From 2015 until now, they have improved so much. 🥹 They truly proved their name of being the nation’s gg of 3rd gen. They have really come so far. 😭 9 years and they are still together.
@@kpopworld2148I am a HUGE Sana bias but even I can agree that Sana still has some mishaps 😭 She’s good but she definitely isn’t as stable as the other 4
So impressed with the J line here, maybe the challenge they have with MISAMO really makes them give their best with singing, so happy to be a Once! I love 9 of them!
1:51. That vibrato when she’s clearly out of breath. I love my girls. Tzuyu voice is improving so much over the years. Our hidden vocal harmonizing queen
@@Verowinday777 lolll !!! Yh, she’s less stable in this performance, but sometimes she is very loud! This range is just not that comfortable for her! Watch Go Hard, Dahyun’s low tone is audible even over the backtrack! She’s incredible.
I wonder why antis and haters fail to recognise TWICE’s IMMENSE talent (that’s been obvious from day one in their iconic debut). Twice has 3Mix that are all literal main vocalists. Does any other group have that?? Tzuyu is a lead vocalist atp, and so is Mina. Sana would be too in any other group! Chae is a very good vocalist as well!!! And Momo is so loud now, and Dahyun is a good singer too! Obviously, they are rappers, so it’s clear that’s what they’re more comfortable with!
Me duele decirlo pero Dahyun vocalmente aqui no destaco nada, se la escuchaba sin aire y algo fatigada, aunque al final con 'Don't lose this spark baby' remonto algo😢
Jihyo still main for official.. but i think if there is reposition, Jihyo and Nayeon will be the main vocalist.. tzuyu lead vocalist, and Jihyo can be the lead dancer too.. Just my opinion.. 😊
예전엔 지효가 더 성량 크다고 느꼈는데 나연이 득음해서 걍 넘사됐네 성량 발성 모두 흠잡을 곳이 없다 ㄷㄷ 일본인들은 어쩔 수 없는 건지 비음 특유의 코막힌 답답한 느낌이 아쉬움 근데 의외로 미나보다 모모가 더 잘하는 것 같음ㅋㅋ 쯔위는 진짜 발성만 다듬으면 더 발전가능성 높아보임 다현은 .. 할많하않
Momo sounds better than Mina, Tzuyu and Dahyun ofc. Edit: My point still stands even if she has less lines than Tzuyu! No more replies from me, I think I've said enough already.
She’s just stable the other girls in my opinion have a better singing voice especially tzuyu but no need to bring another girl to praise another they are all amazing .
숨소리 다들리고 중간중간 음원이랑 다른부분 들리는데 끝까지 에휴 그리고 다른 콘서트들 보면 라이브 인증 다 했는데 뭔 아니 어찌보면 이게 최고의 칭찬이네 그 정도로 트와이스의 실력이 대단하다는거니까 가서 콘서트 라이브 인증 한거 다 보고와라 중간에 숨차서 잠깐 쉬는 부분있는데 노래안부르니까 진짜 아무 소리도 안들리더라 100퍼센트 생라이브
![[ HyeongieeㅣMR Removed ]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/WAPTaC8jWw-FCThVsBYh6IjsG4k6wp-tHmsfytcJFTmIO1ehOhF40V8inodpo4OkgJieOEDG-w=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] TWICE (트와이스) ONE SPARK | Mnet Mcountdown 240229 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nQtGphZ0Nok/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] TWICE (트와이스) ONE SPARK | Mnet Mcountdown 240229 MR제거](/img/tr.png)
![[CLEAN MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] LE SSERAFIM(르세라핌) _ Fire in the belly @ 240414 Coachella 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1yjvB8Xspw8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#예능연구소8K] TWICE - ONE SPARK FanCam | Show! MusicCore | MBC240302onair](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g_JRhcF1zUc/mqdefault.jpg)
Nayeon is INSANE!!! Her voice didn’t shake one single time!!!
Nayeon is always the lady born for intros and choruses and can ever prove that she is main vocalist material.
Exactly!! She’s the main vocalist atp, Tzuyu is lead vocalist, Mina could be too!!
@@sugar_plum_fairymina isn't even close to lead,She didn't improve one bit, her voice seems whispery whenever she sings live!
@@sugar_plum_fairy🤣🤣🤣 jihyo forever will be main vocalist in Twice🤭🤭🤭🤫..
@@nursabrina6887 I mean, Nayeon is too! The both of them are 😉
@@sugar_plum_fairynayeon lead vocalist
From 2015 until now, they have improved so much. 🥹 They truly proved their name of being the nation’s gg of 3rd gen. They have really come so far. 😭 9 years and they are still together.
nayeon sounds so good it’s insane. so proud of all of them!!
