Ranking EVERY 2D Mario Game WORST TO BEST (Top 15 Games)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 81

  • @charlesschofield4018
    @charlesschofield4018 Год назад +21

    15. Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels
    14. Super Mario Land
    13. New Super Luigi U
    12. New Super Mario Bros 2
    11. Super Mario Bros 2
    10. New Super Mario Bros U
    9. New Super Mario Bros Wii
    8. Yoshi's Island: Super Mario World 2
    7. Super Mario Bros
    6. Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
    5. New Super Mario Bros
    4. Super Mario Maker
    3. Super Mario Bros 3
    2. Super Mario Bros Wonder
    1. Super Mario World

    • @aloureirofurlan7378
      @aloureirofurlan7378 7 месяцев назад +7

      👆 This is not the ranking of the video

    • @WarioEnthusiast
      @WarioEnthusiast 6 месяцев назад +1

      thank you for the nsmb appreciation bro

    • @EthanTheFnFCharter_
      @EthanTheFnFCharter_ Месяц назад +1

      why is lost levels 15 but mario bros 7, that's just wild.

  • @JGr2000
    @JGr2000 8 месяцев назад +3

    Super Mario World was my favorite 2D Mario game for basically my entire life. I grew up with the GBA ports of the NES and SNES 2D Mario games, and I absolutely love Super Mario World to this day, but Wonder topped it for me personally. It’s so creative with the Wonder Flower events and the levels would still be great if they didn’t have Wonder events

  • @DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI
    @DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI Год назад +24

    Wonder is arguably the best Mario 2D game of all time but What holds it back for me is the the boss fights..having too fight Bowser JR multiple times just gets tedious.. some worlds don't even have boss fights which is crazy and not a fan of the elephant power up its okay but I can do without it but other then that its amazing

    • @ma_junia
      @ma_junia 10 месяцев назад +1

      Should've done a Yoshi's Island and given regular enemies a big wonder transformation

    • @Salute503
      @Salute503 10 месяцев назад

      I love the game it brought back Mario into my life. bought a switch OLED just for it. But I agree also I wish the music was more memorable

    • @superjumpbros64
      @superjumpbros64 2 месяца назад

      And the lack of true coop

  • @tommycwills
    @tommycwills Год назад +18

    Wonder is for sure my #1 and I’ve played all of these games as they’ve come out my whole life. It is finally the evolution this series has needed for like 30 years.

  • @Vishkala
    @Vishkala Год назад +10

    There's an absolutely fantastic mod for super mario land that ups the graphics a bit and colorized everything, fantastic mod

    • @Aaron-lr1di
      @Aaron-lr1di Год назад

      What's it called?

    • @Vishkala
      @Vishkala Год назад +1

      @@Aaron-lr1di super mario land DX

  • @luisrivera9506
    @luisrivera9506 Год назад +4

    1. Super Mario Bros 3
    2. Super Mario World

  • @NYYanks2003040506
    @NYYanks2003040506 Год назад +5

    Still not sure yet if I can say Wonder is better than World, because I keep thinking it might be recency bias, but it's real close. Both are phenomenal games. I've been a huge fan of World since I first played it at a friend's house during Christmas break 1992. Over 30 years of never getting bored with a game is a lot. Wonder will probably age gracefully as well.

    • @gentronseven
      @gentronseven 11 месяцев назад +1

      I don't see what people like so much about wonder to be honest. It's fine but not significantly better than any of the other new super mario bros games

    • @jclkaytwo
      @jclkaytwo 7 месяцев назад +1

      wonder beats world in pretty much every way imo. there's no question

  • @Livingtree32
    @Livingtree32 10 месяцев назад +2

    My Top 3 are 1. Yoshi’s Island, 2. Wonder, 3. World

  • @AlmightyBruce
    @AlmightyBruce 11 месяцев назад

    14: Super Mario Run
    13: Super Mario Land
    12: New Super Mario Bros. 2
    11: Mario Land 2
    10: Super Mario Wonder
    9: New Super Mario Bros. U
    8: New Super Mario Bros. Wii
    7: New Super Mario Bros.
    6: Super Mario Bros.
    5: Super Mario Bros. 2 - Japan
    4: New Super Luigi U
    3: Super Mario Bros. 2 - USA
    2: Super Mario Bros. 3
    1: Super Mario World

