Okay what you guys don't get is that not every song has to have wendy or joy at the top. Wendy always comes second or third in rv songs,and the lines she sings in this song would highlight her voice. While irene does have the most seconds she just repeats this monotone singing which she would pull off but it's not much.Plus RV has 5 members whereas BP has 4 members so i have to split the vocal lines to wendy or joy.Changing the vocals between seulgi/jennie and wendy/rose would result in the same seconds cuz if i gave wendy jennie's lines then seulgi would have to sing rose's so its the same thing etc.Most 'how would' videos are not realistic it's usually the fans giving lines to what member they think fits the voice. A 'how would' video editor wants everyone to have fair lines.
I mean all these people complaining about distribution on who should get this or who should get that should probably make a video on how they would have the members sing this song instead of telling you how you should have done YOUR video...Good job btw
Whatever, but I don't agree with yours with one thing!!!! Hey, you can't give lines' Jisoo for Yeri to sing!!! How can she do that well?? Instead of that, you should give this lines for Joy or Wendy sings!!!! That is more reasonable!!! Joy and Wendy is better about singing and they're vocal!!!! They can complete that better!!!! Yeri is just "majimak jeoreom ma-ma-majimak jeoreom ...", that is more suitable!!! And lines' Irene is rap!!!! Joy just sing because these notes in this song are quite high and the singer have to be excellent in order to complete their lines as well as they can!!!! You don't have to honor Yeri's ability outrageous!!! I'd like you to think about this problem seriously!!!! It's not kidding!!! Who agree with me??! We can't "judge a book by its cover", right??! Let's look what they can do!!! I confirm that the position of Yeri in this girl group is 'yes is fun' but 'no is also ok'!!!! I'm RV's fan and the thing that make me upset is having Yeri member!!! Sm 'lancer' her ability too much but in fact, her ability is not great like that!!!! You have to say the truth!!! We can't say temporary and let it pass!!! The truth is that 'Yeah, she can sing' but not mean 'She sings well'!!! Just like my sister usually sing to me at home!!! Not very especially!!! @AnoSora @BaeJoohyun
Yumi The Thing me too!!! hoping for that miracle one day~ and now they are preparing for their comeback. and here I am hoping for her to have more lines.
I like this distribution and I find that it matches well with their voices but let's be honest if Red Velvet actually sang this song, Wendy would definitely get more lines.
wendy's vocal is in another level... she is one of the best new generation vocalist and one of the best sm vocalist beside luna... she deserve more line...
maybe becoz they share the same beauty, and both of them are main vocalist and both of them live outside korea?? and both of them are english speaker....
lol guys chill this is just a fanmade distribution seriously calm down ya'll can't you just be happy for those members who are not really given a lot of lines in their real songs
Okay but surely Wendy should sing more than Seulgi considering she's the a Main Vocalist. Sometimes I feel as though SM do the same thing. They give Wendy less parts than she should have and for that reason she has become somewhat under appreciated. Like they have this amazing singer and yet they aren't utilising her talent.
Seulgi usually does get more lines than the other members. Yes, Wendy is the main vocalist, but I'm pretty sure the reason behind them giving more lines to Seulgi is because her voice goes better with more songs. In other words, her voice is a bit more flexible. But yeah I agree Wendy should have more lines since she is the main.
Rhianne Mee well, if you see in red velvet song the most line is depend on whpse voice fit most to the song. like happiness or ootn wendy has the most line. in rr joy got the most, in rookie seulgi got the most. seulgi not always get the most line.
Guys enough its a fanmade video, also BlackPink is kind of Rap-like, which Irene and Yeri are rappers, this might not have many raps but. Some people like me also wish other members got more spotlight each time, Sure I love Wendy, but its a group of 5 not just Seulgi, Wendy and Joy. I just wish each comeback we could get a different member spotlight
If i was to make this, i would of given some of seulgi's lines to Wendy, and some of irene's lines to both joy and Yeri to make things more fairly distributed.
i love this it's so good but unrealistic they would have given Joy one of the choruses or have Joy do one of the part that Lisa does after the chorus and have Irene do the other two but great vid
For an RV fan who's bias is Baechu, this is my dream lime distribution for once in atleast one song so that we'll be able to hear more of Irene's voice and also her capability to somehow rap in her own style :)
I would have had Joy start it off and then chorus part maybe Wendy, and then Irene with Lisa's rap OMG I would die. Anyways what a fun video thanks for the upload xD
actually wendy not having the most lines in this kind of concept won't surprise me. seulgi and irene really fits this type, wendy's voice is more on soulful and ballad.
