The one flaw in y'alls critique: the problem isn't that the material isn't challenging, it's that their blend is so perfect and so effortless, it seems less challenging than it is. Y'alls bodies were telling the tale, rocking and bopping throughout, with every song, even if y'alls conscious minds haven't caught up yet.
With Red Velvet you get two different types of concepts. Their Red side is a more cutesy poppy sound, and their Velvet side is more of a dark r&b sound.
The red and velvet aren't necessarily about the sound of the songs. It's more about the overall concept/combination of visuals used for the mv, the lyrics, etc. hence why russian roulette, feel my rhythm and ice cream cake are a combination of red and velvet while peekaboo for instance is more velvet, etc. There are also many variations/layers when it comes to "red" and "velvet" there are lighter more "upbeat" velvet songs too.
I love the fact that everyone who reacted to Red Velvet on Killing Voice was shocked by Wendy vocals. She is the ultimate K-pop boss in vocal potential, no one is above her.
Agreed. And I hate the fact that people don't even know that Irene is Red Velvet's Main Rapper. She gets over-looked and completely ignored ALL THE TIME. It's a damned shame.
Just because they make it look easy doesn't mean what they're doing is actually easy. RV songs are freaking hard to sing. Did you guys even hear the notes Wendy hit during the video? A lot of RV songs already starts pretty high especially Red side songs that's why they don't seem to go up on notes that much
Pretty hard as singer nor as a person whose hobby is to sing,, red velvet songs are hard coz most of it used HEADTONE technique.. Reason why some kpop idols rn u weren't see them sing as a real singers bcoz Kpop idols esp girl grp today's only rely on their natural voice which is the chest tone technique. prettily they need some stamina which is why almost of them doesn't do belt as much as is it. They're more comfortable to used their natural tone and if they sing high note they must need to require aside frm chest tone HEADTONE is much much important to singers. thats the western singers had like ariana to hit those high note. The whistle sounds thats the HEADTONE technique.
Not sure how high you guys want them to go (because it’s pretty high enough by Kpop standard already), they are known for their versatility and harmony in their song with the high notes for Wendy (and sometimes Seulgi/Joy) but that’s not only the focus of the song.
I was hesitant to finish their reaction but I still gave it a try. I shouldn't have finished it lol! Maybe they can try to check the WHOLE songs first before jumping into conclusion about the song choices they have in this killing voice and how high they want them to go.
Fr, their comments were a little odd. I was a little hesitant to finish the video, but I did😅 They definitely need to check out these songs in their entirety and then make comments - because they clearly don’t know much….
its fine if u dont like red velvet’s music. its not that they “have potential” to be good. they are completely stable in their careers and have 2 solidified aspects to their music; the red and velvet. they have been around for over 10 years and are all incredible vocalists who are known for their unique music style.
Red Velvet is a top tier 3rd generation girl group. Honestly, they are higher tier than Blackpink or Twice. The reason people outside the country don't know is that the main vocalist, Wendy, fell off the stage and got seriously injured before the comeback. She almost died from serious injuries. So when overseas fans started listening to K-pop, they were not able to promote at all. Red Velvet is the team with the prettiest, best singing, and best dancing members among all three generations.
Almost died? How much do you need to exaggerate to win sympathy? She was severely injured, yes. Almost died? C'mon man, this is why no one ever listens to fans when trying to find facts...
On December 25, 2019, Red Velvet member Wendy had an accident when she fell while trying to climb a two-meter lift during a rehearsal for the 2019 SBS Gayo Daejeon held at Gocheok Sky Dome in Guro-gu, Seoul. Shortly after the accident, her agency, SM Entertainment, reported that Wendy suffered serious injuries including facial injuries and fractured her right pelvis and wrist, and is currently in hospital for treatment. The accident left Wendy with injuries that lasted at least six weeks. She fractured her right pelvis and wrist, and her right cheekbone was cracked. She had multiple bruises all over her body. Recovery is expected to take several months. Wendy is currently undergoing a thorough examination at a hospital in Seoul, where the swelling at the location of the injury makes it difficult to make an accurate diagnosis. Red Velvet will only perform on individual stages in the future. Leader Irene will be the MC for KBS-2TV's 'Song Festival' to be held on the 27th2. The accident shocked Red Velvet members and fans.@@mentalmaker03
I love Red Velvet because they play a lot with their own name when making songs. They have Red concept songs that are more pop, refreshing and playful and they have Velvet concept songs with more R&B and ballad styles. Sometimes they combine their concepts and make a completely Red Velvet comeback and it's very fun.
RV is a girlgroup far more focused on harmonies and blending, not really ur typical belting group, tho some members can do it. They're a mix of pop and r&b group. They're also credited for having such experimental whimsical music.
Wendy the first one on the left is coming back with her second mini album Wish You Hell on March 12! Majority of the tracks are rnb already sounding AOTY
As a Moomoo I agree, Wendy is the best main vocalist in a kpop girl group. Solar from Mamamoo comes a close second, with Wheein and Hwasa closely behind. Fun fact. Besides being the two best female kpop main vocalists, Wendy and Solar share the same birthday.
