Speak To Me is not a song, it's an introduction track. It doesn't have melody or musical structure as it is only sounds. The worst song in DSotM would be On The Run.
Here’s my list: Piper: Best is interstellar overdrive, worst is bike Saucer: Best is remember a day, worst is corporal clegg More: Best is Nile song, worst is a Spanish piece Umma: Best is careful with that axe eugene (live), worst is several species of small furry animals gathered together in a cave and grooving with a pict Atom: Best is atom heart mother, worst is Alan’s psychedelic breakfast Meddle: Best is echoes, worst is san tropez Obscured: Best is childhood’s end, worst is absolutely curtains Dark side: Best is us and them, worst is speak to me Wish: Best is shine on you crazy diamond parts vi - ix, worst is wish you were here (but I still love it) Animals: Best is dogs or pigs (I can’t choose between them, I love them both so much), worst is pigs on the wing 2 Wall: Best is comfortably numb, worst is bring the boys back home Cut: Best is gunner’s dream, worst is get your filthy hands off my desert Lapse: Best is on the turning away, worst is a new machine part 1 Divide: Best is high hopes, worst is cluster one Endless: best is louder than words, worst is any of them, I feel like I’m swimming in an endless river when I listen to this album, all the songs blend together
You're back! TPATGOD: Ok, understandable opinion, though I disagree in both Saucerful: also understandable the best one, but saying Corporal Clegg is the worst song should be a crime More: Nile Song is definetly the best one but, A Spanish Piece is definetly worse than main theme Ummagumma: disagree in both of them. AHM: completly agree, underrated album. Meddle: also completly agree OBC: also completly agree² DSOTM: damn we got many same opinions, also agree on that one WYWH: Disagree in the worst one. Welcome To The Machine is hella underrated, for me, its Have A Cigar. The best one is right tho. Animals: Disagree in both of them Best: Pigs Worst: POTW Pt. 1 The Wall: disagree in the best one, for me, its The Trial. TFC: Disagree in the best one, for me, its Not Now John AMLOR: Disagree in both of them. Best: Yet Another Movie Worst: A New Machine Pt. 2 TDB: I agree. TER: dont agree with the best one and idk about the worst, this album its pretty bruh to me, the only songs I really care are Nervana and Louder Than Words.
Every song of the album is absolutely brilliant, they are so perfect that neither of them deserves to be the worst song of the album. That's why if one has to be chosen I understand choosing any of them (except for shine on you crazy diamond parts i-v, that is the only one I would never accept to be the worst of the album)
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn Best: Intelestelar Overdrive Worst: Chapter 24 A Sacerful Of Secrets Best: A Sacerful Of Secrets Worst: Let there be more light More Best: Green is the colour Worst: Quicksilver Ummagumma Best: Careful With That Axe Eugene Worst: Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict Atom Heart Mother Best: Atom Heart Mother Suite Worst: If Meedle Best: Echoes Worst: Seamus (that's the dog) Obscured By Clouds Best: Childhood's End Worst: Absolutely Curtains The Dark Side Of The Moon Best: Money Worst: Speak To Me Wish You Were Here Best: Wish You Were Here Worst: Welcome To The Machine Animals Best: Dogs Worst: Pigs On The Wing 2 The Wall Best: Comfortably Numb Worst: Stop The Final Cut Best: Not Now John Worst: One Of The Few A Momentary Lapse Of Reason Best: Sorrow Worst: Round and Around The Division Bell Best: High Hopes Worst: Cluster One The Endless River Best: Louder Than Words Worst: Side 2 Part 3 Unsung
If you think The Nile Song is the best on that album, i think you should give MORE album another listen. I can't believe you put Main Theme as the album's worse, I would have said Quicksilver. More has so many amazing songs such as Cymbiline, Crying Song, and Ibiza Bar!
@@ernest9013 The eating sounds don't really bother the song itself, but the sound is better than A Spanish Piece for sure, so if the eating sounds were lowered down more than the song would sound more great.
