Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.

The New Tones & I Song is...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 авг 2024
  • NOT BAD
    For the FULL reaction of this song, go to TheNeedleDrop's Patreon:
    / theneedledrop
    0:00 Pre-Surprising Reaction
    0:14 "Charlie"
    0:57 Thoughts on "Charlie"
    4:44 Revisiting trauma
    5:23 Realization.
    ===================================
    Follow your melon:
    Twitter: / theneedledrop
    Instagram: / afantano
    Twitch: / theneedledrop
    TikTok: / theneedletok

Комментарии • 248

  • @perplexed1783
    @perplexed1783 2 года назад +1072

    Can't wait for her redemption collab LP with Kanye called "KID SEES TONES" to get a 10/10 after getting a 0 and pulling a cudi 2.0

    • @swafty5813
      @swafty5813 2 года назад +27

      AND I SEE GHOSTS

    • @leewoodlee557
      @leewoodlee557 2 года назад +5

      The real Madhouse lmao

    • @man4437
      @man4437 2 года назад +7

      Comment would've been funny if you didn't spell out the joke three times

    • @perplexed1783
      @perplexed1783 2 года назад +1

      @MAN okay

    • @clam6254
      @clam6254 2 года назад

      @@swafty5813 DOUBLE ALBUM

  • @boxtrot6435
    @boxtrot6435 2 года назад +1424

    To the guy who said that Tones & I is on her path to getting a 10/10 album from Anthony Fantano you may be not wrong

    • @JaleelMusic
      @JaleelMusic 2 года назад +83

      Kid Cudi paved the way for Tones & I

    • @retnugnahte
      @retnugnahte 2 года назад +73

      @@JaleelMusic cudi walked so she could run

    • @perplexed1783
      @perplexed1783 2 года назад +62

      Can't wait for the Kanye and Tones & I collab album "KID SEES TONES"

    • @countyfacts6920
      @countyfacts6920 2 года назад +7

      If this album gets a 1, you know what Toni's 11th album will be...

    • @cdw2468
      @cdw2468 2 года назад +12

      @@perplexed1783 Kids See Tones & I, Kids See Tones, spirit… spirit… spirit…

  • @AnarchyIsLove
    @AnarchyIsLove 2 года назад +424

    Who knew some funk and sincere vocal delivery would make her music sound sincere.

  • @gabenickels8927
    @gabenickels8927 2 года назад +941

    Everyone: "This is garbage..."
    Fantano: "It's not bad"
    Everyone: "Actually, I kinda like it"

    • @ABC14683
      @ABC14683 2 года назад +168

      @Aaa Aaa GregNelson98

    • @bristow4784
      @bristow4784 2 года назад +44

      @Aaa Aaa Groot10 changed it from 2 to 1.25. I mean we don't have to prove it to you, who is just being skeptical for no reason. People in chat want acceptance lol.

    • @ahhhh4723
      @ahhhh4723 2 года назад +40

      @Aaa Aaa who cares. the fact that a bunch of people only comment once their opinion is validated by fantano is laughable too

    • @line5815
      @line5815 2 года назад +29

      @Aaa Aaa you said "name one person in chat" and they did just that lmfao

    • @RappingChipmunk
      @RappingChipmunk 2 года назад +19

      @Aaa Aaa dude tf does that mean. Pewdiepie has like 100 million subs that don’t watch him anymore. A pewdiepie sub don’t mean shit

  • @Wiggywatup
    @Wiggywatup 2 года назад +239

    Feel like guy was tthinking that the song was being rated a 74/100, or 7/10. But the actual data from the poll just shows that 74% of the people voted in favor rather than disliked.

    • @perplexed1783
      @perplexed1783 2 года назад +14

      Nah fr is bro blind or what? 💀

    • @Wiggywatup
      @Wiggywatup 2 года назад +12

      Not arguing he doesn’t know how the poll works, just his use of the data doesn’t match how he’s using it in his argument. How would only a 74% not “Not” on a song where fantano was visibly vibing with constitute bringing up a question like that. Unless it was being interpreted as a chat grade of 74%

    • @sillybilly4710
      @sillybilly4710 2 года назад +2

      Ahh, the rotten tomatoes scoring

  • @anaccount4354
    @anaccount4354 2 года назад +316

    people do need to remember that kid cudi got both a 0 and a 10

    • @KnotPhound
      @KnotPhound 2 года назад +17

      I mean, before that he had already made some great albums so it seems somewhat possible.

