"India Should Revise Tibet Policy On China Occupation, Make Stance Clear On Dalai Lama's Succession"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- China Occupied Tibet
"India's position at that time (China's invasion of Tibet in 1950) was that the invasion was wrong. The matter should be settled peacefully. And Tibet has internal autonomy. Now, all this has been violated by China. So China has violated the basis on which India and others formulated their policies. It is time to revisit the issue." On 'The Gist', Ambassador Dilip Sinha speaks to StratNews Global Associate Editor Amitabh P. Revi. Ambassador Sinha is the author of the book 'Imperial Games In Tibet: The Struggle for Statehood And Sovereignty'. It is available in bookstores and online and will be officially launched in July. He has served as India's Envoy to the UN in Geneva, was the Former Head of the UN Division and Ex-Head of the PAI(Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran) Division at the Ministry of External Affairs.
"China Claims Everything"In his book, Ambassador Sinha also demolishes the CCP (Chinese Communist Party's attempts to rewrite history by claiming Tibet was always part of China. "China now claims that even Chinggis Khan was a Chinese. So they claim everything. But the Mongols were the first to rule over Tibet. Thereafter Tibet became independent. The Manchus conquered China in 1721. When the Manchu dynasty collapsed in 1912, Tibet declared independence. Tibet was independent until 1950 when Communist China invaded." Infact in history there were times when Tibetan rulers invaded China and captured the then capital.
Ambassador Dilip Sinha also discusses:
The recent U.S. bipartisan lawmakers' visit to the Dalai Lama in Dharamsala.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, NSA Ajit Doval and EAM Dr S. Jaishankar meeting the delegation subsequently.
The latest Tibet Act passed by both Houses in the U.S.
Whether the U.S. is firing off India's shoulders.
India's Tibet and China policy post-independence to the present.
The Great Game over Tibet.
China's renaming of locations in Tibet, Xinjiang and Arunachal Pradesh.
Debunking Chinese imperialism which is now presented as a CCP narrative of the so-called century of humiliation.
The criticality of the Dalai Lama's succession.
China crushing religion on one hand and usurping religious authority on the other.
Whether Xi Jinping fears religion.
What it will take for Tibet to be independent again.
And how India and Tibet helped preserve each others customs, traditions and manuscripts during invasions.
#Tibet #DalaiLama #China #India #US
Join Nitin Gokhale's Strategic Group WhatsApp Channel to get the latest updates from articles on our website and videos on our RUclips Channel: www.whatsapp.c...
Since many of our well-wishers requested a UPI payment id to contribute and support us, here’s the link, which gives us 100% of what you choose: stratnewsgloba...
You can also click and buy a RUclips Super Thanks(the heart icon where you liked this video), which directly supports StratNewsGlobal, with 70% of your chosen amount.
Leave your comments, questions, and feedback. Like and share our videos. Subscribe to our RUclips channel. Click on the 🔔icon to get notified of our latest uploads.
To get instant updates join our telegram circle - t.me/stratnews...
![NOSFERATU - Official Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters December 25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nulvWqYUM8k/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you StratNewsGlobal for hosting Honorable AMB Dilip Sinha. AMB Sinha's microscopic into the history and Geopolitics of Tibet's uncommon situation is most clear and unambiguous. Tibet has been belittled, abandoned, and treated like a Buzkashi trophy by the “Great Game” players. Little regard has been afforded the people of Tibet and her suffering, and AMB Sinha's book on Tibet hopefully shed a flood light on this sad issue, especially in Bharat, whom Tibetans consider to be their Guru. Congratulation on your new book release AMB Sinha and thank you for your support for Tibet.
.......India is chutiya, an American puppet(Ghulam) country and an expansionist country now so we hate India now.............
I guessed correctly, you are a Tibetan in exile in India, right? Strictly speaking, you are now an Indian. Do you want Tibetans to live like Indians (whose GDP per capita is less than one sixth of that of Tibet)?
Jai Tibet Jai Bharat . My motherland Bharat and Tibet my fatherland . free Tibet . Bharat Thankyou for your help to Tibetans
@kamanoble, there are 2 tibetan areas which are in india, southern tibet and sikkim. Why don't you try to secure the release of these 2 places for practice before talking about the tibetan areas within china 😊.
I personally do not respect Tibetan people who have migrated to India from Tibet! The people of the Tibetan camp in our Karnataka are harassing the local people a lot And they cut the legs of cows for food and then buy them to eat.
Thank you so much Ambassador Dilip Sina for supporting Truth and Tibetan Cause. 🙏🙏🙏
GDP per capita
2011 India US$1,458
2011 Tibet US$2,886
2021 India US$2,277
2021 Tibet US$8,157
For the US and the European powers, Tibet is just a negotiating point against China. For India, Chinese occupied Tibet will always be a threat to her sovereignty and territorial integrity. Playing 'Empire games' is to India's detriment, but a Free Tibet may be a boon to her.
