Thank you Matt! Ive spent hours trying to interpret my professor's videos and you taught this in 20 mins! My university needs to fire my professor and give me a refund as well! - Thanks dude! Im sending your link to the class
@@MattMacarty This is a great review on how to use solver. Any other ones? I second Goon Head's comment. My professors focused on the results but not the Answer Report, Sensitivity Report, and Limits Report.
Interesting. ... going to school in the early 70s, we did all of this by hand... with the use of a slide rule to estimate the answer and then draw a couple of graphs by hand to zero in on the better answer. Them were the days!! Enjoyed the clip.
The video shows several important concepts; 1. he introduces the basic linear programming purpose and application 2. show how to formulate linear programming problem 3. how to input data in excel and use solver to find optimal solution 4. it also shows real world scenarios to show how linear programming can help solve complex decision making. And in my opinion this solution is the best.
Edit: I found it! I had to go to Data/Solver and then go through the set-up there and the "Limits Report" showed up! Thank you so much for the video again! Thank you for the insightful video! Only thing I was unable to do on my own when following your video was to find the "Limits Report" which didn't show up anywhere in my Excel document. I'm using the newest versions of things, so it probably is just somewhere I don't know where to look for it
Let me tell you. You definitely aleviated a headache and got me out of a tough spot. You explained and showed me this in a manner that was easy to pick up thanks a ton.
Using this in a business merger and acquisition deal in the Midwest. Its a maximization problem of how much capital to allocate to acquisition 1 vs acquisition 2. Its tricky in that the constraints are sensative to changes and are somewhat subjective. For example, we are using return on investment (ROI) as our maximization goal - similar to the "profits goal" in the video. However, the characteristics used as inputs on ROI have some nuances - i.e, capitalization rates, time horizon, standard deviation of cash flows, industry betas and overall risk profiles. Nevertheless, it does provide a methodology to analyze capital allocations to different investments. I saw the other comments about how Linear Programming is taught at the university level. I experienced the same issue at both the undergraduate and graduate level. It was the most time intensive class I took and most of the learning I received was from my own investigation as the Prof didn't seem to care much about what we absorbed or was so far advanced that he had a difficult time bringing down to an introductory level. Stay with it though - its good real world usage your getting.
Back in the days, we used simplex method, and I wrote C program to solve the opimization... now there is an excel solver.... People have forgotten the importance of solving problems on their own.
Agreed If I were in a classroom I would have started by solving with Simplex and then moved onto Solver. Most courses still cover with a graphical example so you can see what's going on but as soon as you move past a couple of variables pretty much everyone is using a solver. I was actually considering showing Simplex with a python program but I haven't gotten to it yet.
My professor literally gave us a link to this video instead of just teaching it himself, I wish I can just take back the money I gave to my professor and give it to you instead. Have my like and sub cuz idk how else to repay u back
Do you have an example on linear programming to minimize interest payment? Example whether to get bank loan at the beginning of the year or monthly loan or combination of both types of loan. I can’t seem to find any examples online. Hope you can show an example. Thank you.
Hi. I am not sure what you mean. If you want to download the spreadsheet I used follow this link: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
How do you do a weight using your format? I have a problem that I set up just like you did, but one product cannot account for more than 50% of units produced and another has to account for at least 20%. Thanks for your help!
@@houssainchaer8335 Well whatever we do is based on a forecasted return and volatility. There are many ways to formulate the problem, my video describes one of them where we maximize Sharpe ratio.
hello! This is so good my MBA stats prof links this video to show us a different way to learn this. I did have a question! is it possible to get a region of feasibility and/or a graph of such using this method?
Thanks. Yes you can at least easily plot the results of a data table with profit as the objective and varying production levels. This should result in a line graph or you can plot as an area chart.
when i add subj to constraints it says unequal number of cell ref and constraints, however they are equal, how do i fix this? thanks great video btw, just encountered some technical difficulties
Thanks. It's probably telling you that you have selected different dimensions for one of the ranges, so maybe three cells for one and two for the other or something similar. You can download the spreadsheet here: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
I'm wondering if you can help set up the following question in Solver: I'm travelling 15000km. Each tire has travel a max distance of 10000km (assume I start with a set of 4 tires). What is the min number of tires I need to use to complete the trip?
