It'd be pretty funny if the Doctor couldn't speak English given that Delta and the Bannermen kind of implies he can speak Welsh. I'm now going to choose to believe this is the case.
Thanks for going into detail on The Watcher: as always, an ambiguous concept or simple side character is made needlessly convoluted by extended Doctor Who media. This is why your series matters: to make some kind of sense of this crap we love so tragically much!
You know the water can be easily explained like is just the gost of the doctor to 4 is having a weird astro Projection thang like the doctors spirit will look weird Because the doctor is a shape Changer Remember time lords come from the same place as witches and vampires the beginning of time Was wild as s***
I watched Sil and the Devil Seeds of Arodor in November 2019, at a public screening. I was actually sat next to Philip Martin throughout, and wasn't too far away from Nabil Shaban. I met Sophie Aldred as well. At the screening, it was explained that this more a character piece rather than a plot-driven story. As such, I thought it was a success. Shaban is brilliant as always, and performances from Sophie Aldred, Christopher Ryan, Sakuntala Ramanee and Janet Henfrey were great. The work that went into it was thoroughly appreciated by all. Clearly, we weren't the only ones, as it would go on to win a Philip K. Dick award. Like most unofficial film projects, it does the best it can with what it's got, and for that it can only be applauded, frankly.
7:29 actually, ya know what? I'd TOTALLY be fine with that if they reveal that the theme song is the doctors name, cause that honestly makes all the sense in the world and can probably fits into every single piece if media the doctor has been apart of, hell maybe the Sarah Jane adventures theme is HER name gallifraien as well just to tie everything in a neat little bow, that's how we end the series honestly, I'm 100% would be fine with that as an ending
6:55 I always interpreted this panel as the Doctor speaking English (as he always does) and the broken translation matrix translating it into an alien language.
Or hes just speaking some random language I mean doesn't missy speak French occasionally He's probably saying like one word in a different language just because he can
I liked to think the 4th Dr became the new White Guardian, then popped up as the curator later. The Watcher regeneration was different because of this. The White Guardian was merging with the 4th Doc. I conceed that this is quite a stretch though.
I rewatched every episode of Broke Canon released so far this year and checked the wiki for each fact and I swear none of them are false I feel like I'm going insane I'm going to rewatch them all again
I really recommend that you give "Watchers" from Big Finish a listen. It's an Audio Novel written by Adric himself (Matthew Waterhouse). It's set directly before Logopolis, provides a whole new layer of context for the following story, and drip-feeds new facets of Gallifrey brand new to this story, and the Watcher itself.
Psha, Sam, of course something can be a programming language and a form of music at the same time! Do you think Fitz earned the nickname “code boy” among the Remote by being part of his schools computing club in the 50s? The programming language was musical-HOLYSHIT THE REMOTE WERE PROGRAMMING IN GALLIFREYAN AND FITZ CAN READ IT NOW I BET
I think the made up fact of series 3 is that the doctor killed millions to eradicate the disease Agent Yellow. He created an antidote called Agent Scarlet. At least, that's what the wiki says.
From what I can find in online reference guides, that fact is indeed true. The Doctor created Agent Scarlet but it failed, so he did… something with singularities that killed six hundred million humans but cured the rest.
There's nothing to say the faulty Translation Circuits of the TARDIS didn't translate the Doctor's speech from English into a completely different alien language and that's what Alice heard.
Thinking about it, there's a Titan story where 11 is hanging in space and he says something which is possibly not English? Like, a caption genuinely says 'Could be an ancient Gallifreyan curse word or his lips are just fused together' and refuses to give us an answer
Somewhere I read a great theory that the Watcher is actually a deteriorating alternate fifth Doctor, who travels back in time due to the entropy seen in Logopolis, with the purpose of changing the future to save the universe so he doesn’t exist. In the original timeline Nyssa didn’t join the Doctor and that’s one of the things the Watcher corrects. As well as the end of the universe. I’ve never seen the Watcher as a version of the Davison fifth Doctor - his costume is completely different and looks like decaying Elizabethan garb rather than cricket whites. Also in Death Comes to Time the Time Lord the Minister of Chance introduces a computer virus verbally presumably using Old High Gallifreyan.