  • @WarioEnthusiast
    @WarioEnthusiast 6 месяцев назад

    My ranking: (also I won't rank Wonder because I haven't played it in ages)
    11: Lost Levels. Self explanatory.
    10: Super Mario Bros. Decent time, but controls are very clunky and the game's levels get far too difficult and tedious near the end for me to enjoy it after the first few worlds.
    9: New Super Mario Bros. Wii. It's alright! The multiplayer works decently (though I have only tried 2 player), but the biggest drawback for me is that the large focus on the simultaneous multiplayer makes the levels have tons of breathing room and be very empty throughout most of it.
    8: New Super Mario Bros. U. While the main game is a little worse than Wii due to the level designs getting worse at the last quarter of the game, the challenge mode and boost rush modes are JUST good enough for it to edge slightly above Wii.
    7: Super Mario Bros. 3. It's a good time on its own and very consistent, but the highs of the game aren't crazy good and the game is pretty overrated in my opinion.
    6: Super Mario World. The controls are alright, it looks nice, but my main issue is that the level designs are very flat and basic for the first maybe 3 quarters of the game.
    5: Super Mario Land. While it has definitely aged poorly and the controls aren't good, it is definitely playable and is generally a creative, memorable game with some pretty great levels that aren't afraid to experiment.
    4: New Super Mario Bros. 2. While the coin gimmick doesn't keep your attention throughout the game, the game is more creative than people give it credit for and the levels are genuinely some of the best in the series.
    3: Super Mario Bros. 2. Massively underappreciated, mainly due to it being a Doki Doki Panic reskin. The levels are pretty great and experimental to the game's benefit, it controls nice, and I like the graphics way more than I realistically should.
    2: Super Mario Land 2. Fantastic, just amazing. While not perfect and a little rough around the edges, what you have here is a fantastic and creative game with great levels, graphics, and core gameplay. However, the slowdown is just common enough to make me put it under...
    1: New Super Mario Bros. Just great. Not flawless in the slightest, but what you have here is a very solid game with great controls, graphics, levels, creativity, and that side content is just brilliant, the minigames are just fantastic.

  • @michaelhockaday7426
    @michaelhockaday7426 Год назад +2

    My list...
    #16 - Super Mario Run
    #15 - Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels
    #14 - Super Mario Land 2
    #13 - Super Mario Land
    #12 - Super Mario Bros
    #11 - New Super Mario Bros 2
    #10 - New Super Luigi U
    #9 - Super Mario Bros 2
    #8 - New Super Mario Bros DS
    #7 - New Super Mario Bros Wii
    #6 - New Super Mario Bros U
    #5 - Super Mario Maker 1 and 2
    #4 - Super Mario Bros Wonder
    #3 - Super Mario World
    #2 - Super Mario Bros 3
    #1 - Yoshi's Island - Super Mario World 2

    • @DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI
      @DIRTYSOUTHSHINOBI Год назад +1

      You put Yoshi Island above Wonder??? Let alone the best Mario 2D game?? Yeah I don't understand that at all it wouldn't even crack my top 10.. Yoshi Island is one of the few 2D Mario Games that has never held my attention I don't see the hype but too each ya zone

    • @michaelhockaday7426
      @michaelhockaday7426 Год назад

      @javonbatiste3294 yah. Wonder is good at #4 to me but just didn't make my top 3. Yoshis Island is above World even because the map in World for one thing is all blue, green, or brown. Even Mario U had more color. In World, world 3 and 7 have the same theme...underground. Did they run out of ideas? Yoshis Island has a lot of exploring and has a bit of everything. Mario Wonder and World both are a bit easy and felt unfinished to me. Plus the boss fights in both games suck. And putting Yoshi as the games easy mode in Wonder was a bad move.

    • @alibabaschultz352
      @alibabaschultz352 Год назад

      Solid list.

    • @kindlestix8079
      @kindlestix8079 Год назад

      If you include Yoshis island shouldn’t you include Wario land: super Mario land 3 as well

    • @michaelhockaday7426
      @michaelhockaday7426 Год назад

      @kindlestix8079 I didn't because the video didn't either. I wouldn't normally include Yoshis Island either but the video did, so I did as well.