I agree!!! Wendy deserves more lines....not even my bias but she's the main vocal and it's not that "they should let others shine" duh! Wendy's talent is left behind my gash! Irene is so popular and also seulgi....... yeah but well nice video.....I'm just confused Let Wendy shine!!!!!
Black pink rappers especially both jisoo and rose have potential in rapping while red velvet vocals plus both main dancer of RV and BP, if they will collab, it will be 🔥
I'm actually really loving how you distributed this song between members. I also find it funny cause jisoo from BP is my bias and she gets the least lines and then boy from RV is my bias and she got the least lines in this song. It's like they are both meant to be my bias! HAHAHAHA LOVE YOUR VIDEOS BTW! :)
I know that this video is a year old but it just got in my recommened section so. I get that the main vocal doesn’t always need to have the most lines but this isn’t realistic for Red Velvet. They’d sing Jennie’s chorus together and Lisa’s part would probably be shared between Irene and Yeri, like they get a half each. Joy would get Jisoo’s first part and Lisa’s rap would go to Yeri
ppl calm down, for all the ppl saying that wendy should sing more, bp is a group that rappers have to sing more than vocal. this is just a how would distribution. ano sora, made a pretty fair distribution and rv would rock this concept if they’ll do a concept like this.
My babies (red velvet) can also do this, but maybe not exactly the same but I'm pretty sure that they can pull this concept out. They showed up a cute and sexy performance in ice cream cake at the same time so in my opinion I think red velvet can also do this kind of concept.
I love all but to my ranking Joy-Jisoo Seulgi-Jennie Wendy-Rosé Joy -Lisa' s rap parts from "uhh I am gonna find love.." Irene-Lisa's rap "cz we gonna.." YERI-LISA MAJIMAKCHEOROM PART AND BLACKPINK IN YOUR AREA
Okay what you guys don't get is that not every song has to have wendy or joy at the top. Wendy always comes second or third in rv songs,and the lines she sings in this song would highlight her voice. While irene does have the most seconds she just repeats this monotone singing which she would pull off but it's not much.Plus RV has 5 members whereas BP has 4 members so i have to split the vocal lines to wendy or joy.Changing the vocals between seulgi/jennie and wendy/rose would result in the same seconds cuz if i gave wendy jennie's lines then seulgi would have to sing rose's so its the same thing etc.Most 'how would' videos are not realistic it's usually the fans giving lines to what member they think fits the voice. A 'how would' video editor wants everyone to have fair lines.
Ano Sora yea, I don't know about that...
which app you used?
Ano Sora 1:37 why yeri's bar shorter than irene's bar that much ?
I mean all these people complaining about distribution on who should get this or who should get that should probably make a video on how they would have the members sing this song instead of telling you how you should have done YOUR video...Good job btw
Whatever, but I don't agree with yours with one thing!!!! Hey, you can't give lines' Jisoo for Yeri to sing!!! How can she do that well?? Instead of that, you should give this lines for Joy or Wendy sings!!!! That is more reasonable!!! Joy and Wendy is better about singing and they're vocal!!!! They can complete that better!!!! Yeri is just "majimak jeoreom ma-ma-majimak jeoreom ...", that is more suitable!!! And lines' Irene is rap!!!! Joy just sing because these notes in this song are quite high and the singer have to be excellent in order to complete their lines as well as they can!!!! You don't have to honor Yeri's ability outrageous!!! I'd like you to think about this problem seriously!!!! It's not kidding!!! Who agree with me??! We can't "judge a book by its cover", right??! Let's look what they can do!!! I confirm that the position of Yeri in this girl group is 'yes is fun' but 'no is also ok'!!!! I'm RV's fan and the thing that make me upset is having Yeri member!!! Sm 'lancer' her ability too much but in fact, her ability is not great like that!!!! You have to say the truth!!! We can't say temporary and let it pass!!! The truth is that 'Yeah, she can sing' but not mean 'She sings well'!!! Just like my sister usually sing to me at home!!! Not very especially!!! @AnoSora @BaeJoohyun
Red velvet could pull this kind of concept ❤
Go Hard and Slay BP They really could! Like let's hit SM up. 😂
Rumor has it that their upcoming comeback will have a 'sexy girl crush' concept. Let's hope!!
