I have always had an obsession with XTC .Growing up at the vintage era(78-83)of British pop,they're palette was full of fizzy textured colours.Colin was totally underrated,and to here your fine examination of his song writing craft was a pleasure.The strange thing about the man..he is totally unassuming.A quiet genius .
About time for some recognition for Colin. I love Andy but I also love Colin in a different way. No XTC album was complete without Colin's songs. It wouldn't be an XTC album without both.
Kieron Bowker Agreed. And Colin wrote a lot of my favorite XTC songs. My Bird Performs, Sacrificial Bonfire, Grass, Generals and Majors, King for a Day, Wonderland, etc. Also his backing vocals on tracks like Summers Cauldron and Season Cycle are pivotal. Love both and couldn’t choose a favorite though.
Blind Brazilian Tex Atlantis all the other ones are fuckin garbage and have maybe two good songs on them. Skylarking is a masterpiece every song and even note is perfect
Thank you James for giving Colin the props he is due. My list: 10) Vanishing Girl 9) Love at First Sight 8) Generals and Majors 7) My Bird Performs 6) King for a Day 5) Making Plans for Nigel 4) The Meeting Place 3) Grass 2) I Remember the Sun 1) Wake Up
Colin was such an important member of the band and a big part of their sound. Apart from anything else, I like bands where vocals are shared between two or more singers who voices both differ and compliment each other. XTC was a good example, as was The Who and Supertramp, and I guess the Beatles.
Great vid and nice to see Colin get some recognition and love. Big fan of his Generals and Majors, Making Plans for Nigel, Deliver us from the Elements, Grass, The Meeting Place, My Bird Performs, The Good Things and so many more too numerous to mention. I Remember the Sun is a superb hidden gem too.
Love the idea, thanks for the great video. It was very difficult coming with just 10 songs by Colin, but here's my top ten: 10) Making Plans For Nigel; 9) The Meeting Place; 8) Bungalow; 7) Ten Feet Tall; 6) Grass; 5) In Another Life; 4) Love At First Sight; 3) Ball and Chain; 2) Generals and Majors; 1) Sacrifical Bonfire
"What sticks in my mind is the sweet jar on the sideboard, and the multi-colored tea cozy." I consider my self lucky, being in the US, to have purchased the copy of Skylarking with Dying instead of Dear God. Such a great song, again with the distinct imagery that only Colin can deliver.
I like the track Dear God but sticking at the end of Skylarking ruins it, imo. It has the best track to track flow of almost any album I’ve heard and the back to back of Dying and Sacrificial Bonfire was the perfect way to end it.
@@HotStrange agree with you there and forgot that Dying was a Colin song. Love that song because well you just don't get beautiful songs written so well about such things!
David Evans Agreed. Colin wrote a lot of my favorite XTC songs. King for a Day, Wonderland, My Bird Performs, Dying/Sacrificial Bonfire, Grass, Generals and Majors, etc. Andy is a genius, of course, but Colin doesn’t get the credit he deserves, IMO. His backing vocals on a lot of Skylarking make the album for me.
Hey Paul, I have the original Lp without "Dear God", and the revised edition vinyl. I don't understand your point. "Dying" was not the song removed to fit on "Dear God". "Mermaid Smiled" was.
Will Harris this is consistent with my edition which was the earliest distributed in the US. In fact I had to buy the single of Dear God b/w Mermaid Smiled to get the latter.
An excellent presentation. You have a great way with words. Like Paul McCartney, if Colin had never written a song or even sang, he would be recognized by some, as being one hell of an amazing bass player.
Great that you have recognised the wonderful Colin Moulding from XTC.! I would have stuck 'Generals & Majors' in the Top 3 along with 'Making Plans for Nigel' - two classic Colin hits. x LOVE XTC x - all members brought some magic!
Thanks for flagging up Colin Moulding. I've always loved the immense tenderness and sensitivity in his lyrics and his detailed observations. His poetic expression through English melancholy has always hit the spot. I've always admired his loving observation of the lives of his parents and his parents generation. That generation that went through the disciplined 30's, through the horrors of WW2 and out the other side; only to be confronted the crazy, rapid change they witnessed in the psychedelic 60's. Songs like e.g. 'Bungalow', 'Dying', 'In Loving memory of a Name', 'Frivolous Tonight' are all so respectful to that now; past generation. I was a professional bass player in the 80's and having been inspired by Paul McCartney's bass playing as a boy and a teenager, it was Colin's creative bass lines, that were my next source of inspiration through my 20's.
1980 was when I stumbled on Drums and Wires. I still listen to that album, and virtually all of their albums to this day. That's the only band I can say that about. Colin is a great songwriter. I Remember the Sun is a masterpiece...but so many of their songs are great. He supplied a great balance to Andy....both prolific and wonderful and ARTFUL songwriters. But Colin seemed to offer some relief to the jagged, brash, off color chords that possibly was Andy's trademark. Colin, the more soothing musician. Together, it was perfect. Colin is also probably my favorite bass player of all time. He played moments. There was always artistry and taste in his choices, and he buoyed or augmented the melodies of songs...for instance, in Stupidly Happy a train is referenced in the lyrics, and in that place Colin actually plays the feel of a train. He's just very good, subtle, and elegant on the fretless bass. I might have put Dying, Sacrificial Bonfire, and Ten Feet Tall on my list of top tens....but I'm happy to see his work in the spotlight. (The Drums and Wires album cover has to be one of the greatest album covers of all time...to me, it's just as great as what's inside) Anyway, I enjoyed this video.
I used to prefer Andy's songs, but this has been changing the last couple of years. Currently my most favourite XTC/Dukes tune is "Vanishing Girl". But your list is absolutely great anyways! Expecially thanks for all these amazing background informations!
