Tribute to Abbaji | Tabla Solo | Celebrating the Birth Centenary of Ustad Allarakha

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 346

  • @ganessh8160
    @ganessh8160 3 года назад +231

    When people talk about Avengers assembling, show them this video.

  • @debotoshdey6610
    @debotoshdey6610 2 года назад +28

    Legendary discipline, practice, love for the instrument and respect for fellow musicians...all in one place! ❤️ Breaks my heart realising that Pt. Shubhankar ji is no more with us.

  • @shriharidhanvantri2411
    @shriharidhanvantri2411 3 года назад +40

    Do any crime while these legends are performing !! Because even god is busy watching them perform ...

    • @dhananjay608
      @dhananjay608 3 года назад +2

      Best complimentary Remark ever.

  • @TheMarketingMan4U
    @TheMarketingMan4U 4 года назад +70

    When legends are together even the creator wants to sit and listen his creations. Godly performance.

    • @covidfan6371
      @covidfan6371 2 года назад

      You may become the Buddhas.
      You are the Buddhas..
      But you forgot how to become the Buddha.
      Very easy, 1_ keep your mind calm, quiet and ease.
      Ignore bad and good.
      While in that state you speak to your self these words" A Di Da Phat" keep repeat it inside your head and don't think of anything else if you can do like that within 7 days non-stop . You can become the Buddha.

    • @pjagan123
      @pjagan123 2 года назад

      Very well said

  • @vaibhavchoudhary4895
    @vaibhavchoudhary4895 5 лет назад +30

    Each time Ustaad Akram Khan played it sounded different from others.The clarity of both daayan & baayan is something else. The Nikaas is just amazing.

    • @insaan1234
      @insaan1234 5 лет назад +10

      It's his style of playing and is known for it

    • @BuntySingh-ih8bu
      @BuntySingh-ih8bu 5 лет назад +9

      it is becoz he made tabla from qasim khan niyazi...best tabla maker

    • @vaibhavchoudhary4895
      @vaibhavchoudhary4895 5 лет назад +17

      @@BuntySingh-ih8bu My friend, it's not about tabla maker. There are many good tabla makers in county who are "world's best" in their own right. It's all about the hand of Ustaad Akram Khan.

    • @bhargavdeshmukh3011
      @bhargavdeshmukh3011 3 года назад +9

      @@BuntySingh-ih8bu lolll how easily you stated that huh😂
      Bt thats not the case actually..akram bhai already has a very sweet tone

    • @pjagan123
      @pjagan123 2 года назад +1

      Absolutely correct

  • @bikashbhattacharjee7516
    @bikashbhattacharjee7516 4 года назад +31

    Once you close your eyes, Ustad Akram Khan seems so very crisp. Distinct too! Am mesmerised!

    • @soumitrabandyopadhyay3049
      @soumitrabandyopadhyay3049 3 года назад +3

      Sabse surila haat...that's why, sounds outstanding with vocal...Seems to be very humble too..Face resembles Rafi sahab..

  • @Wisdomwithdinesh
    @Wisdomwithdinesh 4 года назад +48

    Satyajit Ji's tirkit in the later part of the video is more crisp and clear than any other I felt. Specially, after listening to Faizal's attempt Satyajit ji's performance feels heavenly.

  • @bluegamefreak
    @bluegamefreak 5 лет назад +45

    Ustad Allarakha was one of a kind. One in a billion honestly. He will be remembered through his magical rhythms.

  • @extra2ab
    @extra2ab 4 года назад +76

    This relieves stress in this Corona quarantine period

  • @soumendubhattacherya2122
    @soumendubhattacherya2122 4 года назад +20

    Pt. Subhankar Banerjee seems to have come out of Ustad Zakir Hussain's aura.
    Pt. Yogesh Samshi's hands are so sweet. Not that I'm comparing anyone. It feels so alliviating to see the greats appreciate each other so heartily and generously.

  • @MANMETR
    @MANMETR 5 лет назад +91

    Sabir Khan in Sarangi is just another dimension. Wah..

