This is not just a case of a man running or swimming faster than a woman. It’s a fact of a man hitting a woman. It’s intolerable that the rights of one person from a tiny, tiny minority usurps the rights of millions of women everywhere.
Exactly. And the fact that the desires of a tiny minority of *men* trump the rights of all women says it all. This is Patriarchy in action, ironically.
and it's actually false that males have a 'right' to everything female, simply because they say so. No human or civil right grants that. Unfortunately, the transactivist lobby is succeeding in changing law in one country after the other to fit their agenda - and destroy women's (actually existing) rights.
I think this person with dsd is born into a muslim country. The muslim belive if a person has a vagina and can have intercorse with a male, it is a female. Khelif grew up, and people classified Khelif as female and,still in muslim worldview classifie Khelif as female. We should look at the bigger picture. Those differences in worldview.
@@DavidMotherlandit can’t be call harassment if it’s the truth. People know themselves better than you think. I saw earlier pictures of Imane dressed like a male, in a men’s suit on several different occasions. He knew he was male for more than a year before the Olympics; Imani was tested two years earlier. He took advantage of weak rules and regulations and entered the Olympic as a woman knowing he was a male. He’s a cheater.
@@bikerjk1205It’s correct though. There’s a reason he went after them for harassment and not “lying” about him. He would have needed to prove them wrong in court which he clearly cannot do because he’s male.
@@DavidMotherland😂the absolute gall of him. Acting like a victim so he can beat up women. I read an article yesterday claiming reduxx who broke this story were " bullying" him! The new world narrative that men who say they are women have more rights than real women and are the victims. 😡😡😡
Won't happen. The IOC knew about it and they stand by the new idea that female is who's saying it. They happily give all the medals to men. As long as they claim to be women. They call it "inclusion" and "compassion".
USA women's BB team needs to return theirs as well. Griner is openly bio male born with a male DSD, XXY. WNBA has several bio males. Clarendon who just retired in Sept after 12 years in the league openly started transitioning while in the WNBA and the league wore gear etc for trans females 😂 Bio males with male DSDs, ovotestes perhaps being the only exception, and bio males who are identifiers or have a trans prefix, belong in male spaces representing males facing those challenges.
@@IWM-123 Can you link the sources that show Brittany Griner is openly a bio male? I looked myself and I couldn’t find any credible source that said this. I only found an article where she doubles down on being a female. My suspicion is that she has DSD like Caster Semenya.
@@mwfmtnmanI mean, it's correct...we view Russia as some massive propaganda state, but...ours is too. There's not really that much of a difference. Yeah, they have a single authority figure, we have more of an authority shadow org (the permanent unelectable parts of the government), but it works the same way. The idea that Russia is somehow "way worse" than us when it comes to information control is completely false.
Thank you for your kind words and (actually) common sense)). I do prefer to tell the truth. Even when it is forbidden by our temporary laws))). I actually always thought that being russian obliges me to tell even more truth)). Because of the soviet past and its lessons, for example.
It's a scheme and anti Russian too. Russia used and independent lab but the results are questionable just because Russia asked for the test. Funny how after sex testing was eliminated we see a surge in males winning in women's sports. It's ridiculous.
I don't know what shocks me more - the widespread apparent hatred of women, or the number of women who are contributing to their own harm through being "kind".
Apparent hatred? Wow, shame on you. Your ancestors will be ashamed as they fought for your rights that you gladly surrender to sympathise a man claiming to be a woman.
Exactly. Generally women need to get angry and act against the enemy instead of feeling sorry for themselves and accepting what the translobby is doing
@@ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Yes! I was very disappointed in Holly somehow accepting this man as a woman bc he thought his whole life he was one. It's the problem with people who see sex wholely through a socialisation lense. Which plays a part, but there is also biological reality which doesn't care about "socialisation". I really don't get how seemingly intelligent people can have such a blind spot.
The actual winner, Melissa Bishop, did not even medal, and her career ended shortly thereafter. I was sick to watch it in 2016 and it still makes my blood the go cold.
I remember watching this interview and didn’t understand what the problem was. I knew Caster Semenya wasn’t a woman, but I didn’t see the medal ceremony, so didn’t see the other two were men. These men know they’re men, probably before puberty, but definitely after.
@@FabrizioPati-i6fyes, and that's also part of this, compassion for the individuals who find their biological reality is not their social reality. I had genetic testing in my 30s, nothing to do with this thankfully! But it did give me some unexpected results that I had to accept. It's hard, genetic councillors help, but in the end I had to do the personal work to understand myself. That's the journey for these people, and for that I feel empathy. I also want biological males out of women's sports, spaces and platforms. It's not a contradiction to recognise that they're human too.
The literally redefined facts, redefined science, redefined logic. So, no matter what you say, the answer is "follow the science they make up with no tethers to reality." You can't win. Folks who properly identify all women to discriminate against and mimic, pretend they have no idea what a woman is when women are getting the short end of the stick.
Agreed. However, this has been the case for men and males since the 1970s: male-only spaces, groups, clubs, etc., were under fire by feminists who demanded female access. In current times the anti-binary campaign has gone enormous distances farther and become far worse. But the error and folly began long before.
@EssensOrAccidens The feminists wanted their own spaces and equal rights. Nowadays, the men are taking over the women's spaces, opportunities, etc. The men are even claiming womanhood as their own.
@gfys756 the science does not support delusions. You clearly do not understand that science does not equal fantasy and men are not, cannot, and never will be women. Seek out a dictionary and real help.