All the Watched info made me think. What if, in Legends of The Sea Devils, Chibnall brings back the watcher and that's our first glimpse at the Fourteenth Doctor?
This is my first experience with this channel and I love it so much lol. Keep up the awesome work dude!!!!! I almost just ordered that Sil movie the other day. I think I'm gonna get it now lol.
When It Comes To The Doctor Not Speaking English, I Think I Can Fix That Canonically. I Take It More As The Translation Circuits Messing Up What He Said Since They Were Currently Being Taken Apart And Meddled With.
is the fact that was incorrect that the characters mentioned in the sarah jane adventures audio adventures during the broke canon with the art were incorrect cause it was rani who was with sarah jane in that story while clyde and sky were having the side adventure with the magician and luke just straight up wasn't in the story
Just saying, but if he’s fixing the translation circuits, maybe they translated the English he was speaking into the gibberish we saw, because he was fixing them
I watched back through season 3 and I either think that the one about Peri saying the N-Word is false, though I understand not finding a lot of info on it, or when talking about stowaways, you mentioned a 4th doctor comic where K-9 and The Doctor have a monster on board, something I can not find anything on. Also your gran prob doesn’t have a multiverse, but God knows she deserves one.
Not to be rude but, There's actually two different gallifreyan languages, high gallifreyan and circular gallifreyan. You seem to have acted as if they're the same thing, there not :-/ Edit: fixed a typo
Okay Sam, its been over a year, ive watched every broken canon multiple times and dived into the eu a tad myself, and i still have no clue what the fake fact is. Can you at least give us a clue (like what month the episode its in dropped, or what characters it involves
Someone got it! It's in the 5-in-1 episode. 'When a Historical goes wrong' The woman who dies in the Ashes of Eternity is an artist, but not a historical figure.
Taking a shot at your "Fake fact". Is it that we don't know who the version of the Master is at the start of the Doctor Who movie? Because technically it's still the Beevers Master, says so in Big Finishes "Planet of Dust". The Beevers Master says "Neering the end of my millenia of life in torment, memories have come back to me, I know now that, that husk escaped the Eye of Harmony and went traveling to Colstar, before being pulled back into the Vortex (referring to the Eric Roberts). Then the the Eleven confirms it again by listing all the ways our favorite crispy time load has survived. Including "body snatching a Trocken, the Cheeta race, the Thuna. And a DEATHWORM MORPHANT (the worm we see the master escape as, and into the body of Eric Roberts). But all of the bodies he inhabits burn out and he always reverts back to his burt out self. The Master being killed at the start of the movie could very well be the Beevers Master, we just can't see his face.
I'm not going to lie the sil movies is trash I've got the dvd and the frist thing I see is a guy dressed as bobba fett took me out of the stroy and I couldn't get back into it it's like they said dress up as si fi to the extras unless star wars and doctor who Share a universe I'm sorry I don't care about budget this is rubbish just for that reason
Ok so I've looked back through season 3 and my best guess is that the doctor did not write a letter to the airport controller from time-flight. Like that cannot be true
Daleks: *Cause more death and destruction than possibly any other species in history* 4th Doctor: Do I have the right? Anzor: *Was a dick to the Doctor when they were children* 6th Doctor: Yes I bloody do!
ok after going through all of them again, these are the ones I have narrowed it down to: 1. The TARDIS Censors All Swearing technically it doesn't censor *all* swearing 2. The Viryans Created All Life it's spelt Viyrans not Viryans though I imagine this was a mistake so, final answer: The TARDIS Censors All Swearing
I own the Sil movie on DVD, blu ray and in novelisation form. Not sure if that's something I should admit on the internet whilst using an account linked to my real name.
