I m using tradingview for last 2 years it is easy but no option data is a very big negative ..... who trades only in cash these day. Looks like i wasted a lot of time learning pine script
In any case, from your video.. I feel one must start with TV and use all these functionality and learn and if they master and wanna go next level, then we can move to ami broker with 1 time 26k fee as monthly fee is gonna be same in both cases...
Biggest problem with Amibroker is data cost, unless you are just interested in the NIFTY. Trading View data is cheap as long you as you don't need lots of tick data .
I observe in trading view even in premium package, there is a delay of 2-3 seconds, which is problem in scalping. candle forms after price changes in zerodha. Can somebody who has used Amibroker tell me is this same with amibroker or we can get exact real time data.
@@robotradingkannada Is there a way to include brokerage and other charges by broker incorporated in backtest results by Amibroker? Then only it will be useful, right.
Can multileg option strategies be created and executed through Trading View with brokers like zerodha or Kotak? Content of your youtube video is really very informative.. Thanks a lot..
Does The Free Version of Trading View Provide Real Time Accurate Data, Price During Market Hour Or Real Time Accurate Data, Price Is Shown Only When We Buy It?
Good comparison, but lacks depth. You have glossed over the differences and these are the kind of things that will come back to bite me later. For example, you speak of backtesting. AmiBroker allows me to test a strategy across a selection of stocks at the same time. With TradingView, I can execute a Strategy only on a single scrip at a time. I can use PineScript to bring in data from more scrips but it takes much more coding to do so and the scrip symbols will have to be hardcoded or at least parametrised. Backtest Reports in AmiBroker are surely much superior to those in TradingView. Secondly, TradingView imposes restrictions on what you can do with a paid account. For example, in the Pro version, you can only have 5 Indicators on a chart. You can only have 2 side by side chart panes active. There are restrictions on Noiseless Charts line Point & Figure, Renko etc on lower timeframes. With AmiBroker I can do whatever I like with my charts. I can modify them, view them, etc in any way I wish to with AFL code. No restrictions. Thirdly, TradingView gives you free data - up to a point. EOD data for a scrip if available from the begining. Lower timeframes are restricted. With my Pro TradingView account, I can only see about 6 months of 5 minute data and about 45 days of 1-minute data. Nothing beyond that is visible. Wit AmiBroker, I can see all the data I have imported from my data provider - no restrictions. The Scanner in TradingView is beyond pathetic. I use ChartInk which is another ~700 Rs., per month and I have to program my scanner there, export the scan results to a CSV (Text) file and then import the same into TradingView to create a Watchlist. This is something I do every day. Gets painful very quickly. I have found that I do not know enough to take a call. My needs will keep changing as I trade more and learn new things. TradingView restricts the field of work. AmiBroker does not. I installed AmiBroker recently, after having used TradingView for more than a couple of years now, and I wish I had gone with AmiBroker and invested the time, money and effort that I put into TradingView into AmiBroker instead. I would not be learning AFL from scratch now after already learning Pine Script and hitting the TV imposed boundaries and looking elsewhere to meet my requirements. May I request that you take a single aspect of these platforms, for example, Backtesting, and do another video on it? Such a discourse is very badly needed and I feel you are ideally positioned to do justice to it given the depth of your experience and acquired knowledge.
Can you explain for whom does these software are for? For full time traders? Or for someone like me who has a 9 to 5 job and does regular trading with 2 lakh capital on my mobile
Very nicely done and in a professional way. Keep it up. If you have any paid strategy for monthly or yearly subscription, do let me know and how to connect with you (Twitter or email etc) for this specific need.