GDP per capita
2011 India US$1,458
2011 Tibet US$2,886
2021 India US$2,277
2021 Tibet US$8,157
"Chinese data is all fake"
Li Keqiang 😂
@@jurmilotay6118 Where is India's high speed rail?
100% correct information,
He is a well inforned ex-Indian top diplomat fullt knows Tibetian history well,
He knows how the British interpret chinese history just like Palestine 😊. Look at kashmir, goa, assam, kalistan, tamil nadu, arunachal pradesh before pointing your fingers at others. It is not only the communists who are in disagreement with the british followed by the indian government, it was the Nationalist and the Qing dynasty as well. Basically, it is all chinese whether you are communist or not, is not important. The indian ex ambassador only have western perspectives, looks like you are a bunch of thoroughly colonised people 😊.
@@gwo-shyanhan1188 On the one hand, Indians hate the British Empire for enslaving Indians, but on the other hand, they say they inherited the (colonial) legacy of the British Empire (so great, my British Empire daddy). It's confusing.
@@snowlee-ml7rr that i am afraid is the colonised mentality. 😊🙏
India also earned her latest medal for being the “Scammers of the World” title, so being labeled “No Shame” is an understatement and a proud Indian achievement and long-term tradition.
FREE TIBET
Jai Bharat jai Tibet Tibet ki aazadi Bharat ki surak sha save Tibet free India History Tibet is peace full country thank you
If Qing/Manchuria and Yuan/Monggol isn't part of China history than Mughal/Islam isn't part of India 🇮🇳 history 🤣 Nice logic lil bro
Very good effort by our ex Ambassador
Totally right Tibet will always remain and there for Tibets freedom is worlds peace
Tibet is free. China liberated it.
Tibetans are happy and prosperous now. They live in an autonomous province with their own government. They do not need outside interference.
💐❤️💐❤️🙏🙏🙏
Few people in India might know that when India and China established diplomatic relations, there was a secret agreement regarding Tibet: India agreed to cease supporting the Dalai Lama's anti-China activities, while China agreed to stop supporting separatists within India. Therefore, India needs to understand that it does not have many cards to play regarding Tibet, with the main reason being the significant disparity in military and economic power between the two countries. Abandoning the meaningless obsession with Tibet is the best choice for India. After all, before the British unified India, there was no such country, and there was no talk of sovereignty over Tibet.
On the one hand, Indians hate the British Empire for enslaving Indians, but on the other hand, they say they inherited the (colonial) legacy of the British Empire (so cool, my British Empire daddy). It's confusing.
Tibet belongs to Tibetans. Truth always comes out in the end. It’s a matter of time. People of conscience needs to stand up for truth and justice. Standing up for truth benefits everybody in the long run. Thank you for this interview and the book. Thank you India🙏
Tibet is never free . It is part of hindu akhand bharat empire.
Black looters will take over
@@biggpicture2930 And China claims Akhand Bharat is Thiers since Ancient times.
Sorry to say this but it's truth. You can't get Tibet back by just writing and being refugees. You must have fighting spirit Which Tibetans lack. Tibetans love to take refuge in western countries rather than fighting for their motherland. Sad... Now , Tibetans are minority in their own Tibet because all the able body Tibetans fled their country and seen many of them working as a dish washers, Amazon workers e.t.c . Stay in your country and fight !! ha ha , otherwise it's a dream only
Tibetans are cruel and they are cutting the legs of cows of poor farmers of Karnataka for food! Please get out of my state 🙏
Quite a lot of bots in the comments section.
yes。like u a Indian bots
Tang Dynasty (Han=Chinese)-(618-907 AD)- Tibet invaded China
Yuan Dynasty (Mongols / not-Chinese)-(1279-1368 AD) - Genghis khan & his clans invaded China and Tibet
Manchu/Qing Dynasty (Manchu/ not Chinese)-(1644-1911) - Manchurian invaded China and Tibet.
While the Yuan and Qing empires exerted some influence over Tibet, the region consistently governed and appointed its political and spiritual leaders autonomously. Tibetan civilization, language, religion, value systems, medicine, culture, adaptability to high altitudes etc. are distinctly unique and nothing to do with Chinese civilization or Chinese history.
Interesting, are Manchu people still citizens of China?
@@tibetanchineseofchina Currently, the Manchu and the majority of Tibetans are citizens of China, having no other option. However, the oppressed Tibetans never accept nor admire Chinese culture, its distorted value system, or the Chinese government, despite being forced to do so over time. The moment the oppressed start admiring the oppressor's culture, it marks the beginning of their downfall. Otherwise, citizenship is merely a legal tag that changes as time progresses, as seen with the current waves of massive immigration. The rich Tibetan civilization, culture, and value systems are based on intellect and compassion, have every strength to survive and flourish.