My first time here so thanks for reacting to RV. I love their discography but you didn't seem to vibe with it much except for One of These Nights and Kingdom Come which is okay. I think the build up you are looking for can be hard in Killing Voice as the snippets are quite short. But more than high vocals which Wendy does, RV is known for their melodies, harmonies and adlibs so if you enjoy that, would recommend diving into their discography.
finally red velvet🥳they are basically the female counterpart of exo, the same company, impressive vocals (not only the high notes count, but their agility is great) all rounder members and who unfortunately have received the same mistreatment from the company and from some kpop stans, just for making music for the artist, not for the masses, thanks for reacting to the killing voice, that's just a glimpse of what they can do, I recommend you look at a guide❤
I guess I can kind of understand your complaints because their vocals do fit one type of genre of music very well. But what is appealing about them to most fans is that they're chameleons, in that they could do any genre of music and do it well. It feels like you were underestimating their music because of some weird focus on their vocal colors. Oh well, not everyone needs to like them. I'm just disappointed that you distracted yourselves too much to really enjoy the music.
@@ds-zd9qz i don't know either. Maybe it because Wendy is the best female vocalist of the third generation. Seulgi would be a main vocalist in pretty much 90% of girlgroups. And despite Joy being a SUB vocalist she still better than some lead AND main vocalist in kpop. Especially from recents years. As for Irene and Yeri, despite being rappers, they are proficient at singing within their range and can deliver amazing live performance with little to no effort even while dancing hard choreo. So yeah, I really don't know why people say that Redvelvet are vocals queen. They're obviously overrated and have never proven themself to be amazing vocalist in their songs, variety show, concert or in public. SM (the most exigent and hardest compagny to get into) definitly dropped the ball with debuting them.
Same, only Wendy and Seulgi are the strong singers in Red Velvet. Joy is my bias in Red Velvet but she has a very limited range. Irene can sing well but SM don't give her any opportunities to show it. Yeri imo has the weakest vocal range in the group. Mamamoo are the undisputed kpop vocal queens.
@@ds-zd9qzIrene and yeri definitely could be a lead singers in other kpop groups like todays kpop vocal standards are so low for example le sserafim they barely can sing but still so popular I never understand that
I didn't really understand the constant pressing for higher notes. They were singing really high pitched throughout most of these songs, especially when compared to the general range of female idols. Maybe since they started off singing high, you kept disappointing yourselves when they didn't go dolphin high. You can tell because when they sang in a more typical range, one of yall mentioned that they were singing deep lol. No that wasn't deep at all, they were just singing really high throughout most of the KV and you got used to it. But yes they don't do many *long* dramatic notes in this KV. They showcase their vocal abilities in more ways than just the generic kpop method of holding one note towards the end of a song and pretending to look like they're struggling. One of the reasons I like Red Velvet is their interesting compositions, as opposed to the cookie cutter layout of most kpop (I still love cookie cutter kpop, but I appreciate some weirdness every now and then).
They're from SM, house agency for EXO,NCT,superjunior,tvxq,shinee,boa,girls generation, RIIZE etc ofc they would be good at vocals cause it's SM (vocals powerhouse) .all idols from SM all of them are good vocalists
About their songs 'not showing potential'. i think their songs do fine showing their potential and go well with their concept, dont forget this IS a kpop dance group not a ballad group. With their songs they also have a choreo to dance to and sing to live (more often then not) and by female kpop groups standard their notes go pretty high.
@@riffgroovei can understand them saying mamamoo is better at vocals (even though i dont agree) but saying mamamoos discography is better than red velvet is funny.
@izo7071 Red Velvet's Killing Voice was twice as long as Mamamoo's decauae their discography justifies it. And what put RV over Mamamoo vocally is something that can't be trained. Wendy, Seulgi, and Joy all have such incredibly disparate vocal tones that blend so well together. 5 girls sound like a whole choir.
them saying the songs are not challenging to red velvet when in fact, very few singers could cover their songs at least good if not perfect as they are...... why? because red velvet made it seems so easy.... they have good skills, thts also why some of their songs are experimental and different... you can search "idols covering red velvet songs" and you will see the difference...... the difference im talking about is not about the style, but how the songs turned from great to...meh..
The thing is, Red Velvet always make their song sounds easy, but it is definitely hard for other girl groups to cover 😂 hence why there is a Red Velvet cover by them. Even if there is, few success and most failed miserably haha
I think they were referring to some of the girls lip-syncing along while one is actually singing because it's hard for them to know who is singing? I think? I, for one, find it cute that they love their own music enough to sing along while they perform. 😊
@@mentalmaker03 You're right but unfortunately Dingo Music has gone down the route of not using 100% live vocals. You can clearly see moments when some members are lip syncing, even when their mouths are mostly hidden by those mic filters that are intentionally raised too high on their mic stands. A lot of backing track is used, including studio version backing vocals and main vocals in each song. Live pitch correction mics with slight auto tune, vocal filter effects and post production mastering are used in this Killing Voice performance. Compare this 'live' performance with Mamamoo's live performance and even the raw version which was accidentally uploaded by Dingo Music and you can clearly see the difference between 'live' and live.