  • @saksham_daksh
    @saksham_daksh 2 года назад +6

    All the artists are like different flowers with their own fragrance. Late Pandit Subhankar Banerjee played so sensibly with mindblowing upaj and very sweet voice is coming from his tabla.Will miss his live performances 😣

  • @ashok5591
    @ashok5591 3 года назад +8

    Pt. Yogesh Samsiji, the maestro with spectacles on thy face, playing on the tabla mesmerised everyone. We all felt lucky to see the legend in the midst.
    In fact, all the great legends are playing on the tabla here.

  • @wisedesi442
    @wisedesi442 4 года назад +11

    I also love how Ustad Akram khan looks when Pandit Samsiji playing , great hall mark of keen observer and life long student.

    • @Arupkant
      @Arupkant 2 года назад +2

      well said indeed.....i also noticed that......

    • @nitishjha6013
      @nitishjha6013 Год назад

      I also noticed

  • @yashmehta5873
    @yashmehta5873 5 лет назад +51

    Pt. Shubhanker Banerjee - Just his temperamant and the effortlessness with which he plays is just amazing
    Ut Zakir Hussain - Superb Laykaari and bold strokes...though he wasn't in full mood here I feel
    Pt Yogesh Samsi - incredible finesse, fine play of tabla...great Laykaari as usual
    Ut Akram Khan Saheb - His Tirakita at 33:32 outshines everyone's in nikaas and tonal quality...Best of Ajrada Gharana
    Pt Satyajit Talwalkar - Amazing tihai kaam... His father Pt. Suresh Ji's Laydaari reflects in his training...
    Ut Fazak Qureshi also played very well but I found others are playing much better than him...seemed a bit loose and strokes were not proper in speed and nikaas

    • @vaibhavchoudhary4895
      @vaibhavchoudhary4895 5 лет назад +2

      I can vouch for you on this bro...

    • @Wisdomwithdinesh
      @Wisdomwithdinesh 4 года назад +2

      Well analysed and I concur with everything you said.

    • @Wisdomwithdinesh
      @Wisdomwithdinesh 4 года назад +3

      And I think though evryone has tuned tabla in same pitch, the tonal quality varies a lot.

    • @santanu20072007
      @santanu20072007 4 года назад +1

      What an analysis! I personally adore Ustaad Akram Khan a lot!!!

    • @zakihussain4613
      @zakihussain4613 4 года назад +5

      My friend its humbly request plz recorect your comment akram khan is not doyen of ajrada gharana
      Doyen of ajrada gharana is ustad manju khan sahab who were son of tabla samrat ustad habibuddin khan sahab

  • @raktimmedhi8001
    @raktimmedhi8001 3 года назад +4

    This is our nation ,this is the Indian classical musical instrument, and these are of course our pride.

  • @psrinivasrao2124
    @psrinivasrao2124 4 года назад +8

    42:05 Ustaad Akram Khan saheb looks so cute while playing..........🤗🤗🤗 Love u all

  • @AjayKumar-eo6em
    @AjayKumar-eo6em 4 года назад +1

    यह इतिहास में लिखा जाएगा। पूरा के पूरे महान पुरुष एक साथ तबला बाजा रहे है और एक दूसरे को तारीफ भी कर रहे है, इसिको को महानता बोलते है।

  • @gedelasimhachalam1483
    @gedelasimhachalam1483 4 года назад +13

    44:38 subhankar obedience and zaker replying..what a scene.

  • @however823
    @however823 4 года назад +29

    I think zakir ji was getting emotional for his father's memories... Its obvious.. How great his father was

  • @parambariar5543
    @parambariar5543 5 лет назад +17

    Waheguru ji tuhanu sareya ustada nu hamesha hi chardikalan cha rakhe ji🤗🙏

  • @sankalangoldar.
    @sankalangoldar. 4 года назад +8

    Apart from only playing.. ustad zakir husaain is having a lot of stuffs in mind... from leading the event....to conduction the entire programme... inpite of that he is the best of alllllll 🤩🤩 all in stage are truely great people...🙏🙏

  • @stevecomins7837
    @stevecomins7837 3 года назад +3

    19:06 I'm having a heart attack...
    ... from playin in a band since 64' it's the interaction that really gets you.

  • @tdbarke
    @tdbarke 2 года назад +5

    One can identify Ustaad Ji’s just by listening , his fingers are divine.