@@ten-zin868 I don't think you're born in China, aren't you?
You said "Tibetan civilization, language, religion, value systems, medicine, culture, adaptability to high altitudes etc. are distinctly unique and nothing to do with Chinese civilization or Chinese history."
Here's what the 14th Dalai Lama stated, you don't agree with him then?
"Tibetan culture and Buddhism are part of Chinese culture." -- Written by the 14th Dalai Lama, March 15, 2005
Do you know princess Wenchen?
Poem written by 陈陶 (AD 812－AD885）: “自从贵主和亲后，一半胡风似汉家”，
Translation: "Since marriage (Wenchen and Songtsen Gampo), half of customs (of Tubo (吐蕃)) are now same as those of the Han people.
Historical records show that that Princess Wencheng's dowry included "Buddha statue, treasures, gold and jade bookcases, 360 volumes of classics, and various gold and jade ornaments", as well as a lot of cooking food, various drinks, and brocade quilts with various patterns, 300 kinds of divination classics, 60 kinds of construction and engineering books, 100 kinds of medical prescriptions for 404 kinds of diseases, 4 kinds of medical treatises, 5 kinds of diagnostic methods, and 6 kinds of medical instruments, also various grains and turnip seeds, etc.
Under her influence, the Han people's milling, textile, pottery, papermaking, winemaking and other technologies were gradually introduced to Tubo (吐蕃); the poems, agricultural books, Buddhist scriptures, history books, medical books, calendars and other classics she brought with her promoted the tremendous development of Tubo's economy and culture.
Without milling, how do you make Tibetan momo (Baozi or Jiaozi)?
When Songtsen Gampo saw the clothing brought in by Wencheng, he changed his clothing (氈裘) immediately.
Do you know history of the Dalai Lama? Do you know it's high official of China who created the Dalai Lama title? Do you know Seal of Authority granted by Central Government of China since the creation of the Dalai Lama title?
Indians are really ignorant of the real history. They fabricate a history that they believe in. Historical nihilism is rampant in India.
Tibet ka asaadi, Bharat ka suraxk-sha
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS CLEAR MESSAGE ON TIBET ❤
Thank you so much Sh.AMB Dilip Sinha sir for telling nthe world truth about Tibet & Tibetans 🎉 Heartiest Congratulations to your newly published book on Tibet, eagerly looking forward to have one earliest 🎉😊Thugjeychenang
Fully support Free Tibet. Tibetan people are our brothers. Bharat owes them a big apology for allowing China to occupy Tibet. One China Policy is ‘bull*hi*’ at must be rescinded. Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
You should ask the Chinese Tibetans whether they agree or not. Do you think the Chinese Tibetans share the same religion as India??? The current Tibetan population in China has changed. They pursue modern life. Are you talking about freedom??? It's really funny.
@@印度印度True! India must show itself first that it is capable to organise its own self properly and thoroughly, and that everyone in India can equally enjoy prosperity and peace, then talk about organising other parts of the world.
How much india want to suffer or betreyed by the china , history tells very peaceful border with Tibet not China, Tibet ki azadi Bharat ki suraksha
I thank the viewer who has pointed out the error in my statement. The Manchus conquered Tibet, not China, in 1720, they had conquered China in 1644.
I think you're somehow wrong in your statement. The military expedition of the Qing of China was to expel the invasion of the Dzungars. The Dzungars invaded Lhasa in November of 1717 and killed Lha-bzang Khan of Khoshut Khanate in the first place. In 1718 October, Kangxi Emperor started to send military to Tibet to expel the Dzungars, and in 1720, the Dzungars were expelled. Khoshut Khanate formally became part of Qing in 1654, seal of authority and golden sheets were granted in that year by China, and Güshi Khan immediately expressed his gratitude:
“皇上勝過締造萬物之如意寶，布仁慈於四海之濱；揚善抑惡，以足眾生之望。蒙天恩賞賜金冊、金印，封為遵行文義慧敏顧實汗，謹望闥跪接祗領，叩謝天恩。”
For the Dalai Lama, following the tradition of granting seal of authority from the Central Government starting right from the first (3rd) Dalai Lama in Ming Dynasty (1587), in 1720, the seaI of authority was also granted for the 7th Dalai Lama.
The Manchus are a minority ethnic group in China. They were once citizens of the Ming Dynasty (a Han Chinese regime). Nurhaci, the founder of the Qing Dynasty, was a local official of the Ming Dynasty. The Manchus today are no different from the Han Chinese, except for their ethnicity on their ID cards. And they are more patriotic than the Han Chinese.LOL
Great interview
Tibet’s freedom is India’s security
GDP per capita
2021 India US$2,277
2021 Tibet US$8,157
Maybe there is a thing or two you can learn from them?