1. Consider X Shipping, a firm owned by Y. One of her trucks, with a capacity of 10,000 pounds, is about to be loaded. Awaiting shipment are the following items: Item Value (Birr) Weight (in Kilogram) 1 22500 7500 2 24000 7500 3 8000 3000 4 9500 3500 5 11500 4000 6 9750 3500 The total value of the items loaded onto the truck without exceeding the truck’s weight capacity. Solve this LP problem, using Excel’s Solver.
Hi. I have a question. I created a macro (VBA) that emulates the solver by clicking on a button. The problem is that sometime I have to click 3-4 times before getting the last results. Do you know how to avoid this and getting on solution with one click?
Hi. This is really difficult to diagnose, but one thing to consider is that usually there are many feasible solutions, but only one optimal solution. it sounds like maybe your script is stopping once it finds a feasible solution and then on subsequent runs it gets closer and closer to the optimal. Another common problem is in the modeling step. It's pretty easy to design your model in such a way that it is no longer linear. When this happens you sometimes end up with "local" optima rather than global optima.
Hi! I am a little confused about 5:37 for the total profit function. Can you explain what you did? I tried sum product for the number to make * used numbers and got VALUE!.
This may mean you have selected the wrong range for one of the arguments or ranges of different sizes. You can download my spreadsheet here: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
When you start doing the SUMPRODUCT part you lose me. It doesn't show how you copied it down and I do not get the $ as you do. I only get the B3:C3 part and there is no explanation on the video as to how you did that since the cell you had already formatted
Hi to add absolute referencing ($), if in Windows press F4. If in MAC press command + T. To copy the formula down position your mouse over the lower right corner of a cell and then click and drag or double-click.
Yes it happens. Probably the easiest thing is to hide the decimals. You could also force integer values by setting int as a constraint on the changing cells.
@@MattMacarty I re-did the entire sheet and resolved and am still having the same issue. The Decision variables are correct and the objective value is correct. I just can't execute the sensitivity analysis because all of the objective coefficients are incorrect. This specific problem is unique in that there are some routes that can not be used - I think maybe that has something to do with it - although I was able to execute a sensitivity analysis with an earlier version of the spreadsheet. Thanks for the help also!!
Man thank you I wish I could give you my money instead of my professors. I’ll repay you one day
Glad it helped. c
Thank you Matt! Ive spent hours trying to interpret my professor's videos and you taught this in 20 mins! My university needs to fire my professor and give me a refund as well! - Thanks dude! Im sending your link to the class
I got help from thechinahacks financially .They got me a transfer of $37,000 just yesterday .
@@MattMacarty This is a great review on how to use solver. Any other ones? I second Goon Head's comment. My professors focused on the results but not the Answer Report, Sensitivity Report, and Limits Report.
lol 😂 for real
Thank you!!! So much better than my prof at explaining, especially since you use much clearer terms.
Thanks. Glad it helped.
@@MattMacarty Do you help with homework at a reasonable $/hr rate? The model I have to create is very complicated!
Interesting. ... going to school in the early 70s, we did all of this by hand... with the use of a slide rule to estimate the answer and then draw a couple of graphs by hand to zero in on the better answer. Them were the days!! Enjoyed the clip.
They still teach that in school, but without the slide rule.
@@MattMacarty we would just use our Ti-84 and a pencil and paper to solve these in my operations management class.
I think I watched about 5 videos before I found one that has the best example on what to do. Thanks!!! Short and Simple!!
Thank you. Glad it helped.
It baffles me that Matt made this problem so easy to understand. Why can’t my Professor break it down like this? Thanks Matt!
Thanks. Glad it helped.
The video shows several important concepts;
1. he introduces the basic linear programming purpose and application
2. show how to formulate linear programming problem
3. how to input data in excel and use solver to find optimal solution
4. it also shows real world scenarios to show how linear programming can help solve complex decision making.
And in my opinion this solution is the best.
Thanks. Glad it helped
Matt, thank you for taking the time to produce this video. It has helped me a lot.
Thank you. Glad it helped.
You are a god among men. This is the best explanation of this I have heard. Thank you.
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Edit: I found it! I had to go to Data/Solver and then go through the set-up there and the "Limits Report" showed up! Thank you so much for the video again!
