagans worshiped statues and committed idolatry. The ismalites before the advent of prophet Muhammad were aware of a transcendental 1 god but then they associated partners. Islam embolishsed that, and prophet's have done that given guidance to every nation. Belief in one God is innate, a fitrah and logically you arrive at a diestic position as told earlier by the contingency and teleological arguments and by looking at the sheer amount of accuracy depicting the origins of the universe inclusive of it expansion of the universe, distinct embryology and knowledge of the future prophecies as like those of the Romans and Persians, and semetic linguistics of the Quran that accommodate any recitation, void of any contradictions and inclusive of advance signs that we see and uncover scientifically. And preserved from the time of the prophet, and memorised completely by millions of Muslims.

  • @animeche9232
    @animeche9232 14 дней назад

    It's a dangerous art

  • @deb7093
    @deb7093 8 дней назад +1

    Bro you remember the interview with logic about Aiysha?
    You know marring a child and having sex at 9 yrs is wrong but you struggle to answer that basic question cus the islam ideology has stopped your common sense to function .
    Now explain Surah 9 29.

  • @LAila-qf4ww
    @LAila-qf4ww 15 дней назад +1

    On the day of judgement, you will be asked by Allah (God the All Mighty), about the details of your life here on planet earth. There was a right and a wrong, the doctrine was provided (the Quran) and it was a clear “guidance for the mutaqeen” (conscious ones) (Suraat Al baqraa, V.2).
    Please keep in mind that those who repent, Allah graciously forgives, so it is never too late to ask for forgiveness and accept Islam. How about visiting a mosque today!!

  • @noonewarefe
    @noonewarefe 6 дней назад

    PLEASE READ!!!!!!! author is american
    The Writing On The Water: Chronicles Of A Seeker On The Islamic Sufi Path
    Muhyiddin Shakoor

  • @ahmadmustakhimabdmutalib59
    @ahmadmustakhimabdmutalib59 12 дней назад

    😊 why we his creation? Because God just want at it, thats only answer

  • @khushboo0786
    @khushboo0786 7 дней назад

    Can I also join you... I've been following you since more than months.. You never take me on stage

    • @graysonbrockk
      @graysonbrockk  5 дней назад

      there are many people bro
      I want to speak with everyone

  • @aadan_cabdirisaaq-saalax
    @aadan_cabdirisaaq-saalax 7 дней назад

    Islam is the truth❤❤❤❤❤

  • @handleisGG
    @handleisGG 14 дней назад

    You could have carried on how can you NOT KNOW WHY GOD CREATED US? To test our patience capabilities of retaining knowledge and MOST IMPORTANTLY to experiment to see if we BELIEVE in God despite not seeing him or knowing of his existence, do we have the INNATE urge to find him and be closer to the almighty the source , God the creator of the heavens and universe and as im writing this im realising he also is seeing through our experiences HOW WE VIEW GOD like what do we think when we think of God? Ofcourse he's all knowing and can anticipate your next move, but I dont think he works in a way where hes constantly watching our every little move, he JUST KNOWS everything thats going on, so how much of God can we comprehend and also how much do we ask for forgiveness , praise and remember him? How OFTEN can we do it but it DOES seem unnecessary since he knows everything anyway 😂 maybe he didnt want to be alone lool

