@@ninapark4342 i know, right? How exciting is that a outside label has decided to work with all of the members to do a comeback for them. There have not been many cases like that, where a different label agrees on "taking over", nor members of previous groups that have agreed to come back. In fact, T-ara has 2 members that have refused to rejoin such later activities but at least the 4 of them still are willing to do so :)))
This is the best Secret song for me. It's just so sad that this had been recognized as one of the best masterpiece by critics in kpop history but not recognized by a lot of people. This group and song deserves moree!!!
It’s crazy how this is 6 years old , I remember the day it came out I couldn’t stop listening 🙉 I’m 23 now 😭 I’m glad I found kpop back then , it was the best era for sure
A lot of people yearn for "2nd gen kpop," but they don't support current groups today that have 2nd gen vibes like April, Gfriend, Fromis 9, Lovelyz, Oh My Girl, and Apink. 😔
Tbh i just started listening to last year, and i listen to the old kpop songs more than now days lip biting lipstick fokin these gae. I listen to B.A.P, BIG BANG, VIXX,GOT7, SHINEE,. the only new group i like is Stray kidz
Nobody can stop me ,secret is the best . First idols who I ever watch they attract me towards kpop and l am in love with 5 years and more until my death .only real fans can't forget them they are the best
This song is listened to every day many times. like the song because But I don't know the meaning. Thank you for sending it to me. I like Ji Eun's voice too, it's even more beautiful in my heart.
Damn, all I can really say of this song is this was really ahead of its time… I still miss the beat that sounds like ocean that made every song good… this would’ve been more successful if it was released in 2017…
i used to have this song as my ringtone and alarm.. my fave from that year. hope jieun and hyosung will have a comeback even tough i love sunhwa. I hope she is happy now.
Okay okay.... SECRET just may be my favourite kpop band now.... Followed them by chance when Isaw 'madonna', but man they've really come such a long way.... And I'm in Love, holy smokes, great stuff............. Now I really don't know whether SNSD or Secret is my #1 favourite....
+Ubayd Deen SNSD have some cute girls in it, but i'd take Secret over them. I'm just not feeling most of SNSD songs and Secret's songs are my genre. Buy my top group on my list is AOA!!!
Hana's singing voice is so lovely. I like it. She should do both singing n rapping next time. It's a waste for her not to show off her singing voice :)
It really was different from the usual Secret cutesy image that I didn't like and showed them in a mature light. I just wish there weren't so many backup dancers in the lives jumping and crawling all over the place because the song has a chill/haunting vibe to it. It is my favorite song from Secret together with "My boy", that I think should have got more spotlight because it is such a pretty song.
Actually sad to think they were so underrated and neglected in the industry. they really had great hits and comebacks, i loved them! It breaks my heart to know they disbanded three years ago, I hope at least Hyosung will comeback soon.
I truly hate TS but I have to admit they have the best mv directors. All of them are beautifuly shot and edited in terms of angles, colour, transitions etc.
As soon as this song was released, it topped many charts real time. Unfortunately, the car accident happened and promotions were halted suddenly. If the accident didn't happen, this song would have won and gave the group huge popularity.
o my God.. why I so like like Ji eun... she's pretty, sweet, elegant and have great voice too.. help me please.. i don't wanna become her big fan 😱😱😱😱 sorry my bad english 😀😀😀
The queens were not afraid of change and had a firm style of their own.And today, there are only groups that have been filmed at the same factory in kpop.
![[MV] After School(애프터스쿨) _ First Love(첫사랑)](/img/1.gif)
The Era where KPOP was full of spice, loving the serious and mature concepts
T-ARA, Secret and KARA are the best kpop girlband Forever.
I’m still a fan of T-ara. They will comeback soon.
@@ninapark4342 i know, right? How exciting is that a outside label has decided to work with all of the members to do a comeback for them. There have not been many cases like that, where a different label agrees on "taking over", nor members of previous groups that have agreed to come back. In fact, T-ara has 2 members that have refused to rejoin such later activities but at least the 4 of them still are willing to do so :)))
my favorite group to the 2nd generation !!!
This is the best Secret song for me. It's just so sad that this had been recognized as one of the best masterpiece by critics in kpop history but not recognized by a lot of people. This group and song deserves moree!!!
There are too many 2nd generation songs that I am still jamming. They got beautiful songs.
Yeahh.. full of meaningg for every song from 2nd generation.. 🥺 ..
So lucky I can know them..
Bro give me the list
@@sovereignboss1841 kard/ b1a4/ b.a.p/ vixx/ sistar/ shinee/ bigbang idk
It’s crazy how this is 6 years old , I remember the day it came out I couldn’t stop listening 🙉 I’m 23 now 😭 I’m glad I found kpop back then , it was the best era for sure
Me too =)) and I'm 24!♡
2021
A lot of people yearn for "2nd gen kpop," but they don't support current groups today that have 2nd gen vibes like April, Gfriend, Fromis 9, Lovelyz, Oh My Girl, and Apink. 😔
Too bad it ended too fast
Tbh i just started listening to last year, and i listen to the old kpop songs more than now days lip biting lipstick fokin these gae.