My favourite Colin songs include One of the Millions and from their alter egos, The Dukes of Stratosphear, The Affiliated and The Vanishing Girl. Even though you didn't include my favourites, I really enjoyed your musings.
Skylarking remains my favorite of their albums, and both Andy's and Colin's songs are amazing. Around this same period, the two Dukes of Stratosphere Lps still bring me joy.
My Bird Performs is my favorite Colin and favorite XTC song in general. He was so underrated within the band. XTC is my absolute favorite band by far. The 2 of them are a songwriting pair on par with Lennon-McCartney, imo and made some of the best pop songs ever. Colin’s work on Skylarking is the most experimental it’s ever been. Grass and Sacrificial Bonfire are excellent. Really enjoyed your video. I’m definitely a new fan of your channel.
Hi James .. I’m really enjoying your videos .. I’m lucky enough to have seen xtc live in Manchester in 1980.. speaking to many people I’ve come to realise not many people seem to have seen them . I bought drums and wires when it came out and for a few years they were my favourite band . As time has passed they’ve been rediscovered by so many people .. keep up the good work James .. all the best for 2019 happy digging .. best wishes rob
I like your description of the "difficult" Andy songs. "Train Running Low on Soul Coal" or "... Donkey Up" are examples of ones I can't stomach. However, "You're the Wish You Are I Had" is a counterpoint. It shines.
XTC, one of the best bands ever. They were the Kinks of the 80s and 90s. Underrated, under appreciated and brilliant. Songwriting akin to Something Else and Village Green., but more angular musically, like no other band.
Outstanding effort Professor James. I was getting a little bit anxious to see if you were going to dive into Nonsuch. But sure enough you pulled out one of my all time favorite Colin Moulding vocals on 'My Bird Performs'. There has late night XTC listening sessions where I have really studied their music. I think it is safe to say that I have got goosebumbs while listening to both Andy and Colin's songs. This is proof purchase that you are a longtime fan of the band. Two XTC related items that I am proud of is my copy of Nonsuch on vinyl and also my ticket stub from 1/29/80. The late show out of two. Well done again James. I would love to chat with you about everything XTC for about sixteen hours~ Rob/Boston
Hi Rob. It's great that you've got a vinyl copy of Nonsuch...funnily enough I was just wondering the other day whether the record had been released on LP, and I searched for it online but couldn't find it. Amazing that you got to see them as well, given how early into their career they gave up touring. Hope you have a great festive season, and speak to you soon.
Great video James. That piano break on Runaways is one of my greatest moments on vinyl, ever. The first time I heard it it sent a chill up my spine and I knew I would love this band for ever. I could probably come up with at least 10 more Colin songs which I love, but this is a good list. Can’t wait to see Colin & Terry play live at the end of October, it will be an emotional moment, that’s for sure!
Colin said in an interview that if all goes well they may play in London, if that’s any easier for you! Cheers James this XTC video led me to discover your channel so I’ve been enjoying catching up on loads of your stuff. BTW if you’re ever on the South coast check out Wow & Flutter in Hastings, it’s my favourite record shop!
Thanks for the video. Xtc is a band that I enjoy quite a few songs from but I don't know a lot about them, I need to change that. Merry Christmas and a happy new year.
Many people identify Colin Moulding by "Making Plans ...", but there is so much more. You shone your expert torchlight on the various Colin Moulding styles. He's the master of irresistible hooks and rhythms, and his vocals occasionally are unbelievable. I somehow have the feeling he only contributed a song when he was absolutely sure to have something very special. That list you did is truly a very clever one, highly recommended! Ball and Chain at the end ... and there is so much more.
Hi James, great to see appraisal for the Paul McCartney of XTC. I think your list of 10 CM songs is on the mark. Again an interesting subject, makes me want to read that book. Thanks for sharing and a happy christmas to you and your family -Johan
I wouldn’t quite call him the McCartney unless you mean he was the pure “pop” writer of the band compared to Lennon/Andy’s more experimental tracks. Macca was much more of a dominant force within the Beatles than Colin was within XTC.
Very informative, astute and unusually enthusiastic! Making Plans For Nigel is definitely #1 but like other commenters, I'd have had Generals & Majors in there, too.
Really enjoyed your video. A great band and the recent doc on Sky Arts is one of the best music docs I’ve ever seen. You are spot on about Skylarking - it has a strong feel of a Wiltshire summer. A teenage summer with that hot sun and a country lane cycle ride. English Settlement is my favourite album but then, Apple Venus vol 1 is incredible from start to finish. You put a lot of time into this vid - much appreciated.
English Settlement is my favorite as well. Skylarking gets all the attention, and rightfully so, but something about ES touched me on a different level when I first heard it.
Cheers, Mate! Excellent Video....I too any thrilled to have discovered XTC here in America. I'm unable to make a top 10 because all of them are crammed in at #1. :) XTC are my absolute favorite band. I feel Colin, Andy and Greg all deserve equal credit for bringing such wonderful music into the world! Thanks, James for such a great review.
Epic video! I am a HUGE XTC fan! I would love to see a similar video for Andy or your take on their catalogue. Tying into your prog comment, I found it interesting Steven Wilson remixed Drums and Wires, Skylarking, Oranges and Lemons and Nonsvch recently in 5.1!
Hi Christopher. Glad you enjoyed the video....I'll try and put together another XTC video later this year. I have a couple of new XTC vinyl pick-ups to show.
Thank you for this James. It was quite the tutorial for me. Since meeting yourself, Jeff, and Sean, I’ve been trying to fill that XTC void in my life. I loved how you spoke the lyrics like poetry. Imagery is such an important part of music for me. I can’t wait to delve further into Colin’s music and also Andy’s. Happy Holiday’s, -Brian
Great video James. We do tend to forget that XTC might be Andy's band but the contribution of Colin in the song writing scheme is essential. A band that kept getting better album after album instead of fading. If you love XTC, you are part of a very lucky few.