Thank you for the insightful video! Only thing I was unable to do on my own when following your video was to find the "Limits Report" which didn't show up anywhere in my Excel document. I'm using the newest versions of things, so it probably is just somewhere I don't know where to look for it
Glad it helped.
easy way to learn ,good work to the developers of the video
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Saved me for my Quantitative Analytics module! My lecturer explained this so badly, thank you!
Glad it helped
Thank you so much. I was struggling to solve LP with excel solver and your video helped me a lot.
Glad it helped!
Extremely good video. I was pulling my hair in class because my teacher was confusing everyone. Thank you!
Thank you. Glad it helped
Let me tell you. You definitely aleviated a headache and got me out of a tough spot. You explained and showed me this in a manner that was easy to pick up thanks a ton.
Thanks very much. Glad it helped.
Wow man, you are a LEGEND; the way you explain.... just wow. I wish I could trade you with my professor.
hank you. Glad it helped.
Easy to understand and so much easier than doing the simplex method by hand 🙏🙌 Thank you!
Glad it helped
Thank you for posting this! you explained it in a easy but clear way. Now, I know how to solve my assignment problem. Thank you!
Glad it helped.
Great video. My professor took 2 hours to teach this method and i did not understand a thing. whereas you made me understand it in 10 mins. :)
Glad it helped!
2024, still a great video. Thanks!
Glad it helped. Only the interface has changed.
This is the best explanation I've seen so far💯 ,Thank you Sir☺️
You are welcome. Glad it helped.
You're awesome for replying to every comment. Good video!
Thanks. Glad it helped
Thank you so much!!!! I had so much trouble with understanding this and you explained it perfectly. I now understand this. THANK YOU!!!
Glad it helped!
You saved my ass. I have an assignment on this and I had no idea before I watched this video.
Glad it helped
it was easy to learn and certainly very helpful to me. Thank you so much for making this video!
Thanks. Glad it helped
Thorough and clear explanation. THANKS so much :)
Glad it helped
I don’t understand why professors make so difficult huhhh thanksss a lot man❤
Thanks. Glad it helped
Using this in a business merger and acquisition deal in the Midwest. Its a maximization problem of how much capital to allocate to acquisition 1 vs acquisition 2. Its tricky in that the constraints are sensative to changes and are somewhat subjective. For example, we are using return on investment (ROI) as our maximization goal - similar to the "profits goal" in the video. However, the characteristics used as inputs on ROI have some nuances - i.e, capitalization rates, time horizon, standard deviation of cash flows, industry betas and overall risk profiles. Nevertheless, it does provide a methodology to analyze capital allocations to different investments.
I saw the other comments about how Linear Programming is taught at the university level. I experienced the same issue at both the undergraduate and graduate level. It was the most time intensive class I took and most of the learning I received was from my own investigation as the Prof didn't seem to care much about what we absorbed or was so far advanced that he had a difficult time bringing down to an introductory level. Stay with it though - its good real world usage your getting.
Thanks for your comment
Back in the days, we used simplex method, and I wrote C program to solve the opimization... now there is an excel solver.... People have forgotten the importance of solving problems on their own.
Agreed If I were in a classroom I would have started by solving with Simplex and then moved onto Solver. Most courses still cover with a graphical example so you can see what's going on but as soon as you move past a couple of variables pretty much everyone is using a solver. I was actually considering showing Simplex with a python program but I haven't gotten to it yet.
My professor literally gave us a link to this video instead of just teaching it himself, I wish I can just take back the money I gave to my professor and give it to you instead. Have my like and sub cuz idk how else to repay u back
Glad it helped.
Explained clearly. Thank You, Matt!
Great it helped
Hi Matt! Thanks for your video, this really helped me to find the LP for my problem.
Glad it helped!
Saved me a lot of time and stress, can't thank you enough!!
Glad it helped
Thank you so much for this video. It really helps a lot for my upcoming report with this kind of topic. Thanks a bunch!
Glad it helped
Better than my professor explanation that took 6 classes and I did not understand a thing
Glad it helped
so so so helpfull, gonna submit my semester project with t your spreadsheet. thank you so muchh
Glad it helped.
THANK YOU! This helped me finally understand Solver.
Thanks. Glad it helped.
you're really a good tutor. thank you so much. this helped a lot.
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Very clear and easily understood.
Thank you
Glad it helped
Do you have an example on linear programming to minimize interest payment? Example whether to get bank loan at the beginning of the year or monthly loan or combination of both types of loan. I can’t seem to find any examples online. Hope you can show an example. Thank you.