춤추면서 하는 라이브로서 충분히 만족스럽다. 한국애들이야 당연하지만 의외로 쯔위도 상당히 안정적이네.
Of course, we love being racist‼️
@@liangteh Now that you've said it, it’s actually kinda racist.
쯔위가 진짜 노래 많이 늘었음
Bro?? 😭😭
@@liangteh 왜 이게 인종차별이냐.. 원래 데뷔때부터 무대에서 라이브 잘하던 지효 나연 정연이 다 한국인이니까 이러지 븅딱아
I know now why Jihyo, Nayeon, Jeongyeon nd Tzuyu given most line in One Spark, yess because they are the most stable in this live stage..
3mix and tzuyu are always the most stable
Tzuyu is the backbone of twice, her and mina are like the other Lead Vocalists, that's why they're in the vocal line too, like Joy in RV
@@thatoneperson731excuse me have you seen Sana in more & more & i can't stop me??? 😒😒😒😒
@@kpopworld2148I am a HUGE Sana bias but even I can agree that Sana still has some mishaps 😭 She’s good but she definitely isn’t as stable as the other 4
나연은 귀가 아플정도로 성량이 너무 커서 진짜 놀람 원래 잘하는데 또 늘은게 너무 실감남 다른애들은 말이 필요없을정도로 잘해졌고 악플을 다 받아들이고 끊임없이 발전하는 모습이 왜 아직고 전성기인지 알갰음
나연은 어느순간 득음했음. 이젠 아무리 고음이라도 얼굴 한번 찡그리지 않고 웃으면서 부름 ㅋ
진짜 고음 어디까지 올라갈지; 치얼업 제일 고음 노트도 걍 웃으면서 올리던데
받아드리고->받아들이고
@@리죠병_걸린_은하 감사해요 수정할게요
Jeongyeon queen of live vocals ❤❤
모모가 놀랍다! 잘 하잖아.
발음만 조금 고치면 진짜 빛을 볼뜻 ㄹㅇ
Nayeon as usual delivers everything on stage ❤❤❤
쯔위 언니는 보컬라인이 아닌데??리드보컬 자격이 충분한데..쯔위 언니는 너무 안정적이야❤❤❤
임나연 진짜 미친거냐구....
So impressed with the J line here, maybe the challenge they have with MISAMO really makes them give their best with singing, so happy to be a Once! I love 9 of them!
쯔위 라이브 미쳣다
Queens literally beautiful vocal,dance and visual TWICE BORN TO BE IDOL
Nayeoun❤❤❤❤
Nayeon*
트와이스 모두 음색 성량 노래실력 다 대박이다..생라이브 퍼포먼스봐🥹😭❤️🔥🔥
Tzuyu stable queen
Everyone is stable So not Queen
@@luxu8824 I never said no one else was, I'm just complimenting her.
@@luxu8824 what a weird comment
@@sunoo763 It shows that everyone*** is stable as Queen อย่างงสิเดี๋ยวโง่นะ
Nayeon's note at 1:40 is wonderful and powerful.
She’s a powerhouse
even jihyo did the highnote ....
쯔위가 진짜 대단하네🥹🤍🤍
많이 늘었네 연차 쌓이니까 잘부르네 이젠
라이브 논란이 있었던 멤버들도 있었는데 이제는 실력들이 훌륭하게 발전한 거 같아요
They’ve all come so far. 🥹💖
這場TWICE現場演唱的功力，沒有炫技，不標榜個人，而是講究群體感，整個團體的音準跟節拍都在點上，九兔各有各的音色都充分展現，子瑜同樣在激烈的唱跳，但是子瑜歌唱部分無論音準非常準確，舞蹈跟歌聲完全跟節拍契合，聲音優美而明亮，共鳴悠揚順暢，真的完全達到視覺跟聽覺都美的境界，這就是TWICE團魂滿滿，敬業認真，達到國際水準的現場唱場跳表演舞台啊！真的JYPE倍多力分，沒有給TWICE足夠的資源，非常可惜！但是我確信TWICE的表現值得所有現場表演的舞台，逆行召回TWICE回到舞台表演，所以ONCE請展現對TWICE跟子瑜更大的支持吧！
다현이는 춤추느라 음정 흔들리는것까진 어쩔 수 없지만 성량이라도 좀만 더 끌어올리자... 나머지 멤버들은 완벽하네 굿굿
1:20 TZUYU!!!!!!
나연이 성량 미쳤다..
MOMO LOVE HER DEEP VOICE ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
1
i got goosebumps
1:11 I love this part so much!!!!