I listen to B.A.P, BIG BANG, VIXX,GOT7, SHINEE,.
the only new group i like is Stray kidz
it's June 2019 and i'm coming back to every old kpop songs😭 i miss this era of kpop💔
crystaltears 02
Loved this era of kpop T-T
It's September 2019 and I'm still here 😢 I miss them so much
They are still Queens 😭❤️
Same🙂
me too really really miss old kpop song
It's been 2020, anybody same with me
And I'm back again today on APRIL 2021 🤟 (miss K-Pop 2nd generation)
Me... Really miss old kpop sing...
Yes
omg yes ofc
Yes
I hate modern k-pop. Hallyu 2.0 for life!
Secret was so underrated, they deserved more recognition ❤
Nobody can stop me ,secret is the best . First idols who I ever watch they attract me towards kpop and l am in love with 5 years and more until my death .only real fans can't forget them they are the best
How I wish they would have a reunion, they are missed 🥺
The fact that none of the current girlgroups will be able to pull this off the way Secret did
2nd gen girl/boy bands are irreplaceable
I miss Secret! ㅠㅠ
same
Same ! I don't understand why they don't make comeback
They are due a three member comeback the latter half of this year- so really soon!! Hana, hyoseong and Jieun. :)
This song is listened to every day many times. like the song because But I don't know the meaning. Thank you for sending it to me. I like Ji Eun's voice too, it's even more beautiful in my heart.
Cant believe that this song is 8 years old😭😭 im sobbing i miss 2012 era soo much 😭😭
came back because i just got to know that this song was written by LE (ex-exid) and yeah, this was one of the best secret songs truly ~~
Is EXID disband?
@@sam-yeonnie yes
I miss this era Secret, T-ara, kara snsd T T
4minute, Orange caramel, brown eyes girls, wonder girls
@@NathyGaRa Thats rightt....i misss all of them
What happened to them?
@@sovereignboss1841 some disbanded and some are not active anymore.
@@sovereignboss1841 also a member of Kara and F(x) died :(
i miss secret so muchhhhh
this song is scrumptious, it tickles the right place in my brain
The way the bass just subtly supports this song. so beautiful ugh
kpop will never be the same anymore...not based on views and just pure talent....i feel like everything changed to the worst...
Damn, all I can really say of this song is this was really ahead of its time… I still miss the beat that sounds like ocean that made every song good… this would’ve been more successful if it was released in 2017…
역시 좋은 노래는 2023년에 와서도 참 좋네요❤
2nd kpop gen is the best era 💖 💓 💕 ❤ 💗 ♥ 💖 💓 💕
Still my favourite Secret song. Never gets old for me.
~FM :)
Cuz of Twice comeback with Talk that Talk soon which reminded me of my fav song
Fr
this is such a beautiful song - ballad-like, yet addictive melody.
Tidak ada habisnya kalau berbicara group wanita gen. 2 rata2 bertalenta dan konsepnya sangat unik please comeback buat group wanita gen. 2
Class, beauty, sophistication, perfection - only in Kpop!
i used to have this song as my ringtone and alarm.. my fave from that year. hope jieun and hyosung will have a comeback even tough i love sunhwa. I hope she is happy now.
One of the best kpop songs ever. I can't stop hearing it!! How so underrated
They were the second female group I loved after CSJH The Grace, it seriously broke my heart when they disbanded. They had so much potential.
It's 2018 and I still watching this. ❤
Immortal song
I still watch it in 2019...🤣🤣🤣 Anyone will comment in 2020?
this song bring bad memories :( .. but i like it so much .. wonder if secret ever will sing it again :(
Why this good song is so underrated ?!!! TT
Secret didn't get to promote it for long because the members were in a car accident, so it wasn't promoted for long.
They promoted for like 2 weeks due to that car crash T_T Took months for them to appear again.
I'm not even a Secret fan, but I gotta admit that this is one of the best kpop songs ever, at least for me.
2024년에도 찾아왔습니다
저도요 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
still their best song to date. way too underrated
It's 2021 but this song hits different :
Why?
@@sovereignboss1841 it's just that 2nd gen kpop has the best songs that I can't get over with hehe
They were one of the most talented groups in the history of women's groups.
I heard this song when I was 9 years old. and now after 9 years I finally found it
I miss them
2021
Okay okay.... SECRET just may be my favourite kpop band now.... Followed them by chance when Isaw 'madonna', but man they've really come such a long way.... And I'm in Love, holy smokes, great stuff............. Now I really don't know whether SNSD or Secret is my #1 favourite....
+Ubayd Deen SNSD have some cute girls in it, but i'd take Secret over them. I'm just not feeling most of SNSD songs and Secret's songs are my genre. Buy my top group on my list is AOA!!!
Hana's singing voice is so lovely. I like it. She should do both singing n rapping next time. It's a waste for her not to show off her singing voice :)
이 곡 진심 레알 좋았는디ㅠㅠ
그때도 알았는데 시크릿 명곡 너무 많은 것 같다 막 제 친구들은 시크릿 춤 너무 못추고 쉽고 야하다고 욕해서 나 엄청 스트레스 받았는데....
