There is something about Demetrius that you discover just by looking a little closer at the other characters' dialogue as well: the neglect he has with Sebastian who is his stepchild. Sebastian talks a lot about the favoritism Maru receives and it doesn't seem to be something simple, this is something that Demetrius could improve over time. Also, the game confirms that Sebastian was already born when Robin and Demetrius married and he grew up with Maru, Sebastian tells himself when you are married to him that he and Maru fought a lot when they were children and that he expects his children to be treated equally and not fight, so Demetrius basically has no excuse as he had many years to spend time getting to know Sebastian and raise him along with Maru, if Sebastian was already a teenager when he and Robin got married it would be more understandable since Demetrius could have a hard time with someone in that age group from what we've already seen, but as we know this is not the case, and Sebastian's dialogue suggests that Demetrius's favoritism for Maru goes back to when she and Sebastian were children and that this was probably the reason for the fights and the two remain distant until today. Robin doesn't seem to have anything to say about it either, and Sebastian living in the basement doesn't seem to help either, so I'll leave this to anyone who wants to talk about it because it would be strange for her not to notice what happened to her son for so many years and even having already entered his room and been worried about the smell of the cigarette holder, so she technically cares about him and pays attention to what happens but not about the treatment he has received? But Maru also doesn't seem to understand what's going on despite saying that she would like to have a better relationship with Sebastian, so it doesn't seem to be on purpose.
Ik this is an old comment, but I thought I might share anyway. I grew up with an emotionally abusive family member. My family has always known that we don’t exactly get along all the time, but they are completely blind to the trauma I lived through every single day just waking up in the same house as him. I’ve tried to explain it to them and they in turn try to explain his actions to me (in hopes we might understand each other better or something), but while understanding how he thinks has helped me heal to some extent it can’t fix everything. The fact of the matter is that our relationship will never heal because my abuser is completely unwilling to change. I’ve spent over six years in and out of therapy constantly trying to improve and understand myself and everyone around me better than before. I’ve made so much progress that I can finally confidently say I am stable now. My abuser doesn’t care to think about my feelings or try to understand me. My abuser will never see me as an equal human being and he has made it abundantly clear to me that mending our relationship is not worth his effort. I had to explain to my dad that me not wanting to work to mend or maintain a relationship with my abuser was not some petty act of bitterness, it’s literally for my own wellbeing. He had his chance. We talked about it. Yet he continues to hurt me. I can’t force him to change. I can’t make him WANT to change. I can’t make him care about me. I can’t control him. If he wants to stay the same then that’s his right and his problem. It’s not up to me to chase after him trying to attain something neither of us really want. I don’t have to keep in touch with him now that he’s moved out-not for me, not for my siblings, not for our parents, not anyone. He can live his life the way he wants and I’ll live mine. He’ll never understand but it’s not my job to make him understand my trauma. It’s not my job to teach him empathy or remorse. I’m done trying to rebuild what was never a solid structure in the first place. I’ll do what I have to do to protect myself from being hurt again, and if that means minimal contact, so be it. Does anyone in my family understand? No. They don’t. They probably never will. But it’s not my job to make them understand. It’s not my job to justify my trauma to them like I need their validation that I have a good enough reason to be traumatized. My experience is my own. So, in a way, I relate to Sebastian. He often mentions receiving unfair treatment but no one else seems to acknowledge it. Robin cares about him, but she still clearly doesn’t see an issue the way Sebastian does (probably because she’s not the one treating him differently). Maru mentions wanting to have a relationship with Sebastian, but it’s really difficult trying to ‘let someone in’ when in your head they are allies to your abuser. I don’t feel safe with any of my abuser’s friends even though most of them are people I’ve known my whole life. A lot of them I went to school with. One I graduated high school with. One I was friends with (until I got ghosted). I think I could be friends with a lot of them if I gave it a shot, but they’ve already crossed the invisible line. It’s not their fault and I don’t hate any of them, my brain is just instinctively terrified by association. Robin’s overall attitude seems rather dismissive of Sebastian’s feelings, probably thinking he’s just a moody teenager and Sebastian and Demetrius will make up once Sebastian gets a bit older or less ‘emo’ or whatever. It’s not that she isn’t trying. She may never really be able to understand even if it was explained to her because she just can’t see it-it’s not HER trauma. I wouldn’t necessarily say Robin has failed as a mother to Sebastian or Maru as a sister. It isn’t really their fault and even if there was something they could have done to stop or prevent it that moment has long passed. It’s Demetrius who failed as a parent. At least, that’s the way I see it based on my own experiences.
lol, what is this list? Demetrius, bronze medal of good: ignores his stepson Krobus, deep in the "evil" category: supposedly keeps relations with his own kind
Let's also not forget about Lewis apparently embezzling funds he could've used for the town. You arrive, the bridge to the quarry is in disrepair. The only access to the Flower Dance is over a small, rickety bridge - no wonder George is pissed -, the Community Center is in disrepair, the bus is broken down etc. And all the while, Lewis has a life sized gold statue of himself hidden away at home. Could've used that money for town repairs, but nope.
How the hell is Marlon the most evil. You say you are not picking up theories or conjectures, and then you accuse him of stealing, throwing away all the other things he's doing for the village, including loosing his loved ones, his eye and many friends to protecting others. Risking his life every day on patrol through the mines alone is worth a higher rank I agree that it's rather a service of getting your stuff back, then stealing from you. And even if not, he finds you, picks you up and carries you out of the mine safely.