  • @harkiratnanda26
    @harkiratnanda26 4 года назад +12

    Utmost heartfelt respect for all the Ustads. 🙏🏼 The unpredictability of Pandit Yogesh Samsi Ji's variations- simply mind-blowing. Ustad Akram Khan Sahab's speed. Particularly mentioning these two as this video introduced me to these virtuosos of the art of Tabla.
    So fortunate to see all of them play.

  • @nitishjha6013
    @nitishjha6013 Год назад

    Akram khan ji kitne pyar se aur dhyan se dekh rahe hain yogesh samsi ji ko mahan koi aise hi nhi ban jata ise kehte hai sachcha kalakar

  • @avinashdamami
    @avinashdamami 5 лет назад +5

    Boht kismat wala samjhta hu apne aap ko is dor me janam liya he jaha in mahan ustado ko sun pa raha hu ....allah inko hamesha salamat rakhe

  • @sreembit
    @sreembit Год назад

    5 Gods and one brother on one stage. The building would have caught on fire after they left..

  • @aymen2949
    @aymen2949 4 года назад +22

    They are all in the same level, great tabla players

    • @prithvigadekar1206
      @prithvigadekar1206 4 года назад +1

      But Zakir Hussain is famous in all of them

    • @aymen2949
      @aymen2949 4 года назад +1

      @@nareshsamlal maybe that some of them have larger career than others, but technically they are inthe same level

    • @nareshsamlal
      @nareshsamlal 4 года назад

      Harsh Raval I refuse to carry on this pointless conversation and desecrate such an invaluable recording of tabla history.

    • @bhargavdeshmukh3011
      @bhargavdeshmukh3011 3 года назад

      @@nareshsamlal smartie

  • @sabyasachijds93
    @sabyasachijds93 3 года назад +2

    Came across this video after a long time.....and with a heavy heart would like all tabla lovers to know that Pandit Subhankar Banerjee is no more. His soul has left for its heavenly abode on 25 August 2021 after fighting with Covid-19 . A huge loss to Indian Classical music. May his soul rest in peace 🙏🏻

    • @naveenct100
      @naveenct100 3 года назад +1

      What a loss ! Vibhutiyan kabhi marti nahein . Woh phir ayeingay !

  • @TheAlijafar
    @TheAlijafar 5 лет назад +10

    What a treat to listen to maestros.
    What a tribute to the legend Ustad Allah Rakkha sahab

  • @ksttayadepatil2685
    @ksttayadepatil2685 4 года назад +8

    भारतरत्न सहा तबला वादक यांना भारतरत्न म्हणतात खरोखरच

  • @bardsanindustries7447
    @bardsanindustries7447 4 года назад +5

    Most clarity and melody like right and left hand ...is Zakir Hussain

  • @vedantjoshi1487
    @vedantjoshi1487 5 лет назад +42

    at 40:54 ustat ji varied the pitch of dagga if we listened carefully, that's the reason everyone acknowledged ustad ji....pranam !

    • @AmirKhan-ng8ut
      @AmirKhan-ng8ut 3 года назад +1

      Who ?

    • @tdbarke
      @tdbarke 3 года назад +3

      @@AmirKhan-ng8ut There is only one Ustaad Ji..

  • @Rajatm2112
    @Rajatm2112 8 месяцев назад

    42:40 showmanship and maestroness ki bhi hadd hoti hai yaar! Ufff, the rhythmic cuteness ❤

  • @kishoresinha314
    @kishoresinha314 3 года назад

    बहुत खूब, बहुत खूब, बहुत खूब। सचमुच उस्ताद अल्लाह रक्खा ख़ां साहब की याद आ गई।

  • @sekharkar125
    @sekharkar125 3 года назад +4

    This performance shows how our bengali representative excell in tabla, jakir ji has to praise him during show.

  • @sourin.majumdar
    @sourin.majumdar 3 года назад +2

    Truly Mind-blowing,
    Rest in peace Pandit Subhankar Bannerjee

  • @however823
    @however823 4 года назад +7

    Saaarangi is also at its best.... Creating environment ❤️

  • @mkkrish9209
    @mkkrish9209 4 года назад +1

    what a humbleness by all respecting each other by enjoying each others performance. I have never seen Zakir Bhai enjoying so much. He enjoys others performance so much. Much Love. Finally Sabri Khan is doing a fabulous job without any lapse of concentration. Hats off.