    • @R-H-B
      @R-H-B 2 года назад +8

      @@KnotPhound Melon hadn’t given Cudi any higher than a 6/10 before KSG

    • @windysradio
      @windysradio 2 года назад

      @@R-H-B he didnt even review motm 1

    • @R-H-B
      @R-H-B 2 года назад

      @@windysradio okay?

    • @windysradio
      @windysradio 2 года назад

      @@R-H-B if he reviewed motm 1 there wouldve been a higher score imo

  • @TalkingMusicAllDay
    @TalkingMusicAllDay 2 года назад +221

    "The chat has always been trash." Strongly agreed, Anthony.

  • @larissabrglum3856
    @larissabrglum3856 2 года назад +75

    I was shocked by how much I liked the production on this song

  • @denissosis7958
    @denissosis7958 2 года назад +81

    as much as I do hate "Welcome to the Madhouse" album, which really deserved its 0, and how horrendous "Dance Monkey" is too...I kinda like this song, moreover, I'm really happy for Tones & I to move forward! I doubt her next album will be anything above, like, 3 or 4, but I can't deny I am excited to hear more

    • @musichere3287
      @musichere3287 2 года назад +3

      Nah Dance Monkey is a solid pop song. I'd give this song a 5/10 while Dance Monkey 6/10

    • @gigatronusprime
      @gigatronusprime 2 года назад +15

      @@musichere3287 I'll have to disagree with you, there. Dance Monkey was hard for me to listen to, and this is much easier on my ears.

    • @Thesportsmusicgod
      @Thesportsmusicgod 2 года назад

      What about chant with Macklemore

  • @thecinematicmind
    @thecinematicmind 2 года назад +49

    A song from Tones & I not bad. UNEXPECTED

  • @Elias_Reed_25
    @Elias_Reed_25 2 года назад +153

    This honestly gives me a Lorde, Bruno Mars, and BTS vibe. Like the funk-pop style of Bruno Mars like on Finesse, the pop style of BTS like on Butter, and the singing voice of Lorde. It’s not that bad! Not the best I’ve heard, but I am surprised how this song sounded! It’s pretty interesting!

    • @dasheroo1229
      @dasheroo1229 2 года назад +5

      bro heard a bass and instantly thought of bruno mars lmao listen to more music the bass is an INSTRUMENT not a genre.

    • @Elias_Reed_25
      @Elias_Reed_25 2 года назад +21

      @@dasheroo1229 No, 😆? Me saying that the song reminds me of Bruno Mars, and you translate it to “the drum and bass reminds you of Bruno Mars?” Lmao It’s because of the music style. Reminds me of Bruno Mars’ Finesse song. Don’t be ridiculous and assume that I instantly think of Bruno Mars from a drum and bass. That’s stupid

    • @vividworld101
      @vividworld101 2 года назад +3

      Lorde?? lmao

    • @Elias_Reed_25
      @Elias_Reed_25 2 года назад +5

      @@vividworld101 Her singing voice reminds me of Lorde. I should’ve made that clear, lol

    • @vividworld101
      @vividworld101 2 года назад +1

      @@Elias_Reed_25 Ahhh gotchu lol

  • @shnye
    @shnye 2 года назад +67

    this genre of music sounds very similar to each other

    • @perplexed1783
      @perplexed1783 2 года назад +1

      Dance music can get repetitive pretty fast

    • @joshentertainment2
      @joshentertainment2 2 года назад +3

      That’s the funk/dance-pop baby

    • @sovietelmo3000
      @sovietelmo3000 2 года назад +3

      You must listen to real music

    • @shnye
      @shnye 2 года назад

      @@sovietelmo3000 what does that mean

  • @andros1486
    @andros1486 2 года назад +18

    I still wouldn't go out of my way to actually put this track on, and I'm still dreading her next full length album
    Dance Monkey has done too much damage