The fact that Demi "I have only one child." trius is on 3rd place is weird. Did you even consider other townspeoples opinions of him. He is not the best taking in the role of a husband, father and stepfather. Robin asks him once to go buy some fruit. And he bought tomatoes because in his scientific mind they are not vegetables, but fruit. It is okay when he thinks that, but he is old enough to know that the average person puts tomatoes into the vegetable groub. Then in a cut scene Robin build a bed with long posts. She was very proud of it and even Seb came up to agknowledge his moms work. Then Demitrius came in and said the posts are inefficent. Wow... how nice of him. Maru cringed and Seb was annoyed... what a great family. Now to his treatment of Maru his bloodrelated pride. Demitrius gets passivly hostile towarts the farmer as soon as you have two hearts with Maru. Maru is actually again emberassed by her father. She is a grown woman and is not very pleased by her fathers behavior. And now to Seb ohhh boy... Seb has just one room. A basement... no windows. While Maru has two. Her sleep room and her science room. Then Seb can tell you many stories about Demitrius treating him like he doesn't belong to the family. Demitrus praises Maru for her smartness, but seb, who btw programms a game, plays keyboard, fixing a motorcycle and knows how to handle frogs (who are a very sensitvie pet to keep) is simply not in his mind at all. I dislike him for this. He acts as if everything is fine when in fact it isn't.
also: you get *less* friendship with him if you honestly tell maru and don’t lie to her face. wouldn’t he rather his lovely daughter have a honest and good w communication friend/partner?
What happens with Demetrius is called "being on the autistic spectrum", and this is no fault of him. In that scene, Robin is way worse, telling him "normal people" knows not to call tomatoes fruits. People isn't aware of how painful it is to hear "normal people" do things differently. We know, don't rub it in.
updated version pls and swap krobus and demetrius- krobus can get you like 2 stardrops and demetrius favorites maru and makes sebastian feel unwanted and unnoticed krobus only fought the dwarf because the dwarf attacked him
like the only bad thing you could find about krobus is that he is friends with hostile creatures like if he can be friends with them and still be peaceful that just makes him better lol
@@thevillageidiotyeahhe prob with Krobus isnt him being friends with hostile enemies, it’s that he technically doesn’t do anything to prevent both of his friend groups (the monsters and the farmer) from killing each other. Krobus doesn’t foster peace between both groups, he sits back to watch his friends kill his other friends No hate to Krobus btw
@@DeadlyVeggie23 nothing he can really do tho, and he doesn't really leave the sewers much and it can be unsafe for him to leave due to the dwarves and uncertainty Abt the villagers
This ranking is so wrong, it makes me feel like they did ten minutes of research and then mad the video. Like honestly I don't know any stardew player that would put DEMETRIUS as the bronze metal of good. He belongs in the lower half of the grey scale
AINT NO WAY Demetrius is in the good tier, he shouldn't be so high in how he treats Sebastian by barely acknowledging him and coming off as condescending to sebastian, like bro gave maru a nice room with windows and her own little private room, then used the other room for his lab and giving sebastian the basement, he constantly praises maru but is dismissive of sebastian who needs a father figure but doesnt seem to have one, bro bought the how to be a step dad book but clearly hasn't read it it seems, also mayor lewis has funds to build a solid gold statue of himself but not enough to fund the community centre or fix the bus, also knobs doesnt deserve to be that low for all we know the monsters are just defending their home
Uh... 2 bedroom house with a basement and garage... 2 children. Lab nook. Where is Demetrius and Robin gonna sleep. Maru is their biological daughter with seb being Robin's only. It would be weird that Maru and Seb sleeps in the same bedroom. Maru's bedroom is smaller. Sebastian's bedroom is bigger. He is friends with Abigail and Sam. Who is Maru friends with? Harvey is her boss. She and Penny chat at time but not really have any dialogue to one another.
Krobus needs to be higher so should Gunther, in his secret dialouge if for the first time you enter without anything to donate he tells you that the previous owner stole the collection.
I think you misunderstood what the recovery service is. He DOES have to go down to get it. The only reason you can see your items on the screen where you pick what you want him to recover is because it wouldn’t make sense if you could ask him to recover something you didn’t have… or if the game made you just remember what you had. It’s a UI convenience feature, not a character flaw.
Once you befriend Jodi she almost never shuts up about how much she hates her life and regrets having a family. Wouldn’t really put her that high, personally
Honestly not impressed with this list. You make a point about this being about character morality and then proceed to judge heavily on usefulness to the player. Example: Marnie. Yes, she is difficult to get hold of for shopping, but how is that about her morality? Another example: the Wizard. Yes, he is very helpful to you personally, but his past deeds clearly make him at best grey in morality. He is shown to regret, but there is no indication of the regret ever manifesting in actual deeds or even apologies to those he wronged. And there is no mystery of him wronging people only in who the wronged are. Another point is how you just plain fail to draw the right conclusions from the info that we are given. Businesses aren't evil for being businesses, but for how they practise their business. Joja is given to be evil in its dealings and while we don't get many details on exactly how we can safely assume them to be corrupt to the max. But, even while we take Joja's evilness for granted, no character becomes evil simply for working for Joja or buying their products. Morris however is clearly very much a part of the evil aspect of the corporation. Underhanded methods are accompanied with clear personal satisfaction in making life difficult for someone else. And judging Krobus on basis of being a Shadow person? That's just racist. Judging the Shadow people to be evil for defending their home against a murderous invader is not just racist, but psychotic. (Seriously, since we are shown Krobus to be at least as peaceful as humans, we are clearly the evil ones for slaughtering Shadow people) Over all this is just shallow and morality is ALWAYS a much deeper question. Actions matter, but the motives behind the actions matter more.
honestly the fact marnie is open at all is shocking considering no one else in the town owns farm animals, like dude just give her some days off, you don't even have to buy from her that often either
Uh... Where's Sandy? Does she not make enough of an impression? Better question, where's Mr. Qi? Since you included someone with as little character as the mermaid pendant guy, it's only fair that the most important character of the endgame gets mentioned. And Sandy, because we all love our daffodil sink.
Gil doesn't steal your stuff, those are the options for you to choose what he's going to go and recover for you. That's why it he doesn't just give it to you over the counter.