Piper at the gates of dawn: Best: Lucifer Sam Worst: take thy stethoscope and walk Saucerful is secrets: Best: Corporal Clegg Worst: Saucerful of secrets More: Best: Ibiza Bar Worst: Circus manor Ummagumma: Best: grandchester Meadows Worst: several species of small furry animals gathered together in a cave and grooving with a pict Atom heart mother: Best: Atom Heart mother Suite Worst: Alan’s psychedelic breakfast Meddle: Best: Echoes Worst: Seamus Obscured by clouds: Best: Childhoods end Worst: Absolutely Curtains The Dark Side Of the moon: Best: Time Worst: Speak to me Wish you were here: Best: shine on you crazy diamond Worst: Welcome to the machine Animals: Best: Dogs Worst: Pigs on the wing 2 The Wall: Best: Comfortably Numb Worst: Stop The Final Cut: Best: Not now John Worst: One of the Few A momentary lapse of reason Best: On the turning away Worst: A New Machine Pt. 1 The division bell: Best: High Hopes Worst: Cluster One The Endless River: Best: Louder than words Worst: all except Louder than words
My ranking: The piper at the gates of dawn: best: bike worst: I guess flaming A Saucerful of secrets: best: corporal clegg worst: seesaw More: best: the Nile song worst: more blues Ummagumma: best: sysyphus worst: astronomy donine live Atom heart mother: best: fat old Sun worst: none Meddle: best: Seamus worst: a pillow of winds Obscured by clouds: best: mud men worst: childhoods end The dark side of the moon: best: money worst: speak to me wish you were here: best: title track and shine on worst: have a cigar Animals: best: dogs worst: worst pigs on the wing The wall: best: comfortably numb worst: young lust The Final Cut: best: the fletcher memorial home: worst: not now John A momentary lapse of reason: best: on the turning table😂😂 worst: nothing The division bell: best: lost for words worst: keep talking The endless River: best: louder than words worst: N/A
Here's my list: The Piper at the Gates of Dawn Best: Lucifer Sam Worst: Chapter 24 -------- A Saucerful of Secrets Best: See-Saw Worst: Corporal Clegg -------- More Best: Cymbaline Worst: Quicksilver -------- Ummagumma Best: Grantchester Meadows Worst: Several Species... -------- Atom Heart Mother Best: Atom Heart Mother Worst: Summer 68 -------- Meddle Best: Echoes Worst: A Pillow Of Winds -------- Obscured By Clouds Best: Mudmen Worst: When You're In -------- The Dark Side Of The Moon Best: Us And Them Worst: Money -------- Wish You Were Here Best: Welcome to the Machine Worst: Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI - IX) -------- Animals Best: Dogs Worst: Sheep -------- The Wall Best: Is There Anybody Out There? Worst: Outside The Wall -------- The Final Cut Best: The Fletcher Memorial Home Worst: Southampton Dock -------- A Momentary Lapse Of Reason Best: Yet Another Movie Worst: The Dogs Of War -------- The Division Bell Best: High Hopes Worst: A Great Day For Freedom -------- The Endless River Best: Side 4, Pt.2: Eyes To Pearls Worst: Side 2, Pt.1: Skins
You know Wish You Were Here is an amazing album when its "worst" song is one of Pink Floyd's best.
Corporall clegg 😢
Speak To Me is not a song, it's an introduction track. It doesn't have melody or musical structure as it is only sounds. The worst song in DSotM would be On The Run.
If you talk about album impact it’s different, but I understand your opinion when it is just the song.
i clicked on this because i wanted to see your pick for wywh. that's the only floyd album that imo doesn't have a standout "least good" track
Yeah, I love Welcome to the Machine and its still top tier Pink Floyd, just I think the other tracks are better
@@filmevolution3366 completely agree
I love Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict
The fact that the worst of WYWH is "Welcome to the Machine" shows why it's my favourite album.
0:45 it is underrated composition with Scottish accent
The biggest offense is claiming they had a 'worst' song.
They had.
Just because it's the worst on the album doesn't mean it's bad 🚬🗿
if there is best there is worst, very simple
you forgot that there are no worst songs
The animal noise one is pretty bad
There are but they're all great
What about Spanish Piece?
Except “Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave Grooving with a Pict”
Stop is actually good
If welcome to the machine is the worst song on your album you know you made one of the best albums of all time
I find it to be equally as good as the title track and better than Have a Cigar. But you’re right, this album is perfect
Here’s my list:
Piper: Best is interstellar overdrive, worst is bike
Saucer: Best is remember a day, worst is corporal clegg
More: Best is Nile song, worst is a Spanish piece
Umma: Best is careful with that axe eugene (live), worst is several species of small furry animals gathered together in a cave and grooving with a pict
Atom: Best is atom heart mother, worst is Alan’s psychedelic breakfast
Meddle: Best is echoes, worst is san tropez
Obscured: Best is childhood’s end, worst is absolutely curtains
Dark side: Best is us and them, worst is speak to me
Wish: Best is shine on you crazy diamond parts vi - ix, worst is wish you were here (but I still love it)
Animals: Best is dogs or pigs (I can’t choose between them, I love them both so much), worst is pigs on the wing 2
Wall: Best is comfortably numb, worst is bring the boys back home
Cut: Best is gunner’s dream, worst is get your filthy hands off my desert
Lapse: Best is on the turning away, worst is a new machine part 1
Divide: Best is high hopes, worst is cluster one
Endless: best is louder than words, worst is any of them, I feel like I’m swimming in an endless river when I listen to this album, all the songs blend together
Just pass the tequila, manuel...