  • @sueellenelasali7278
    @sueellenelasali7278 15 дней назад

    Grayson im helping You catch up READ & LEARN AND DO UR RESEARCH 👇

  • @nor7435
    @nor7435 15 дней назад +3

    1. Allah's days are 1000 years - Quran 22:47
    2. Allah's days are 50000 years - Quran 70:4
    3. Allah was invisible to Muhammad - Quran
    81:15-29
    4. Allah was visible to Muhammad - Quran 51:1-18
    5. Marriage with idolatrous women is forbidden - Quran 2:221
    6. Marrying with idolatrous women is allowed - Quran 5:5
    7. Unbelievers won't be rewarded - Quran 9:17, 9:69
    8. Unbelievers can be rewarded too along with believers - Quran 99:7
    9. Muslims should show kindness to their parents even if they are Christians - Quran 17:23-24
    10. Only show kindness to Muslim parents - Quran
    9:23, 58:22
    11. Muslims have only one mother - Quran 58:2
    12. Muslims have two mothers - Quran 4:23
    13. Muslims have at least ten mothers - Quran 33:6
    14. Allah doesn't pray, but others must pray to Him - Quran 11:61
    15. Allah prays for prophet - Quran 33:56
    16. Allah makes everything clear and He is all-knowing - Quran 4:26
    17. Allah says "perhaps" and had doubts regarding
    Fir'aun's fate - Quran 20:44
    18. Allah is the god of maybe - Quran 49:11
    19. Allah doesn't know Mary is NOT the sister of Aaron - Quran 19:28
    20. Allah didn't know the persons of Trinity - Quran
    5:72-75
    21. Allah failed to remember whether heaven or earth art was created first Quran 2:29 (earth first), Quran 79:27-30 (heaven first)
    22. There is no compulsion in religion - Quran 2:256
    23. There is compulsion in religion - Quran 9:29
    24. Allah is not a man - Quran 17:111
    25. Allah has an eye - Quran 20:36-39
    26. Allah has a face - Quran 55:26-27
    27. Allah has a shin - Quran 68:42
    28. Allah has a "face" - Sahih al-Bukhari 9:503
    29. Allah had "a hand and fingers" - Hadith No. 206, Vol. 6) (Sahih al-Bukhari 9:508)
    30. Who was the first Muslim? Muhammad - Quran 7:28
    31. Who was the first Muslim? Moses - Quran 6:14,163
    32. Who was the first Muslim? Some Egyptians - Quran 26:51
    33. Who was the first Muslim? Abraham - Quran
    2:127-133, 3:67
    34. Who was the first Muslim? Adam, the first man who also received inspiration from Allah - Quran
    2:37

    • @NOK000
      @NOK000 15 дней назад +4

      How stupid one can be?! Just grab a Qur'an instead of copy pasting whatsapp message

    • @elleash3888
      @elleash3888 15 дней назад +4

      Tell me you’re making stuff up and have never read the Quran without telling me you’re making stuff up and have never read the Quran

    • @nor7435
      @nor7435 15 дней назад

      @@elleash3888 always making baseless claim but never proving anything wrong. It is so clear you never read the Quran

    • @nor7435
      @nor7435 15 дней назад

      @@NOK000 the Quran chapter and verse is there your welcome to find out the truth yourself!

    • @AamonJs
      @AamonJs 15 дней назад +2

      Lol I stopped reading at Allah prays the Amount of times it got debunked is crazy .
      Check Dawah over Duniya

  • @shosho-r1w
    @shosho-r1w 15 дней назад +1

    Whats that stupid questions?

  • @npc9520
    @npc9520 15 дней назад +2

    astaghfirullah with your silly questions philosophy is haram u not supposed to question so much with this type of silly questions who are this group of people bring real Muslim Br's

    • @TruRedCRIME
      @TruRedCRIME 15 дней назад +4

      @@npc9520 it's not haram. Don't be so medieval. The entire Muslim world used philosophy from ghazali to ibn tamiyyah

    • @handleisGG
      @handleisGG 14 дней назад

      ​@@TruRedCRIMEnot sure why content creators usually minimise commenting on others posts, see off this comment alone im interested in your channel and subscribing 😂 you have a good reasonable head on your shoulders alhamdolilah and mashallah

    • @npc9520
      @npc9520 10 дней назад

      @@TruRedCRIME then you have not watched any video from scholars or dawah brothers

    • @npc9520
      @npc9520 10 дней назад

      @@TruRedCRIME they have made clear is not allowd

  • @sueellenelasali7278
    @sueellenelasali7278 15 дней назад +2

    To You GRAYSON 👉 I TOLD YOU READING THE NOBLE QURAN in one SITTING DID NOT HELP YOU. YOU MISSED ON SO MUCH. MANY OF UR QUESTIONS ARE ANSWERED BY ALLAH IN HIS LAST HOLY BOOK THE NOBLE QURAN. THE NOBLE QURAN SAYS THE REASON WHY ALLAH CREATED Us is to WORSHIP him & find out who is BEST AT WORSHIPPING him. .... Also ALLAH SAYS always in the Noble Quran I Created Both HUMANS & DEMONS FOR THE SIMPLE REASON TO WORSHIP HIM that's about it. I add he has 7 HEAVENS he CREATED WHEN HE CREATED THE WORLD IN 6 DAYS. THAT BEING SAID the 7 heavens Allah Created when he FIRST created the world is To FILL THEM ALL WITH BOTH Us, Human beings and DEMONS. WHAT ARE WE GOING TO BE DOING IN HEAVEN? WORSHIP HIM just like ANGELS MUSLIMS PLANTS TREES MOUNTANS ANIMALS Basically anything that consume water WORSHIP HIM. HAVE YOU SEEN ANIMALS WORSHIP HIM? IF NOT GOOGLE BIRDS WORSHIPPING FOR example! READ THE NOBLE QURAN. YOU DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT ISLAM... YOU ASK & YOU KEEP ASKING QUESTIONS ALREADY MENTIONED IN THE NOBLE QURAN!