It actually kinda has a happiness vibe to it but like a more hardcore version!
Go Hard and Slay BP yea you right I hope they do a concept like this too!
Kristi Nguyen I hope it's sexy and still mixed with weirdness, Kinda like Stellar's Sting MV. It was sexy but the MV was kinda weird too. :-)
RV IN YOUR AREA~
+Rebeca Moyano 😂
yes
it would be 'ReVel in your area'
Aisyah Syafira Aisyah Syafira don't mean to be rude. But that suits bp more
BlackVelvet In your Area!
Before I leave the kpop world.. I want to see black pink and red velvet collab 😭🙏
Hannah So. Same
So Am i haha
Hannah So. Yes please 😭❤️
Me too~
But the problem is, You can never leave once you join
If yeri actually got this many lines my life would be so much better
Yumi The Thing but sadly we know that'll never happen.
Yumi The Thing me too!!! hoping for that miracle one day~ and now they are preparing for their comeback. and here I am hoping for her to have more lines.
aida Vanilla Yeri got more lines in Russian Roulette higher than Wendy
I know right? 😂😂😂. Baby Yeri! 💝
Look at the attaboy line distribution
This song is like the "softest" among BP song. I think if RV do this concept, they actually can pull it.
sky배 97 yes i notice that . it's like they are showing their cutesy side
CJ casildo
It shows blackpink's Pink side
Black - Boombayah, Whistle, Playing with Fire.
Pink - Stay, As If It's Your last.
it is their pink side, but it would still be more badass then other RV songs.
Stay is "softer"(imo).
Black- Boombayah, Playing with Fire
Pink- Stay, As If It's Your Last
Blackpink-Whistle
Unbohlievable i think too since stay is a ballad
Irene has more lines than both Wendy and Joy, and Yeri has more lines than Joy? It's just not realistic.
Ashlee In the rookie mini album Joy had sang less than Irene and Yeri in some songs
Ashlee Maybe because Irene is the main rapper (I think)
And AIIYL has a lot of rap in it so it should go to Irene.
Ashlee Better than Sm himself
It's a different world, my friend
RBB? She has more than everyone
WAAAAAAA Irene!!!! This is so perfect, everyone has a good time to shine and Irene had the most, And Yeri had so much :D
KpopAnime7392 that's exactly what makes it unrealistic
i dont know i should laugh or cry with this comment :(
+Boujee, there are songs that Irene has either the most or the 2nd most, recently Yeris getting more lines, so I don't see this as unrealistic
SHINeeVelvet First of all, Blackpink's voices / capabilities should match with the member she/he's giving them to.
SHINeeVelvet 2nd,
Joy will never have less lines than Yeri
wow irene partss
I like this distribution and I find that it matches well with their voices but let's be honest if Red Velvet actually sang this song, Wendy would definitely get more lines.
Irene: Lisa
Seulgi: Jennie
Wendy: Rose
Joy: Rose/Lisa
Yeri: jisoo
jennie and seulgi❤😍 my fav
bitha unicorns ME too !!
Same my biases of rv and bp
wendy's vocal is in another level... she is one of the best new generation vocalist and one of the best sm vocalist beside luna... she deserve more line...
idk why but rose reminds me of wendy so much
maybe becoz they share the same beauty, and both of them are main vocalist and both of them live outside korea?? and both of them are english speaker....
Wonho Is Mine ikr pfft haha
lol guys chill this is just a fanmade distribution seriously calm down ya'll can't you just be happy for those members who are not really given a lot of lines in their real songs
i really think that Wendy is more suitable for Lisa's rap part, like seriously only Wendy can slay this part
Quynh Le Of course omg
the last majimakchereom was intense.. i can almost imagine irene saying to seulgi " not today bish "
Okay but surely Wendy should sing more than Seulgi considering she's the a Main Vocalist. Sometimes I feel as though SM do the same thing. They give Wendy less parts than she should have and for that reason she has become somewhat under appreciated. Like they have this amazing singer and yet they aren't utilising her talent.