This is a very interesting channel
99% of Han Chinese people never had any contact with Europeans in the 19th century so how exactly were they "humiliated"? The humiliation, if there was any of, was of the Manchu empire... but as this gentleman says, the Europeans helped prop up the Manchu during the Taiping rebellion which was a Han revolt against them.
If the Japanese had toppled the British Raj, would the Indians have been "humiliated"? (It would be nice if Indians would recognise the role Indian elites played in the formation of the Raj. I don't really see how a small country from 4000 miles away with 1/20th the population can conquer a vast country without internal help)
It was the subsequent collapse of that Manchu empire which allowed the Han to take control of "China". So again, how exactly were they humiliated? As far as I can see, this narrative is a) about a deep inferiority complex vis a vis the West, b) a device to bind the Chinese people to the CPC and c) to justify the continued occupation of Tibet, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia etc.
Free Tibet
Make India great again
I am so happy that the Indian intellectual elites are now fully informed about Tibet’s pass independent history, its current political situation and future significance for both Tibet and India!
@@Skygoers British India militarily conquered North East India. The current India should renounce its control and let the region be independent.
CCP troll, you have no clue of indian history and the very concept of how indians interpret it.
So he is a intellectual elite in India? more like a low class intellectual clown when he could not even state the correct time in history.
Indians are really ignorant of the real history. They fabricate a history that they believe in. Historical nihilism is rampant in India.
心比天高，命比纸薄😂
🤣
💐💐💐💐💐💐💐 JAI BHARAT JAI HIND Free TIBET
Tibet was independent nation and will be independent.
Hahaha
Are you saying the hundreds of pre-British kingdoms were independent nations and will be independent again? Including the Khalistan, Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram, Manipur, and Nagaland?
in your daydream
If China of the Mongol and Ching dynasties were not China of today. Is colonial India equal to modi's India?
India of today have British empire for credit as the British gave what is now modern India . In India you have parts of Tibet , Myanmar, in fact the whole of northern East of India that even the mughal failed to take by force.
If all countries give away parts that were united long ago ., no nation of today will be the same . The United states will only be for native Indian Americans, no blacks , no European, no Asians .
USA Govt's initiating a Tibet Resolve Act, made India talking, even if half of the World, following the same policy in favour of Tibet, India would still be in a discussion mode.Keep talking but Do not Harm,if cannot help.
Thank you stratsnews for bringing this up in the media. Appreciate and gratitude to both sides!
So, now the next book for this author is to revise the legality of U.S. land back to the American Indians? 😅😅😅
Actually the US has vast reservations for American Indians which have real autonomy.
@@MaTara01how if some still barely have water
CCP PROPAGANDA.
@@MaTara01LOL
Free Tibet, Jai Bharat
Thank you sir.What a true voice!🙏
Everything is fair in love and war ! It is up to India to defeat China and do what you want. Politics has no morals.
Jai bharat jai Tibet. Free Tibet
Indian fantasy is reaching a new level 😂😂
Thank you India ❤
Try not to interfere in China internal affairs regarding the Tibet, Xinjiang and Taiwan and South China Seas.
China has been very patience with those countries poking their nose in China affairs.
India will not like it when China starts to interfere in India affairs, like the Punjab, Kashmir & Jamu, Khalistan and other disputed areas in North East India.
As for US there are many territories that are illegally occupied. Don't get upset when China turn the tables.
Indians overestimate themselves. Indians think they are at the table, but in the eyes of Westerners, India is on the plate.
will be interesting if NE indians randomly found arms in the forest.
Why chines interfer manchus;mongols-tibetens;xinziang;kzikistann;tiwan;banking;philipiens;lndia?mao;chowanli;xiping aren't heros to the world
Very Constructive Discussion And Knowledge.
After all is said and done, China-Tibet is still China-Tibet .... BTW, it is time to Free India! -- Free Hindustan, Free South India, Free Northeast 7-Sister states! ... Free India!
Tibet Was Never a Part of China. Long Live His Holiness The Dalai Lama
@@dawatsering2775 British India militarily conquered North East India. The current India should renounce its control and let the region be independent.
Dalai lama admited tibet as Chinese... It is world knowledge
is Dalai Lama a slave master?
Northeast India like Nagaland, Manipur, Mizoram, Arunachal Pradesh and Ladakh also not a part of India in olden times.
Free Tibet ✊✊✊
Don't have your demand in India, go to Tibet and shout
India needs to cooperate with China to accelerate its transformation into a global manufacturing power, with seamless integration with global supply chain.
It has long been China's stance that "Put the border disputes aside, let us cooperate on everything else. "
An emerging power like India cannot let its development be kidnapped by border disputes.