And now news comes out that trans player,, Blair on San Jose team colluded with an opposing team member to hurt the team captain, who joined the lawsuit. It caused their first loss because Blair failed to defend the space next to the targeted teammate. Huge scandal.
I hate it when people say "we shouldn't presume males have an advantage." Like we don't have literally hundreds of sports records to go by! That all goes out the window when it comes to gender identity.
@@HekateSelini Exactly. And what really boiled me was when Veronica Ivy, a transgendered bicyclist tried to say "We don't know. So we should lean to acceptance." No, we should lean to safety! That's always how it's been.
@@TheRisky9 OMG, that one gets me, too! first named Rachel McKinnon, now VY - but still doing everything to justify TIMs beating women in women's sports. And since VY is an academic, VY knows very well that sex can't be changed - of course we know. Still, VY said on TV: "I am biologically female: I'm a biological being and my passport says female." These people feel so safe in today's woke climate, they state outrageous lies & logical fallacies - and can be sure nobody calls them out. Women's cycling in North America is dominated by men - I find it disgusting.
I hope all these people declaring previously “trans women in women’s sports won’t take away from biological women” have a really good think about fairness in sport and the consequences of these actions. Biological women lost out on medals, sponsorships, etc.
No XY in female sports. I don't care what condition it is, even if their may not be an advantage with certain DSDs. Just no. Xy should only be abled to compete with males for the fairness of women. No exceptions.
At this point all they may do in the future is remove or fudge the record. Saying the medal was given to a male (for whatever reason/accident they wanna put). This is now history and we don’t like to admit ‘mistakes’ in history. WE NEED TO REMEMBER IT AND RELAY IT to future generations.
Omg! She said herself that women lost 890 medals to men and then goes on to say that it's just a minor issue?? How many medals do we have to lose to men before it becomes an issue? 10.000??
These men are vile, from the ioc, to the coaches, to the governments, to the athletes. And sorry...to ALL the athletes that carried on competing while women were being punched out by men. They are ALL vile.
This MAN needs to be jailed for fraud plus return medal and any monies that this moron received. And dismiss all the idiot's that went along with this nut job..
Give yourself a break. If Khelif has a particular syndrome, then it is normal that he was identified as female at birth and later raised as such. Only the DNA test could provide certainty, a test that the IOC abolished 8 years ago, I believe, for privacy reasons (?????). Disqualify Khelif, yes, but even prison....
It's beyond unfair to all those female athletes who have given so much and achieved so much. To be beaten by a male in a female competition is unjust, dangerous and cruel. There are so many instances where female athletes have been seriously injured in contact sports playing against these men who claim to be woman. It is a disaster waiting to happen and those who have allowed this madness to continue should be held accountable.
I called this months ago ~~ 1. Khelif was born with xy chromosomes with DSD 5-ARD deficiency.. Internal testes and no ovaries ... As such, Khelif was misassigned at birth as a female .. same as Caster Semenya and Brittany Griner ... 2. When Khelif reached puberty, his xy chromosomes kicked in (specifically the y chromosome) releasing normal male levels of testosterone from internal testes and resulting in all the attributes associated with being a male (muscle mass, bone density, lung capacity, larger heart, broader shoulders, deeper voice, etc) .. just look at the video of Khelif walking around Paris .. major broad shoulders and a typical male gait .. 3. In 2023, Khelif was banned by the IBA for not meeting the female division sex requirements .. ie. Not having xx chromosomes ... Khelif initially appealed this decision but then abandoned it .. when a simple cheek swab would easily prove whether Khelif was xx or xy ... 4. The fact Khelif chose NOT to fight the IBA ban or take this simple test is very telling, if not damning .. hiding behind a dubious passport is not proof of anything.. 5. In 2024, Khelif decides to compete as a woman in the Olympics, knowing the IOC has a loophole in not requiring actual proof that women are xx chromosomal.. Instead, a passport will do, which is zero proof at all ! 6. Any empathy for Khelif I had disappeared upon learning he is gaming the system by KNOWING he is xy chromosomal and STILL deciding to use his xy size/muscle/power advantage to beat up xx women .. the power advantage difference between men and women is massive (one paper cited a 162% difference!) .. 7. The IOC banned Caster Semenya in the 2024 Olympics for having naturally high testosterone (but ignoring why this is occurring ie. xy chromosomes) ... yet allows Khelif, Lin, and Griner to compete ... the inconsistency is mind-boggling 8. Algeria should be ashamed knowing full well they are exploiting the IOC's incompetence and willful woke ignorance, instead of actual solid recognized facts and science. 9. Their egregious decision (IOC) could lead to serious injuries, or even death, to actual xx female athletes. It's just insane. Solution: * Cheek swabs for ALL competitors ... * Only XX can participate in women's sport events * Its just that simple!!
It s so frustrating to still hear nowadays people so gaslighted saying he was just a poor female victim critisized by all us... Grrrrrrr... Stop trying to be nice all the time!!!or at least be nice to the girls who fight so hard to be there!!!!!
The Olympic committee should immediately take back Mr. Khelif's gold medal and give it to the female runner up. This was a travesty committed by both Mr. Khelif and the Olympic committee...
As an old white woman, I'm telling you. You have a powerful powerful platform. Keep doing the work. You're doing because no one wants to hear from people like me. But you are and I don't know what I'm supposed to call you cause I don't wanna get in trouble, but a woman of color is that okay? And I really like listening to you and seeing how you present things you should be on the news. Maybe you can take over for cnn
I would rather a few people be left out because of false positive results over this garbage. This is actively destroying any reason for women's sports to even exist. We created a division for women why the F can't we do the same for trans individuals or people with sexual disorders? The market certainly seems to be growing.