The reason why I am sure Abigail is actually the wizards daughter is cause there is dialogue that makes me a little suspicious about this is Abigail dialogue: “I don’t remember ever dying my hair purple.” And the only other person in Stardew valley with purple hair is the wizard and Pierre dialogue: “sometimes I wonder is if Abigail is my daughter.” And obviously the wizard’s dialogue
@@Rasecoon27LOL NO? Not tryna be mean but one of her questions are "What color should I dye my hair again?" SHE SAID AGAIN? FANFICS REALLY GOT ON YALL
she says a question to you and she says "What color should I dye my hair again?" LOOK AT THE WIKI. Saying OHHHH SHE IS COVERING IT UP!!!! is entirely an excuse.
I don't get why Lewis wants to keep his "affair" with Marnie a secret. The mayor of a town of 28 people can have a spouse. Lol To me, it just points to Lewis wanting someone else, but is with Marnie just for some quick action. It's just a weird situation that I wish was resolved.
What about Sandy. She dead? She died of dehydration or something? Oh wait I think she heard about Demetrius’s and Krobus’s ranking and ran, she now a part of the Islands.
Demetrius does NOT deserve to be that high up, like, did you pull a him and forget about seb? Krobus does NOT deserve to be that low, OF COURSE HE'S FRIENDS WITH OTHER SHADOW PEOPLE THAT DOESN'T MAKE HIM EVIL!!! shadow people are AFRAID of humans, that's why they're hostile!! he SAYS THIS to the player "You see, we've learned to fear humans... there have been too many... unpleasant encounters." HE IS AMAZING AND I WILL NOT STAND FOR KROBUS SLANDER FOR ANY REASON WHAT SO EVER
Lewis is the most evil. A corrupt politician, and simply treats Marnie like a side chick. I know Marnie made her choice but we all hope she realizes she deserves better.
Here is some sinner medals: Darwin; Gus. As nice as he is, he should stand up for himself more. Gluttony; Pam. Gus wouldn't be struggling if she didn't drink so much. At least she pays for the drinks if you explain Gus' situation. Wrath; Kent. Sorry, I'd give Pierre it for being too eager to TKO Morris but he is too busy scamming people with mah crops. The second closest is Kent for yelling at Jodi, but at least he's doing his best to overcome his problems. Lust; Clint. Yeaaaah... Pride; Demetrius. I'd even say he was among the darker side of neutral for playing favorites. You should be more attentive to your stepson too, bro. Sloth; Gil. Hard to blame his low energy given his age but I couldn't think of much else. Greed; Pierre. Even Morris didn't sell MY crops for that high a price. Still... Envy; Morris. Messing with a competitor seems to stem from a bit of envy.
I've seen one other person and myself point this out. Which is weird because Sandy is subjectively the most important vendor in the endgame due to Starfruits and Mr. Qi is objectively the most prominent character in the late endgame.
Sorry, but I quit watching when I saw that Demitrius is in the good tier and read in the comments that Krobus is in the evil tier... I developed a deep seeded hatred for Demitrius after I got close with Seb. He's a terrible stepdad who just decided to give up on his wife's son, shove him in the basement and make his own. There's a book in his and Robin's room which is a guide for first time step parents... which he never read obviously. Sebastian has obvious emotional and anxiety disorders and it's all because he never had a caring and loving father figure in his life
In a community where you're the only other person who potentially raises animals while at the same time she's got Shane and Jas to look after (not to mention the mayor toying with her).
@@kristenhanisch8508 Exactly! She has more responsibilities than anyone else in town and still manages to be unfailingly kind to everyone. I'd put her as absolute first, or maybe right below Gus.
My head canon is not that Lewis isn't good at his job, but that Pelican Town is hurting for funding when the farmer arrives in town. Your character starting a farm and shipping items rejuvenates the town, which in turn provides the funds needed to revive the Community Center, repair the Beach bridge, etc.
He really isn’t good at his job though. Instead of using the taxes to do something to help he uses it to make a gold statue of himself. He’s greedy too. The town is in total disrepair. Even in the town, the cobblestone walk has signs of erosion.
@@SunnySimmer80Plus there's litter everywhere! I mean, maybe he doesn't have a lot of money, but people could get together and try to fix things up. Sebastian and Maru know something about mechanics, Robin obviously knows construction. Instead of having an egg hunt, have a town cleanup, and so on.
Don't get why korbus is so low, because he's a shadow person and is friends with he's people??? THEY attack you, not him and only because you're in their home. Also if he's so low then Kent should be too, he was in a war and had friends who hurt people. Just because he is a shadow person doesn't make him evil.
Aside from putting Demetrius waaaaaay lower down (mid gray highest) due to his literal abandonment of Sebastian, I'd say you did great! (Granted, I'm a little biased given I have been in Sebastian's situation more times than I'd like to admit.)
I know it is little late but Jodi really offten tell you how she regrets having a children and thinks of leaving them ,,sometimes'' and that she ,,got married and had a kids really young and she regrets it''
I always say that the Wizard's daughter must be Emily, because she's the only one who shows... actual magic powers. "Oh she has purple hair like he does!" is not much of an argument, especially since we don't know how anime hair colors interact with one another and normal hair colors. Which colors are recessive? Which are dominant? Etc. Also Krobus is a sweet cinnamon bun, he's a little sassy, but I'd be pretty lippy too if a midget showed up and started picking a fight with me. Dwarves are almost always assholes, in any fantasy setting. Like as a societal expectation, even.
@@ple8379if this is relevant, in a random piece of dialogue Caroline says that Abigail’s hair wasn’t always purple, and when she was born, she had brown hair like pierre
@@Flower-ix7vq Huh, I actually forgot that... But maybe, we're pointing fingers at a wrong person here.. What if It's Caroline who's dying her hair and they are naturally brown? Abigail was born with natural color of her mother's hair, and it eventually turned magically purple because of the wizard genes?? I doubt so, it's rather a joke, but who knows at this point :0.