I laughed so hard when you guys said their song choices were easy..??? LIKE WHAT??? Maybe they make it look so easy but they have some of the hardest discography in kpop, like what MORE do you guys want? seriously???? U guys want them to be being belting every 3 sec??
not sure how much higher you want these girls to go....the songs already are being sung in the 5th octave often (G5 is usually the limit for most pop belters in the chest voice) during the verses let alone the chorus. But thats kinda of the overall training/talent of these girls, they make everything look insanely easy when its very much not. I would say, if you did enjoy any of these songs, try and listen to the entire song.....Killing Voice is great but they do have to chop up the song to fit all of them in so you're not hearing the song as it was meant/written.
I was waiting till they got to the Velvet section... R&B saving lives. They are a great group who can serve any genre. I love their velvet tracks the most. Wendy, the first one (fox) is just extra and we love her for it. You should listen to their velvet tracks that start at (Peek-a-boo) also add 'Body Talk' & 'Perfect 10'. Their most recent velvet track 'Red Velvet - Underwater' is impeccable R&B, hope you react to the lyrical vid. They vocally came to seduce and take souls. Great reaction guys.
I’ve been a RV fan for years and will say that these ladies are the best “3rd” generation K-pop group. Their versatility is unquestionable. Wendy,Seulgi and Joy are the best of what K-pop has ever put together into one group. Their portfolio is unmatched.
These girls are all about synergy, one thing about red velvet is all the adlibs their songs have and how good their 5 voices match. Every song uses their voices as instruments, that's the highlight of red velvet. I've noticed through this reaction that you guys didn't get that. If you only care about full raw vocal power, that's not what you are getting with their songs or most kpop songs for that matter. However I've noticed you guys seemed to enjoy Wendy, one of the main vocalist, you should probably watch or react to Wendy's Lee Mujin's service because that will blow you away, like what you seem to want from songs.
I highly recommend their cover of “Milky Way”by BoA for her anniversary! I believe it was their first group activity after a hiatus due to Wendy’s injuries
SM Group never failed about vocal... Exo, Red Velvet, Taeyeon next TVXQ NCT and taemin from shinee... Cant wait for more red velvet... Bad boy, psycho,wilside,one of these night etc...
LOL, don't forget after all this is an "idol" group, their songs are for their fans, fans who buy merchandise, go to concert and member's birthday party, etc. Things you old guys like are not necessary those fans will like. Also unlike in killing voice, when they do live performance, need do dancing the same time
Red Velvet fandom name : ReVeluv. Red Velvet MVs (The playlist has all of their MVs) : ruclips.net/p/PLG9J3dru6j3vR8BZ2HlBI8D_k2pDOMj27&feature=shared My recommendations : "A Complete Helpful Guide to Red Velvet 2023 Part 1 - Who's Who" by park baebae "A Complete Helpful Guide to Red Velvet 2023 Part 2 - Who's Who" by park baebae "an actually helpful guide to red velvet! (2023)" by seulgistars
its SM vocal as expected, their in the same company with EXO and NCT 😁, The harmony in the song is what SM signature and compare to other girlgroup nowadays they are top tier, only SM group can compare with SM group in term of vocal
I feel you guys, tbh we as fans really want more songs like Kingdom Come and Time to Love because we know RED VELVET CAN SING. But, in Kpop it nearly impossible for groups to have a such a soulful song that you mention through out the video. Even Red Velvet is one of few at top on terms of versatility in kpop
Bruh, the reason why i cant casually sing their tracks is because of how high the keys/notes are lol if they will go higher than that? Only Beyonce and the Diva queens can sing their tracks 😭😭😭
Only 3 groups EVER!!!! Have had 3 #1 albums in the same year.... the Beatles, BTS, and Red Velvet... They are going on their 11th year strong... Pfft terrible takes here
idk if you're referring to wendy or seulgi with the fox hair... anyways, seulgi has a solo w/c has a dark/villain concept! hope you could react to her works! she's a great dancer and vocalist 💕
Hi! I really enjoyed your reaction! Your frustration is warranted, but it also definitely has to do with the snippets of songs chosen. Considering your comments, here are my recommendations for you, as a long time ReVeLuv: - Feel My Rhythm/Psycho: I mention these two first because artistically, they are the same. These may seem subtle at first, but I promise you, they are powerhouse songs in every sense of the word, song and music video. Based on your reactions to the beginning parts of both, it is WELL worth for you to listen to the whole thing. - Really Bad Boy: That song is one of the most challenging songs in Kpop. They hit some brilliant notes and it’s an experience to watch. - Either Russian Roulette or Peek a Boo: These are classic Red Velvet music videos and you’ll get an experience of Red Velvet’s concept here. As others have explained their dual side, you’ll get to see their Velvet side a bit more and see part of what makes them so interesting as a group. It’s super fun to watch. BONUS: Kingdom Come (a fan favourite in B sides- actually, the ENTIRE Perfect Velvet album), Underwater from their new Chill Kill album, Bye Bye and Zoom from The Reve Festival 2022 : Birthday, La Rouge from The Reve Festival Finale (another fan favourite- if I’m correct, it was actually a special release because it was a song from their tour, and it got so popular that they released it.) I apologise for the long and highly detailed comment, but I hope you’ll take some suggestions from here! Any other ReVeLuvs, please pitch in any other songs!