Its so crazy how they sang the whole song during a long concert. Its so refreshing to hear their live voices and breaths ❤
내가 원스인게 자랑스럽다
They’re all so stable ❤❤❤
They’ve all improved so much since debut 🥹❤️
Jeongyeon ❤️
TZUYU IS LEAD VOCALIST, NAYEON IS MAIN VOCALIST!!!❤❤❤
역시 나연님 잘해 👍
they are improved so much 🥹
Tzuyu so stable...
mina so stable
That's concert you know. They sing live. All the time. Always even in stage.
TWICE powerful voice and stability goes to nayeon jihyo jeongyeon and amazingly tzuyu!!!!
i think chaeyoung and dahyun still need to work on their live vocals a bit, but this was a very good performance from twice!! well done ❤
THEY ALL IMPROVED SO MUCH SINCE THEIR DEBUT, AS A ONCE I'M SO PROUD❤
1:51. That vibrato when she’s clearly out of breath. I love my girls. Tzuyu voice is improving so much over the years. Our hidden vocal harmonizing queen
Clearly NMIXX’s mothers ❤❤❤
Except Dahyun, I am happy she’s receiving less lines.
@@Verowinday777 lolll !!! Yh, she’s less stable in this performance, but sometimes she is very loud! This range is just not that comfortable for her! Watch Go Hard, Dahyun’s low tone is audible even over the backtrack! She’s incredible.
@@sugar_plum_fairy If it’s not an MR removed then no, thanks,. her voice is so soft so it probably faded out into the backtrack.
@@Verowinday777 just- no. Admit you’re OT8 atp, anti.
@@sugar_plum_fairy Ok?? It’s now my fault for wanting to hear decent live vocals from every member?
JeongMiTzu vocals are no joke
IMAGINE TZUYU NOT IN THE VOCAL LIINE, BUT SANG LIKE THIS?😮😮😮
Nayeonna❤
Times for:
aprecciating Tzuyu's sense of breath support 1:20
Jeonyeon's vibrato 1:50
What note did Tzuyu support during the timestamp?
it's really good 😮
يا هشام بكل فيديو😂
@@kziompop هلااااااا😂
看到了嗎？這就是TWICE的實力
WOW this so clean that the entire music bg is removed
Sana's vocal❤
THE WAY EVERYONE SOUNDS HEAVENLY ESPECIALLY 3MIX
THEIR VOCALS ARE INSANE❤
this is what i personally love about jihyo's voice is the unique open quality and fullness she brings to her belting!
JEONGHYOO QUEENS
jihyo wow
nayeon wow
I wonder why antis and haters fail to recognise TWICE’s IMMENSE talent (that’s been obvious from day one in their iconic debut).
Twice has 3Mix that are all literal main vocalists. Does any other group have that??
Tzuyu is a lead vocalist atp, and so is Mina. Sana would be too in any other group!
Chae is a very good vocalist as well!!! And Momo is so loud now, and Dahyun is a good singer too! Obviously, they are rappers, so it’s clear that’s what they’re more comfortable with!
Tzuyu 😍
3mix❤
1:59 en ese milisegundo escuche el cielo xd
Jeong chorus
Icons!
Me duele decirlo pero Dahyun vocalmente aqui no destaco nada, se la escuchaba sin aire y algo fatigada, aunque al final con 'Don't lose this spark baby' remonto algo😢
Sana is stable too
LOVIN U MY 9 VOCALISTS!!!!
Wow nayeon
Cheayoung is so underrated
저 춤추면서 이 정도면 너무 잘하네. 정연이도 살찐게 득도있네 성량이 풍성한거보니.
Jihyo! 🔥🔥🔥
Sana❤❤❤
1:37
르세라핌보단 훨 낫네..
훨이 아니라 넘사인 것 같은데...
@@chan-e1dㄹㅇ 트와이스 라이브 퍼포먼스 넘사
이제는 비교불가임 ㅇㅇ
wow Jihyo and Jeongyeon are amazing projecting their voices incredible, all of them did very good love twice forever ❤️
the sounds is so ngongo😭😭😭
You know its live when dahyun's voice are bit shaky
Jihyo🤒❤
다현인 여전해 다른팀원은 진짜 잘하네!!
유리성대라 그런것도 있는데 현장에서 다른 노래 부르는 거 보면 다현이도 못하지 않음
This is what Le Sserafim needs to do. Improve their singing. Twice is also bad singing live before, but they improved so much in the last years.