Absolutely risking to repeat an often voiced opinion.. why th is Demitrius so high up? Gray I could have seen, but he is such a neglectful stepparent and likes to be very "correct", seemingly to feel superiot to others...
Lmfao you shocked me when Evelyn wasn’t the first on the Good List, but I thought maybe Ive just become a bit biased about her. You COMPLETELY LOST me with Demetrius. Worst Stardew take I’ve ever heard tbh.
Do these Good to Evil or other ideas - Ratchet and Clank - Good to most Good Playstation 1 Heroes - Evil to most Evil Playstation 1 Villains - Which Playstation Hero Would Win Squid Game? - Which Playstation Villain Would Win Squid Game? - Which Crash Bandicoot Character Would Win Squid Game? - Which Ratchet and Clank Character Would Win Squid Game? - Weak to Powerful Cuphead Weapons and Items - Easy to Hardest Dark Souls Boss Fights
I watched that show it was OK for the first few episodes but it clearly wanted to be a action anime I for one feel it would have been better as a slice of life anime.
clint isnt creepy hes just fat. reread his heart events. if he were skinny would you be treating him like this. "im a nice guy" isnt Nice Guy but instead "i am so depressed and cut off that i am harsh to those outside of me, but i truly am nice underneath." and his hiding in the bushes is because he was going to confess then got cold feet and ran to hide. hes the love of my life
One video I think would be really GOOD if 1UpBinge does it would be which Video Game Characters would make the best heist crew, I know they did one for Pokémon Villains, but that is kind of small scale, like it only deals with one franchise and only the villains of that franchise. Maybe they could do characters like from the Sly Cooper Series, Persona 5 characters, Lara Croft, Nathan Drake, Wario, Bowser or other characters. That would be an awesome which Video Game Characters would make the ULTIMATE heist Crew. The possibilities of a good heist crew from Video Games could be possibly infinite, all it would take is their own personal picks for the brains, muscle, hacker, distraction, master of disguise, and get away driver.
Willy and Evelyn over Demetrius. I like Demetrius, but he puts all his focus and energy as a parent into Maru and smothers her while he completely ignores Sebastian.
Demetrius is a terrible stepdad. Playing favorites will never win you any points with me. I've already lived that route. It sucks. I prefer Linus. He as very little in terms of items. Yet, he shares it with you once you get to know him. That, to me, is worth more than anything anyone else in the game does. He is kind and getting to know Linus is a treat. He lives alongside nature and leads a simple life. I'm proud to have the highest level of friendship with him. I usually ignore all other NPCs unless absolutely needed.
You know what? We have no idea how old the witch and Wizard M. Rasmodius are or when they got divorced, right? What if he’s Caroline’s father? Hmmmmmm 🧐
Idk why Demetrius is so high considering hes a terrible parent and doesnt even acknowledge sebastian's existence
Same
And also he sometimes yells at Robin
That and he made Sebastian knock over his snow goon and praised Maru’s. And he’s creepy af from her first heart event!
i was going to say that
"Lol he ain't my kid."
-Demetrius probably
"Bronze medal goes to Demetrius"
BYE
There is something about Demetrius that you discover just by looking a little closer at the other characters' dialogue as well: the neglect he has with Sebastian who is his stepchild. Sebastian talks a lot about the favoritism Maru receives and it doesn't seem to be something simple, this is something that Demetrius could improve over time. Also, the game confirms that Sebastian was already born when Robin and Demetrius married and he grew up with Maru, Sebastian tells himself when you are married to him that he and Maru fought a lot when they were children and that he expects his children to be treated equally and not fight, so Demetrius basically has no excuse as he had many years to spend time getting to know Sebastian and raise him along with Maru, if Sebastian was already a teenager when he and Robin got married it would be more understandable since Demetrius could have a hard time with someone in that age group from what we've already seen, but as we know this is not the case, and Sebastian's dialogue suggests that Demetrius's favoritism for Maru goes back to when she and Sebastian were children and that this was probably the reason for the fights and the two remain distant until today. Robin doesn't seem to have anything to say about it either, and Sebastian living in the basement doesn't seem to help either, so I'll leave this to anyone who wants to talk about it because it would be strange for her not to notice what happened to her son for so many years and even having already entered his room and been worried about the smell of the cigarette holder, so she technically cares about him and pays attention to what happens but not about the treatment he has received? But Maru also doesn't seem to understand what's going on despite saying that she would like to have a better relationship with Sebastian, so it doesn't seem to be on purpose.
Ik this is an old comment, but I thought I might share anyway. I grew up with an emotionally abusive family member. My family has always known that we don’t exactly get along all the time, but they are completely blind to the trauma I lived through every single day just waking up in the same house as him. I’ve tried to explain it to them and they in turn try to explain his actions to me (in hopes we might understand each other better or something), but while understanding how he thinks has helped me heal to some extent it can’t fix everything. The fact of the matter is that our relationship will never heal because my abuser is completely unwilling to change. I’ve spent over six years in and out of therapy constantly trying to improve and understand myself and everyone around me better than before. I’ve made so much progress that I can finally confidently say I am stable now. My abuser doesn’t care to think about my feelings or try to understand me. My abuser will never see me as an equal human being and he has made it abundantly clear to me that mending our relationship is not worth his effort. I had to explain to my dad that me not wanting to work to mend or maintain a relationship with my abuser was not some petty act of bitterness, it’s literally for my own wellbeing. He had his chance. We talked about it. Yet he continues to hurt me. I can’t force him to change. I can’t make him WANT to change. I can’t make him care about me. I can’t control him. If he wants to stay the same then that’s his right and his problem. It’s not up to me to chase after him trying to attain something neither of us really want. I don’t have to keep in touch with him now that he’s moved out-not for me, not for my siblings, not for our parents, not anyone. He can live his life the way he wants and I’ll live mine. He’ll never understand but it’s not my job to make him understand my trauma. It’s not my job to teach him empathy or remorse. I’m done trying to rebuild what was never a solid structure in the first place. I’ll do what I have to do to protect myself from being hurt again, and if that means minimal contact, so be it.