Glad it helped
thanks, gonna use this to find probable missing amounts
Glad it helped
Saved my life homie. Much love.
Glad it helped
So helpful, thank you so much Matt!
Glad it helped.
Thank you! Awesome job btw, and very clearly and thoroughly explained :)
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Thank you very much for your RUclips video. I’ve subscribed to your channel.
Thanks! Glad it helped
Great video! Thank you so much for the explanation.
Thank you. Glad it helped
im student from indonesia, thank youu this video really helpful :)
Glad it was helpful!
sen türk değil misin şimdi? ali fikri türkçe ad değil mi?
Very clear and concise tutorial thank you!
Thank you. Glad it helped.
You are incredible thank you for your help 🙏🤗
Glad it helped
Thank you for making this video!
Glad it helped
Very easy to understand, thank you!
Glad it helped
man you are literally a god thank you so much !!!!!
Thanks. Glad it helped
Very helpful and straight forward - thank you!
Glad it helped.
My Professor shared this Video with in class :)
Thanks, hop it helped.
@@MattMacarty Thankyou too :)
Thank you - very well explained!
Glad it helped.
This sensitivity report is not clear. Can you make a detailed video on its analysis please
You mean you can't see the report? You can changethe settings to HD and that should clear it up.
Wow! well explained. Thanks.
Thank you. Glad it helped.
thanks Matt, you're awesome
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Wonderful video... Can we use excel solver to solve goal programming?
Yes, you may also be able to simply use goal seek
nice presentation
Glad it helped
Thank you Matt. It was very helpful for me 🙏
Glad it helped
Thank you so much this was super helpful
Glad it helped!
Can you give me the same example (question, issue) Because I want to solve it on my own?
Hi. I am not sure what you mean. If you want to download the spreadsheet I used follow this link: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
Thank you so much, really helped a lot!! Awesome work
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Thanks. You teach better than my prof. who teach in the most famous university in my country.... #youtuisbetterteacherthanteacherinclass
Thank you. Glad it helped.
Thanks Matt - it was help in college
Glad it helped.
Thank you! This helped a lot
Glad it helped!
How do you do a weight using your format? I have a problem that I set up just like you did, but one product cannot account for more than 50% of units produced and another has to account for at least 20%. Thanks for your help!
So you need side constraints. This example has something like what you are talking about: ruclips.net/video/C_v0rlpTEmc/видео.html
Thank you. Well explained. Great Job (thumbs up).
Glad it helped.
Thank you! Very helpful
Glad it helped
Your channel it s very helpful 👏👏
I just want to ask How we can use linear programming for asset allocation
HI. Take a look at this one: ruclips.net/video/sI5X2kJA_4k/видео.html
@@MattMacarty can we solve it with simpleLP ?
@@houssainchaer8335 Well whatever we do is based on a forecasted return and volatility. There are many ways to formulate the problem, my video describes one of them where we maximize Sharpe ratio.
Thank you so much. Can I share this youtube with my students?
Thanks. Yes please feel free to share.
Hello Matt, what keys did you press for you to change (B4:C4) to ($B$4:$C$4)??
It's F4 (function4) in Windows, command + T in MAC
Excellent Matt
Thanks, glad it helped.
Thank you so much!! Now I understand a lot!
Thanks. Glad it helped.
Thanks for the help! Definitely useful stuff
Glad it helped
Thank you! Video was very helpful!! :)
Glad it helped
Video really helped me! Thank you!
Thanks. Glad it helped
hello! This is so good my MBA stats prof links this video to show us a different way to learn this.
I did have a question! is it possible to get a region of feasibility and/or a graph of such using this method?
Thanks. Yes you can at least easily plot the results of a data table with profit as the objective and varying production levels. This should result in a line graph or you can plot as an area chart.
when i add subj to constraints it says unequal number of cell ref and constraints, however they are equal, how do i fix this? thanks great video btw, just encountered some technical difficulties
Thanks. It's probably telling you that you have selected different dimensions for one of the ranges, so maybe three cells for one and two for the other or something similar. You can download the spreadsheet here:
alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
LIFESAVER THANK YOU SO MUCH
Glad it helped
I'm wondering if you can help set up the following question in Solver:
I'm travelling 15000km. Each tire has travel a max distance of 10000km (assume I start with a set of 4 tires).
