Super interesting-this has expanded and clarified what was my apparently narrow understanding of the subjunctive mood, thinking that by its use in “irrealis” situations it was regulated only to ideas such as wishes, hopes, dreams, anxiety…etc.
Does this got anything to do with evidentiality? Evidentiality shows in a lot of languages, and I wonder if latin shows its evidentiality in the causal clause. If I witnessed an event could I use the indicative mood? "Grātiās eī ēgistī quia malōs tibi dedisset." If I witnessed the event of the third person giving the apples to the second person, could I say: "Grātiās eī ēgistī quia malōs tibi dederat"?
Your explanation on the subjunctive uses makes perfect sense, since these conjunctions plus the subjunctive were also used as an alternative for the accusative plus infinitive for indirect speech in later Latin. Instead of: audio illum esse discipulum bonum; It could be: audio quia ille sit discipulus bonus
Super interesting-this has expanded and clarified what was my apparently narrow understanding of the subjunctive mood, thinking that by its use in “irrealis” situations it was regulated only to ideas such as wishes, hopes, dreams, anxiety…etc.
more subtle than I had previously understood. THANK YOU!
Just in time for my students' grammar review of Spring semester!
As always, your uploads are well received. Thank you!
Just 10 more boys we’re almost there.
Let's get this thing finished!
You were the first comment
love u bro
Does this got anything to do with evidentiality? Evidentiality shows in a lot of languages, and I wonder if latin shows its evidentiality in the causal clause.
If I witnessed an event could I use the indicative mood?
"Grātiās eī ēgistī quia malōs tibi dedisset."
If I witnessed the event of the third person giving the apples to the second person, could I say:
"Grātiās eī ēgistī quia malōs tibi dederat"?
Can we please get a playlist of these?
Already done! ruclips.net/p/PLI76N29qybf-o5U6tvD-8VPILacttSaM3
my god he's still going
Can’t stop until 91.
Gratias tibi agimus, magister, quia hanc pelliculam perbene fecisti. Et indicativo utor 🙂
Your explanation on the subjunctive uses makes perfect sense, since these conjunctions plus the subjunctive were also used as an alternative for the accusative plus infinitive for indirect speech in later Latin.
Instead of: audio illum esse discipulum bonum;
It could be: audio quia ille sit discipulus bonus
Great video, thks 4 posting!
I'm proud to have [almost] been
First
Proud to have almost been first