  • @SarahsKnight0
    @SarahsKnight0 Год назад +2

    At #9 right now. Respect for your opinion, and I think you've made some good arguments so far, man.
    Still, I must say, for me personally Super Mario Land 1 is way better than the NES original despite similar graphics. I think Land has WAY better music, and way more interesting level design, especially with the changeup in gameplay where Mario can use a submarine and an airplane once.
    SMB1 on the NES for me actually had rather plain and even repetitive level design (levels 2-2 and 7-2 seem to be identical, actually, along with 2-3 and 7-3), and I think the soundtrack sucks overall (yes, I actually am not at all a fan of the base level 1-1 theme, and the castle track is just flat-out annoying), and bosses were all the same, just with an added obstacle on the bridge each time, or an extra attack from Bowser. The only thing I think Land 1 did worse than SMB1 was the fireball powerup. Land 1's "superball" was generally pretty useless with the way it bounces right in front of you.
    Respect for what SMB1 did, seemingly having a big hand in making home gaming popular again, but the game itself I think actually kind of sucks.

    • @StewNWT
      @StewNWT 11 месяцев назад

      yeah I agree. SMB1 is iconic but in retrospect it's def not as fun. SMB2 is the shit I will always stan it. As good as SMB3 is I just never connected with it - something about it feels soulless.

  • @michaelreardon303
    @michaelreardon303 2 месяца назад

    I used to think that lost levels had bad design; actually the level design isn’t bad at all, but so many Mario games have the gold standard of level design. The Sequel we got was exponentially better but honestly since most Mario side scrollers top off at about 7/10 difficulty it’s great for the hardcore Mario gamer

    • @michaelreardon303
      @michaelreardon303 2 месяца назад

      It’s also hard to design 52 more levels to a game that had 27 & 5 repeats. There definitely were some well designed Levels;
      1-1 1-2 2-1 5-1 5-3 7-1 7-3 8-2 8-3 8-4 World 9 is unique A-1 C-2 D-3
      B-4 might be one of the best designed warp zone placement in any Mario game that rewards you for focusing on every detail.

  • @danharrold6352
    @danharrold6352 Год назад +3

    Mario Land 2 is on NSO but Mario Land 1 is not currently

    • @anthonymanuel55000
      @anthonymanuel55000 Год назад +1

      Which really makes no sense they need to add 1. It’s the only 2d Mario I’ve never played

  • @adamwilson1691
    @adamwilson1691 Месяц назад

    the controls are stiff in Super Mario brothers? what are you talking about, they're spot on.

  • @c88rrado
    @c88rrado 16 дней назад

    20:05 yea! but also no... i lived through smb3. that was the real "new one"

  • @kindlestix8079
    @kindlestix8079 Год назад +1

    Tatanga has come back as a boss in Mario land 2

  • @bblovely7788
    @bblovely7788 6 месяцев назад

    I genuinely love the Lost Levels.

  • @Aaron-lr1di
    @Aaron-lr1di Год назад +1

    "kinda shite" never heard an american use the word shite before lol 32:35

  • @Mischler81
    @Mischler81 Год назад

    My top 3:
    1. New Super Mario Bros U Deluxe
    2. Super Mario Bros Wonder
    3. Super Mario World

  • @Victory-in-YAHUSHA
    @Victory-in-YAHUSHA 7 месяцев назад

    14. Mario Bros.
    14. Donkey Kong 1981
    13. SML
    12. TLL
    11. SMB1
    10. Mario Vs Donkey Kong
    9. SMB2
    8. Donkey Kong Remake (Game Boy)
    7. 6 Golden Coins
    6. NSMB1
    5. SMB3
    4. NSMB2
    3. NSMBW
    2. SMW
    1. NSMBU
    It will be a long time until I play Wonder.