    • @zeropulses9180
      @zeropulses9180 15 дней назад +1

      I am not sure I understand what you are saying, when you went from mentioning the seven heavens to mentioning "to fill them all with both of us", that's not true. The seven heavens are not seven Paradises. They are universes. The lowest is this dunya. Paradise is not the same as heaven in the Quran. Paradise is Jannah. Also, again, when you say we worship him in Paradise, it won't be the same as here. Not by praying and such. It seems like you got that from Christianity or something, IF in fact you meant worship the same way as here. There, you can do whatever you want, no obligations. And if you were to argue we worship Him, it would be as easy as existing and breathing, rather than having to do certain actions. Again, not sure why you said "basically anything that consumes water worships Him", where did you get this idea from? Who said you need water to be made out of or require water to worship God? Better not speak on things we don't know. Allahu Allam.

    • @trinitymatrix9719
      @trinitymatrix9719 15 дней назад +1

      Nothing is answered in quran, you need hadits to make sense of everything, context etc....God bless us all... Amiiiin.

    • @zahrahaidari2380
      @zahrahaidari2380 14 дней назад

      Every being worship Allah but in their own way and that’s by doing what they created for? Laws of universe!
      یسبح لله ما فی السموات والارض

    • @zahrahaidari2380
      @zahrahaidari2380 14 дней назад

      Whatever we do if we do it for Allah counts as rewards for this world and the next! That’s make a big difference we all live and more or less doing the same things but believers are the winners as they don’t miss out of pleasures of the hereafter

    • @trinitymatrix9719
      @trinitymatrix9719 14 дней назад

      Nobody should worship a god shaped and formed by former polytheistic moon gods. Where did u get this idea bro?

  • @sueellenelasali7278
    @sueellenelasali7278 15 дней назад

    ANYONE BORN AFTER PROPHET MOHAMMED Peace Be Upon HIM or during his time MUST BE FOLLOWING HIM & HIM ONLY NOT iSSA not David not Moses NONE OF THESE PROPHETS ARE THE RIGHT ONES TO FOLLOW NONE 👉 YOU ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO FOLLOW ANY OF THESE PROPHETS according to ISLAM!

  • @sueellenelasali7278
    @sueellenelasali7278 15 дней назад

    4 MAIN HOLY BOOKS WERE CREATED BY ALLAH which are👉 1)TORAH 2) iNJEEL aka BIBLE Yes the Bible was created by Allah 3) ZABOOR 4) NOBLE QURAN. All thease Holy Books were ASSIGNED To Specific PROPHETS 1) MOSES 2) ISSA You call him JESUS no somebody changed his name 3) DAVID 4) NOBLE QURAN 👉 NOW LEARN wether you agree or not THESE ARE THE 4 MAIN HOLY BOOKS ALLAH CREATED AND ASSIGNED TO SPECIFIC PROPHETS PEACE BE UPON THEM ALL!

    • @sactownizzy9312
      @sactownizzy9312 15 дней назад

      Bible is not the Injeel, why people think Allah created books of Matthew mark Luke and John 😂 they are supposed stories about Jesus, so he gave Injeel to Jesus from these men which are stories about Jesus??? That doesn’t make sense, Injeel is the gospel Jesus preached & everyone knows he didn’t preach stories of Matthew mark Luke John 😂👎🏼

    • @SacramentUnleash
      @SacramentUnleash 15 дней назад +2

      torah is first 5 books of bible and zaboor also in bible. bible says jesus was crucified and quran says jesus wasn't crucified. quran isnt from God.

    • @nor7435
      @nor7435 15 дней назад

      Quran makes no sense and contradict itself all over the place

  • @irfanahmed7847
    @irfanahmed7847 14 дней назад

    You will keep questioning yourself this way and there will never be any answer to why god exist., Because there are things out of your knowledge for which you cant answer. These questions are pointless. You need to ask why do you exist. let Free thinker answer that.