2-DAY WORKSHOP IN HYDERABAD & BANGALORE Hey guys, We are planning a 2-day Option Masterclass in Hyderabad (11TH to 12TH DEC, 2021) & Bangalore (18TH to 19TH DEC, 2021)Timings: 9am-6pm; Fees for the 2 days session is 25k. Ideal for someone who wants to get a deep dive into the world of options (no prior background necessary; beginners are welcome). Its going to be really awesome with a lot of real-life strategies and examples. Our goal is to give you the tools and techniques you need to trade options in real-life (not from a bookish perspective). To enroll please visit www.vrdnation.com/workshops1 If you're interested, fill out this form and my team will reach out to you with the details (first-come, first-serve basis). forms.gle/4ovCxCuX1UberQA16 We want to keep it limited so that we can have a better interaction and learning experience. Cheers Phone +91-7331111326 Phone +91-6281316743 Email info@vrdnation.com
![The Ultimate Guide to Amibroker [for Beginners]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LEOUax2gAuw/mqdefault.jpg)
Please join our new channel for more trading related knowledge. The link to the new channel is :
ruclips.net/channel/UCrAEUt-BYT-WbxF_pdcmzkA
Is there a way to include brokerage and other charges by broker incorporated in backtest results by Amibroker? Then only it will be useful, right.
Things you missed -
1-Strategy optimization - amibroker ( very big advantage)
2-Custom time frame- amibroker
3-Monte Carlo simulation- amibroker
Chartink can help in stock screening + tradingview algo can be built in underlying to trade options
Thank You Sir,
Amibroker के विषय में भी कुछ जानकारी मिली.
I m using tradingview for last 2 years it is easy but no option data is a very big negative ..... who trades only in cash these day. Looks like i wasted a lot of time learning pine script
Those who don't trade in algoes or FnO Tradingview is the clear winner
In any case, from your video.. I feel one must start with TV and use all these functionality and learn and if they master and wanna go next level, then we can move to ami broker with 1 time 26k fee as monthly fee is gonna be same in both cases...
Is there a way to include brokerage and other charges by broker incorporated in backtest results by Amibroker? Then only it will be useful, right.
Biggest problem with Amibroker is data cost, unless you are just interested in the NIFTY. Trading View data is cheap as long you as you don't need lots of tick data .
can you please do another comparison video between these two tools, as I see that a lot of features are introduced by TradingView?
Between these two, can you please say, which has higher letency?
Great Video Sir. Your content are awesome as always. Please do a compare best account both full and discount brokers
Which is the low cost and legal data provider for amibroker ?
Amifeed
How much these data vendors charge ? And are these charges recurring?
Thanks for the video.. does amibroker have server version?
Plz compare MT5 vs Tradingview
I observe in trading view even in premium package, there is a delay of 2-3 seconds, which is problem in scalping. candle forms after price changes in zerodha. Can somebody who has used Amibroker tell me is this same with amibroker or we can get exact real time data.
I am using amibroker since 2004. Yes in amibroker too we have 2-3 seconds delay in price updation irrespective of the data provider.
@@robotradingkannada Is there a way to include brokerage and other charges by broker incorporated in backtest results by Amibroker? Then only it will be useful, right.
Thanks, great video!
Can multileg option strategies be created and executed through Trading View with brokers like zerodha or Kotak? Content of your youtube video is really very informative.. Thanks a lot..
Is Sierra Charts functional in India and if yes can you compare that with Amibroker! :) Thank you
Nice comaparision. Could you please make a video on How to integrate Amibroker with broker platforms like Kite(zerodha)
Get bridge from algoji
Thank you ❤️❤️
Thank you rao garu
Monthly data vendors feeds stars from 600 rs.
Undervalued youtuber 😔
I hope one day his channel will give breakout
@@vipinkumar-qr1dq I pray soo
You are really doing a great job sir❣️
Does The Free Version of Trading View Provide Real Time Accurate Data, Price During Market Hour Or Real Time Accurate Data, Price Is Shown Only When We Buy It?
It does provide real time data but in some cases the data is delayed
Great & Good Comparision . . .....🙂
I would say for AmiBroker you also need to be a more advanced programmer.
Very nice explanation please continue
very nice. kindly compare trading view with trendlyne...
Good informative content in all of your videos 🙏
Can you please make a video on how to integrate tradingview with zerodha ! Coz we can use the strategies library available on tradingview and trade
Awesome 👍 kudos👌
Trading view also has desktop application
Great.
Trading View 👌🏻
Can Amibroker installed in multiple systems. Like use same credentials in multiple systems at same time.