I respect putting wish you were here last on that album, it is good but overrated. Lacking a really good David Gilmore solo
How the hell is San Tropez the worst song on Meddle? Seamus exists
How is corporal Clegg the worst, I like that song
@@Soldier_comeback I like it too, just less than the others
the first two are a crime
You're back!
TPATGOD: Ok, understandable opinion, though I disagree in both
Saucerful: also understandable the best one, but saying Corporal Clegg is the worst song should be a crime
More: Nile Song is definetly the best one but, A Spanish Piece is definetly worse than main theme
Ummagumma: disagree in both of them.
AHM: completly agree, underrated album.
Meddle: also completly agree
OBC: also completly agree²
DSOTM: damn we got many same opinions, also agree on that one
WYWH: Disagree in the worst one. Welcome To The Machine is hella underrated, for me, its Have A Cigar. The best one is right tho.
Animals: Disagree in both of them
Best: Pigs
Worst: POTW Pt. 1
The Wall: disagree in the best one, for me, its The Trial.
TFC: Disagree in the best one, for me, its Not Now John
AMLOR: Disagree in both of them.
Best: Yet Another Movie
Worst: A New Machine Pt. 2
TDB: I agree.
TER: dont agree with the best one and idk about the worst, this album its pretty bruh to me, the only songs I really care are Nervana and Louder Than Words.
In second album best is Set controls for the heart of the sun
We think the same 😊
Personally I like stop, corporal clegg, and take thy stethoscope and walk, but it is still a good list
Stop is in there just because it’s not even a minute long
I just think that the impact helps the story progress.
@@OliverGonzales-sj8ce I agree.
ok im sorry but Cluster One is the most relaxing thing ever
не может быть у них плохих песен
How can you have welcome to the machine as the worst on wish you where here?
Bro, I think we all think the album is flawless, every song, there’s gonna be one song that gotta be a least favorite it’s what it is 💀
Every song of the album is absolutely brilliant, they are so perfect that neither of them deserves to be the worst song of the album. That's why if one has to be chosen I understand choosing any of them (except for shine on you crazy diamond parts i-v, that is the only one I would never accept to be the worst of the album)
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
Best: Intelestelar Overdrive
Worst: Chapter 24
A Sacerful Of Secrets
Best: A Sacerful Of Secrets
Worst: Let there be more light
More
Best: Green is the colour
Worst: Quicksilver
Ummagumma
Best: Careful With That Axe Eugene
Worst: Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict
Atom Heart Mother
Best: Atom Heart Mother Suite
Worst: If
Meedle
Best: Echoes
Worst: Seamus (that's the dog)
Obscured By Clouds
Best: Childhood's End
Worst: Absolutely Curtains
The Dark Side Of The Moon
Best: Money
Worst: Speak To Me
Wish You Were Here
Best: Wish You Were Here
Worst: Welcome To The Machine
Animals
Best: Dogs
Worst: Pigs On The Wing 2
The Wall
Best: Comfortably Numb
Worst: Stop
The Final Cut
Best: Not Now John
Worst: One Of The Few
A Momentary Lapse Of Reason
Best: Sorrow
Worst: Round and Around
The Division Bell
Best: High Hopes
Worst: Cluster One
The Endless River
Best: Louder Than Words
Worst: Side 2 Part 3 Unsung
Why does everyone hate Alan’s psychedelic breakfast?
The mouth sounds make it unlistenable
@@ernest9013 they don’t bother me
Pretty spot on I'd say
If you think The Nile Song is the best on that album, i think you should give MORE album another listen. I can't believe you put Main Theme as the album's worse, I would have said Quicksilver. More has so many amazing songs such as Cymbiline, Crying Song, and Ibiza Bar!
Alan's psychedelic breakfast isn't actually bad the piano was great, if anything If should be the worst.