I don't like the way they were laughing during the Red side tracks and they went so silent during the Velvet tracks. Lol! They thought these girls came to just play but nah 🤣🤣🤣 *didnt enjoy the reax tho, non reveluvs who doesn't even know sings even tho they clearly zooming in on who's singing is plainly bl!ND 😭
Was meant as a compliment. Like their voices are better than the songs. Further explanation: while listening to Red Velvet, their voice were so good that we did not pay attention to the song. We did not mean any disrespect.
How so? We enjoyed them and only wanted to hear more of their voices? We did not mean any disrespect.. maybe things came off kinda blunt and straightforward.
Don't blame the girls for holding back on their vocals. SM Entertainment constantly screws these ladies over at every opportunity so it is most likely the company that decided to do the songs a little weird. SM does not promote their artists very well at all. Actually one of the Red Velvet members does a much better job of promoting RV than the company PR Department does. To get an idea of how shady SM really is, the company even had the older four members debut in 2014 without their fifth member; the group was ALWAYS going to be five members, it's just that SM debuted the older four earlier than planned. The Boy Groups in SM were Money Pits at the time and SM was struggling. The company needed a money-maker to cover the difference. So most of these ladies debuted early. The fifth member was deemed 'too young to debut' by somebody; my guess is that her own parents decided that. So she joined the group almost a year later, shortly after her Sixteenth birthday. SHE (the 16-year-old girl) caught ALL KINDS OF HELL from full-grown ADULTS, simply for joining an already-formed group. Yeri had even lived in the dorms with the other four for a few years worth of training. The oldest member and the Group Leader, Irene, was in practice a second Mom and basically finished raising Yeri. The company was SILENT about the bullying and trolling. The members themselves had to defend their maknae because the company did not give a shit about any of them, they were just a cash cow and that's all. That is how fucked up that company STILL is and that is how fucked up the Korean online bullies and Korean internet trolls are.
![Red Velvet - Killing Voice - (Happiness) & More [REACTION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0OMcSvY13YU/mqdefault.jpg)
The one flaw in y'alls critique: the problem isn't that the material isn't challenging, it's that their blend is so perfect and so effortless, it seems less challenging than it is. Y'alls bodies were telling the tale, rocking and bopping throughout, with every song, even if y'alls conscious minds haven't caught up yet.
With Red Velvet you get two different types of concepts. Their Red side is a more cutesy poppy sound, and their Velvet side is more of a dark r&b sound.
Ahhh that's good to know! Thank you
The red and velvet aren't necessarily about the sound of the songs. It's more about the overall concept/combination of visuals used for the mv, the lyrics, etc. hence why russian roulette, feel my rhythm and ice cream cake are a combination of red and velvet while peekaboo for instance is more velvet, etc. There are also many variations/layers when it comes to "red" and "velvet" there are lighter more "upbeat" velvet songs too.
I love the fact that everyone who reacted to Red Velvet on Killing Voice was shocked by Wendy vocals. She is the ultimate K-pop boss in vocal potential, no one is above her.
Agreed.
And I hate the fact that people don't even know that Irene is Red Velvet's Main Rapper. She gets over-looked and completely ignored ALL THE TIME. It's a damned shame.
Just because they make it look easy doesn't mean what they're doing is actually easy. RV songs are freaking hard to sing. Did you guys even hear the notes Wendy hit during the video? A lot of RV songs already starts pretty high especially Red side songs that's why they don't seem to go up on notes that much
Pretty hard as singer nor as a person whose hobby is to sing,, red velvet songs are hard coz most of it used HEADTONE technique.. Reason why some kpop idols rn u weren't see them sing as a real singers bcoz Kpop idols esp girl grp today's only rely on their natural voice which is the chest tone technique. prettily they need some stamina which is why almost of them doesn't do belt as much as is it. They're more comfortable to used their natural tone and if they sing high note they must need to require aside frm chest tone HEADTONE is much much important to singers. thats the western singers had like ariana to hit those high note. The whistle sounds thats the HEADTONE technique.
i dont think theyre musicians lol they may not understand on a deep enough level
its not always about how how high they can sing.
True
Not sure how high you guys want them to go (because it’s pretty high enough by Kpop standard already), they are known for their versatility and harmony in their song with the high notes for Wendy (and sometimes Seulgi/Joy) but that’s not only the focus of the song.
I was hesitant to finish their reaction but I still gave it a try. I shouldn't have finished it lol! Maybe they can try to check the WHOLE songs first before jumping into conclusion about the song choices they have in this killing voice and how high they want them to go.
Fr, their comments were a little odd. I was a little hesitant to finish the video, but I did😅 They definitely need to check out these songs in their entirety and then make comments - because they clearly don’t know much….