No
Sir on what concepts do you trade??I mean on technical analysis?or smart money or any other concept??
Good information 🙏🙏🙏
Trading View is Best
Bhai Trading View Ke Free Version Mein Price Accurate Aur Real Time Mein Dikhta Hai Kya? Ya Uske Liye Khareedna Padega?
Trading has come up with desktop version
Sir do more videos sir...🙏
Good video
👏👏👏
I like Tradingview ✌
First comment, as always.. excellent video
plz make short videos of less than 10 or 7 minute ,who has time to watch this long video
People who want to take this seriously.
that is why people lose money in stock market
If u have no time to make money then simply avoid it to watch.
Good comparison, but lacks depth. You have glossed over the differences and these are the kind of things that will come back to bite me later.
For example, you speak of backtesting. AmiBroker allows me to test a strategy across a selection of stocks at the same time. With TradingView, I can execute a Strategy only on a single scrip at a time. I can use PineScript to bring in data from more scrips but it takes much more coding to do so and the scrip symbols will have to be hardcoded or at least parametrised. Backtest Reports in AmiBroker are surely much superior to those in TradingView.
Secondly, TradingView imposes restrictions on what you can do with a paid account. For example, in the Pro version, you can only have 5 Indicators on a chart. You can only have 2 side by side chart panes active. There are restrictions on Noiseless Charts line Point & Figure, Renko etc on lower timeframes. With AmiBroker I can do whatever I like with my charts. I can modify them, view them, etc in any way I wish to with AFL code. No restrictions.
Thirdly, TradingView gives you free data - up to a point. EOD data for a scrip if available from the begining. Lower timeframes are restricted. With my Pro TradingView account, I can only see about 6 months of 5 minute data and about 45 days of 1-minute data. Nothing beyond that is visible. Wit AmiBroker, I can see all the data I have imported from my data provider - no restrictions.
The Scanner in TradingView is beyond pathetic. I use ChartInk which is another ~700 Rs., per month and I have to program my scanner there, export the scan results to a CSV (Text) file and then import the same into TradingView to create a Watchlist. This is something I do every day. Gets painful very quickly.
I have found that I do not know enough to take a call. My needs will keep changing as I trade more and learn new things. TradingView restricts the field of work. AmiBroker does not.
I installed AmiBroker recently, after having used TradingView for more than a couple of years now, and I wish I had gone with AmiBroker and invested the time, money and effort that I put into TradingView into AmiBroker instead. I would not be learning AFL from scratch now after already learning Pine Script and hitting the TV imposed boundaries and looking elsewhere to meet my requirements.
May I request that you take a single aspect of these platforms, for example, Backtesting, and do another video on it? Such a discourse is very badly needed and I feel you are ideally positioned to do justice to it given the depth of your experience and acquired knowledge.
Can you explain for whom does these software are for? For full time traders? Or for someone like me who has a 9 to 5 job and does regular trading with 2 lakh capital on my mobile
Very nicely done and in a professional way. Keep it up. If you have any paid strategy for monthly or yearly subscription, do let me know and how to connect with you (Twitter or email etc) for this specific need.
2-DAY WORKSHOP IN HYDERABAD & BANGALORE
Hey guys, We are planning a 2-day Option Masterclass in Hyderabad (11TH to 12TH DEC, 2021) & Bangalore (18TH to 19TH DEC, 2021)Timings: 9am-6pm;
Fees for the 2 days session is 25k. Ideal for someone who wants to get a deep dive into the world of options (no prior background necessary; beginners are welcome). Its going to be really awesome with a lot of real-life strategies and examples.
Our goal is to give you the tools and techniques you need to trade options in real-life (not from a bookish perspective). To enroll please visit
www.vrdnation.com/workshops1
If you're interested, fill out this form and my team will reach out to you with the details (first-come, first-serve basis).
forms.gle/4ovCxCuX1UberQA16
We want to keep it limited so that we can have a better interaction and learning experience.
Cheers
Phone +91-7331111326
Phone +91-6281316743
Email info@vrdnation.com