To be fair Colin did write 1/3 of the tracks and most of the hits. Quite an accomplishment but Andy’s dominant personality kind of overshadows Colin’s more quiet demeanor.
Great video paying a so much deserved homage to Colin! "Life Begins at the Hop", "Teen Feet Tall" and "War Dance" are some favourites of mine. Merry Christmas!
Thanks for reminding me why I love this band! Others i'd have are In loving memory of a name (Mummer) and Cross wires from White music, which kind of sounds like an Andy song.
Thanks for making the video James, I really enjoyed that. It's only been in recent years that i've started listening to XTC. Prior to that I knew 1 song - Making Plans For Nigel. Not too long ago I heard a song that I liked, subsequently discovered it was XTC and then bought English Settlement as a result. I was shocked at how good it was and so not long after I purchased Skylarking and that was as good, if not better. I know i've shown the former on a video quite some time ago but not that latter so i'll do that next month actually, thanks for the reminder!
I'm a bit late with my reply as just found your channel James & a huge Colin & XTC fan here James & my top 10 Colin songs are as follows.... 10 - Washaway 9 - Shiny Cage 8 - Ball & Chain 7 - Deliver Us From The Elements 6 - One Of The Millions 5 - Blame The Weather 4 - Making Plans For Nigel 3 - Bungalow 2 - Runaways 1 - I Remember The Sun.....
As much as I enjoy this video it is nice to read other people's top ten songs and it has made me realise how many great songs that Colin wrote. My own top ten would have included Ten Feet Tall, Life Begins At The Hop and my personal favorite, The World Is Full Of Angry Young Men.
Finally unearthed this Christmas present, James! I definitely gained a deeper appreciation on Colin’s songwriting. And your breakdown of the arrangements was stellar. And ending with NIGEL was great, interesting how the factory jobs and pensions look like from today’s generation. I never made the connection between Blur and Colin before, being American I guess I was oblivious to it but I totally see it now that you mention it, wild. Ok, I really like the Dukes THE AFFILIATED, I think that is Colin’s. And his last song I think with the band, I think the song is YES? Or something, it is a bonus track on the Apple Venus 7” collection. And one more, his track with the PROG COLLECTIVE was was great as well. Very stylish bass player as well. Cheers, man! This was great! Chris
Thank you very much, James, for the thoughtfulness in giving Colin's songs the much-deserved attention. It would probably be easiest for me to list a Moulding song per XTC album (before additional tracks were brought to CD releases), or to solely feature b-sides, but here's my own list, which is subject to change at any given moment due to the quality of sentiment that I carry throughout his discography; I'd actually like to extend it to twenty, but.... :D : 1. The Good Things (demo version) 2. Runaways 3. Wake Up 4. Big Day 5. Deliver Us from the Elements 6. Find the Fox 7. The World is Full of Angry Young Men 8. Fly on the Wall 9. Didn't Hurt a Bit 10.Vanishing Girl
James Griffiths Thank you, James. I soon realized how difficult a task it was to list only ten of Colin's songs, as I suspect you had initially felt as well.
I personally think that my two favourite Colin songs have to be King For A Day and Deliver Us From the Elements. Both are just absolute art pieces in themselves
Perfect Christmas morning viewing James. Colin Moulding wrote some great songs. Life Begins At The Hop was my introduction to the band. I must admit I need to catch on later XTC. I always thought that Colin had the pop sensibilities within the band. Have a great day today.
Terry Chambers left the band (I think) at the beginning of the sessions for mummer. Very good presentation of colins' song writing. I love general & majors, English round about, the meeting place, the smartest monkeys and war dance.
Hey James, glad you divested those lights off yourself early on - had me a bit worried for your safety there... this is yet another illuminating video on a subject dear to your heart. I like how you place these songs in context and dig deeper as to just WHY they work, why they move you. Never knew Runaways was Moulding, always enjoyed that song, but my word I did not know the lyrics behind it!! It's amazing hearing the songwriting progression in this video as well. I really need to investigate more XTC... thanks again for this video, James.
Sorry Dean, I did read your comment at the time but I obviously neglected to reply to it. Glad you enjoyed the video...yeah I was surprised when I finally sat down to read the lyrics of Runaways. Hope you do get to check out some XTC...
My top10 10. In Loving Memory Of A Name 9. King For A Day 8. That Is the Way 7. Vanishing Girl 6.Ten Feet Tall 5. Wake Up 4. Deliver Us From the Elements 3. English Roundabout 2. Frivolous Tonight 1. I Remember the Sun
Hi, there is a great new Andy Partridge interview in the magazine Swindon Heritage from the Winter 2017 issue. One of the best I’ve read. Andy visits loads of Swindon landmarks that shaped the XTC vision. My mum got me it for Christmas. Worth seeking out. Cheers.
I really appreciate your video. Thanks. In the beginning it seems your view is a competition between the two. I think they have always collaborated together. Merry Christmas!
Great video James. Nice that you didn't just focus on the obvious and included a few gems from the often overlooked Wasp Star. Didn't Hurt A Bit and Blame the Weather would be my additions to the list.
Great video James! Colin is such an underrated force in XTC. It’s great to see him spotlighted. I really need to listen to Nonsuch more. I’ve only heard it once and have no recollection of it.
Thanks Sean! You must be sick of the sight of me though. I'd largely forgotten Nonsuch before I started researching this video. I had to put it on the ipod and spend some car time with it. It's a good album but too long...came out in the CD era so probably has at least 4 surplus songs on it.