Sounds like they never heard RBB (Really Bad Boy) yet 😎
These guys always have weird as hell takes in their Killing Voice reactions lol. They implied Lee Hi is a bad singer for example
My favorite RV video is “Automatic”.
its fine if u dont like red velvet’s music. its not that they “have potential” to be good. they are completely stable in their careers and have 2 solidified aspects to their music; the red and velvet. they have been around for over 10 years and are all incredible vocalists who are known for their unique music style.
Red Velvet is a top tier 3rd generation girl group. Honestly, they are higher tier than Blackpink or Twice.
The reason people outside the country don't know is that the main vocalist, Wendy, fell off the stage and got seriously injured before the comeback. She almost died from serious injuries. So when overseas fans started listening to K-pop, they were not able to promote at all. Red Velvet is the team with the prettiest, best singing, and best dancing members among all three generations.
While Red Velvet are the 2nd best vocal kpop girl group behind Mamamoo, Wendy didn't almost die from her injuries.
Wendy's fall definitely could have ended her career and her ability to sing, but luckily, not severe enough to put her life at risk
I agree with everything escepet about dancing. Its my favourite group but i think Blackpink and Twice have stronger main dancers.
Almost died? How much do you need to exaggerate to win sympathy? She was severely injured, yes. Almost died? C'mon man, this is why no one ever listens to fans when trying to find facts...
On December 25, 2019, Red Velvet member Wendy had an accident when she fell while trying to climb a two-meter lift during a rehearsal for the 2019 SBS Gayo Daejeon held at Gocheok Sky Dome in Guro-gu, Seoul. Shortly after the accident, her agency, SM Entertainment, reported that Wendy suffered serious injuries including facial injuries and fractured her right pelvis and wrist, and is currently in hospital for treatment.
The accident left Wendy with injuries that lasted at least six weeks. She fractured her right pelvis and wrist, and her right cheekbone was cracked. She had multiple bruises all over her body. Recovery is expected to take several months.
Wendy is currently undergoing a thorough examination at a hospital in Seoul, where the swelling at the location of the injury makes it difficult to make an accurate diagnosis. Red Velvet will only perform on individual stages in the future. Leader Irene will be the MC for KBS-2TV's 'Song Festival' to be held on the 27th2.
The accident shocked Red Velvet members and fans.@@mentalmaker03
I love Red Velvet because they play a lot with their own name when making songs. They have Red concept songs that are more pop, refreshing and playful and they have Velvet concept songs with more R&B and ballad styles. Sometimes they combine their concepts and make a completely Red Velvet comeback and it's very fun.
RV is a girlgroup far more focused on harmonies and blending, not really ur typical belting group, tho some members can do it. They're a mix of pop and r&b group. They're also credited for having such experimental whimsical music.
The girl on the far left with short hair called WENDY... She will release her solo album 'WISH YOU HELL' on MARCH 12th🔥
Wendy the first one on the left is coming back with her second mini album Wish You Hell on March 12! Majority of the tracks are rnb already sounding AOTY
Wendy to the left is our very talented main vocalist, who in my opinion is one of the best female vocalists in Kpop❤❤🙌🏾👑
As a Moomoo I agree, Wendy is the best main vocalist in a kpop girl group. Solar from Mamamoo comes a close second, with Wheein and Hwasa closely behind.
Fun fact. Besides being the two best female kpop main vocalists, Wendy and Solar share the same birthday.
My first time here so thanks for reacting to RV. I love their discography but you didn't seem to vibe with it much except for One of These Nights and Kingdom Come which is okay. I think the build up you are looking for can be hard in Killing Voice as the snippets are quite short. But more than high vocals which Wendy does, RV is known for their melodies, harmonies and adlibs so if you enjoy that, would recommend diving into their discography.
Welcome. Yes, we know that the full versions of the songs are the best way to hear them. This was still a great watch!
finally red velvet🥳they are basically the female counterpart of exo, the same company, impressive vocals (not only the high notes count, but their agility is great) all rounder members and who unfortunately have received the same mistreatment from the company and from some kpop stans, just for making music for the artist, not for the masses, thanks for reacting to the killing voice, that's just a glimpse of what they can do, I recommend you look at a guide❤
I guess I can kind of understand your complaints because their vocals do fit one type of genre of music very well. But what is appealing about them to most fans is that they're chameleons, in that they could do any genre of music and do it well. It feels like you were underestimating their music because of some weird focus on their vocal colors. Oh well, not everyone needs to like them. I'm just disappointed that you distracted yourselves too much to really enjoy the music.
Finally, they react to the queens of vocals ❤
=)
lol 2 out of the 5 are good singers. i never understood why red velvet are conisdered vocal queens.
@@ds-zd9qz i don't know either. Maybe it because Wendy is the best female vocalist of the third generation. Seulgi would be a main vocalist in pretty much 90% of girlgroups. And despite Joy being a SUB vocalist she still better than some lead AND main vocalist in kpop. Especially from recents years. As for Irene and Yeri, despite being rappers, they are proficient at singing within their range and can deliver amazing live performance with little to no effort even while dancing hard choreo. So yeah, I really don't know why people say that Redvelvet are vocals queen. They're obviously overrated and have never proven themself to be amazing vocalist in their songs, variety show, concert or in public. SM (the most exigent and hardest compagny to get into) definitly dropped the ball with debuting them.