Look at Japan and S. Korea. These two East Asia neighbors can sit down for negotiations and cooperations, despite of their long time disputes over the sovereignty of the Liancourt Rocks in the sea between them. That is political wisdom and diplomatic maturity on full display.
Other countries such as China and India can definitely learn from S. Korea and Japan to manage their difference on borders, LAC, or whatever, and develop their relationship for the benefit of the economy and people.
The US, with its dirty "divide and conquer" tricks, doesn't want to see BRICS countries developing fast together. They'd rather see the two neighboring Asian giants fighting, hurting and weakening each other, to maintain their domination in Indo-Pacific for their own geopolitical interests.
Only morons will fall into the traps of confrontation and conflicts pushed by the US.
But won’t China then revise their policy on Khalistan, Kashmir, Dravidia, and India occupied Burmese territories in the North East?
You are such a great scholar - how do you not know that Dravidia has already declared independence from India? 🤔
@@MaTara01 the BJP wants to impose Hindi on Tamil speakers. This is the beginning of Tamil independence and the founding of Dravidia.
@@Nom_AnorVSJediReally? Do you know how a real democracy like India functions? Let me just tell you - I have several Tamil friends, all of who speak & understand Hindi. There's no need for BJP to impose anything. Very strange that BJP just wants to impose Hindi on Tamil Nadu and not in any other southern state.
By the way, why is CCP destroying the use of Tibetan, Mongolian and Turkic languages in China? Tibet, East Turkistan and Inner Mongolia should declare independence from China, just as Taiwan has.
@@MaTara01 does India allow Kashmir to vote for independence? What about Khalistan, what happens when Sikhs ask for independence, they get a visit from RAW agents! Democracy right?
If Tibetans, Turks, Mongols, Taiwan gave the right to declare independence, doesn’t China have the right to crush independence? Don’t rights go two ways, not one way.
India will break up soon, with Modi weakened, all the castes, religions and ethnic and language groups will declare independence soon enough. Therefore India needs China’s support to keep things together in the face of American interference to break up India.
@@Nom_AnorVSJedi Do you know how convoluted your logic is? If you are China's brightest, then I am effing delighted!! You can blah blah blah all you like about India, I am hearing only the bleating of sheep! 🤣
We knew all but what next . All countries should recognise Tibet as an Independent Country.
Is southern Tibet a free independent country or taken by India?
Part-II: Indian PM Pandit Nehru….. -> ”We Can’t Support Save Tibet Independent”. ~And America 🇺🇸 Never Fight with China “For Tibet Independent.” Also Plead to UNO No responses. 👉 Better is You Go Back and Talk with China 🇨🇳.
और PM Pandit Nehru ने Dalai Lama को ….. आप आज़ादी के लिए आंदोलन मत करना से अच्छा होगा। इसे आप फिलहाल भारत के मेहमान तरह बनकर रहना।
Q: कब तक भारत के मेहमान तरह बनकर रहना चाहिए उनको ? तिब्बत को पूरा नष्ट य ख़त्म होने तक ? PM Pandit Nehru to the Dalai Lama….. You would be better off not agitating for freedom Movement. For the time being, you should live like a guest of India.
Q: Now How long to stay he guests of India ? Until Tibet is completely destroyed or annihilated ? 😂😂😂😅
Q: Kya India’s Brutal than China 🇨🇳 ?
Sir please we want to hear more on Tibet
... So, now every Indian today has become a "Tibet-China Expert" in Indian Talk-shows ?!! ... ha ha ha
Hindustan jindabad 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai dlailama
Free Tibet🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
my spirit as a Tibetan.. grew when I borne.. our roots is strong.. a few branches waving couldn’t shake the roosts as a Tibetan .. Tibet is not china
Manchu conquered China in 1720? What sort of historian are you? Manchu (Qing Dynasty) entered Beijing the then Chinese capital in April 1644 and defeated the last Ming Dynasty Loyalist in 1683 as it conquered Taiwan. Tibet was part of Qing Empire in 1680 and China's position on Tibet was a direct inheritance of Qing and also during republic of China. The old Republic of China has a five stripe flag with each color stripes represent major ethnic groups in the country. If this guy is an UN envoy then it show case why India is a country that nearly nobody respect because he does not even know the history of the countries involved with Tibet. He certainly had high profile roles but his understanding of history is reflect low understanding of history.
中國幾個政權相繼不遵守清室優待條例,同時也就失去了繼承清朝領土的資格。現在中國對西藏,新疆,滿洲的佔領都不是繼承清朝領土,而是私自用武力佔領
中國不能繼承中國，有資料來源嗎？
🐸
@@tibetanchineseofchina 他妈被印度人轮奸了，让让吧
Thank you sir
Very interesting.... Thanks
India should use its diplomatic and army power to free Tibet . People of Tibet is with India.
