All the effin negatives on here ffs dave is nearly 80 and no doubt this will be his last tour, please just enjoy the master while we still can. I've seen Floyd many times from the first time in 1975 when i was 18 yrs old till the last time in 1994. I'm 67yrs old now and really enjoying this, and yes i saw Floyd in their prime but i am not going to be criticising David as true Pink Floyd fans wouldn't dream of doing that.
The ticket for the concerts has a “prime” price. So let Dave get out of that laziness and he should practice his own music. We like when he improvise well.
The trouble with the coments is they expect them all to be comfortable numb and wish you were here there not he’s trying something new for me i think his new stuff is good
It’s also a brand new band! Only Guy Pratt from Floyed. That’s like learning to play with a compelet new family.!! Huge congrats to the sound techs. What a fenomial job guys❤❤❤❤❤🙏🙏👍👍🇬🇧🇬🇧🥃🥃💎💎💎
Not entirely true... There's a couple of guys he's been playing with in his solo career, for example: Greg Phillinganes was there the last tour as well.
So I may be the critical one: but let me preface this with David is the last living of my guitar gods. I have him tattooed on my arm for god's sake. But he is aging and it is so sad. This guitar performance was sub-par for him. Voice was not good either. I still paid to see him at Madison Square Garden but I'm bummed I'm not seeing David in his prime.
Excuse me but that song was epic in Live at Pompeii with Bryan Chambers. The current singer can not do anything in comparison. And Dave did what he is used to do: improvise too match and play out of scale.
There's something deeply mournful that one of the greatest guitarists to ever live may be playing his last tour. But, at the same time, we can celebrate Gilmour is alive and well and healthy enough to be touring once more to leave what could be his farewell tour without him labeling it as such. I don't mind that he was slightly off. It proves he is not using backing tracks or pre-recorded music in his sets. Just bummed that tickets are so expensive for this tour as I got to see Waters & Mason in their recent tours. I'm going to have to splurge for the tickets somehow.
Boy solo was bit rough I hope he would get rust off, last tour he has been playing better as tour progressed, this time hes not gonna have lots of time giving how short tour will be
@@marccosta7376 You know we gather here as his fans, but it is what it is. I felt that for 2006 it was still a tail of his prime and you could sense that he had full control of what he wanted to play and brought it. 2016 he obviously lost a step but left us with many fabolous renditions of these guitar leads( Sorrow, CN at Pompeii, his last stint at RAH, you name it). This time I ve got this tense feeling through his solos of how decently would they sound and dont get me wrong some of them were still pretty good. TBH I was bit suprised that he decided to play live again because I remember him stated once maybe in RS magazine of how many mistakes he starts to make, I guess it was around 2020
@@JacobHolda Totally understand your point of view. As a 35 year old fan watching him millions of times on TV throughout Delicate sound of thunder, Pulse and even On an island, as you point, it has been a hard time for me listening to the great David Gilmour doing 2-3 mistakes every half a minute. Saw him 3 times during Rattle that lock tour and I noticed he had lost hability but he was still great. As a guitarist I have felt anxious with this video and as a fan...sad. But at a certain age you lose mental agility, creativity, speed on your fingers....I will pardon every mistake he does next week in Rome in front of me and other fans. I will never be able to give him back what he has given me.
😢Je suis triste pour lui il ne devait pas être bien , l age est là, la fatigue le stress les doigts aussi son fatigués et tous guitariste peut merder sur un solo je sais se que c est 😢 En tous cas le plus grand merci du monde a Mr Gilmour pour tous ce qu il m a apporté depuis ma jeunesse, on vous aimera et écoutera toujours.Merci❤❤❤❤❤
Even at 80, he sounds fantastic! He struggled a touch with the high notes on Comfortably Numb but not nearly as much as I'd have expected. He still sings better than the other guy on this one. He was flat in a couple spots. And David hasn't missed a step on guitar, although maybe a little less adventurous. A+ as usual! Thanks for uploading these!