I think I might have found the fake fact, but I'm not sure. If I know it correctly Peri didn't say the n-word in Shell Shock. Or is it like an actual fact with the whole "title card" thingie being wrong and not just part of it?
It'd be pretty funny if the Doctor couldn't speak English given that Delta and the Bannermen kind of implies he can speak Welsh. I'm now going to choose to believe this is the case.
He does translate “Blaidd Drŵg” in Boom Town
Thanks for going into detail on The Watcher: as always, an ambiguous concept or simple side character is made needlessly convoluted by extended Doctor Who media. This is why your series matters: to make some kind of sense of this crap we love so tragically much!
But complicated stuff is fun lmao
But......the Watcher was the Doctor all along! What more of an explanation could any question ever have?
You know the water can be easily explained like is just the gost of the doctor to 4 is having a weird astro Projection thang like the doctors spirit will look weird Because the doctor is a shape Changer Remember time lords come from the same place as witches and vampires the beginning of time Was wild as s***
I watched Sil and the Devil Seeds of Arodor in November 2019, at a public screening. I was actually sat next to Philip Martin throughout, and wasn't too far away from Nabil Shaban. I met Sophie Aldred as well. At the screening, it was explained that this more a character piece rather than a plot-driven story. As such, I thought it was a success. Shaban is brilliant as always, and performances from Sophie Aldred, Christopher Ryan, Sakuntala Ramanee and Janet Henfrey were great. The work that went into it was thoroughly appreciated by all. Clearly, we weren't the only ones, as it would go on to win a Philip K. Dick award. Like most unofficial film projects, it does the best it can with what it's got, and for that it can only be applauded, frankly.
The fake fact HAS to be the Ace foot fetish, right?
7:29 actually, ya know what? I'd TOTALLY be fine with that if they reveal that the theme song is the doctors name, cause that honestly makes all the sense in the world and can probably fits into every single piece if media the doctor has been apart of, hell maybe the Sarah Jane adventures theme is HER name gallifraien as well just to tie everything in a neat little bow, that's how we end the series honestly, I'm 100% would be fine with that as an ending
Who's name is the Torchwood theme then? Jack?
All the current members of Torchwood's names combined?
@@sacrificiallamb4568 which explains why the theme is shorter during Children of Earth.
@@EditedAF987 And different for Miracle Day.
That just makes the scene in Silence In The Libary a lot funnier.
6:55 I always interpreted this panel as the Doctor speaking English (as he always does) and the broken translation matrix translating it into an alien language.
Or hes just speaking some random language I mean doesn't missy speak French occasionally He's probably saying like one word in a different language just because he can
I liked to think the 4th Dr became the new White Guardian, then popped up as the curator later. The Watcher regeneration was different because of this. The White Guardian was merging with the 4th Doc. I conceed that this is quite a stretch though.
I rewatched every episode of Broke Canon released so far this year and checked the wiki for each fact and I swear none of them are false
I feel like I'm going insane
I'm going to rewatch them all again
Holy shit you watched my fan edit???? i'm honored to have gotten a little shout out in your videos
The whole way through, wild wild ride
@@SamyulDavis if you like that one you should see the plans I have for the Auton trilogy :^3c
@@CDoss-bc7tv link me
@@SamyulDavis kept trying to comment it here but the link seems to be getting deleted, i made an account on twitter to send it to you
wait its real? oml i need to see this
I really recommend that you give "Watchers" from Big Finish a listen. It's an Audio Novel written by Adric himself (Matthew Waterhouse). It's set directly before Logopolis, provides a whole new layer of context for the following story, and drip-feeds new facets of Gallifrey brand new to this story, and the Watcher itself.