Oh, India? 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
talk talk no action...
@@jetli740 I hope Indians will read it carefully and experience it with their hearts. The huge difference in the founding of China and India is destined to be the biggest difference between India and China. Just look at the modern history of the two countries and you will understand. India was colonized by Britain for more than 200 years. In 1947, Britain experienced World War II, its strength declined greatly, and its status was replaced by the United States. India took the opportunity to gain independence through "non-violent non-cooperation". In other words, India's independence has not experienced the test of blood and fire. Such an independent country has no cohesion and willpower, and no national identity. Now let's talk about China. Since Britain defeated the corrupt and incompetent Qing government in 1840, the Chinese people have been living in dire straits. Various disasters and wars followed one after another. At that time, China was very poor and backward, and suffered all kinds of humiliation. Including the cession of Hong Kong and Macau, Taiwan became a Japanese colony, the burning of the Old Summer Palace by the Eight-Power Allied Forces, and the subsequent comprehensive and brutal invasion of China by Japan. In 1931, Japan launched a full-scale invasion war against China. From 1931 to 1945, the war lasted for 14 years. The Chinese army and civilians rose up to resist, fought bloody battles for 14 years, and suffered 30 million casualties, but finally won. Do you know why China suffered so many casualties? There are hundreds of reasons. I will only give one example: when the Chinese troops encountered the Japanese army, it was often the case that if there were 100 Chinese soldiers in the battle, the Chinese soldiers only had 20 to 30 guns. The remaining soldiers would not give up resistance or surrender. They used machetes, steel forks, and wooden sticks to bravely fight against the machine guns and cannons in the hands of the Japanese army until they died. This spirit of facing death and never retreating is the Chinese spirit. 30 million casualties! Do you think this can happen in India? For India, there are zero casualties, because India's knees are soft. India will give up resistance soon. Do you know why there is "Nanjing"? Because of the desperate resistance of the Chinese army and civilians, never surrendering and never giving up. After Japan broke through Nanjing, it was first to vent its anger, and secondly to scare off other Chinese soldiers and civilians who were resisting. But all this not only did not scare off any Chinese, but further aroused the Chinese people's resistance. The founding of New China was a test of blood and fire. Do you know why the Chinese national flag is red? That's because the founding of New China was paid for by countless Chinese ancestors with their blood, and we Chinese will always remember it. From 1945 to 1949, there was a civil war in China, and the Kuomintang fled to Taiwan. Originally, the Chinese people thought they could live a long-awaited peaceful life, but in 1950, the Korean War broke out and lasted for three years. The Chinese Volunteer Army successfully resisted the US route to the north without air superiority, sea superiority, backward army equipment, and extremely poor logistics, and our price was the loss of hundreds of thousands of brave PLA soldiers. In 1962, in the eyes of us Chinese, it was not a war at all. First of all, the time was only 32 days, and secondly, from 1959 to 1961, China experienced the most difficult three years since its founding, and many people starved to death in China during these three years. In 1962, India's economy far surpassed China. The United States, the Soviet Union, and Britain all supported India. At that time, India implemented the "Forward Policy" and attacked China with elite troops. We Chinese really don't want to fight. The Chinese troops that fought with India in 1962 were ordinary border defense troops, not regular PLA. In China, soldiers are called "the most lovely people". There is a Chinese proverb: Without a country, there is no home. Soldiers are the backbone of the country. Thanks to our brave People's Liberation Army soldiers, who are always ready to defend the borders of the motherland. No matter how India's military develops, it can't surpass China. Whether in the past, present or future, China can always defeat India. This is determined by the history and culture of the two countries. The Chinese people pay attention to the spirit of dedication and sacrifice. Don't surrender, don't yield, fight to the death, and see death as home on the battlefield. It is a huge shame for Chinese soldiers to surrender on the battlefield, and the spirit of dying rather than surrendering is deeply engraved in the bones of every Chinese. These are not possessed by Indians. Therefore, even now or in the future, India will never be able to defeat China. Now, do you think India can stand in the world like China? Absolutely not.
Lmao
@@mingmuyiyang8615 CN fight the US in korean war, with limited weapon and no air support and they still hold the US back..
that all we need to know.
Indian have a fist fight at the border and they make it a big deal
CIA provided fund for Tibet rebellion and India provided sanctuary for Tibet separatists.
Tibet was never part of china.
😂😂 it was part of India
Tibetans are not native to India so please go away from here
Has anything the British had touched ever not been a major f up around the world? Just wondering.
The LIE LAMA
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
India is the only country in the world who knows the history of Tibet very well.Now time has come india to revise Tibet policy without feeling external pressure from China or any Chinese allied nations..
British India militarily conquered North East India. The current India should renounce its control and let the region be independent.
Free the North East, Kashmir and Khalistan !.