저도 시크릿 나머지 멤버들이 꼭 컴백해주면 좋겠어요. I'm in Love랑 Talk That도 너무너무 좋아요. 그렇게 야하지도 않은데… 같은 여자인데도 정말 멋있고, 특유의 발랄함이 있어서 좋아하는 걸그룹이에요.
@@달콤한디저트-u1x 암인럽 춤도 끝내주는데 아까운 걸그룹었어요
저두ㅎㅎ
It really was different from the usual Secret cutesy image that I didn't like and showed them in a mature light. I just wish there weren't so many backup dancers in the lives jumping and crawling all over the place because the song has a chill/haunting vibe to it. It is my favorite song from Secret together with "My boy", that I think should have got more spotlight because it is such a pretty song.
still one of the best songs of kpop history
Actually sad to think they were so underrated and neglected in the industry. they really had great hits and comebacks, i loved them! It breaks my heart to know they disbanded three years ago, I hope at least Hyosung will comeback soon.
BEST UNDERRATED SONG TO EXISTS⭐
I truly hate TS but I have to admit they have the best mv directors. All of them are beautifuly shot and edited in terms of angles, colour, transitions etc.
may i recommend you some loona's MV if youre into neat and beautiful filming
true, ts did their idols really dirty. but remember that they seriously mistreated their employees too.
The music is always amazing too
yupp i agree
zaku196 flops
정말 명곡..
i love this
this era of kpop will be forver in my heart
2nd of 2019 and i'm still here listening to this beautiful song sung by beautiful angels.
Favorite song from elementary school until now still ringing ❤️😭
And here I'm still listening to this song. Omg it's being so long. All the old kpop memories coming back.
이 노래 좋아했었는데 지금 들어도 좋다
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL,THEY ARE BEAUTIFUL,EVERYTHING IS BEAUTIFUL
This MV deserve more views the song is amazing!
Hana & Ji Eun ♥
One of best kpop song of all time
I am literally rewatching all of secrets mv's rn 😭😭😭✨ I miss my gg
Not me having a playlist of songs from this iconic k-pop generation
This is their most underrated comeback, I mean IT IS ART
OMG this song is a jewel, i really miss the k-pop 2nd generation 😭
Secret plz have a comeback secret times miss you all a lot
how ironic, their debut song is titled "I Want You Back"
Can listen to this over and over again all day.
Came here 2021, cause i miss 2nd Gen. GG Song...
Best Secret Song !!!
this is my favorite secret song, im in love even in the first tatatata
Primeiro girlgroup de kpop que ouvi, lá em 2013, e até hoje sou apaixonada por essa música
It's september 2019, the kpop old really cool, the song has meaning
I agree
As soon as this song was released, it topped many charts real time. Unfortunately, the car accident happened and promotions were halted suddenly. If the accident didn't happen, this song would have won and gave the group huge popularity.
Lovely …. Klassic Kpop !!
One of the best songs in Kpop.
the bass line got me hooked to this song.
These songs remind me .. the best time of my childhood 🥺🥺❤️❤️❤️❤️ second generation kpop songs hit so hard 😭😭💗💗💗💗
i miss so much secret.. queens of kpop
I’m crying always when I listen to ‘Talk that’
6 years and still watching
Cant stop watching Ji Eun'parts TT
2023 but still THE best song in kpop history
it's been 2021, and here i am still crying over this masterpiece 🥲💕
Omg ma girls... miss the song
I was 15 when this song was released and im 23 song time flies too fast😭 i miss this era
I like this💖It's really beautiful song!!
One of the best kpop song, i hope secret do comeback
The song reminds me of my high school era
2022년 겨울에 이노래가 생각나서 검색해서 보는건 나뿐인가...?🤣
Miss Secret so much.Willing to watch this until 2019!!
Secret is THE BEST EVER
아깝다 명곡인데. 이런 슬프고 심각한듯한 감정선의 댄스곡 좋아
I USED TO DANE TO THE CHORUS ALL THE TIME ahhhh I miss old kpop
This is a beautiful song; I feel better when I listen it; although I know that this is a sad song.
why am I just being OBSESSED with this song in 2021?!!
o my God..
why I so like like Ji eun...
she's pretty, sweet, elegant and have great voice too..
help me please.. i don't wanna become her big fan 😱😱😱😱
sorry my bad english 😀😀😀
어디에서
why not? my bias is SunHwa but Ji Eun is a very close second to me... i like her a lot too.
Still love this song till now
This song bring my old memories of old kpop. The gold one
This song is bomb asf !!!
Their best song IMO. :)
와 12년말에 저거 티비에서 오지게 들은거 생각난다 시크릿 그립다
I miss Secret. This was peak kpop era back then.
My favourite song from them
Hồi còn nhỏ là mê mẩn giờ nghe lại hồi ức về nửa .
The queens were not afraid of change and had a firm style of their own.And today, there are only groups that have been filmed at the same factory in kpop.
2021 and this is still one of the best songs out there