He missed several steps on the guitar on this song. A few wrong notes in there. But then that's what rehearsals are for. I'm sure by the end of the tour his guitar playing will be back to its best.
@@bujin1977 Yeah, quite a few bum notes or missed notes in the other songs too, but better than someone miming to a backing track and it shows that even gods can be human.
Before anyone gets their panties in a twist David is 78 years old, there are going to be times he struggles on certain parts, his voice isn't as young as it was and quite frankly I think it's a lot better that he designates the parts he's struggling to sing to the other musicians while singing the parts he is able to. Much better than lip-syncing.
He tones is great as always but he needs to practice more because he’s struggling to keep up with his own solos. I expect he’ll improve significantly after a few weeks of touring
Gilmour torna a suonare con la red strat ti prego...da quando hai la black strato il tuo suono si è spento,senza dinamica, senza sustain,poca presenza suono esile fiacco,non esce proprio da quella chitarra nera..i cambi chitarra oppure tecnico del suono.....gilmour= red strato.
Honestly I’m hoping they are holding back some for the actual shows. He is having trouble hitting notes. Overall they are not in sync and the sound not well balanced. It’s why it’s a rehearsal…I hope. Even with that said I could listen to it over and over again. I wish he had the backup singers from last tour along with his daughter and the others. Especially on this song.
@@thedarkdefender7780 he doesn’t set the prices. And even then, what does the cost have to do with people have completely unrealistic expectations of an old man?
I discovered in bootleg and in the pay per view complete version of Pulse that he usually made mistakes. It is not related with his age. The thing is that we grow up listening the edited concerts. I love him but I feel a little disappointed.
Playing guitar without making mistakes is impossible especially live on studio albums you can play it 500 times through and just take all the best parts. Mistakes also lead too different sounds it can be a good thing. Plus the way I see it he's the creator of it and no one will ever play it as good as he can. and when he doesn't make mistakes people will try too copy those too.
@@damianbouttell537and one thing even worse: because the light guy did not know what Dave is going to improvise, the lights are out of the momentum with the solo. This is not comfortably numb pulse version that the lights were key with the music
@@wetbluesba I get what you’re saying, but I don’t watch the light show. I’m just watching the band and living the music. Light show is completely irrelevant to me. But I guess that is something I am missing out on?
![David Gilmour - Vita Brevis/ Between Two Points [Live From Circo Massimo, Roma🇮🇹 (27/09/2024)]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ViyaL40LdCA/mqdefault.jpg)
Buenísimo Gilmour ... gracias por subir los videos
That 2nd guitarist is like David from the 80s!
All the effin negatives on here ffs dave is nearly 80 and no doubt this will be his last tour, please just enjoy the master while we still can. I've seen Floyd many times from the first time in 1975 when i was 18 yrs old till the last time in 1994. I'm 67yrs old now and really enjoying this, and yes i saw Floyd in their prime but i am not going to be criticising David as true Pink Floyd fans wouldn't dream of doing that.
The ticket for the concerts has a “prime” price. So let Dave get out of that laziness and he should practice his own music. We like when he improvise well.
@@wetbluesba Yeah the guys 78 he doesn't have too this ya know. plus he doesn't set the ticket prices the venue does.
Exactly. The fact that he's still creating music and out performing is a gift.
The trouble with the coments is they expect them all to be comfortable numb and wish you were here there not he’s trying something new for me i think his new stuff is good
What was full set list for the night?
You Can google it. Basically it was all the songs from the new album mixed with Pink Floyd songs.
No David Gilmour- No Pink Floyd!
It’s also a brand new band!
Only Guy Pratt from Floyed.
That’s like learning to play with a compelet new family.!!
Huge congrats to the sound techs. What a fenomial job guys❤❤❤❤❤🙏🙏👍👍🇬🇧🇬🇧🥃🥃💎💎💎
Not entirely true... There's a couple of guys he's been playing with in his solo career, for example: Greg Phillinganes was there the last tour as well.