@@pikachus5m166 CCP bots. 😄😄😄
@@slomo4672 so you're from North East dreaming like Mao.
@@dorjeebhutia9238 Not a bot, just someone who clearly sees through the never lit beacon of democracy that is India.
Thank you
Congratulations AMB Dilip Sinha on your invaluable work on Tibet! Tibet was independent until Communist China invaded it in 1949. It is high time for the government of India to review its stand on Tibet and support it's struggle for independence.
I am not discriminating against you. Indians have this strength?
Very informative 😊 Hope politician give some space for morality in the mist of geopolitics. Because Tibet struggle is peacefull persistent and Wise .
this country is a laughing stock of the world, haha :)) with all this kind "scholars",
India actually tried to get into Tibet since 1960s , but failed miserably all the time, they still remember 1962, and 2020, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ...........",. well, you are really very very welcome to try again.
The Chinese are not bold enough to try again. This time it is Not 1962.
Xi is very well aware of that.
@@harryblack879 seems you do not ready things carefully, it is in 2020, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ...........
@@harryblack879 what a BS logic, China is not in 1962 either, only 5 times more stronger than India compare to 1962
China must start having policies for Kashmir, Khalistan, Ladakh, Sikkim and the entire stolen North East. Fund some think tanks, provide safe haven for indian separatists in Tibet and arm them if necessary. Of course, some bills must also be passed.
You must be left liberal pervert
No harm in having dreams and nightmares🛑
@@gopalramanathan7062 Are you sure? Because those groups he mentioned above are causing more harm to Indians in terms of life, material, and stability, more than any so-called anti-China groups in China. Imagine if China did the same thing as India did by hosting separatist Indians in China. India would be in chaos like the Middle East. within a year
China should promote and facilitate Indias return to 600 separate maharaja states, all this Bharat bs about some mythical past is so infantile.
The ravings and ramblings of the miserable Communist Party thugs, the dregs🛑
Why don't hediscuss about india sovereignty first.
Every natio same same,encroach on weaker stare that include India.
India should act right now to China on Tibet Act. Both the speakers spoke boldly that Tibet is not part of China . When America passed the resolution why can’t India. India is too timid on China when t comes Tibetan issue.
it is very simple,India is not the US, Delih is 400 km from China border, within the range of China's long range rocket artillery, not saying missiles, the US is more than 10000 km away, certainly you can try, but past showed, all did not work well for India, as shown in Oct 10th 2021, The Express Tribune, with title "Indians furious. ..........."
india want to be ukraine 2?
British India militarily conquered North East India. The current India should renounce its control and let the region be independent.
CCP should renounce it’s control of Tibet and let the region be Independent.
1000 years Tibet is not China. It sounds like blackmail to hold Tibet as a pawn between India and china or the west. They clearly have a dynamic, long history of language, culture, tradition and religion. If Tibet was part of China what was China's religion then, Buddhist? What happened to the Buddhist religion then in China in ancient times? What are the linguistic, cultural and religious linkages? We understand what happened after Mao.
South Tibet is already part of China's Sovereignty ... The current status is only lease-rental to India for Development and why not? .. after the 50-year lease is up no more renewal.
South Tibet is already part of China's Sovereignty ... current status is only lease-rental to India for Development and why not? .. after the 99-year lease is up no more renewal.
21:19 this guy's knowledge of the Dalai Lama reincarnation system is quite limited, no mention of the traditional Golden Urn process, no mention of the traditional approval from the Central Government of China, no mention of the creation of the Dalai Lama, no mention of the authorization of authority from China for the Dalai Lama. That guy's view is limited, no need to waste time and $ on his book.
India must modify the Indo- chin five mutual agreement in 1954 under unknown by the Tibetan Government.
India never gained till today by bowing their head under the CCP's aggression so now the time comes to get their head up and look for future long-lasting matter of India rather seeking temporary profit.
Congratulations Dilip Sinha sir on your new book release..👍
The province of Tibet-China's GDP-per-capita is much higher than any Indian State of similar land mass and population density. The Tibetans living in China are well off living longer and richer than any average Indian today, why would any smarter Tibetan-Chinese want to give up their good life, and join the poorer Indians & Tibetan separatists to suffer in India? ... Is this freedom or slavery in poor and under-developed India?
The province of Tibet-China's GDP-per-capital is much higher than any Indian State of similar land mass and population density. The Tibetans living in China are well off living longer and richer than any average Indian today, why would any smarter Tibetan-Chinese want to give up their good life, and join the poorer Indians & Tibetan separatists to suffer in India? ... Is this freedom or slavery in poor and under-developed India?