But twice's vocal line the 3mix always good in singing live since debut tho, u should watch their debut live stage mr removed ver.
all was good the best of all is nayoen dahyun was the weakest but still slayed
🎉
❤❤❤❤
Mina. Wow
Hybe group would never
No need to do comparison, 只会为兔宝招黑罢了
@@ze-di6wg it's not comparison, it's A FACT!! So accept the criticism instead of sugarcoating HYBE
except fromis
NEVER speak on Fromis_9 and Seventeen again EVER
2:47 wtf is that, im sure chaeyoung doesnt sounds like that
the way she's struggling with a B4, even in studio thats bad😭🆘
@@caito787i think the mr just messed up her voice a bit. she sounds fine in the original video
데뷔초만 해도
지효>>나연>정연>>미나 였는데
이제는
지효=나연>정연>사나>채영>쯔위
되었네
Giving dahyun a chorus with a falsetto and tiring choreography isn't a good thing, she's airy and her stamina isn't really good compared to others
JIHYO MY QUEEN ❤
메인보컬 바꼈냐 나연 득음함?
Jihyo still main for official.. but i think if there is reposition, Jihyo and Nayeon will be the main vocalist.. tzuyu lead vocalist, and Jihyo can be the lead dancer too..
Just my opinion.. 😊
@@Zyo_YueDiyes ❤
Jihyo 👑
예전엔 지효가 더 성량 크다고 느꼈는데 나연이 득음해서 걍 넘사됐네 성량 발성 모두 흠잡을 곳이 없다 ㄷㄷ 일본인들은 어쩔 수 없는 건지 비음 특유의 코막힌 답답한 느낌이 아쉬움 근데 의외로 미나보다 모모가 더 잘하는 것 같음ㅋㅋ 쯔위는 진짜 발성만 다듬으면 더 발전가능성 높아보임 다현은 .. 할많하않
Live or pre-recorded?
Live you can hear them breathing and some parts they’re a little shaky cause of it
Obviously live🌝
Live 100% you can see the original video
100% 생 라이브 입니다
다른 콘서트 영상에서도 숨차서 잠깐 쉬는 부분있는데 노래안부르니까 진짜 아무 소리도 안들리더라
퀸와이스❤❤
Jihyo so good ❤
Jihyo ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Momo sounds better than Mina, Tzuyu and Dahyun ofc.
Edit: My point still stands even if she has less lines than Tzuyu! No more replies from me, I think I've said enough already.
I agree that she sounds better than Dahyun in this performance but no, Mina and Tzuyu clearly sounds better than Momo.
She’s just stable the other girls in my opinion have a better singing voice especially tzuyu but no need to bring another girl to praise another they are all amazing .
@@steakoncearmyengene9326 I would have put Tzuyu above Momo if she didn’t crack her voice tbh, and Mina was too shaky in her pre-chorus.
@@lani746 Sorry, but comparisons between idols have always existed, that’s why positions and reality shows exist also.
@@Verowinday777 shaky doesn't mean she is worst but let's not argue
왜 그들의 목소리가 이상하게 들리나요? 😅😂
다현 😂❤
라이브로 춤추면서 노래하는 게 정말 힘들어요
@@kziompop 네 알아요 하지만 그들의 목소리는 날 웃게 만들어요 ㅋㅋ
MR을 제거하는 작업을 하면서 목소리가 살짝 변형되는 듯해요
다른 그룹들도 다 본래보다 굵고 코 막힌 목소리가 되더라고요
@@uaiesy레세라핌이랑 비교하면 나쁘지도 않은데
@@uaiesy 비웃는다면 그들의 노력을 폄하하는 것 입니다
이게무슨 mr제거야 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 배경만 지운거지 ㅋㅌㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
어디서 멍청하단 말 안듣고 다니냐 ?
@@Pak-n2oㅇㅇ 넌 듣나봐?
네 정확히 100퍼센트 mr제거 입니당 음정나가고 사소하게 흔들리는 것도 다들리는데 씨디 삼켯단 말을 돌려서 칭찬하는거죠??😊 애초에 콘서트에서는 ar 자체를 작게 틀었어서 목소리가 비교적 선명하게 mr제거가 된거랍니당
숨소리 다들리고 중간중간 음원이랑 다른부분 들리는데 끝까지 에휴 그리고
다른 콘서트들 보면 라이브 인증 다 했는데 뭔
아니 어찌보면 이게 최고의 칭찬이네
그 정도로 트와이스의 실력이 대단하다는거니까
가서 콘서트 라이브 인증 한거 다 보고와라 중간에 숨차서 잠깐 쉬는 부분있는데 노래안부르니까 진짜 아무 소리도 안들리더라 100퍼센트 생라이브
칭찬을 이렇게하네 ㅋㅋㅋ