Does anyone in my family understand? No. They don’t. They probably never will. But it’s not my job to make them understand. It’s not my job to justify my trauma to them like I need their validation that I have a good enough reason to be traumatized. My experience is my own.
So, in a way, I relate to Sebastian. He often mentions receiving unfair treatment but no one else seems to acknowledge it. Robin cares about him, but she still clearly doesn’t see an issue the way Sebastian does (probably because she’s not the one treating him differently). Maru mentions wanting to have a relationship with Sebastian, but it’s really difficult trying to ‘let someone in’ when in your head they are allies to your abuser. I don’t feel safe with any of my abuser’s friends even though most of them are people I’ve known my whole life. A lot of them I went to school with. One I graduated high school with. One I was friends with (until I got ghosted). I think I could be friends with a lot of them if I gave it a shot, but they’ve already crossed the invisible line. It’s not their fault and I don’t hate any of them, my brain is just instinctively terrified by association. Robin’s overall attitude seems rather dismissive of Sebastian’s feelings, probably thinking he’s just a moody teenager and Sebastian and Demetrius will make up once Sebastian gets a bit older or less ‘emo’ or whatever. It’s not that she isn’t trying. She may never really be able to understand even if it was explained to her because she just can’t see it-it’s not HER trauma. I wouldn’t necessarily say Robin has failed as a mother to Sebastian or Maru as a sister. It isn’t really their fault and even if there was something they could have done to stop or prevent it that moment has long passed. It’s Demetrius who failed as a parent.
At least, that’s the way I see it based on my own experiences.
@@charliegreen7988 I'm sorry, but I'm glad you got out of the situation.
Part of me marrying him was wanting to get him out of that household.
lol, what is this list?
Demetrius, bronze medal of good: ignores his stepson
Krobus, deep in the "evil" category: supposedly keeps relations with his own kind
Okay WHY the heck is Demetrius higher then Willy?! Willy is nicer the him
Yeah that's why Willy is higher! It means he is nicer he got higher in the good characters
Why the hell is Krobus evil?! I'm mad, that's not fair!
exactly lol krobus is KING
Dwarf conflict probably
Yeah, really! Kent was in a war and he wasn't counted as evil. And how can you just not love Krobus?
@@kristenhanisch8508 it’s never shared what side he was in a war
Let's also not forget about Lewis apparently embezzling funds he could've used for the town.
You arrive, the bridge to the quarry is in disrepair. The only access to the Flower Dance is over a small, rickety bridge - no wonder George is pissed -, the Community Center is in disrepair, the bus is broken down etc. And all the while, Lewis has a life sized gold statue of himself hidden away at home. Could've used that money for town repairs, but nope.
Also the bus (driven by the town drunk) is broken down... There are so many examples of Lewis' mayoral incompetence!
How the hell is Marlon the most evil. You say you are not picking up theories or conjectures, and then you accuse him of stealing, throwing away all the other things he's doing for the village, including loosing his loved ones, his eye and many friends to protecting others. Risking his life every day on patrol through the mines alone is worth a higher rank
I agree that it's rather a service of getting your stuff back, then stealing from you. And even if not, he finds you, picks you up and carries you out of the mine safely.
The fact that Demi "I have only one child." trius is on 3rd place is weird. Did you even consider other townspeoples opinions of him.
He is not the best taking in the role of a husband, father and stepfather.
Robin asks him once to go buy some fruit. And he bought tomatoes because in his scientific mind they are not vegetables, but fruit. It is okay when he thinks that, but he is old enough to know that the average person puts tomatoes into the vegetable groub.
Then in a cut scene Robin build a bed with long posts. She was very proud of it and even Seb came up to agknowledge his moms work. Then Demitrius came in and said the posts are inefficent. Wow... how nice of him. Maru cringed and Seb was annoyed... what a great family.
Now to his treatment of Maru his bloodrelated pride. Demitrius gets passivly hostile towarts the farmer as soon as you have two hearts with Maru. Maru is actually again emberassed by her father. She is a grown woman and is not very pleased by her fathers behavior.
And now to Seb ohhh boy...
Seb has just one room. A basement... no windows. While Maru has two. Her sleep room and her science room. Then Seb can tell you many stories about Demitrius treating him like he doesn't belong to the family. Demitrus praises Maru for her smartness, but seb, who btw programms a game, plays keyboard, fixing a motorcycle and knows how to handle frogs (who are a very sensitvie pet to keep) is simply not in his mind at all.
I dislike him for this. He acts as if everything is fine when in fact it isn't.
also: you get *less* friendship with him if you honestly tell maru and don’t lie to her face. wouldn’t he rather his lovely daughter have a honest and good w communication friend/partner?
my words exactly on why i dont like him
Demetrius thinks that my character likes his daughter, although my character (Oliver Reed) married Alex. Oliver Reed is bisexual, but prefers men.
What happens with Demetrius is called "being on the autistic spectrum", and this is no fault of him. In that scene, Robin is way worse, telling him "normal people" knows not to call tomatoes fruits. People isn't aware of how painful it is to hear "normal people" do things differently. We know, don't rub it in.
I agree with pretty pretty much everything outside of... that honestly I think Sebastian likes his basement room. It fits his character.
updated version pls and swap krobus and demetrius-
krobus can get you like 2 stardrops and demetrius favorites maru and makes sebastian feel unwanted and unnoticed
krobus only fought the dwarf because the dwarf attacked him
like the only bad thing you could find about krobus is that he is friends with hostile creatures
like
if he can be friends with them and still be peaceful that just makes him better lol
based
@@thevillageidiotyeahhe prob with Krobus isnt him being friends with hostile enemies, it’s that he technically doesn’t do anything to prevent both of his friend groups (the monsters and the farmer) from killing each other. Krobus doesn’t foster peace between both groups, he sits back to watch his friends kill his other friends
No hate to Krobus btw
@@DeadlyVeggie23 nothing he can really do tho, and he doesn't really leave the sewers much and it can be unsafe for him to leave due to the dwarves and uncertainty Abt the villagers
This ranking is so wrong, it makes me feel like they did ten minutes of research and then mad the video. Like honestly I don't know any stardew player that would put DEMETRIUS as the bronze metal of good. He belongs in the lower half of the grey scale
George is probably my favorite character and he gets a lot nicer once you get to know him. I have ten hearts with him, he is great.