Same, only Wendy and Seulgi are the strong singers in Red Velvet. Joy is my bias in Red Velvet but she has a very limited range. Irene can sing well but SM don't give her any opportunities to show it. Yeri imo has the weakest vocal range in the group.
Mamamoo are the undisputed kpop vocal queens.
@@ds-zd9qzIrene and yeri definitely could be a lead singers in other kpop groups like todays kpop vocal standards are so low for example le sserafim they barely can sing but still so popular I never understand that
I didn't really understand the constant pressing for higher notes. They were singing really high pitched throughout most of these songs, especially when compared to the general range of female idols. Maybe since they started off singing high, you kept disappointing yourselves when they didn't go dolphin high. You can tell because when they sang in a more typical range, one of yall mentioned that they were singing deep lol. No that wasn't deep at all, they were just singing really high throughout most of the KV and you got used to it.
But yes they don't do many *long* dramatic notes in this KV. They showcase their vocal abilities in more ways than just the generic kpop method of holding one note towards the end of a song and pretending to look like they're struggling. One of the reasons I like Red Velvet is their interesting compositions, as opposed to the cookie cutter layout of most kpop (I still love cookie cutter kpop, but I appreciate some weirdness every now and then).
You seemed to like their velvet side more so I would suggest reacting to
PSYCHO, AUTOMATIC & BAD BOY
be natural too
They're from SM, house agency for EXO,NCT,superjunior,tvxq,shinee,boa,girls generation, RIIZE etc ofc they would be good at vocals cause it's SM (vocals powerhouse) .all idols from SM all of them are good vocalists
About their songs 'not showing potential'. i think their songs do fine showing their potential and go well with their concept, dont forget this IS a kpop dance group not a ballad group. With their songs they also have a choreo to dance to and sing to live (more often then not) and by female kpop groups standard their notes go pretty high.
Best vocals and discograhy in the industry.
Argue with the wall.
Laughs in Mamamoo 😂🤣
@@djvillan Mamamoo doesn't exist anymore.
Try to keep up with current events.
Even when they were, they weren't in RV's league.
@@riffgroovei can understand them saying mamamoo is better at vocals (even though i dont agree) but saying mamamoos discography is better than red velvet is funny.
@izo7071 Red Velvet's Killing Voice was twice as long as Mamamoo's decauae their discography justifies it.
And what put RV over Mamamoo vocally is something that can't be trained. Wendy, Seulgi, and Joy all have such incredibly disparate vocal tones that blend so well together.
5 girls sound like a whole choir.
Thanks for appreciating Red Velvet! You've got to see the m/v's for the songs.🤗🤗
The left one Wendy gonna release her comeback on 12/3. 💙💙💙
them saying the songs are not challenging to red velvet when in fact, very few singers could cover their songs at least good if not perfect as they are...... why? because red velvet made it seems so easy.... they have good skills, thts also why some of their songs are experimental and different... you can search "idols covering red velvet songs" and you will see the difference...... the difference im talking about is not about the style, but how the songs turned from great to...meh..
The thing is, Red Velvet always make their song sounds easy, but it is definitely hard for other girl groups to cover 😂 hence why there is a Red Velvet cover by them. Even if there is, few success and most failed miserably haha
I love this group Red velvet
Music videos propositions:
Bad Boy, Automatic, Be Natural, and Psycho. Their most recent comeback was Chill Kill, the song they sang at the end.
guys no lip syncing on killing voices they have backing tracks, but they are singing live..you cant belittle their singing ability
I think they were referring to some of the girls lip-syncing along while one is actually singing because it's hard for them to know who is singing? I think? I, for one, find it cute that they love their own music enough to sing along while they perform. 😊
@@mentalmaker03 You're right but unfortunately Dingo Music has gone down the route of not using 100% live vocals. You can clearly see moments when some members are lip syncing, even when their mouths are mostly hidden by those mic filters that are intentionally raised too high on their mic stands. A lot of backing track is used, including studio version backing vocals and main vocals in each song. Live pitch correction mics with slight auto tune, vocal filter effects and post production mastering are used in this Killing Voice performance.
Compare this 'live' performance with Mamamoo's live performance and even the raw version which was accidentally uploaded by Dingo Music and you can clearly see the difference between 'live' and live.
I would suggest you to watch Wendy's Lee Mujin service EP. 88 performance. Its best way to understand you fav's potential.
I laughed so hard when you guys said their song choices were easy..??? LIKE WHAT??? Maybe they make it look so easy but they have some of the hardest discography in kpop, like what MORE do you guys want? seriously???? U guys want them to be being belting every 3 sec??
not sure how much higher you want these girls to go....the songs already are being sung in the 5th octave often (G5 is usually the limit for most pop belters in the chest voice) during the verses let alone the chorus. But thats kinda of the overall training/talent of these girls, they make everything look insanely easy when its very much not. I would say, if you did enjoy any of these songs, try and listen to the entire song.....Killing Voice is great but they do have to chop up the song to fit all of them in so you're not hearing the song as it was meant/written.