  • @mierardi88
    @mierardi88 2 года назад +6

    That song is actually fun! Well deserved "Most Improved"

  • @infinityquartz4744
    @infinityquartz4744 2 года назад +7

    Its just a fun song tbh. I think the story behind it is pretty cute and actually kinda endeering. And its funky and catchy. I like

  • @JpegErza
    @JpegErza 2 года назад +19

    all Tones & I has to do is make a collab album with Kanye and they’ll get a 10

  • @christophersorick4929
    @christophersorick4929 Год назад +4

    I absolutely love this song! It's one of her best in a bevy of completely unforgettable singles that she's released in the past 3 years. Well done, Tones!

  • @djangelwingz
    @djangelwingz 2 года назад +7

    MORE NOT BAD’s!! I NEED MOREEEEE!

  • @brendensica
    @brendensica 2 года назад +15

    Tones & I redemption arc confirmed 🔥

  • @blondiebear42
    @blondiebear42 2 года назад +17

    Even the first new Tones & I single, Eyes Don’t Lie, was good. I think it’s the best of the new batch and I feel like it wasn’t given a fair chance on stream. It has the cheesiest instrumental but best vocal performance of any Tones & I track by far.

  • @gardenjhr
    @gardenjhr 2 года назад +54

    Sounds pretty generic to me, the instrumental is cool though

    • @itsallenwow
      @itsallenwow 2 года назад +42

      A little generic but a pretty solid instrumental.
      When you put it up to dance monkey this is really solidly improved

    • @musichere3287
      @musichere3287 2 года назад +3

      @@itsallenwow Dance Monkey is better imo

    • @genesisosuna
      @genesisosuna 2 года назад +17

      @@musichere3287 bait

    • @musichere3287
      @musichere3287 2 года назад +6

      @@genesisosuna Nah I really believe that. This song is generic. Dance Monkey is a lot more distinguishable and interesting in every way: vocally, instrumentally and lyrically. Never found her vocals to be that annoying in Dance Monkey so this song feels like it lacks personality. Although I do have to admit I can only listen to her vocals in small doses. Vocals are really the only thing people can dislike about Dance Monkey because they are so weird. When you don't hate them, it's pretty easy to enjoy it.

    • @0nyxFR773
      @0nyxFR773 2 года назад

      @@musichere3287 you right lowkey. Have you heard Anthony’s bass playing? Trash. Mediocre at best. He’s the annoying one tbh. We outta spin the block on his wife and his valentines video.

  • @Shmuel420
    @Shmuel420 2 года назад +9

    I love how the chat is nonstop people saying dance monkey is the worst one, and Anthony completely ignores them

  • @PRiMEog_
    @PRiMEog_ 2 года назад +4

    "Target fitting room"
    lmaoooo

  • @arthurmilo8837
    @arthurmilo8837 2 года назад +62

    seriously a huge part of fantano fandom doesn't have own opinion lol

  • @oops6876
    @oops6876 2 года назад +10

    You know what? Good for her

  • @hayden7062
    @hayden7062 2 года назад +30

    Legit pretty good wtf

  • @danielmashanic5738
    @danielmashanic5738 2 года назад +14

    Anyone have to constantly remind themselves Tones and I is actually one person??

    • @colloquially
      @colloquially 2 года назад +3

      Oh shit I thought it was a duo

  • @jcnot9712
    @jcnot9712 2 года назад +92

    guy off-camera sounds even more smug and holier-than-thou than Melon. What an accomplishment.

    • @MrPikminmaster
      @MrPikminmaster 2 года назад

      Damn you're quite a miserable person to say weird shit like this. Sounded like a normal conversation between two people to me. How are your social skills?