  • @Sudip_Banerjee
    @Sudip_Banerjee 6 месяцев назад +1

    Would love to visualize more bigger picture
    An ultimate tabla worship...
    Ustad Tari Khan, Ustad Shahbaz Hussain, Ustad Zakir Hussain, Pt. Anindo Chatterjee, Pt. Kumar Bose, Pt. Swapan Chowdhury, Pt. Nayan Ghosh

  • @mahimasinha3007
    @mahimasinha3007 5 лет назад +9

    This one performance gave me so many such deep lessons. Just those simple notes and simple beats..... But ufffff!! Kitni baate flooding my mind.

  • @krishangautam3907
    @krishangautam3907 3 года назад +1

    Like a Tabla Class -- a class in itself. Thanks. Be happy. I have seen the great Ustaad Alla Rakha perform with the great Ravi Shanker. What a great treat it was! Be blessed.

  • @sanjaypurohit6237
    @sanjaypurohit6237 3 года назад

    उस्ताद जाकिर, पंडित योगेश सम्शी और उस्ताद अकरम खान के फिंगर टेक्निक बहुत बेस्ट है व्हाट आ स्पेशल इफ़ेक्ट यू कैन फील गॉड ब्लेस्स आल लेजेंड्स मएस्ट्रॉ😍😍😍🌹💐🙏🙏🙏

  • @malharchitnis7910
    @malharchitnis7910 3 года назад +12

    3:33 literally crying out

    • @clipkraze2.0
      @clipkraze2.0 3 года назад

      Sarangi is the Instrument which doesn't cry , but is Mourns...

  • @pervaizakhtar8649
    @pervaizakhtar8649 3 года назад +1

    A wonderful and befitting tabla rendition to the soul of grat Ustad Allah Rakha sb, Lost of variations and fine artistic work by the descendants and disciples of his school.

  • @syedowaisbukhari
    @syedowaisbukhari 5 лет назад +22

    Wow, i should've stopped after the first 20 minutes! I've never felt this incongruous with, undeserving of experiencing, an art-form before. Why are my hands & brain so stupid?

    • @soumendubhattacherya2122
      @soumendubhattacherya2122 4 года назад +3

      It's heartening to find someone so humble now-a-days. I don't know if you've ever practised tabla, but certainly, your brain is not stupid.

    • @rinadas1541
      @rinadas1541 4 года назад

      यहां के सारे कमेंट करने वाले।
      ऐसा है भाई साहब इन लोगों को किसी को इज्जत देना आता ही नहीं है वहीं लोगों की।परिवार से सिखाया ही नहीं गया है तो इसमें आप क्या कर सकते हो और हम क्या कर सकते हैं बताइए?

    • @rosybuddy28
      @rosybuddy28 4 года назад

      One feels that way when listening to maestros.

  • @Youtuberkeyboard
    @Youtuberkeyboard 3 года назад +3

    Respect everyone in present whoever you met in your life bcus you dosent know you or either someone is gonna pass and when..there is no exact time ...so pls dont be angry dont be jealous just respect and spread love ☺️🙏😭❤️

  • @aka3396
    @aka3396 4 года назад +1

    Very fortunate to have all legends together and listening them in adorable voice ......God keep them happy ever.........

  • @maitreyakulkarni5202
    @maitreyakulkarni5202 3 года назад +2

    Pt. Satyajit Talwalkar, Pt Yogesh Samsi and Pt. Shubhankar Banerjee stole the showw!!!! (ofc the rest are legends tooo!)

  • @smitpawar1341
    @smitpawar1341 4 года назад +1

    Nice to see you satyajeet talwalkar dada 1st saw you in vid with kaushiki "saawan zhar lagela dheere dheere"

  • @akshayabhuyan8892
    @akshayabhuyan8892 5 лет назад +2

    Kya baat he pura musical dunia dikha diye,waah waah😍😍😍,salute to you all

  • @iu233
    @iu233 3 года назад

    I can't even breath, woow.
    Mashallah, Allah gave them hands made out of clay but more precious than gold and fire.