AINT NO WAY Demetrius is in the good tier, he shouldn't be so high in how he treats Sebastian by barely acknowledging him and coming off as condescending to sebastian, like bro gave maru a nice room with windows and her own little private room, then used the other room for his lab and giving sebastian the basement, he constantly praises maru but is dismissive of sebastian who needs a father figure but doesnt seem to have one, bro bought the how to be a step dad book but clearly hasn't read it it seems, also mayor lewis has funds to build a solid gold statue of himself but not enough to fund the community centre or fix the bus, also knobs doesnt deserve to be that low for all we know the monsters are just defending their home
Uh... 2 bedroom house with a basement and garage... 2 children. Lab nook. Where is Demetrius and Robin gonna sleep. Maru is their biological daughter with seb being Robin's only. It would be weird that Maru and Seb sleeps in the same bedroom. Maru's bedroom is smaller. Sebastian's bedroom is bigger. He is friends with Abigail and Sam. Who is Maru friends with? Harvey is her boss. She and Penny chat at time but not really have any dialogue to one another.
I really like Willy. I see him as either my dad or my grandpa
How the hell is evelyn rated under the wizard🧍♀️
This comment made me think more than I'd like to admit. But I have reasons for both sides of the story.
Krobus needs to be higher so should Gunther, in his secret dialouge if for the first time you enter without anything to donate he tells you that the previous owner stole the collection.
I think you misunderstood what the recovery service is. He DOES have to go down to get it. The only reason you can see your items on the screen where you pick what you want him to recover is because it wouldn’t make sense if you could ask him to recover something you didn’t have… or if the game made you just remember what you had. It’s a UI convenience feature, not a character flaw.
Once you befriend Jodi she almost never shuts up about how much she hates her life and regrets having a family. Wouldn’t really put her that high, personally
plus she hates flowers
like wtf
Honestly not impressed with this list.
You make a point about this being about character morality and then proceed to judge heavily on usefulness to the player. Example: Marnie. Yes, she is difficult to get hold of for shopping, but how is that about her morality? Another example: the Wizard. Yes, he is very helpful to you personally, but his past deeds clearly make him at best grey in morality. He is shown to regret, but there is no indication of the regret ever manifesting in actual deeds or even apologies to those he wronged. And there is no mystery of him wronging people only in who the wronged are.
Another point is how you just plain fail to draw the right conclusions from the info that we are given. Businesses aren't evil for being businesses, but for how they practise their business. Joja is given to be evil in its dealings and while we don't get many details on exactly how we can safely assume them to be corrupt to the max. But, even while we take Joja's evilness for granted, no character becomes evil simply for working for Joja or buying their products. Morris however is clearly very much a part of the evil aspect of the corporation. Underhanded methods are accompanied with clear personal satisfaction in making life difficult for someone else.
And judging Krobus on basis of being a Shadow person? That's just racist. Judging the Shadow people to be evil for defending their home against a murderous invader is not just racist, but psychotic. (Seriously, since we are shown Krobus to be at least as peaceful as humans, we are clearly the evil ones for slaughtering Shadow people)
Over all this is just shallow and morality is ALWAYS a much deeper question. Actions matter, but the motives behind the actions matter more.
honestly the fact marnie is open at all is shocking considering no one else in the town owns farm animals, like dude just give her some days off, you don't even have to buy from her that often either
Well all the shadow people i have faces attacked me first so it was like a neutral self defense run in undertale
Uh... Where's Sandy? Does she not make enough of an impression? Better question, where's Mr. Qi? Since you included someone with as little character as the mermaid pendant guy, it's only fair that the most important character of the endgame gets mentioned. And Sandy, because we all love our daffodil sink.
My thoughts exactly at least include all the heart event characters
Residents of pelican town*
I’m guessing they didn’t do very much research for this video…
Gil doesn't steal your stuff, those are the options for you to choose what he's going to go and recover for you. That's why it he doesn't just give it to you over the counter.
Marlon you mean and IK im really mad about that. He is so underrated
The reason why I am sure Abigail is actually the wizards daughter is cause there is dialogue that makes me a little suspicious about this is Abigail dialogue: “I don’t remember ever dying my hair purple.” And the only other person in Stardew valley with purple hair is the wizard and Pierre dialogue: “sometimes I wonder is if Abigail is my daughter.” And obviously the wizard’s dialogue
@@Rasecoon27LOL NO? Not tryna be mean but one of her questions are "What color should I dye my hair again?" SHE SAID AGAIN? FANFICS REALLY GOT ON YALL
she says a question to you and she says "What color should I dye my hair again?" LOOK AT THE WIKI. Saying OHHHH SHE IS COVERING IT UP!!!! is entirely an excuse.
@@TurtleManias sorry I don’t use the wiki much :(
@@Weird_Axolotl ah okay sorry if you thought if I was rude using caps
@@TurtleManias no it’s alr!
Wth??? This had so much potential! Gus definitely deserves the top spot but wtf???
Demetrius should not be this high up on the list.
don't fault my main man willy for selling tickets to ginger island, we don't know the fuel prices or boat licence fees in pelican town!!
Plus, by the time you can afford to fix up the boat 1000 gold isn't really that steep a price. You can easily get that much selling some iridium fish.
Marlon also only returns one of your items that you lost. You can't get the others back.