    • @matthall7359
      @matthall7359 2 года назад

      @@Her_Viscera is parroting what you think the circle jerk opinion of chat is going to be really living tho

    • @genesisosuna
      @genesisosuna 2 года назад +30

      Melon is not that smug nor does he think his opinion holds more weight than others. But that person in the background was so annoying. Thinking everything has to be ironic or bashing on people for liking something they didn't because its "canned pop" because it isn't super progressive bedroom hyperpop core
      I'm assuming hes like a mod in fantano's streams, so that definitely checks out

    • @grey8478
      @grey8478 2 года назад +9

      they're both fine wtf

    • @ts-wo6pp
      @ts-wo6pp 2 года назад +14

      fr i really hope this guy aint gonna be a regular thing

  • @nagnot6718
    @nagnot6718 2 года назад +6

    the chat's switch up is crazy

  • @TeaRektum
    @TeaRektum 2 года назад +5

    we NEED an interview

  • @camerontremblay-adams9640
    @camerontremblay-adams9640 2 года назад +3

    EXPECTATION is everything

  • @monkeypaw09
    @monkeypaw09 2 года назад +17

    I'm sensing a redemption arc.

  • @sabalos
    @sabalos 2 года назад +14

    I keep calling her 'Tones and Loc' without realising. It's getting to be a problem.

  • @Thesportsmusicgod
    @Thesportsmusicgod 2 года назад +1

    He have you heard the song she did with Macklemore it’s really good

  • @eggressive_
    @eggressive_ 2 года назад +4

    Waiting for AJR 10/10

  • @sebwatson1
    @sebwatson1 2 года назад +17

    So it went from painfully generic and awful pop music to painfully generic and tolerable pop music

  • @HipKonik
    @HipKonik 2 года назад +3

    The Tones Store
    To Be Tones
    To Pimp a Tone
    Kids See Tones

    • @R-H-B
      @R-H-B 2 года назад +1

      Tones Won’t Get What Tones Want
      The Toning Wheel
      Toney Get Ready

  • @OxzowachiAlt
    @OxzowachiAlt 4 месяца назад

    definitely a "pleasantly surprised" poll result from chat

  • @Bae_Cop2027
    @Bae_Cop2027 2 года назад +4

    Huh... ... Yeah it is that bad.

  • @FooFighters530
    @FooFighters530 2 года назад +1

    This sounds like a Old Navy commercial song

  • @DavidSGrop
    @DavidSGrop 2 года назад +5

    Shockingly decent.

  • @stopbreathing2839
    @stopbreathing2839 2 года назад +7

    Don Cheadle

  • @isabellamorris7902
    @isabellamorris7902 2 года назад +1

    I'm such a sucker for this funk revival stuff... this is junk food music but I'm enjoying it

  • @usrnewxnew5227
    @usrnewxnew5227 Год назад +1

    Tones & I redemption arc of the anime is gonna be amazing

  • @codywright7932
    @codywright7932 2 года назад +3

    Charlie >>Won't sleep

  • @breakingmadeline3063
    @breakingmadeline3063 2 года назад +1

    Hey, it is good. That's all I have on this!

  • @auba4417
    @auba4417 2 года назад +1

    Legit pretty good what in tarnation

  • @cason8197
    @cason8197 2 года назад +7

    legit pretty good wtf

  • @kingkev6338
    @kingkev6338 2 года назад +7

    Epiphany…. Fantano judges music more for what it’s trying to do, rather than what it ends up being, and I fucks with it… maybe I’m stupid and think I had a smart moment… most likely…. But still I fucks with fantano and his reviews

  • @Mistashiba
    @Mistashiba 2 года назад +3

    this is the sign, the world is ending. grab your melons and run for your lives!!!!

  • @ideac.
    @ideac. 2 года назад +1

    Definitely a big improvement
    I hope that song gets more attention than whatever the fuck dance monkey is

  • @treyebillups8602
    @treyebillups8602 2 года назад +2

    The new song is radio-filler tier funk but it’s still miles better than any of her previous “work”

  • @virtueisdead
    @virtueisdead 2 года назад

    my jaw dropped when i saw this thumbnail and title, this better fuckin deliver
    edit: honestly... wow

  • @qwertyiuwg4uwtwthn
    @qwertyiuwg4uwtwthn 17 дней назад

    It's okay....