Psha, Sam, of course something can be a programming language and a form of music at the same time! Do you think Fitz earned the nickname “code boy” among the Remote by being part of his schools computing club in the 50s? The programming language was musical-HOLYSHIT THE REMOTE WERE PROGRAMMING IN GALLIFREYAN AND FITZ CAN READ IT NOW I BET
The fake fact is that you're a fan of the show, you just do this to punish yourself
In the Broke canon Playlist there is a "Hot Singles" video and an Attack of Titan song... do I get a prize?
As I notice this, I have, just minutes ago, finished Mindwarp.
I think the made up fact of series 3 is that the doctor killed millions to eradicate the disease Agent Yellow. He created an antidote called Agent Scarlet. At least, that's what the wiki says.
From what I can find in online reference guides, that fact is indeed true. The Doctor created Agent Scarlet but it failed, so he did… something with singularities that killed six hundred million humans but cured the rest.
@@Chubby_Bub oh ok 👍
Small error, whereas the purposeful false fact is an entire segment that's untrue!
There's nothing to say the faulty Translation Circuits of the TARDIS didn't translate the Doctor's speech from English into a completely different alien language and that's what Alice heard.
Thinking about it, there's a Titan story where 11 is hanging in space and he says something which is possibly not English? Like, a caption genuinely says 'Could be an ancient Gallifreyan curse word or his lips are just fused together' and refuses to give us an answer
Somewhere I read a great theory that the Watcher is actually a deteriorating alternate fifth Doctor, who travels back in time due to the entropy seen in Logopolis, with the purpose of changing the future to save the universe so he doesn’t exist. In the original timeline Nyssa didn’t join the Doctor and that’s one of the things the Watcher corrects. As well as the end of the universe. I’ve never seen the Watcher as a version of the Davison fifth Doctor - his costume is completely different and looks like decaying Elizabethan garb rather than cricket whites. Also in Death Comes to Time the Time Lord the Minister of Chance introduces a computer virus verbally presumably using Old High Gallifreyan.
All the Watched info made me think. What if, in Legends of The Sea Devils, Chibnall brings back the watcher and that's our first glimpse at the Fourteenth Doctor?
This is my first experience with this channel and I love it so much lol. Keep up the awesome work dude!!!!! I almost just ordered that Sil movie the other day. I think I'm gonna get it now lol.
When It Comes To The Doctor Not Speaking English, I Think I Can Fix That Canonically.
I Take It More As The Translation Circuits Messing Up What He Said Since They Were Currently Being Taken Apart And Meddled With.
I think it'd be cool as fuck if The Watcher made an appearance in the modern series
Merry Chrysalis
Mission to Magnus is a lost story that I wish stayed missing. Ugh
Suhtek...meeting Ace, in McDonald's.... I still can't believe that one.
is the fact that was incorrect that the characters mentioned in the sarah jane adventures audio adventures during the broke canon with the art were incorrect cause it was rani who was with sarah jane in that story while clyde and sky were having the side adventure with the magician and luke just straight up wasn't in the story
Aye my idea got in here! Thanks Davis :)))
Just saying, but if he’s fixing the translation circuits, maybe they translated the English he was speaking into the gibberish we saw, because he was fixing them
The false fact was about Heatanite in the section about the Doctor's Robot Cat.
That into has made me feel like my trust is violated
I watched back through season 3 and I either think that the one about Peri saying the N-Word is false, though I understand not finding a lot of info on it, or when talking about stowaways, you mentioned a 4th doctor comic where K-9 and The Doctor have a monster on board, something I can not find anything on. Also your gran prob doesn’t have a multiverse, but God knows she deserves one.
Unfortunately you have not found it ;)
@@SamyulDavis if the April Fools joke is that there is no fake fact I’m going to scream.
I need to understand why Jeremy Corbyn has this Blu-Ray?
Not to be rude but, There's actually two different gallifreyan languages, high gallifreyan and circular gallifreyan.
You seem to have acted as if they're the same thing, there not :-/
Edit: fixed a typo
I establish that ancients different from the ring-based one at the start, but get them a little mixed up by the end.