Hey James, so late to this video but today I got inspired because I received a copy of "English Settlement" and to my surprise it was signed by Colin, Andy, and Dave. I had no idea the copy I ordered would be signed and apparently neither did the seller, as it's on the back of the record and he didn't notice it. Well anyway I really enjoyed this video and as usual it's like an education watching you. Thanks for making excellent, informative videos. I hope you are doing well. - James
Cheers for this - really interesting commentary on Colin Moulding songs. Definitely the more Mcartneyesque and accessible songwriter in XTC. Great to see Bungalow in there. I think the recent 'Scatter Me' is one of his best yet. What do you reckon? I'd also put In Loving Memory of a Name up there!
OMG! JK! I initially watched this with judgement in my heart but I appreciate your appreciation for these guys. Colin is one of my all-time- favorite musicians & writers. Thank U. F
Great essay James, thank you. Should you be able to contact Colin, perhaps ask him to release a compilation of his songs with or without XTC??? If you would be so kind. For the first twenty years of my life I was Nigel. Thanks again.
Colin's great gift was simply an ear for a wonderful tune. Songs such as Generals and Majors, Blame the Weather, English Roundabout, In Loving Memory of a Name, Grass, Wonderland, I Remember the Sun, Big Day, Cynical Days, and many more contain such glorious melodies. My personal favourite is My Bird Performs - a song that starts quite innocuously but builds and builds into the most glorious masterpiece with so many threads fused together. Although it's quite a clumsy comparison, Colin was Macca to Andy's Lennon. The Beatles will always be the greatest band ever for many reasons, but XTC were the nearest anybody got to them. I have to say also that I thought Colin's songs on the last two albums were a bit mediocre, but he contributed dozens of wonderful songs to the XTC catalogue as well as being a brilliant bassist and vocalist.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
'Wonderland' is great too. lovely vocal harmonies.
I have always had an obsession with XTC .Growing up at the vintage era(78-83)of British pop,they're palette was full of fizzy textured colours.Colin was totally underrated,and to here your fine examination of his song writing craft was a pleasure.The strange thing about the man..he is totally unassuming.A quiet genius .
True words, Tom. Thanks.
SACRIFICIAL BONFIRE. Masterpiece!!!!
About time for some recognition for Colin. I love Andy but I also love Colin in a different way. No XTC album was complete without Colin's songs. It wouldn't be an XTC album without both.
Thanks Kieron, much appreciated.
His playing is tops. Big influence on me.
I think the only xtc album that mattered was skylarking. And it has the most colin written songs on that album than any other xtc release
Kieron Bowker Agreed. And Colin wrote a lot of my favorite XTC songs. My Bird Performs, Sacrificial Bonfire, Grass, Generals and Majors, King for a Day, Wonderland, etc. Also his backing vocals on tracks like Summers Cauldron and Season Cycle are pivotal. Love both and couldn’t choose a favorite though.
Blind Brazilian Tex Atlantis all the other ones are fuckin garbage and have maybe two good songs on them. Skylarking is a masterpiece every song and even note is perfect
Thank you James for giving Colin the props he is due. My list:
10) Vanishing Girl
9) Love at First Sight
8) Generals and Majors
7) My Bird Performs
6) King for a Day
5) Making Plans for Nigel
4) The Meeting Place
3) Grass
2) I Remember the Sun
1) Wake Up
Thanks Michael, great list.
Ach! How did I forget Wake Up!
Blame the Weather, I keep coming back to this song.
Love that song. B side of Senses WOT, alog with Tissue Tigers. Still got the 45 :-)
Huge Colin Moulding fan so this is a gem of a compilation. Thank you!
You're very welcome, thanks for watching!
Colin was such an important member of the band and a big part of their sound. Apart from anything else, I like bands where vocals are shared between two or more singers who voices both differ and compliment each other. XTC was a good example, as was The Who and Supertramp, and I guess the Beatles.
Pink Floyd too!
Great vid and nice to see Colin get some recognition and love. Big fan of his Generals and Majors, Making Plans for Nigel, Deliver us from the Elements, Grass, The Meeting Place, My Bird Performs, The Good Things and so many more too numerous to mention. I Remember the Sun is a superb hidden gem too.
Deliver us from the Elements is a good one
Colin Moulding was crucial to XTCs success especially in the early days- he only produced a few songs per album but they became the hits!
Very true David. Colin had a more commercial touch than Andy originally, though I think Andy did learn from him over time!
Love the idea, thanks for the great video. It was very difficult coming with just 10 songs by Colin, but here's my top ten: 10) Making Plans For Nigel; 9) The Meeting Place; 8) Bungalow; 7) Ten Feet Tall; 6) Grass; 5) In Another Life; 4) Love At First Sight; 3) Ball and Chain; 2) Generals and Majors; 1) Sacrifical Bonfire
Thanks for sharing your choices, we have a few cross-overs! Glad you enjoyed the video, all the best.
Wow good list but no My Bird Performs? It’s my personal favorite XTC songs. Just shows how music speaks to everyone differently :)
I started to listen to XTC this year, and already is one of my favourite bands. I love all their songs, specially the Colin's songs
Colin has made a memorable career out of exalting the quotidian and eschewing vintage wine and designer clothes. God bless him.
"What sticks in my mind is the sweet jar on the sideboard, and the multi-colored tea cozy."
I consider my self lucky, being in the US, to have purchased the copy of Skylarking with Dying instead of Dear God. Such a great song, again with the distinct imagery that only Colin can deliver.
I like the track Dear God but sticking at the end of Skylarking ruins it, imo. It has the best track to track flow of almost any album I’ve heard and the back to back of Dying and Sacrificial Bonfire was the perfect way to end it.
@@HotStrange agree with you there and forgot that Dying was a Colin song. Love that song because well you just don't get beautiful songs written so well about such things!
David Evans Agreed. Colin wrote a lot of my favorite XTC songs. King for a Day, Wonderland, My Bird Performs, Dying/Sacrificial Bonfire, Grass, Generals and Majors, etc. Andy is a genius, of course, but Colin doesn’t get the credit he deserves, IMO. His backing vocals on a lot of Skylarking make the album for me.