  • @ilovecody7514
    @ilovecody7514 8 месяцев назад

    Evil Fantano be like:

  • @heroina707
    @heroina707 2 года назад +3

    Omg this other dude was so insufferable that hearing him made the chat seem tolerable

  • @JamieSwitzer
    @JamieSwitzer 2 года назад +2

    I've asked this before, but no one replied, who is the second person talking?!

    • @poopy-discoop982
      @poopy-discoop982 2 года назад

      probably his editor? I've heard him before

    • @phoquedevelopment
      @phoquedevelopment 4 месяца назад

      @@poopy-discoop982i’m pretty sure his editor is a girl so i don’t think so

  • @MiketheNerdRanger
    @MiketheNerdRanger 2 года назад +1

    Man is it me or is everyone is doing the whole disco funk thing now?

  • @Lily-cd4fx
    @Lily-cd4fx 2 года назад

    this is the second time in history i think that something got a not bad

  • @Goobuh36
    @Goobuh36 2 месяца назад

    comethany backtano

  • @n0etic_f0x
    @n0etic_f0x 2 года назад +1

    Track slaps pretty hard as BGM for running or doing exercises and shit NGL defiantly gave me a lot of respect for Tones & I, the problem is now youtube wants to put that in a playlist of freaking AJR songs... and just no... I still hate every AJR song.

  • @soulcune8670
    @soulcune8670 2 года назад +1

    tones and i da 🐐no 🧢

  • @Theeosees
    @Theeosees 2 года назад +1

    It's still just passable though, honestly I think it's garbage but trying to look at it through the most positive lens it's still just kinda good or mehhh

  • @walnuthead
    @walnuthead 2 года назад +11

    That other guy is annoying

  • @firstnamelastname7244
    @firstnamelastname7244 10 месяцев назад

    It's actually okay. I'm impressed.

  • @fackumon292
    @fackumon292 2 года назад

    I have some problems with the vocals but the rest is kinda neat

  • @wilbaaaaaa
    @wilbaaaaaa 2 года назад

    tones and i makes me feel bad to be an australian living in victoria

  • @BushidoMauve
    @BushidoMauve 2 года назад

    It's a kinda lukewarm Jabuki vibe to it. quite pleasant

  • @Viper-dz2kw
    @Viper-dz2kw 2 года назад

    This kinda slaps wtf

  • @dookie3453
    @dookie3453 2 года назад +3

    I don’t understand how people can possibly say that Dance monkey is the most trash thing they’ve ever heard and then listen to this song and act like it’s good bruh

    • @mocapcow2933
      @mocapcow2933 2 года назад +1

      She experimented with her vocals on dance monkey and the vocals is what people hated. She made a non offensive song here that is way easier to like.

  • @findlayrutherford
    @findlayrutherford Год назад

    holy shit her singing is... weird in a different way. I don't like the production, it feels like it's scared to let you relax, but ig I'm not really interested in that kinda music. but her singing is defo more tolerable. I do like johnny run away tho lol

  • @KRistian87283
    @KRistian87283 2 года назад

    We can say Tones & I is pulling a kid cudi here then?

  • @eminemfan50098
    @eminemfan50098 2 года назад +16

    Guy off camera ruined this.

  • @yungchris3238
    @yungchris3238 2 года назад +1

    Can’t the other guy wait for a second? I wanted to hear the first impression not a discussion about the poll that doesn’t interest anyone anyways.

  • @lakejizzio7777
    @lakejizzio7777 Год назад

    I am surprised how good this song is.

  • @ARWG
    @ARWG 2 года назад +15

    I'm sorry, but her voice makes me want to die.

    • @perplexed1783
      @perplexed1783 2 года назад +6

      her voice was pretty listen able on this track tho

  • @weregretohio7728
    @weregretohio7728 2 года назад

    A Tones & I song that didn't make me want to die? Huh.

  • @w.w.6725
    @w.w.6725 2 года назад +1

    Whos the guy with you off camera?

