My fiance attends school across the country and he and I just said goodbye for one whole year before we see each other again. I love him but I didn't cry because I knew he would come back. I was actually looking for the song of the same name by She-Daisy. I found this and by the time the chorus hit, I was sobbing. Thank you.
Empathic Taste: Bittersweet, a hint of honey, a dash of nostalgia, and a bucket of tears. Your singing along with this picture really capture the raw sense of loss Princess Celestia must have felt when Princess Luna was banished. It must have been heartwrenching beyond words for Celestia to have done what she did. It would have taken a rare kind of strength to persist, for a thousand years no less.
You have a rare talent. Lots of people can sing but not many have that special feel to their voice that makes their music so much greater. Your voice (at least for me) hits a special spot in my heart, so many feels and I love it.
Every. One. Having just subscribed to your channel, I'm not going through your music history, and every, single, damn song makes me weep openly. Just... I can't even......
Another song for my trip home from vacation. Your voice just keep sounding better and better. When I need touching songs from this community, I always can count on you. Keep on doing what youre best at, Joaf :)
My god, Joaf... Keep bringing us these beautiful songs. This is my best christmas gift right here. Bought the song and I won't be listening to anything else for a while. I'll also learn to play it, thanks for the chords!
I've only listened to this and Fears so far, but I'm really digging your work man. The vocals, the lyrics, and the chord progressions. That iv chord at the end of the chorus is perfectly utilized x) and all those nice secondary dominants in Fears... Mmmmmm. So much nicer than the usual stock progressions on the radio. Keep it up. Definitely going to continue looking through what you've done.
I just started listening to your music last week, and since then I've been listening to several of your songs routinely. XD You're my favorite Brony musician as of now.
I always love songs that showcase the relationship between Celestia and Luna. it always breaks my heart to think of these two sisters separated for a thousand years by mutual mistakes.
Thank you, thank you for not being one of those fans that jumps off the deep end and says the entire thing was Celestia's fault, they were both to blame. And, yes, it's truly heartbreaking, I know how it feels, after all, I was sent to a maximum security mental rehab facility for 3 straight weeks, and every day, I looked to the sky, wishing I was back with my family, it truly hurts, being away from those you love
I wished they'd make an episode exploring Tia's and Luna's relationship Or even a flash back to who Tia felt and coped after she had sent Nightmare moon/Luna to the moon.
Joaf, you are my top favorite brony artist. Gosh, I thought its only The Hardest Thing I liked about your songs, but with the recent ones... Well, you know the rest.
Simply Marvellous! I wish I could shake your hand to congratulate and thank you! (I guess I should thank JWoodony as well, since I only stumbled over this video because he commented here)
Only a month?! Joaf, it's been 3 months since my last song! I'm the slacker here xD But man, you're simply amazing. This song brings tears to my eyes & you are by far, My favourite musician to date! & to think that maybe one day we'll have the opportunity to collab gets me all giddy inside :3
Joaf, 37 more subs until you hit the big 1k, you're awesome, and now, with my fellow 962 listener, I go back into waiting for your next song. (perhaps a Christmas Special?) songs this is why you're the artist with the highest play count on my itunes
Joaf man, I loved your stream the other day. I'm so glad you released this song. My girlfriend is gone for the next 6 days. The lyrics are just perfect. Keep up the great work!
Woah, where did all this water come from? Oh, I've been crying for quite some time. I guess it must have been this amazingly sweet and beautiful song. Thank you. Sincerely, Soulyman
It's been almost a week at the time of this comment's original posting since my twin sister moved away to go to college far from me. I miss her so much, but I'll know I'll see her again soon.
I like how the artwork depicts the original elements. (= Well, I won’t say anything about the performance and compilation of the song, obviously it’s very good. =)
This made me cry with happyness and sadness. My Boyfriend is in the military and he is in irqa and i really miss him! This song reminds me of him! Good job on the song Joaftheloaf! love the guitar and love the lyrics. Just to let you now that this song would have been better with a girl singing it...just a suggestion... but yay BRO HOOVE! :') /)
Joaf!!! This is wonderful....I love how flowing and sweet the lyrics are! A great ballad indeed...Did you play the piano in this too, or just the awesome guitar?? Either way, the chord progression is somber but cheerful at the same time. It seems that Celestia would sing this song often if it's every 100 years. Good luck waiting, Tia! Luna will come back soon enough.
This sounds too happy for that pic which is making me cry....
*listens to the whole song*
-is weeping in the floor-
After watching the finale, I noticed the elements on the floor look exactly like the elements in the actual show
Hiuv
One of the most beautiful things in this fandom. Thanks so much, Joaf, for giving us this song.
Can't believe I never saved it, when I was listening to it the first time. Corrected as of now. Thanks so much for the song!