Hey Paul, I have the original Lp without "Dear God", and the revised edition vinyl. I don't understand your point. "Dying" was not the song removed to fit on "Dear God". "Mermaid Smiled" was.
Will Harris this is consistent with my edition which was the earliest distributed in the US. In fact I had to buy the single of Dear God b/w Mermaid Smiled to get the latter.
I totally agree with this POV. This is why I so enjoy Colin. Thanks for this!
Thanks for watching Kathryn, glad you enjoyed the video.
I am touched by your very thoughtful review. You groked it. Thank you. (My Bird Performs)
Thanks, you're welcome and glad you enjoyed it.
An excellent presentation. You have a great way with words.
Like Paul McCartney, if Colin had never written a song or even sang, he would be recognized by some, as being one hell of an amazing bass player.
Yeah true, I didn't even mention his bass playing! Thanks for the nice feedback.
halcyon289 he’s definitely in my top 5 bassists ever.
Great that you have recognised the wonderful Colin Moulding from XTC.! I would have stuck 'Generals & Majors' in the Top 3 along with 'Making Plans for Nigel' - two classic Colin hits. x LOVE XTC x - all members brought some magic!
Very true! Thanks for watching.
How about a Top 10 of the great Andy Partridge songs too? So many to choose from...
Ursulauu very true. No Thugs In Our House is probably my favorite Andy song. Or All You Pretty Girls.
Can’t believe I’ve only just seen this. I obviously was never Making Plans for watching it. Terrific video James. Thank you
Better late than never....glad you enjoyed it!
I love all these equally: Set Myself on Fire, English Roundabout, Runaways, Plans for Nigel, Generals and Majors, What in the Wold, My Bird Performs.
His "Fly on the Wall" is like no other song. Fine and evocative stuff!
Very true....thanks Jeff.
That one doesn't get enough love.
great insight into Colin's contributions - agree with many of your choices for top 10- I remember the Sun - especially! Thanks!
You're welcome...glad you enjoyed it, David.
Thanks for flagging up Colin Moulding. I've always loved the immense tenderness and sensitivity in his lyrics and his detailed observations. His poetic expression through English melancholy has always hit the spot. I've always admired his loving observation of the lives of his parents and his parents generation. That generation that went through the disciplined 30's, through the horrors of WW2 and out the other side; only to be confronted the crazy, rapid change they witnessed in the psychedelic 60's. Songs like e.g. 'Bungalow', 'Dying', 'In Loving memory of a Name', 'Frivolous Tonight' are all so respectful to that now; past generation. I was a professional bass player in the 80's and having been inspired by Paul McCartney's bass playing as a boy and a teenager, it was Colin's creative bass lines, that were my next source of inspiration through my 20's.
Great comment, thanks.
Hands down, the best narrative on XTC that I've ever heard. Absolutely brilliant commentary.
Cheers, glad you enjoyed it and appreciate the nice feedback.
1980 was when I stumbled on Drums and Wires. I still listen to that album, and virtually all of their albums to this day. That's the only band I can say that about. Colin is a great songwriter. I Remember the Sun is a masterpiece...but so many of their songs are great. He supplied a great balance to Andy....both prolific and wonderful and ARTFUL songwriters. But Colin seemed to offer some relief to the jagged, brash, off color chords that possibly was Andy's trademark. Colin, the more soothing musician. Together, it was perfect. Colin is also probably my favorite bass player of all time. He played moments. There was always artistry and taste in his choices, and he buoyed or augmented the melodies of songs...for instance, in Stupidly Happy a train is referenced in the lyrics, and in that place Colin actually plays the feel of a train. He's just very good, subtle, and elegant on the fretless bass. I might have put Dying, Sacrificial Bonfire, and Ten Feet Tall on my list of top tens....but I'm happy to see his work in the spotlight. (The Drums and Wires album cover has to be one of the greatest album covers of all time...to me, it's just as great as what's inside) Anyway, I enjoyed this video.
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it.
I used to prefer Andy's songs, but this has been changing the last couple of years. Currently my most favourite XTC/Dukes tune is "Vanishing Girl". But your list is absolutely great anyways! Expecially thanks for all these amazing background informations!
I wish Colin would make his own album. I'd grab it in a heartbeat!!!
He kind of did with TC & I about two years ago. Played a couple of sold out gigs with Terry Chambers on drums, then abruptly/sadly called it quits.
Great observations, thanks so much! XTC is my favourite band of all times - Love the vid
Really good info. What is cool for me is that when song titles are mentioned, I know these songs! I can bring them to mind immediately!
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed it!
@@jamesgriffithsmusic Good job on the video.
My favourite Colin songs include One of the Millions and from their alter egos, The Dukes of Stratosphear, The Affiliated and The Vanishing Girl. Even though you didn't include my favourites, I really enjoyed your musings.
Thanks!
Vanishing Girl #1
Skylarking remains my favorite of their albums, and both Andy's and Colin's songs are amazing. Around this same period, the two Dukes of Stratosphere Lps still bring me joy.
My Bird Performs is my favorite Colin and favorite XTC song in general. He was so underrated within the band. XTC is my absolute favorite band by far. The 2 of them are a songwriting pair on par with Lennon-McCartney, imo and made some of the best pop songs ever. Colin’s work on Skylarking is the most experimental it’s ever been. Grass and Sacrificial Bonfire are excellent. Really enjoyed your video. I’m definitely a new fan of your channel.
Hi James .. I’m really enjoying your videos .. I’m lucky enough to have seen xtc live in Manchester in 1980.. speaking to many people I’ve come to realise not many people seem to have seen them . I bought drums and wires when it came out and for a few years they were my favourite band . As time has passed they’ve been rediscovered by so many people .. keep up the good work James .. all the best for 2019 happy digging .. best wishes rob
Thanks Robert, appreciate the comment and glad you enjoyed the video. I wish I'd seen XTC in their hey-day!