I don't get why Lewis wants to keep his "affair" with Marnie a secret. The mayor of a town of 28 people can have a spouse. Lol
To me, it just points to Lewis wanting someone else, but is with Marnie just for some quick action. It's just a weird situation that I wish was resolved.
What about Sandy. She dead? She died of dehydration or something? Oh wait I think she heard about Demetrius’s and Krobus’s ranking and ran, she now a part of the Islands.
Okay, can I add that if you marry Emily, Creepy-ass Clint STILL asks you if you think he could get with her?
How is the wizard so high up? He's pure neutral!
Demetrius does NOT deserve to be that high up, like, did you pull a him and forget about seb?
Krobus does NOT deserve to be that low, OF COURSE HE'S FRIENDS WITH OTHER SHADOW PEOPLE THAT DOESN'T MAKE HIM EVIL!!! shadow people are AFRAID of humans, that's why they're hostile!! he SAYS THIS to the player "You see, we've learned to fear humans... there have been too many... unpleasant encounters." HE IS AMAZING AND I WILL NOT STAND FOR KROBUS SLANDER FOR ANY REASON WHAT SO EVER
He cant be mad if i do self defense
Lewis is the most evil. A corrupt politician, and simply treats Marnie like a side chick. I know Marnie made her choice but we all hope she realizes she deserves better.
She should drop him for Marlon! He openly compliments her at the flower dance!
I'm glad we all think Demetrius should be bottom tier.
Kent being a war veteran makes him gold for the good guys 🫡
Here is some sinner medals:
Darwin; Gus. As nice as he is, he should stand up for himself more.
Gluttony; Pam. Gus wouldn't be struggling if she didn't drink so much. At least she pays for the drinks if you explain Gus' situation.
Wrath; Kent. Sorry, I'd give Pierre it for being too eager to TKO Morris but he is too busy scamming people with mah crops. The second closest is Kent for yelling at Jodi, but at least he's doing his best to overcome his problems.
Lust; Clint. Yeaaaah...
Pride; Demetrius. I'd even say he was among the darker side of neutral for playing favorites. You should be more attentive to your stepson too, bro.
Sloth; Gil. Hard to blame his low energy given his age but I couldn't think of much else.
Greed; Pierre. Even Morris didn't sell MY crops for that high a price. Still...
Envy; Morris. Messing with a competitor seems to stem from a bit of envy.
You missed Mr Qi and Sandy
I've seen one other person and myself point this out. Which is weird because Sandy is subjectively the most important vendor in the endgame due to Starfruits and Mr. Qi is objectively the most prominent character in the late endgame.
The way that we all went "what." When Demetrius appeared in 3rd place
Sorry, but I quit watching when I saw that Demitrius is in the good tier and read in the comments that Krobus is in the evil tier...
I developed a deep seeded hatred for Demitrius after I got close with Seb. He's a terrible stepdad who just decided to give up on his wife's son, shove him in the basement and make his own. There's a book in his and Robin's room which is a guide for first time step parents... which he never read obviously.
Sebastian has obvious emotional and anxiety disorders and it's all because he never had a caring and loving father figure in his life
Krobus deserves better
Marnie not in good tier, just because she doesn't work 24/7... wow.
In a community where you're the only other person who potentially raises animals while at the same time she's got Shane and Jas to look after (not to mention the mayor toying with her).
@@kristenhanisch8508 Exactly! She has more responsibilities than anyone else in town and still manages to be unfailingly kind to everyone. I'd put her as absolute first, or maybe right below Gus.
Justice for Krobus.
My head canon is not that Lewis isn't good at his job, but that Pelican Town is hurting for funding when the farmer arrives in town. Your character starting a farm and shipping items rejuvenates the town, which in turn provides the funds needed to revive the Community Center, repair the Beach bridge, etc.
He really isn’t good at his job though. Instead of using the taxes to do something to help he uses it to make a gold statue of himself. He’s greedy too. The town is in total disrepair. Even in the town, the cobblestone walk has signs of erosion.
@@SunnySimmer80Plus there's litter everywhere! I mean, maybe he doesn't have a lot of money, but people could get together and try to fix things up. Sebastian and Maru know something about mechanics, Robin obviously knows construction. Instead of having an egg hunt, have a town cleanup, and so on.
Demetrius i feel should be lower
Okey I have to disagree you on Demetrius he treats his step son like crap
Stardew Valley: Dumb to Brilliant
Don't get why korbus is so low, because he's a shadow person and is friends with he's people??? THEY attack you, not him and only because you're in their home. Also if he's so low then Kent should be too, he was in a war and had friends who hurt people. Just because he is a shadow person doesn't make him evil.
Pierre is the real evil
(Whats that secret stash?)
Joja provides sam and shane with jobs
I RAN to the comments as soon as i saw Demetrius in 3rd place.
I don't exactly like Demetrius. You should pay more attention to my dark Husbando, bruh! Don't care if you're his stepdad.
Vincent is Better than Jas
1. He doe'snt have a father (Until year 2)
2. He's Friendly
3. He's Nice
3. He's amazing
4. JAS SAYS YOU SMELL LIKE GRASS
what did krobus do? just because he's friends with the other monsters doesn't mean he deserves 4th place for being bad!
Not you ranking Demetrius higer than Willy
Aside from putting Demetrius waaaaaay lower down (mid gray highest) due to his literal abandonment of Sebastian, I'd say you did great! (Granted, I'm a little biased given I have been in Sebastian's situation more times than I'd like to admit.)
I know it is little late but Jodi really offten tell you how she regrets having a children and thinks of leaving them ,,sometimes'' and that she ,,got married and had a kids really young and she regrets it''
4:17 excuse me what he neglect to stepson is an overbearing dad to his daughter
Man Mayor Tax Fraud should have been last. Not the chad Marlon
Love the video. I know late to the party. But Pierre and Morris are both pretty much the same person it seems like.