My fiance attends school across the country and he and I just said goodbye for one whole year before we see each other again.
I love him but I didn't cry because I knew he would come back. I was actually looking for the song of the same name by She-Daisy. I found this and by the time the chorus hit, I was sobbing.
Thank you.
+C.L. May Yes. of course it is. He's in Ferelden and I'm in Tevinter
C.L. May Its a strange thing
Empathic Taste: Bittersweet, a hint of honey, a dash of nostalgia, and a bucket of tears.
Your singing along with this picture really capture the raw sense of loss Princess Celestia must have felt when Princess Luna was banished. It must have been heartwrenching beyond words for Celestia to have done what she did. It would have taken a rare kind of strength to persist, for a thousand years no less.
oh sorry, I must not have extended it when I added it. It's fixed now! :D
Lol well I just put them up in the desc if you'd like them :D
I always come back to these songs because they're just too good
You have a rare talent. Lots of people can sing but not many have that special feel to their voice that makes their music so much greater. Your voice (at least for me) hits a special spot in my heart, so many feels and I love it.
The feels. Why you do dis to me.
Your doge pic matches wonderfully with your comment.
XD
This has been stuck in my head all day, so i had to come back and hear it. again.
I just started listening to this song, never having heard one from him, and subscribed. Great voice, good at guitar. That's what I like.
heard this song when it came out for like 3 weeks straight, somehow forgot about it until now, now I can't stop listening to it again
Damn Joaf, the backing so brings the song up from the sad lines. Heavenly.
The chords are actually in the description :D
The feels...
Every. One. Having just subscribed to your channel, I'm not going through your music history, and every, single, damn song makes me weep openly. Just... I can't even......
I like this song a thousand times, but stupid RUclips won't let me. ...And I think making a thousand accounts is a little excessive.
I know, I totally agree, Flame.
Well I wouldn't do 1000, I would do 1000000
Nah, its not tooo excessive...
eh.
Do it
A Pony Ad just Popped up, and it was the one of the iPhone spoof! xD
Heard this song on Ever Free Radio awhile back, really good song!
Another song for my trip home from vacation. Your voice just keep sounding better and better. When I need touching songs from this community, I always can count on you. Keep on doing what youre best at, Joaf :)
My god, Joaf... Keep bringing us these beautiful songs. This is my best christmas gift right here. Bought the song and I won't be listening to anything else for a while. I'll also learn to play it, thanks for the chords!
I've only listened to this and Fears so far, but I'm really digging your work man. The vocals, the lyrics, and the chord progressions. That iv chord at the end of the chorus is perfectly utilized x) and all those nice secondary dominants in Fears... Mmmmmm. So much nicer than the usual stock progressions on the radio. Keep it up. Definitely going to continue looking through what you've done.
I just started listening to your music last week, and since then I've been listening to several of your songs routinely. XD
You're my favorite Brony musician as of now.
Your songs pack like a million feels each.
I love this song I mean its just emotional and, just wow I am astonished! Thank you so much I might listen every day!
Tis is one of those songs where I actually FEEL those feels. This is so beautiful and might just be my favorite joaftheloaf somg now
Joaf you're literally the best singer I've ever heard.
This is absolutely beautiful. All those feels i got means you nailed this song.
Oh so you watch the show then? good job rick! I'm glad you're stepping out of your comfort zone! :D
i cant get over how much i love this song.
I love how I can share your songs with my non-Brony friends, it makes our friendship that much more magical.
I absolutely love every song you've ever made, but this one by far has to be my favorite.
This song came on Everfree Radio and I looked at the artist; Joaftheloaf. I knew I would love it right away, and now I'm here for more :P
I always love songs that showcase the relationship between Celestia and Luna. it always breaks my heart to think of these two sisters separated for a thousand years by mutual mistakes.
Thank you, thank you for not being one of those fans that jumps off the deep end and says the entire thing was Celestia's fault, they were both to blame. And, yes, it's truly heartbreaking, I know how it feels, after all, I was sent to a maximum security mental rehab facility for 3 straight weeks, and every day, I looked to the sky, wishing I was back with my family, it truly hurts, being away from those you love
Your music makes me feel so much more than I normal do... You are a great musician... and now.. i'm gonna go shed liquid pride..
This is incredible! The lyrics are sad but the song makes me feel so happy!
Grats on the well-deserved feature, Joaf! And on 1000 SUBS!!!!!! :DDD!!!
Wow, how have I not heard you until now?
This song is great, can't wait to hear more from you
This still good after all these years!
You have a very beautiful voice Joaftheloaf, I mean a very very very Beautiful voice
That subscribe button now has a check mark by it. Thanks for making these amazing songs.
Me Too! it shall be the most epic collab ever!
How are all your songs sooooo beautiful!?!?! HOW?!?!