What is the min number of tires I need to use to complete the trip?
I may be missing something, but this sounds like a simple algebra problem
@@MattMacarty I'd like to know if Solver is smart enough to calculate that I need 6 tires as opposed to 8.
It should if you set the objective to minimize instead of maximize.
@@MattMacartyI think this is where I’m struggling with, is to set up the constraints.
can you do it with multiple objective? and can we pick one thing from list with multiple objective problem with excel solver?
You can only have one objective function.
Can you articulate the example in a paragraph or give the link of the example?
Hi. I have posted in the video description: ruclips.net/video/6xa1x_Iqjzg/видео.html
hi- to define if i exceeding daily usage what would be my constraints?
I think you will just have to compare actual usage with "optimal" usage
Thanks, really helpful!
Glad it helped.
You are the man!
Thanks. Glad it helped
1. Consider X Shipping, a firm owned by Y. One of her trucks, with a capacity of 10,000 pounds, is about to be loaded. Awaiting shipment are the following items:
Item Value (Birr) Weight (in Kilogram)
1 22500 7500
2 24000 7500
3 8000 3000
4 9500 3500
5 11500 4000
6 9750 3500
The total value of the items loaded onto the truck without exceeding the truck’s weight capacity. Solve this LP problem, using Excel’s Solver.
This sounds like a transportation problem. See this video: ruclips.net/video/C_v0rlpTEmc/видео.html
very helpful, thank you very much for sharing
Thanks. Glad it helped
Hi. I have a question. I created a macro (VBA) that emulates the solver by clicking on a button. The problem is that sometime I have to click 3-4 times before getting the last results. Do you know how to avoid this and getting on solution with one click?
Hi. This is really difficult to diagnose, but one thing to consider is that usually there are many feasible solutions, but only one optimal solution. it sounds like maybe your script is stopping once it finds a feasible solution and then on subsequent runs it gets closer and closer to the optimal. Another common problem is in the modeling step. It's pretty easy to design your model in such a way that it is no longer linear. When this happens you sometimes end up with "local" optima rather than global optima.
Very helpful! Thank you
Glad it helped.
Hi! I am a little confused about 5:37 for the total profit function. Can you explain what you did? I tried sum product for the number to make * used numbers and got VALUE!.
This may mean you have selected the wrong range for one of the arguments or ranges of different sizes. You can download my spreadsheet here: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
When you start doing the SUMPRODUCT part you lose me. It doesn't show how you copied it down and I do not get the $ as you do. I only get the B3:C3 part and there is no explanation on the video as to how you did that since the cell you had already formatted
Hi to add absolute referencing ($), if in Windows press F4. If in MAC press command + T. To copy the formula down position your mouse over the lower right corner of a cell and then click and drag or double-click.
Thank you so much!!!
Glad it helped
Hi Marty, do you have this as a certificate course on Udemy?
No, sorry.
Thank you so much.
Glad it helped
How to avoid decimal number. I want natural number but i keep getting decimal numbers
Yes it happens. Probably the easiest thing is to hide the decimals. You could also force integer values by setting int as a constraint on the changing cells.
what course do you learn this in? operations management?
There used to be a course called management science or operations research. Now it may be covered in OM.
@@MattMacarty cool it will help google stuff
how can i add a constraint to disable the use of decimal?
You can solve as an integer problem, but it's likely better to just decrease decimals in Excel
@@MattMacarty found it, its in the constraints button, set the operator to int
@@nomnom914 Yes
Why is my Objective coefficient different in my sensitivity analysis than it is in my LP model?
Did you select Simplex method before solving? Did you change it in the spreadsheet after solving?
@@MattMacarty I re-did the entire sheet and resolved and am still having the same issue. The Decision variables are correct and the objective value is correct. I just can't execute the sensitivity analysis because all of the objective coefficients are incorrect. This specific problem is unique in that there are some routes that can not be used - I think maybe that has something to do with it - although I was able to execute a sensitivity analysis with an earlier version of the spreadsheet. Thanks for the help also!!
@@baselineiggy Maybe download my spreadsheet and strat from there: alphabench.com/data/linear-programming-optimization.html
@@MattMacarty Thankyou
Grazie mille Signore
Glad it helped