The keys player was the last tour the black guy I know that and of course guy Pratt known for Floyd tours!!
Thank you for these uploads Sean. Awesome 😎👍🏻
So I may be the critical one: but let me preface this with David is the last living of my guitar gods. I have him tattooed on my arm for god's sake. But he is aging and it is so sad. This guitar performance was sub-par for him. Voice was not good either. I still paid to see him at Madison Square Garden but I'm bummed I'm not seeing David in his prime.
Sean, thanks for sharing these videos. 🙏✨
Tutto quello che esprime suonando... è immenso! Troppo per riuscire a descriverlo! Un GIGANTE immenso!!!👏💯💓🎸🎶
Excuse me but that song was epic in Live at Pompeii with Bryan Chambers. The current singer can not do anything in comparison. And Dave did what he is used to do: improvise too match and play out of scale.
I get it your right
Just a word: AMAZING
Nice to know this will be in the set list. Probably my favorite of all his solo works (although haven't listened to all of Luck yet).
The solo in "Scattered" on the new album is also amazing, close to the one in Comfortably Numb
L’une de nos dernières Légendes … en pesant bien mes mots ! Merci David pour ton œuvre … 🥰
There's something deeply mournful that one of the greatest guitarists to ever live may be playing his last tour. But, at the same time, we can celebrate Gilmour is alive and well and healthy enough to be touring once more to leave what could be his farewell tour without him labeling it as such. I don't mind that he was slightly off. It proves he is not using backing tracks or pre-recorded music in his sets. Just bummed that tickets are so expensive for this tour as I got to see Waters & Mason in their recent tours. I'm going to have to splurge for the tickets somehow.
Boy solo was bit rough I hope he would get rust off, last tour he has been playing better as tour progressed, this time hes not gonna have lots of time giving how short tour will be
Last tour was 9 years ago..
@@marccosta7376 You know we gather here as his fans, but it is what it is. I felt that for 2006 it was still a tail of his prime and you could sense that he had full control of what he wanted to play and brought it. 2016 he obviously lost a step but left us with many fabolous renditions of these guitar leads( Sorrow, CN at Pompeii, his last stint at RAH, you name it). This time I ve got this tense feeling through his solos of how decently would they sound and dont get me wrong some of them were still pretty good. TBH I was bit suprised that he decided to play live again because I remember him stated once maybe in RS magazine of how many mistakes he starts to make, I guess it was around 2020
@@JacobHolda Totally understand your point of view. As a 35 year old fan watching him millions of times on TV throughout Delicate sound of thunder, Pulse and even On an island, as you point, it has been a hard time for me listening to the great David Gilmour doing 2-3 mistakes every half a minute. Saw him 3 times during Rattle that lock tour and I noticed he had lost hability but he was still great. As a guitarist I have felt anxious with this video and as a fan...sad. But at a certain age you lose mental agility, creativity, speed on your fingers....I will pardon every mistake he does next week in Rome in front of me and other fans. I will never be able to give him back what he has given me.
Gilmour seguindo firme e forte a nos emocionar! Kisses from Brazil!
Thank you for this!
El mejor músico de la historia y del mundo entero siempre!!!!!!!!.....
Superb.
Bravissimo come sempre un bel Buongiorno fortunato chi lo ha visto e sentiti ❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
Domenica tocca a me a Roma
Un genio di un'altra galassia
@@00enomisdomenica ci sarò anch’io con mio figlio
Sabato tocca a me. 🎉😊
domani tocca a me! :-)
Presente pure io! Grazie David per tutto!!
😢Je suis triste pour lui il ne devait pas être bien , l age est là, la fatigue le stress les doigts aussi son fatigués et tous guitariste peut merder sur un solo je sais se que c est 😢
En tous cas le plus grand merci du monde a Mr Gilmour pour tous ce qu il m a apporté depuis ma jeunesse, on vous aimera et écoutera toujours.Merci❤❤❤❤❤
Even at 80, he sounds fantastic! He struggled a touch with the high notes on Comfortably Numb but not nearly as much as I'd have expected. He still sings better than the other guy on this one. He was flat in a couple spots. And David hasn't missed a step on guitar, although maybe a little less adventurous. A+ as usual! Thanks for uploading these!