  • @mrityunjoyananjanabhattach7921
    @mrityunjoyananjanabhattach7921 4 года назад

    When white horses run..........
    The middle man is unrecognisable. He runs similarly with his fellows.
    Alla Rakha, the GGGGGGGod of tabla
    সবাইকে শাষ্টাঙ্গ প্রণাম

  • @prasadinfoTV
    @prasadinfoTV 5 лет назад +10

    They are talking with there laungage ...music ..☺️🙏🙏

  • @soumendubhattacherya2122
    @soumendubhattacherya2122 4 года назад +10

    Subhankar banerjee at 30:20 to 30:26!!!!! OH! It's numbing.

    • @yashmehta5873
      @yashmehta5873 3 года назад

      Exactly ! Look how, in the flurry of complex laykaam, what joy a simple but "mijaazi" tihaai brings !!

  • @seans9149
    @seans9149 4 года назад +3

    This is priceless. Thank you for uploading it! Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow, wow🙏🏻❤️ they all have so much love and respects for each other!

  • @prof.shripadupasani1050
    @prof.shripadupasani1050 5 лет назад +40

    Satyajit playing tabla solo since long back, much experienced and senior tabla solo player should prefixed with Pandit rather than Shri.

    • @sayantandas1300
      @sayantandas1300 5 лет назад +3

      I was about to write the same thing brother. But then i noticed your comment. Same pinch here

    • @aaronrosenbloom2722
      @aaronrosenbloom2722 5 лет назад +4

      @@sayantandas1300 Agree 100% Satyajit Talwalkar is a Pandit of Tabla and the entry should be amended to add this title.

    • @SayemTabla
      @SayemTabla 3 года назад +2

      That's because his father is a Pandit who is still alive. I guess he will be Pandit after his father...

  • @bikashmondal261
    @bikashmondal261 5 лет назад +6

    dislike karne wale v kahan se aa jate hai. kuch to samjho hamari desh ki dharohar ko. sirf Funny Singh ko sunne se kahan yeh sab samjh aayega

    • @rinadas1541
      @rinadas1541 4 года назад +1

      ऐसा है भाई साहब इन लोगों को किसी को इज्जत देना आता ही नहीं है वहीं लोगों की।परिवार से सिखाया ही नहीं गया है तो इसमें आप क्या कर सकते हो और हम क्या कर सकते हैं बताइए?

  • @prathameshbhalerao4718
    @prathameshbhalerao4718 5 лет назад +10

    Legends at Work !!!!

  • @grandmasterbeats9732
    @grandmasterbeats9732 Год назад

    MAY GOD BLESS ALL OF THESE LEGANDS. I LOVE YOU ALL MY BROTHERS.

  • @sakshamsingh2305
    @sakshamsingh2305 3 года назад

    Not comparing anyone but Pt. Subhankar Banerjee was exceptional.His tabla sounded so sweet and calm at the same time.

  • @santoshsabharwal9029
    @santoshsabharwal9029 4 года назад +1

    Wah ustad wah amelodious recital of tabla . Congratulations 🥳

  • @alpanabanerjee4810
    @alpanabanerjee4810 3 года назад

    Amaiging . Pranam to the Legend!🙏🙏🙏

  • @partha.p.b
    @partha.p.b 4 года назад +2

    My India !!! I love you !!!

  • @arunroy2983
    @arunroy2983 4 года назад +1

    Sarengi player...ohhhh.. jobordost. Enara prochar pan naa.

  • @ravindrajavalagi
    @ravindrajavalagi 4 года назад +2

    Sabi pandit logos Salam 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌👌👌👌👌❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @kamaldey3893
    @kamaldey3893 3 года назад

    Great tribute to Badhe saheb on his birth centenary by creating the beautiful sound of tabla by all the maestro.

  • @Gameon.official
    @Gameon.official 2 года назад

    What an excellent masterpiece all ustad gave their best and best . The whole masterpiece helped to learn more and more for me . Heartly very thankful to all tabla players . 🙏🏻🙏🏻🌷🌷🙂

  • @AbdulMajid-zl7df
    @AbdulMajid-zl7df 4 года назад

    Bhot shandar ustad zakir hussain khan shab and all ustad ji bhot shandar video

  • @vijayaskuckian5297
    @vijayaskuckian5297 3 года назад

    Very very very nice to listen rains of Thabla(chirapunji) and to see six Thabla artists and saarang

  • @MusiGig
    @MusiGig 3 года назад

    My God... this is goose bump stuff... kya baat hai!!!!