  • @kagemara277
    @kagemara277 2 месяца назад

    this is sad to place Wonder as number 1, since for many players 2D MArio is about gameplay first, not visuals first. Wonder overwhelms with visuals so pleople overlook it, but its so streamlined and easy that it ruined that for me. World and SMB3 are leagues ahead in terms of gameplay, and I bet that in a few years, when the hype wears off, people will not praise it so highly. Also ditching the timer loses replayability of the game- with limitations comes creativity, and they could easily offer a timed levels fo increased challenge and leave it as a selectable option like in Tropical Freeze. SMB3 also has challenge just how we progress through the map, and how the player handles powerups, which could be lost while traveling on the map just adding extra challenge and thought to it. Wonder ditches all that and just creates a lot of visual noice so that younger players are amazed with visuals, and overlook what is essential. I remember in SMM2 even average levels that has 20-30% success rates were harder than the most challenging levels in Wonder. Wonder completely lacks any challenge exept for a few levels, which still arent too hard. Wonder is not a fair treatment of the franchise.

  • @peacefulcello
    @peacefulcello Год назад

    Tatanga returns in Super Mario Land 2 : 6 Golden Coins

  • @epicbww
    @epicbww 9 месяцев назад

    I always like to play the Japanese Super Mario Bros. USA instead of 2 because it just makes me laugh to see “USA” in the USA colors in a Mario game. Also, Mario 2 is the best 2D Mario game ever made.

  • @ozcet5641
    @ozcet5641 7 месяцев назад

    I think that s exactly why the lost levels are good, because mario bros is supposed to be difficult and not have that donkeyass easy new mario bros. Hard difficulty of the first one and the lost levels is what makes bros series a good one. Also super mario bros 1 is the no. 1 for me

  • @underatededits131
    @underatededits131 11 месяцев назад

    its a hard decision because wonder doesent have the koopalings, but it is definitely the most creative, i think new super mario bros wii is great tho

  • @KillswitchRobie828
    @KillswitchRobie828 Год назад +2

    Pretty decent list.

  • @loquopj
    @loquopj Месяц назад

    If you consider Yoshi's Island, you should have been consiered Yoshi's Island DS, New Yoshi's Island and so on. And probably Super Mario Bros. special (Sharo X1) amd SMB VS (arcade) should have been considered...

  • @4kcris293
    @4kcris293 11 месяцев назад

    Honestly i actually really like Lost levels. I beat the original using Luigi once.

  • @WaterLoggedStevemc
    @WaterLoggedStevemc 6 месяцев назад

    24:52 is wild
    💀
    🙏

  • @henveee
    @henveee 11 месяцев назад

    couldve sworn theres a few repeat wonder seeds?

  • @NateAnderson69
    @NateAnderson69 10 месяцев назад +2

    I've played through 90% of Wonder, and... Ehhh.
    Its defintely a fun game, and the Wonder effects are super cool, but... I don't know. I just don't think it's the second coming of Christ that people are making it out to be.
    The talking flowers, little flower-toads, and Prince Florian are all sooooo annoying.
    The game is pretty much constantly baby mode. I haven't died more than once in a single level, and it definitely lacks challenge.
    There are only 4 power ups in the game, and they're all pretty niche. The fire flower is just the fire flower, the bubble flower is cool in concept, but because everything is so gimicky, you never really get a chance to creatively use it, and the drill hat is more of a utility to interact with straight forward puzzles relating solely to the ability. The Elephant is awesome, though, and I totally love how it feels and how it's integrated into the game.
    The co-op feels cheapened in this game compared to previous ones, too.
    Honestly, if it wasn't for the fun Wonder mechanics, I probably wouldn't even consider this game in my top 7 2D Mario games.
    Mario 3 still reigns supreme, for me.
    To be positive, I really like the graphics, and I like how they feel like a modernization of Mario 2 and 3's design. That's really cool!

    • @kauffamn1016
      @kauffamn1016 8 месяцев назад

      My wife and I play wonder , we’re hooked on it . But my all time favorite is Smb3 for sure

  • @faresktari8977
    @faresktari8977 Месяц назад

    ( Im not gonna rank new super luigi U cuz Idk abt It and also yoshi’s island cuz I dont consider It a Mario game but a yoshi game)
    13. Super mario bros 2
    12. Super mario land
    11. Super mario bros the lost levels
    10. New super Mario bros 2
    9. Super Mario land 2
    8. New super Mario bros wii
    7. New super Mario bros U
    6. Super Mario bros
    5. New super Mario bros
    4. Super Mario bros Wonder
    3. Super Mario world
    2. Super Mario bros 3
    1. Super Mario maker 2
    Actually I Invert 10 and 11

  • @saradyson9534
    @saradyson9534 9 месяцев назад

    FINALLY NO GOD DAMN NOSTALGIA.EVERY OTHER RUclipsR PUTS 3 AND WORLD #1 CUZ OF NOSTALGIA.