Jai Hin Jai. Tibet ❤️❤️💐💐🔥👏🙏🙏
Long live his holiness the great 14th Dalai Lama 🙏🙏🙏🏵️🏵️🏵️🌼🌼🌼🌷🌷🌷🌺🌺🌺🌹🌹🌹💐💐💐🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️
Every people sport free Tibat Agitation
Thank you 🙏
Tibet was a good buffer state between India and China which was actually useful in keeping good relations between these two nations
That book should b read by all. Thank you
India should understand very deeply of the concept what CCP consideration of their Tibet autonomous region and there should be differences what India look on Tibet autonomous region.
A middle way approach also seeking Tibet as a fully autonomous region so one name of autonomy described in a different views.
With due respect to the ambassador and his perspectives on Tibet's history , I can't help but feel that there's a lot more he knows but is not talking about it for various reasons. He's merely repeating western narratives on the situation and interpreting truth to fit those narratives. Unfortunately, HH the Dalai Lama was too young and totally unprepared to be responsible to take on such a big secular role when it was pushed upon his shoulders at 16 years of age instead of focussing solely on being the spiritual leader that he was and still is. He was easily manipulated by the Brits and the Americans and got caught up with the machinations of politics and geopolitics from which he could not extricate himself from, declaring too late that he'd be happy for Tibet to be an autonomous region within China.
The fact is clear for all to see that today, Tibet and Tibetans are living a much better quality of life and a better standard of living than they'd ever been.
The reason why Tibet is back in the news again is purely because of the US's need to distract the world and to try to encircle China in their futile effort to " contain" China's rapid growth fast overtaking them to be inevtiably, the world's No.1 economy.
Very much the same playbook in stirring up the status of Taiwan, the South China Sea with Philippines etc. And now India is being conveniently led into being a stooge and proxy for the US as well in this geopolitical game.
Brian Berlectec in his regular commentary on geopolitics on RUclips entitled The New Atlas, has done a very well researched segment supported with lots of factual evidence to explain how the US had been meddling into the domestic affairs of China as well as Tibet and other countries to advance their own interests as the global al hegemony. Check this out and form your own opinions. instagram.com/reel/C8uL6h9Bq7t/?
Dilip Sinha have Many many prejudices.
Thanks so much for the real truthful interviews🙏🙏🙏, populations of Tibet is too less compared the Area’s, Youtsang, Kham & Amdo, it’s vast lands, maybe similar India, thanks for your support for truths and justice, World should help us, if Tibet free, world will become peaceful & Happy, you must read book My Land My Peoples. Thanks 🎉🎉🎉
H.Holiness, The great Dalai Lama immediately after reaching in exile india wrote the book, My land and My people 🙏
@@TenzinKunphel-yf3vr your H.Holiness said,
"We want to live in peace with our Chinese brothers and sisters," the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader told a news conference in the western city of Bochum on the second day of a visit to Germany.
"We are not seeking independence," but merely greater autonomy and more respect for Tibet culture, religion and language, he said.
Tibet is not part of of china
pity is nobody gives a fk what you think or believe, your government said, Tibet is a part of China.
Kashmir is not part of India. The British militarily conquered it. Let it be independent.
@kalsangnangchen7464, the Dalai Lama does not agree with you.
"Tibet is a part of the People's Republic of China. It is an autonomous region of the People's Republic of China. Tibetan culture and Buddhism are part of Chinese culture." -- Written by the 14th Dalai Lama, March 15, 2005
Tibetan refugees are also not Indians! They should respect the local people or they should leave India and go to Tibet.
I am not from China either i am fro India but opinion is India shouldn’t be obsess with Tibet and try to be an international policeman like USA and interfere with other countries affairs. There is already enough wars in this world and India shouldn’t try to start another unnecessary war. That is my advice to India because the best business is to mind your own business. India should focus on their economic progress, development and growth. Since India independence, India GDP are at least at par with China if not a little bit bigger but now China have a economy 5 times larger than India. So India should be focus on their economy growth and catch up with China instead of obsess with Tibet issues.
Insightful conversation. Thanks for this amazing program on Tibet.
Pretty useless interviewee that interpret according to his own understanding!
Who care about India perspective?
for this history scholar, in 1860, the Southern US claimed independence and found the federation, then Lincoln led the north army "invaded" the South, and occupied the south, with this "scholar"s logic, all the south should be out of the US, ,
Thank you so much India and it's people for taking care of Tibetans. Jai hind.
How long will you stay here harassing the local people in our country? We don't want you, go to your Tibet country.
Tibet is never part of China
No, Xizang is a part of China, forever.
Sorry, you're against the Dalai Lama.
"Tibet is a part of the People's Republic of China. It is an autonomous region of the People's Republic of China. Tibetan culture and Buddhism are part of Chinese culture." -- Written by the 14th Dalai Lama, March 15, 2005
You people do not belong to India you people are just eating free food here we don't want crazy Tibetans.
Do these people really know Tibet and China or talking nonsense