If Imane was labeled a female due to the abnormality as an infant, did not have access to medical care and testing, and grew up truly believing he was female then IMO this is heartbreaking on all sides. I am not so lacking in compassion that I cannot feel sadness for someone who believed one thing only to have their world turned upside down with the truth. Sadly, it does not change the fact that a bio male boxer in the ring against a female is dangerous and should not be accepted.
One can only feel sympathy for anyone born with a DSD. However, it must have become clear at puberty that something was wrong and, for that, my sympathy ends. The bulk of my displeasure, though, goes to the authorities who have overseen and endorsed this travesty.
I'll cut him some slack prior to the two tests, but not much, after that he just becomes a liar. He himself signed and acknowledged both sets of test results. The fact remains that coming from a small villain a primarily Muslim country, he knew at the onset of puberty he was male. He continued to play soccer with boys up until moving into boxing at 16.
It was already clear to me that Khelif was fully aware of being a man and that his trainer also knew it, the moment his trainer cheerfully took him on his shoulders after his victory... There are regions where things are a little more free and regions where things are a little stricter, but in general In Algeria, men and women don't even shake hands in public, not even people who are closely related to each other. Touching a woman in this way in public is considered extremely inappropriate, and most likely also in front of an audience of millions on television...but expressions of joy of this kind among men are not a problem.
Ofcourse it is heartbreaking for him but he has to deal with that on a personal level, like we all have to do when we meet with difficulties. Women shouldn't be the victim of this.
Irene, thank you so much for your supporting and standing up for XX women! Only activism will stop certain distorted people from pushing men in women's sports and life spaces. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Caster Semanya is also a similar case. This has been going on for a long time. The advantage that Caster had over fellow competitors so obvious, but they tried to say that she was been harrased bcos of her race. The professional bodies may need to create third categories for XY competitors with DSD bços it is most unfair to the females they crush in professional competitions.
I saw another video on this yesterday. This should have been put to bed before this male competed in women’s sports and won top honors. The first time I became aware of this was the story about caster semenya. It just isn’t fair to women. 😢
So back during the Olympics when this issue with Khelif was a hot button topic, i got into a back and forth with some folks on Reddit. Although i was in disagreement with the people I was corresponding with i remained respectful throughout - I never name called or used harsh language, i just stated what I believed, and then i also provided a link to Andrew Gold’s YT channel “Heretics” and his interview with Dr. Emma Hilton. It was a disagreement, and i thought a respectful one, though i was definitely getting name-called. The following day I received an email from Reddit telling me that my account had been given a “warning for harassment.” I had apparently broken some rule by having the gall to actually question the narrative around Khelif, and someone had reported me. I feel a bit more validated after seeing this news today, but these truly are scary times, when if you disagree with the modern left you risk being banned from a platform that you enjoy.
I don't think anyone with eyes and ears is at all surprised by this alleged revelation. It's still disgusting, though. We need to stop treating women unfairly and especially stop putting women in danger.
We all knew he was a man, but the Olympic committee didn’t care less that women were getting beaten up by a man. What about the other male boxer any news on him
Thanks for the reminder why I don't watch the Hill. It's too bad they don't pick a straw to decide who takes what side of an argument that doesn't exist? Keep to the facts. The numbers speak for woman, not silly newsroom pundits. 600 female athletes in 400 competitions lost 890 medals in 29 different sports. Just quiet the rattle in your head and let the numbers sink in. For a stretch try to think what else those women lost.
The worst part is that there were Doctors out here like me screaming to the rooftops that you would find this man's testicles in his abdomen. The boxing commission had released their report when he was suspended from their competitions. We were able to read the medical results prior to the Olympics. I'm SO tired of being called a racist, transphobe, and the kicker I was called fat phobic for telling a 658 lb woman that the reason she can't breathe is because her body is literally smothering her. At 50, and a decade of being denied publication in science and medical journals to pseudoscience is getting old. We need help out here and they aren't taking us seriously. We are about to hit a mental health crisis of epic proportions. How can we be there for those that reality slaps really hard. I just don't know if I have the energy anymore to stay in trauma medicine being degraded, spit on, and wasting my time when I could help those that truly want and need it.
I'm really curious what is going to come from this. I wouldn't be surprised if the media won't report it and nothing will initially change without a fight.
The world record for the deadlift is approximately 630 lbs for a female and 1100+ lbs for a male. If the male record holder woke up in the morning and said, "I feel like a woman, the XY chromosomes would magically disappear.
Am watching now but I knew something was up… Well, obviously something was up just by looking at him… But when I dug deeper & found out he was allowed to play sports in the town center with boys in a Muslim country where girls were not allowed to play, not to mention when you look at pictures of his mother and I’m assuming are his sisters they’re all covered up like good Muslim women yet he’s not (plus look at body language of how he sits). It also says an awful lot that his coaches would not allow him to spar with actual women when training yet they were OK with having him actually compete against women. They legitimately lucky he didn’t accidentally unalive a woman. Isn’t he suing Elon Musk…anyway I’m going finish listening now… Great work
There is also a picture of Inmane with a female trainer. The trainer is wearing a long sleeve shirt,pants, and a head scarf covering her hair. She looks like any woman in a Muslim country. Inmane has the hair uncovered,wearing long male shorts and a short sleeve shirt. It was pretty obvious that no Muslim woman would dress like that.
International relations, including through sports, used to be something of national pride and and cheating would be an international reputation disaster - why hasn't that happened?