I waited for this so long just for you guys not to vibe with it lmaoooo
I was waiting till they got to the Velvet section... R&B saving lives. They are a great group who can serve any genre. I love their velvet tracks the most. Wendy, the first one (fox) is just extra and we love her for it. You should listen to their velvet tracks that start at (Peek-a-boo) also add 'Body Talk' & 'Perfect 10'. Their most recent velvet track 'Red Velvet - Underwater' is impeccable R&B, hope you react to the lyrical vid. They vocally came to seduce and take souls. Great reaction guys.
y'all would probably enjoy TVXQ's killing voice
Wait till u watch Peek A-Boo MV then u understand why this song is a cult song for us LOL. And of course they are the Queen of harmony.
*FROM LEFT TO RIGHT* :
WENDY, SEULGI, IRENE (Leader), YERI (Maknae) and JOY.
Music is not a circus act. If you focus on what they're trying to express, you'll be able to dispel doubts about their choice.
I’ve been a RV fan for years and will say that these ladies are the best “3rd” generation K-pop group. Their versatility is unquestionable. Wendy,Seulgi and Joy are the best of what K-pop has ever put together into one group. Their portfolio is unmatched.
My fav kpop girl group 😊.
In my opinion, Red velvet has the best discography in all of kpop girl group ,queen of vocal.
These girls are all about synergy, one thing about red velvet is all the adlibs their songs have and how good their 5 voices match. Every song uses their voices as instruments, that's the highlight of red velvet. I've noticed through this reaction that you guys didn't get that.
If you only care about full raw vocal power, that's not what you are getting with their songs or most kpop songs for that matter.
However I've noticed you guys seemed to enjoy Wendy, one of the main vocalist, you should probably watch or react to Wendy's Lee Mujin's service because that will blow you away, like what you seem to want from songs.
I highly recommend their cover of “Milky Way”by BoA for her anniversary! I believe it was their first group activity after a hiatus due to Wendy’s injuries
finallyyy! another series of killing voice 😭❤️ thank youuu! love this a lotssss 🫶🏻
RED Velvet : AUTOMATIC, PSYCHO, FEEL MY RHYTHM
Honestly I think you guys would like really bad boy, nearly the whole song is lead by their voices and the high notes 😍😍😍
please react to wendy's lee mujin service (the girl on the left)
Exo and red velvet in the same company these two are the vocals monster
Psycho, Bad Boy, Chill Kill, Feel my rythm
SM Group never failed about vocal... Exo, Red Velvet, Taeyeon next TVXQ NCT and taemin from shinee... Cant wait for more red velvet... Bad boy, psycho,wilside,one of these night etc...
thanks for the reaction ! We love red velvet !!
ABSOLUTE VOCAL QUEENS
LOL, don't forget after all this is an "idol" group, their songs are for their fans, fans who buy merchandise, go to concert and member's birthday party, etc. Things you old guys like are not necessary those fans will like.
Also unlike in killing voice, when they do live performance, need do dancing the same time
Only Bulldog is old 🙈🙉🙊
"songs are not challeging them" 🤡
Hahaha
Red Velvet fandom name : ReVeluv.
Red Velvet MVs (The playlist has all of their MVs) : ruclips.net/p/PLG9J3dru6j3vR8BZ2HlBI8D_k2pDOMj27&feature=shared
My recommendations :
"A Complete Helpful Guide to Red Velvet 2023 Part 1 - Who's Who" by park baebae
"A Complete Helpful Guide to Red Velvet 2023 Part 2 - Who's Who" by park baebae
"an actually helpful guide to red velvet! (2023)" by seulgistars
Took you long enough man😭
It be like that sometimes! 🙊🙉🙈
Facts ❤
you guys will definitely like tvxq's killing voice based on your reaction to this
HOLY VOCALS
Killing Voice TVXQ, please
its SM vocal as expected, their in the same company with EXO and NCT 😁, The harmony in the song is what SM signature and compare to other girlgroup nowadays they are top tier, only SM group can compare with SM group in term of vocal
Please do TVXQ Killing voice too.. I'll wait for it :")
Finally what I waiting for
I feel you guys, tbh we as fans really want more songs like Kingdom Come and Time to Love because we know RED VELVET CAN SING. But, in Kpop it nearly impossible for groups to have a such a soulful song that you mention through out the video. Even Red Velvet is one of few at top on terms of versatility in kpop
Is there anyone in your opinion more versatile than RV either rn or anytime during their time cuz I literally don't think there was or is rn
Bruh, the reason why i cant casually sing their tracks is because of how high the keys/notes are lol if they will go higher than that? Only Beyonce and the Diva queens can sing their tracks 😭😭😭
Thankyou i'm so excited❤
Only 3 groups EVER!!!! Have had 3 #1 albums in the same year.... the Beatles, BTS, and Red Velvet... They are going on their 11th year strong... Pfft terrible takes here
Amazing RV!!
Anyway I missed your NCT reaction :(
I assure you they do know what's a russian roulette....go watch their music videos, it's literally their concept
Max Changmin 'Devil' and 'Fever', please
idk if you're referring to wendy or seulgi with the fox hair... anyways, seulgi has a solo w/c has a dark/villain concept! hope you could react to her works! she's a great dancer and vocalist 💕
SM GROUPS FOR THE WIN♥
You guys reaaaally need to react to TVXQ/DBSK's Killing Voice.