Seulgi usually does get more lines than the other members. Yes, Wendy is the main vocalist, but I'm pretty sure the reason behind them giving more lines to Seulgi is because her voice goes better with more songs. In other words, her voice is a bit more flexible. But yeah I agree Wendy should have more lines since she is the main.
Rhianne Mee well, if you see in red velvet song the most line is depend on whpse voice fit most to the song. like happiness or ootn wendy has the most line. in rr joy got the most, in rookie seulgi got the most. seulgi not always get the most line.
*whose
Rhianne Mee not all main got the most
I don't think she's under appreciated. Everyone knows she can sing well, so the other members are given a chance to prove they can too.
Guys enough its a fanmade video, also BlackPink is kind of Rap-like, which Irene and Yeri are rappers, this might not have many raps but. Some people like me also wish other members got more spotlight each time, Sure I love Wendy, but its a group of 5 not just Seulgi, Wendy and Joy. I just wish each comeback we could get a different member spotlight
KpopAnime7392 Joy is a rapper too. Like in Dumb Dumb, Ice cream Cake, Happiness
Oriane Lefebvre now she’s a vocal and Irene and Yeri are the rappers
HOW CAN YOU READ MY THOUGHTS IF RV ACTUALLY SING THIS? YOU GOT ALL OF THIS RIGHT FROM MY THOUGHTS
RV should try such concept
If i was to make this, i would of given some of seulgi's lines to Wendy, and some of irene's lines to both joy and Yeri to make things more fairly distributed.
Jay J Yes! I agree!! and that's way more fair and realistic
Jay J I mean what's stopping you?
Nah it is perfect the way it is. And it suits them.
@@icequeen8536 ikr
Yasssss!!!! Joy rapped in that how would video!
Another change is that I might have Joy sing the chorus first line - I think she could do it! ;)
now we know what happens when rv does this kind of concept. Irene gets hella lines lol
i love this it's so good but unrealistic they would have given Joy one of the choruses or have Joy do one of the part that Lisa does after the chorus and have Irene do the other two but great vid
WOAA IRENE 💖😍
For an RV fan who's bias is Baechu, this is my dream lime distribution for once in atleast one song so that we'll be able to hear more of Irene's voice and also her capability to somehow rap in her own style :)
I would have had Joy start it off and then chorus part maybe Wendy, and then Irene with Lisa's rap OMG I would die. Anyways what a fun video thanks for the upload xD
RAPPER JOY CAME BACK!
just passing by but i love your line distribution setup!! so pleasing to look at
actually wendy not having the most lines in this kind of concept won't surprise me. seulgi and irene really fits this type, wendy's voice is more on soulful and ballad.
Irene and Lisa my favorite😘😘😘
When your bias is singing your bias' part :)
(Jennie x Seulgi)
Majimakcheorom ma ma majimakcheorom....
THIS LINE STUCK IN MY HEAD!!😍😍
what?????
wendy should sing the much in RV
Give everyone to shine more than Wendy, but i know they are always shine :)
I agree!!! Wendy deserves more lines....not even my bias but she's the main vocal and it's not that "they should let others shine" duh! Wendy's talent is left behind my gash! Irene is so popular and also seulgi....... yeah but well nice video.....I'm just confused Let Wendy shine!!!!!
Red Vlevet Is my VALENTINES DATE ikr that's what I've been thinking this whole time
黃品嘉 then wendy should take the rap part.. since nobody fluent english in rv
not all main vocals should be the first in line distributions though
2:18 - 2:47 Wendy’s timer be like "Imma unnoticeably go up"
IRINE FTW😂😘😍
Seulji Too😍😍😍
you know why irene got more line now? because she is the main rapper and she's lisa here and lisa got 2nd more line
If you dont like this then make your own :))))))
ooh I love the new layout!!
seulgi would fit this song so well
Joy singing Rosé's part 😂 Both of them are my bias
Same !
Yeah! More lines for Yeri! I love this video! Yeri is an excelent artist and she deserves more lines ^^
Irene is SO PRETTY ! 😍
Black pink rappers especially both jisoo and rose have potential in rapping while red velvet vocals plus both main dancer of RV and BP, if they will collab, it will be 🔥
I NEED THEM TO COLAB OR MAYBE SINGS EACH OTHER SONGS
noone can't sing that song better than BLACKPINK
YAS QUEENS AND QUEENS
it does sound like something red velvet would sing
I love this so much
OMG! Yeri has lines 😍 but sad because this won't never happen 😪
Irene got the most lines! I would be happy if that happens in their title tracks. But it's unrealistic. And btw, I love the thumbnail.