I do have some compassion for young Khalif, I’m sure it was confusing and they didn’t receive the proper medical care they needed. However, Khalif went through male puberty and knows they are male and just continued the lie. It is shameful that the IOC is supporting men in women’s sports. Why do they even have categories then?
Males don't just have strength advantages, but their wider shoulders give them a leverage advantage. Women have a disadvantage in running because of their wider hips.
Here in the US, we “solved” corruption by calling it another name…lobbying. In education/hiring practices we’ve “solved” racism by calling it affirmative action or DEI. In sports we’ve “solved” cheating by calling it acceptance. See how that works?😂
Its disgraceful. All those medals stolen by men cosplaying as woman. This insanity need to ends!
Why don’t women just boycott? We know men will never put up with unfairness.
The Olympics committee that allowed women to be abused by that man should be taken to justice also.
For aiding and abetting physical assault.
💯
I totally agree, the Olympic Committee needs to be jailed
Class action !
prison for 50 years...
Bring back chromosomal testing for *all* female sports on *all* levels!
@@FitBabe It's a must!
SRY gene as well, if suspicions. The SRY gene test was halted in 2006 summer olympics
It's as simple as a COVID test.
@@tomorrowhowever7488 Unless SRY gene testing is considered.
@tomorrowhowever7488 Unless SRY gene testing is considered.
This is not just a case of a man running or swimming faster than a woman. It’s a fact of a man hitting a woman. It’s intolerable that the rights of one person from a tiny, tiny minority usurps the rights of millions of women everywhere.
Exactly. And the fact that the desires of a tiny minority of *men* trump the rights of all women says it all. This is Patriarchy in action, ironically.
Millions of women are boxing at the olympic level? Come on, stop being a twat.
Leftists are fine with men beating women if it's for the sake of their LGBTQ+ narrative. XD
and it's actually false that males have a 'right' to everything female, simply because they say so. No human or civil right grants that. Unfortunately, the transactivist lobby is succeeding in changing law in one country after the other to fit their agenda - and destroy women's (actually existing) rights.
and Democrat women in America are fine and OK with this, all the while screaming Trump is 'taking their rights away'. They are NUTS.
The IOC should be sued by every female who lost a medal or was abused by this man.
Yes, Imane Khalif is welcome to battle _male_ boxers.
Except he wouldn’t make to Olympics
And has, in fact, done so, in foreign countries!
@@tablescissors
And did well. I usually try to be polite, but this guy is a POS.
@@tablescissorsReally?
@@tablescissors😂😂😂😂 so to beat up women to win because he couldn't beat men. Wow weak
He is a cheat and a woman abuser. He deserve jail time.
I think this person with dsd is born into a muslim country.
The muslim belive if a person has a vagina and can have intercorse with a male, it is a female.
Khelif grew up, and people classified Khelif as female and,still in muslim worldview classifie Khelif as female.
We should look at the bigger picture.
Those differences in worldview.
So he’s a cheater… and yet he wanted to sue Rowling and Musk for being correct about him, talk about having balls.
No, Khelif sought to have them criminally charged in France for “acts of aggravated cyber harassment”
@@DavidMotherlandit can’t be call harassment if it’s the truth. People know themselves better than you think. I saw earlier pictures of Imane dressed like a male, in a men’s suit on several different occasions. He knew he was male for more than a year before the Olympics; Imani was tested two years earlier. He took advantage of weak rules and regulations and entered the Olympic as a woman knowing he was a male. He’s a cheater.
@@DavidMotherlandCountering your lies is not cyber harassment.
@@bikerjk1205It’s correct though. There’s a reason he went after them for harassment and not “lying” about him. He would have needed to prove them wrong in court which he clearly cannot do because he’s male.
@@DavidMotherland😂the absolute gall of him. Acting like a victim so he can beat up women.
I read an article yesterday claiming reduxx who broke this story were " bullying" him! The new world narrative that men who say they are women have more rights than real women and are the victims. 😡😡😡
Absolutely the gold medals should be returned and the runner ups all elevated.
🙌🏾✊🏽♀️💖👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽💥💯
Won't happen. The IOC knew about it and they stand by the new idea that female is who's saying it. They happily give all the medals to men. As long as they claim to be women. They call it "inclusion" and "compassion".
I 💯 agree with you.
USA women's BB team needs to return theirs as well. Griner is openly bio male born with a male DSD, XXY. WNBA has several bio males. Clarendon who just retired in Sept after 12 years in the league openly started transitioning while in the WNBA and the league wore gear etc for trans females 😂 Bio males with male DSDs, ovotestes perhaps being the only exception, and bio males who are identifiers or have a trans prefix, belong in male spaces representing males facing those challenges.
@@IWM-123 Can you link the sources that show Brittany Griner is openly a bio male? I looked myself and I couldn’t find any credible source that said this. I only found an article where she doubles down on being a female. My suspicion is that she has DSD like Caster Semenya.
Being Russian doesn't mean you're not telling the truth.
Right. Surely that's a racist propaganderised statement?
Uh....
@@mwfmtnmanI mean, it's correct...we view Russia as some massive propaganda state, but...ours is too. There's not really that much of a difference. Yeah, they have a single authority figure, we have more of an authority shadow org (the permanent unelectable parts of the government), but it works the same way. The idea that Russia is somehow "way worse" than us when it comes to information control is completely false.
Thank you for your kind words and (actually) common sense)).
I do prefer to tell the truth.
Even when it is forbidden by our temporary laws))).
I actually always thought that being russian obliges me to tell even more truth)). Because of the soviet past and its lessons, for example.