I wasn't aware until recently how many of the great XTC songs were written by Colin. So much talent in this band.
Thanks Geoff.
Thanks for your tutorial and, overall, to xtc 4 this amazing music. Max - Sardinia
You're welcome, thank you for watching.
King for a day, always moves me while I'm doing the ironing .👍🏻
I like your description of the "difficult" Andy songs. "Train Running Low on Soul Coal" or "... Donkey Up" are examples of ones I can't stomach. However, "You're the Wish You Are I Had" is a counterpoint. It shines.
Fantastic!
XTC, one of the best bands ever. They were the Kinks of the 80s and 90s. Underrated, under appreciated and brilliant. Songwriting akin to Something Else and Village Green., but more angular musically, like no other band.
Thanks Bill, yes definitely some common ground between XTC and the Kinks.
That painting on the wall reminds me of the albumcover of Strange Fright by The Band ☺️
Just stumbled onto this can’t wait to check it out XTC so good the whole Effen catalog
Outstanding effort Professor James. I was getting a little bit anxious to see if you were going to dive into Nonsuch. But sure enough you pulled out one of my all time favorite Colin Moulding vocals on 'My Bird Performs'. There has late night XTC listening sessions where I have really studied their music. I think it is safe to say that I have got goosebumbs while listening to both Andy and Colin's songs. This is proof purchase that you are a longtime fan of the band. Two XTC related items that I am proud of is my copy of Nonsuch on vinyl and also my ticket stub from 1/29/80. The late show out of two.
Well done again James. I would love to chat with you about everything XTC for about sixteen hours~
Rob/Boston
Hi Rob. It's great that you've got a vinyl copy of Nonsuch...funnily enough I was just wondering the other day whether the record had been released on LP, and I searched for it online but couldn't find it. Amazing that you got to see them as well, given how early into their career they gave up touring. Hope you have a great festive season, and speak to you soon.
Wow, spot on list!
I'd like to call atention to two Dukes Of Stratosphere tracks, 'Vanishing Girl' and 'The Affiliated', which are also great
I know, I love the Dukes tracks. Thanks for watching.
@@stephenkulakowski1040 agreed, love the hokey 60's lyrics too.
Bloody great vid, James. Thanks for that!
You're very welcome!
Colin always put a magic touch on the XTC, my favorite.
Thanks Max.
Great video James. That piano break on Runaways is one of my greatest moments on vinyl, ever. The first time I heard it it sent a chill up my spine and I knew I would love this band for ever. I could probably come up with at least 10 more Colin songs which I love, but this is a good list. Can’t wait to see Colin & Terry play live at the end of October, it will be an emotional moment, that’s for sure!
Thanks Paul, glad you enjoyed the vid. Wish I could get to Colin and Terry, but it's too far away from me.
Colin said in an interview that if all goes well they may play in London, if that’s any easier for you! Cheers James this XTC video led me to discover your channel so I’ve been enjoying catching up on loads of your stuff. BTW if you’re ever on the South coast check out Wow & Flutter in Hastings, it’s my favourite record shop!
superb video about a band a bit forgotten and underrated except by true listeners and more often musicians ... especialy bass players...;-))
Thanks Olivier!
10 feet tall, king for a day,Nigel.
Thanks for the video. Xtc is a band that I enjoy quite a few songs from but I don't know a lot about them, I need to change that. Merry Christmas and a happy new year.
Thanks, and the very same to you.
Any hardcore XTC fan is a friend o MINE! ✌️👏👏👍👍
Cheers, thanks for watching!
Great review. Thanks.
Many people identify Colin Moulding by "Making Plans ...", but there is so much more. You shone your expert torchlight on the various Colin Moulding styles. He's the master of irresistible hooks and rhythms, and his vocals occasionally are unbelievable. I somehow have the feeling he only contributed a song when he was absolutely sure to have something very special.
That list you did is truly a very clever one, highly recommended! Ball and Chain at the end ... and there is so much more.
Thanks Peter, much appreciated.
Hi James, great to see appraisal for the Paul McCartney of XTC. I think your list of 10 CM songs is on the mark. Again an interesting subject, makes me want to read that book. Thanks for sharing and a happy christmas to you and your family
-Johan
Many thanks Johan, and the same to you and yours.
I wouldn’t quite call him the McCartney unless you mean he was the pure “pop” writer of the band compared to Lennon/Andy’s more experimental tracks. Macca was much more of a dominant force within the Beatles than Colin was within XTC.
Standing In For Joe, The Affilliated, What In The World, Washaway, Dying... the list is endless. I love them all.
The Affiliated is a great song.
Very informative, astute and unusually enthusiastic!
Making Plans For Nigel is definitely #1 but like other commenters, I'd have had Generals & Majors in there, too.
Really enjoyed your video. A great band and the recent doc on Sky Arts is one of the best music docs I’ve ever seen. You are spot on about Skylarking - it has a strong feel of a Wiltshire summer. A teenage summer with that hot sun and a country lane cycle ride. English Settlement is my favourite album but then, Apple Venus vol 1 is incredible from start to finish. You put a lot of time into this vid - much appreciated.
Thanks really appreciate the feedback.
English Settlement is my favorite as well. Skylarking gets all the attention, and rightfully so, but something about ES touched me on a different level when I first heard it.
an excellent description
Thank you kindly
Cheers, Mate! Excellent Video....I too any thrilled to have discovered XTC here in America. I'm unable to make a top 10 because all of them are crammed in at #1. :) XTC are my absolute favorite band. I feel Colin, Andy and Greg all deserve equal credit for bringing such wonderful music into the world! Thanks, James for such a great review.