The eating sounds make it terrible... That's disgusting how could you listen to these effects while working or daydreaming
@@ernest9013 The eating sounds don't really bother the song itself, but the sound is better than A Spanish Piece for sure, so if the eating sounds were lowered down more than the song would sound more great.
Piper at the gates of dawn:
Best: Lucifer Sam
Worst: take thy stethoscope and walk
Saucerful is secrets:
Best: Corporal Clegg
Worst: Saucerful of secrets
More:
Best: Ibiza Bar
Worst: Circus manor
Ummagumma:
Best: grandchester Meadows
Worst: several species of small furry animals gathered together in a cave and grooving with a pict
Atom heart mother:
Best: Atom Heart mother Suite
Worst: Alan’s psychedelic breakfast
Meddle:
Best: Echoes
Worst: Seamus
Obscured by clouds:
Best: Childhoods end
Worst: Absolutely Curtains
The Dark Side Of the moon:
Best: Time
Worst: Speak to me
Wish you were here:
Best: shine on you crazy diamond
Worst: Welcome to the machine
Animals:
Best: Dogs
Worst: Pigs on the wing 2
The Wall:
Best: Comfortably Numb
Worst: Stop
The Final Cut:
Best: Not now John
Worst: One of the Few
A momentary lapse of reason
Best: On the turning away
Worst: A New Machine Pt. 1
The division bell:
Best: High Hopes
Worst: Cluster One
The Endless River:
Best: Louder than words
Worst: all except Louder than words
oh come on, Speak to Me is not considerable a song :D it's just the Breathe intro
More like least favorite
My ranking:
The piper at the gates of dawn: best: bike worst: I guess flaming
A Saucerful of secrets: best: corporal clegg worst: seesaw
More: best: the Nile song worst: more blues Ummagumma: best: sysyphus worst: astronomy donine live
Atom heart mother: best: fat old Sun worst: none
Meddle: best: Seamus worst: a pillow of winds
Obscured by clouds: best: mud men worst: childhoods end
The dark side of the moon: best: money worst: speak to me wish you were here: best: title track and shine on worst: have a cigar
Animals: best: dogs worst: worst pigs on the wing
The wall: best: comfortably numb worst: young lust
The Final Cut: best: the fletcher memorial home: worst: not now John
A momentary lapse of reason: best: on the turning table😂😂 worst: nothing
The division bell: best: lost for words worst: keep talking
The endless River: best: louder than words worst: N/A
Let’s get our kazoos out people 🗿🗿🗿
Not Seamus 😢
..... chile anyways
Whoa... some incredibly dumb picks for Worst songs!?!
I actually think Intestellar Overdrive is the worst song on Piper and the best song is the rest of the entire album
Best song on The Wall is Nobody Home
Brooo, Alan PSychedelic breakfast is alot better than IF
If (reference 😱 😱) APB was less people eating it would probably be better
Here's my list:
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Best: Lucifer Sam
Worst: Chapter 24
--------
A Saucerful of Secrets
Best: See-Saw
Worst: Corporal Clegg
--------
More
Best: Cymbaline
Worst: Quicksilver
--------
Ummagumma
Best: Grantchester Meadows
Worst: Several Species...
--------
Atom Heart Mother
Best: Atom Heart Mother
Worst: Summer 68
--------
Meddle
Best: Echoes
Worst: A Pillow Of Winds
--------
Obscured By Clouds
Best: Mudmen
Worst: When You're In
--------
The Dark Side Of The Moon
Best: Us And Them
Worst: Money
--------
Wish You Were Here
Best: Welcome to the Machine
Worst: Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI - IX)
--------
Animals
Best: Dogs
Worst: Sheep
--------
The Wall
Best: Is There Anybody Out There?
Worst: Outside The Wall
--------
The Final Cut
Best: The Fletcher Memorial Home
Worst: Southampton Dock
--------
A Momentary Lapse Of Reason
Best: Yet Another Movie
Worst: The Dogs Of War
--------
The Division Bell
Best: High Hopes
Worst: A Great Day For Freedom
--------
The Endless River
Best: Side 4, Pt.2: Eyes To Pearls
Worst: Side 2, Pt.1: Skins
This band as a whole is pretty boring in my opinion, although I love Dark Side of the Moon.
Their golden age is not boring at all, i can understand that you don't like their beginning and their end but they had fantastic albums in the 70s
Childhood's End > Wot's uh the deal? 🫡🫡