Wenrosé makes me happy omg
I don't know if I like rose and joy better or wendy and rose.........
Btw rose and joy are my biases
Seulgi- Jennie
Yeri- Jisoo, Lisa
Joy- Rose, Lisa
Wendy- Rose
Irene- Lisa
black velvet in your area
I love this
I'm actually really loving how you distributed this song between members. I also find it funny cause jisoo from BP is my bias and she gets the least lines and then boy from RV is my bias and she got the least lines in this song. It's like they are both meant to be my bias! HAHAHAHA LOVE YOUR VIDEOS BTW! :)
joy is like the jin in the group
Joy and Rosé😍
I know that this video is a year old but it just got in my recommened section so. I get that the main vocal doesn’t always need to have the most lines but this isn’t realistic for Red Velvet. They’d sing Jennie’s chorus together and Lisa’s part would probably be shared between Irene and Yeri, like they get a half each. Joy would get Jisoo’s first part and Lisa’s rap would go to Yeri
Both Yeri and Jisoo are my biases
Joy sounds so much like rose
ppl calm down, for all the ppl saying that wendy should sing more, bp is a group that rappers have to sing more than vocal. this is just a how would distribution. ano sora, made a pretty fair distribution and rv would rock this concept if they’ll do a concept like this.
If only people weren't trying to make it "Wendy ft.RV" but I liked the video regardless of the complaints in the comments (:
BlackVelvet 💖
Oooooh this is creative, and quite accurate! :D good job, I love this! :)
Loveeee this❤️
Wendy is the main vocalist and yet she shared lines with Joy 😂 Wendy dominating almost all Red Velvet's song and yet... 😂 Well...
wow i can actually see this happening
RED VELVET IN YOUR AREA 💖💖
lol
wendy and joy deserve more
The lines are hella fair. SM needs to take notes from you.
Nctsbuuuts I'm sorry but it's not fair tho
Red Vlevet Is my VALENTINES DATE it's fair, just not realistic.
I know...
Nctsbuuuts So who said sm isn't fair with Red velvet?
Usually I would say that Wendy should be Rosé but Joy's voice more fits with Rosé's
RV AND BP COLLABORATION PLEASE!! BLACKVELVET RISE 😍🙌🏻👑
ReVel in your area~~~~
Yeah Joy rap !!
Lisa as Irene and Joy
why do i agree so bad with this
appropriate
Did Irene just get the most!
I Ĺolve you Seulgi and Irene
RV IN YOUR AREEA
RV would definitely sing the chorus together
(MY OPINION)
ROSE - SEULGI & WENDY
JENNIE - JOY & SEULGI
LISA - YERI & IRENE
JISOO - IRENE
I think you should give one of the chorus to Joy, cause she's lead vocal
I like it BlackVelvet
#BlackVelvet💘
cute
if only yeri will get that much line in rv T^T
Irene: **raps**
Joy: **impressively raps**
Yeri: **doesn't raps**
_excuse me wtf_
Wendy should rap to since she has that YG Rappnig vibes
My babies (red velvet) can also do this, but maybe not exactly the same but I'm pretty sure that they can pull this concept out. They showed up a cute and sexy performance in ice cream cake at the same time so in my opinion I think red velvet can also do this kind of concept.
Red velvet will slay this but in my own opinion I don't think anyone can do this better than BP.
I agree irene should sing majimakcheorom part since it would suit her voice well
If really red velvet sing this song they will sing the chorus together.
Nice~ ♡♡
Seulgi- Jennie
Wendy-Rose
Joy-Jisoo
Irene and Yeri-Lisa👌
so acurate
I love all but to my ranking
Joy-Jisoo
Seulgi-Jennie
Wendy-Rosé
Joy -Lisa' s rap parts from "uhh I am gonna find love.."
Irene-Lisa's rap "cz we gonna.."
YERI-LISA MAJIMAKCHEOROM PART AND BLACKPINK IN YOUR AREA