You're welcome Scott, glad you enjoyed it.
Leaving out Generals & Majors as well as Life begins at The Hop! You cheeky bastard.
Epic video! I am a HUGE XTC fan! I would love to see a similar video for Andy or your take on their catalogue. Tying into your prog comment, I found it interesting Steven Wilson remixed Drums and Wires, Skylarking, Oranges and Lemons and Nonsvch recently in 5.1!
Hi Christopher. Glad you enjoyed the video....I'll try and put together another XTC video later this year. I have a couple of new XTC vinyl pick-ups to show.
Thank you for this James. It was quite the tutorial for me. Since meeting yourself, Jeff, and Sean, I’ve been trying to fill that XTC void in my life. I loved how you spoke the lyrics like poetry. Imagery is such an important part of music for me. I can’t wait to delve further into Colin’s music and also Andy’s. Happy Holiday’s,
-Brian
Thanks Brian, glad you enjoyed it. Happy cooking! Or is it eating now??
James Griffiths - Still cooking!!! Haha
Very enjoyable always loved Nigel it was so different when it came on TV
Thanks John.
Great block of tracks from Colin. I would add Sacrificial Bonfire. Also love Colin's cover of Pink Floyd's Brain Damage.
I haven't heard Colin doing Brain Damage!
Great video James. We do tend to forget that XTC might be Andy's band but the contribution of Colin in the song writing scheme is essential. A band that kept getting better album after album instead of fading. If you love XTC, you are part of a very lucky few.
Cheers Erik.
To be fair Colin did write 1/3 of the tracks and most of the hits. Quite an accomplishment but Andy’s dominant personality kind of overshadows Colin’s more quiet demeanor.
Andy Partridge released the Go+ and Take Away dub albums, which also showed that he was more experimental. Excellent video, by the way.
Thanks Simon! Just heard that Colin has some new material coming out.
Great video paying a so much deserved homage to Colin! "Life Begins at the Hop", "Teen Feet Tall" and "War Dance" are some favourites of mine.
Merry Christmas!
Compliments of the season! Thanks for watching.
Thanks for reminding me why I love this band! Others i'd have are In loving memory of a name (Mummer) and Cross wires from White music, which kind of sounds like an Andy song.
Nice job you made me get up my copy of complicated game.
That's a book I need to get.
@@jamesgriffithsmusic I'm honestly surprised you haven't already got it-- you're quite well informed.
I Remember the Sun...Exquisite
Yeah, love it.
Thanks for making the video James, I really enjoyed that. It's only been in recent years that i've started listening to XTC. Prior to that I knew 1 song - Making Plans For Nigel. Not too long ago I heard a song that I liked, subsequently discovered it was XTC and then bought English Settlement as a result. I was shocked at how good it was and so not long after I purchased Skylarking and that was as good, if not better. I know i've shown the former on a video quite some time ago but not that latter so i'll do that next month actually, thanks for the reminder!
Thanks, I thought you’d like XTC
Absolutely awesome video! I’m am huge XTC fan in the US. Great job!
Thanks Aden, glad you enjoyed it.
I'm a bit late with my reply as just found your channel James & a huge Colin & XTC fan here James & my top 10 Colin songs are as follows....
10 - Washaway
9 - Shiny Cage
8 - Ball & Chain
7 - Deliver Us From The Elements
6 - One Of The Millions
5 - Blame The Weather
4 - Making Plans For Nigel
3 - Bungalow
2 - Runaways
1 - I Remember The Sun.....
Thanks Stevie, appreciate the comment and you list!
Very interesting overview, XTC fans need more of this. PS Xmas does this kind of thing to me as well
Thanks Steve! I think I subbed to you last week, but haven't paid you a call yet. I'll do that right now.
@@jamesgriffithsmusic no problem, defo be going to look at some more of your vids, cheers
As much as I enjoy this video it is nice to read other people's top ten songs and it has made me realise how many great songs that Colin wrote. My own top ten would have included Ten Feet Tall, Life Begins At The Hop and my personal favorite, The World Is Full Of Angry Young Men.
Yeah, Angry Young Men is great. As is The Smartest Monkeys.
Finally unearthed this Christmas present, James! I definitely gained a deeper appreciation on Colin’s songwriting. And your breakdown of the arrangements was stellar. And ending with NIGEL was great, interesting how the factory jobs and pensions look like from today’s generation. I never made the connection between Blur and Colin before, being American I guess I was oblivious to it but I totally see it now that you mention it, wild. Ok, I really like the Dukes THE AFFILIATED, I think that is Colin’s. And his last song I think with the band, I think the song is YES? Or something, it is a bonus track on the Apple Venus 7” collection. And one more, his track with the PROG COLLECTIVE was was great as well. Very stylish bass player as well. Cheers, man! This was great! Chris
Thanks Chris, glad you enjoyed it!
Thank you very much, James, for the thoughtfulness in giving Colin's songs the much-deserved attention. It would probably be easiest for me to list a Moulding song per XTC album (before additional tracks were brought to CD releases), or to solely feature b-sides, but here's my own list, which is subject to change at any given moment due to the quality of sentiment that I carry throughout his discography; I'd actually like to extend it to twenty, but.... :D :
1. The Good Things (demo version)
2. Runaways
3. Wake Up
4. Big Day
5. Deliver Us from the Elements
6. Find the Fox
7. The World is Full of Angry Young Men
8. Fly on the Wall
9. Didn't Hurt a Bit
10.Vanishing Girl
Good list Jason.
James Griffiths Thank you, James. I soon realized how difficult a task it was to list only ten of Colin's songs, as I suspect you had initially felt as well.
#7 yes! I couldn't think of that title.
Thank you for this excellent video- best wishes for 2018.
Thanks and the same to you.