  • @kishankarnataki9566
    @kishankarnataki9566 4 года назад

    Legends of a class we ordinary people can't reach. One needs tremendous focus, tapsya and dedication to reach there. You all brought a great happiness in our lives Sirs. You all are Dhruvas 🙏🏼

  • @gauravrajan2703
    @gauravrajan2703 4 года назад

    Kismmat hai hamari jo ham in sabko ek hi frame mein dekh paa rahe hain...RUclips pe hi sahi

  • @sauravpandit11
    @sauravpandit11 4 года назад +1

    It's a taal yagya. No words🙏💐🙇

  • @ankanbanerjeeneetaspirant1730
    @ankanbanerjeeneetaspirant1730 3 года назад +2

    Rip Pandit subhankar ji. ❤️❤️😭

  • @ashaymategaonkar7775
    @ashaymategaonkar7775 3 года назад

    What a journey it was to see these legends.

  • @arunghosh6185
    @arunghosh6185 3 года назад

    Amazing👌 great performance by all the tabla maestros🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @thermalengineeringmanojshe1302
    @thermalengineeringmanojshe1302 5 лет назад +9

    The legends of tabla

  • @pjagan123
    @pjagan123 2 года назад

    Just marvellous. I am lucky to see this video at least🙏🙏

  • @ernestoramirezgarcia9464
    @ernestoramirezgarcia9464 5 лет назад +9

    It's absolutely amazing!

  • @anirudhadeshpande05
    @anirudhadeshpande05 3 года назад

    Aye haye haye haye haye hayeeeeee! 🙌

  • @devenvaija09
    @devenvaija09 2 месяца назад +1

    ❤critic rating 4.9 I stars namaste

  • @manimish7jan
    @manimish7jan 4 года назад +2

    Legends with huge respect for each other

  • @anilmontaz1775
    @anilmontaz1775 3 года назад

    We lost Shankar Benarjee ji. Great loss to Indian music. Rip 😞😞😞

  • @vedantjoshi1487
    @vedantjoshi1487 5 лет назад +180

    36:23 me in exam hall.

  • @PanditKeshri
    @PanditKeshri 4 года назад +1

    Pt. Shubhankar Banarjee playing amazing...

  • @rabisibghat5764
    @rabisibghat5764 2 месяца назад

    Maestro piece 😣

  • @nirmalsingh-lc7wo
    @nirmalsingh-lc7wo 4 года назад +1

    Awesome performance! Words fail to express.👌

  • @Sanghitabasu50
    @Sanghitabasu50 3 года назад

    Pt Subhankar Banerjee's tihai is always amazing

  • @helppoorpeople9748
    @helppoorpeople9748 3 года назад

    After shubhankar banerjee left us I saw this video again only to see them 🙏😭

  • @gedelasimhachalam1483
    @gedelasimhachalam1483 4 года назад

    Please close our eyes.. when jaker was playing that time open our eyes... this is the test... observations and different.

  • @arunkushwahtabla8413
    @arunkushwahtabla8413 3 года назад +1

    R.I.P. Pt. Shubhankar Banerjee 🙏🏻💐😪

  • @yssdd773
    @yssdd773 4 года назад +2

    Normal people after people die: sob, cry, drink, smoke,make themself forget pain.
    Ustad jis': sob,cry (but then..) tune, gather, play, and feel the blessings.

  • @holyguacamole1
    @holyguacamole1 4 года назад +1

    Astounding mastery. Beautiful.

  • @ketumandave8690
    @ketumandave8690 Год назад

    Shubhankarji ko dekhe , aankh bhar jati he 😢

  • @Dholak_with_surendra_
    @Dholak_with_surendra_ 2 года назад

    सभी गुरुजनों के चरणों में सादर प्रणाम ❤️🙏

  • @valiyavalappilvenugopal668
    @valiyavalappilvenugopal668 3 года назад

    that was awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    oh 11!!!!

  • @mastersinghify
    @mastersinghify 4 года назад +3

    satyajit talwalkar is insanely creative

  • @santanu20072007
    @santanu20072007 3 года назад

    Today one of them left ! RIP Pandit Subhankar Banerjee!