And Angela was forced to apologize. Never forget that.
IOC needs to be investigated for corruption and incompetence.
It's a scheme and anti Russian too. Russia used and independent lab but the results are questionable just because Russia asked for the test. Funny how after sex testing was eliminated we see a surge in males winning in women's sports. It's ridiculous.
I don't know what shocks me more - the widespread apparent hatred of women, or the number of women who are contributing to their own harm through being "kind".
NONE of it is shocking unless you haven’t been paying attention.
Apparent hatred? Wow, shame on you. Your ancestors will be ashamed as they fought for your rights that you gladly surrender to sympathise a man claiming to be a woman.
Exactly. Generally women need to get angry and act against the enemy instead of feeling sorry for themselves and accepting what the translobby is doing
I've even seen a few terven seemingly having their empathy for naturally masculine women co-opted to stand up for this bloke. It's very sad
@@ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Yes! I was very disappointed in Holly somehow accepting this man as a woman bc he thought his whole life he was one. It's the problem with people who see sex wholely through a socialisation lense. Which plays a part, but there is also biological reality which doesn't care about "socialisation". I really don't get how seemingly intelligent people can have such a blind spot.
Chromosomal testing for ALL Olympic athletes
4:55 It’s so hard to watch this female athlete breakdown. She worked so hard, just to have her dreams shattered by the male players.
The actual winner, Melissa Bishop, did not even medal, and her career ended shortly thereafter. I was sick to watch it in 2016 and it still makes my blood the go cold.
I remember watching this interview and didn’t understand what the problem was. I knew Caster Semenya wasn’t a woman, but I didn’t see the medal ceremony, so didn’t see the other two were men. These men know they’re men, probably before puberty, but definitely after.
@@laf4891 Growing up as a woman for 20-odd years, and then finding out that you're a man with some syndrome, is hard to stomach.
@@FabrizioPati-i6fyes, and that's also part of this, compassion for the individuals who find their biological reality is not their social reality. I had genetic testing in my 30s, nothing to do with this thankfully! But it did give me some unexpected results that I had to accept. It's hard, genetic councillors help, but in the end I had to do the personal work to understand myself. That's the journey for these people, and for that I feel empathy.
I also want biological males out of women's sports, spaces and platforms. It's not a contradiction to recognise that they're human too.
And this is the mess people have to deal with when you don’t live by facts and truth. It’s all so absurd
The literally redefined facts, redefined science, redefined logic. So, no matter what you say, the answer is "follow the science they make up with no tethers to reality."
You can't win. Folks who properly identify all women to discriminate against and mimic, pretend they have no idea what a woman is when women are getting the short end of the stick.
Absolutely!
It appears that women's rights cannot exist unless men are included. Somehow, this seems to make sense nowadays.
But it’s not enough for them to be included, they want to push women back into a second class status, it’s just misogyny by another name.
As soon as men are included, womens rights are not important anymore.
And at the same time, men's rights and humanity are being destroyed by females. Irony .
Agreed. However, this has been the case for men and males since the 1970s: male-only spaces, groups, clubs, etc., were under fire by feminists who demanded female access. In current times the anti-binary campaign has gone enormous distances farther and become far worse. But the error and folly began long before.
@EssensOrAccidens The feminists wanted their own spaces and equal rights. Nowadays, the men are taking over the women's spaces, opportunities, etc. The men are even claiming womanhood as their own.
We can see all the proof with our eyes, but yeah.
Yes, and now we have science to back us up.
I saw this coming. But we know science deniers who defended Imane, rarely admit when they’re wrong.
The people defending Khelif call you science deniers.
@@gfys756they have a faulty understanding of English.
@gfys756 the science does not support delusions. You clearly do not understand that science does not equal fantasy and men are not, cannot, and never will be women. Seek out a dictionary and real help.
@@gfys756
Wrong answer dude!!!
@@gfys756they can call us what they like. We can see their (and your) projection. Scientific tests say man so we were right, like we didn’t know.
Women still fighting for female sports.
Women are still fighting for women’s rights, not just sports.
nothing new under the sun, but how crazy? i remember writing how title 9 should pass in sixth grade.
So, so sad!! 😢
Woman defending men doing this makes me so cross. They should know better
And now news comes out that trans player,, Blair on San Jose team colluded with an opposing team member to hurt the team captain, who joined the lawsuit. It caused their first loss because Blair failed to defend the space next to the targeted teammate. Huge scandal.
❗❗❗
I hate it when people say "we shouldn't presume males have an advantage."
Like we don't have literally hundreds of sports records to go by! That all goes out the window when it comes to gender identity.
There are also many studies confirming that males have hundreds of advantages
It should be the other way around: *always* assume male advantage, undless the person proves beyond a doubt they have none!
@@HekateSelini Exactly. And what really boiled me was when Veronica Ivy, a transgendered bicyclist tried to say "We don't know. So we should lean to acceptance." No, we should lean to safety! That's always how it's been.
@@TheRisky9 OMG, that one gets me, too! first named Rachel McKinnon, now VY - but still doing everything to justify TIMs beating women in women's sports. And since VY is an academic, VY knows very well that sex can't be changed - of course we know. Still, VY said on TV: "I am biologically female: I'm a biological being and my passport says female." These people feel so safe in today's woke climate, they state outrageous lies & logical fallacies - and can be sure nobody calls them out. Women's cycling in North America is dominated by men - I find it disgusting.
That poor runner breaking down, broke my heart. 😢
Hearn isn’t stupid, he knows Khelif is male. He’s like an old, Victorian freak show promoter-only interested in the spectacle.