  • @frumiousgaming
    @frumiousgaming Год назад

    You mentioned patreon but I can’t see a link in the description?

  • @StewNWT
    @StewNWT 11 месяцев назад +1

    HOW DARE YOU HAVE SMB2 so low!!!! seriously though that's some MF blasphemy right there - you did say good things about it though

    • @LolEleiteye
      @LolEleiteye 9 месяцев назад

      Fr idk why everyone always rates this game low out of all the og marios I've played (the nes ones so 1, 2, 3, and lost levels) this one is my favorite

  • @Gigimave
    @Gigimave Месяц назад

    Wonder is really great bit the recency bias is notable in this video and in the comments lol

  • @anordinaryuser5818
    @anordinaryuser5818 Год назад

    Great list

  • @tepidpit8737
    @tepidpit8737 8 месяцев назад

    30 minutes on the final four games?

  • @raisie6334
    @raisie6334 Год назад +7

    Recency bias hits really hard with Wonder in the fan scene. It's a fine game but it has some huge problems. There are so many filler levels and the pacing is really terrible. Why is there so much useless text between the levels? It can take several minutes (!) to reach the next level at certain parts of the game. This destroys the fun in replaying the game which made the other Mario games so good.

  • @CodyRyanWaz
    @CodyRyanWaz 6 месяцев назад

    19 the lost levels
    18 bros arcade
    17 donkey kong
    16 advance 3
    15 yoshi island
    14 run
    13 advance 2
    12 world
    11 bros 3
    10 all stars
    9 advance
    8 bros 2
    7 advance 4
    6 bros nes
    5 u
    4 land
    3 land 2
    2 maker 2
    1 wonder
    yea my ranking

  • @marioluigibros.8176
    @marioluigibros.8176 3 месяца назад

    luigi u and lost levels near the bottom are completely braindead

  • @Gavman_Gaming_09_79
    @Gavman_Gaming_09_79 7 месяцев назад

    Luigi U is better than most of the NSMB games, I hear it might be the best. Why is it the lowest.

  • @tonyp9313
    @tonyp9313 6 месяцев назад

    You're nuts if you think Super Mario Wonderer is the best 2D Mario game when it's probably 14th on that list.

  • @gracekim1998
    @gracekim1998 Год назад

    Hello again

  • @mrjoeyb717
    @mrjoeyb717 10 месяцев назад

    a lot of people dont like amer mario 2 cause its not a real mario game.....

  • @wdavis911
    @wdavis911 Год назад +42

    This video could’ve been so much shorter, dude just repeats himself over and over again

    • @marioprogamer12345
      @marioprogamer12345 Год назад +11

      You’re kinda right I’m alr bored after the first 6 mins lol

    • @gooeydude574
      @gooeydude574 Год назад +2

      Thanks for saving me the trouble of watching this video

    • @yoshitaxfraudosaurus
      @yoshitaxfraudosaurus 11 месяцев назад +4

      Review for the bad games
      "Its so bad its so bad i waste time"
      Review for good games
      "Its so good its SOOOOO good"

    • @chasedwyer5167
      @chasedwyer5167 11 месяцев назад +6

      @@yoshitaxfraudosaurusif that’s what u think u obviously didn’t watch the video

    • @fashie4968
      @fashie4968 5 месяцев назад

      I don't think he repeats himself so much but he definitely over explains each entry a bit too much. If he cut off 1 or 2 mins from each game he could still make the points he outlines.

  • @rangermansgaming7717
    @rangermansgaming7717 Год назад

    Should done chapter on video

  • @zeldabombsquad1144
    @zeldabombsquad1144 9 месяцев назад

    Sorry mate, I just can't keep hearing the same thing over and OVER again

  • @ehabgamesnow2154
    @ehabgamesnow2154 4 месяца назад

    Lost levels is good you are just noob man...and worse one is super mario bros 2

  • @WhatIfHis
    @WhatIfHis Год назад

    FIIIIIIIIIIRST also w vid