Okay Sam, its been over a year, ive watched every broken canon multiple times and dived into the eu a tad myself, and i still have no clue what the fake fact is. Can you at least give us a clue (like what month the episode its in dropped, or what characters it involves
Someone got it! It's in the 5-in-1 episode. 'When a Historical goes wrong'
The woman who dies in the Ashes of Eternity is an artist, but not a historical figure.
Fiddlesticks
11:24 ah, a being of culture, I see
Is it the one about the time traveling dildo robot? Cus I tried to look that one up and couldn't find anything about it
Taking a shot at your "Fake fact". Is it that we don't know who the version of the Master is at the start of the Doctor Who movie? Because technically it's still the Beevers Master, says so in Big Finishes "Planet of Dust".
The Beevers Master says "Neering the end of my millenia of life in torment, memories have come back to me, I know now that, that husk escaped the Eye of Harmony and went traveling to Colstar, before being pulled back into the Vortex (referring to the Eric Roberts). Then the the Eleven confirms it again by listing all the ways our favorite crispy time load has survived. Including "body snatching a Trocken, the Cheeta race, the Thuna. And a DEATHWORM MORPHANT (the worm we see the master escape as, and into the body of Eric Roberts). But all of the bodies he inhabits burn out and he always reverts back to his burt out self.
The Master being killed at the start of the movie could very well be the Beevers Master, we just can't see his face.
Is the fake fact an entire topic, like "Fact #X from the Matrix", or just something referenced under one of those topics?
Hurry! Run all facts through the TARDISwiki! Haha. Just kidding. Got it.
reveal the truth!
i cant even imagine what you went thru you poor thing
Old Sil looks like David Warner.
I'm not going to lie the sil movies is trash I've got the dvd and the frist thing I see is a guy dressed as bobba fett took me out of the stroy and I couldn't get back into it it's like they said dress up as si fi to the extras unless star wars and doctor who Share a universe I'm sorry I don't care about budget this is rubbish just for that reason
3:23 Am I being fucked with or does this fancut have a name and/or actual download link?
Fake facts?! I just don’t know if I can trust you anymore Samuel.
Ok so I've looked back through season 3 and my best guess is that the doctor did not write a letter to the airport controller from time-flight. Like that cannot be true
That absolutely exists
I think the the 5th doctor’s watcher is omega.
Daleks: *Cause more death and destruction than possibly any other species in history*
4th Doctor: Do I have the right?
Anzor: *Was a dick to the Doctor when they were children*
6th Doctor: Yes I bloody do!
How is that Corbyn picture real
The guy who plays Sil is a good friend of Jezza's and he gave him the DVD
ok after going through all of them again, these are the ones I have narrowed it down to:
1. The TARDIS Censors All Swearing technically it doesn't censor *all* swearing
2. The Viryans Created All Life it's spelt Viyrans not Viryans though I imagine this was a mistake
so, final answer: The TARDIS Censors All Swearing
Noble work, still not the one I'm afraid!
I own the Sil movie on DVD, blu ray and in novelisation form. Not sure if that's something I should admit on the internet whilst using an account linked to my real name.
I think I might have found the fake fact, but I'm not sure. If I know it correctly Peri didn't say the n-word in Shell Shock. Or is it like an actual fact with the whole "title card" thingie being wrong and not just part of it?
The lie is in the title card segment itself, yeah.
@@SamyulDavis Ah, OK, thanks
There's a sil movie?
Is the Marie Celeste Ashildr fact the fake one?
It is not! The Fortunate Isles is a great story.
No that circle galafrayen and Jack's office Not Agent You're basically comparing modern English to middle English Language evolves
The Ewok movies of Doctor Who
is your favorite color actually yellow?! is that the fake fact?!
I read that comic as a kid, I assumed the translation matrix was altering his normal English to some alien language not the other way around