I hope all these people declaring previously “trans women in women’s sports won’t take away from biological women” have a really good think about fairness in sport and the consequences of these actions. Biological women lost out on medals, sponsorships, etc.
A week ago it was said that men had won 890 medals belonging to women in various sports.
Those promoting this counterintuitive nonsense don't care about fairness. That isn't part of the agenda of social destabilization.
We aren't to believe our eyes.
No XY in female sports. I don't care what condition it is, even if their may not be an advantage with certain DSDs. Just no. Xy should only be abled to compete with males for the fairness of women. No exceptions.
Particularly for combat sports.
When I first saw him I thought it was a Borat skit
😂
What is that Skit
@@laf4891Sacha Baron Cohen is a famous actor and comedian that plays a well known character named “Borat” look it up to see. 😂
😂😂😂
This is the twilight zone. WTF?
We already knew Imane was male, but glad it’s finally been acknowledged publicly.
Another public outing but we will be told to ignore this one too.
@@Susan-id5xj: Yup! And they’ll try to spin it and gas light us and make him seem like a victim again. 🙄😒
The IOC needs to release a public apology for their mistakes and clarify the rules to prevent this BS it future.
no mistake
What is the likelihood of that happening…🤨🤔🫤🫤🤨
Surprise, surprise. So, will HE be giving back their wholly undeserving Olympic gold medal.
The IOC qualified him. We can't even say he cheated! They never really did care about it.
It's a real kick in the 🏀🏀's
At this point all they may do in the future is remove or fudge the record. Saying the medal was given to a male (for whatever reason/accident they wanna put). This is now history and we don’t like to admit ‘mistakes’ in history. WE NEED TO REMEMBER IT AND RELAY IT to future generations.
The Olympics are ded to many of us
@@Demmie-nl2qhThe Olympics are not what I watched back in the ‘70’s or 80’s. So sad
Not if he can help it, I bet!
Omg! She said herself that women lost 890 medals to men and then goes on to say that it's just a minor issue?? How many medals do we have to lose to men before it becomes an issue? 10.000??
XY - who would have guessed? Thanks Irene. So proud of you. Stay safe. 👏👏😃👋🇭🇲👏👏👏
These men are vile, from the ioc, to the coaches, to the governments, to the athletes. And sorry...to ALL the athletes that carried on competing while women were being punched out by men. They are ALL vile.
This MAN needs to be jailed for fraud plus return medal and any monies that this moron received.
And dismiss all the idiot's that went along with this nut job..
Give yourself a break. If Khelif has a particular syndrome, then it is normal that he was identified as female at birth and later raised as such. Only the DNA test could provide certainty, a test that the IOC abolished 8 years ago, I believe, for privacy reasons (?????).
Disqualify Khelif, yes, but even prison....
The people who put him into the position also should lose their jobs then Jailed for fraud
It's beyond unfair to all those female athletes who have given so much and achieved so much. To be beaten by a male in a female competition is unjust, dangerous and cruel. There are so many instances where female athletes have been seriously injured in contact sports playing against these men who claim to be woman. It is a disaster waiting to happen and those who have allowed this madness to continue should be held accountable.
This is so hard to see happening. Thank you Irene, and all others standing up for women in sports.
It’s obvious by his comportment that he doesn’t think he is female.🤷♀️
I called this months ago
~~
1. Khelif was born with xy chromosomes with DSD 5-ARD deficiency.. Internal testes and no ovaries ... As such, Khelif was misassigned at birth as a female .. same as Caster Semenya and Brittany Griner ...
2. When Khelif reached puberty, his xy chromosomes kicked in (specifically the y chromosome) releasing normal male levels of testosterone from internal testes and resulting in all the attributes associated with being a male (muscle mass, bone density, lung capacity, larger heart, broader shoulders, deeper voice, etc) .. just look at the video of Khelif walking around Paris .. major broad shoulders and a typical male gait ..
3. In 2023, Khelif was banned by the IBA for not meeting the female division sex requirements .. ie. Not having xx chromosomes ... Khelif initially appealed this decision but then abandoned it .. when a simple cheek swab would easily prove whether Khelif was xx or xy ...
4. The fact Khelif chose NOT to fight the IBA ban or take this simple test is very telling, if not damning .. hiding behind a dubious passport is not proof of anything..
5. In 2024, Khelif decides to compete as a woman in the Olympics, knowing the IOC has a loophole in not requiring actual proof that women are xx chromosomal.. Instead, a passport will do, which is zero proof at all !
6. Any empathy for Khelif I had disappeared upon learning he is gaming the system by KNOWING he is xy chromosomal and STILL deciding to use his xy size/muscle/power advantage to beat up xx women .. the power advantage difference between men and women is massive (one paper cited a 162% difference!) ..
7. The IOC banned Caster Semenya in the 2024 Olympics for having naturally high testosterone (but ignoring why this is occurring ie. xy chromosomes) ... yet allows Khelif, Lin, and Griner to compete ... the inconsistency is mind-boggling
8. Algeria should be ashamed knowing full well they are exploiting the IOC's incompetence and willful woke ignorance, instead of actual solid recognized facts and science.
9. Their egregious decision (IOC) could lead to serious injuries, or even death, to actual xx female athletes. It's just insane.
Solution:
* Cheek swabs for ALL competitors ...
* Only XX can participate in women's sport events
* Its just that simple!!
If my daughter got hurt or injured by a male boxer or a male in any other sport I’m afraid I’d be going to jail 100%
You need to stay available to your loved ones. Go about things the legal way, please.