Putting dimetrius in good and krobus in bad kinda invadilate this whole video bruh
Evelyn also gives you gifts
Omori characters: good to evil
evelyn is an angel
I always say that the Wizard's daughter must be Emily, because she's the only one who shows... actual magic powers. "Oh she has purple hair like he does!" is not much of an argument, especially since we don't know how anime hair colors interact with one another and normal hair colors. Which colors are recessive? Which are dominant? Etc.
Also Krobus is a sweet cinnamon bun, he's a little sassy, but I'd be pretty lippy too if a midget showed up and started picking a fight with me. Dwarves are almost always assholes, in any fantasy setting. Like as a societal expectation, even.
If I'm guessing this guy says Abigail is the wizards daughter? When Abigail explicitly tells us she dyes her hair.
@@ralcogaming7674 Abigail said she "doesn't remember ever dying her hair purple" .
@@ple8379if this is relevant, in a random piece of dialogue Caroline says that Abigail’s hair wasn’t always purple, and when she was born, she had brown hair like pierre
@@Flower-ix7vq Huh, I actually forgot that... But maybe, we're pointing fingers at a wrong person here.. What if It's Caroline who's dying her hair and they are naturally brown? Abigail was born with natural color of her mother's hair, and it eventually turned magically purple because of the wizard genes?? I doubt so, it's rather a joke, but who knows at this point :0.
Cars: On the Road Characters: Good to Evil.
Well, this list is controversial to say the absolute least.
Where is Sandy?
i like Willy, Gus and Krobus the best!
They missed Sandy! She's an npc too!
and they missed Emily.. oh my
Emily's a bachelorette
Sandy lives in a desert 🏜️
swap krobus and demetrius and then i'll be happier.
7:57 The harvest moon 64 clip! Very nice.
Willy is way more good than Demetrius
Love learning about new games from this channel
Absolutely risking to repeat an often voiced opinion.. why th is Demitrius so high up? Gray I could have seen, but he is such a neglectful stepparent and likes to be very "correct", seemingly to feel superiot to others...
Do Metal Gear Solid Characters: Good to Evil!
Terraria Npc & Bosses: Good to evil
Lmfao you shocked me when Evelyn wasn’t the first on the Good List, but I thought maybe Ive just become a bit biased about her. You COMPLETELY LOST me with Demetrius.
Worst Stardew take I’ve ever heard tbh.
Tmnt cowabunga collection games: worst to best
honestly I doubt the prolific theory about Abigail being Rasmodius's daughter, people really overlook the holes in this theory
Do these Good to Evil or other ideas
- Ratchet and Clank
- Good to most Good Playstation 1 Heroes
- Evil to most Evil Playstation 1 Villains
- Which Playstation Hero Would Win Squid Game?
- Which Playstation Villain Would Win Squid Game?
- Which Crash Bandicoot Character Would Win Squid Game?
- Which Ratchet and Clank Character Would Win Squid Game?
- Weak to Powerful Cuphead Weapons and Items
- Easy to Hardest Dark Souls Boss Fights
COD Zombies
how dare thy insult joja and marlin
GTA 1@2 characters good to evil
BNA: Brand New Animal good to evil
I watched that show it was OK for the first few episodes but it clearly wanted to be a action anime I for one feel it would have been better as a slice of life anime.
One advice dont play this game its so good its addictive.
Indeed. And it's expensive too at $15!
The harvest moon clip made me giggle.
where's shane, where's haley, where's emily?
clint isnt creepy hes just fat. reread his heart events. if he were skinny would you be treating him like this. "im a nice guy" isnt Nice Guy but instead "i am so depressed and cut off that i am harsh to those outside of me, but i truly am nice underneath." and his hiding in the bushes is because he was going to confess then got cold feet and ran to hide. hes the love of my life
One video I think would be really GOOD if 1UpBinge does it would be which Video Game Characters would make the best heist crew, I know they did one for Pokémon Villains, but that is kind of small scale, like it only deals with one franchise and only the villains of that franchise.
Maybe they could do characters like from the Sly Cooper Series, Persona 5 characters, Lara Croft, Nathan Drake, Wario, Bowser or other characters. That would be an awesome which Video Game Characters would make the ULTIMATE heist Crew. The possibilities of a good heist crew from Video Games could be possibly infinite, all it would take is their own personal picks for the brains, muscle, hacker, distraction, master of disguise, and get away driver.
Did y’all forget penny?
Willy and Evelyn over Demetrius. I like Demetrius, but he puts all his focus and energy as a parent into Maru and smothers her while he completely ignores Sebastian.
Demetrius is a terrible stepdad. Playing favorites will never win you any points with me. I've already lived that route. It sucks.
I prefer Linus. He as very little in terms of items. Yet, he shares it with you once you get to know him. That, to me, is worth more than anything anyone else in the game does. He is kind and getting to know Linus is a treat. He lives alongside nature and leads a simple life. I'm proud to have the highest level of friendship with him. I usually ignore all other NPCs unless absolutely needed.
Super Mario Odyssey : Good to Evil
Good : Pauline
Neutral : Mario and Cappy
Evil : Bowser
Gta hd universe good to evil
21:36 Morris blasts off again
Harvey is also pretty good!
You know what? We have no idea how old the witch and Wizard M. Rasmodius are or when they got divorced, right? What if he’s Caroline’s father? Hmmmmmm 🧐
Little Nightmares: good to evil
Most Good: Mono
Good: Runaway kid
Neutral: Six
Evil: Thin Man
Most Evil: The Lady
Telltale Twd characters good to evil
Angel 😇: Lee
Good 😇: Javier
Grey area 👿😇: Jane
Bad 😈: Larry
Evil 😈: Avro
Devil 😈: Lily
You forgot Badger await he might be so evil that he doesn't belong on the list like they did with bendy for Foster's home
pls do an "Brand New Animal Good to Evil" and an "Naruto Good to Evil".
Are there any horror games to make a good to evil video?
18:14 daam... some people are VERY sensible.
Video suggestion: Batman: Arkham Characters: Good to Evil.