I personally think that my two favourite Colin songs have to be King For A Day and Deliver Us From the Elements. Both are just absolute art pieces in themselves
Agreed, both great. Surprisingly, Colin himself doesn't rate King for a Day.
Perfect Christmas morning viewing James. Colin Moulding wrote some great songs. Life Begins At The Hop was my introduction to the band. I must admit I need to catch on later XTC. I always thought that Colin had the pop sensibilities within the band. Have a great day today.
Thanks Steve, merry Christmas!
Your description of “My Bird Performs” is perfect. My #1 Colin song.
Thanks Steve.
Terry Chambers left the band (I think) at the beginning of the sessions for mummer. Very good presentation of colins' song writing. I love general & majors, English round about, the meeting place, the smartest monkeys and war dance.
But my list would have to have Ten Feet Tall and fly on the wall and English roundabout.
I'm intrigued. Never heard of this band. Thanks Professeur.
But you must Paul, you must!
Definitely do a deep dive into their catalogue. My favorite band ever.
Hey James, glad you divested those lights off yourself early on - had me a bit worried for your safety there... this is yet another illuminating video on a subject dear to your heart. I like how you place these songs in context and dig deeper as to just WHY they work, why they move you. Never knew Runaways was Moulding, always enjoyed that song, but my word I did not know the lyrics behind it!! It's amazing hearing the songwriting progression in this video as well. I really need to investigate more XTC... thanks again for this video, James.
Sorry Dean, I did read your comment at the time but I obviously neglected to reply to it. Glad you enjoyed the video...yeah I was surprised when I finally sat down to read the lyrics of Runaways. Hope you do get to check out some XTC...
My top10
10. In Loving Memory Of A Name
9. King For A Day
8. That Is the Way
7. Vanishing Girl
6.Ten Feet Tall
5. Wake Up
4. Deliver Us From the Elements
3. English Roundabout
2. Frivolous Tonight
1. I Remember the Sun
"Vanishing Girl" is my all time favorite Colin Moulding song.
Great track.
Hi, there is a great new Andy Partridge interview in the magazine Swindon Heritage from the Winter 2017 issue. One of the best I’ve read. Andy visits loads of Swindon landmarks that shaped the XTC vision. My mum got me it for Christmas. Worth seeking out. Cheers.
Thanks for that. Is that magazine available nationally, i.e.WH Smiths??
Not a national publication but you can find out more at their website which is Swindonheritage.com. All a very good read.
I really appreciate your video. Thanks. In the beginning it seems your view is a competition between the two. I think they have always collaborated together. Merry Christmas!
Cheers, glad you enjoyed it.
Ten Feet Tall...absolute fave Colin Moulding song. End of.
Great video James. Nice that you didn't just focus on the obvious and included a few gems from the often overlooked Wasp Star. Didn't Hurt A Bit and Blame the Weather would be my additions to the list.
Great video James!
Colin is such an underrated force in XTC. It’s great to see him spotlighted.
I really need to listen to Nonsuch more. I’ve only heard it once and have no recollection of it.
Thanks Sean! You must be sick of the sight of me though. I'd largely forgotten Nonsuch before I started researching this video. I had to put it on the ipod and spend some car time with it. It's a good album but too long...came out in the CD era so probably has at least 4 surplus songs on it.
Underrated?! Hardly.
this wouldn't be my list, but I can't argue with any of the choices here. Love the top 3 in particular. Wonderful list.
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it.
Hey James, so late to this video but today I got inspired because I received a copy of "English Settlement" and to my surprise it was signed by Colin, Andy, and Dave. I had no idea the copy I ordered would be signed and apparently neither did the seller, as it's on the back of the record and he didn't notice it. Well anyway I really enjoyed this video and as usual it's like an education watching you. Thanks for making excellent, informative videos. I hope you are doing well. - James
Hi James, wow that's unbelievable, you must have been so excited to get that. Can't wait to see it! Thanks for dropping by, always a pleasure.
VinylCollector James , You lucky dog!
BassByTheBay I know! What a surprise it was !
Cheers for this - really interesting commentary on Colin Moulding songs. Definitely the more Mcartneyesque and accessible songwriter in XTC. Great to see Bungalow in there. I think the recent 'Scatter Me' is one of his best yet. What do you reckon? I'd also put In Loving Memory of a Name up there!
Yeah, both great tracks. I could have done a whole other video.
Great narrative
Thanks!
OMG! JK! I initially watched this with judgement in my heart but I appreciate your appreciation for these guys. Colin is one of my all-time- favorite musicians & writers. Thank U. F
Hi James. Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching.
King for a Day I'm a bit obsessed with at the moment. Such a well crafted, light pop song with a slightly darker undertone in the lyrics.
Great song Alex, surprisingly political if you study the lyrics!
Great essay James, thank you. Should you be able to contact Colin, perhaps ask him to release a compilation of his songs with or without XTC??? If you would be so kind. For the first twenty years of my life I was Nigel. Thanks again.
Rewatching this video as i go deeper into XTC!!!! When's your top 10 andy partridge tunes haha..??
Good point! Will try to do it this year. Thanks Peter.
Colin's great gift was simply an ear for a wonderful tune. Songs such as Generals and Majors, Blame the Weather, English Roundabout, In Loving Memory of a Name, Grass, Wonderland, I Remember the Sun, Big Day, Cynical Days, and many more contain such glorious melodies. My personal favourite is My Bird Performs - a song that starts quite innocuously but builds and builds into the most glorious masterpiece with so many threads fused together. Although it's quite a clumsy comparison, Colin was Macca to Andy's Lennon. The Beatles will always be the greatest band ever for many reasons, but XTC were the nearest anybody got to them. I have to say also that I thought Colin's songs on the last two albums were a bit mediocre, but he contributed dozens of wonderful songs to the XTC catalogue as well as being a brilliant bassist and vocalist.