Tak away his gold metals. Jail time for fraud.
What?! No way! Next you're going to say water is wet and the sky is blue...😂
Exactly, please maintain the integrity of women's sports, well said!
We will be saying, "told you so," way too much sadly.
It s so frustrating to still hear nowadays people so gaslighted saying he was just a poor female victim critisized by all us... Grrrrrrr... Stop trying to be nice all the time!!!or at least be nice to the girls who fight so hard to be there!!!!!
This is another example of why so many people think the IOC are a complete joke!!! No need to prove that you are who you say you are.🙄
I wish it was just a joke. Every year there are scandals involving the IOC at every level
The Olympic committee should immediately take back Mr. Khelif's gold medal and give it to the female runner up. This was a travesty committed by both Mr. Khelif and the Olympic committee...
Every time facts are presented, the denial is so obvious.
No facts were presented. Absolutely no scientific evidence. Searching high and low and can't find these scientific papers.
Well my eyes NEVER lied to me.
Who knew that the male boxer was a man battering women!! He should be reported to the police for battering women!
As an old white woman, I'm telling you. You have a powerful powerful platform. Keep doing the work. You're doing because no one wants to hear from people like me. But you are and I don't know what I'm supposed to call you cause I don't wanna get in trouble, but a woman of color is that okay? And I really like listening to you and seeing how you present things you should be on the news. Maybe you can take over for cnn
I would rather a few people be left out because of false positive results over this garbage. This is actively destroying any reason for women's sports to even exist. We created a division for women why the F can't we do the same for trans individuals or people with sexual disorders? The market certainly seems to be growing.
Yes. A man. In every way. Wtf.😢
I already suspected him to be a guy with only one look,
took them a lot of times to do that.
This hospital report confirms exactly what was being said about Kalif all along,
They should take the medal back
If Imane was labeled a female due to the abnormality as an infant, did not have access to medical care and testing, and grew up truly believing he was female then IMO this is heartbreaking on all sides. I am not so lacking in compassion that I cannot feel sadness for someone who believed one thing only to have their world turned upside down with the truth. Sadly, it does not change the fact that a bio male boxer in the ring against a female is dangerous and should not be accepted.
One can only feel sympathy for anyone born with a DSD. However, it must have become clear at puberty that something was wrong and, for that, my sympathy ends. The bulk of my displeasure, though, goes to the authorities who have overseen and endorsed this travesty.
I'll cut him some slack prior to the two tests, but not much, after that he just becomes a liar. He himself signed and acknowledged both sets of test results. The fact remains that coming from a small villain a primarily Muslim country, he knew at the onset of puberty he was male. He continued to play soccer with boys up until moving into boxing at 16.
He knew before the Olympics that he was male, so no sympathy from me
It was already clear to me that Khelif was fully aware of being a man and that his trainer also knew it, the moment his trainer cheerfully took him on his shoulders after his victory...
There are regions where things are a little more free and regions where things are a little stricter, but in general In Algeria, men and women don't even shake hands in public, not even people who are closely related to each other.
Touching a woman in this way in public is considered extremely inappropriate, and most likely also in front of an audience of millions on television...but expressions of joy of this kind among men are not a problem.
Ofcourse it is heartbreaking for him but he has to deal with that on a personal level, like we all have to do when we meet with difficulties. Women shouldn't be the victim of this.
Irene, thank you so much for your supporting and standing up for XX women! Only activism will stop certain distorted people from pushing men in women's sports and life spaces.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Please don't say XX women, it almost seems like there are other types
This will change when Sebastian Coe heads up the IOC. He made World Athletics sane.
Caster Semanya is also a similar case. This has been going on for a long time. The advantage that Caster had over fellow competitors so obvious, but they tried to say that she was been harrased bcos of her race.
The professional bodies may need to create third categories for XY competitors with DSD bços it is most unfair to the females they crush in professional competitions.
Thank you so much for covering this kind of thing! In Canada, we don't get this kind of thing in the news.
Yes, because information does not cross a border? If information is available, it’s available to everyone not just certain countries.
@@CathyTimberlake Canadian media does not report it, that I believe is what OP meant.
@@reneep.1978 research
@@CathyTimberlake The Government has locked down information on this issue. It's considered hate speech.
Somebody referred it too now Canada renamed as Tranada because it's trans rights b4 womens 😢😮
This is all so infuriating. Thanks again for speaking out Irene!!
Just waiting for all the apologies from trans activists who said Imane Khelif was absolutely a woman. I wonder how long I’ll wait.
Imagine my non-shock!
I saw another video on this yesterday. This should have been put to bed before this male competed in women’s sports and won top honors. The first time I became aware of this was the story about caster semenya. It just isn’t fair to women. 😢
So back during the Olympics when this issue with Khelif was a hot button topic, i got into a back and forth with some folks on Reddit. Although i was in disagreement with the people I was corresponding with i remained respectful throughout - I never name called or used harsh language, i just stated what I believed, and then i also provided a link to Andrew Gold’s YT channel “Heretics” and his interview with Dr. Emma Hilton. It was a disagreement, and i thought a respectful one, though i was definitely getting name-called. The following day I received an email from Reddit telling me that my account had been given a “warning for harassment.” I had apparently broken some rule by having the gall to actually question the narrative around Khelif, and someone had reported me. I feel a bit more validated after seeing this news today, but these truly are scary times, when if you disagree with the modern left you risk being banned from a platform that you enjoy.