  • @anathuu1124
    @anathuu1124 2 года назад

    I thought it wasnt a decent track, until I heard the cowbell

  • @vamoacalmarno3868
    @vamoacalmarno3868 2 года назад

    What about the new Pixies tho?

  • @user-wq7rw8dd7q
    @user-wq7rw8dd7q 2 года назад

    Antonio el Fantas

  • @joshentertainment2
    @joshentertainment2 2 года назад

    Dance pop

  • @WiloPolis03
    @WiloPolis03 2 года назад +3

    Only the attention span of Anthony Fantano fans would need timestamps for a six minute long video

  • @Ivanisasi
    @Ivanisasi 2 года назад +1

    who's the guy off camera?

  • @Leeqzombie
    @Leeqzombie 2 года назад

    Her next album is gonna be the reverse of a sophomore slump

  • @fuziontonygaming
    @fuziontonygaming 2 года назад +4

    Nice for there too be a song dedicated to Moist himself

  • @TheRealChiefBeef
    @TheRealChiefBeef 2 года назад

    Not really my cup of tea, but I enjoy the less abrasive vocal delivery. The debut was at times migraine inducing due to that weird growly voice she does. It's an above average Tones and I song, but a subpar pop song imo.

  • @DillonBrookussy
    @DillonBrookussy 2 года назад

    Sounds aight but also just a Future Nostalgia knock off imo

  • @OkaySoShit
    @OkaySoShit 2 года назад

    Lol

  • @monolith_g
    @monolith_g 2 года назад

    They are using you Melon.

  • @jackspurlock9201
    @jackspurlock9201 2 года назад

    Who is this character

  • @katoffeevhs9798
    @katoffeevhs9798 2 года назад

    so tones got someone to make a beat for her. the voice is still unacceptable.

  • @jbofficial32
    @jbofficial32 2 года назад

    Dance Monkey is better than this but this easily better than the rest of Welcome to the Madhouse

  • @Wopko
    @Wopko 2 года назад +4

    I don't care what this guy thinks. Tones and I have a distinct sound and produce catchy music. I wish them success.

    • @idorus
      @idorus 2 года назад +1

      lol if you don't care why do you feel the need to watch this video and comment on it?

    • @Wopko
      @Wopko 2 года назад

      @@idorus youtube has a funcrion on Their site called "recommended" and this video in particular popped up.
      I recognized Fandango and his untamed ego. He has a tendency to be unrealistic and wrong.
      I dont care what he thinks. And tones and I have a good sound.

    • @inceptionova3006
      @inceptionova3006 2 года назад +1

      @@Wopko Dislikes an artist = Massive ego

    • @chriskindler10
      @chriskindler10 2 года назад

      @@inceptionova3006 aside from tones & I, don‘t you think that Fantano comes across as a bit of a pretentious lad sometimes? I think that‘s sort of part of his „music nerd“ character but still

  • @sanchittiwari7690
    @sanchittiwari7690 2 года назад

    This song is her Magnum Opus

  • @0_Cardboard_0
    @0_Cardboard_0 2 года назад +1

    Suarez questioned the song because she sounds too much like Yoshi

  • @enjoshi-godrez8775
    @enjoshi-godrez8775 2 года назад

    Who is he speaking to?

  • @berkeskaya
    @berkeskaya 2 года назад +3

    I had only heard Dance Monkey and it doesn’t sound as bad as people make it out to be. It can be annoying like an overplayed Shape of You kinda way.
    Now that I’ve heard Won’t Sleep here, it sounds to me that the new track Charlie just dialed down on the personality of her first record. As annoying as it may sound to a lot of people, the first record had a tiny tinge of something that can later be turned into an original style.
    This new track has zero personality and sounds as mass produced as anything on the radio. Tones and I must be happy that she’s more embraced but that’s just a loss for the music. If every “bad” and “awful” thing in the pop scene is demolished, we’re gonna get “listenable” shit like this as if that’s a better course.

  • @larissabrglum3856
    @larissabrglum3856 2 года назад

    "Won't Sleep" strikes me as a shitty knockoff of that Billie Eilish song

  • @chrischris9157
    @chrischris9157 2 года назад +4

    Off camera guy is annoying