I wished they'd make an episode exploring Tia's and Luna's relationship Or even a flash back to who Tia felt and coped after she had sent Nightmare moon/Luna to the moon.
I'm actually in tears right now. I miss my brother so much
Joaf, you are my top favorite brony artist. Gosh, I thought its only The Hardest Thing I liked about your songs, but with the recent ones... Well, you know the rest.
I always end up coming back to this song.
Simply Marvellous! I wish I could shake your hand to congratulate and thank you! (I guess I should thank JWoodony as well, since I only stumbled over this video because he commented here)
Absolutely fantastic! there's no way I could take this piece without paying you for it! amazing :3
You need to be on the radio man
Only a month?! Joaf, it's been 3 months since my last song! I'm the slacker here xD But man, you're simply amazing. This song brings tears to my eyes & you are by far, My favourite musician to date! & to think that maybe one day we'll have the opportunity to collab gets me all giddy inside :3
im sorry i think my ears just weeped with joy
this is amazing music
I don't know if you already know this, but you have the greatest voice ever. :)
oh my gosh you responded to me yay. =D btw im praying my high tenor vocals wont ruin this wonderful song. P.S love your work =)
The FEELS!!!! There's so much feels.
Man, this is beautiful. Well done.
Amazing. Simply, amazingly, beautiful
so many covers!! great song by the way
I can't even count how many times I've listened to this song.
People like you make this world ... colorful.
Thank you so much for this. *Bronyhug*
How does this not have views? Incredible....
I can't stop listening to this song the voice is just too damn nice
I think im gonna cry... that song was so good....
Joaf, 37 more subs until you hit the big 1k, you're awesome, and now, with my fellow 962 listener, I go back into waiting for your next song. (perhaps a Christmas Special?)
songs this is why you're the artist with the highest play count on my itunes
Best birthday present evar! (Well, maybe not -for- me but it was posted on my birthday :P and it's freakin awesome)
I love the lyrics! It's about two sisters that miss each other greatly.
OH DEAR JESUS! THE FEELS
So many remixes...this is still the original and still the best.
Joaf man, I loved your stream the other day. I'm so glad you released this song. My girlfriend is gone for the next 6 days. The lyrics are just perfect. Keep up the great work!
JoafIsLife
LifeIsJoaf
JoafTheLoaf
Joaftheloaf is the brony equivalence to Simon and Garfunkel.
Woah, where did all this water come from? Oh, I've been crying for quite some time. I guess it must have been this amazingly sweet and beautiful song. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Soulyman
I have, and I was absolutely blown away by it :D
It's been almost a week at the time of this comment's original posting since my twin sister moved away to go to college far from me.
I miss her so much, but I'll know I'll see her again soon.
U did a amazing song. This song reminds me of my friend. Some1 make a Christmas Song! Keep up the amazing work Joaf! :D
Your voice is so incredible!
dude this song is amazing!
Great job! Awesome song, and very touching
GASP--Even more epic-amazing are you! Most excellent work~
One word: Amazing
I like how the artwork depicts the original elements.
(=
Well, I won’t say anything about the performance and compilation of the song, obviously it’s very good. =)
I love this song joaf hope this week to create a PMV of your song ...
simply wonderful :)
nice vocals special and does the job hits where it matters miss you too kas
This is so sad!!!!! Great voice!
Best song i ever heard... Like legit
This made me cry with happyness and sadness. My Boyfriend is in the military and he is in irqa and i really miss him! This song reminds me of him! Good job on the song Joaftheloaf! love the guitar and love the lyrics. Just to let you now that this song would have been better with a girl singing it...just a suggestion... but yay BRO HOOVE! :')
/)
This song is so fucking brilliant. You sir are the man
HOLY LOANLY PONY EATING MACARONI! YOUR VOICE MY GOOD SIR IS MAJESTIC!
ERMERGERD!! you should have a Cd :D! You sir, are amazing :D !!!
love the guitar chords they are nice =D i think ill try this on for a talent show with permission of course
*sniffs* I'm not crying!... well I am but it's just so beautiful ;_;
Absolutely brilliant mate! But you already knew that, because I told you already xD
Joaf!!! This is wonderful....I love how flowing and sweet the lyrics are! A great ballad indeed...Did you play the piano in this too, or just the awesome guitar?? Either way, the chord progression is somber but cheerful at the same time. It seems that Celestia would sing this song often if it's every 100 years. Good luck waiting, Tia! Luna will come back soon enough.
The feels man it reminded me of my cat when he ran away from my grandmas house its been 5 years and i still miss him
I love this song so much it's amazing!!! :) And I was wondering if when the talent show comes at my school could I have permission to sing this?
Beautiful! I love it!
Damn, I wish I have your vocal skill. Great song btw
This pic just intensifies the feels.