It's not left. It's just wrong. Debate is a healthy part of Democracy 🎉
It’s definitely not a left perspective. The left dies not want men competing with women.
@@oceanside88 The whole problem lies with the left. The right knows the difference between male and female.
Irrational ideas can not withstand scrutiny so censorship is all they've got.
Sorry, but a platform ban isn’t a real risk. The REAL risk is losing jobs and opportunities and even lawsuits and other issues.
I don't think anyone with eyes and ears is at all surprised by this alleged revelation. It's still disgusting, though. We need to stop treating women unfairly and especially stop putting women in danger.
We all knew he was a man, but the Olympic committee didn’t care less that women were getting beaten up by a man. What about the other male boxer any news on him
The way this person was hoisted onto the shoulders of a man after the ‘victory’ is NOT what happens to female athletes in their part of the world!
Because they all know it’s a dude. It’s Rocky… Not Adrian.
Nature. It understands XX and XY. Unfortunately, some humans don't.
This nasty individual should hand that medal back!
Thanks for the reminder why I don't watch the Hill. It's too bad they don't pick a straw to decide who takes what side of an argument that doesn't exist? Keep to the facts. The numbers speak for woman, not silly newsroom pundits. 600 female athletes in 400 competitions lost 890 medals in 29 different sports. Just quiet the rattle in your head and let the numbers sink in. For a stretch try to think what else those women lost.
Make common sense common again!
"Grew up in the mountains". 😂😂
It's so bigoted. I'd like to see women who grew up in the mountains. I bet they don't look like men.
😂
I hate when I go to the bathroom and there’s someone who grew up in the mountains there 😩
@mega-lomart7154 This made me choke on my tea 😂
😂😂
IOC should be questioned before next Olympics and charged for woman abuse.
not only disgusting but cruel and heartless.
It's amazing how the "be kind"lobby can also be so racist.
The worst part is that there were Doctors out here like me screaming to the rooftops that you would find this man's testicles in his abdomen. The boxing commission had released their report when he was suspended from their competitions. We were able to read the medical results prior to the Olympics. I'm SO tired of being called a racist, transphobe, and the kicker I was called fat phobic for telling a 658 lb woman that the reason she can't breathe is because her body is literally smothering her. At 50, and a decade of being denied publication in science and medical journals to pseudoscience is getting old. We need help out here and they aren't taking us seriously. We are about to hit a mental health crisis of epic proportions. How can we be there for those that reality slaps really hard. I just don't know if I have the energy anymore to stay in trauma medicine being degraded, spit on, and wasting my time when I could help those that truly want and need it.
It's frustrating, eh? Being forced to deny basic medical science...
Doctors like you are what the world needs. I am sorry you have to fight fools just to help people.
The first 'reporter' could barely get her words out. Guessing the truth was fighting with her mouth.
I'm really curious what is going to come from this. I wouldn't be surprised if the media won't report it and nothing will initially change without a fight.
We can get Rowling has seen it. Musk won't be far behind once the election is done here in the US.
The world record for the deadlift is approximately 630 lbs for a female and 1100+ lbs for a male. If the male record holder woke up in the morning and said, "I feel like a woman, the XY chromosomes would magically disappear.
Am watching now but I knew something was up… Well, obviously something was up just by looking at him… But when I dug deeper & found out he was allowed to play sports in the town center with boys in a Muslim country where girls were not allowed to play, not to mention when you look at pictures of his mother and I’m assuming are his sisters they’re all covered up like good Muslim women yet he’s not (plus look at body language of how he sits).
It also says an awful lot that his coaches would not allow him to spar with actual women when training yet they were OK with having him actually compete against women. They legitimately lucky he didn’t accidentally unalive a woman. Isn’t he suing Elon Musk…anyway I’m going finish listening now…
Great work
There is also a picture of Inmane with a female trainer. The trainer is wearing a long sleeve shirt,pants, and a head scarf covering her hair. She looks like any woman in a Muslim country. Inmane has the hair uncovered,wearing long male shorts and a short sleeve shirt. It was pretty obvious that no Muslim woman would dress like that.
Nomiki Konst deserves a gold medal for her mental gymnastics!
The gaslighting was crazy
Anyone with a brain knew when he refused to release his tests
Well, this was the same olympics that allowed a guy from swedden to compete despite having a convicting for SAing an underage girl, so...
This is fantastic journalism.
The stupid part is it’s SO OBVIOUS by just looking at them. So testing of course should confirm suspicions and make it fair.
Imane knew this for at least a few years. Disgusting
Ha, we knew it all along!
More importantly, they knew it all along,
International relations, including through sports, used to be something of national pride and and cheating would be an international reputation disaster - why hasn't that happened?
I do have some compassion for young Khalif, I’m sure it was confusing and they didn’t receive the proper medical care they needed. However, Khalif went through male puberty and knows they are male and just continued the lie. It is shameful that the IOC is supporting men in women’s sports. Why do they even have categories then?
Great reporting! Thank you !
Hello Ms Irene! You’re doing a wonderful job on your Chanel! Thank you
Males don't just have strength advantages, but their wider shoulders give them a leverage advantage. Women have a disadvantage in running because of their wider hips.
How did we get here !?!
Good works Irene ❤
Here in the US, we “solved” corruption by calling it another name…lobbying. In education/hiring practices we’ve “solved” racism by calling it affirmative action or DEI. In sports we’ve “solved” cheating by calling it acceptance. See how that works?😂
Women are overcoming it, so happy to hear about this
Irene, Irene, I love your channel, you and the way you do your thing. Love this information 🥰😂🥰😃🥰😂