He missed several steps on the guitar on this song. A few wrong notes in there. But then that's what rehearsals are for. I'm sure by the end of the tour his guitar playing will be back to its best.
A little younger Peter Gabriel kept his voice as ever - really amazing! Saw him live June Last year.
@@bujin1977 Yeah, quite a few bum notes or missed notes in the other songs too, but better than someone miming to a backing track and it shows that even gods can be human.
He's 78, not 80. He's a Pisces like me.
PG is 73.
merciiiiiii😍🤩😍🥰❤❤❤❤🌝🌞
First time I hear a few wrong notes in his solo. Thank God, he's human 😂
He's 78 man.
He's always amazing whether solo or as in pink Floyd
amazing Mate!!!!!!
Top
It’s like anythin. If ya ain’t done it for a while , it takes a couple , in Dave’s case, shows to get into the flow.
Great job Everyone.❤❤❤❤🙏🙏👍👍🇬🇧🇬🇧🥃🥃
Eternal David Gilmour! Long life to the King! ❤
Gran cancion
O músico mais completo
Tks❤
My God
Is a great album good work
Before anyone gets their panties in a twist David is 78 years old, there are going to be times he struggles on certain parts, his voice isn't as young as it was and quite frankly I think it's a lot better that he designates the parts he's struggling to sing to the other musicians while singing the parts he is able to. Much better than lip-syncing.
Not one of his best it has to be said. Amazing he's still doing this though.
Thankyou for the video.
Beautiful!
He tones is great as always but he needs to practice more because he’s struggling to keep up with his own solos. I expect he’ll improve significantly after a few weeks of touring
Gilmour torna a suonare con la red strat ti prego...da quando hai la black strato il tuo suono si è spento,senza dinamica, senza sustain,poca presenza suono esile fiacco,non esce proprio da quella chitarra nera..i cambi chitarra oppure tecnico del suono.....gilmour= red strato.
❤❤❤🎉
Honestly I’m hoping they are holding back some for the actual shows. He is having trouble hitting notes. Overall they are not in sync and the sound not well balanced. It’s why it’s a rehearsal…I hope.
Even with that said I could listen to it over and over again. I wish he had the backup singers from last tour along with his daughter and the others. Especially on this song.
He’s 78 years old.
@@kjek1 And charging fans a lot of money to see him.
@@thedarkdefender7780 he doesn’t set the prices. And even then, what does the cost have to do with people have completely unrealistic expectations of an old man?
Can't remember seeing him struggle so much during a solo...must be heartbreaking for him as he's always been a perfectionist...
I discovered in bootleg and in the pay per view complete version of Pulse that he usually made mistakes. It is not related with his age. The thing is that we grow up listening the edited concerts. I love him but I feel a little disappointed.
Playing guitar without making mistakes is impossible especially live on studio albums you can play it 500 times through and just take all the best parts. Mistakes also lead too different sounds it can be a good thing. Plus the way I see it he's the creator of it and no one will ever play it as good as he can. and when he doesn't make mistakes people will try too copy those too.
in realtà ha sempre suonato male, solo che prima non c'erano gli smartphone 😉
the same boring Lightshow, as nine years ago .
If you can do better………put up or shut up!
@@damianbouttell537and one thing even worse: because the light guy did not know what Dave is going to improvise, the lights are out of the momentum with the solo. This is not comfortably numb pulse version that the lights were key with the music
@@wetbluesba I get what you’re saying, but I don’t watch the light show. I’m just watching the band and living the music. Light show is completely irrelevant to me. But I guess that is something I am missing out on?
лысый совсем играть разучился...
👌