You should watch their full mv- psycho, bad boy, feel my rhythm etc
Psycho, Automatic, Bad Boy.
Next tvxq killing voice 🙏
They have easy songs ? lol till this date very few idols dared to cover red velvet songs
red velvet top videos
1. Dumb Dumb
2. Peekaboo
3. All the rest of them equally
Y’all should totally check out Highlight or Infinite’s killing voice next. Both are 2nd gen and are really talented
Ya’ll should’ve listened to RV singing RBB if u wanna hear the VOCALS and then Psycho Live
YASSSSS❤❤❤
웬디 ❤조이❤😊
Is it just me, or is the audio balance off? I can't hear the reactors- I think the song audio is too loud (or the reactors are too quiet).
React to like water by wendy from red velvet you guys are gonna love it for sure
those girls take me to the church.
Hi! I really enjoyed your reaction! Your frustration is warranted, but it also definitely has to do with the snippets of songs chosen. Considering your comments, here are my recommendations for you, as a long time ReVeLuv:
- Feel My Rhythm/Psycho: I mention these two first because artistically, they are the same. These may seem subtle at first, but I promise you, they are powerhouse songs in every sense of the word, song and music video. Based on your reactions to the beginning parts of both, it is WELL worth for you to listen to the whole thing.
- Really Bad Boy: That song is one of the most challenging songs in Kpop. They hit some brilliant notes and it’s an experience to watch.
- Either Russian Roulette or Peek a Boo: These are classic Red Velvet music videos and you’ll get an experience of Red Velvet’s concept here. As others have explained their dual side, you’ll get to see their Velvet side a bit more and see part of what makes them so interesting as a group. It’s super fun to watch.
BONUS: Kingdom Come (a fan favourite in B sides- actually, the ENTIRE Perfect Velvet album), Underwater from their new Chill Kill album, Bye Bye and Zoom from The Reve Festival 2022 : Birthday, La Rouge from The Reve Festival Finale (another fan favourite- if I’m correct, it was actually a special release because it was a song from their tour, and it got so popular that they released it.)
I apologise for the long and highly detailed comment, but I hope you’ll take some suggestions from here! Any other ReVeLuvs, please pitch in any other songs!
Thank you! We will try to come back to this comment and take some songs! But the best place to get our attention is our discord =)
히트곡❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊
한국❤걸그룹 ❤언니 ❤
I don't like the way they were laughing during the Red side tracks and they went so silent during the Velvet tracks. Lol! They thought these girls came to just play but nah 🤣🤣🤣
*didnt enjoy the reax tho, non reveluvs who doesn't even know sings even tho they clearly zooming in on who's singing is plainly bl!ND 😭
Check out their sub unit - Irene and Seulgi - monster mv and naughty mv
Songs are not challenging enough? Bro, can u even sing? 😂
Was meant as a compliment. Like their voices are better than the songs.
Further explanation: while listening to Red Velvet, their voice were so good that we did not pay attention to the song. We did not mean any disrespect.
레드벨벳 🎉🎉🎉같이들어서좋아요 ㅋㅋ
같이들어서좋아요 ❤🎉
I thought you were kind of rude.
How so? We enjoyed them and only wanted to hear more of their voices? We did not mean any disrespect.. maybe things came off kinda blunt and straightforward.
KARA's killing Voice please ❤
Seconded
슬기 ❤
Don't blame the girls for holding back on their vocals. SM Entertainment constantly screws these ladies over at every opportunity so it is most likely the company that decided to do the songs a little weird. SM does not promote their artists very well at all. Actually one of the Red Velvet members does a much better job of promoting RV than the company PR Department does.
To get an idea of how shady SM really is, the company even had the older four members debut in 2014 without their fifth member; the group was ALWAYS going to be five members, it's just that SM debuted the older four earlier than planned. The Boy Groups in SM were Money Pits at the time and SM was struggling. The company needed a money-maker to cover the difference. So most of these ladies debuted early.
The fifth member was deemed 'too young to debut' by somebody; my guess is that her own parents decided that. So she joined the group almost a year later, shortly after her Sixteenth birthday. SHE (the 16-year-old girl) caught ALL KINDS OF HELL from full-grown ADULTS, simply for joining an already-formed group. Yeri had even lived in the dorms with the other four for a few years worth of training. The oldest member and the Group Leader, Irene, was in practice a second Mom and basically finished raising Yeri. The company was SILENT about the bullying and trolling. The members themselves had to defend their maknae because the company did not give a shit about any of them, they were just a cash cow and that's all.
That is how fucked up that company STILL is and that is how fucked up the Korean online bullies and Korean internet trolls are.
OMG FINALLYYYYYYY
=)
You should react to One Of These Nights, Kingdom Come, & automatic!
u guys have react to big mama killing voice!
Yes, soooo good!
Now you guys should react to Twice’s killing voice and Apinks Killing voice as well ❤
Next reaction vvup predebut single.
RedVelvet is so good ❤❤❤❤